Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3, 1986
Research Note
In connection with possible application as a coolant fluid in fusion reactors, molten LiNO3
and LiNO3/LiNO2 mixtures, and their mixtures with N a / K nitrates, have been evaluated
with respect to their high temperature stability, their ability to reversibly dissolve and[ release
tritium and, in a very limited sense, their corrosiveness toward structural alloys. The results of
the primarily thermochemical evaluation indicate that with respect to thermal/radiolytic
decomposition and corrosivity LiNO3/LiNO 2 may be suitable for application up to - 700~
however, with respect to reversibility/irreversibility of tritium release, it appears unsuitable at
all likely operating temperatures ( - 675-800~
constraints for the condensed phase, the equilibrium Equilibrium calculation were performed both
composition of a multiphase, multicomponent system manually and on an IBM PC using a floppy disk
may be calculated at a specified temperature. (11'16) version of the computer code SOLGASMIX-PV. (15'16)
This Second Law method yields equilibrium partial Preliminary calculations showed that the pressures of
pressures for gaseous constituents and chemical ac- many gaseous species (for example: N, O, M, MNO,
tivities for condensed phase constituents. Often, the N203, N204, N205, and N20 ) were trivially small at
total pressure, or one or more partial pressures or T < 800~ consequently these species were omitted
condensed phase activities, are prespecified. Our ap- in subsequent calculations. An inert diluent (argon)
proach was to apply this method to the LiNO 3- was included as a species in the SOLGASMIX calcu-
LiNO2, NaNO3-NaNO2, and KNO3-KNO 2 systems lations; this served the dual purpose of fixing or
and then compare predicted decomposition pressures adjusting the total system pressure.
for comparable degrees of decomposition at a repre-
sentative temperature. On the basis of the recent
Blanket Comparison and Selection Study, (3~ 4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
700~176 was selected as the threshold for use-
ful high temperature operation, and 800~176 4.1 Thermal Decomposition Pressures
was assumed as a realistic upper operating limit.
Selected equilibria were computed over a somewhat Preliminary calculations performed at 800~ for
wider range--600 to 900~ properly evaluate a specified composition of condensed phase (i.e., 50%
the effect of temperature. decomposition in reactions 1, 2, and 4) indicated that
Since the available thermodynamic functions for the LiNO 3 decomposition pressures for "case a" (N 2
M N O 3 and MNO 2 (M = Li, Na, and K) only refer to allowed) were several (> 2) orders of magnitude higher
low temperatures, and in certain cases are estimated, than the corresponding "case b" (no N 2 allowed)
we chose to neglect heat capacity corrections for pressures. Stern's calculations for Li, Na, and K
these species in the equilibrium calculations. Instead nitrates refer to "case b" with special restrictions on
we used the approximation AG~176 the condensed and gas phase compositions. In order
TAS~ to describe the T-dependence of the Gibbs to compare Stern's predicted decomposition pres-
energies of formation AG~ This approximation sures at 800~ we extended his calculations for
has been shown to be acceptable in a variety of LiNO 3 to 800~ using a standard logP (or Keq ) -
calculated gas-condensed phase equilibria in nuclear 1/T extrapolation. The resulting "equilibrium" pres-
fuel systems, (12'13~ even at temperatures as high as sures at 800~ are compared in Table II. From these
1200~ (It is acceptable in the sense that uncertain- results, it is clear that LiNO 3 is considerably less
ties for condensed phase reactants and products tend stable than NaNO 3 and KNO~. However, it should
to cancel out.) The principal sources of thermody- be noted that somewhat higher pressures were ob-
namic data used for our calculations were the JANAF tained for "case b" decomposition using SOLGAS-
Tables, (14) NBS Technical Note 270-8, (15~ and refs. 7 MIX free energy minimization calculations; this is
and 11. believed to be the consequence of removing Stern's
Two approaches were taken in calculating de- somewhat artificial compositional constraints.
composition pressures over MNO3-MNO 2 systems: For "case a" decomposition, which represents
(a) allowing the formation of molecular N 2 as a the least restrictive equilibrium condition, N 2 was
gaseous reaction product, and (b) not allowing its included as an additional reaction product and the
formation. As will be seen, allowing N 2 to form as a
product has a rather dramatic effect on the predicted
decomposition pressure. For calculations on MNO 3- Table II. Comparison of Stem's Calculated Decomposition
M 2 0 - M O H - H 2 0 equilibria, which were used to Pressures for LiNO3, NaNO3, and K N O 3 at 800~ and 50%
evaluate the reversibility of tritium dissolution and Decomposition
m
release, the activity of hydroxide reaction product Partial pressure (atmospheres)
(aMolO was determined as a function of water activ-
Material 0 2 NO 2 NO Total
ity (aH2o) at two representative temperatures. The
LiNO 3 3• -3 9• -5 3.0• -3 6.3 • -3
magnitude of the constant relating aMoH and aR~o
NaNO 3 9• -6 2• -8 1.2• -s 2.1• -5
is a measure of the relative stabilities of MOH (dis) KNO 3 4• 8 7• 5.0• 9.0• 10-8
and H 2 0 (dis). m
250 Adamson et al.
Table IlL Comparison of " C a s e a" Decomposition Pressures for Molten Li, Na, and K Nitrates
at 700 and 800~ (Upper and Lower P Limits)
total decomposition pressures ( -- Po2 + PN2 + PNo + Table IV. T e m p e r a t u r e D e p e n d e n c e of the " M a x i m u m "
PNo2) recalculated for each nitrate. In the absence of Decomposition Pressure of LiNO 3 (% Decomposition = 1.5 +_.1)
i
Table V. Calculated Values of the Constant B T in the Relation CO 2 and H20, and MHD-induced external polariza-
aMO H = BT(aH20) 1/2 for M = El, Na, and K
tion effects, could dramatically influence the corro-
T emperatu re (~ M = Li M = Na M = K sion rate.
600 196 3.6• -3 1.1 • -s Although the extant literature on corrosion by
800 5 x 104 14 0.16 LiNO3/LiNO2 molten salts is sparse, two related
effects are considered particularly relevant in assess-
ing its corrosion behavior:
spect to dissolution/evolution of water in terms of 1. the relatively low thermal stability of LiNO 3
the general equilibrium reaction: coupled with radiolytic decomposition will
lead to significantly higher oxygen activities
2MNO3 (1) + H20(dis ) than in mixed K, Na salts (i.e., decreased
"acidity," increased "basicity');
= 2MOH(dis) + N2(g ) + 5/2 O2(g ) 2. b u i l d u p of H 2 (T2) will decrease
"acidity"/increase "basicity" via the genera-
tion of L i O H / L i O T described in the previous
( M = L i , Na, o r K ) (11)
section (note that molten alkali metal hydrox-
Assuming the activities of 02 and N 2 to be fixed by ides can be particularly corrosive toward
the composition of air at NTP, and the nitrate is austenitic stainless steels(t9)).
essentially undissociated (aMNo3=I), we calculated From this brief survey we conclude that molten Li
values of the T-dependent constant B T in the expres- nitrate coolant will exhibit greater corrosivity toward
sion aMO H ~ BT(aI~20) 1/2 for each nitrate at 600~ structural steels than Na and K nitrates; however, at
and 800~ The results are presented in Table V. T < 750~ the resulting reduction in wall thickness
These results show clearly that dissolved LiOH is may fall well within current design allowances. Un-
considerably more stable than its Na and K analogs fortunately, more quantitative statements cannot be
(Li > Na > K), and that the chemically stable form made without the benefit of additional test data.
of Hz dissolved in liquid LiNOs is in fact LiOH
(dis). This appears to explain the previously noted
observation of poor H20 reversibility in LiNO3, (is) 5. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
and it certainly argues against use of the Li salt in
liquid NaNO3-KNO 3 mixtures to enhance tritium The foregoing assessment suggests that due to
breeding capability. The stability of LiOH relative to thermochemical limitations molten LiNO 3 or
its nitrate is so much greater than for the correspond- LiNO3-LiNO2 mixtures may not be suitable for ap-
ing Na or K salts, even LiNO 3 concentrations as low plication in current fusion breeder reactor designs.
as 1 mol% would not prevent preferential formation Although features such as stability and corrosivity
of LiOH (LiOT). It is also worth noting that the may be tolerable at temperatures currently consid-
stability of MOH (dis) relative to H20 (dis) increases ered too low for serious interest ( < 650~ say), the
with temperature. material's tendency to retain tritium is not signifi-
cantly improved at these temperatures. Specifically,
4.3. Corrosiveness of Molten LiNO3-LiNO 2 we reach the following conclusions:
Mixtures 9 with respect to decomposition to gaseous
reaction products in a reactor environment,
In a recent review of exreactor corrosion data LiNO 3/LiNO 2 will be considerably less sta-
for various Fe-base structural steels in contact with ble than its K and/or Na counterparts;
liquid Na and K nitrates, DeVan(18) concluded that 9 coupled thermal/radiolytic decomposition of
corrosion rates appeared acceptably low ( _<13/tm/yr LiNO3/LiNO 2 in a closed system is ex-
alloy conversion to adherent oxide) at temperatures pected to lead to the development of (02 +
up to 600~ However, he also indicated how subtle N2) pressures as high as 70 arm (7 MPa) at
interactions between salt "acidity" (as represented by 800~
the log inverse 0 2- ion concentration in the equi- 9 in the intense radiation field of a fusion
librium NO 3 + 2e = NO~- + 0 2. ), impurities such as reactor blanket, the LiNO3/LiNO2-O2-N2
252 Adamson et al.