1

DAGAR V. HEIRS OF RUBIATO 28. ANTONIO S. DELOS

SANTOS
Assalamu alaykum. 29. ROJEAN F. VENDER
30. APOLINARIO A.
Good morning your honor. MONSERATE

I am Atty. Bai Pangandongan G.

Dilangalen of the FLD Law office, --------
Roll # 83952, Cotabato Chapter, Permission to speak , your Honor

RESpectfully entering my Point of clarification. I would like to

appearance as counsel for clarify to the plaintiff’s counsel the
defendant- Heirs of Rabiato purpose of presenting the
(NAMELY: municipal Assessor ______.
DOLORES RABIATO
JANILO R The notice I have received for
JAROLYN R-OCAMPO today’s hearing is a pretrial.
EDSEL R-BIBAY
HAMILCAR R If the assessor is being presented
(AS REPRESENTED BY ROSELLA as a witness, it is still premature at
DIMACUTAC) this stage.

For the defendant Josephine Baluya the purpose of the pre-trial is

ET AL, limited to what is enumerated
under the law and the presentation
NAMELY: of a witness is not among those
1. HEIRS OF EDILBERTO included.
BALUYA
2. CLAUDIA BARNIDO IF MENTIONED, ASSESSED
3. HEIRS OF PABLO BASADRE VALUE IN DET. DOCKET FEES---
4. ESTERLITA M. BARBANTE
5. MARIETTA R. BOGLOSA OBJECTION , YOUR HONOR.
6. PACITA B. CASTRO
7. CHERRY D. CRUZ UNDER A.M. NO. 35-2004, FOR
8. JACKYLOU B. DE DIOS FILING FEES, THE BASIS FOR
9. ANASTACIO T. FABRO COMPUTING IT IS THE FMV OF
10. CATHERINE POSADA- THE REAL PROPERTY IN
BISNAR LITIGATION STATED IN THE
11. ENCARNACION C. CURRENT TAX DECLARATION OR
VICENTE THE CURRENT ZONAL
12. JOSEPHINE D. BALUYA VALUATION OF THE BIR,
13. RODOLFO B. BOSQUE WHICHEVER IS HIGHER.
14. DOREEN JARABELO
15. ELIZABETH IF TCT 39241 IS MENTIONED, IT
MAGSALANG SHOULD BE THE TAX
16. MICHAEL A. RIVERA DECLARATION OF THE ENTIRE
17. PERCIVAL ORACION TITLE.
18. CERILA MUÑOZ
19. REYNALDO D. FUENTES ----IF NAG-OKAY PADIN SI
20. FLAVIO PARREÑO, JR. JUDGE: YOUR HONER, MAY WE BE
21. ROSITA L. BORLAZA ALLOWED TO REGISTER OUR
22. SEGUNDINA B. DENOY CONTINUING OBJECTION TO THE
23. JANJIE M. PALACIO RULING OF THIS COURT.
24. DELIA D. LIBOON
25. ELIZABTEH B. THANK YOU.
BASADRE
26. CERILA CUAJOTOR ADD’L PROPOSED ISSUE:
27. EDGAR D. ROJAS
RABIATO
2

SHALL BE HEARD OR ADMITTED BY

THE DEFENDANT – HEIRS OF THE COURT.
RUBIATO VALIDLY AND LEGALLY
ACQUIRED THRU A VALID SALE (CHECK IF THE DOCUMENTS OF
THEIR RESPECTIVE PROPERTIES THE OTHER COUNSEL ARE
SUBJECT MATTER OF THIS CASE. ORIGINAL)

JOSEPHINE BALUYA et al, WITNESSES: YOUR HONOR WE

WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT THE
3. THE DEFENDANT – HEIRS OF FOLLOWING WITNESSES.
RUBIATO VALIDLY AND LEGALLY
ACQUIRED THRU A VALID SALE FOR THE DEFENDANT
THEIR RESPECTIVE PROPERTIES HEIRS OF RABIATO, WE
SUBJECT MATTER OF THIS SUIT. WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT AS
WITNESS:
STIPULATIONS: WE WOULD LIKE
TO STIULATE THAT: DOLORES RABIATO

Baluya : FOR THE DEFENDANT

BALUYA et al, WE WOULD
4. xxx. Mr. Ibrahim’s LEGAL AND LIKE TO PRESENT THE
FACTUAL BASIS XXX FOLLOWING WITNESSES:

Rabiato: 1. ESTERLITA M. BARBANTE

JUST READ THE PTB 2. MARIETTA R. BOGLOSA
3. PACITA B. CASTRO
4. CHERRY D. CRUZ
MARKINGS: FOR THE 5. JACKYLOU B. DE DIOS
DEFENDANTS HEIRS OF RABIATO 6. ANASTACIO T. FABRO
AND BALUYA ET. AL,CONSIDERING 7. CATHERINE POSADA-BISNAR
THE VOLUMINOUS DOCUMENTS 8. ENCARNACION C. VICENTE
AND EXHIBITS THAT WE HAVE, SO 9. JOSEPHINE D. BALUYA
AS NOT TO UNDULY DEPRIVE THE 10. RODOLFO B. BOSQUE
OTHER LITIGANTS’ HEARINGS, 11. DOREEN JARABELO
MAY WE BE ALLOWED 12. ELIZABETH
MAGSALANG
YOUR HONOR WE WOULD LIKE TO 13. MICHAEL A. RIVERA
RESERVE THE PRESENTATION OF 14. PERCIVAL ORACION
ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE DURING 15. CERILA MUÑOZ
THE COURSE OF THE 16. REYNALDO D. FUENTES
PROCEEDINGS 17. FLAVIO PARREÑO, JR.
18. ROSITA L. BORLAZA
IF DEAN PAHM MARKS A 19. SEGUNDINA B. DENOY
JUDAFF— 20. JANJIE M. PALACIO
21. DELIA D. LIBOON
OBJECTION HONOR. 22. ELIZABTEH B.
BASADRE
UNDER THE RULES OF COURT, 23. CERILA CUAJOTOR
ONLY WITNESSES WHOSE 24. EDGAR D. ROJAS
JUDICIAL AFFIDAVITS ARE 25. ANTONIO S. DELOS
ATTACHED TO THE PLEADING SANTOS
SHALL BE PRESENTED BY THE 26. ROJEAN F. VENDER
PARTIES DURING THE TRIAL. 27. APOLINARIO A.
MONSERATE
EXCEPT IF A PARTY PRESENTS
MERITORIOUS REASONS AS BASIS
FOR THE ADMISSION OF WE WOULD LIKE TO RESERVE THE
ADDITIONAL WINESSES, NO PRESENTATION OF MA. JEANNIE L.
OTHER WITNESS OR AFFIDAVIT OCTAVIO AS THE DEFENDANT’S
3

ADDITIONAL WITNESS TO TESTIFY

ON THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF HER
FATHER’S PURCHASE OF LOT 53-
M.

TRIAL DATES:

FOR THE DEFENDANT HEIRS OF

RABIATO, WE WOULD LIKE TO
ASK FOR JUST ONE TRIAL DATE

FOR THE DEFENDANT BALUYA ET

AL, MAY WE BE ALLOWED TO
PRESENT 2-WITNESSES A DAY. SO
THAT WOULD BE 14-TRIAL DATES.