You are on page 1of 3

ANG DAPAT MABATID NG MGA External criticism:

TAGALOG (reviewer)
1. Author: Andres Bonifacio
Content: 2. Originally written in Spanish
language
1. The Philippines was rich in 3. Translated in Tagalog by Jose P.
resources before the Spaniards Santos
came. 4. Published under the Nom de plume
2. The Philippines is economically Agapito Bagumbayan
associated with neighboring 5. Online source: Kasaysayan-KKK
countries like Japan. 6. The text is written in old Tagalog
3. Filipinos know how to read and write language (uses of letter ‘Y’ instead
in Tagalogs’ way (before the of ‘I’).
Spanish colonization).
4. Spaniards came with a promise to
bring the Philippines to be a better Internal Criticism:
state.
5. The promise or treaty between the 1. Translated article was published by
two nations were sealed by Jose P. Santos in 1930s
extracting blood and drinking it, it 2. Jose P. Santos is a historian and a
was a tradition of the Tagalogs son of historian (Epifanio de los
before to avoid fake relations with Santos) who happened to be
the others, it is called sandugo. obsessed with collecting documents
6. The sandugo happened between of the Philippine revolution.
Haring Sikatuna and Legaspi (the 3. Jose P. Santos translation is widely
king of the Spain before). use in the nation and is, therefore,
7. The treaty did not happen as good credible.
as the promise was. 4. Who were the recipients?
8. Filipinos were subjected to protect • The Tagalogs during the Spanish
the Spaniards during wars (Filipino until the present time
soldiers were sent to Spain). • Students, historians, and
9. The Filipinos were certainly abused researchers (for study purposes)
and maltreated, the culture and
personality of them before vanished
and was replaced by the teachings CONSEQUENCES
of the Spaniards.
10. The article calls for an action to rebel 1. Filipinos learn how to speak up to
against the Spaniards. fight for their country.
11. Andres Bonifacio aims to open the 2. Filipinos experienced the
eyes of the Tagalogs and (indirectly) freedom/independence of the
join the Katipunan for a fight towards Philippines.
independence. 3. Filipinos experience unity to fight for
the justice of the Philippines.
4. Filipinos opened their eyes to know • The wars and piratical attacks
the people who they need to trust. reduced the inhabitants of the
Philippines.
• These piratical attacks also led
to abandonment of the
THE INDOLENCE OF THE FILIPINOS
cultivators to their fields.
3. Abandonment of industry,
• Rizal admitted that indolence exists agriculture, and commerce
among the Filipinos. 4. Stolen liberty
• Indolence is not a cause of trouble - the Filipinos were deprived
and backwardness, but it is an effect by the Spaniards to
of backwardness and trouble. commerce with other nations,
• Indolence is not a hereditary trait changing the economy
amongst Filipinos, but it is a result of system of the state.
Spaniards’ teachings that were - Filipinos are not allowed to
instilled to the minds of the Filipinos. go to their farms without the
• wars, abandonment of industry, permission of higher authority
agriculture, and commerce added up 5. Encouragement and Propagation
to why Philippines’ population was of Gambling (Taught by the
reduced to one-third in less than 30 Spaniards)
years. - Filipinos were taught
gambling as the best means
• Two classes of cause for indolence:
of securing a livelihood.
defects of training and lack of
- Cock fights were one of the
national sentiment.
most notorious way of
gambling.
The following are the reasons why Filipinos 6. Forced Labor in Shipbuilding
are indolent according to Rizal: - Due to existence of war and
to protect the Spain from the
enemies, Filipinos were
1. Tropical climate forced to build a ship that will
• A hot climate that is experienced in be used in fighting on a war.
the Philippines is more likely to 7. Too Much Government Restriction
suggest rest and quietness, whereas and Red Tape in the Approval of
cold climate requires labor and Permit to Transact Business
action. 8. Collection of excessive
• An hour of work under the burning taxes/tribute
sun is equal to a day of work in a 9. Ownership of the Big Estates by
cold climate; individuals in cold the Friars
countries spend their summers on a 10. The Teaching of the Spanish
vacation. Missionaries that Heaven is for
• While the rich and the friars are not the Poor | Heavy reliance in
subjected to indolence, the poor miracles and prayers.
clerk and/or native coadjutor is to be 11. Less appreciation to local
blamed for indolence despite longer products; great consumption of
working hours. imported items
• Indolence in the Philippines is 12. Deprivation of Human Dignity
fostered and magnified.

2. Wars
EXTERNAL CRITICISM • Provided incentives for workers.

• A motivation to become more


1. Author: Jose P. Rizal (written in (destroying social standards)
essay form; his longest essay)
2. Language: Spanish translated in
english by Charles E. Darbyshire
3. Published in: La Solidaridad in
Madrid on July 15 to September 15,
1890
4. Publisher: Vasco Caini
5. Source: Project Gutenberg (an
online library of free electoral books
or ebooks; founder: Michael Hart)
6. The essay was translated into deep
English language.

INTERNAL CRITICISM

1. The source was published in 2004.


2. Charles Derbyshire is historian and
political activist.
3. Charles Derbyshire is also known for
his translation of Noli Me Tangere
(The Social Cancer), El
Filibusterismo, and Mi Ultimo Adios

CONSEQUENCES

• An eye-opener to not tolerate a


dictatorship government again;
independence could be an
indicator of a quality life.

• Have a clearer standard of an


effective leader (A leader should
secure the welfare of their
constituents)

• Heavy reliance on religion was


lessened.

• Acknowledged and appreciated


local products/services
(especially, the agricultural
sector)

You might also like