Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Annex-A
to the Minutes of 109th EAB held on March 22, 2023 at PEC HQ, Islamabad
Zone-I (Punjab)
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
01. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Sahiwal Campus)
Program Bachelor of Science Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
in Mechanical against accreditation criteria/ quality
Engineering standards and implementation of the
Current Intake of Batch Fall- Outcome-Based Assessment procedures
Status 2014. [*From Intake of and CQI, re-accreditation is granted for one
Batch 2010 to Spring- (01) year i.e. Intake Batch 2018 under Level-
2014] to 2017. II.
Visit Type Re-accreditation
The Institution, however, is required to
Date of Visit November 21-22, address all weaknesses & concerns
2022 particularly in Criteria 2, 3, and 4 as
mentioned in the visit report as part of its CQI
process before applying for re-accreditation.
02. Khwaja Fareed University of Engineering & Information Technology, Rahim
Yar Khan
Program BS Civil Engineering Based on partial implementation of OBE and
Current Intake of Batch 2017 incomplete assessment along-with CQI of
Status only the program, re-accreditation is granted for
a. Visit Type Re-Accreditation one (01) year i.e. Intake Batch 2018 under
Level-I.
Date of Visit December 2-3, 2022
The Institution, however, is required to
address all deficiencies, weaknesses &
concerns particularly in Criteria 3, 5 and 8 as
mentioned in the visit report as part of its CQI
process before applying for re-accreditation.
Program BS Computer Based on partial implementation of OBE and
Engineering incomplete assessment along-with CQI of
Current Intake of Batch 2017 the program, re-accreditation is granted for
Status only one (01) year i.e. Intake Batch 2018 under
Level-I.
Visit Type Re-Accreditation
b. The Institution, however, is required to
Date of Visit December 2-3, 2022 address all deficiencies, weaknesses &
concerns particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3, 5 and
8 as mentioned in the visit report as part of
its CQI process before applying for re-
accreditation.
03. NFC Institute of Engineering & Fertilizer Research, Faisalabad
Program B.Sc. Civil Based on partial implementation of OBE and
Engineering incomplete assessment along-with CQI of
2
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
a. Current From Intake of Batch the program, re-accreditation is
Status 2010 to 2017 recommended for one (01) year i.e. Intake
Visit Type Re-Accreditation Batch 2018 under Level-II subject to
Date of Visit December 30-31, fulfillment of PhD requirement (Total 4 PhDs
2022 for 02 Sections).
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
iii. Wind & Hydropower Conversion (ESE-
312)
iv. Boiler Engineering & Power Plants
(ESE-314)
v. Hydrogen & Fuel Cells (ESE-321)
vi. Bio-Energy Engineering (ESE-322)
vii. Microbial Bioenergy & Biofuels (ESE-
325)
viii. Renewable Energy Systems (ESE-
414)
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
concerns, particularly in Criteria 2,3,5,8 and
9 as mentioned in the visit report as part of
its CQI process before applying for re-
accreditation.
Program B.Sc. Civil Based on partial implementation of OBE and
Engineering incomplete assessment along-with CQI of
Current From Intake of Batch the program, re-accreditation is granted for
Status Fall-2014 to 2017 one (01) year i.e. Intake Batch 2018 under
Visit Type Re-Accreditation Level-I.
b. Date of Visit November 4-5, 2022
The Institution, however, is required to
address all deficiencies, weaknesses &
concerns, particularly in Criteria 1,2,3,4 and
8 as mentioned in the visit report as part of
its CQI process before applying for re-
accreditation.
Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on partial implementation of OBE and
(Electronics/ Power) incomplete assessment along-with CQI of
Engineering the program, re-accreditation is granted for
Current From Intake of Batch one (01) year i.e. Intake Batch 2018 under
Status 2009 to 2017 Level-I.
c. Visit Type Re-Accreditation
Date of Visit November 4-5, 2022 The Institution, however, is required to
address all deficiencies, weaknesses &
concerns, particularly in Criteria 1,3,4,8 and
9 as mentioned in the visit report as part of
its CQI process before applying for re-
accreditation.
06. Wah Engineering College, Wah
Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
Engineering against accreditation criteria/ quality
Current From Intake of Batch standards and implementation of the
Status 2010 to 2016) Outcome-Based Assessment procedures
(From Intake of Batch and CQI, re-accreditation is granted for Two
2004 to 2009), (02) years i.e. Intake Batch 2018 & 2019
including enrolment at under Level-II.
Wah Engineering
College, Wah Cantt. The Institution, however, is required to
(affiliated with address all weakness & concerns,
University of particularly in Criteria 3 as mentioned in the
Engineering and visit report as part of its CQI process before
Technology, Taxila) applying for re-accreditation.
Visit Type Re-Accreditation
Date of Visit December 1-2, 2022
-
5
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
01. Indus University, Karachi
Program B.E. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of
(Electronics/Power) compliance against accreditation criteria/
Current From Intake of Batch quality standards and implementation of the
Status 2015 to 2017 Outcome-Based Assessment procedures
Visit Type Re-accreditation and CQI, re-accreditation is recommended
Date of Visit December 12-13, for one (01) year i.e. Intake Batch 2018
2022 under Level-II subject to appointment of at
least one (01) additional PhD faculty in core/
relevant engineering discipline for fulfilment
of minimum two (02) PhD requirement per
section as per PEC policy.
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
ii. Summative assessment (PLO
attainment in three KSA domains) of
the graduating batches.
iii. Faculty training for proper
understanding and implementation of
OBE.
iv. Evidence of Complex Engineering
Problems as per guidelines of PEC
Accreditation Manual 2019 on
Problem-based Learning, and Open-
ended Labs.
v. Lab rubrics to be revised and mapped
to appropriate learning domains i.e.
cognitive, affective or psychomotor
along with justifiable taxonomy level.
SoPs and rubrics for FYDP needs to
be improved.
vi. Proper maintenance of Course
Folders of all subjects along with
course- review-proformas.
vii. Well-defined CQI process,
institutionalized with clear evidence of
corrective actions and curriculum
review.
Note:
No students were enrolled by HEI after
intake batch 2020.
03. Mehran University of Engineering and Technology-Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali
Bhutto, Campus Khairpur Mirs (Mehran University of Engineering and
Technology, Jamshoro)
a. Program B.E. Software Based on the satisfactory level of
Current Intake of Batch 2016 compliance against accreditation criteria/
Status to 2017 quality standards and implementation of the
Visit Type Re-accreditation Outcome-Based Assessment procedures
7
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
Date of Visit December 23-24,2022 and CQI, reaccreditation is recommended
for one (01) year i.e., for Intake Batches
2018 under Level-Il subject to fulfillment of
Minimum Faculty Strength (MFS) i.e. eight
(08) for a section of 40 students.
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
and Part-II (having mapping with
relevant PLOs) along with FYDP
report evaluation rubrics.
iv. Submission of revised lab
assessment mechanism, lab
semester project rubrics (including
lab project report marks), lab project
report template and lab assessment
rubrics as per taxonomy levels (one
for software related lab and while
second one for hardware based lab).
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
v. The course files should reflect an
adequate exposer of complex
engineering problems (CEPs) to the
students.
vi. Training of Faculty members on
PLO/CLOs mapping, CQI process
and CEPs
vii. Biomedical instrumentation and
biomedical control lab to be
established with appropriate number
of workstations/kits
viii. Exclusive provisions of funding for
FYDP, R&D persuades, lab supplies,
etc must be reflected in the budget.
ix. Documentary evidence of
proceedings/ minutes of the meeting
and involvement of other
stakeholders in the formulation and
review of PEOs.
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
01. The University of Lahore, Lahore (Islamabad Campus)
a. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of
Engineering compliance against accreditation criteria/
Current From Intake of Batch quality standards and implementation of the
Status 2014 to 2018 Outcome-Based Assessment procedures
Visit Type Re-Accreditation and CQI, re-accreditation is granted for one
Date of Visit January 28-29, 2023 (01) year i.e., Intake Batch 2019 under
Level-II.
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
Current From Intake of Batch
Status 2015 to 2017 Further, re-accreditation is also
Visit Type Re-Accreditation recommended for intake batch 2019 under
Date of Visit November 24-25, Level-I subject to submission of satisfactory
2022 compliance report alongwith tangible
evidences on all observations/ deficiencies,
weaknesses & concerns as mentioned in
the detailed visit report.
Annex B
to the Minutes of 109th EAB held on March 22, 2023 at PEC HQ, Islamabad.
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
01. Mehran University of Engineering and Technology, Jamshoro
Program B.E. Metallurgy & Based on physical verification and
Materials assessment during confirmatory visit, re-
Current Till Intake of Batch F- accreditation is granted for intake batch
Status 2016 to 2017 2018 under Level-II.
Visit Type Confirmatory visit
Date of November 28, 2022 The Institution, however, is required to
Visit address all weaknesses & concerns in all
Criteria as mentioned in the PEV report as
part of its CQI process before applying for
re-accreditation visit.
02. The Salim Habib University, Karachi
Program B.E. Biomedical Based on physical verification and
Current From Intake of Batch assessment during confirmatory visit, re-
Status 2017 accreditation is granted for intake batch
Visit Type Confirmatory visit 2018 under Level-II.
Date of February 6, 2023
Visit The Institution, however, is required to
address all weaknesses & concerns in all
Criteria as mentioned in the PEV report as
part of its CQI process before applying for
re-accreditation visit.
03 Habib University, Karachi
Program BS Computer Based on physical assessment and
Engineering evaluation of the program, permission is
Current Under Process granted to continue the program.
Status
Visit Type Confirmatory of The Institution, however, is required to
Interim visit address all other observations as mentioned
Date of November 12, 2022 in the detailed report as part of CQI process
Visit for verification during Accreditation visit.
04 Balochistan University of Engineering and Technology, Khuzdar
a. Program B.E Electronics Based on physical assessment and
Current Under Process evaluation of the program, permission is
Status granted to continue the program.
Visit Type Interim
Date of November 19, 2022 The Institution, however, is required to
Visit address all other observations as mentioned
in the detailed report as part of CQI process
for verification during Accreditation visit.
b. Program B.E Energy Based on physical assessment and
Current Under Process evaluation of the program, permission is
Status recommended to continue the program
Visit Type Interim subject to submission of satisfactory
16
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decisions
Profile
Date of November 19, 2022 compliance report on all observations
Visit mentioned in the PEV Report.
05 Pakistan Navy Engineering College, Karachi (National University of Sciences
and Technology, Islamabad)
Program B.E Naval Architecture Based on physical assessment and
Current evaluation of the program, permission is
Under Process recommended to continue the program
Status
Visit Type Interim subject to submission of satisfactory
Date of November 07, 2022 compliance report on the following
Visit observations:
i. Establishment of Environmental
Chemistry & Microbiology Lab.
ii. Separate dedicated labs of Air
Quality, Noise Quality, water &
Wastewater Quality.
iii. Addition of lab part in the course of
Fluid Mechanics.
iv. Improvement in Lab Manuals and
development of proper rubrics for
lab work
-
17
Name of University/Program
S# 109-EAB Decision
Profile
01. Institute of Engineering and Technology, Gomal University, Dera Ismail Khan
a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on physical verification and
(Telecommunication)E assessment during Confirmatory visit, re-
ngineering accreditation is granted for Intake Batch
Current From Intake of Batch 2018 under Level-II.
Status Fall-2011 to 2017
Visit Type Confirmatory of Re- However, the observations/ weaknesses
Accreditation and concerns identified in the PEC visitation
Date of November 26, 2022 report must be addressed. Further, to
Visit observe CQI, university/institute has to
submit separate progress report along with
evidence to PEC, while applying for
subsequent re-accreditation visit.
-----