Professional Documents
Culture Documents
672~680, 2012
http://dx.doi.org/10.5370/JEET.2012.7.5.672
P. Kumkratug†
Abstract – This paper proposes the control strategy of the shunt Flexible AC Transmission System
(FACTS) devices to improve transient stability in multimachine power system. The multimachine
power system has high nonlinear response after severe disturbance. The concept of Lyapunov energy
function is applied to derive nonlinear control strategy and it was found that the time derivative of line
voltage is not only can apply to control the shunt FACTS devices in multimachine system but also is
locally measurable signal. The fuzzy logic control is also applied to overcome the uncertainty of
various disturbances in multimachine power system. This paper presents the method of investigating
the effect of the shunt FACTS devices on transient stability improvement. The proposed control
strategy and the method of simulation are tested on the new England power system. It was found that
the shunt FACTS devices based on the proposed nonlinear control strategy can improve transient
stability of multimachine power system.
Keywords: Power system, Transient stability, FACTS devices, Lyapunov, Fuzzy logic control
devices includes the Static Synchronous Series shunt FACTS devices equipped at bus m. The Static Var
Compensator (SSSC), Static Synchronous Compensator Compensator (SVC) consists of the fixed capacitor with a
(STATCOM), Unified Power Flow Controller (UPFC) and thyristor controlled reactor whereas the Static Synchronous
Interline Power Flow Controller (IPFC) [5, 6]. Compensator (STATCOM) consists of a solid-state voltage
Static Var Compensator (SVC) and Static Synchronous source converter (VSC) with GTO thyristor switches or
Compensator (STATCOM) are considered as the shunt other high performances of semi-conductor switches, a DC
FACTS devices and they are used for controlling the line capacitor, and transformer as shown in Fig. 1(a). They are
voltage by supplying or absorbing the reactive power. Most of used for exchanging reactive power from power system.
previous researches use the remote signal such as machine The load injections of both the SVC and STATCOM are
speed to control the shunt FACTS devices for improving shown in Fig. 1(b).
transient stability of the power system [7-9]. However, the
machine speed may not be available at the optimal placement
of the shunt FACTS devices [10]. Thus, in multimachine
power system, the remote signal may not be practical.
In modern power system, it is very large scale and
complex network. The disturbance may results in nonlinear
response. The second method of the Lyapunov second
method or called the Lyapunov energy function is the
concept of nonlinear system. The successful application of
Lypunov energy function of series FACTS devices have
been reported in [11].
The uncertainty of various disturbances often happening (a)
in power system provides the difficulty of control. The
fuzzy logic control provides very powerful to handle this
difficulty. Reference [12, 13] represents the application of
fuzzy logic to control UPFC and STATCOM in a single
machine infinite bus.
Traditional tool for evaluating transient stability of power
system is called the momentary mode. In this mode, power
system and the FACTS devices are modeled in detail. The
examples of working in this mode are PSS/E, Eurostag, and
PSCAD, EMTP/EMTDC. However, implementation of new
(b)
components, especially soft computing ones, within these
packages can be very difficult and it is very time consuming Fig. 1. Shunt FACTS devices: (a) Configurations; (b)
for evaluating transient stability of the multimachine power Reactive power load injection models.
system [14-16].
This paper applies the concepts of Lyapunov energy
function and fuzzy logic to determine control strategy of The capacitive power load injection model of the SVC is
the shunt FACTS devices for enhancing stability of given by
multimachine power system. Due to the drawbacks of the
momentary mode, this paper aims to develop computation Qinj = − BsvcVm2 (1)
method of power system equipped with the shunt FACTS
devices. The outline of this paper is as follows: Section 2
reviews the shunt FACTS devices model, power system The capacitive power load injection model of the
model and Lyapunov energy function. Section 3 proposes STATCOM is given by
the shunt FACTS devices control strategy based on
Lyapunov energy function and fuzzy logic control. Section
Qinj = −Vm I q (2)
4 presents the method of simulations. Section 5
investigates the proposed control strategy.
The degree and the direction of control reactive power
2. Mathematical Model and Lyapunov Energy injections are determined by variable susceptance (Bsvc) on
Function the SVC or shunt current injection (Iq) on the STATCOM,
respectively. When the controlled parameters (Bsvc , Iq) are
2.1 Model of shunt FACTS devices positive, they supply reactive power into the system; when
the controlled parameters are negative, they absorb reactive
Fig. 1 shows the configurations and the model of the power from the system.
674 Application of Lyapunov Theory and Fuzzy Logic to Control Shunt FACTS Devices for Enhancing Transient Stability in~
δɺi = ωi (3)
1
ωɺ i = [ Pmi − Pei − Diωi ] , i=1,2…ng (4)
Mi
ng
Pei = ∑ (F
j =1; ≠ i
ij sin θ ij + H ij cos θij ) (5) (b)
Here θij = (θi − θ j ) , Fij = Eqi′ Eqj′ Bij , H ij = Eqi′ Eqj′ Gij
red
and Ybus = G + jB
where
δ i : machine angle of the i-th machine E′q1 E′q 2 E′qng
ng ng + nb ng + nb
QLi
∑ ∑∫ ∑
1 E′q1 E′q 2 E′qng
E= M i ωɶi2 + dVi + PLiθɶi −
2 i =1 i = ng +1
Vi i = ng +1 par
Ybus
ng ng + nb
∑P
i =1
miθi
ɶ −1
2 ∑ ∑B
i =1 j =1
mnViV j cos θɶij + Ec (13) S Fm = P Fm + jQFm
Vm = Vm ∠θ m
Here
Ec is constant energy at equilibrium point.
V, θ and nb are the line voltage magnitude, line voltage
S Lm = P Lm + jQLm Qinj
Qinj
− Vɺm ≤ 0 (17)
Vm
BsvcVmVɺm ≤ 0 (18)
(a)
I qVɺm ≤ 0 (19)
(b)
4. Algorithm (g) Evaluate the machine angles and speeds from (6) and (7).
(h) Repeat steps b)-g) until the maximum period of
This Section will present the evaluation method for investigation is reached.
investigating the proposed control strategy of the shunt
FACTS devices on transient stability of the multimachine
power system. The computation steps of the transient 5. Results and Discussion
response of power system equipped with the shunt FACTS
devices are given in the following: The proposed control strategy of the shunt FACTS
devices is tested on the new England power system. Its
(a) Perform the reduced admittance matrix of all single line diagram is shown in Fig. 8. The detail of system
par
physical load buses except bus m ( Ybus ). Here the data and initial operating point are given in [17]. First
constant load at bus m ( S Lm ) is converted into consider a 3-phase fault occurred near bus 29 and it is
par
constant admittance and add in Ybus . cleared by opening the line 26-29 (between bus 26 and bus
(b) Evaluate the Vm as given by 29). Fig. 9(a) and Fig. 9(b) show the rotor angles in Center
Of Inertia (COI) of all generators in the system with the
I g1 E′q1 fault clearing time (tcl) =90 and 91 msec, respectively. It
′ can be observed from Fig. 9 that with this fault and without
I g 2 Eq 2 FACTS devices, the generator 9 have the most severe
⋮ = par
Ybus ⋮
(20) disturbance and the critical clearing time (CCT) of the
I gng E′qng system is around 90-91 msec. With tcl=91 msec, the system
is considered as unstable. First a SVC is arbitrary equipped
0 Vm at bus 27. The system can be considered as stable with the
R
rating of SVC ( Bsvc R
) ≥ 0.03 pu. With this fault and Bsvc =
Here Igng is the current injection of machine of the i-th 0.03 pu, the maximum rotor angle of generator 9 is around
machine 116.97 degree as shown in Fig. 10. The simulations show
(c) Evaluate the Bsvc or Iq based on the proposed control that with this fault the suitable location of the shunt FACTS
strategy devices for improving CCT is the bus 29 or bus 38. Table 1
(d) Calculate the susceptance equivalent of the shunt summarizes the CCT of the system with various ratings of
R R
FACTS devices (ymi) as shown in Fig. 7 and given by a SVC ( Bsvc ) and a STATCOM ( I q ) equipped at bus 29.
The simulations have shown that the capability of the shunt
± jBsvc for SVC FACTS devices for enhancing transient stability of power
system depends on their ratings, locations and fault
y mi = Iq (21)
± j for STATCOM occurrence. If the fault occurs near bus 23 and it is cleared
Vm by opening the line 23-24, the best location of shunt
FACTS for enhancing transient stability of the system
would not be bus 29 as can be seen in Fig. 11. The first
maximum ( δɶmax ) and minimum swing curve ( δɶmin ) of the
R
E′q1 E′q 2 E′qng system with SVC ( Bsvc = 1 pu) at bus 29 are 115.03 and -
44.12, respectively whereas that of the SVC at bus 21 are
par
Ybus 113.24 and -42.20, respectively. Thus the better location of
the SVC with the new fault occurrence should be bus 21.
Vm = Vm ∠θ m
y mi
par
(e) Incorporate the ymi into the Ybus as shown in Fig. 7.
(f) Perform the reduced admittance matrix of all physical
red
load buses ( Ybus ). Fig. 8. Single line diagram of the new England system.
678 Application of Lyapunov Theory and Fuzzy Logic to Control Shunt FACTS Devices for Enhancing Transient Stability in~
(a)
(a)
120
δ%max
100
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
δ%min
-60
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
(b)
(b)
Fig. 9. Generator rotor angle in COI of the new England
system without the shunt FACTS devices and with 120
δ%max
Generator rotor angle in COI
fault near bus 29: (a) tcl=90 msec; (b) tcl=91 msec. 100
80
60
(degree)
40
20
0
-20
-40
δ%min
-60
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
Time (sec)
(c)
Fig. 11. Generator rotor angle in COI of the new England
Fig. 10. Generator rotor angle in COI of the new England
R
system with fault near bus 23 and tcl=191 msec: (a)
system with the rating of SVC ( Bsvc ) = 0.03 pu for without FACTS devices; (b) with a SVC at bus 29;
tcl=91 msec. (c) with a SVC at bus 21.
location, the shunt FACTS devices can improve transient strial Applications, vol.AI-15, no. 5, pp. 521-532,
stability of the multimachine system. September/October 1979.
[4] N. Hingorani and L. Gyugyi, Understanding FACTS:
concepts and technology of flexible ac transmission
systems: IEEE Press, 1999.
[5] Y. Song and A. Johns, Flexible ac transmission
systems (FACTS: The Institute of Electrical Engineers,
1999.
[6] L. Gyugyi, K. Sen and C. Schauder, “The interline
power flow controller concept: a new approach to
power flow management in transmission line
system,” IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery
Vol.14, no.3, pp.1115-1123, July 1999.
[7] P. Rao, M. L. Chow and Z. Yang, “STATCOM
control for power system voltage control appli-
Fig. 12. Generator rotor angle in COI of the new England cations,” IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol.
system with fault near bus 23, tcl=191 msec and 15, no.4, pp. 1311-1317, October 2000.
with a STATCOM at bus 15. [8] B. Mahdad, T. Bouktir, K. Srairi and M. E. L.
Benbouzid, “Optimal Power Flow with Disconti-
nuous Fuel Cost Functions Using Decomposed GA
Coordinated with Shunt FACTS,” Journal of
6. Conclusion
Electrical Engineering & Technology KIEE, vol. 4,
no. 4, pp. 457-466, December 2009.
This paper presented the control strategy of the shunt
[9] M. H. Haque and P. Kumkratug, “Application of
FACTS devices for improving transient stability of
Lyapunov stability criterion to determine the control
multimachine power system and presented the method of
strategy of a STATCOM,” IEE Proceeding of
investigating the effects of shunt FACTS devices on
Generation. Transmission and Distribution, vol. 151,
transient stability of multimachine power system. The
no. 2, pp. 415-420, May 2004.
concept of the Lyapunov energy function is applied to
[10] Y. Yu, C. Jianye and H. Yingduo, “STATCOM
derive the nonlinear control of shunt FACTS devices. It
modeling and analysis in damping power system
was found that the time derivative of line voltage in the
oscillations,” proceedings of Energy Conversion
system equipped with shunt FACTS devices is satisfied the
Engineering Conference and Exhibit, Las Vegas,
concept of the Lyapunov energy function and is the locally
USA, 2000.
measurable signal. The fuzzy logic control was further
[11] M. Ghandhari, Andersson G and Hiskens I. A. Control
applied to suitable control for various sizes of disturbances.
Lyapunov functions for controllable series devices.
This paper presented the mathematical model of
IEEE Transactions on Power Systems 2001; 16(4),
multimachine power system equipped with shunt FACTS
689-694.
devices. It can be applied to investigate the transient
[12] S. Limyingchareon, U. D. Annakkage and Pahala-
stability improvement of power system. The successive
waththa, “Fuzzy logic based unified power flow
model of shunt FACTS devices is represented by a variable
controllers for transient stability improvement,” IEE
susceptance and is incorporated into power system. The
Proceeding of Generation Transmission and Distri-
simulation results were tested on the new England power
bution, vol. 145, no. 3, pp. 225-232, May 1998.
system. It was found from the simulation results that the
[13] A. Ghafouri, M. R. Zolghadri and M. Ehsan, “Power
presented control strategy can improve transient stability of
system stability improvement using self-tuning fuzzy
multimachine systems. The capability of improvement
logic controlled STATCOM,” proceedings of Eurocon
depends on their ratings and locations.
2007, Poland, 2007.
[14] A. R. Bakhshai, G. Joos, and H. Jin, “EMTP
simulation of multi-pulse unified power flow
References controllers,” Proceedings of the Canadian Confer-
ence on Electrical and Computer Engineering,
[1] Y. Yao-nan, Electric power system dynamics: Acade- Alberta, Canada, 1996.
mic press, 1993. [15] K. L. Lo, T. T. Ma, J. Trecat, and M. Crappe,
[2] H. Saadat, Power system analysis: Mc Graw-Hill, “Detailed real-time simulation and performance
1999. analysis of UPFC using electromagnetic transient
[3] L. Gyugyi, “Reactive power generation and control program (EMTP),” Proceedings of International
by thyristor circuits,” IEEE Transactions on Indu- Conference on Power Con’98, Beijing, China, 1998.
680 Application of Lyapunov Theory and Fuzzy Logic to Control Shunt FACTS Devices for Enhancing Transient Stability in~