Professional Documents
Culture Documents
P01-E28-02 Rev 5 Dec 2021 Design Requirements For FRP Piping Systems
P01-E28-02 Rev 5 Dec 2021 Design Requirements For FRP Piping Systems
NUMBER P01-E28-02
REV. No. 5
ENGINEERING STANDARD DATE DEC 2021
PAGE 1 OF 51
This document is issued by PED, SABIC E&PM, Jubail Industrial City, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The information contained
in this document is the confidential property of SABIC. It cannot be disclosed, copied or used for any purpose without
approval from SABIC. If you are not authorized to posses this document, please destroy it immediately.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
CONTENTS
1 SCOPE ..........................................................................................................................................4
2 REFERENCES ..............................................................................................................................4
3 DEFINITIONS ................................................................................................................................5
4 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS .......................................................................................................5
4.1 Design Conditions .................................................................................................................5
4.2 Service Considerations ..........................................................................................................6
5 PROPERTIES REQUIRED FOR SYSTEM DESIGN ....................................................................6
5.1 General ..................................................................................................................................6
5.2 Allowable Axial Stress ...........................................................................................................7
6 PIPING SYSTEM DESIGN ...........................................................................................................9
6.1 General Design Considerations ............................................................................................9
6.2 Layout Considerations .........................................................................................................10
6.3 Piping Stress Analysis .........................................................................................................12
6.4 Other Considerations ...........................................................................................................13
7 ABOVEGROUND PIPE ANALYSIS ............................................................................................14
8 UNDERGROUND PIPE ANALYSIS............................................................................................28
8.1 General ................................................................................................................................28
8.2 Additional underground loads and parameters ...................................................................29
8.3 Manual Techniques .............................................................................................................31
8.4 Computer stress analysis techniques ..................................................................................43
9 DESIGN REPORT REQUIREMENTS ........................................................................................44
9.2 Summary of Design Conditions and Assumptions ..............................................................44
9.3 Qualification of Pipe and Components ................................................................................45
9.4 Calculation Package ............................................................................................................46
9.5 Drawings ..............................................................................................................................46
9.6 Data .....................................................................................................................................46
10 TECHNICAL BID SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS .....................................................................47
11 HOLD POINTS ............................................................................................................................47
12 REVISION HISTORY ..................................................................................................................48
Appendix A - Design Condition Summary ........................................................................................49
Appendix B - Bid Submittal Form .....................................................................................................50
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
1 Scope
1.1 This standard is for design of aboveground and underground fiberglass reinforced plastic
(FRP) piping systems for use in SABIC facilities.
1.2 The FRP piping system shall be designed for 30 years plant life as a minimum.
2 References
Reference made in this standard to the following documents. The latest issue, amendments and
supplements to these documents shall apply unless otherwise indicated.
SABIC Engineering Standards (SES)
B01-E01 Design criteria for concrete and steel structure
F02-E01 Fire protection system
C02-S01 Site Preparation, Excavation and Backfill Specification
I01-E02 System Hydraulics
I05-E01 Design Pressure and Design Temperature
P01-E04 Flexibility Analysis Requirements of Piping System
P01-E28-01 Qualification of FRP Pipe and components
P13-C05 Installation Requirements for FRP Piping Systems
P14-T02 Quality Assurance of FRP Piping
High Commission of Industrial Security (HCIS), KSA.
SAF-04 Fire Protection Systems
American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM)
D 638 Test Method for Tensile Properties of Plastics
D 695 Test Method for Compressive Properties of Rigid Plastics
D 696 Test Method for Coefficient of Linear Thermal Expansion of Plastics Between -
30C and 30C
D 698 Standard Test Methods for Laboratory Compaction Characteristics of Soil Using
Standard Effort (12 400 ft-lbf/ft3 (600 kN-m/m3))
D 790 Standard Test Methods for Flexural Properties of Unreinforced and Reinforced
Plastics and Electrical Insulating Materials
D 792 Standard Test Methods for Density and Specific Gravity (Relative Density) of
Plastics by Displacement
D 1599 Standard Test Method for Resistance to Short-Time Hydraulic Pressure of Plastic
Pipe, Tubing, and Fittings
D 2105 Standard Test Method for Longitudinal Tensile Properties of “Fiberglass” (Glass-
Fiber-Reinforced Thermosetting-Resin) Pipe and Tube
D 2412 Standard Test Method for Determination of External Loading Characteristics of
Plastic Pipe by Parallel-Plate Loading
D 2925 Standard Test Method for Beam Deflection of “Fiberglass” (Glass-Fiber-
Reinforced Thermosetting-Resin) Pipe under Full Bore Flow
D 2992 Standard Practice for Obtaining Hydrostatic or Pressure Design Basis for
“Fiberglass” (Glass-Fiber -Reinforced Thermosetting-Resin) Pipe and Fittings
D 3839 Standard Guide for Underground Installation of “Fiberglass” (Glass-Fiber
Reinforced Thermosetting-Resin) Pipe
D 4253 Standard Test Methods for Maximum Index Density and Unit Weight of Soils
Using a Vibratory Table
D 4255 Standard Guide for Testing In-plane Shear Properties of Polymer Matrix
Composite Materials by the Rail Shear Method
American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)
B31.3 Process Piping
NM.2 Glass-Fiber-Reinforced Thermosetting-Resin Piping System
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
3 Definitions
For the purpose of understanding this standard, the following definitions apply. For additional
definitions refer to SES P01-E28-01.
Bi-axial Pressure. Pressure which is restrained by the pipe and exerts both hoop and axial stress
in the pipe wall.
Fixed Pipe Region. That portion of underground piping which is restrained from axial movement
by soil friction.
Lamination Theory. Mathematical procedure for determining stress and strain in individual
layers, as well as estimating material properties, of a composite laminate.
Moving Pipe Region. That portion of underground piping which is near bends or tees and is not
completely restrained from axial movement by soil friction.
Native Soil. The soil which exists in the area of the underground pipe installation.
Orthotropic. Term used to characterize the directional behavior of most composite pipe
laminates.
Shear Collar. An FRP laminate applied to the exterior of the pipe adjacent to anchors or other
pipe supports for the purpose of transferring axial pipe loads into the supporting structure.
Tied Length. That length of underground pipe near corners where joints are designed to carry
the axial pipe load; approximately equal to the length of the Moving Pipe Region.
Virtual Anchor. The theoretical point in underground pipe between the Moving Pipe Region and
the Fixed Pipe Region. The virtual anchor point is some distance away from a bend or tee, where
soil friction overcomes axial pipe loads and the pipe becomes locked in the soil.
4 General Requirements
These requirements apply to the selection, qualification and manufacture of all FRP pipe and
components, and design of the piping system.
4.1 Design Conditions
All design conditions shall be documented and summarized for use by the project, using
the Design Condition Summary form included in the Appendix A, or similar format. It is
Design Engineering Company's responsibility to identify all conditions that could potentially
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
affect the selection of materials or design of the piping system. As a minimum, the following
conditions shall be considered.
4.1.1 Pressure
a. Operating Pressure. See SES I05-E01 for definition.
b. Design Pressure. See SES I05-E01 for definition
c. Maximum Upset Pressure. See SES I05-E01 for definition
d. Hydrotest Pressure. The pressure used for static hydrotesting of the system
after installation. Hydrotest pressure shall not be less than1.5 times the design
pressure.
4.1.2 Vacuum
a. Operating vacuum: See SES I05-E01 for definition
b. Design vacuum: See SES I05-E01 for definition
4.1.3 Temperature
a. Operating temperature: See SES I05-E01 for definition.
b. Design temperature. See SES I05-E01 for definition.
c. Ambient temperature. The range of climatic conditions under which the system
is expected to operate. Refer to Project Basic Engineering Design Data (BEDD)
d. Installation temperature. The range of ambient temperatures anticipated during
the piping system installation period. Refer to SES P01-E04 and project BEDD.
4.1.4 Wind and Earthquake Loads
a. The design wind speed at site shall be as per Project Basic Engineering
Design Data (BEDD).
b. The seismic zone shall be as per Project Basic Engineering Design Data
(BEDD).
4.1.5 Velocity
Velocity limitation of FRP piping system shall be maximum 3 m/s as specified in
SES I01-E02.
4.2 Service Considerations
Refer to section 9 of SES P01-E28-01.
4.3 All FRP piping of aboveground and underground piping shall be UV-Protected. The UV-
Protection shall be suitable for 30 years of operation.
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
5.2.1 For all aboveground and underground pressure pipe, determine the allowable axial
stress under 2:1 bi-axial pressure loading:
2 = (HDS) Equation 1
2
Where:
2 = allowable axial stress under 2:1 bi-axial loading
HDS = hydrostatic design stress
5.2.2 For all pipe, determine allowable axial stress when no pressure exists:
1 = ult Equation 2
5
Where:
1 = allowable axial stress at pressure = 0
ult = ultimate axial stress, (see section 10.6.1, SES P01-E28-01)
5.2.3 For pressure piping, determine allowable axial stress under combined loading
conditions:
(𝜎2 −𝜎1 )𝜎ℎ
𝜎𝑎𝑥 = 𝜎1 + Equation 3
(𝐻𝐷𝑆)
Where:
ax = allowable axial stress under combined loading conditions
1 = allowable axial stress at pressure = 0, (per section 5.2.2)
2 = allowable axial stress under 2:1 bi-axial loading, (per section 5.2.1)
h = hoop stress under applied design loads, (per section 7.2.2)
HDS= hydrostatic design stress(per section 10.3, 10.4 or 10.5 of SES P01-E28-01 as
applicable)
For non-pressure piping, ax is equal to 1 of section 5.2.2, as other hoop loads are
ignored.
The allowable axial stress is represented under various loading combinations by
the following graph/Figure-1
Figure 1
Stress Design Envelope
Axial Stress Direction
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Bollard/Gard Post shall be installed to barricade the areas where vehicles are
prohibited to protect underground FRP piping.
6.3 Piping Stress Analysis
This section provides minimum requirements and applicable input data to be used when
conducting stress analysis of piping system.
6.3.1 General
a. Piping flexibility analysis shall be performed for all above ground and
underground piping (both pressurized and non-pressurized piping) to determine
piping system movements, forces and moments, and stresses in the piping.
b. As a minimum the analysis shall determine the following:
i. Maintain reaction forces and moments on equipment nozzles within
allowable limits
ii. Maintain axial stresses in the pipe and fittings within allowable limits
iii. Determine the type and location of supports
iv. Provide reaction forces for supports design
v. Determine piping system movement and displacements
c. Piping stress analysis shall be performed in accordance with ISO 14692.
However, the stress design envelope shall be constructed to meet the
requirement mentioned in Para 5.2.3. The flexibility analysis requirement shall
comply with SES P01-E04 as applicable.
6.3.2 Design Conditions
Refer to section 4.1 for the definition of design conditions.
6.3.3 Loads Cases and Combinations
The following minimum load combinations shall be analyzed for the piping system.
It is the responsibility of the Design Engineering Company to identify and resolve
all of the loads and appropriate combinations.
c. As a minimum, the following load cases shall be analyzed.
i. Operating cases (Minimum, maximum operating and design pressure /
Temperature)
ii. Occasional cases (e.g. surge, wind, seismic, PSV pop-up etc.)
iii. Hydrotest case
d. Various type of Transient loads
Transient loads are those that occur infrequently and for short duration. While
an increase in allowable stress is permitted for evaluation of transient
conditions, the Stress Analyst shall assure that the loading condition does not
cause damage to the piping system, support structure or adjacent equipment.
The increased allowable stress can be permitted for the following cases in
accordance with ISO 14692.
i. Wind and seismic loads are considered transient and are permitted an
increased allowable stress. Apply these loads in principal directions and in
combination with the most severe combination of other loads.
ii. Excursions beyond the operating temperatures are considered transient,
with an increased allowable stress. If excursions are significantly above
operating temperatures, the maximum displacements should be checked to
assure there is no interference with adjacent equipment or structures.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 2
Representation of total change in length
Equation 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
b. Direction Changes
Axial stress at a given directional change depends on the operating pressure,
the total change in length and the distance to the first secure pipe support. See
Figure-3
To ensure that the flexible leg length (Ls) is sufficient to accommodate the total
change in length anticipated, it is necessary to compute the combined axial
stress and compare with the allowable stress defined in section 5.2.
Figure 3
Location of flexible leg length (Ls)
This procedure, called the “guided cantilever method”, is conservative and may
be used for computing axial stresses in the pipe at changes in direction.
Where:
ax = allowable axial stress
L = total change in length
Eaf = axial flexural modulus of elasticity
Pd = design pressure
R = radius of pipe
Ls = flexible leg length
t = structural wall thickness
Include adjustments for temperature, as they may increase or decrease
flexibility of the pipe.
If the allowable axial stress is exceeded, then the length of the flexible leg shall
be increased. However, support spacing cannot be completely disregarded as
support for gravity loads and stability of the system shall be maintained.
c. Expansion Loops
Expansion loops are utilized when simple direction changes cannot
accommodate changes in length of a pipe run. Normally, expansion loops are
used in very long piping with relatively few changes in direction.
A conservative design method assumes a cantilevered beam with a
concentrated load at the free end to calculate axial stress. The recommended
guide spacing on the main piping is shown in the following figure-4.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 4
Pipe Guide Spacing Arrangement
Where:
ax = allowable axial stress
L = total change in length
K = 0.75 for non-guided cantilever
= 3.00 for guided cantilever
Eaf = axial flexural modulus of elasticity
Pd = design pressure
R = radius of pipe
Ls = flexible leg length
t = structural wall thickness
Include adjustments for temperature, as they may increase or decrease
flexibility of the pipe.
d. Support Spans
The criterion for establishing the maximum support span is deflection. The
deflection of a particular pipe between supports will depend on the length of the
pipe run and number of supports used within this length.
The deflection can be determined by selecting one of the following span models
which are most representative of the piping configuration. See Figure-5.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 5
Pipe support span configuration
In most cases, calculated deflection will be conservative, since the end of the
pipe run is assumed to be simply supported. In the actual piping layout, these
ends continue as direction changes or terminate at equipment connections
which tend to provide more support or rotational resistance and reduce the
maximum deflection of the span.
Calculate the maximum support span:
Where:
Ls = maximum support span
y = allowable deflection, 1/2 inch or 1/2 percent of the span Ls,
whichever is less
Eaf = axial flexural modulus of elasticity
I = moment of inertia of the pipe, using structural wall thickness only
W = total weight of pipe and contents
K = constant based on span model type, see table-1
Table-1
Value of constant for span model type
SPAN MODEL K
Type I 0.0130
Type II 0.0054
Type III 0.0069
Type IV 0.0065
e. Guide Spacing
In situations where the pipe is in compression, guides are required to prevent
column buckling. Most frequently, this situation arises when anchors are placed
at directional changes dividing the system into straight runs as shown below
figure-6
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 6
Maximum guide spacing for pipe in compression
The guide spacing shall be determined such that the pipe will not buckle from
the thermal end load resulting from an operating temperature above the
installed temperature of the pipe.
The thermal end load can be obtained from:
Ft = EacA(T) Equation 11
Where:
Ft = thermal end load
= axial coefficient of linear thermal expansion
Eac = axial compressive modulus of elasticity
A = cross-sectional area of the pipe wall, using total thickness
T = change between the operating temperature and the installation
temperature
The guide spacing is conservatively determined assuming the pipe is a simply
supported column where rotation of the ends is not resisted.
The maximum guide spacing is determined from:
Where:
Lg = maximum guide spacing
Eac = axial compressive modulus of elasticity
I = moment of inertia of the pipe, using structural wall thickness
only
Ft = thermal end load, (note this can be any mechanical load
causing compression)
N = 5.0, minimum safety factor
The anchors shall be designed to accommodate the thermal end force plus the
thrust developed from internal pressure at the bends.
f. Shell buckling
In situations where the pipe is in compression either from direct axial
compression or bending, a check for elastic shell buckling shall be made. This
is primarily a concern for large diameter low thickness pipe, (D/t > 50). The
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Where:
b = critical buckling stress
= correlation factor
= 1-0.901(1-e)
Figure-7
Guide position from expansion joints
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Where:
Lt = change in length due to temperature change
= axial coefficient of linear thermal expansion
L = distance to the anchor
T = change between the operating temperature and the
installation temperature
Since expansion or contraction of fiberglass pipe can be quite large relative to
metallic pipe, the required movement of the expansion joint is similarly large. In
some cases multiple expansion joints may be required. This can make the use
of expansion joints a costly solution.
A more accurate approximation of the required movement accounts for the
change in length or shortening of the pipe due to the Poisson effect.
Calculate the contraction from Poisson effect:
Where:
L = change in length due to Poisson effect
ha = Poisson ratio (axial response to an applied hoop load)
Pd = design pressure
R = radius of pipe
L = distance to the anchor
t = structural wall thickness
Eht = hoop tensile modulus of elasticity
The required movement of the expansion joint is:
m = Lt - L Equation 16
Note: This procedure computes required expansion joint movement from one
side of the joint only. In selecting the expansion joint, movement from both
sides shall be computed.
h. Bend and Tee Factors
An important area where the flexibility analysis of FRP piping systems differs
from the analysis of isotropic (metallic) piping systems is in the use of flexibility
and stress intensification factors. Because of ovalization of the cross-section
during bending, the flexibility of a bend or tee is increased and the stresses are
greater than that of an equivalent length of straight pipe of the same wall
construction and diameter.
In conventional metallic piping systems where the fitting and pipe are made of
the same material, diameter and thickness, methods for determining flexibility
and stress intensification factors are well known and built into the design codes.
In FRP systems the pipe and fitting are separate components bonded or
laminated together and the material properties, diameter and thickness are
often different than that of the straight pipe.
Computer analysis programs include default values of flexibility and stress
intensification factors for FRP fittings that are usually considered conservative.
However, there is little experimental evidence to substantiate these values and
limited testing has shown that they may not be conservative.
Given the lack of well-established data, the following procedure is considered
conservative and has been used in a number on analyses and proven
satisfactory. The default values for flexibility and stress intensification factors of
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
2.53𝑃𝑑 𝑅𝑏 1/3 𝐷𝑏 2 −1
𝛿𝑎 = [1 + ( 𝑡 ) (2𝑡 ) ] Equation 18
𝐸ℎ𝑡 𝑏 𝑏
The minimum value of FFb shall be 1.0 and the maximum value shall be 3.0.
Calculate the In-plane Stress Intensification Factor for smooth bends:
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
The minimum value of SIFi or SIFo shall be 1.0 and the maximum value shall
be 2.5.
Where:
FFb = flexibility factor for bends (smooth or mitered)
SIFi = in-plane stress intensification factor for bends (smooth or mitered)
SIFo = out-of-plane stress intensification factor for bends (smooth or mitered)
tb = average thickness of bend fitting
tp = thickness of pipe adjacent to bend
Db = inside diameter of bend
Rb = mean radius of bend
Eht = hoop modulus of bend
Eaf = axial flexural modulus of elasticity of pipe adjacent to bend
Eab = axial flexural modulus of the bend
Pd = design pressure
(ii) Factors for Tee Fittings
For all tees, the Flexibility Factor, FFt, shall be 1.0.
Calculate the Tee Factor:
Where:
= Tee factor
FFt = flexibility factor for tees
SIFt = stress intensification factor for tees
th = average thickness of header portion of tee fitting
Dt = inside diameter of tee header
The minimum value of SIFt shall be 1.0 and the maximum value shall be 3.0.
i. Pipe supports requirements
In general, FRP piping systems may be supported using the same principles
as those for metallic piping systems. The following guidelines should be
followed when positioning, designing, and specifying supports for FRP piping
systems. Standard pipe supports for use with metallic piping are not necessarily
suitable for use with FRP piping. For example, standard size supports will not
typically match the outside diameter of the FRP pipe but may be adapted by
using saddles and elastomeric pads. Other modifications to standard supports
may be necessary to meet the guidelines for supporting FRP piping.
In all cases support design should meet or exceed the requirements of the pipe
manufacturer, based on the following considerations.
i. Supports for FRP pipe should be wider than those typically used for support
of metallic piping to prevent point loading and damage to the pipe. Supports
saddles should be curved and fitted to the bottom 180 degrees of the pipe.
Unprotected pipe should never bear directly against roller supports, flat
structural steel or U-bolts. The minimum width of the saddle should be ½ D
(where D is the diameter of the pipe). For pipe diameters larger than 4 inch
the support saddles should be steel that is lined with an elastomeric material.
ii. Clamping forces at guides, anchors, and vertical supports should be such
that crushing of the pipe from a poor fit or over-tightening does not occur.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
iii. Supports should preferably be located on plain pipe and not on joints or
fittings. If the piping layout is such that this is not possible, custom supports
must be designed.
iv. Valves and other heavy equipment shall be independently supported. In
addition to vertical loads from their weight, valves can have heavy control
mechanisms offset from the center of the pipe which can cause bending and
torsional loads.
v. Protect the pipe against external abrasion if vibrations, pulsations or sliding
are possible. Wear saddles are commonly used in these situations. For
supports that intentionally slide or move the saddle should be adhered to the
pipe so that all movement occurs between the saddle and the supporting
structure to prevent rubbing and wear of the pipe wall.
vi. For pipes above 1.0 m in diameter and with a large diameter/thickness ratio
(D/t > 150), contact stresses can become significant and the possibility of
localized buckling is a concern. Above saddle supports, circumferential
bending moments are produced which permit the upper portion of the pipe
to deform. This deformation makes the upper portion of the pipe ineffective
as a beam by reducing the cross-section. In this case simple beam
calculations are not accurate in determining axial stress in the pipe and
special consideration in design of the pipe utilizing local reinforcement
should be considered.
Description of basic support types and typical uses:
Simple Sliding Supports. These supports permit the pipe to move laterally
and axially and allow rotational movement. Vertical gravity loads are
supported and uplift is permitted. Frictional resistance to sliding provides
the only lateral and axial restraint. While this type of support maximizes
the flexibility of the piping system overuse can lead to excessive lateral
deflections or a system that is overly sensitive to pipe flow, pulsations
and pressure surges, and externally applied loads. Advantages of simple
supports are that allowable axial stresses are more easily maintained and
that loads transmitted to supporting structures are minimized.
Guides. Guides restrict lateral movement and but permit axial and
rotational movement. Vertical gravity loads are supported and uplift is
sometimes prevented. Frictional resistance to sliding provides the only
axial restraint. Guides are recommended when lines are subject to side
loads or uplift from pipe flow, pulsations and pressure surges, and
externally applied loads such as wind and seismic conditions. Guides can
be used to control lateral defections and are necessary to prevent
buckling when the pipe is compressed. The use of guides provide a more
stable system but impart lateral loads to support structures and shall be
used with care very close to changes in direction and branch connections
to minimize bending stresses.
Anchors. Anchors restrain all lateral, axial and vertical movement but are
not typically considered to prevent rotation. Anchors divide the pipe
system into individually expanding sections. Anchors usually occur at
valves, expansion joints, to protect equipment from piping loads, and with
care very close to changes in direction and branch connections as
allowable axial stresses are easily exceeded. Anchors maximize the
ability of the system to withstand loads from pipe flow, pulsations and
pressure surges, and externally applied loads such as wind and seismic
conditions. Very large loads can be developed at anchors which the pipe
shall withstand and transfer to the anchor saddle and structural supports.
To be effective, anchor saddles shall be placed between two 360 shear
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 8
Stiffener/Gusset Attachment - Overview
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure-9
Typical Hydrant/Monitor Support Arrangement
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Where:
Pc = external collapse pressure
Ehf = hoop flexural modulus of elasticity
t = structural wall thickness
R = inside radius of pipe structural wall
= Poisson ratio computed by:
= (haah)1/2
ha and ah are the Poisson ratios of the pipe for hoop and
axial loading
This calculation method is conservative since it does not utilize all of the
properties of the typical orthotropic pipe laminate. It also assumes the length of
pipe is significantly greater than the diameter, (L/D greater than 20). The
collapse pressure is higher for shorter lengths.
To determine the allowable vacuum for the pipe the collapse pressure shall be
divided by a safety factor.
Calculate the allowable vacuum:
Where:
Pv = allowable vacuum
Pc = external collapse pressure
N = 2.5, minimum safety factor
The allowable vacuum shall be equal or exceed the Design Vacuum
requirement for the specific pipe service.
k. Computer stress analysis Techniques
i. General
A piping flexibility analysis is conducted as per section 6.3.
ii. Computer Analysis Requirements
Some modeling techniques are unique to FRP piping systems, which are
discussed below.
The properties required for analysis are defined in section 5. The material
properties appropriate for the loading condition should be used.
For example, most programs allow input of only one modulus value. In
most cases the axial flexural modulus of elasticity is used, but in
situations where the pipe is compressed between anchors, the axial
compressive modulus should be appropriate. The compressive modulus
can be much lower and can reduce anchoring forces and the structural
requirements for the supports. The lower modulus also means that the
guide spacing required to prevent buckling will be shorter.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
The depth at which the pipe is buried determines loads from soil overburden and
the magnitude of live loads transferred to the pipe from vehicular traffic at the
surface. The minimum and maximum (1.5 m to 5 m, finished grade to top of pipe)
depths should be used in the analysis to bound the range of combined live and soil
overburden loads.
The pipe elevation can be compared to boring logs from geotechnical
investigations showing the strata and stiffness of the native soils at various depths
aiding in determination of the degree of support provided by the native soil.
Resistance to buckling from external hydrostatic pressure and to uplift from
buoyant forces are also influenced by the burial depth. (AWWA M45, Sections
5.7.3.5, 5.7.3.6, and 5.7.5)
8.2.5 Settlement
Settlement of structures connected to or in the vicinity of the pipe require special
attention and some means to allow settlement without over-stressing the pipe shall
be provided. In some situations additional reinforcing of the pipe is a solution. In
many cases, particularly with large diameter pipe (D>24 inch), flexible connections
or backpacking the pipe with a cushion material are required.
8.2.6 Trench Curvature
Curvature of the trench bottom causes bending of the pipe and an axial load that
shall be considered in the analysis. With small diameter pipe, horizontal curvature
from laying the pipe can be a concern. The most common approach used to avoid
additional axial stress is to ensure that directional changes occur at joints during
installation of the pipe, (AWWA M45, Section 5.8).
Settlement of 6mm at Concrete Structures and Uniform Curvature Producing
20mm Displacement in 20 m of Pipe Length shall be considered for the trench
curvature.
8.2.7 Live Loads
Live loading from vehicular surface traffic including loads from constructions
equipment such as cranes and from railroads are additive to soil overburden loads
in the analysis of underground pipe. Construction traffic is normally a transient
condition and may not need to be combined with other operational loads. The loads
transferred to the pipe from construction traffic are relieved by construction haul
roads or by using protective matting to prevent short-term damage to the pipe,
(AWWA M45, section 5.7.3.6).
Live loading of AASHTO 20 shall be considered in the analysis of underground
pipe. In addition to the live loading, annual construction crane loading of 12 tons
per axle shall also be considered on paved roadways:
80 ton capacity 4 axle crane – static load is 48 tons
400 ton capacity 7 axle crane – static load is 84 tons
8.2.8 Backfill and Bedding Material
The impact of bedding and backfill material selection on installation procedures,
effort and pipe cost should be considered in the initial stages of design. Refer to
AWWA M45, Sections 5.7.3.8 and 6.5 and Section 5.3.3.(c) of SES P13-C05.
Backfill soil density shall be minimum 2000 kg/m 3.
Specify backfill/bedding soil that conforms to AWWA M45 Stiffness Category SC1
or SC2 and in accordance with SES C02-S01 and ASTM D3839. Refer to Section
5.3.3 (e) of SES P13-C05.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 10
Representation of virtual anchor
Manual calculations are sufficient to determine hoop stresses in both areas of the
piping system. Axial stresses in fixed pipe regions of the piping system are also
easily calculated by manual techniques but, due to the complexity of soil restraining
horizontal movement, the axial stresses in moving pipe regions are best resolved
using computer analysis. For the same reason, in areas where settlement is
expected, computer analysis is appropriate The stress analysis shall be carried out
considering soil likely settlement.
Pipe movement is considered to be completely restrained by friction so that thermal
expansion and contraction from the Poisson effect do not occur and axial stresses
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
∆y = Equation 30
Where:
∆y = Vertical deflection. The maximum vertical deflection for any
underground application shall not exceed 2.5 percent of the mean
diameter of the pipe.
D = pipe diameter
DL = Deflection lag factor. Sound engineering judgment shall be used in
selecting this value, (see M45). A minimum value of 1.5 shall be
used in all designs.
E' = composite modulus of soil reaction as determined by M45
PS = Pipe stiffness as determined in M45. The minimum pipe stiffness
class allowed for any underground application shall be 36 psi (248
kPa).
WC = Soil column load, calculated per M45
WL = Live load, calculated per M45
Kx = bedding coefficient selected from the following table-2
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Table 2
Value of bedding coefficient
EQUIVALENT
BEDDING
TYPE OF INSTALLATION BEDDING
COEFFICIENT
ANGLE(1)
Highly compacted, coarse-grained, shaped bedding
with highly compacted backfill material placed at the
180º 0.083
sides of the pipe; 95 percent standard proctor density
or 70 percent relative density or greater
Moderately compacted, coarse-grained, shaped
bedding with moderately compacted backfill material
placed at the sides of the pipe; 85-95 percent 60º 0.103
standard proctor density or 40-70 percent relative
density or greater
(1) The bedding angle is an estimate of the degree of support provided by the
soil at the bottom and haunch area of the pipe. The equivalent bedding angle
may be achieved without special bottom shaping provided that the backfill is
placed and compacted at the sides of the pipe in several lifts below the
springline. For small diameter pipe at least one compacted lift is required
below the springline.
Note: The following charts are examples of the relationship between soil and
live loads and their effect on total load on the pipe.
Figure-11
Relationship between soil load, live loads and total load for highway loading.
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure-12
Relationship between soil load, live loads and total load for railroad loading.
𝜎ℎ ≤ HDS Equation 32
Equation 33
Where:
h = combined hoop stress
b = ring bending strain
Pd = design pressure
D = pipe diameter
Ehf = hoop flexural (ring bending) modulus of elasticity
t = structural wall thickness
tt = total wall thickness
rc = re-rounding coefficient, for P ≤ 3 then rc = 1 – P / 3, for P > 3 then rc = 0;
Df = shape factor per M45
y = vertical deflection
HDS = hydrostatic design stress
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure-13
Restrained thermal contraction due to axial tensile stress
Equation 34
Where:
t = axial stress from restrained thermal contraction
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure-14
Hoop expansion due to internal pressure
Equation 35
Where:
m = axial stress from restrained Poisson effect
ha = Poisson ratio (axial response to an applied hoop load)
Pd = design pressure
R = radius of pipe
Eat = axial tensile modulus of elasticity
Eht = hoop tensile modulus of elasticity
t = structural wall thickness
d. Axial stress from bending curvature
Beam bending inducing axial stress in the pipe can result from an uneven
bedding, differential settlement and subsidence of the soil. The pipe design shall
allow for trench irregularities that cannot be resolved at joints and for potential
settlement and subsidence by applying an appropriate bending model to
calculate the resulting stress. The general equation based on a uniform radius
of curvature of the pipe, as well as one additional example are given below and
figure-15.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure-15
Pipe radius of curvature
Equation 36
The following example is based on the assumption that the pipe is fixed on both
ends, with displacement forced at one end. See figure-16.
Figure-16
Pipe fixed on both ends
Equation 37
Where:
c = axial stress from curvature
Eaf = axial flexural modulus of elasticity
R = radius of pipe
r = radius of curvature of deflected pipe
M = bending moment from the selected beam bending model
d = expected displacement from trench irregularities or settlement
L = assumed length over which displacement occurs
It is the responsibility in the design engineering to select an appropriate beam
bending model to represent the anticipated displacement of the pipe in the
specific system.
e. Combined axial stress in Fixed Pipe Regions
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
The allowable axial stress used for design is determined in section 5.2 and shall
be compared to the combined axial stresses as follows:
Equation 38
Where:
ax = allowable axial stress under combined loading conditions,
per section 5.2
t = axial stress from restrained thermal contraction
m = axial stress from restrained Poisson effect
c = axial stress from curvature
8.3.6 Thrust restraint
a. Thrust Forces
All thrust forces occur at changes in direction, changes in cross-sectional area,
and at piping terminations. Thrust forces develop as a result of the static internal
pressure in the pipe and dynamic thrust due to changes in momentum of a
flowing fluid. Forces from thermal expansion of the pipe are additive to thrust
forces from internal pressure but displacements are usually small as movement
is resisted by pipe-soil friction.
Typical examples of hydrostatic thrust are shown in the following Figures.
Calculate hydrostatic thrust force T as noted below for the specific configuration
shown in figure-17.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 17
Typical examples of hydrostatic thrust
Equations
39, 40
Equations 41, 42
Equation 43, 44
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Figure 18
Virtual anchor location and various UG weight
For dead end, wye, tee and reducer fitting configurations shown above,
calculate the virtual anchor location as follows:
L= thrust force Equation 45
Frictional resistance
L= T Equation 46
f(2We + Wp + Ww)
For bend and bifurcation fitting configurations shown above, calculate the virtual
anchor location as follows:
L= T Equation 48
2f(2We + Wp + Ww)
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Where:
L = distance from the applied thrust point to the virtual
anchor
T = thrust force
We = weight of soil cover per unit length
Wp = weight of pipe per unit length
Ww = weight of fluid contents per unit length
f = coefficient of friction between pipe and soil, see table-3
Table-3
Coefficient of friction between pipe and soil
f SOIL
0.4 Silt
0.5 Sand
0.6 Gravel
0.6 Clay
Note: These values are appropriate for soils compacted to 95 percent of the
maximum dry density as determined by the Standard Proctor method, ASTM D
698
d. Vertical Bends
Uplift forces caused by vertical bends shall be resisted by dead weight alone,
without the benefit of frictional forces. The mass of the length of pipe tied to
each leg of the bend provides the necessary balancing forces. Joints within this
tied length shall be capable of transmitting axial forces. See figure-19.
Figure-19
Uplift forces caused by vertical bends
L= Equation 50
Where:
L = tied length
T = thrust force
We = weight of soil cover per unit length
Wp = weight of pipe per unit length
Ww = weight of fluid contents per unit length
= angle of pipe per above Figure
= angle of pipe per above Figure
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
e. Thrust Blocks
Concrete thrust blocks increase the ability of fittings to resist movement by
increasing the bearing area and dead weight of the fitting.
Thrust blocks should be shaped with the 'bearing area' against undisturbed
native soil of the trench wall and perpendicular to the direction of the thrust.
The 'bearing area' of the thrust block is determined by:
Ab = TN Equation 51
s
Where:
Ab = bearing area of thrust block
T = thrust force
N = 1.5, minimum safety factor
s = bearing strength of soil
Knowledge of local native soil conditions is necessary for proper sizing of thrust
blocks. The design shall consider the proper bearing strength of a particular soil
type. Typical values for bearing strength are given in the following table-4
Table-4
Typical values for bearing strength
BEARING
SOIL TYPE
STRENGTH (psf)
Soft Clay 1000
Silt 1500
Sandy Silt 3000
Sand 4000
Sandy Clay 6000
Hard Clay 9000
Firm Gravel 15000
This procedure for sizing thrust blocks is typically valid when the depth to the
bottom of the block is twice the height of the block. For shallower thrust blocks
shear resistance of the passive soil wedge behind the block rather than bearing
strength shall govern. In this case special design consideration is required.
The dimensions of the thrust block should be large enough so that the pipe is
encapsulated. At the junction of the pipe and thrust block excessive bending
stresses can develop between the pipe and rigid concrete. The pipe should be
wrapped in rubber at the interface to cushion the pipe and distribute stresses.
8.3.7 Combined Axial Stress in Moving Pipe Regions
For pipe in moving regions near changes in direction, stresses from restrained
temperature change and Poisson effect decrease from maximum at the virtual
anchor position to nearly zero at the fitting. However, axial bending stresses
resulting from movement into the soil reach maximum near the fitting. In many
installations the changing stresses in the moving pipe regions tend to be self-
balancing and pipe designed for fixed pipe regions is adequate. This tendency is
heavily dependent on operating conditions and soil parameters and for most
applications, computer analysis should be used to accurately determine combined
axial stresses.
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Fp = PdAi Equation 52
Equation 53
Where:
Fp = pressure thrust
p = axial stress due to pressure thrust
Pd = design pressure
Ai = cross-sectional area of the pipe of interest
Ai = πD2
4
R = average radius
t = structural wall thickness
D = pipe diameter
The allowable axial stress used for design is determined in SES P01-E28-01
and shall be compared to the axial stress due to pressure thrust as follows:
a p Equation 54
Where:
ax = allowable axial stress under combined loading conditions, per
section 5.2
p = axial stress due to pressure thrust
8.4 Computer stress analysis techniques
8.4.1 General
Computer analysis is not intended to replace the traditional manual calculations in
section 8.3 of this standard. Computer analysis shall be used to augment manual
calculations and to provide sufficient resolution.
8.4.2 Computer Analysis Requirements
Program requirements for computer analysis of underground piping systems are
the same as those for aboveground systems with the additional ability to model
pipe-soil interaction.
The backfill and native soils provide resistance to movement of an underground
pipe and the magnitude of displacements is dependent upon the stiffness of this
surrounding soil envelope. Because of this dependency, it is critical that the soil
properties input in the computer analysis accurately represent the intended
installation. The geotechnical factors required as input by computer programs
includes:
a. Soil density
b. Coefficient of friction between pipe and soil
c. Friction angle between pipe and soil
d. Coefficient of horizontal stress (coefficient of horizontal subgrade reaction)
e. Undrained shear strength
From this simplified input many other geotechnical factors, soil stiffness and
strengths, and ultimate loads are computed to fully characterize pipe-soil
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
The following general categories shall be included; refer to the applicable sections of this
standard for additional clarification:
9.2.1 Operating and Upset Design Conditions
Include the full range of positive and negative pressures and temperatures
potentially experienced in the system.
9.2.2 Wind and Earthquake Conditions.
9.2.3 Burial Conditions
Include any available information used as a basis for classification of native soils
or other site conditions.
Include all underground pipe installation conditions to fully describe the excavation
and backfill methods to be used as a basis for the associated design parameters.
Include manufacturer's installation specification.
Include groundwater, surface conditions, anticipated settlement, or any other
unusual sources of load on the pipe.
Include the range of installation temperatures anticipated or used as the basis for
the analysis.
9.2.4 Live Loads
Define all loads resulting from personnel, traffic, construction or other potential
sources.
9.2.5 Service Considerations
Describe the service fluids and other special conditions which may affect material
selection or serviceability of the piping.
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
11 Hold Points
Design Engineering Company shall carry out the review to clear the following hold points.
11.1 Award of FRP piping shall be kept on hold until qualified review of bidders’ technical
proposal is completed and approved by Third Party FRP consultant and company.
11.2 Deleted
11.3 Manufacturing/Fabrication of FRP pipe and components shall be kept on hold until design
review and stress analysis (including surge analysis and FEA) is completed.
11.4 Delivery of pipe and components shall be kept on hold until all outstanding NCRs have
been resolved for applicable batch.
11.5 Hydrotest at construction site shall be kept on hold until all outstanding NCRs and field
changes to piping design have been resolved for applicable batch.
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
12 Revision History
Revision No 3, Dec. 2014 Restructured: Overall restructuring by combining SES P01-
E28-03 requirement, renumbering, rearranging and formatting
the various sections.
Updated: References
Added: Various sections based on improvements and lessons
learned
Modified: Various sections based on improvements and
lessons learned
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
Sr.
Criteria Units Value Source Remarks
No.
1 Service Conditions
1.1 Service Fluid Provide separate detailed
description
1.2 Piping Class
2 Pressure
2.1 Operating Pressure KPa
2.2 Design Pressure KPa
2.3 Maximum Upset Pressure KPa
2.4 Hydrotest Pressure KPa
2.5 Operating Vacuum KPa mm of mercury or mm of water
2.6 Design Vacuum KPa mm of mercury or mm of water
3 Temperature
3.1 Operating Temperature, min/max ºC
3.2 Design Temperature ºC
3.3 Upset Temperature, min/max ºC
4 Site Conditions
4.1 Wind Zone
4.2 Seismic Zone
4.3 Ambient Temperature ºC
4.4 Live Loading Such as personnel, etc
4.5 Traffic Loading
4.6 Groundwater Elevation m Relative to pipe elevation
4.7 Native Soil Classification
5 Installation
5.1 Trench Type and Width
5.2 Burial Depth range m Finish grade to top of pipe
5.3 Backfill/Bedding Soil Classification
5.4 Backfill Soil Density
5.5 Installation Temperature
a. Aboveground, min/max ºC
b. Belowground, min/max ºC
5.6 Surface Paving Material and
Thickness
5.7 Settlement or Trench Curvature mm
6 Other
6.1 Fire retardancy
6.2 Abrasion resistance
6.3 Unusual transient loads
Classification: General Business Use
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5
The following form shall be completed and returned with the Pipe Vendor's quotation for pipe and
components proposed for each Line Class. Only data pertaining to a single Line Class shall be submitted
on this form. If construction method, materials, configuration or pressure rating vary between diameters
within this Service Class, a separate form shall be used for each type.
NUMBER P01-E28-02
Design Requirements for REV. No. 5