Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The production of such documents is carried through several stages. At the Forum on
Technoiogy and Road Management organized by PWD/REAM in Novemb er I99J,
Technical Committee 6 - Drainage was formed with the intention to review Arahan
Teknik (Jalan) 15/97 - INTERMEDIATE GUIDE To DRAINAGE DESIGN oF
ROADS. Members of the committee were drawn from various government
departments and agencies, and from the private sector inciuding privitized road
operators, engineering consultants and drainage products manufacturers and
contactors.
The drafts of all documents were presented at workshops during the Fourth and Fifth
Malaysian Road Conferences held in 2000 and 2002 respectively. The comments and
suggestions received from the workshop participants were reviewed and incorporated
in the finalized documents
-J-
TABLE OT CONTENTS
pase
5.1 INTRODUCTION
...5-1
<) PROVISION AND LOCATION OF SUBSOIL
DRAINAGE...... ... 5.1
5.3 DESIGN OF SUBSOIL DRAINAGE SYSTEMS...
5.3.1. The Control of Seepage Flow in Rollins ..".,..5-2
or Mountainous Terrain .....
tuX
5'3'2 The conrrol of a High wut", ,"or"tr ar", ,".rt*. .
5.3.3 The Control of Water Entering the Subgrade
Through a
Pervious Road Surface........ . .
5-2
5.4 DESIGN FLOW CAPACITY
5.4.1 Field Trial Method.
5.4.2 Calculation Method
5 .5 .2 Standpipe .5_g ..
5.5.3 Piezomerer Standpipe
..5_g ."
;*--
LIST OF FIGURES
Fig. 5.1 Longitudinal Subsoil Drain used to cut off seepage and lower
.
the groundwater table ...... ' '5-3
Ftg.5.2 MultipleSubsoilDrain. ......: ....5-3
Fig. 5.3 Symmetrical Longitudinal Drains used to lower the water table . ........5-3
Fig. 5.4 Subsoil Drain for Multilanes Road "... '..5-4
Fig. 5.5 Sunsoil Drain to directly drain the base course ..... ..........5-4
Fig.5.6 Interception of Shallow Seepage .
Zone ........5-4
Fig. 5.7 Subsoil Drainage Layers for High Fill .. .."......5-5
Fig. 5.8 Standpipe Installation .........5-11
Fig. 5.9 Piezometer Standpipe Installation --""....5-I2
Fig. 5.10Nomograph for Estimating Coefficient of Permeability of Granular
Drainage and Filter Materials . '..5-13
Fig. 5.11 Particle Size Distribution for Concrete Sand B.S. 882
Filter Material Recommended for Clay Soils ..5-19
Fig. 5.l}Gradation of Filter Material ..5-24
Fig. 5.13 Filter and Slot Design for Example 2 ..... .........5-24
Fig. 5.14Filter Design for Example 3.. .
Fig. 5.15 Single Size Aggregate Filled Trench Lined with Synthetic Filter Cloth.. ........5-31
Fig. 5.16 Subsoil Pipe and Single Size Aggregate Filled Trench Lined with
Synthetic Filter Cloth . .5-31
LIST OF TABLES
Table 5.1 Normal Range of Permeability Coefficient of Typical Soils . . ... .. .5-7
5.1 INTRODUCTION
5-1
5.3 DESIGN OF SUBSOIL DR.AINAGE SYSTEMS
(b) the removal of stationary water in the soil to control and to lower the
ground water table and providing outlets (see Fig. 5.3 and Fig. 5.4);
(c) to drain the subgrade and pavement during and after the construction
period (see Fig. 5.5).
There are two methods of dealing with the condition of seepage flow.
If the seepage zone is narrow and within 1m of the surface then the
usual procedure is to install an intercepting subsoil drain just in the
impermeable strata underlying the seepage zone as shown in Fig. 5.1.
If, however, the seepage zone is wide or the impermeable stratum is
deep, it is generally, impracticable to construct the drainage trench
sufficiently deep to intercept all the seepage water.
t\l
-\l
.\.\'_\-i-
DRAWDOWN
CURVT
SUESOIL DRAJN
DRAWDOWN
CURVT
SUBSOIL DRAIN
ORIGINAL WATTR
FORI/ATIONLEVEL \ I TABLI
p*o*00**;;;:l-Li:0HffilJof,Y-J[;--L
rMpERVr.us B',NDAR'
nG. 5.3
THE TATER TABIE
5-3
v
1
SHOULDER
SHOULDER
SUBBASE
o DESIGN FILTER
l'/ATERIAL
ROADSIDI
DRAIN
WATIRTABLE
SETPAGE
ZONE
54
-
l
co
,U)^
4zz.
w X!2
^TU
!-ll
Fll
lE{l
I
CJI
o_
J
(n
pll I
i!o
a
E{l
I
e F
u)l
:<
z fEll
J
m >l
<t
zo Fll
(/) I
l< HI
(5l
= <l
F
zl
<l
EI
al
-l
(t)l
z.
5 ql
m DI
t Ql
L!
tE r
J
)<
(J
t\
.ri
ri
F={
z. IL
z. t
o
E O z. l o
o l<J
U
J
6 PB3 =
(/) C)>
a L! LrJ -z
co
f
I
z.
A Lr)
dog ;{-E
O a
L! LT
c)o
F
=J
1.s (MAX)
ooa o<=:
epER =E
F
{r,r oYs6 z-
UF
>-- cD<
IJ'\ J
LI U) e<5tr=
LLLD><
)-)
x
:l
I
5-6
f
5-6
s.4.2 Calculation Method
Darcy's Law:
a = kiA
where a = seepage volume (cu.cm/sec)
k = coefficient of permeability (cm/sec)
A = cross sectional area of seepage
layer (sq.cm)
i = hydraulic gradient
5-l
5.5 DETAILEDSUBSURFACEINVESTIGATION
(b) after work finished in the evening but before water is added to
the borehole.
The depth of the borehole and the casting (if any) is measured when
each water level measurement is taken"
5.5.2 Standpipe
Standpipe of 19mm internal diameter rigid unplasticised P.V.C. tubing
can be installed in selected boreholes especially directed. (See Fig.
s.8).
The top of the P.V.C. tubing is then sealed with a steel cap to prevent
the ingress of surface water.
5-8
,i
,,*-,-ifl.
5.5.3 Piezometer Standpipe _ (Cont,d)
2nP. H1
K= 1og"
1 1 (r2- t1) H2
5-9
;"J#."
(a) Variable Head in Soils - (Cont'd)
The formula for determining the coefficient of permeability
from packer test results is given in the United States Bureau of
Land Reclamation "Earth Manual" (1963) as:-
a
K = 1og"(L/r)forl>10r
2nLH,
-x
where K = coefficient of permeability (cm/sec)
a = rate of flow (cu.cm.sec)
L = test section length (cm)
Ht = total dynamic head (cm)
r = radius of test hole (cm)
Ht = (Hp+Ht+Hz)-H"
where Hn = the pressure head (from the pressure gauge)
5-10
j
j
PIPT
GROUND LEVEL GROUND LtVtL
COARST SAND
FI
3| nrnronnrro
o) SECTION
P.V.C. COVER
1m SAND
COARST SAND
5-11
COVER
COARSE SAND
PIEZOMITER TIP
t.oml
T- sOlL/sAND BACKFTLL
t (BonoM oF BORrHOLT)
5-12 i
t4"
-_---*.-.f,"
([op/'ll) [nrgv]nurd J0 lNllct:Jloo - )j
*=9t=t=
\
(t: nrl'sq1;1^-ttsNl. IUC - pI
oo8
@o
3\R
l!-
A S
- -
+
I
\\o(d
=h
\ 'lJ
trH
beqq=o
J
'"1 Lil w)l
-l
x'l FJI
l
I
<l
j
l
l
*l
=l
trll
=d 7-
^N-F.o S-
E
tP.l
a
trlt
E-{l
l. <l
>l
I
EI
EEll
E-{l
hl I
zl
<l I
f-ll
(rl
<l
(rr) :zrs Ntvucll^[c]llt - oLn zl
tu
I <l
E qE396rao:q
dcjdo.jl:;=3 al
I
I Flt
6
; <t
I pl
zl
I <l
F
l**l $ (Jl
6 oo >- lc\l
l-
NI
>o
FT
6 ilEtl =6i
o
x ts .E
a E=
xx
--5
Fa
d3 u?
I
0
ri
E
I
oLntsit
l^lts 002 '0N SNtssvd lNlculd - 002.
d
5-13
E
E
E un oT
E q
U
5
L
L v.
o o lr
o
E, E r )D
lrl t^l
L F
o
L--
u.l
=
l,rl
o
lrJ J
T x. =
l.r1 i,J
E
F
J
^l^
l-
rcr
q)l(o
E .D otlot
c) u cilo'
o o e. -l- o-
l4J 6
UJ
(9
E
E
14,
EL
L
o
ssrib-sz=ou
!O-(o
ot
E \\iH
(\.1
TD
=
J= (9
or or
oo
EE
lrl
J I o
o U cY,
z, '(Jo
lAn6
co = il,
U U
F lrl
6 iltl F? |
E
CD
?
L J
: ar',
(J !L =
o L -61 el3
^l : 3
|
ci b l--l-
t1 Ll lt', L FI l4l x x
= lrl U o !g o -l- lv
c{l
F U J F L
o CL <-) aDo
x)e
r\ r.c!
a J
l4l o o o e. u G
LI l! o)
F z,
l*l l4l -F o z.
f
lil
F
U F -o o iltl
o EE (D F
o lrJ
o
e,
Lrl
CL z.
l4J
(L iltl
E
- o (9 -
lrl
J CEI ct J -(\t
6
l4I
E
l4J
IL
= o N rr r r N n r 6 z.
=
a
z E E E EE E E - o
o
o
o
o o oo:
@
o
o
@
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o:
o
o € N
o
N
o
€
@
o:
@ @
o
o
o
ol
o
lr) o o o o o o
lf)|r) tt) In
(\l qq
gr €tr !- ,a?
I 6.1 L
o
F
o
U
U o € e
F (.) n @
o
N
r O rr 6n or @ @
r
fe, ar
l4.l
u? : @
a
N F F rN rN F
N
N sN
n
N
6
N
rN N
N
F
€ \
@
@
c;
@
@
N
':N o
F N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N E
o =
F
- lr',
o
- =
lt)
v,
2
l4l z,
F =
o J
F -,=E e,Uo 9E
FU
J
=
6
N
r o oo o ts N N
n r@ r Noq
N @ N J
o (, o o o o o
td
e ia== (, z,U' Eqt= CD o c; O o
u
l*,1
&
o
rssFHe v, = (-) 4
LJ IesF.*E
Y>=r*E
=E o o ualtolrt ; C)
l-
N N @ o o o o
=
{P9eHd L o o z. o N n r o o d
TJ o
J
CD
- F F
[l
CE
=3E
l4l
0
U
= +^^^^^
=HHP'E=
s2
lrl
U
J
tJl
d lrJ
v
E
=o-clo'oo IJ F
o
z.
5-14
-, . ---**L
N
3l z, €
9a 8==
<9zJ
@ @
n
N
H..
Oo ==
N
6=
b
c tr.; o I I I
o
I I I
E zg J3
F
g? c
rN L
q
=> ':
>e
N
.1
a
@
cCj ff-
L
_ o oi
E
U
Z.o
F\ J -
(J I
E
E
J
6.. ;F o
9N N N N N N r
=
at',
- 6
z.
6
- U,
5
FL F
nu tt1 =
3/7
|!o U e
u^
FT
s{
- N r F rN rN
o
F
U
e,
r
-o
J
*3 o
z,
r
L
o
c)o o
Efi - o F U
&
a F
u
G
L
#? e
H
tsl
;-
4a -
al 6
z,
u1l
(rwc/6a)
FJI
-l
>-l
--
=f;
FI F o
o
<n
6l
=l *- o n a @ o
M;
o @
<l H o N n
Ul v U (9 o
>l il U
o.l :< z. &
U }.s EEtrE ?OY
Hl ?
ICL
z,
U iE r lllotl
@t @t ,:t I
ox
^l
€t rt at N{ ?Jl
JI
r!l
4l 4c
ltttt
ttttl
d
.nol
o
trl\
. t^
D 19
oc
a?
r/) s.S
OE
J A 3
^ =i
;l
":l-
s
a
-
U =:<.1 =
ull -t
Li *s =-l
J
J
6 s.S
6E .. 1...t
U O =
*+d-pl=Pq .l= rl
Xt4e
s==g E_u=lF3
a-OxlN
€-E
tsE ,, o L < o + loi
F
zU o.i o-fi =
=
F J U
=zeo=f 6 -
F-A
J
= f€
@E
=
;:tu=-r.{
q6=ooo !i.,,h"
eouo 8
=
=
u
HH-#54 Pi=3-
E 4s
F (,E
N @
N
=
=
o +i N z
- iFE
9 EC
F
F
6
N @ € F
lr r,E
N
o =
U oi o o € z
o
ts GIE
e o
+E
6.= ts b FU =
n
-E *ec
!!F
e= &-
E
k-r
t!6 E o =+
g> N
F
Cv
z
=
:< Y E
U F
o <J U
E a
J E
=F€
5-15
j
TABLE 5.4 - MEASUREMENT OF W.L. FOR STANDP!PE / PIEZOMETER STANDPIPE
No. oF STANDPIPES : BH4
(INSTALLATION oF STANDPIPE DEPTH To 30.70m b.g.l)
DATE TIME W.L. MEASURED FROM DATE TIME W.L. MEASURED FROM
GRoUND LEVEL (m) cRoUND LEVEL (m)
02/07t87 25.64
03t07t87 25.68
(Aug 02)
C:\REANAT5.4-Standpipe.xls(IMfVct) 5-1 6
-.--- r-
5.7 DESIGN OF FILTER MATERIAL
In the past little attention has been paid to the nature of the material backfill
into the drainage trench and that surrounding the drain pipe. It has been found
that the usage of unsuitable filter material has resulted in an inefficient
drainage system, which after few years has ceased to function owing to the
siiting up of the backfill. In addition, where the drains are installed in silty
sandy soi1, fine silts are often washed through the voids leading to the
formation of large voids (also known as "soil piping" or "internal erosion")
which have caused failure in pavements due to lack of the structural integrity
of the underlying soil.
(a) the stability of grains, i.e. not early weathered nor dissolved.
(b) proper gradation, well graded natural gravel or graded crashed rock is
most suitable.
(a) it must prevent finer material, usually the subgrade soil, from piping or
migrating into the drainage layer and clogging it.
(c) it must be strong enough to carry the loads applied and, for aggregate
filters, to distribute live loads to the subsrade.
The aim of filter design is to ensure that the pores in the filter are fine
enough to prevent the migration of coarser soil particles (soil piping)
which will support the soil mass. Filter design criteria therefore needs
to relate to the pore size of backfill material and the particle sizes of
the soil around the drain, filter material must also be sufficiently
permeable to allow the flow of water. The design life of filter material
should be 10 to 15 Years. Generallv" we have to desisn filter materials
for:-
i:
(a) Predominantlv Clav Soils
Concrete sand complying to MS 30, Zone Z grading or similar
material has proved quite satisfactory for all silty and clayey
soils. The concrete sand is fine enough to act as a filter for
silts, and will protect the drain from any fine non-cohesive
particles in clays. Fig.5.11 and Table 5.5 show the particles
size distribution for concrete sand MS 30.
Drsp
<5
D85S
Drsr
>5
Drss
5-1 8
-..--,i
SNISSVd ]CVIN]3U]d
ogsooooooo
qtcOl-.@n+nN;
CN
U
J
co
O
U
U)
E.
a
J
E
E E
E U
z.
E E;
Ld
N,I
lr I (n
-J o
z.
6 -U
E
=
E
o_
U
z.
c;
t!
U)
U)
F
J
U1
=
o
U
U
z.
d
I
.fj
I
oaaooooooo
o)oN@tr)*.N; h
CNISSVd :CVIN]3U]d
3
5-19
I
i
*itr&i.
(b) Predominantly Sandy or Gravel Soils - (Cont'd)
(iii) Hole Ratio
For the filter material to be prevented from being
carried away through the holes of the drain pipes, the
followins must hold:
Dasp
D (diameter of hole)
Notes:
(1) Dtsp is used to designate the size of the sieve that
allows fifteen percent (l5%o) by weight of the filter
material to pass through it. Similariy, Dass designates
the size of sieve that allows eighty-five (852o) by
weight of the base soil to pass through it. particle sizes
smaller than the 75 um sieve refer to Hygrometer
analysis results.
(2) The filter must not be gap-graded (i.e. when some sieve
fractions are scarce or missing altogether). Where the
soil around a drain is gap-graded, filter design shall be
based only on the particles finer than the gap in the
grading. Such precautions are intended to ensure that
the finer soil cannot migrate through the coarser
particles and therefore clog the drain.
(3) If the soil contains layers of fine material, the filter shall
be designed from the grading of the finer soil.
(4) Filter material shall not have more than five percent
(5%) of its weight passing through the 75 um sieve, to
prevent migration of fines from the filter into the drain.
5-20
5.7.2 Synthetic Filter Cloth / Fabrics - (Cont,d)
Five (5) fresh samples shall be tested. About 150 gm of each of
the following fractions of sand composed of sound rounded
particles shall be as tabulated below:-
Notes:
(1) whenever possible, fabric with the iargest
possible EOS shall be preferred.
5-2r
l
(c) Chemical Composition Requirements
Notes:
5-22
-r-- --- i a1 ?E:.gj'-Pr
Example 1
l
l
j
;>s
:
-j = D15F>5xDtss
j
5 x 0.02 (f6omFig.5.12)
= 0.10mm hence, D15F > 0.1mm
*i
I
A backfill material should be chosen for the drain that is within the
specifications above. Please note in Figure 5.12 thatit is desirable that
the gradation curve of the filter material is smooth and parallel to that
of the subgrade.
Example 2
D15F
<5
*-il
,
l
Dlss
;;
; - D15F<5.rDsss
"i = 5x0.21(fromFig.5;13)
i .: = 1.05mm hence, Dtsr < 1.05mm
'-':
:
I
<12
J-LJ
*-;it-
2D (HOL[ StZ
80
b's
F
z HOLE SlZt = l0mm
L!.1
cr60
U
ALLOWABLE RANGE
o- 0F Des (FILIER)
GRADIATION CURVE OF SUBGRADE ,
z.
a I
i?40 N CURVT
o_ FILTIR MATTRIAL
5 Drs (SUBGRADE) = P.1rt
0.5 'l
SAND GRAVTL
100
z.
U) 6U
a ' BASE SOIL TO
o_
,.60 /- BT FILTERTD
U
z+0 /
UJ CALCULATED
*: / FILTTR MATTRIALS
L! ?n
o- --
0 )
0.05 0.1 1.0 10
5-2/+
5.7.3 Examplesof FilterDesign - (Cont'd)
D15F
>5
D155
= D15F>5xDtss
= 5 x 0.085 (from Fig. 5.13)
= 0.425mmhence, D15F > 0.421mm
If the holes in the pipe are too large, a coarser filter material
must be placed next to the pipe. The grading of the coarser
material must be able to prevent migration of the filter into the
pipe. It should therefore be designed in the way indicated
above, except that the finer filter material is considered as the
base soil.
Example 3
D15F
<5
Dsss
Drsp<5xDsss
5; 1.05 (from Fig. 5.1a)
5.25mmhence, D15F < 5.25mm
5-25
COBBLES
100
E-
U
2.80
L-
L!
^^
BASE JI IL TI rEREI
I
s )
CAL :UI \TFD
2.,^ FILI :R UATE (l ,L
LI +U
U.
u^^
o_ 4u
5-26
5.7,3 Examples of Filter Design - (Cont'd)
(b) For Permeabilitlz
Drsr'
>5
D155
D15F>5xDtss
5 x 0.025 (from Fig. 5.14)
0.125mmhence, Dtsp > 0.125mm
The backfiil chosen for the drain should lie within the calculated
grading limits.
The type of subsoil drain to be used will depend mainly on the source and the
volume of water to be handled.
(a) single size aggregate filled trench lined with synthetic filter cloth (See
Fig.5.15);
(b) subsoil pipe and single size aggregate filled trench lined with synthetic
filter cloth
(See Fig. 5.16);
(c) porous / perforated / slotted pipe with design filter material (See Fig.
5.17):
In this type of subsoil drain, the trench is lined with geotextiles (made
up of very fine holes and high porosity) protecting gravel filled trench.
The geotextile acts as a filter as it allows water seeping from the soil to
pass through while preventing most soil particles from being carried
away by seepage water.
5-21
5.8.1 Single Size Aggregate Filled Trench Lined with
Synthetic Filter Cloth (See Fig. 5.15) - (Cont,d)
5.8.2 Subsoil Pipe and Single Size Aggregate Filled Trench Lined with
Synthetic Filter Cloth (See Fig. 5.16)
Currently in the market, there are other patented types of subsoil drain
which are marketed by various manufacturers. Proprietary types
should be given due consideration and there is no reason why they
cannot be used if they a.re proven to be suitable after proper evaluation
and field tests as described under Section 5.4.r. If in doubt, the
Engineer should refer the new products to IKRAM for advice.
5-28
5.9 DRAIN PIPE DESIGN
(c) Perforations
(i) slot width
1.2
(ii) hole diameter
n
The perforated or slotted pipes shall have holes in the lower half of
their circumference only. This is to increase the interception ability
of
the pipes and to reduce the in washing of filter materiai.
Subsoil pipes shall have a minimum cover of 300mm (from top of pipe
to formation level) if it is not subjected to vehicular loadine. Ii theie-is
vehicular loading minimum cover shall be 1.0m.
(D For Inspection
5-29
5.9 Drain Pipe Design - (Cont'd)
(0 Pipe Outlet
5-30
SHOULDER
ROADSIDT DRAIN
FIG. 5.15
ROADSIDE DRAIN
FORMATION LEVIL
N
12rrm - 25mm SINGLI
SIZE AGGREGATE
5-31
SHOULDER
ROADSIDT DRAIN
SUBBAST
i (To BE DrslcN[D)
CENTTRLINE
5-32
-
,75
n
,
t
tv
lL.)
GALV. WIRI
(stT rN PLASTTC OR NITTING '19mm
HIAD WALL PLUG) (MrsH)
FRONT VIET
SIDE YIET
150mm 0 PIPE
___-tt tr)
-f-
TOP VIET
5-33
r--- _
ACKI.{OWLEDGEMENTS
Volume 5 now provides guidelines to the practical design of subsoil drainage, with
worked examples provided to assist users.