Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1, 2013
Shaker M. Al-Jobori, Ali A. Fahad Al-Taii, Farid M. Mohammed and Marwan R. Abass*
ABSTRACT
The objective of the present study was to investigate the natural isotopes in soil of Salah Aldeen
Governorate, 200 km north Baghdad, Iraq and the possible contamination from 137Cs and depleted
uranium (DU). High-resolution gamma spectrometric system with a relative efficiency of 50% was
employed for the measurement of 232Th, 226Ra, 40K, and 137Cs activity in the soil samples. The ratio
235
U/238U was calculated to indicate the presence of DU and possible contamination. In general, all
values of the natural isotopes are within the range of normal expectation found in soils. Activity
concentration of 40K exhibited higher values in the range 200 to 400 Bq/kg although these values
seem lower than values reported in soils of other countries. Although the magnitudes of 137Cs
concentration were low as compared with natural isotopes, the range value was very wide. Based on
235
U/238U ratio, it is evident that the investigated soil samples were none contaminated with depleted
uranium.
Keywords: Soil, Natural Radioisotopes, 137Cs, Depleted Uranium.
and becomes irreversibly fixed to clay minerals over time soil samples were taken from different locations (Fig. 1).
(Absalom et al., 1995). Once 137Cs reaches the soil Table 1 presents the locations of soil samples. Each soil
surface, it is strongly and quickly adsorbed by the fine sample represents a cube of 90 cm x 90 cm and 5 cm
soil particles and is essentially nonexchangeable in most deep. The soil samples were then air dried and screened
environments (Ritchie, 2004). Therefore, there may be a through a 2.00 mm sieve.
risk for ecosystems, agro-systems and health.
The depleted uranium (DU) ammunitions were Measuring of radioactivity (gamma ray spectrometry):
heavily used in the southern region of Iraq during war High-resolution gamma spectrometric system with a
times of 1991 (Robicheau, 1999) and in many locations relative efficiency of 50% and a resolution of 2.2 keV at
during 2003 (Bem and Bou-Rabee, 2004). The concern the 1.17 and 1.33 MeV was employed for the
should be manifest not only at the southern region, but measurement of the 232Th, 226Ra, 235U, 40K, and 137Cs
also across the country where there have been huge activity in the soil samples. The efficiency of the detector
contaminated scraps moved from battlefields to other is defined as the ratio between the numbers of out pulses
places. to the number of incident γ-ray photons (Allen, 1981).
Soil is a valuable environmental monitoring medium
because it can accumulate contaminants that have been
introduced from many sources. Hence, soil sampling and
analysis evaluates long-term contamination trends and Where,
monitors environmental radionuclide inventories (DOE = efficiency of the Germanium detector.
1991). The objective of the present study is to monitor ƩN = total measured area under peak.
natural radioactive isotopes and possible contamination t = time of measurement.
from radioactive isotopes in soil of Salah Alden I = relative intensity of energy from radioactive source.
Governorate, Iraq.
For estimation of detector efficiency, Europium-152
MATERIALS AND METHODS standard source of multi energies (121.8 to 1409.1 keV)
was placed in Marinelli Beaker. The efficiency was 0.98
Study Site and Sampling of soils: for the energy 121.8 keV, 0.72 for the energy 444.6 keV,
The investigated area was at Salah Aldeen and 0.24 for the energy 1409.1 keV.
Governorate, 200 km north Baghdad, Iraq with This system was used for measuring energy spectrum
coordinates of 34o 32’ latitude and 43o 28’ longitude and of the emitted gamma rays in the energy range between
elevation of 129.5 m. Soils are arid and semi-arid, which 50 keV and 2000 keV. The gamma spectroscopy system
have low water content under natural conditions for the consists of a pure germanium (HPGe) detector connected
growth of crop. Farming is possible only if land is to a multi-channel analyzer through amplifier (Ministry
irrigated. The major source of irrigation water is the of Science and Technology, Baghdad, Iraq).
Tigris river. The physiographic units are Tigris Flood Energy calibration was accomplished using standard
Plain in the north part of the Governorate (e.g., Shirqat sources with known peaks energy. We used 40K with
and Baiji) with secondary gypsum to gypsiferous energy of 1460 keV, 60Co with energy of 1332-1173 keV,
alluvium and River Teraces in the south (e.g., Sammara) and 137Cs with energy of 661 keV (Fig. 2). There was a
(Buringh, 1960). Therefore, Soil conditions differ in linear relation between energy source and channel
different localities, due to diverse processes of soil position. For estimation background in working zone, the
formation in terms of clay content, type of dominated spectrum of γ-ray for empty Marnelly beaker was
clay mineral, and the content of gypsum. Accordingly, calculated (Muhammed et al., 2012). The following
the content of natural isotopes and the behavoir of equation was used to get an estimate of specific activity
deposited radionuclides will be different. of certain isotope:
Sampling of soils was carried out to cover different
locations of the Governorate including all towns and
districts starting from the north, Shirqat and Baiji down
Tikrit, and far in the south Balad and Al-Fares. Fifteen Where,
- 99 -
Natural and Contaminated … Shaker M. Al-Jobori, Ali A. Fahad Al-Taii, Farid M. Mohammed and Marwan R. Abass
Sp.A = specific activity. Eff = percent of system efficiency for a specified energy.
CR = count rate (counts/s). m = soil mass (1 kg)
BG = background. The measurement time for each soil sample was
I = percent of energy intensity. 7200s.
I = the absolute transition probability of γ- decay
- 100 -
Dirasat, Pure Sciences, Volume 39, No. 1, 2013
Fig. 2. Spectrum of the 40K, 60Co, and 137Cs for energy calibration system of measurement.
Estimation of the ratio 235U/238U in soil: isotopes at 911 keV was equivalent to specific activity for
232
In the absence of DU in soil samples (natural non- Th (Eisenbud and Gesell, 1997). Specific activity of
contaminated soil), the ratio of 235U/238U (UR) will be the natural isotopes (228Ac, 235U, 226Ra, and 40K) and 137Cs
(UNEP, 2000): for the 15 locations at Salah Al-Deen Governorate is
presented in Table 2. Statistical parameters (mean,
(0.7200%/99.2745%) = 0.00725 maximum, and minimum) for the six isotopes are also
given. The mean values of specific activity were 15.83
However, in a mixture of natural U and DU with DU (228Ac), 45.67 (235U), 56.28 (226Ra), 323.61 (40K), and
defined as 235U = 0.35%, the ratio of 235U/238U was 4.43 (137Cs) Bq/kg. The range values (maximum –
calculated using the following Eq. (UNEP, 2000), minimum) were low for 228Ac increased for both 235U and
226
Ra and reached the highest for 40K. In general, all
(3) values of the natural isotopes are within the range of
normal expectation found in soils. Karadeniz and Yaprak
where, (2011) reported close values in forest soils of West
UR = 235U/238U Anatolia in the range 14-51 for 226Ra, 17-79 for 232Th,
x = the part of DU in soil sample in mg. and 308-879 Bq/kg for 40K. Therefore, uranium as a
Eq.1 was used to calculate UR in soil samples based on natural component of the human environment is likely to
the followings: be present in trace amounts in environmental components
x is the ratio of DU in mg/238U in mg, and (Brenda, 2004). It occurs in soils in typical concentrations
238
U in mg estimated from 226Ra activity divided of a few parts per million and decays into other
by 12.4 (to convert radioactivity in Bq to mass in mg), radioactive elements (Stegnar, and Benedik, 2001). Also,
and uranium occurs together with its radioactive decay
DU in mg equals to: radioactivity of 238U for the products in numerous minerals such as pitchblende,
soil sample - reading of background reference sample. uraninite or carnotite and also found in higher
The reference sample is undisturbed soil sample taken concentrations 50–300 mg/kg (ppm) in phosphate rocks,
from uncontaminated area. lignite or monazite sands (UN SCEAR 2000). On the
other hand, the reported values for 40K are much less than
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION values reported by researchers worldwide. In this respect,
Statistical parameters of isotopes specific activity: Holmgen et al. (1993) reported values nearly 5474 Bq/kg
The specific activity for 226Ra isotopes at 182 keV for 40K in soil of the USA and this value is not high
was equivalent to specific activity of 238U and for 228Ac enough to be hazardous.
- 101 -
Natural and Contaminated … Shaker M. Al-Jobori, Ali A. Fahad Al-Taii, Farid M. Mohammed and Marwan R. Abass
Although the magnitudes of 137Cs concentration are to 80 S. These values are typically compared to baseline
low as compared with natural isotopes, the range value estimates of 137Cs concentrations world-wide. Much
was very high (Table 2). For instance, the specific higher values on 137Cs in the range 20-82 Bq/kg were
activity in soil of Baije City (S1) was 12.2 decreased to reported by Karadeniz and Yaprak (2011) in forest soils
1.04 Bq/kg in soil of Sherkat City (S3). Aslani et al., of West Anatolia, Turkey 16 years after the Chernobyl
(2003) reported close values in the range 2.81-20.75 accident.
Bq/kg for 137Cs in soils of Buyuk Menderes basin in Spectral analysis of gamma radiation measured by
Turkey in 1997-1998. Since the distribution of fallout HPGe detector for only two selected soil samples are
137
Cs generated from 1960s nuclear tests and Chernobyl given in Fig. 3 (Sample 5, Al Quads army from Tikrit and
accident in 1986 is assumed to be uniform on soil surface, Sample 15, Al Dejail city near midway). In general,
the variability of radioactivity concentration observed in nearly the same spectrum was observed for the
soil samples is affected by many site specific factors investigated 15 soil samples. The difference was in
including soil type, rainfall, drainage, terrain, vegetation magnitude of energy peaks for 214Pa, 137Cs, and 40K. The
and local activities and conditions. Furthermore, local spectrum given is a natural-gamma energy spectrum,
meteorological conditions can have significant impact on which is caused by the decay of uranium, thorium, and
the fallout deposition and transport in a given area. potassium-40, along with anthropogenic radioactive
However, these values are still within the acceptable isotopes 137Cs. Natural gamma rays are emitted by
limit and no contamination had occurred. In this regards, isotopes that are the natural products (daughter products)
Moscovitch et al. (1994) reported values between 2.4 to of the uranium decay series, the thorium decay series, and
35 Bq/kg for the 0-5 cm depth as an estimates of potential potassium-40 (Pritchard, 2004).
137
Cs concentration in soils by latitude from 0 to 80 N and
- 102 -
Dirasat, Pure Sciences, Volume 39, No. 1, 2013
Fig. 3. Gamma spectral analysis of soil samples for Site 5(S5) and Site 15 (S15).
Pattern of activity concentration of natural isotopes (Al Door city games town) and Site 8 (Ragah Samara
for Sites: city). With the exception of Sites 2 and 4, which showed
Specific activity of natural isotopes 228Ac, 226Ra, 235U, the lowest specific activity (less than 30 Bq/kg), values of
and 40K in soils of the 15 Sites, Salah Aldeen 226
Ra for most Sites, were nearly 60 Bq/kg. Unlike 228Ac
Governorate is presented in Figure 4. Magnitudes of and 226Ra, the activity concentration of 235U was
activity concentration were different with the lowest for fluctuated among Sites with Sites 6, 7, and 8 exhibited
228
Ac and the highest for 40K. Since 228Ac and 226Ra are the highest values. On the other hand, activity
decay daughters products, the specific activity of the concentration of 40K exhibited higher values in the range
former is equivalent to 232Th and the later to 238U (Knoll, 209.8 to 403.7 Bq/kg although these values seem lower
1979). For specific activity of 228Ac, values fluctuated than values reported in soils of other countries (Holmgen
within 10.7 to 20.5 Bq/kg soil with the minimum in Site 5 et al., 1993; Karadeniz and Yaprak, 2011).
(Al Quads army from Tikrit) and the maximum in Site 7
- 103 -
Natural and Contaminated … Shaker M. Al-Jobori, Ali A. Fahad Al-Taii, Farid M. Mohammed and Marwan R. Abass
Activity concentration of 137Cs behavior may be explained on the basis that the rate of
Specific activity of 137Cs for the 15 Sites is given in deposition of fallout radionuclides would decrease toward
Figure 5. Although the magnitude of values was low the south.
(nearly 1 to 12 Bq/kg soil), the variation among Sites was
high. That stems from the fact that 137Cs radionuclides Ratio of 235U/238U (UR) in soil samples
have been introduced to the environment (land surface) Table 3 presents values of the ratio UR in the 15 soil
mainly after the Chenobyl accident and the expected samples. The values ranged from 0.00662 to 0.00722
change in soil due to human activities was behind the with most samples exhibited values close to the highest
great variation in 137Cs concentration. The uniform ratio (no contamination with DU). It is indicated that with
distribution of 137Cs on soil surface is expected probably zero concentration of DU in sample, the UR reaches
few years after deposition. However, the long time past 0.00720 and 1/UR equals to 139 (UNEP, 2000). Also, the
1986 Chernoby accident would change pattern of 137Cs presence of 0.1 mg DU in soil resulted in UR of 0.00688
redistribution in surface soil samples. and 1/UR of 145. However, most samples given in Table
Based on the slope of regression line relationg the 3 were greater than the ratio 0.00688 and corresponding
activity concentration of 137Cs in Bq/kg to Sites location to 1/UR less than 145. Therefore, based on these data, it
starting from north, it is observed a slight decrease in the is evident that the investigated soil samples were none
concentration toward samples of the south (Fig. 5). This contaminated with depleted uranium.
- 104 -
Dirasat, Pure Sciences, Volume 39, No. 1, 2013
Fig. 4. Activity concentration of the natural isotopes 228Ac, 226Ra, 235U, and 40K in soil samples taken from 15
Sites at Salah Aldeen Governorate.
- 105 -
Natural and Contaminated … Shaker M. Al-Jobori, Ali A. Fahad Al-Taii, Farid M. Mohammed and Marwan R. Abass
Fig. 5. Activity concentration of 137Cs for the 15 Sites and the regression line of those concentrations
- 106 -
Dirasat, Pure Sciences, Volume 39, No. 1, 2013
in Salah Alden Governorate. Australian Journal of Basic Robicheau, D. 1999. The next testing site for Depleted
and Applied Sciences 5: 1822-1829, 2011. ISSN 1991- Uranium weaponry. In Depleted Uranium: A post-war
8178. disaster for environment and health. Laka Foundation.
NS, National Safety Council. 2005. Understanding http://rimbaud.freeserve.co.uk/depleted.htm.
Radiation in Our World. 1025 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Stegnar, P. and Benedik, L. 2001. Depleted uranium in the
Suite 1200, Washington, DC 20036, 202/293-2270, environment – an issue of concern? Archive of Oncology,
http://www.nsc.org/issues/radisafe.htm. 9:251-255.
Pritchard. M. 2004. Health Risks of Depleted Uranium: An UN SCEAR, United Nations Scientific Committee Effect
Independent Review of the Scientific Literature. Atomic Radiation. 2000. Sources and Effects of Ionizing
Students of Science for Peace, University of Toronto. radiation. Report to the General Assembly, with
Ritchie, J., McCarty, G., Venteris, E. 2004. Cesium-137, scientific annexes.
soil, and soil organic carbon redistribution on the UNEP, United Nation Environmental Protection. 2000.
landscape. the 2nd Research Coordination Meeting of the Depleted Uranium in Kosovo, Post-Conflict
IAEA/FAO Co-ordination Research Project, Vienna, Environmental Assessment. United Nation Environment
Austria. Programme. 5-19.
*شاكر محمود الجبوري وعلي عبد فهد الطائي وفريد مجيد محمد ومروان رشيد عباس
ملخـص
العراق واحتمال التلوث، كم شمال بغداد022 ،تهدف الدراسة الحالية الى البحث في النظائر الطبيعية في تربة صالح الدين
و030- لقياس الثوريوم%02 استخدمت منظومة أشعة كاما ذات قدرة تحليل عالية مع كفاءة نسبية.731-من السيزيوم
لإلشارة الى032-اليورانيوم/030- حسبت نسبة اليورانيوم. في عينات التربة731- والسزيوم02- والبوتاسيوم002-الراديوم
. وعلى العموم كانت جميع قيم النظائر الطبيعية ضمن المدى الطبيعي المتوقع في الترب.وجود التلوث باليورانيوم المنضب
رغم أن هذه القيم تقل عن القيم،كغم/ بكريل022-022 قيما عالية ضمن المدى02-أظهر النشاط اإلشعاعي للبوتاسيوم
إال، كانت واطئة مقارنة بالنظائر الطبيعية731- وبالرغم من أن مقادير تركيز السيزيوم.المنشورة عن الترب في أقطار أخرى
فإن من المؤكد أن عينات التربة لم،032-اليورانيوم/030- إستنادا الى قيم النسبة اليورانيوم.أن المدى كان عاليا بين العينات
.تكن ملوثة باليورانيوم المنضب
. اليورانيوم المنضب،731- السيزيوم، النشاط اإلنشعاعي الطبيعي، التربة:الكلمات الدالة
________________________________________________
تاريخ استالم. العراق، تكريت، جامعة تكريت، كلية العلوم، العراق؛ وقسم الفيزياء، بغداد، الكاظمية،* كلية مدينة العلم الجامعية
.0273/0/01 وتاريخ قبوله0270/9/00 البحث
- 107 -