8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

Palisade is now Lumivero

Leveraging Probabilistic
Analysis to Improve Rock Fall
Protection Structure Designs
with @RISK and PrecisionTree

 Customer
Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers

 Industry
Construction & Engineering

 Product(s)
@RISK & TopRank, PrecisionTree
2
Z Application
Disaster Planning, Engineering system design and optimization,
Transportation safety and investment

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 1/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

Application
Modeling rock fall masses, trajectories, velocities, and energies to design rock fall
protection structures. Communicating risk to clients by calculating impact energy
probability so that the impact capacity of the protection structure can be matched
to the consequence of an accident.

Summary
Duncan Wyllie, a Principal of Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers, uses @RISK and
PrecisionTree for probabilistic modeling of rock fall hazards. The analyses
incorporate uncertainty in values of the mass and velocity that are expressed as
probability distributions, and Monte Carlo simulation in @RISK is used to calculate
the probability distribution of the impact energy. The energy calculations are then
used to design protection structures such as concrete sheds and wire rope fences
with the appropriate impact energy capacity to suit the possible consequences of
an accident. Decision analysis using PrecisionTree is then applied to determine the
optimum mitigation strategy.

In the example, Wyllie explains how Palisade software is used to calculate potential
rock fall impact energies and make recommendations for a fence to protect traffic
at the base of a steep mountain slope.

Background
Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers, with offices in Seattle and Vancouver, Canada, is a
specialist engineering company working in the fields of rock slopes, tunnels,
blasting, foundations, landslides, and rock falls. Duncan Wyllie and Norman Norrish,
the company principals, have a combined total of 80 years of experience in applied
rock mechanics.

Since the 1990s, Wyllie and Norrish have been utilizing Palisade software to 2
analyze rock fall risks and hazards, and design rock fall protection structures. They
provide hazard mitigation services for rock falls in mountainous areas by
identifying rock fall sources, modelling rock fall trajectories and energies, and

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 2/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

designing customized protection structures. Projects have been undertaken for

highways, railways, hydro-electric power plants, and residential developments.

Using Palisade Products

For most rock fall projects, very limited, or no, information is available from
previous events. In these circumstances, uncertainty exists in the design
parameters of rock fall frequency, mass, velocity and trajectory. These uncertainties
can be quantified using @RISK to define probability distributions that account for
the possible range of values, and the most likely values, based on judgement and
experience.

Wyllie found that the BetaGeneral and Pert distributions incorporated in @RISK
provide the optimum models for these conditions. Multiplication of mass by the
square of the velocity distributions gives the impact energy that is also defined by a
probability distribution. This information can be used to design protection
structures that reduce the hazard to an acceptable level of societal risk.

Another component of risk management for rock fall projects is to implement

decision analysis in which alternative courses of action, such as construction of a
high strength containment fence or of a less expensive ditch, can be compared.
This analysis can be carried out using PrecisionTree in which the sum of
construction costs and expected value of an accident (i.e., the product of an
accident cost and its probability) can be compared for each course of action.
 PrecisionTree allows rapid analysis of these alternatives and incorporates
sensitivity analyses that show how uncertainty in values of the costs and
probabilities influence the selection of the optimum action.

A particular value of analyses using @RISK and PrecisionTree is that it is possible

to define low risk but high consequence events that have a low expected value,
such as a large-scale landslide. Comparison of this event with more frequently
occurring, but less costly rock falls will show if the optimum mitigation measure is
to stabilize the landslide or contain the rock falls. The analyses often show that 2
very rare events are acceptable.

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 3/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

Summary
Duncan Wyllie, a Principal of Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers, uses @RISK
and PrecisionTree for probabilistic modeling of rock fall hazards. The
analyses incorporate uncertainty in values of the mass and velocity that
are expressed as probability distributions, and Monte Carlo simulation in
@RISK is used to calculate the probability distribution of the impact energy.
The energy calculations are then used to design protection structures such
as concrete sheds and wire rope fences with the appropriate impact energy
capacity to suit the possible consequences of an accident. Decision
analysis using PrecisionTree is then applied to determine the optimum
mitigation strategy.

Duncan Wyllie
Principal of Wyllie

“If we use @RISK and

as to what structural p

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 4/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

Rock Fall Modeling Example

When a rock fall source on a steep mountain slope was identified above a road,
Wyllie used @RISK to calculate the probability distribution of the potential rock fall
impact energies that would be used to design a protection structure. Because the
site had no history of rock falls that could be used for design, @RISK was used to
analyze the geology and empirical equations for velocity to develop BetaGeneral
distributions for the mass and velocity, from which the distribution for the impact
energy was calculated. These plots are shown below where the maximum,
minimum, and mean values for mass, velocity, and energy are indicated.

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 5/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

These results were discussed with the owner to determine an appropriate design
energy capacity for a fence to protect the road from rock falls.

“Because access to the road was restricted and traffic was infrequent, it was
decided that a rock fall event with high energy but low probability was acceptable,”
said Wyllie. “The design energy of 1250 kJ was selected such that about 90% of
falls would be contained, with the understanding that the low probability of an event
with an energy exceeding 1250 kJ was acceptable.”

The image below shows the installed Attenuator fence.

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 6/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

In comparison, if the fence was installed above a busy Interstate highway where the
consequence of a high energy rock fall event could be severe, it is likely that the
design energy would be about 2500 kJ to 3000 kJ to ensure that almost all rock
falls would be contained.

“If we use @RISK and PrecisionTree to present results, people can make rational
decisions as to what structural protection to install,” said Wyllie.

Results
Thanks to the probabilistic analysis conducted by Wyllie, the road has a fence in
place that can withstand an impact energy of 1250 kJ that will contain about 90%
of future rock falls. Those traveling on the road can have peace of mind knowing
the hazard mitigation structure was designed through quantitative analysis.
2
A Competitive Edge
The use of @RISK and PrecisionTree software to prepare designs where many or all
of the design parameters are uncertain allows Wyllie to quantitatively determine the

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 7/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

best mitigation strategy.

With Palisade’s products, Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers can:

Calculate all possible scenarios with Monte Carlo simulations

Easily communicate risk to clients with PrecisionTree

Recommend defensible hazard protection strategies.

By using deterministic analysis, Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers ensure that
effective hazard mitigation structures are in place to protect people, facilities, and
infrastructure.

Over 200 Customer Success Stories using Palisade

Solutions 

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 8/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

Join decision-makers around the

world who

RELY ON
PALISADE.
Request a Demo

Products Plans
@RISK @RISK Plans
DecisionTools Suite DecisionTools Suite
+1-800-432-7475 (Toll Free)
RISKOptimizer
+1-607-277-8000
ScheduleRiskAnalysis Resources
(Americas)
TopRank Blog & News
+44 (0)1895 425 050
PrecisionTree Events
(EMEA)
NeuralTools
+61 2 9252 5922 (APAC)
StatTools

555 Fayetteville Street Evolver

Suite 300 Academic Offerings

Raleigh, NC 27601 USA Licensing Options 2

Email: sales@palisade.com

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 9/10
8/3/23, 3:17 PM Wyllie & Norrish Rock Engineers | Palisade

   

Support Company Contact

Customer Support About Us Sales and General

Training Careers Support

Technical Support Leadership Request a Demo

Knowledgebase News & Press Request a Free Trial

Partners Buy Now

© Copyright 2023 Palisade.com. All Rights Reserved

https://palisade.lumivero.com/case_studies/wyllie-norrish-rock-engineers/ 10/10