Professional Documents
Culture Documents
trust-based conceptual approach to e- FROM RETAILING TO VALUE- To create genuine added value in a
commerce. ADDED RETAILING distribution channel, technology is
only a necessary condition: ‘Technol-
The Internet is a new distribution ogy is not the object, but merely the
channel generally available to every enabler that facilitates the delivery of
enterprise for offering its goods and value to the end users.’ (Hagel et al.
services. Companies who wish to uti- 1996: 67). The potential of a technol-
lize this distribution channel have to ogy must be developed and exploited
develop an adequate strategy, find a by a company’s particular strategy.
suitable corporate project manage- Applying the technology to meet the
ment, and define an effective imple- specific expectations and demands of
mentation process. Existing offers in target customer groups can generate
A u t h o r s e-commerce are particularly character- real added value for innovative distri-
Ben Birkhofer ized by a high degree of substitutabil- bution systems. The acquisitional ef-
(ben.birkhofer@unisg.ch) is a doctoral ity of the products and services fect of the added value offered in e-
student and research assistant at the offered. Under such market condi- commerce must always be judged
Institute for Marketing and Retailing at tions, companies urgently need to against the background of the benefit
St Gallen University. His research develop strategies to differentiate expected by the customer, the spec-
focuses on business models and themselves. Here, the inherent lack of trum of services offered by the com-
marketing strategies in e-commerce.
Volume 10 (3): 169–175. www.electronicmarkets.org
offering new services, from which characteristics as goal objects that may after comparing the offered total cus-
both the end customer and the sup- or may not supply the benefits desired tomer value and the total customer
pliers benefit, that go beyond the (Assael 1995: 86). The specific bene- costs, on the basis of the expected
generic elements of traditional retail fits sought by the customer thus form customer delivered value (Kotler and
trade (e.g. stationary outlets, shop- the basis for successful marketing and Bliemel 1999: 51).2 ‘Total customer
ping convenience, product range the starting point for deriving pro- value is the bundle of benefits custo-
etc.). For the customer, these services ducts, concepts and strategies that are mers expect from a given product or
THEORETICAL FOUNDATIONS
the link to added value and thus is the nies that concentrate on the tech- further develop its products. In this
starting point in the interactive loop. nological possibilities with e- regard, it should be emphasized that
As a consequence of the confidence- commerce and focus their strategies mutually exclusive alternatives are not
building effect of increased added on perfecting transaction processing involved, but rather two different
value, the frequency of the transac- and offering specific added value starting points in one and the same
tions will also increase. This in turn (cf. Quelch and Klein 1996). Here, basic interactive loop (Figure 2).
leads to optimized customer data, the benefit lies in innovative value- Which value added strategy is ap-
which then leads to renewed adapta- added services that differentiate propriate for which company can only
tion of the product and service offer- what is increasingly becoming a be assessed in regard to the compa-
ings and additional added value for commodity in e-commerce, namely, ny’s specific situation. One might
the customer (Figure 2). the basic value of transaction pro- assume that companies with a real-
In the ideal case, this interactive cessing. world presence (brick-and-mortar) al-
171 loop develops and leads to a situation · On the other hand, companies exist ways tend to start with a trust-based
strategy and new businesses without a opened its Internet mall under the tive services (value-added services).
real-world presence (dot coms) only new label ‘Shopping 24’. In coopera- These then basically differentiate the
have the option to start with a trans- tion with currently 22 partners they supplier’s services from the competi-
action-based strategy. These conclu- do not only offer a much broader tion beyond generic transaction pro-
sions are shortfalling and overlook selection of goods but also innovative cessing and supply customers with
important issues and corporate op- services that improve the transaction added value, which in turn ties them
tions in making this decision. It is processing and add value for the cus- to the supplier. For example, Amazon
obvious that a start-up company with- tomer. Figure 3 gives an overview of started with that approach by challen-
out a real world presence is more the essential strategic approaches to e- ging traditional book retailing with
likely to start with a transaction-based commerce based on the preceding the clear advantage of buying through
strategy. But this is much more in discussion of the interactive loop. In the Internet. Here, the customer re-
favour of the advantage to built-up the long run both strategies aim to ceives added value during the course
processes and systems with state of simultaneously reach a high level of of ongoing interactions, while at the
the art technologies and partners than transactions and a trustful relationship same time the offer can be increas-
in fear of a inherent lack of trust in with customers. ingly tailored to suit him or her
the initial phase. These investments (customization). The most important
are prerequisites to offer products and task of the supplier is to continue
services valued by the customer and Transaction-Based Strategy generating new added value for the
Downloaded By: [German National Licence 2007] At: 15:06 11 March 2010
tribution infrastructure and secure a Trust-Based Strategy and retailers often seek to form a
flawless and efficient order picking partnership with other companies to
and delivery is supplied by the Swiss The trust-based strategy is built on an build a joint innovative distribution
Post. Le-Shop acts as a ‘bottleneck’ established buyer–seller relationship system.
(see Schögel et al. 1999a) between from traditional channels (market- The leading Swiss supplier in retail
manufacturers and customers and fo- place) or the assets of a trusted brand trade, Migros, is pursuing a trust-
cuses on customer and supplier rela- name. Companies try to offer added based strategy in developing its home
tionship management. value to their customers through a delivery business for its already exist-
This start up could be described as process that follows the pattern ‘from ing lines of grocery products (Migros
a typical ‘infomediary’ because its pri- trust to transaction’. The general idea Online). In its offerings, the supplier
mary characteristic in formulating its is to minimize the perceived risk of largely refrains from offering innova-
e-commerce offerings is geared to- customers concerning online shop- tive services, but rather borrows heav-
wards delivering custom-built value ping. Customer trust can be based, ily from the ‘look and feel’ of the
based on customer data (Hagel and for example, on a long-term custo- stationary outlet. This is expressed in
Singer 1999). The value added de- mer–supplier relationship, a compa- a product range that is comparable to
rives from a wide range of technol- ny’s positive public image, or a that of the stationary outlets. The
ogy-based value-added services (e.g. personal attitude towards an estab- corporation’s policy to offer as much
Shopping Assistant ‘Max’). Max lished brand. However, once ex- private labelled goods as possible is
guides the customer through the pressed, customer trust is a volatile consequently transferred to the Inter-
shopping process and provides useful matter. Should a customer be disap- net. This clearly shows an effort to
tools like sorting abilities, shopping pointed, such trust can easily change utilize the trust, built up over the
lists, special offers and the customer’s into mistrust (Bleicher 1995: 214). years in the supplier –customer rela-
shopping history. These services not In the trust-based approach, the tionship in traditional retail trade, for
only make shopping more convenient particular challenge is to exploit and the new distribution channel.
but also deliver a distinctive added safeguard the added value of a brand Contrary to Le Shop’s approach
value that could not be offered eco- that has been built up through the Migros Online started with a wide
Electronic Markets Vol. 10 No 3
nomically without the new web-tech- classical media in the different envir- and deep selection of products and
nologies. This service is meant to onment of the Internet. In contrast to services very similar to its stationary
improve the customer retention rate. the transaction-based approach, an supermarket range. They follow a
The key success factor for the com- existing supplier–customer relation- regional expansion strategy. They
pany, along with the constantly in- ship from the market place is used to started their home delivery service in
creasing depth and breadth of the offer added value. In this connection, selected, densely populated urban
product assortment can be seen in the the supplier focuses on transferring a areas (e.g. Zürich, Bern) and are now
development of professional custo- product already introduced to and gradually increasing their market cov-
mer-relationship management. accepted by the customer (for exam- erage. Order picking is done from a
In summary, the key future success ple, a brand) in a kind of image central company-owned warehouse in
factor of the transaction-oriented ap- transfer into the innovative distribu- Bern. Transport is organized with the
proach can be seen in the building tion system. Here, the benefits that existing fleet of refrigerator trucks and
173 and establishing of a brand. Brands customers already know from this two logistical partners (Swiss Post and
City Trans). In addition to the home Table 1. Characteristics, challenges and key success factors of alternative
delivery of goods, Migros offers a strategies in online retailing
delivery to selected pick-up locations
within its stationary outlets. Transaction-based strategy Trust-based strategy
A competitive advantage is the op- · efficient processes, operational · strong brand, brand portfolio
portunity to exploit the already estab- excellence · customer knowledge from the past
lished database (e.g. by starting a club · specialized partners, strategic · strong emotional bond with customers
concept called ‘Cumulus Card’ three networks · core competence brand management
years ago). In the online shop Cumu- · transaction intensity, critical mass and customer-relationship
lus Card-members are offered a dis- · core competence in supply-chain management
count of 2% in vouchers as reward for management and technology · reduction of perceived risk as a core
their anonymized customer data (Sie- management added value for the customer
ber 1999: 18). This discount rate is · broad selection of added values for · extension of added values that are
twice as high as in the traditional customers complementary to the existing core
outlets. The other big advantage is to · long term goal: build and establish a brand and values
involve the existing stationary outlets strong brand
in establishing the link between mar-
ketplace and marketspace. The men-
Downloaded By: [German National Licence 2007] At: 15:06 11 March 2010
tioned pick-up points are located in gic approaches only becomes apparent Cincinatti: South Western College
the photo- or flower-shops, which are in the middle to long term. Hence, Publishing.
already separated from the main areas transaction-oriented products are not Bachmann, C. (1999) ‘Online Retailing
in the shops. Future plans include the fully realized until the knowledge – Erfahrungen und Erfolgsfaktoren
installation of further pick-up loca- about the supplier –customer relation- aus Sicht des E-Commerce-Pioniers
tions in company-owned filling sta- ship suffices to provide genuine added Primus Online’, in Tomczak, T.,
tions to increase the number of value. Even so, trust-based approaches Belz, C., Schögel, M. and Birkhofer,
characteristics, challenges and key suc- value based on a strict behaviorist Hagel, J. and Armstrong, A.G. (1997)
cess factors of transaction and trust- model see, for example, Wiswede ‘Net Gain - Expanding Markets
based strategies. (1974) Scherhorn (1992). through Virtual Communities’, The
2. In addition, there are a variety of McKinsey Quarterly 1, 141 –53.
situational factors influencing cus- Hagel, J. and Rayport, J.F. (1997a)
CONCLUSION tomer buying behavior that a com- ‘The New Infomediaries’, The
pany can influence or control to a McKinsey Quarterly 4, 55–70.
Both strategies are successful and can very limited degree. Hagel, J. and Rayport, J.F. (1997b)
even be complementary, but they re- ‘The Coming Battle for Customer
quire a clear vision of the specific Information’, Harvard Business
value offered to the customer and the References Review 1, 53 –65.
goals that are to be reached by the Assael, H. (1995) Consumer Behaviour Hagel, J. and Singer, M. (1999) Net
company. The benefit of both strate- and Marketing Action, 5th edn, Worth – Shaping Markets When 174
Customers Make the Rules, Boston: Scherhorn, G. (1992) ‘Kritik des Sieber, P. (1999) ‘Nahrungsmittel-
Harvard Business School Press. Zusatznutzens’, Thexis 2, 24–8. Detailhandel’, in Griese, J. and
Herrmann, A. (1998) Schögel, M. (1997) Mehrkanalsysteme in Sieber, P. (eds), E-commerce - Aus
Produktmanagement, München: der Distribution, Wiesbaden: Gabler. Beispielen lernen, Zürich: Werd
Vahlen. Schögel, M., Birkhofer, B. and Verlag, 9–31.
Kotler, P. (1997) Marketing- Tomczak, T. (1999a) ‘Kooperative Vershofen, W. (1940) Handbuch der
Management – Analysis, Planning, Leistungssysteme – Eigenschaften, Verbrauchsforschung, 1. Band:
Implementation, and Control, 9th Herausforderungen und Grundlagen, Berlin: Duncker and
edn, New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Lösungsansätze’, Thexis 3, 10–16. Humblot.
Kotler, P. and Bliemel, F. (1999) Schögel, M., Birkhofer, B. and Werner, G. and Richter, M. (1998)
Marketing-Management - Analyse, Tomczak, T. (1999b) ‘A Typology ‘Marken im Bereich
Planung, Umsetzung und Steuerung, of Business Models in E-commerce Dienstleistungen: Gibt es das
9. Aufl., Stuttgart: Schäffer-Poeschel. for Marketing Consumer Goods’, in überhaupt?’, in Tomczak, T.,
Nieschlag, R., Dichtl, E. and Proceedings of COTIM 99 - Schögel, M. and Ludwig, E. (eds),
Hörschgen, H. (1997) Marketing, Conference on Technology and Markenmanagement für
18. durchges. Aufl., Berlin: Duncker Information Management, Rhode Dienstleistungen , St. Gallen: Thexis,
& Humblot. Island, 27 –29 September 1999. 24–35.
Porter, M.E. (1985) Competitive Schögel, M., Birkhofer, B. and Winand, U. and Pohl, W. (1998) ‘Die
Downloaded By: [German National Licence 2007] At: 15:06 11 March 2010
Advantage, New York: The Free Press. Tomczak, T. (2000) E-Commerce im Vertrauensproblematik in
Quelch, J.A. and Klein, L.R. (1996) Distributionsmanagement - Status elektronischen Netzwerken’, in Link,
‘The Internet and International Quo und Entwicklungstendenzen, J. (ed.) Wettbewerbsvorteile durch
Marketing’, Sloan Management Fachbericht für Marketing 2000/2, Online Marketing, Berlin: Springer
Review 2, 60–75. St. Gallen: Thexis. Verlag, 243–59.
Reichheld, F.F. and Sasser, E.W. (1990) Schwartz, E.I. (1997) Webonomics – Wiswede, G. (1974)
‘Zero-Defections: Quality Comes to Nine Essential Principles for Growing ‘Verbrauchsforschung’, in Tietz,
Services’, Harvard Business Review your Business on the World Wide Web, B. (ed.), HWA, Stuttgart,
5, 105 –11. New York: Broadway Books. 2039 –46.
Electronic Markets Vol. 10 No 3
175