Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
978-1-4244-2740-6/08/$25.00 © 2008 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
components. [4, 6] Since the 01005 components have been 01005 test vehicle (TV). TV is an 8×8 laminated SiP module,
introduced but it is still very little, publicly available details composed of 5×6×2 matrix. A fully populated test vehicle
on assembling small components and solder stencil printing contains 2,160 components for 01005. All 01005 component
techniques. Previous experience and earlier studies have pads in this design were fixed at 0.175mm(L) × 0.175mm(W)
shown that electroform stencils with a lower thickness (3mil), × 0.150mm(S), and all solder pads are solder mask defined
and finer powder size (Type-4 or 5) could potentially pad on three sides.(See Figure 3) The components used in this
outperform the described stencil. [1-2], [7-8], [10-11] experiment were 01005, 0201 and 0402 sizes and all provided
However, in actual manufacturing applications, electroform by Murata Co. The component was fed in tape and reel
stencils are considerably more expansive [9] and longer packaging.
processing times to fabricate than conventional laser-cut
stencils. Moreover, electroform stencil technology thus far are
non-standard process in the normal wireless module lines of
high-volume manufacturing (HVM). Additional tools such as
special squeegee blade for using electroform stencils [10] and
standard process changes are required for achieving good
release qualities. On the other hand the laser-cutting has the
advantage of high-flexibility, high-speed, and is able to cut
very small apertures, but the problem with conventional laser-
cutting is poor aperture quality. It needs a post-treatment to
clean the stencil and remove burrs on the backside. The Figure 2. Photograph of 01005 Test Vehicle.
electro-polishing are used to further smooth surface walls and
improve solder paste release. [11] In the electro-polishing, in L
which the solutions used commonly acide, anodic currents or
potentials lead to dissolution and passivation of the metal,
promoting the leveling of the metal surface. In the literature, W
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Table 1. Laser-Cut Stencil Fabrication Variables.
Laser Cutting Machine LPKF (Micro Cutting)
Laser-Beam Size 20mm
Laser Type YAG
E/P Solution Phosphoric Acid: 95wt%
Sulphuric Acid: 5wt%
Figure 4. Thermal reflow profile.
E/P Time 0, 5, 8, 15 and 20sec
Stencil Mesh Tension 0.55mm – 0.70mm
Experiment Design
Stencil Thickness 3mil(80um) To determine the best condition of electro-polishing for
enhanced laser-cut stencil fabrications, test stainless steel
A commercially available solder pastes supplied from sheets were designed with five levels of times; 0, 5, 8, 15 and
Alpha Metal Co., water-soluble (WS609 flux), 95Sn/5Sb 20s in this experiments. A stencil was designed based on the
solder paste was used throughout the study. The metal content results from this experiment. Only one electro-polishing time
is 90% and the solder melting point was proximately was selected for the enhanced laser-cut stencil fabrication.
232~240°C as specified in the supplier’s specification. Two variants of stencil types (electroform stencil and
Since the solder paste is stored at 4°C it has to be brought enhanced laser-cut stencil) are evaluated for the paste release
up to room temperature before being used in the screen printer performance comparison purposes when the aperture volumes
for the experiments. Screen printing was carried out using to be deposited are kept constant. The variable held constant
Speedline MPM AP Excel printer with metal squeegees are stencil thickness (3mil), stencil design (1:1 opening), paste
angles at 60° were fitted to the printer. The stencil was type (type-3 and type-4 particle sizes) and equipments used.
cleaned before use. A stencil is mounted on the printer frame.
A stencil is placed on the PCB substrate, and after vision Results and Discussion
alignment, a squeegee travels at a certain pressure and speed Results of the different evaluation steps are described in
to push the solder paste through the stencil apertures. The the following section. The data gathered from the
following screen printing parameters were used for all stencil experimentation was arranged and the data was analyzed
printing: Print speed = 8mm/sec, squeegee type = metal using JMP ® data statistical software.
blades, print force = 5.3, balance = 50:50 and print gap = 0(on
contact). The solder deposited PCB substrate was inspected in Effect of Electro-Polishing on Aperture Quality
a microscope equipped with a digital camera and documented In this study, initially the effect of electro-polishing times
photographically. The next step in the assembly process is the on the aperture wall quality of the surface polish was
component pick and place. The pick and place machine from investigated. For such, electro-polishing time was varied: 0, 5,
Siemens HS60 was used and programming was carried out 8, 15 and 20sec. As soon as each electro-polished stencil
with same mounting speeds and forces. Pick-up nozzle is 906 surface was obtained, its polish quality was evaluated by
and it is currently in used for 0201 components. visual inspection. Figure 5 - (a) and (b) shows the SEM
All solder paste reflow was performed in a Heller 1800 images of laser-cut stencil’s aperture wall with different
convection oven. The reflow system contained 8 heating and electro-polishing times, and electroform stencil’s aperture
1 cooling zone. The populated PCB substrates were reflowed wall for comparison purpose. No electro-polished aperture
under nitrogen atmosphere via a Heller convection reflow shows the effects of poor aperture quality as a result of the
oven. The nitrogen environment was controlled at less than laser-cutting process. ((a)-①, (b)-①) From the Figure 5 - ②,
400 oxygen ppm level. Peak temperature is 251°C for 38.8 ③, ④, and ⑤ show the improved aperture quality and an
seconds at above 232°C of solder melting point and the belt electro-polished aperture significantly has smoother surfaces
speed is 16 inch/minutes. Figure 4 is the thermal profile that than no electro-polished aperture (0sec). The best quality of
was used to reflow all boards assembled during the aperture was achieved for electro-polishing times of 8sec and
experiments. The final process step was deflux cleaning and a its polish quality was improved with increasing electro-
Trek machine was employed for cleaning of flux residues. All polishing times in general. But, for electro-polishing times of
boards were visually inspected after stencil printing, after pick 15 and 20sec, the good aperture quality could not be realized
and place, and after reflow processes. Component shear test and the corner inside of aperture was more ragged than times
was performed using a Dage-series 4000 shear tester. of 8sec. It should be pointed out that suitable processing time
will improve the surface quality but the excessive processing
time will lead to quite lower surface quality. This result
therefore that it is desirable to consider process efficiency for
high surface quality. Up to now, no optimization of the
electro-polishing parameters for many laser-cut stencil
manufacturing has been made in industry.
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
(a)
Laser-Cut Electroform
① 0sec ② 5sec ③8sec ④15sec ⑤20sec (Control)
(b)
Laser-Cut Electroform
① 0sec ② 5sec ③8sec ④15sec ⑤20sec (Control)
Figure 5. SEM images of laser-cut apertures with different electro-polishing times. (a) Top view at 410X, (b) Angled view
at 410X.
However, aperture quality has a direct influence on paste improved surface quality of aperture wall by electro-
release and because of this, electro-polishing process is polishing process.
necessary to achieve the smoother surface. In addition, the (a) (b)
laser-cut aperture size must be adjusted to the electro-
polishing employed since the aperture size will change
during the processing. [7] For this study, we did not measure
the each aperture size after electro-polishing processing at
this moment.
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Secondly, the repeat printing experiment was performed different paste types for enhanced laser-cut stencil. Similar
on 30 boards for each of the stencil. The objective of this print deposition results were observed as when electroform
experiment is to determine the print frequency and stencil stencil was used. However, enhanced laser-cut stencil
cleaning interval for each stencil types. Figure 8 and Figure 9 showed better paste coverage than the electroform stencil
shows paste thickness by repeat printing without wiping for used for a type-4 paste.
the 0402, 0201, and 01005 components for each of the
stencils. From the graphs, it is seen that there was no (a)
significant drop in repeat printing for both electroform and
laser-cut stencils. However, the paste thickness and print ① Type-3 Paste ② Type-4 Paste
stability for enhanced laser-cut stencil is better than
electroform stencil. Visual inspection was performed on 7
boards of the 30 boards printed for each of the stencils. The
1st, 5th, 10th, 15th, 20th, 25th, and 30th print are used in the
visual inspection test. There is no significant difference in
visual inspection between electroform and enhanced laser-cut
stencils.
(b)
① Type-3 Paste ② Type-4 Paste
Figure 9. Effect of repeat printing without wiping for After all boards had completed the reflow soldering,
enhanced laser-cut stencil. Type-4 paste and 3mil thick component shear test was performed for each of solder types.
stencil. Ten components for each type (01005, 0201 and 0402 sizes)
on each boards were sheared for each experimental trials. For
fracture modes, most of the samples fractured at the solder
Effect of Solder Paste Powder Size
joint as shown in Figure 11. The result of shear test is shown
Figure 10-(a) shows some representative photographs from in Figure 12. A type-3 paste provided an average shear forces
solder deposition on 01005 pads with different paste types of 290gf and 255gf for electroform and enhanced laser-cut
for electroform stencil. Paste depositions on pads are stencils respectively. It was a lower shear performance than
significantly better for a type-4 paste compare to a type-3 type-4 paste which conform the notion that finer paste sizes
pastes. When a type-3 paste was used, several insufficient are required for tiny 01005 components. It is clear from the
solder pastes in pad deposited were observed and paste print images that a type-4 paste gives a more consistent,
release was worse for both electroform and enhanced laser- higher volume print than type-3 paste. However, it is
cut stencils. (See Figure 10 (a) - ①) This is in agreement interesting to note that enhanced laser-cut stencil has lower
with some article published on 01005 solder printing studies. shear force than electroform stencil, but highest paste
[2, 8] A type-4 paste has smaller particle size which will give thickness for a type-4 paste as Figure 7. From the graph,
better paste release performance, and will aid in depositing enhance laser-cut stencil and type-4 paste combinations had
more solder volume in pads. Figure 10-(b) show the only average shear force of 239gf even though it had average
photographs from solder deposition on 01005 pads with
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
relative paste thickness of 0.105mm. On the other hand the
electroform stencil had average shear force of 319gf and
average paste thickness of 0.095mm for 01005 components.
(a) (b)
Figure 12. Shear force comparisons: Type-3 vs. Type-4
pastes and Electroform vs. Laser-cut stencils.
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
increased, durable long stencil life, good manufacturability,
fast delivery time and more cost reduction opportunities.
Acknowledgements
All work was performed at ASE Korea Inc. The authors
would like to thanks their colleagues and management team
at the Packaging Engineering Team of ASE Korea Inc.
References
1. Paul N. Houston. et al, “Processing Strategies for High
Speed 0201 Implementation”, IEMT2002, Proc 27th
Annual IEEE/SEMI International, San Jose, CA, June.
2002, pp. 166-172
2. Roy Jarvina. et al, “01005 SMT Component Assembly
for Wireless SiP Modules”, Proc 50th Electronic
Components and Technology Conf, Orlando, FL, May.
2005, pp. 1502-1505
3. T. A. Nguty. et al, “Understating the Process Window
for Printing Lead-Free Solder Pastes”, Proc 50th
Electronic Components and Technology Conf, Las
Vegas, NV, May. 2000, pp. 1426-1434
4. W. Steplewski. et al, “Stencil Design for Lead-Free
Reflow Process” Proc 30th International Spring Seminar
on Electronics technology, Cluj-Napoca, Romania,
2007, pp. 330-334
5. Leila J. Ladani. et al, “Effect of Selected Process
Parameters on Durability and Defects in Surface-Mount
Assemblies for Portable Electronics”, IEEE Trans-
CPMT, Vol. 31, No. 1(2008), pp. 51-60
6. Joe Belmonte. et al, “Consideration in the Development
of the 01005 Component Assembly Process”, Proc
SMTA International Conf, Chicago, IL, Sept. 2005
7. William E. Coleman, “Stencil Print Performance
Studies”, Proc SMTA International Conf, Chicago, IL,
Sept. 2005, pp. 94-101
8. Vatsal Shah. et al, “Process Development for 01005
Lead-free Passive Assembly; Stencil Printing”, Proc
APEX’07, Los Angeles, CA, Feb. 2007
9. Fredrik Mattsson. et al, “Design and Assembly of 01005
Passives Using Pb-free Solder”, Circuit Assembly, May.
2005
10. Michael R. Burgess. et al, “Electroformed vs. Laser-cut:
A Stencil Performance Study”, SMT Magazine, June.
2007
11. William E. Coleman. et al, “Choosing a Stencil”, SMT
Magazine, July. 2006
12. Satyanarayan Iyer. et al, “Implementing 0201s on High-
Density Lead-Free Memory Modules”, IEEE Trans-
CPMT, Vol. 31, No. 1(2008), pp. 41-50
13. Harry Trip, “The persistent Problem of Tombstoning”,
Circuit Assembly, June. 2003, pp.20-22
2008 International Conference on Electronic Packaging Technology & High Density Packaging (ICEPT-HDP 2008)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE DE SAO PAULO. Downloaded on October 6, 2009 at 13:15 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.