102 EAB All Zones Decision(s)

Annex-A1
to the Minutes of 102nd EAB held on September 21, 2021 at PEC HQ, Islamabad.
Agenda Item No.07 (a) (1) Consideration of Reports/ Summaries

[Accreditation/Re-accreditation]
Zone-I (Punjab)
Name of University/Program
S# Decision of 102nd EAB
Profile
1. University College of Agriculture, Multan (Bahauddin Zakariya University,
Multan)
Program B.Sc. Agricultural Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses
Engineering in most of the criteria and partial
Current Status From Intake of implementation of OBE, re-accreditation is
Batch 2004 to granted for one year i.e., Intake Batch 2017
2016 under Level-I, First Schedule of PEC Act.
Visit Type Re-accreditation
Date of Visit July 03-04, 2021 Further, next SAR for Intake Batch 2018 will
only be considered subject to submission of
satisfactory compliance report alongwith
tangible evidences on all deficiencies and
weaknesses mentioned in visit report.
The Institution; however, is advised to

address all deficiencies/ weak areas/
concerns, particularly in Criteria 3, 5, 6, & 8.
Furthermore, all other observations as
mentioned in the detailed report be addressed
as a part of its CQI process before applying
for re-accreditation visit under OBA.
2. University College of Engineering and Technology, Multan (Bahauddin Zakariya

University, Multan)
a. Program B.Sc. Civil Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses
Batch 1994 to granted for two years i.e., Intake Batches
2014 2015 & 2016 under Level-I of First Schedule.
Date of Visit July 03-04, 2021 Further, re-accreditation is also
recommended for Intake Batch 2017 under
Level-I of First Schedule subject to
submission of satisfactory compliance report
on the deficiencies and major weaknesses
mentioned in the visit report.

concerns, particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4 5, 6,
7, 8 & 9. Furthermore, all other observations
as mentioned in the detailed report be
i
Profile
addressed as a part of its CQI process before
applying for re-accreditation visit under OBA.
b. Program B.Sc. Computer Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Engineering compliance against accreditation criteria/
quality standards during physical
Current Status From Intake of accreditation visit, the already granted
Batch 2004 to provisional accreditation to intake batch 2016
2016 under Level-I is validated.
Date of Visit July 03-04, 2021 Further, re-accreditation is also
recommended for Intake Batch 2017 under
Level-I of First Schedule subject to
on following:
a) Appointment/ hiring of HoD registered in

same/ core engineering discipline having
PhD in relevant engineering discipline.
b) Appointment/ hiring of one (01) MS/ PhD

qualified faculty to meet the Minimum
Faculty Strength i.e 08 for one section of
40 students.
c) Evidence regarding conduction of two

courses i.e. CPE-426 (Parallel &
Distributed Computing) and CPE-321
(Embedded Systems)
d) Evidence regarding assessment of FYDP

as per new Accreditation Manual-2019
guidelines with trackable record and
plagiarism test for onward submission for
the compliance.
Moreover, the HEI is advised to submit

tangible evidences on followings within Six
(06) months:
a) Procurement of deficient lab equipment in

all the labs as mentioned in visit report.
b) Adequacy of arrangements should be

taken to ensure work-place safety (EHS
concerns) in general, and while performing
experiments in the labs in particular.
c) Evidence regarding completion of course

folders as per Accreditation Manual-2019
guidelines.
ii
Profile
d) Formal Training on OBE of all faculty.
e) Proper mechanism should be adapted for
Complex Engineering Problems (CEPs),
Open Ended Labs and Problem based
learning for relevant courses.

c. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on partial implementation of OBE and

Engineering incomplete assessment/ CQI, re-accreditation
Current Status From Intake of is granted for Two years i.e., Intake Batch
Batch 1997 to 2016 & 2017 under Level-I of First Schedule.
2015
Visit Type Re-accreditation The Institution; however, is advised to
Date of Visit July 03-04, 2021 address all the deficiencies/ weak areas/
d. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on partial implementation of OBE and

Engineering incomplete assessment/ CQI, re-accreditation
Current Status From Intake of is granted for One year i.e., Intake Batch-
Batch 2004 to 2017 under Level-I of First Schedule.
2016
Date of Visit July 03-04, 2021 address all the deficiencies/ weak areas/
concerns, particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 4, 5, & 7.
3. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Lahore Campus) [*Formerly COMSATS

Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad (Lahore Campus)]
a. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
Science in against accreditation criteria/ quality
Electrical standards and implementation of the
(Electronics) Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
Engineering CQI, provisional re-accreditation already
Current Status From Intake Batch granted to Intake Batch-2016 under Level-I is
Fall-2012 to 2016 validated and up-graded to Level-II.
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 Intake Batch 2016 is the last batch of the
program Bachelor of Science in Electrical
(Electronics) Engineering.
iii
Profile
b. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
Current Status From Intake Batch CQI, re-accreditation is granted for two (02)
Fall-2004 to 2016 years i.e. intake batches 2017 & 2018 under
Visit Type Re-accreditation Level-II.
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021
address all the deficiencies/ weak areas/
concerns, particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 4 & 7.
4. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Wah Campus) [*Formerly COMSATS Institute

of Information Technology, Islamabad (Wah Campus)]
Program B.Sc. Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering against accreditation criteria/ quality
Current Status From Intake of standards and implementation of the
Batch 2012 to Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
2016 CQI, provisional re-accreditation already
Visit Type Re-accreditation granted to Intake Batch-2016 under Level-I is
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 validated and up-graded to Level-II.
Further, based on the satisfactory level of

compliance against accreditation criteria/
quality standards and implementation of the
Outcome Based Assessment re-accreditation
is also granted for two years i.e., Intake
Batches 2017 & 2018 under Level-II.

concerns, particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 4, 5 & 7.
5. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Sahiwal Campus) [*Formerly COMSATS

Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad (Sahiwal Campus)]

Current Status Under process implementation of OBE, re-accreditation is
Visit Type Accreditation granted for one year i.e., Intake Batch 2017
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 under Level-I, First Schedule of PEC Act.
iv
Profile
concerns, particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 4,5, 6, 7,
8 & 9. Furthermore, all other observations as
b. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Mechanical standards and implementation of the
Current Status From Intake of CQI, accreditation is granted for one year i.e.,
Batch Fall-2014 to Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II.
2016
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 address all the deficiencies/ weak areas/
concerns, particularly in Criteria 3, 4, 5, 6, & 7.
c. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Current Status From Intake of CQI, accreditation is granted for two years i.e.,
Batch Fall-2014 to Intake Batches 2017 & 2018 under Level-II.
2016
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 address all the deficiencies/ weak areas/
concerns, particularly for the Criteria 1, 3, 5, &
7. Furthermore, all other observations as
6. College of Engineering and Emerging Technologies, Lahore (University of the

Punjab, Lahore)
a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

2016 CQI, accreditation is granted for one year i.e.,
Visit Type Re-accreditation Intake Batch 2016 under Level-II.
Date of Visit July 02-03, 2021
Further; re-accreditation for intake batch 2017
is also recommended under Level-II subject to
alongwith evidences on the weaknesses as
highlighted in the visit report.
v
Profile

address the weak areas/ concerns,
particularly in Criteria 2 & 3. Furthermore, all
other observations as mentioned in the
detailed report be addressed as a part of its
CQI process before applying for re-
accreditation visit under OBA.
b. Program B.Sc. Metallurgy Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

and Materials against accreditation criteria/ quality
Engineering standards and implementation of the
Current Status From Intake of Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
Batch 2015 to CQI, accreditation is granted for One year i.e.,
2016 Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II.
Date of Visit July 02-03, 2021 Further; re-accreditation for intake batch 2018
is also recommended under Level-II subject to
a confirmatory visit to verify the compliance on
all observations (deficiencies & major
weaknesses) highlighted in the visit report.

concerns, particularly for the Criteria 2, 3, 4, 5,
7. Dr. A. Q. Khan Institute of Computer Sciences and Information Technology,

Kahuta, Rawalpindi (University of Engineering and Technology, Taxila)
a. Program Bachelor of Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses
Science in in most of the criteria and partial
Computer implementation of OBE for Intake Batch 2016,
Engineering provisional re-accreditation already granted
Current Status From Intake of under Level-I is validated.
Batch Fall-2014 to
2016 Further, based on the satisfactory level of
Visit Type Re-accreditation compliance against accreditation criteria/
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 quality standards and implementation of the
Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
CQI, re-accreditation is granted for two years
i.e., Intake Batch 2017 and 2018 under Level-
II.
vi
Profile
8. Government College University, Faisalabad

a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses
(Telecommunicatio in most of the criteria and partial
n) Engineering implementation of OBE for Intake Batch 2016,
Current Status From Intake of provisional re-accreditation already granted
Batch 2009 to under Level-I is validated.
2016 Further, based on partial implementation of
Visit Type Re-accreditation OBE and incomplete assessment/ CQI for
Date of Visit June 25-26, 2021 intake batch 2017, re-accreditation is granted
for one year under Level-I, First Schedule of
PEC Act.
Moreover; re-accreditation for intake batch

2018 is also recommended under Level-II
subject to a confirmatory visit to verify the
compliance on all observations (deficiencies &
major weaknesses) highlighted in the visit
report

concerns, particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8
& 9. Furthermore, all other observations as
9. Government College University, Lahore

a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses
implementation of OBE for Intake Batch 2016,
Current Status From Intake of provisional re-accreditation already granted
Batch 2008 to under Level-I is validated.
2016
Visit Type Re-accreditation Further; re-accreditation for intake batch 2017
Date of Visit June 17-18, 2021 is also recommended under Level-I subject to
a confirmatory visit to verify the conduct of
hardware component of the experiments
related to following courses by the students of
intake batch 2017.
a) Communication Systems (3+1)

b) Power Electronics (3+1)
c) Linear Control Systems (3+1)
d) Digital Signal Processing (3+1)
e) Computer Communication Networks (3+1)
f) Industrial Electronics (3+1)
g) Mobile & Wireless Communication (3+1)
h) Power System Analysis (3+1)
Moreover, the HEI is advised to submit

vii
Profile
tangible evidences on procurement of
equipment/ workstations to accommodate 3-4
students in all labs within Six (06) months.

10. HITEC University, Taxila

a. Program B.Sc. Computer Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
2016 CQI, accreditation is granted for three years
Visit Type Re-accreditation i.e., Intake Batches 2017 to 2019 under Level-
Date of Visit June 14-15, 2021 II.

particularly in Criteria 5, 6 & 8. Furthermore,
all other observations as mentioned in the
b. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

2016 CQI, accreditation is granted for three years
Visit Type Re-accreditation i.e., Intake Batches 2017 to 2019 under Level-
Date of Visit June 14-15, 2021 II.

particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, & 5.
c. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Current Status From Intake of standards, implementation of the Outcome
Batch 2007 to Based Assessment procedures & CQI and as
2016 a result of validation visit, re-accreditation is
Visit Type Re-accreditation granted for Two years i.e., Intake Batches
Date of Visit June 14-15, 2021 2017 & 2018 under Level-II, First Schedule of
PEC Act.
viii
Profile
particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3 & 8. Furthermore,
11. Information Technology University, Lahore

a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory implementation of
Engineering OBA and reasonable attainment of PLOs at
Current Status From Intake of student and cohort level, the already granted
Batch 2013 to provisional accreditation to intake Batch –
2016 2016 under Level-I is validated and up-graded
Visit Type Re-accreditation to Level-II.
CQI, accreditation is granted for two years i.e.,
Intake Batches 2017 & 2018 under Level-II.

address all the weak areas/ concerns,
particularly for the Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 & 7.
12. Institute of Southern Punjab, Lahore

Current Status From Intake of implementation of OBE for Intake Batch 2016,
Batch 2014 to provisional re-accreditation already granted
2016 under Level-II is reverted to Level-I.
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 The Institution; however, is advised to
concerns, particularly in Criteria 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 &
b. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

Current Status From Intake of implementation of OBE for Intake Batch 2016,
Batch 2014 to provisional re-accreditation already granted
2016 under Level-II is reverted to Level-I.
ix
Profile
concerns, particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,
6, 7, 8 & 9. Furthermore, all other observations
13. Lahore University of Management Sciences, Lahore

2016 CQI, provisional re-accreditation already
Visit Type Re-accreditation granted to Intake Batch 2016 under Level-II,
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 is validated.

CQI, re-accreditation is granted for three
years i.e., Intake Batches 2017 to 2019 under
Level-II.

14. NFC Institute of Engineering and Technology, Multan

2016 CQI, accreditation is granted for one year i.e.,
Visit Type Re-accreditation Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II.
address all the weak areas/ concerns,
particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 6, 8 & 9.
for re-accreditation visit under OBA
b. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

x
Profile
Date of Visit June 25-26, 2021 The Institution; however, is advised to
concerns, particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 4, 5, 6,
c. Program B.Sc. Petroleum & Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

Gas Engineering in most of the criteria and partial
Visit Type Accreditation
Date of Visit June 25-26, 2021 The Institution; however, is advised to ensure
full compliance on deficiencies / weak areas /
concerns, particularly for the Criteria 3, 4 & 5.
Zone-II (Sindh & Balochistan)
S# Name of University/Program Profile Decision of 102nd EAB

01. Dawood University of Engineering and Technology, Karachi
a. Program B.E Chemical Based on verification of satisfactory level of
Current Status From Intake of Batch compliance against accreditation criteria/
2005 to 2016 quality standards during physical accreditation
Visit Type Re-accreditation visit, the already granted provisional
Date of Visit June 24-25, 2021 accreditation to intake batch 2016 under Level-
I is validated.

CQI, re-accreditation is granted for two (02)
years i.e., Intake Batches 2017 and 2018
under Level-II, First Schedule of PEC Act.
The Institution, however, is required to address

the deficiencies/ weak areas/ concerns,
xi
as a part of its CQI process before applying for
re-accreditation visit under OBA.
b. Program B.E. Computer System Based on verification of satisfactory level of

I is validated.
Further, based on deficiencies and major

weaknesses in most of the criteria and partial
implementation of OBE, re-accreditation is
granted for one (01) year i.e., Intake Batch

particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 4, 5, 8 & 9.
c. Program B.E. Electronics Based on verification of satisfactory level of

I is validated.


particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8 & 9.
d. Program B.E. Energy and Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

Environment in most of the criteria and partial
Current Status From Intake of Batch implementation of OBE, re-accreditation is
2011 to 2015 granted for two (02) years i.e., Intake Batches
xii
Date of Visit June 24-25, 2021 2016 & 2017 under Level-I, First Schedule of
PEC Act.

particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 & 8.
e. Program B.E. Industrial Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering and against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Management and implementation of the Outcome Based
Current Status From Intake of Batch Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
2005 to 2016 (except accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.,
intake batch 2006 to Intake Batches 2017 and 2018 under Level-II,
2007) First Schedule of PEC Act.
Date of Visit June 24-25, 2021 The Institution, however, is required to address
particularly in Criteria 2, 3 & 9. Furthermore, all
f. Program B.E. Petroleum and Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Gas compliance against accreditation criteria/
Current Status From Intake of Batch quality standards during physical accreditation
2011 to 2016 visit, the already granted provisional
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation to intake batches 2015 & 2016
Date of Visit June 24-25, 2021 under Level-I is validated.


g. Program B.E. Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

Telecommunication in most of the criteria and partial
Current Status From Intake of Batch implementation of OBE, re-accreditation is
2011 to 2015 granted for two (02) years i.e., Intake Batches
xiii
Date of Visit June 24-25, 2021 2016 & 2017 under Level-I, First Schedule of
PEC Act.

02. Mehran University of Engineering and Technology, Jamshoro

a. Program B.E. Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
Current Status Till Intake of Batch against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
2016-F and implementation of the Outcome Based
Visit Type Re-accreditation Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.,
Intake Batches 2017 and 2018 under Level-II,
First Schedule of PEC Act.

b. Program B.E. Biomedical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Current Status From Intake of Batch against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
2003 to 2016 and implementation of the Outcome Based
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.,
Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II, First
Schedule of PEC Act.

c. Program B.E. Electronics Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Current Status Till Intake of Batch F- against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
2016 and implementation of the Outcome Based

xiv
d. Program B.E. Industrial Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering and against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Management and implementation of the Outcome Based
Current Status Till Intake of Batch F- Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
2016 accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.,
Visit Type Re-accreditation Intake Batches 2017 and 2018 under Level-II,
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 First Schedule of PEC Act.

e. Program B.E. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance


f. Program B.E. Petroleum and Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Natural Gas against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Current Status Till Intake of Batch F- and implementation of the Outcome Based
2016 Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation is granted for three (03) years
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 i.e., Intake Batches 2017, 2018 & 2019 under
Level-II, First Schedule of PEC Act.

xv
g. Program B.E. Chemical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 accreditation is granted for three (03) years
i.e., Intake Batches 2017, 2018 & 2019 under

03. Mohammad Ali Jinnah University, Karachi

a. Program B.E. Computer Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses
Systems in most of the criteria and partial
Current Status First accreditation implementation of OBE, accreditation is
Visit Type Accreditation recommended for one (01) year i.e., Intake
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 Batch 2017 under Level-I subject to hiring of
more faculty from core engineering discipline
for fulfillment of minimum 8 MFS requirement.

b. Program B.E. Electrical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

Current Status First accreditation in most of the criteria and partial
Visit Type Accreditation implementation of OBE, accreditation is
Date of Visit July 05-06, 2021 granted for one (01) year i.e., Intake Batch

04. NED University of Engineering and Technology, Karachi

a. Program B.E. Automotive Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
2005-06 to 2016-17 and implementation of the Outcome Based
xvi
Intake Batches 2017 & 2018 under Level-II,

b. Program B.E. Petroleum Based on verification of satisfactory level of

2004-05 to 2016-17 quality standards during physical accreditation
Date of Visit July 01-02, 2021 accreditation to intake batch 2016-17 under
Level-I is validated.

years i.e., Intake Batches 2017 & 2018 under

c. Program B.E. Biomedical Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Date of Visit June 21-22, 2021 accreditation to intake batch 2016-17 under

CQI, re-accreditation is granted for one (01)
year i.e., Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II,
Furthermore, re-accreditation is also

recommended for intake batch 2018 under
Level-II subject to the confirmatory visit on the
following:
xvii
i. Appointment of HoD having PEC
registration in relevant discipline and
possessing PhD in Biomedical Engineering
as per the policy in vogue.
ii. Implement FYDP SoPs with the help of
QEC
iii. Ensure FYDP SoPs are implemented on
Intake Batch 2018
iv. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict of
interest between supervisor and
examination committee
v. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in FYDPs
vi. Standardization and proof reading of Project
Reports for quality assurance
vii. Grading of FYDP in line with International
accepted best practices

the deficiencies/ weak areas, particularly in
Criteria 1, 2 & 8. Furthermore, all other
observations as mentioned in the detailed
report be addressed as a part of its CQI
process before applying for re-accreditation
visit under OBA.
d. Program B.E. Chemical Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Level-II is validated.

CQI, re-accreditation is granted for three (03)
years i.e., Intake Batches 2017, 2018 & 2019

e. Program B.E. Civil Based on verification of satisfactory level of

xviii


f. Program B.E. Food Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Date of Visit July 01-02, 2021 accreditation to intake batches 2015-16 &
2016-17 under Level-I is validated.


g. Program B.E. Metallurgical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Date of Visit June 21-22, 2021 accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.,
Further, re-accreditation is also recommended

for intake batch 2018 subject to the submission
of compliance report on the following:
xix
i. Implement FYDP SoPs with the help of
QEC
ii. Ensure FYDP SoPs are implemented on
Intake Batch 2018
iii. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict of
iv. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in FYDPs
v. Standardization and proof reading of Project
vi. Grading of FYDP in line with International

Criteria 2, 3, 5 & 9. Furthermore, all other
visit under OBA.
h. Program B.E. Polymer and Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Petrochemical against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Current Status From Intake of Batch and implementation of the Outcome Based
2007-08 to 2016-17 Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.,
Date of Visit June 21-22, 2021 Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II, First


QEC
Intake Batch 2018
iii. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict of
iv. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in FYDPs
v. Standardization and proof reading of Project

xx
visit under OBA.
i. Program B.E. Software Based on verification of satisfactory level of



recommended for intake batch 2018 subject to
the submission of compliance report on the
following:
i. Appointment of dedicated HoD registered

with PEC in core engineering and
possessing PhD qualification in relevant
discipline.
ii. Appointment of full-time dedicated faculty
to bring student teacher ratio to 20:1
iii. Implement FYDP SoPs with the help of
QEC
iv. Ensure FYDP SoPs are implemented on
Intake Batch 2018
v. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict
of interest between supervisor and
vi. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in
FYDPs
vii. Standardization and proof reading of
Project Reports for quality assurance
viii. Grading of FYDP in line with International

Criteria 1, 2, 3, 5, 8 & 9. Furthermore, all other
visit under OBA.
xxi
j. Program B.E. Textile Based on verification of satisfactory level of


submission of compliance report on the
following:
i. Appointment of dedicated HoD registered

with PEC in core engineering and
possessing PhD qualification in relevant
discipline.
ii. Implement FYDP SoPs with the help of
QEC
iii. Ensure FYDP SoPs are implemented on
Intake Batch 2018
iv. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict
v. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in
FYDPs
vi. Standardization and proof reading of
vii. Grading of FYDP in line with International

visit under OBA.
k. Program B.E. Electrical Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Current Status Till Intake of Batch compliance against accreditation criteria/
2016-17 quality standards during physical accreditation
xxii
accreditation to intake batch 2016-17 under


the induction of more faculty to bring down
student teacher to 20:1.

l. Program B.E. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Current Status Till Intake of Batch against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
2016-17 and implementation of the Outcome Based
i.e., Intake Batches 2017, 2018 & 2019 under

m. Program B.E. Electronics Based on verification of satisfactory level of


xxiii
particularly in Criteria 1, 2, & 8. Furthermore,
n. Program B.E. Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Telecommunication compliance against accreditation criteria/
2002-03 to 2016-17 visit, the already granted provisional
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation to intake batch 2016-17 under
Date of Visit July 01-02, 2021 Level-II is validated.


particularly in Criteria 1, 2, & 8. Furthermore,
o. Program B.E. Material Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
Date of Visit June 21-22, 2021 accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.,


QEC
Intake Batch 2018
iii. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict
iv. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in
FYDPs
xxiv
v. Standardization and proof reading of

visit under OBA.
p. Program B.E. Computer Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Systems against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Current Status Till Intake of Batch and implementation of the Outcome Based
2016-17 Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.,
Date of Visit June 21-22, 2021 Intake Batch 2017 under Level-II, First


QEC
Intake Batch 2018
iii. Ensure fair assessment and avoid conflict
iv. CEPs/CEAs should be inculcated in
FYDPs
v. Standardization and proof reading of

q. Program B.E. Industrial and Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Manufacturing compliance against accreditation criteria/
1999-2000 to 2016-17 visit, the already granted provisional
xxv
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation to intake batch 2016-17 under
Date of Visit July 01-02, 2021 Level-II is validated.


Zone-III (Islamabad, AJK, KPK, GB)

01. Mirpur University of Science and Technology, Mirpur
a. Program B.Sc. Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering against accreditation criteria / quality
Current Status standards and implementation of the Outcome
Visit Type Re-Accreditation Based Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
intake batches 2017 and 2018 under Level-II.
Further, the HEI is advised to submit the

evidences on followings before submission of
next re-accreditation visit request/ SAR:
i. Attainment of PLO at student as well as

cohort levels along-with the assessment
at appropriate taxonomy up-till the
conclusion of Fall-2021 semester.
ii. Effective implementation of CEPs/ PBLs/
OELs up-till the conclusion of Fall-2021
semester.
iii. Addressal of all the observations/
weaknesses & concerns as mentioned in
the detailed report as a part of CQI
process.
The Institution, however, is required to

address all weak areas / concerns, particularly
in Criteria 2, 3, 5, 6 & 8. Furthermore, all other
xxvi
visit under OBA.
b. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory implementation of

Engineering OBA and reasonable attainment of PLOs at
Current Status student and cohort level, the already granted
Visit Type Re-Accreditation provisional accreditation to intake Batch –
Date of Visit July 9-10, 2021 2016 under Level-I is validated and up-graded
to Level-II.

compliance against accreditation criteria /
years i.e., for intake batches 2017 and 2018
under Level-II.

address all weak areas and concerns,
c. Program B.Sc. Computer Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Systems Engineering against accreditation criteria / quality

next reaccreditation visit request / SAR:
i. Appointment of at least one more PhD

engineering qualified faculty member
from core/ relevant engineering
discipline for fulfillment of four (04) PhD
faculty requirement for two (02)
sections.
ii. Attainment of PLO at student as well as
at appropriate taxonomy levels in all
three domains till the conclusion of Fall-
2021 semester.
iii. Effective implementation of CEPs/
PBLs/ OELs till the conclusion of Fall-
2021 semester.
xxvii
iv. Addressal of all the observations/
weaknesses as mentioned in the
detailed report as a part of CQI process.

in Criteria 3 & 8. Furthermore, all other
visit under OBA.
d. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Current Status and implementation of the Outcome Based
Visit Type Re-Accreditation Assessment procedures & CQI, re-

next reaccreditation visit request / SAR:
i. Appointment of at least one more PhD

from core/ relevant engineering
discipline for fulfillment of four (04) PhD
faculty requirement for two (02)
sections.
ii. Attainment of PLO at student as well as
at appropriate taxonomy levels in all
three domains till the conclusion of Fall-
2021 semester.
iii. Effective implementation of CEPs/
PBLs/ OELs till the conclusion of Fall-
2021 semester.
iv. Addressal of all the observations/
weaknesses as mentioned in the
detailed report as a part of CQI process.

e. Program B.Sc. Software Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

xxviii

02. Air University, Islamabad

a. Program Bachelor of Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
Visit Type Re-accreditation Based Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 accreditation is recommended for two (02)
years i.e., intake batches 2017 and 2018
under Level-II subject to hiring of more faculty
from core engineering discipline to bring down
student teacher ratio upto 20:1.
Further, the subsequent re-accreditation visit

request from HEI will only be entertained
subject to submission of satisfactory
compliance report alongwith tangible
evidences on all observations/ deficiencies,
weaknesses and concerns, particularly in
Criteria 2, 3, 4, 7 & 8 as identified in visitation
report.
Moreover, all other observations as mentioned

in the detailed report be addressed as a part
of CQI process before applying for re-
Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Mechanical against accreditation criteria / quality
Engineering standards and implementation of the Outcome
Current Status Based Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 for intake batch 2017 only under Level-II.

b. for intake batch 2018 under Level-II subject to
alongwith tangible evidences on all
observations/ deficiency, weaknesses and
concerns particularly in Criteria 2, 3, 7 & 8 as
identified in visitation report.
Moreover, all other observations as mentioned

in the detailed report be addressed as a part
xxix
of CQI process before applying for re-
c. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Mechatronics against accreditation criteria / quality
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.,
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 for intake batches 2017 and 2018 under Level-
II.
Violation pertaining to admitting more students

than allowed in intake Fall-2020 will be dealt in
accordance with Article-8 of PEC Regulations
of Engineering Education in Pakistan for
imposition of penalty.

address the deficiency and all weak areas and
concerns, particularly in Criteria 3, 7 & 8.
d. Program Bachelor of Computer Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Visit Type Accreditation Based Assessment procedures & CQI,
Date of Visit June 28-29, 2021 accreditation is recommended for one (01)
year i.e. for intake batch 2017 under Level-II
subject to hiring of atleast one (01) more MS
engineering qualified faculty from core
discipline for fulfillment of minimum eight (08)
MFS requirement for one section as per PEC
Accreditation Manual – 2019.

for Intake Batch-2018 under Level-II subject to
along with tangible evidences on all
observations/ weaknesses highlighted in
visitation report in addition of hiring of at least
One more MS Qualified Faculty member as
mentioned above.

address all deficiencies, weak areas and
xxx
03. Hamdard Institute of Engineering and Technology, Islamabad Campus (Hamdard
University, Karachi)
a. Program BE Electrical Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Current Status quality standards during physical accreditation
Date of Visit July 12-13, 2021 accreditation to intake batch 2016 under

under Level-II.

04. National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad - Institute of

Geographical Information Systems, Islamabad
a. Program BE Geoinformatics Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Current Status against accreditation criteria / quality
Visit Type Re-accreditation standards and implementation of the Outcome
Date of Visit July 1-2, 2021 Based Assessment procedures & CQI, re-
accreditation is recommended for two (02)
years i.e. for intake batches 2017 & 2018
under Level-II subject to hiring of atleast one
(01) more MS engineering qualified faculty
from core/ relevant discipline for fulfillment of
minimum eight (08) MFS requirement for one
section as per PEC Accreditation Manual –
2019.

xxxi
05. National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad - Institute of Civil
Engineering, Islamabad
a. Program BE Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance
accreditation is granted for four (04) years i.e.,
for intake batches 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020
under Level-II.

06. National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad - Institute of

Environmental Science and Engineering, Islamabad
a. Program Bachelor of Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Environmental compliance against accreditation criteria/
Engineering quality standards, implementation of the
Current Status Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
Visit Type Re-accreditation CQI during physical accreditation visit, the
Date of Visit July 1-2, 2021 already granted provisional accreditation to
intake batch 2016 under Level-II is validated.

CQI, re-accreditation is recommended for two
(02) years i.e., intake batches 2017 and 2018
under Level-II subject to hiring of atleast two
(02) more MS engineering qualified faculty
from core discipline for fulfillment of minimum
eight (08) MFS requirement for one section as
per PEC Accreditation Manual – 2019.

particularly in Criteria-8. Furthermore, all other
visit under OBA.
07. National University of Sciences and Technology, Islamabad School of Chemical

and Materials Engineering, Islamabad
a. Program BE Chemical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

xxxii
accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.,

b. Program BE Metallurgy & Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Materials against accreditation criteria / quality
i.e., intake batches 2017, 2018 and 2019
under Level-II.

address the deficiency and all weak areas &
08. Institute of Space Technology, Islamabad
a. Program Bachelor of Science Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

(B.S.) in Mechanical against accreditation criteria / quality
Date of Visit July 12-13, 2021 i.e., for intake batches 2017, 2018 and 2019
under Level-II.

b. Program Bachelor of Science Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

(B.S.) in Avionics against accreditation criteria / quality
Date of Visit July 12-13, 2021 i.e., for intake batches 2017, 2018 and 2019
under Level-II.
xxxiii
concerns, particularly in Criteria 3 & 8.
09. National University of Computer and Emerging Sciences, Islamabad (Main

Campus)
a. Program Bachelor of Science Based on verification of satisfactory level of
(B.S.) in Electrical compliance against accreditation criteria/
Engineering quality standards during physical accreditation
Current Status visit, the already granted provisional
Visit Type Re-accreditation accreditation to intake batch 2016 under
Date of Visit July 14-15, 2021 Level-I is validated.

year i.e. for intake batch 2017 under Level-II.
Moreover, re-accreditation is also

Level-II subject to submission of satisfactory
compliance report alongwith evidences on all
observations/ deficiency, weaknesses &
All other observations as mentioned in the

10. Pakistan Institute of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Islamabad

a. Program B.S. in Mechanical Based on verification of satisfactory level of
Current Status quality standards, implementation of the
Visit Type Re-accreditation Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
Date of Visit June 14-15, 2021 CQI during physical accreditation visit, the
already granted provisional accreditation to

years i.e., for intake batches 2017, 2018 and
2019 under Level-II.

xxxiv
particularly in Criteria-8. Furthermore, all other
visit under OBA.
11. The University of Lahore, Lahore (Islamabad Campus)

a. Program B.Sc. Civil Based on verification of satisfactory level of
Date of Visit June 24-25, 2021 accreditation to intake batch 2016 under

under Level-II.

b. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on verification of satisfactory level of


under Level-II.
Since the program has been phased out by the

HEI and there is no further intake after 2018,
therefore, the HEI is advised to maintain the
faculty and other teaching, learning and
assessment standards as per PEC guidelines,
till the graduation of intake batch 2018.

xxxv
c. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on verification of satisfactory level of


years i.e. intake batches 2017 & 2018 under
Level-II.
Since the program has been phased out from

2020 by the HEI and there is no further intake
after 2019, therefore, the HEI is advised to
maintain the faculty and other teaching,
learning and assessment standards as per
PEC guidelines and apply afresh for intake
batch 2019 accordingly.

12. COMSATS University Islamabad (Abbottabad Campus)
a. Program Bachelor of Science in Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Computer compliance against accreditation criteria/
Engineering quality standards, and implementation of the

Moreover, re-accreditation is also

Level-II subject to verification of all
xxxvi
observations/ deficiency, weaknesses &
concerns, particularly in Criteria 1, 2, 3, 5 & 8
through a confirmatory visit.
All other observations as mentioned in the

b. Program Bachelor of Science in Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Electrical (Power) compliance against accreditation criteria/

years i.e. for intake batches 2017, 2018 &

c. Program Bachelor of Science in Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Electrical (Electronics) compliance against accreditation criteria/

years i.e. intake batches 2017, 2018 & 2019
under Level-II.

xxxvii
d. Program Bachelor of Science in Based on major deficiencies & weaknesses in

Civil Engineering most of the criteria (particularly in criteria 1, 2,
Current Status 3, 5, 6, 8 & 9) and partial implementation of
Visit Type Re-accreditation OBE, the current accreditation level of the
Date of Visit July 8-9, 2021 program is downgraded from Level-II to Level-
I, and therefore, the re-accreditation is granted
for one (01) year i.e. for intake batch 2017
under Level-I.
The HEI is advised to hire at least one (01)

more PhD engineering qualified faculty from
core/ relevant disciplines for fulfilment of four
(04) PhD faculty members requirement for two
(02) sections. In case the HEI does not want
to increase the PhD faculty, then a formal
application be submitted to EAB for reduction
of student intake inline with available PhD
faculty members.
Further, next SAR for intake Fall-2018 will only

be considered subject to submission of
tangible evidences on followings:
i. Appointment of at-least one more PhD

from core/ relevant discipline.
ii. Addressal of all observations/
deficiencies, weak areas & concerns,
particularly in criteria 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 8 & 9 as
mentioned in visitation team report.
13. Sarhad University of Science and Information Technology, Peshawar

Date of Visit July 16-17, 2021 accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.
for intake batch 2017 under Level-II.
The HEI is advised to hire more PhD

engineering qualified faculty from core/
relevant discipline for fulfilment of two (02)
PhD faculty per section as per the allowed
intake. In case the HEI does not want to
increase the PhD faculty then a formal
faculty members.
xxxviii
b. Program B.Sc. Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Date of Visit July 16-17, 2021 accreditation is granted for one (01) year i.e.
for intake batch 2017 under Level-II.
The HEI is advised to hire one (01) more PhD

relevant disciplines for fulfilment of six (06)
PhD faculty requirement for three (03)
sections (2 PhDs per section). In case the HEI
does not want to increase the PhD faculty then
a formal application be submitted to EAB for
reduction of student intake in line with
available PhD faculty members.

c. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Date of Visit July 16-17, 2021 accreditation to intake batch 2016 under

The HEI is advised to hire one (01) more PhD

relevant disciplines for fulfilment of four (04)
PhD faculty requirement for two (02) sections
(2 PhDs per section). In case the HEI does not
want to increase the PhD faculty then a formal
xxxix
faculty members.

address deficiency, all weak areas and
14. University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar (Main Campus)

a. Program B.Sc. Chemical Based on verification of satisfactory level of
Current Status quality standards, implementation of the
Visit Type Re-accreditation Outcome Based Assessment procedures &
Date of Visit June 18-19, 2021 CQI during physical accreditation visit, the
already granted provisional accreditation to

under Level-II.

b. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on verification of satisfactory level of


years i.e. for intake batches 2017, 2018 &

xl
c. Program B.Sc. Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Date of Visit June 18-19, 2021 accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.
for intake batches 2017 & 2018 under Level-II.

d. Program B.Sc. Mechatronics Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Date of Visit June 18-19, 2021 accreditation is granted for three (03) years i.e.
for intake batches 2017, 2018 & 2019 under
Level-II.

e. Program B.Sc. Agricultural Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Date of Visit June 18-19, 2021 accreditation is granted for two (02) years i.e.
intake batches 2017 & 2018 under Level-II.

f. Program B.Sc. Mining Based on verification of satisfactory level of

xli
accreditation to intake batch 2016 under

CQI, re-accreditation is recommended for two
(02) years i.e. for intake batches 2017 & 2018
under Level-II subject to hiring of atleast one
(01) more MS Engineering qualified faculty
member from core/ relevant discipline for
fulfilment of minimum eight (08) MFS
requirement as per PEC Accreditation Manual
– 2019.

15. University of Engineering and Technology, Mardan

a. Program B.Sc. Based on the satisfactory implementation of
Telecommunication OBA and reasonable attainment of PLOs at
Engineering student and cohort level, the already granted
Current Status provisional accreditation to intake Batch –
Visit Type Re-accreditation 2016 under Level-I is validated and up-graded
Date of Visit July 16-17, 2021 to Level-II.

under Level-II.
Moreover, the HEI is advised to submit the

tangible evidences on followings before
submission of subsequent re-accreditation
visit request:
i. Addressal of observations related to

underutilization/ restoration of un-
operational equipment in Control Lab.
ii. Formulation of formal policy on industry
applied research and design projects.
iii. Addressal of all observations/ deficiency,
weaknesses & concerns, particularly in
Criteria 2, 8 & 9.
xlii
b. Program B.Sc. Computer Based on the satisfactory implementation of
Software Engineering OBA and reasonable attainment of PLOs at
Current Status student and cohort level, the already granted
Visit Type Re-accreditation provisional accreditation to intake Batch –
Date of Visit July 16-17, 2021 2016 under Level-I is validated and up-graded
to Level-II.

under Level-II.

in Criteria 3, 5 & 8. Furthermore, all other
visit under OBA.
c. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Engineering against accreditation criteria/ quality standards
Current Status and implementation of the Outcome Based
i.e., for intake batches 2017, 2018 and 2019
under Level-II.

tangible evidences on followings before
subsequent re-accreditation visit:
i. Addressal of observations related to

underutilization/ restoration of un-
operational equipment in Control Lab and
Electric Machines Lab.
ii. Addressal of all observations/
weaknesses & concerns, particularly in
Criteria 3, 4 & 8.
****************
xliii

102 EAB All Zones Decision(s)

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

102 EAB All Zones Decision(s)

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Annex-A1

Agenda Item No.07 (a) (1) Consideration of Reports/ Summaries

The Institution; however, is advised to

2. University College of Engineering and Technology, Multan (Bahauddin Zakariya

The Institution; however, is advised to

b. Program B.Sc. Computer Based on verification of satisfactory level of

a) Appointment/ hiring of HoD registered in

b) Appointment/ hiring of one (01) MS/ PhD

c) Evidence regarding conduction of two

d) Evidence regarding assessment of FYDP

Moreover, the HEI is advised to submit

a) Procurement of deficient lab equipment in

b) Adequacy of arrangements should be

c) Evidence regarding completion of course

The Institution; however, is advised to

c. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on partial implementation of OBE and

d. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on partial implementation of OBE and

3. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Lahore Campus) [*Formerly COMSATS

b. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

4. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Wah Campus) [*Formerly COMSATS Institute

Program B.Sc. Civil Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

Further, based on the satisfactory level of

The Institution; however, is advised to

5. COMSATS University, Islamabad (Sahiwal Campus) [*Formerly COMSATS

a. Program B.Sc. Civil Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

b. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

c. Program Bachelor of Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

6. College of Engineering and Emerging Technologies, Lahore (University of the

a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

The Institution; however, is advised to

b. Program B.Sc. Metallurgy Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

The Institution; however, is advised to

7. Dr. A. Q. Khan Institute of Computer Sciences and Information Technology,

8. Government College University, Faisalabad

Moreover; re-accreditation for intake batch

The Institution; however, is advised to

9. Government College University, Lahore

a) Communication Systems (3+1)

Moreover, the HEI is advised to submit

The Institution; however, is advised to

10. HITEC University, Taxila

The Institution; however, is advised to

b. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

The Institution; however, is advised to

c. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

11. Information Technology University, Lahore

The Institution; however, is advised to

12. Institute of Southern Punjab, Lahore

b. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

13. Lahore University of Management Sciences, Lahore

Further, based on the satisfactory level of

The Institution; however, is advised to

14. NFC Institute of Engineering and Technology, Multan

a. Program B.Sc. Electrical Based on the satisfactory level of compliance

b. Program B.Sc. Mechanical Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

c. Program B.Sc. Petroleum & Based on deficiencies and major weaknesses

Zone-II (Sindh & Balochistan)

S# Name of University/Program Profile Decision of 102nd EAB

Further, based on the satisfactory level of

The Institution, however, is required to address

b. Program B.E. Computer System Based on verification of satisfactory level of

Further, based on deficiencies and major

The Institution, however, is required to address

c. Program B.E. Electronics Based on verification of satisfactory level of