Professional Documents
Culture Documents
38 september
Downloaded2from
:: volRCNi.com ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use only. NoNURSING
30 no 1 ::by2015 STANDARD
other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Health (DH) 2015), and this has been particularly with the 6Cs of nursing (DH 2012b), specifically
emphasised following the findings of the Report those of care, competence and commitment,
of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust by striving to improve health outcomes, ensuring
Public Inquiry (Francis 2013). Improving the that staff have the relevant level of training and
monitoring and recording of respiratory rates is in expertise appropriate for the tasks they are
keeping with this principle and also reflects central undertaking, and promoting positive patient and
values associated with healthcare services, such as staff experiences.
the commitment to innovation and excellence in
standards of care for all. Published studies into the
measurement of respiratory rates are not specific Change management process
to mental health wards. The focus of the planned The change management process involves:
change project on mental health wards arises from identifying possible causes, identifying an
the author’s experience as a mental health nursing appropriate solution, defining project aims and
student in clinical practice. It is also supported objectives, change management, evaluating
by national strategies to improve physical health change, overcoming barriers to change and
care among those with mental health disorders ensuring quality.
(DH 2011, 2014). Research has shown that those
with mental health problems are more likely to Identifying possible causes
have poor physical health and die prematurely The cause of a problem in nursing practice should
compared with the rest of the population (Royal be explored to understand what needs to change
College of Psychiatrists 2009). The government’s and to enable the issue to be tackled effectively
mental health strategy for England aims to (Hewitt-Taylor 2012). A root cause analysis was
improve physical health outcomes and to ensure conducted to investigate why respiratory rates
that mental and physical illness are treated might be neglected and what the underlying
equally in healthcare services (DH 2011, 2014). causes could be.
Furthermore, The NHS Outcomes Framework This was undertaken using the ‘5 Whys’ tool,
2013/14 (DH 2012a) includes an indicator to which can help to clarify and describe a problem
reduce premature mortality for those with serious in detail (Kerridge 2012a). This involved
mental illness. identifying the reasons why respiratory rates
An abnormal respiratory rate is a significant are not monitored and recorded in the literature
predictor of acute deterioration and serious clinical and then repeatedly asking ‘Why?’ to dissect the
events such as cardiac arrest and/or admission to problem and determine a root cause. In this case,
intensive care units (Butler-Williams et al 2005). four main underlying causes were identified from
There is evidence that those with a serious mental the literature, some of which were supported by the
illness are at risk of dying 10-20 years earlier author’s clinical experience. These were examined
(Chesney et al 2014). For example, compared with further in accordance with the 5 Whys tool to
the general population, those with a serious mental reveal root causes of the issue (Figure 1).
illness have three times the risk of dying from The 5 Whys approach was useful to the
chronic heart disease, and there are reports of a planning of this change project; however, it may
tenfold-increase in deaths from respiratory disease not be suitable for all types of problem because
for people with schizophrenia (Rethink Mental it does not always clearly show connections
Illness 2013). Rethink Mental Illness (2013), between causes (Hewitt-Taylor 2012). A further
a charity in England, asserts that people who limitation is that it may not be possible to identify
have a serious mental illness are one of the most the causes of a problem and/or link such causes to
high-risk groups in the UK in terms of avoidable a solution (Hewitt-Taylor 2012). Another method
deaths. Therefore, comprehensive physiological of obtaining the required information could
observations, including recognising and recording involve the use of workshops. Such an approach
alterations in respiratory rate, are crucial. could be beneficial because it could involve staff
The aim of the planned change project would be from the early stages: they may then feel more
to ensure that nurses and healthcare assistants who invested in assisting with the delivery of the change
are tasked with performing vital signs monitoring plan (Gage 2013).
are adequately trained and supported to carry The 5 Whys analysis identified a lack of
out the task effectively, in accordance with the knowledge, confidence and understanding of
guiding principles of The NHS Constitution (DH respiratory rate measurement and an over-reliance
2015). Healthcare staff should also understand on equipment (as opposed to manual monitoring),
the potential meaning of results, to promote high as reasons why respiratory rates are not
quality patient care. The project plan also aligns monitored and recorded.
NURSING
DownloadedSTANDARD september
from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use only. No 2 :: vol
other 30without
uses 2015 39
no 1 :: permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Art & science mental health
FIGURE 1
‘5 Whys’ analysis
Because some staff Because some staff Because nurses and Because some staff
are unsure how to feel unconfident healthcare assistants are unaware of
monitor respiratory or uncomfortable rely on equipment the importance of
rates correctly. with measuring when observing respiratory rates in
respiratory rates. patients’ vital signs. the assessment of a
Evidence: Hogan
patient’s condition.
(2006) and clinical Evidence: Hogan Evidence: Hogan
experience. (2006) and clinical (2006), Parkes Evidence: Butler-
experience. (2011) and clinical Williams et al (2005),
Why?
experience. Hogan (2006).
Why?
Why? Why?
40 september
Downloaded2from
:: volRCNi.com ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use only. NoNURSING
30 no 1 ::by2015 STANDARD
other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
deterioration. Attendees would also be educated on Improvement 2011). A follow-up audit of the EWS
the relevance of respiratory rates within the EWS charts after the training would show if there had
system and the need for a complete set of vital sign been any improvements.
measurements. Trainers could then demonstrate
the correct techniques for measuring respiratory Change management
rates, and attendees would have the opportunity At the planning stage, support should be
to practise these techniques in pairs. There would gained from those senior members of staff who
also be time allowed at the end of the session for have an appropriate area of responsibility, and
questions and comments. who would benefit from this service improvement
The use of a training programme to improve idea; these staff could assist to raise the
monitoring and recording of respiratory rates profile of the change project and support the
is reported by Butler-Williams et al (2005). implementation of the project plan (Gage 2013).
The authors performed a hospital audit and Potential candidates to approach might include
results showed a low rate of documentation the ward’s modern matron, ward managers and
of patients’ respiratory rates (24/341, 7%). clinical team leaders.
A training programme was implemented in the A change management model is recommended
hospital to increase staff awareness of the value of when planning to implement a service
respiratory rates. improvement. A systematic, tried and tested
When the audit was repeated, a considerable approach can enhance a project’s chances of
improvement (199/325, 61%) in the recording of success (NHS Improvement 2011). Lewin’s (1951)
this vital sign was observed. Following the success three-step process to change management offers
of the project, the intention was to disseminate the a structured approach to understanding and
training across the trust with the expectation that changing behaviour in the workplace. It relates
EWS rates would continue to improve. However, well to healthcare practice, as its three stages of
long-term results of the project could not be ‘unfreezing’, ‘moving’ and ‘refreezing’ are similar
verified (Butler-Williams et al 2005). to the healthcare processes of ‘planning’,
‘implementing’ and ‘evaluating’ care (Bowers
Defining project aims and objectives 2011). Lewin (1951) recommends that the
Once a solution, such as a training programme, ‘driving’ and ‘resisting’ forces to the planned
has been established, a clearly defined aim and change should be examined using a force field
set of SMART (specific, measurable, achievable, analysis (Figure 2). The three-step model can then
realistic and time-bound) objectives should be used to facilitate a shift in the direction of the
be developed, to enable the change project proposed change.
to be planned effectively and to inform those Lewin’s (1951) first step, unfreezing, involves
involved of the main events and their rationale changing the magnitude of the forces that
(Kerridge 2012b). maintain the status quo. The best way to do this
The following aims and objectives were is by reducing the ‘resisting’ forces rather than
proposed for the planned change project: increasing the ‘driving’ forces (Kerridge 2012b).
The aim should be that 100% of patients who For example, the resisting force relating to lack of
have their vital signs checked will have their knowledge of how to correctly measure respiratory
respiratory rate monitored and recorded on rates could be reduced by training, during which
the EWS chart. staff would have the opportunity to watch and
The first SMART objective should be that practise the correct techniques. The moving
nurses and healthcare assistants receive half a step involves implementing the change. Nurses
day of ward-based training on how to assess the and healthcare assistants should have received
respiratory rate correctly and its significance in the relevant training and could move forward,
the EWS system. routinely measuring respiratory rates as part of
The second objective should be that the their observations of vital signs.
ward-based training will be provided to all new The final, refreezing step occurs after the
nurses and healthcare assistants as part of their change has been made; it involves stabilising and
induction programme, and will be included evaluating change. For example, staff could be
in the mandatory continuing professional provided with ongoing education and support.
development programme for existing staff. However, it might be argued that the refreezing
Specific dates should be given in which to achieve step cannot be wholly achieved within the
objectives and aims. A baseline audit should continually changing environment of the NHS,
be conducted to assess the current recording since subsequent changes usually affect any
of respiratory rates on EWS charts (NHS changes made previously (Bowers 2011).
NURSING
DownloadedSTANDARD september
from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use 2 :: vol
only. No other 30without
uses 2015 41
no 1 :: permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Art & science mental health
FIGURE 2
Force field analysis for improving monitoring and recording of respiratory rates
Improving
monitoring
Promotes continuing professional and Negative past experience of
development recording of change
respiratory
rates
42 september
Downloaded2from
:: volRCNi.com ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use only. NoNURSING
30 no 1 ::by2015 STANDARD
other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
and why; practicalities, for example time and feedback, and working together to create a shared
resources; skills, for example people’s confidence vision. Further, it emphasises that leadership does
in new ways of working; individual attitudes and not involve ‘distant leaders’ who are inaccessible,
beliefs; the external environment, including political high-level, individuals, but ‘nearby leaders’
and financial influences; and external and internal whom people interact with on a daily basis.
motivation, for example financial reward and This idea is consistent with the notion of ‘opinion
self-improvement (NICE 2007, Hewitt-Taylor 2013). leaders’, a term that refers to individuals who
Many of these elements were identified as resisting can be found at any level of an organisation but
forces in the force field analysis (Figure 2) and relate who have a significant influence because they
predominantly to how staff perceive and respond to are respected (Hewitt-Taylor 2013). Support
proposed changes. from these nearby leaders is an important part
This is consistent with research conducted of change management.
into team service improvement (NHS Institute
for Innovation and Improvement 2005). Studies Ensuring quality
have shown that the human aspects of change Clinical governance is central to contemporary
management can have a significant effect on a healthcare services and provides a systematic
project’s success or failure and that dealing with approach to improving the quality of services
such aspects is fundamental to embedding and (Braine 2006). Clinical governance should
sustaining change in practice in the long term therefore be a central consideration in the
(Gage 2013). Therefore, although some aspects conception, planning and implementation of the
of staff members’ reactions to change may be planned change project. The Royal College of
beyond the control of the planned change project, Nursing (2015) identifies five key themes of clinical
many aspects may be anticipated and addressed. governance: patient focus, information focus,
The training session would aim to equip staff with quality improvement, staff focus and leadership.
up-to-date, evidence-based knowledge to carry out A service improvement strategy should work in
respiratory monitoring and record observations accordance with these themes by measuring the
with confidence and expertise. Further, the session effects of the project through continuous auditing,
would seek to empower staff to play an active staff development and training, promoting
role in their continuing professional development, effective leadership and teamwork, and improving
rather than criticising or undermining previous awareness of the EWS system.
ways of working. All these elements should contribute to
The role of leadership is another fundamental improving the quality of patient care. However,
component of service improvement. Research one particular aspect of clinical governance
shows that effective leadership requires engaging would require development and careful planning:
and motivating staff, creating a shared purpose the issue of patient involvement and experience.
and vision in line with people’s values and The difficulty with this aspect of clinical
experiences so that staff feel invested in the governance relates to the fact that, for effective
change (Finney 2013, Storey and Holti 2013). measurement of respiratory rates, patients should
Without a sense of shared purpose, staff may not be aware that it is being measured, because this
perceive the planned change project simply as might influence their breathing pattern (Mooney
an exercise in compliance, with tasks imposed 2007). It is therefore unlikely that patients would
from the top (Finney 2013). The Report of be able to provide direct feedback or make
the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust suggestions for improvement on respiratory rate
Public Inquiry (Francis 2013) emphasised the monitoring. One alternative approach could be
value of leadership in health care and found that to ensure that the patient-focused component of
when effective leaders are not in place and work the change project involved exploring patients’
is perceived as purely target-driven, there is a experiences of and feelings about vital sign
deterioration in staff engagement and, hence, monitoring. Respiratory rates would be measured
patient care. The Chartered Institute of Personnel unobtrusively as part of this process.
and Development (CIPD) (2008) suggests a
model of leadership that focuses on engaging
and motivating staff. This model comprises Conclusion
four elements: engaging individuals, engaging This article provides a systematic, comprehensive
the organisation, moving forward together, and measurable plan for a change project
and personal qualities and values. to improve the recording and monitoring of
The CIPD model promotes teamworking, respiratory rates on mental health wards,
transparency and consistency, questioning and with the overall aim of promoting high quality
NURSING
DownloadedSTANDARD september
from RCNi.com by ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use only. No 2 :: vol
other 30without
uses 2015 43
no 1 :: permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.
Art & science mental health
physical health care in mental health practice. them with the knowledge to perform the task
The root cause analysis described indicates that effectively. A training programme to overcome
limitations on the awareness, competence and potential barriers to the change project, by taking
confidence of nurses and other staff are potential into account the human aspects, is proposed.
reasons for poor recording of respiratory Leadership is identified as an important element
rates. The proposed solution included a staff of effectively managing change, and engaging and
training programme to empower staff and equip motivating staff NS
References
Bowers B (2011) Managing change Midwifery and Care Staff: Our Vision Hogan J (2006) Why don’t nurses Development. tinyurl.com/pdajsuy
by empowering staff. Nursing Times. and Strategy. tinyurl.com/c5lc4n2 monitor the respiratory rates of (Last accessed: July 28 2015.)
107, 32–33, 19-21. (Last accessed: July 28 2015.) patients? British Journal of Nursing.
15, 9, 489-492. Parkes R (2011) Rate of respiration:
Braine ME (2006) Clinical governance: Department of Health (2014) the forgotten vital sign. Emergency
applying theory to practice. Nursing Closing the Gap: Priorities for Kerridge J (2012a) Leading change: Nurse. 19, 2, 12-17.
Standard. 20, 20, 56-65. Essential Change in Mental Health. 1 – identifying the issue. Nursing
tinyurl.com/ofeyofv (Last accessed: Times. 108, 4, 12-15. Rethink Mental Illness (2013) Lethal
Butler-Williams C, Cantrill N, Maton S July 28 2015.) Discrimination: Why People with
(2005) Increasing staff awareness Kerridge J (2012b) Leading change: Mental Illness are Dying Needlessly
of respiratory rate significance. Department of Health (2015) The 2 – planning. Nursing Times. and What Needs to Change. tinyurl.
Nursing Times. 101, 27, 35-37. NHS Constitution: The NHS Belongs 108, 5, 23-25. com/ncwqa6h (Last accessed:
to Us All. tinyurl.com/c9qmsac July 28 2015.)
Chartered Institute of Personnel (Last accessed: July 28 2015.) Kerridge J (2012c) Leading
and Development (2008) Engaging change: 3 – implementation. Royal College of Nursing
Leadership: Creating Organisations Edwards Deming W (1986) Out of Nursing Times. 108, 6, 23-25. (2015) Clinical Governance.
that Maximise the Potential of their the Crisis: Quality, Productivity and www.rcn.org.uk/development/
People. CIPD, London. Competitive Position. Cambridge Lewin K (1951) Field Theory in practice/clinical_governance
University Press, Cambridge. Social Science: Selected (Last accessed: July 28 2015.)
Chesney E, Goodwin GM, Fazel S Theoretical Papers.
(2014) Risks of all-cause and suicide Finney L (2013) Our Shared Harper & Row, London. Royal College of Physicians (2012)
mortality in mental disorders: Purpose: A Practical Guide. tinyurl. National Early Warning Score (NEWS):
a meta review. World Psychiatry. com/pk8kurs (Last accessed: Mooney GP (2007) Respiratory Standardising the Assessment of
13, 2, 153-160. July 28 2015.) Assessment: How to Accurately Acute-Illness Severity in the NHS.
Measure and Record Respiration Royal College of Physicians, London.
Cretikos MA, Bellomo R, Francis R (2013) Report of the Mid Rates. tinyurl.com/qg7ozq9
Hillman K, Chen J, Finfer S, Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust (Last accessed: August 13 2015.) Royal College of Psychiatrists (2009)
Flabouris A (2008) Respiratory Public Inquiry: Executive Summary. Physical Health in Mental Health:
rate: the neglected vital sign. The Stationery Office, London. National Institute for Health Final Report of a Scoping Group.
Medical Journal of Australia. and Care Excellence (2007) Occasional Paper OP67. RCP, London.
188, 11, 657-659. Gage W (2013) Using service How to Change Practice. NICE,
improvement methodology to London. Smith S (2011) Early warning
Department of Health (2011) change practice. Nursing Standard. scores: effective use. Nursing
No Health Without Mental Health: 27, 23, 51-57. NHS Improvement (2011) First Times. 107, 3, 16.
A Cross-Government Mental Health Steps towards Quality Improvement:
Outcomes Strategy for People of All Hewitt-Taylor J (2012) Identifying, A Simple Guide to Improving Smith S, Fraser J, Plowright C
Ages. DH, London. analysing and solving problems Services. www.nhsiq.nhs.uk/ et al (2008) An Audit of Nursing
in practice. Nursing Standard. media/2591385/siguide.pdf Observations on Ward Patients.
Department of Health (2012a) The 26, 40, 35-41. (Last accessed: July 28 2015.) tinyurl.com/l8kfdbg (Last accessed:
NHS Outcomes Framework 2013/14. August 13 2015.)
tinyurl.com/ptdd8ez (Last accessed: Hewitt-Taylor J (2013) NHS Institute for Innovation and
July 28 2015.) Planning successful change Improvement (2005) Improvement Storey J, Holti R (2013) Towards
incorporating processes and Leaders’ Guide. Managing the a New Model of Leadership for the
Department of Health (2012b) people. Nursing Standard. Human Dimensions of Change: NHS. tinyurl.com/pxyxnyx
Compassion in Practice. Nursing, 27, 38, 35-40. Personal and Organisational (Last accessed: July 28 2015.)
44 september
Downloaded2from
:: volRCNi.com ${individualUser.displayName} on Mar 23, 2016. For personal use only. NoNURSING
30 no 1 ::by2015 STANDARD
other uses without permission.
Copyright © 2016 RCNi Ltd. All rights reserved.