Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Khaled Saad, Ahmed A. Abdel-rahman, Yasser M. Elserogy, Abdulrahman
A. Al-Atram, John J. Cannell, Geir Bjørklund, Mohamed K. Abdel-Reheim, Hisham A. K. Othman,
Amira A. El-Houfey, Nafisa H. R. Abd El-Aziz, Khaled A. Abd El-Baseer, Ahmed E. Ahmed &
Ahmed M. Ali (2015): Vitamin D status in autism spectrum disorders and the efficacy of vitamin
D supplementation in autistic children, Nutritional Neuroscience
Article views: 1
Faculty of Nursing, Assiut University, Egypt, 9Department of Pediatrics, Qena Faculty of Medicine, South Valley
University, Egypt
Objectives: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a developmental disorder characterized by pervasive deficits
in social interaction, impairment in verbal and non-verbal communication, and stereotyped patterns of
interests and activities. Vitamin-D deficiency was previously reported in autistic children. However, the
data on the relationship between vitamin D deficiency and the severity of autism are limited.
Methods: We performed a case–controlled cross-sectional analysis conducted on 122 ASD children, to
assess their vitamin D status compared to controls and the relationship between vitamin D deficiency and
the severity of autism. We also conducted an open trial of vitamin D supplementation in ASD children.
Results: Fifty-seven percent of the patients in the present study had vitamin D deficiency, and 30% had
vitamin D insufficiency. The mean 25-OHD levels in patients with severe autism were significantly lower
than those in patients with mild/moderate autism. Serum 25-OHD levels had significant negative
correlations with Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) scores. Of the ASD group, 106 patients with low-
serum 25-OHD levels (<30 ng/ml) participated in the open label trial. They received vitamin D3 (300 IU/
kg/day not to exceed 5000 IU/day) for 3 months. Eighty-three subjects completed 3 months of daily
vitamin D treatment. Collectively, 80.72% (67/83) of subjects who received vitamin D3 treatment had
significantly improved outcome, which was mainly in the sections of the CARS and aberrant behavior
checklist subscales that measure behavior, stereotypy, eye contact, and attention span.
Conclusion: Vitamin D is inexpensive, readily available and safe. It may have beneficial effects in ASD
subjects, especially when the final serum level is more than 40 ng/ml.
Trial registration number: UMIN-CTR Study Design: trial Number: R000016846.
Keywords: Autism, Neurodevelopmental, Children, Vitamin D
accounted for the bulk of ASD risk in twins, with the compared to controls and the relationship between
genetic contribution being only modest.7,8 vitamin D deficiency and the severity of autism. We
During the last decades, the reported incidence and also conducted an open trial of vitamin D supplemen-
prevalence for autism have drastically increased. tation in ASD children.
Todays 14.7 per 1000 (one in 68) children aged
8-year-old in the USA are diagnosed with ASD.9 Materials and methods
There is no agreement as to whether autism preva- The Ethical Committee of Assiut University, Assiut,
lence is truly on the rise or if a higher reported rate Egypt, approved the study. All methods and procedures
in recent years might be secondary to better awareness, used in this study were approved by the Institutional
and more sensitive diagnostic tools.10–13 However, as Review Board at Assiut University, Egypt. Informed
ASD children are so remarkable it is unlikely that consent followed the guidelines set forth by the
doctors, parents, and teachers would have missed a Institutional Review Board at Assiut University and
majority of these patients 30 years ago. Therefore, it included a brief description of study procedures, poten-
is likely that a substantial proportion of the change tial benefits and risks, a discussion of the voluntary
in the prevalence of ASD is real.14 nature of the study, right to withdraw without conse-
Many different well-defined biological disturbances quences, and confidentiality of information. Informed
occur in ASD patients. The problem is that some of the consents were written in Arabic language that was age
most commonly found disturbances, like evidence appropriate for all participants in the study. Prior to
demonstrating enhanced oxidative stress or impaired participation in the study, children were required to
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 01:46 03 February 2016
antioxidant defense, are very non-specific and give their assent and parents were required to give
common in many other diseases as well. Other differ- consent for participation. Finally, participants were
ence epidemiological and clinical found in ASD indi- given a Participant’s Bill of Rights.
viduals are very specific, but not universal since they
are found only in a subgroup of ASD patients.15 Patients
Recently, Patrick and Ames16 used a genetic database The present study included 122 Egyptian children with
to demonstrate how something as simple as vitamin D ASD (aged from 3 to 9 years) participated in this
deficiency explains some of these differences. For case–control, cross-sectional study. All patients were
example, they found vitamin D deficiency explains recruited from the neuropediatric clinics Assiut univer-
six mysteries of ASD: the low concentrations of seroto- sity hospitals and five private centers for autism in
nin in the brain and its elevated concentrations in Assiut city, Upper Egypt. A total of 204 patients
serum; the low concentrations of the vitamin D were screened for eligibility, and 122 were enrolled
hormone precursor 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25-OHD); (20 failed to provide consent and 62 did not meet eli-
the high male prevalence of autism; the presence of gibility criteria and/or one or more of exclusion cri-
maternal antibodies against fetal brain tissue; and teria). ASDs were diagnosed according to DSM-IV-
the abnormalities in ASD of two peptide hormones, TR diagnostic criteria.1 Structured interviews of at
oxytocin and vasopressin.16 least 1 hour each both with the parents and the child
Vitamin D has a unique role in brain homeostasis, were performed, in a room equipped with play
neurodevelopment, immunological modulation, material appropriate for age level. Later on, another
ageing, and also, importantly, in gene regulation. In 2 hours session was conducted for classification of
addition, it has been shown to bind to more than ASD patients by using the Childhood Autism Rating
2700 genes and to regulate the expression of more Scale (CARS).25 CARS is a well-established scale for
than 200 of them. In children (1–18 years), the rec- the screening and classification of childhood autism
ommended daily requirement of vitamin D ranged with good agreement between DSM-IV-TR diagnostic
from 200 to 600 IU per day.5,17,18 Vitamin D criteria and CARS.26 The scale assesses behavior in 14
deficiency has recently been proposed as a potential domains that are affected by severe problems in ASD,
environmental risk factor for ASD.4,18–20 Vitamin-D plus one general category of impressions of ASD, with
deficiency was previously reported in autistic chil- the aim of identifying children with ASD, as differen-
dren.4,21–24 However, the data on the relationship tiated from the other developmental disorders. The
between vitamin D deficiency and the severity of examiner assigned a score of 1–4 for each item: one
autism are limited; also, the previous studies had indicates behavior appropriate for age level, while
several drawbacks, such as absence of controls, small four indicates a severe deviance with respect to the
sample sizes, and some were not conducted on chil- normal behavior for age level. The scores for the
dren.18 We attempted to remedy some of these deficits single items are added together into a total score,
in the present study by using a case–controlled cross- which classifies the child as not autistic (below 30),
sectional analysis conducted on a large patient group mild or moderately autistic (30–36.5) or severely autis-
of ASD children to assess their vitamin D status tic (above 36.5).25,26 One hundred typically developing
apparently healthy Egyptian children of comparable Germany. All subjects were studied during 2 months
age and sex (75% males) were included as a control (May and June) to avoid the seasonal variation of
group; the social status of the control group was com- vitamin D levels. Normal level of vitamin D is
patible with cases. All control cases were recruited defined as a 25-OHD concentration >30 ng/ml,
from outpatient clinics Assiut university hospitals vitamin D insufficiency (20–30 ng/ml), and vitamin
and from healthy siblings of the patients. The dietary D deficiency (<20 ng/ml).28
intake of all subjects was assessed by a questionnaire
conducted by researchers for parents of all cases and Statistical analysis
controls. All subjects were in a good nutritional Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) program
status; children with feeding problems or malnutrition version 11 was used for data analysis. Descriptive stat-
were excluded from the study. Subjects who had istics as minimum, maximum, and mean ± SD and
associated gastrointestinal problems, autoimmune dis- independent sample t-test, correlation, and linear
orders, anemia, neurological diseases (such as cerebral regression. P value of ≤0.05 denoted the presence of
palsy and tuberous sclerosis) and metabolic disorders statistically significant difference.
(e.g. phenylketonuria) as well as any subjects receiving
Results
vitamin D containing preparations and drugs that may
The age, vitamin D levels of the ASD individuals, and
affect vitamin D (e.g. steroid and antiepileptics) were
controls are summarized in Table 1. Only 13%
excluded. All control cases were screened by DSM-
(16/122) of the patients in the present study had
IV-TR diagnostic criteria and CARS, none of them
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 01:46 03 February 2016
Table 1 Age and baseline 25-OHD levels of ASD subjects and controls
Age (years) 5.09 1.42 3.00 9.00 4.88 1.30 3.00 9.00
25-OHD (ng/ml) 18.02* 8.75 5.00 46.00 42.51* 9.48 16.00 59.00
Discussion
Many studies have investigated the plasma levels of
vitamin D directly in individuals with ASD. In agree-
ment of the present study, Mostafa and Al-Ayadhi29
reported that autistic children had significantly lower
serum levels of 25-OHD than healthy children and
25-OHD was inversely associated with severity on
autism rating scales (R = 0.84). In addition, children
with ASD had significantly higher serum levels of
anti-MAG autoantibodies (R = 0.86). Gong et al. 30
reported that mean serum 25-OHD levels were signifi-
cantly lower in autistic children as compared with
normal cases. There was a significant negative
relationship between circulating serum 25-OHD
Figure 1 Correlation autism scores and vitamin D levels. levels and the severity of ASD. Meguid et al. 4 reported
a cohort of autistic children having significantly lower
levels of calcifediol and calcitriol values compared to
with vitamin D treatment were classified into three healthy controls. The season of birth in relation to
groups. The first group consisted of 16 patients with vitamin D and ASD was also taken into account,
Downloaded by [Gazi University] at 01:46 03 February 2016
final serum 25-OHD levels >40 ng/ml; all had but no significant difference was found for the
decreased CARS scores between 3.5 and 6.5 points. month or season of birth in either group. Molloy
The second group consisted of 49 patients with final et al. 23 compared the plasma calcifediol levels in a
serum 25-OHD levels between 30 and 39 ng/ml. cohort of autistic boys (4–8 years old) and a group
Most of them (31/49 patients) had decreased CARS of boys having intravenous catheters placed for outpa-
scores by 1.5–4.5 points, while the rest of this group tient tonsillectomies. There were no differences
(18 patients) had no improvements. Collectively, observed in the levels of vitamin D between ASD
80.72% (67/83) of subjects who received vitamin D3 and controls. The drawbacks of this study were that
treatment (5000 IU/day) had significantly improved the patient group included only males, and the
(P ≤ 0.05) outcome. Table 3 and Fig. 2 showed the control groups were all suffering from acute inflam-
details of CARS scores before and after vitamin D mation, which could affect the levels of plasma
therapy. Regarding ABC subscales before and vitamin D.18 Humble et al. 22 tested vitamin D levels
after vitamin D therapy, there were statistically in adult patients with psychiatric disorders and
significant improvement in irritability (P = 0.021), found that those with a diagnosis of ASD had signifi-
lethargy/social withdrawal (P = 0.028), hyperactivity cantly lower levels of vitamin D than any of the other
(P = 0.01), and stereotypic behavior (P = 0.04), with groups. However, the study did not have a control
no significant difference in inappropriate speech group and examined only adults with a range of dis-
(Table 4). orders, not only ASD.18 Another study examined
Table 3 CARS scores in ASD patients before and after vitamin D therapy
*Significant values.
Figure 2 CARS scores in ASD patients before and after vitamin D therapy.
Table 4 ABC subscales in ASD patients before and after vitamin D therapy
ABC measure Mean ± SD scores before therapy Mean ± SD scores after therapy t P-value
*Significant values.
mothers of Somali origin with children with ASD in potential role in treating diseases with autoimmune
Sweden.21 In this small study, Somali mothers with involvement, such as ASD.17,32,33 Vitamin D might
autistic children had average vitamin D levels of also reduce the severity of autism through an increas-
6.7 ng/ml, about 30% lower than Somali mothers ing seizure threshold, increasing T-regulatory cells,
without autistic children. protecting the mitochondria, and upregulating gluta-
The present study confirms that 25-OHD levels in thione, which scavenges oxidative byproducts and che-
ASD children are lower than controls, that 25-OHD lates heavy metals.17
levels are inversely correlated with autism rating
scales, and, for the first time, that the open label Conclusion
administration of high doses of vitamin D appears to Vitamin D deficiency is a frequent finding among chil-
improve ASD rating scales. We noted a more substan- dren with ASD. Like two other groups, we found the
tial improvement of ASD rating scales in patients severity of the deficiency is significantly inversely
whose final 25-OHD was >40 ng/ml compared to associated with autism rating scales.
subjects with lower levels (P ≤ 0.05). All children Vitamin D is inexpensive, readily available and safe.
with final 25-OHD levels >40 ng/ml had improved It may have beneficial effects in ASD subjects,
CARS scores. especially when the final serum level is more than
Vitamin D has multiple anti-inflammatory effects. 40 ng/ml. Vitamin D insufficiency is common in autis-
It inhibits the synthesis of proinflammatory prosta- tic children. A baseline measurement of 25-OHD level
glandins, which are elevated in ASD. In addition, it should be obtained to determine the dosage that will
inhibits NF-κB, which is involved in aberrant signaling result in a final 25-OHD of at least 40 ng/ml.
in autistic brains.17,31 The antiautoimmune effects of There are an increasing number of studies
vitamin D may explain the reported epidemiological suggesting an important link between low vitamin D
associations between vitamin D status and many auto- and ASD. Randomized controlled trials using ade-
immune disorders. Thus, vitamin D may have a quate doses of vitamin D3 are urgently needed.