Table 3.

5 Comparison with practical analysis

1. Bending Moment
Ly/Lx = 1.0 in % Ly/Lx = 1.5 in % Ly/Lx = 2.0 in %
Boundary Coeff. EBCS-2 Comp Coeff. EBCS-2 Comp Coeff. EBCS-2 Comp

Conditions Method 1995 arison Method 1995 arison Method 1995 arison

αxs 0.034 0.032 5.88 0.056 0.053 5.36 0.069 0.063 8.7

1
αys 0.034 0.032 5.88 0.036 0.032 11 0.038 0.032 15.8
αxf 0.026 0.024 7.69 0.044 0.04 9.09 0.053 0.048 9.43
αyf 0.026 0.024 7.69 0.028 0.024 14 0.029 0.024 17.2
αxs 0.042 0.039 7.14 0.078 0.073 6.41 0.096 0.089 7.29
αys 0.042 0.039 7.14 0.047 0.039 17 0.048 0.039 18.8
3
αxf 0.032 0.03 6.25 0.061 0.055 9.84 0.07 0.067 4.29
αyf 0.032 0.03 6.25 0.036 0.03 17 0.037 0.03 18.9
αxs 0.05 0.047 6 0.086 0.078 9.3 0.1 0.093 7
4 αys 0.05 0.047 6 0.057 0.047 18 0.056 0.047 16.1
αxf 0.037 0.036 2.7 0.066 0.059 11 0.076 0.07 7.89
αyf 0.037 0.036 2.7 0.043 0.036 16 0.044 0.036 18.2
αxs - - - - - - - - -
8 αys 0.06 0.058 3.33 0.066 0.058 12 0.07 0.058 17.1
αxf 0.047 0.044 6.38 0.089 0.084 5.62 0.112 0.105 6.25
αyf 0.047 0.044 6.38 0.051 0.044 14 0.052 0.044 15.4
αxs - - - - - - - - -
9 αys - - - - - - - - -
αxf 0.058 0.056 3.45 0.094 0.092 2.13 0.116 0.111 4.31
αyf 0.058 0.056 3.45 0.062 0.056 9.68 0.061 0.056 8.2
 2. Shear Force
Ly/Lx = 1.0 in % Ly/Lx = 1.5 in % Ly/Lx = 2.0 in %
Boundary Coeff. EBCS-2 Comp Coeff. EBCS-2 Comp Coeff. EBCS-2 Comp

Conditions Method 1995 arison Method 1995 arison Method 1995 arison

βx,Con 0.333 0.33 0.9 0.471 0.45 4.46 0.534 0.5 6.37
βx,Disc - - - - - - - - -
1
βy,Con 0.331 0.33 0.3 0.35 0.33 5.71 0.359 0.33 8.08
βy,Disc - - - - - - - - -
βx,Con 0.378 0.36 4.76 0.544 0.51 6.25 0.643 0.59 8.24

3
βx,Disc 0.251 0.24 4.38 0.342 0.34 0.58 0.369 0.38 -3
βy,Con 0.362 0.36 0.55 0.379 0.36 5 0.392 0.36 8.16
βy,Disc - - - - - - - - -
βx,Con 0.382 0.4 -4.7 0.571 0.54 5.43 0.657 0.6 8.68
4
βx,Disc 0.272 0.26 4.41 0.348 0.35 -0.6 0.386 0.4 -3.63
βy,Con 0.397 0.4 -0.8 0.427 0.4 6.32 0.43 0.4 6.98
βy,Disc 0.274 0.26 5.11 0.286 0.26 9.09 0.291 0.26 10.7
βx,Con - - - - - - - - -

8 βx,Disc 0.312 0.3 3.85 0.423 0.42 0.71 0.494 0.48 2.83
βy,Con 0.453 0.45 0.66 0.488 0.45 7.79 0.491 0.45 8.35
βy,Disc 0.306 0.3 2 0.332 0.3 9.64 0.334 0.3 10.2
βx,Con - - - - - - - - -
9 βx,Disc 0.332 0.33 0.6 0.461 0.45 2.39 0.521 0.5 4.03
βy,Con - - - - - - - - -
βy,Disc 0.336 0.33 1.79 0.365 0.33 9.59 0.367 0.33 10.1