Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Each year, an estimated 76 million cases of foodborne illness monella species and STEC, including the emergence of anti-
occur, resulting in 325,000 hospitalizations and 5000 deaths biotic-resistant strains of Campylobacter and Salmonella species;
[1]. The annual cost associated with infection due to the 4 most and (4) the future and improved safety of the food supply.
common bacterial enteropathogens acquired from contami-
nated food is ∼$7 billion [2]. The collateral damage adds im- CHANGING PATTERN OF FOOD CONSUMPTION
portantly to the cost, with lost productivity and litigation sec- The general public became increasingly interested in consuming
ondary to resultant illnesses. Three of the 4 common fresh fruits and vegetables after the release of health claims
enteropathogens (Campylobacter and nontyphoid Salmonella regarding the practice. Healthy People 2010 is a US government
species and Shiga toxin–producing Escherichia coli [STEC]) program aimed at increasing the amount of fruits and vege-
have an animal reservoir, can be associated with fatal compli- tables in the diet, with the objective of increasing the percentage
cations, and are presently threatening our food supply. of persons aged ⭓2 years who eat at least 2 daily servings of
The following topics are covered in this review: (1) the chang- fruit and at least 3 daily servings of vegetables to 75% and 50%,
ing pattern of food consumption; (2) surveillance of foodborne respectively [3]. The last survey obtained (in 2005) by the Be-
infectious diseases and disease-control methods; (3) emerging havioral Risk Factor Surveillance System found rates of 33%
public health threats associated with Campylobacter and Sal- and 27%, respectively [3]. During the 1950s, grocery stores in
the United States stocked an average of 300 food items, whereas
Received 29 May 2007; accepted 17 July 2007; electronically published 4 October 2007. this number grew 180-fold in the 1990s, to 25,000–50,000 dif-
Presented in part: 15th Annual James H. Steele DVM Lecture at the University of Texas– ferent food items [4]. Increased availability of fresh foods in-
Houston School of Public Health, Houston, Texas, 4 April 2007.
Reprints or correspondence: Dr. H. L. DuPont, 6720 Bertner Ave., MC 1-164, Houston, TX
creases the risk of human illness associated with foodborne
77030 (Herbert.L.Dupont@uth.tmc.edu). pathogens [5]. More and more people are eating at commercial
Clinical Infectious Diseases 2007; 45:1353–61 food service establishments [6]. The risk of foodborne illness
2007 by the Infectious Diseases Society of America. All rights reserved.
1058-4838/2007/4510-0018$15.00
is greater when food is eaten in public restaurants rather than
DOI: 10.1086/522662 in homes [7, 8].
Table 1. Estimates of annual disease burden for selected foodborne bacterial enteropathogens of animal origin.
NOTE. HUS, hemolytic uremic syndrome; STEC, Shiga toxin–producing Escherichia coli.
the strain is resistant during the month before illness and con- in chickens dramatically increased thereafter [69]. The removal
sumption of uncooked ground beef, runny scrambled eggs, or of fluoroquinolones from use in animal populations in the
omelets prepared in the home during the 5 days before the European Union [70] and the United States [71] was a major
onset of illness [41]. Bovine sources appear to be particularly public health accomplishment. Additional efforts are needed
important for acquisition of multidrug-resistant S. Newport to reduce fluoroquinolone use by humans in our fight to slow
infection [42]. the emergence of antibacterial resistance among Salmonella spe-
Outbreaks of gastroenteritis due to S. enterica Heidelberg, cies [31] and Campylobacter species [22, 26].
the third or fourth most commonly identified Salmonella se- A national registry study in Denmark demonstrated that pa-
rotype in the United States, are characteristically related to tients with fluoroquinolone-resistant Campylobacter infection
consumption of poultry or eggs [43, 44]. In one study of spo- had a 6-fold (95% CI, 1.62–23.47-fold) increased risk of in-
radic illness, egg consumption outside the home was found to vasive disease or death ⭐30 days after obtainment of a stool
be particularly important [45]. sample for culture, compared with patients whose illness was
due to fluoroquinolone-susceptible strains [72]. Compared
ANTIBACTERIAL RESISTANCE OF with drug-susceptible strains, multidrug-resistant Salmonella
CAMPYLOBACTER AND SALMONELLA strains were shown to have greater virulence [73], resulting in
SPECIES more-severe infection and higher rates of hospitalization [74]
Antibiotic use in agriculture exceeds that in human populations and mortality [75]. In a FoodNet study, bloodstream Salmonella
[60–62] and is credited for producing resistance among enteric infection occurred more frequently among patients who were
bacterial pathogens, causing illnesses in humans that are dif- infected with an isolate that was resistant to at least 1 anti-
ficult to treat [22, 62–64], including campylobacteriosis [23] bacterial drug (adjusted OR, 1.6; 95% CI, 1.2–2.1), compared
and salmonellosis [65]. The growth-promoting effects of an- with patients who were infected with drug-susceptible strains
tibiotics in food animals should be better quantified, with em- [76].
phasis on nonantimicrobial drugs that have equivalent benefits
STEC, INCLUDING E. COLI O157:H7
for the food production industry [66]. Abolishment of the use
of antibiotics for growth promotion will lead to reductions in In a study of 5 FoodNet sites, the following risk factors of
the rate of drug resistance among bacterial enteropathogens sporadic STEC infection were identified: eating at a table-ser-
[67] while increasing meat costs by only fractions of a cent per vice restaurant (matched OR, 1.7; 95% CI, 1.0–2.9), eating a
pound [60], making it cost-effective, considering both animal pink (i.e., undercooked) hamburger at home (matched OR,
production and human health goals [68]. 5.0; 95% CI, 1.7–15) and away from home (matched OR, 5.0;
The fluoroquinolones sarafloxacin and enrofloxacin were 95% CI, 1.3–20), using immunosuppressive medications
first licensed for use in animals in 1995 and 1996, respectively; (matched OR, 11; 95% CI, 1.6–72), and living on or visiting
the presence of fluoroquinolone-resistant Campylobacter strains a farm for persons aged ⭓6 years (matched OR, 10; 95% CI,
1.8–53) or !6 years (matched OR, 5.2; 95% CI, 1.3–22) [77]. [85], whereas a second study found that the organisms survived
Other studies have revealed a variety of risk factors for or on the farm for 8–12 months [86, 87]. In a third study, when
epidemics of STEC infection, including visiting a diary farm bovine or poultry manure compost was exposed to irrigation
[78] or a petting zoo [79, 80]. water contaminated with a pathogenic strain of E. coli O157:
There are 3 general modes of transmission of STEC infection H7 under natural growing conditions, STEC persisted in the
in human populations: foodborne transmission, environmental soil for 154–217 days and was detected on lettuce and parsley
transmission from contaminated animals or water, or trans- for up to 77–177 days [88]. Recovery of viable STEC from the
mission through person-to-person contact. In a US study that inner tissues of lettuce may occur when plants are grown in
examined 18000 cases of STEC illness that occurred during contaminated manure, providing evidence that STEC bacteria
1982–2002 as part of 350 outbreaks occurring in 49 states, is capable of entering the lettuce plant through the root system
foodborne transmission occurred in 183 cases (52%), person- with migration to the edible portion of the plant [89]. In a
to-person transmission occurred in 50 cases (14%), waterborne related study, the association of lettuce seedlings with STEC in
transmission occurred in 31 cases (9%), transmission associated soil was studied using experimentally contaminated irrigation
with animal contact occurred in 11 cases (3%), and transmis- water in a hydroponic model and a soil model [90]. The path-
sion associated with laboratory acquisition occurred in 1 case ogen was found to adhere preferentially to the plant root in
(0.3%); the transmission route was uncertain in 74 cases (21%) both model systems and to seed coats in the hydroponic system.
[81]. In the reported outbreaks of foodborne infection, 75 out- The studies support the idea that preharvest crop contami-
breaks (41%) were associated with ground beef, and 38 (21%) nation with STEC strains can occur via irrigation water through
were associated with contaminated produce [81]. the plant roots, which makes control measures designed to
Multiple-state outbreaks of STEC infection occurred in the prevent STEC contamination of produce particularly
United States in 2005 and in 2006 in association with spinach challenging.
and lettuce purchased at retail outlets or at popular restaurant Although most diagnostic laboratories in the United States
chains in the United States [82, 83]. These outbreaks have put routinely test for Salmonella and Campylobacter species when
great pressure on the growers, processors, distributors, retailers, stool samples obtained from patients with diarrhea are sub-
consumers, and the government [84]. Most studies of produce mitted for bacteriologic culture, not all routinely test for E. coli
contamination with STEC have focused on store-bought let- O157:H7 strains [91]. Studies of non-O157 STEC strains that
tuce. Little is know about the attachment of STEC to growing allow determination of their incidence and disease-producing
plants in the field, although this appears to be the central prob- capacity are lacking. Increased clinical suspicion and devel-
lem in outbreak illness. One study found that fully virulent opment of improved methods of laboratory detection and iso-
strains of STEC persisted in farm environments for 8 weeks lation are needed for this group of organisms [92].