West Visayas State University

COLLEGE OF EDUCATION
Luna St., La Paz, Iloilo City 5000
Iloilo, Philippines
* Trunkline: (063) (033) 320-0870 loc 1808 * Telefax No.: (033) 320-0879
Acc. No.: M2700903PM
* Website: www.wvsu.edu.ph * Email Address: coe@wvsu.edu.ph
SCP000194Q

Matrix of Comments, Suggestions and Recommendations

Comments/Suggestions Action Taken Page number

Dr. Ricky M. Magno

 Theoretical Framework- add more  Accomplished pp. 6-9

citation and others must be
transferred to RRL.

 Research method- IPO model  Accomplished pp. 37-38

instead of ADDIE model.

 Remove “its effect” in the title.

 The definition of terms should be  Accomplished pp. 10-12

define operationally and
conceptually.

Prof. John R. Ladublan

 Add some related studies in RRL  Accomplished pp. 28-33
such as Gamification

 Add significance of the Study  Accomplished pp. 12-14

 Expert should be included in the  Accomplished pp. pp. 11

definition of terms

Dr. Baby Rose G. Robles:

 Organized the background.  Accomplished pp. 1-4

 Background of the study- further

improved, look for more citations.  Accomplished pp. 4-5
Statement about gamification and
game development.

Dr. Roberto G. Sagge Jr.

 Remove SOP 4 and SOP 5  Accomplished pp. 10

 Some of the cited theoretical

framework must be transferred to  Accomplished pp. 22-26
RRL.
 SOP 2 should be mobile games  Accomplished pp. 10
instead of instructional materials

 Research design. developmental  Accomplished pp. 37-38

only no more addie.

 Experts- science teachers  Accomplished pp. 11

 Experts- IT experts  Accomplished pp. 11

 Assessment to determine the  Accomplished pp. 16-24

least mastered competencies

 Instruments: checklist  Accomplished pp. 40-41

Questionnaire on the acceptability

 Cite the study in a background  Accomplished pp. 5-6

justifying the need to have this
kind of study.

Prepared by:

PATRICIA KEVIN R. GAYACAO

MAED Physical Science