The Crisis of Public Transport in India - Overwhelming Needs But L

ʾF$SJTJTPG1VCMJD5SBOTQPSUJO*OEJB
/PUFʾJTBSUJDMFPSJHJOBMMZBQQFBSFEJO7PMVNF /VNCFS#FDBVTFPGQSJOUJOH
JSSFHVMBSJUJFTJOUIBUJTTVF XFBSFSFQSJOUJOHJU0VSBQPMPHJFTUPUIFBVUIPS
4HE #RISIS OF 0UBLIC 4RANSPORT

IN )NDIA /VERWHELMING .EEDS
BUT ,IMITED 2ESOURCES
+PIO1VDIFSBOE/JTIB,PSBUUZTXBSPPQBN 3VUHFST6OJWFSTJUZ
/FFOV*UUZFSBI *OEJBO3BJMXBZT $IFOOBJ *OEJB
!BSTRACT
ʾFSBQJEHSPXUIPG*OEJBTVSCBOQPQVMBUJPOIBTQVUFOPSNPVTTUSBJOTPOBMMUSBOT
QPSUTZTUFNT#VSHFPOJOHUSBWFMEFNBOEGBSFYDFFETUIFMJNJUFETVQQMZPGUSBOTQPSU
JOGSBTUSVDUVSFBOETFSWJDFT1VCMJDUSBOTQPSU JOQBSUJDVMBS IBTCFFODPNQMFUFMZPWFS
XIFMNFE.PTUCVTBOEUSBJOTFSWJDFTBSFPWFSDSPXEFE VOEFQFOEBCMF TMPX JODPOWF
OJFOU VODPPSEJOBUFE BOEEBOHFSPVT.PSFPWFS UIFQVCMJDPXOFSTIJQBOEPQFSBUJPO
PGNPTUQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFTIBTHSFBUMZSFEVDFEQSPEVDUJWJUZBOEJOnBUFEDPTUT
*OEJBT DJUJFT EFTQFSBUFMZ OFFE JNQSPWFE BOE FYQBOEFE QVCMJD USBOTQPSU TFSWJDF
6OGPSUVOBUFMZ NFBHFS HPWFSONFOU mOBODJBM BTTJTUBODF BOE UIF DPNQMFUF MBDL PG
BOZTVQQPSUJWFQPMJDJFT TVDIBTUSBċDQSJPSJUZGPSCVTFT QMBDFQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUJOBO
BMNPTUJNQPTTJCMFTJUVBUJPO
)NTRODUCTION
1VCMJDUSBOTQPSUGBDFTTFWFSFQSPCMFNTJOBMNPTUBMMDPVOUSJFTPGUIFEFWFMPQJOH
XPSME BMUIPVHIUIFTJUVBUJPOWBSJFTGSPNPOFDPVOUSZUPBOPUIFS BOEFWFOGSPN

+PVSOBMPG1VCMJD5SBOTQPSUBUJPO 7PM /P
POF DJUZ UP BOPUIFS 7BTDPODFMMPT 1FSIBQT NPTU JNQPSUBOU UIF MBDL PG
mOBODJBMSFTPVSDFTQSFWFOUTOFDFTTBSZJOWFTUNFOUTJONBJOUBJOJOHBOEVQHSBEJOH
FYJTUJOH CVT BOE SBJM TZTUFNT BOE CVJMEJOH OFX POFT -JLFXJTF NBOZ BEWBODFE
UFDIOPMPHJFTMPOHBWBJMBCMFJO8FTUFSO&VSPQFBSFTJNQMZOPUBĊPSEBCMFJONPTU
EFWFMPQJOH DPVOUSJFT 1VCMJD USBOTQPSU TZTUFNT JO UIF ʾJSE 8PSME BSF QMBHVFE
CZDISPOJDDPSSVQUJPOBOEJOFċDJFODZ PWFSDSPXEFEBOEVOEFQFOEBCMFTFSWJDF
DPOHFTUFESPBEXBZTUIBUTMPXEPXOCVTFT BOEBOPQFSBUJOHFOWJSPONFOUUIBUJT
PGUFODIBPUJDBOEDPNQMFUFMZVODPPSEJOBUFE
ʾPTFQSPCMFNTPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUPDDVSXJUIJOUIFCSPBEFSDPOUFYUPGEBVOUJOH
VSCBOUSBOTQPSUQSPCMFNTJOHFOFSBM"JSQPMMVUJPO OPJTF DPOHFTUJPO BOEUSBċD
GBUBMJUZMFWFMTBSFPGUFONVDINPSFTFWFSFUIBOUIPTFPGEFWFMPQFEDPVOUSJFT0OF
NJHIUFYQFDUUIFNVDIMPXFSJODPNFTJOEFWFMPQJOHDPVOUSJFTUPBTTVSFBIVHF
QPUFOUJBMNBSLFUPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUSJEFST*OGBDU NBOZDJUZSFTJEFOUTBSFTPQPPS
UIBUUIFZDBOOPUBĊPSEFWFOMPXGBSFT BOESPVUFTBSFOPUEFTJHOFEUPTFSWFUIF
QPPSBUBOZSBUFʾVT UIFQPPSJOEFWFMPQJOHDPVOUSJFTTVĊFSFWFONPSFUIBO
UIPTFJOUIF8FTUFSO8PSMEGSPNMPXMFWFMTPGNPCJMJUZBOEBDDFTTJCJMJUZ FTQFDJBMMZ
UPKPCT
*ONBOZSFTQFDUT UIFTJUVBUJPOJO*OEJBJTUZQJDBMPGPUIFSEFWFMPQJOHDPVOUSJFTʾF
NPTUJNQPSUBOUDPNNPOBMJUZJT*OEJBTMPXQFSDBQJUBJODPNFPOMZ64 JO
MFTTUIBOBUFOUIPGUIFBWFSBHFJODPNFTPGDPVOUSJFTJO/PSUI"NFSJDBBOE
8FTUFSO&VSPQF $FOUSBM*OUFMMJHFODF"HFODZ 8JUIQFSDFOUPGJUTVSCBO
QPQVMBUJPOMJWJOHJOQPWFSUZ *OEJB IBT CFFO GPSDFE UP LFFQ JUT QVCMJD USBOTQPSU
GBSFTFYUSFNFMZMPXʾBUIBTTIBSQMZSFTUSJDUFEUIFPQFSBUJOHSFWFOVFTPGBMMQVC
MJDUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNT NBLJOHJUEJċDVMUUPBĊPSEFWFOSPVUJOFNBJOUFOBODFBOE
WFIJDMFSFQMBDFNFOU MFUBMPOFTZTUFNNPEFSOJ[BUJPOBOEFYQBOTJPO
1PWFSUZJTOPUPOMZBQSPCMFNBUUIFJOEJWJEVBMMFWFM CVUBMTPJOUIFQVCMJDTFD
UPS XJUIDJUJFTBOEUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNTEFTQFSBUFMZMBDLJOHUIFOFDFTTBSZmOBODJBM
SFTPVSDFT GPS JOWFTUNFOU JO JOGSBTUSVDUVSF WFIJDMFT OFX UFDIOPMPHJFT BOE GBSF
TVCTJEJFTʾFmOBODJBMQSPCMFNTTUFNNJOHGSPN*OEJBTMPXQFSDBQJUBJODPNFBSF
QSPCBCMZUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOUDIBMMFOHFTGBDJOH*OEJBOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU CVUUIFSF
BSFNBOZPUIFSTBTXFMMJOFċDJFODZ SPBEXBZDPOHFTUJPO USBċDBDDJEFOUT MBDLPG
QMBOOJOH PWFSDSPXEJOH OPJTF BOEUPUBMMBDLPGDPPSEJOBUJPOPGBOZLJOE

4RENDS IN 0OPULATION AND ,AND 5SE

ʾF SBQJE HSPXUI PG *OEJBT VSCBO QPQVMBUJPOBT JO PUIFS EFWFMPQJOH DPVO
USJFTIBT HFOFSBUFE BO FOPSNPVT OFFE GPS FċDJFOU QVCMJD USBOTQPSU TFSWJDFT
UP DBSSZ IJHI WPMVNFT PG QBTTFOHFST UISPVHI EFOTF DPOHFTUFE VSCBO BSFBT #Z
PWFS NJMMJPO *OEJBOT MJWFE JO DJUJFT NPSF UIBO JO BMM /PSUI "NFSJDBO
DJUJFTDPNCJOFE 0ċDFPGUIF3FHJTUSBS(FOFSBMPG*OEJB ʾFSFIBTCFFO
FTQFDJBMMZ SBQJE HSPXUI PG UIF WFSZ MBSHFTU NFUSPQPMJUBO BSFBT TVDI BT .VNCBJ
#PNCBZ ,PMLBUB $BMDVUUB BOE%FMIJ XIJDIOPXFYDFFENJMMJPOSFTJEFOUT
FBDI$IFOOBJ .BESBT )ZEFSBCBE "INFEBCBE BOE#BOHBMPSFFBDIIBWFNPSF
UIBONJMMJPOSFTJEFOUT"OENFUSPQPMJUBOBSFBTIBWFQPQVMBUJPOTFYDFFEJOH
NJMMJPO BMNPTUUXJDFBTNBOZBTJO4JODFMBSHFDJUJFTBSFGBSNPSFEFQFOEFOU
POQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUUIBOTNBMMDJUJFT UIFOFFEGPSQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFTIBT
JODSFBTFEGBTUFSUIBOPWFSBMMQPQVMBUJPOHSPXUI
.PSFPWFS UIF MBDL PG FĊFDUJWF QMBOOJOH BOE MBOEVTF DPOUSPMT IBT SFTVMUFE JO
SBNQBOUTQSBXMFEEFWFMPQNFOUFYUFOEJOHSBQJEMZJOBMMEJSFDUJPOT GBSCFZPOEPME
DJUZCPVOEBSJFTJOUPUIFEJTUBOUDPVOUSZTJEFʾBUBMTPIBTHSFBUMZJODSFBTFEUIF
OVNCFSBOEMFOHUIPGUSJQTGPSNPTU*OEJBOT JODMVEJOHUIPTFCZQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU
.PTUQVCMJDQPMJDJFTJO*OEJBBDUVBMMZFODPVSBHFTQSBXM*OBOFYQMJDJUBUUFNQUUP
EFDPOHFTU DJUZ DFOUFST HPWFSONFOU SFHVMBUJPOT MJNJU UIF SBUJP PG nPPS BSFBT UP
MBOEBSFBTGPSCVJMEJOHTJOUIFDFOUFS BOEUIVTSFTUSJDUUIFIFJHIUTPGCVJMEJOHT
BOEEFOTJUZPGEFWFMPQNFOUJOUIFDFOUFS'PSFYBNQMF UIFTPDBMMFEinPPSTQBDF
JOEFYwJOTBNQMFEDJUZDFOUFSTJO*OEJBXBTPOMZ DPNQBSFEUPJOEJDFTSBOHJOH
GSPNUPJOPUIFS"TJBODJUZDFOUFST #FSUBVE1BEBNBOE4JOHI
#ZDPOUSBTU HPWFSONFOUSFHVMBUJPOTQFSNJUIJHIFSnPPSTQBDFMBOEBSFBSBUJPTJO
TVCVSCBOEFWFMPQNFOUT ZFUNPSFJOEVDFNFOUGPSmSNTUPEFDFOUSBMJ[F*OEFFE
MPDBMHPWFSONFOUTFWFOBEWFSUJTFUIFMFTTTUSJOHFOUSFHVMBUJPOTJOUIFTVCVSCTUP
QSPNPUFNPSFEFWFMPQNFOUUIFSF4VDIMBOEVTFQPMJDJFTPCWJPVTMZEJTDPVSBHF
EFWFMPQNFOUJOUIFDFOUFSBOEGPSDFCPUImSNTBOESFTJEFODFTUPTFFLMPDBUJPOT
POUIFTVCVSCBOGSJOHF.PSFPWFS MPDBMHPWFSONFOUTIBWFQFSNJUUFETDBUUFSFE
DPNNFSDJBMBOESFTJEFOUJBMEFWFMPQNFOUJOPVUMZJOHBSFBTXJUIPVUUIFOFDFTTBSZ
JOGSBTUSVDUVSFTVDIBTSPBET VUJMJUJFT IPTQJUBMT TIPQQJOH BOETDIPPMTʾBUHFOFS
BUFTMPOHUSJQTCFUXFFOSFTJEFODFTBOEBMNPTUBMMPUIFSUSJQEFTUJOBUJPOT
+VTU BT JO /PSUI "NFSJDB NPTU OFX DPNNFSDJBM EFWFMPQNFOU JT JO UIF EJTUBOU
TVCVSCT'PSFYBNQMF 5JEBM1BSLJTBTPGUXBSFDFOUFSPOUIFPVUTLJSUTPG$IFOOBJ
(VSHBPO JT B MBSHF OFX JOEVTUSJBM BSFB PVUTJEF %FMIJ BOE 1JNQSJ$IJODIXBE JT
BTJNJMBSDFOUFSPVUTJEFPG1VOF #FSUBVE 4JNJMBSMZ #BOHBMPSFJTQMBOOJOH

TFWFSBMUFDIOPMPHZQBSLTPOJUTGSJOHFBTXFMMBTTFWFSBMDJSDVNGFSFOUJBMIJHIXBZT
JOUIFTVCVSCT CPUIPGXIJDIXJMMJOEVDFGVSUIFSEFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPO*ONPTUDBTFT
UIFSFJTJOBEFRVBUFJOGSBTUSVDUVSFUPTFSWFUIFTFOFXTVCVSCBOEFWFMPQNFOUTBOE
UIFSFTJEFODFTMPDBUJOHBSPVOEUIFN3BNBDIBOESBO DIBSBDUFSJ[FT*OEJBO
TVCVSCTBTBOiVODPOUSPMMFENJYPGJOEVTUSJBMEFWFMPQNFOU EVNQTBOEPCOPYJPVT
VTFT wXJUIUIFiFYUFOTJPOPGVSCBOTFUUMFNFOUDBVTJOHDPOEJUJPOTJOUIFPWFSUBLFO
WJMMBHFTUPEFUFSJPSBUF CPUIQIZTJDBMMZBOETPDJBMMZwʾFMFBQGSPHEFWFMPQNFOU
UZQJDBMPGTVCVSCBOTQSBXMUFOETUPGPMMPXNBKPSIJHIXBZTPVUPG*OEJBODJUJFTUP
UIFEJTUBODFDPVOUSZTJEF
ʾFSFBSFJNQPSUBOUDPOTFRVFODFTPGTVDIMPXEFOTJUZ TQSBXMFEEFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPO
GPSQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU+VTUBTJO/PSUI"NFSJDBBOE&VSPQF JUHFOFSBUFTUSJQTUIBU
BSFMFTTGPDVTFEJOXFMMUSBWFMFEDPSSJEPSTBOEUIVTNPSFEJċDVMUGPSQVCMJDUSBOT
QPSUUPTFSWF*O*OEJB JUIBTMFEUPSBQJEHSPXUIJODBSBOENPUPSDZDMFPXOFSTIJQ
BOEVTFBOEUIVTJODSFBTJOHMZDPOHFTUFESPBEXBZTUIBUTMPXEPXOCVTFT JODSFBTF
CVTPQFSBUJOHDPTUT BOEGVSUIFSEJTDPVSBHFQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUVTF
4RENDS IN 0UBLIC 4RANSPORT

ʾFCFTUTUBUJTUJDTGPSQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUJO*OEJBBSFGPSTVCVSCBOSBJM CFDBVTFJUJT
DFOUSBMMZPXOFEBOEPQFSBUFECZ*OEJBO3BJMXBZT"TTIPXOJO'JHVSF TVCVSCBO
SBJMVTBHFIBTTIBSQMZJODSFBTFEPWFSUIFQBTUmWFEFDBEFT XJUIBGPMEHSPXUI
JO QBTTFOHFS LN PG USBWFM *OEJBO 3BJMXBZT ʾFSF BSF OP DPNQSFIFOTJWF
OBUJPOBMTUBUJTUJDTPOCVTTFSWJDFTVQQMZ MFUBMPOFUIFOVNCFSPGSJEFST CVUUIF
GSBHNFOUFETUBUJTUJDTGPSJOEJWJEVBMDJUJFTTVHHFTUTVCTUBOUJBMHSPXUI'PSFYBNQMF
JOUIFZFBSTGSPNUP UIFSFXBTBOQFSDFOUJODSFBTFJOUIFTJ[FPG
.VNCBJTCVTnFFU BOEBQFSDFOUJODSFBTFJO$IFOOBJTCVTnFFU8IJMFUIFTJ[F
PG%FMIJTQVCMJDCVTnFFUBDUVBMMZGFMM UIFOVNCFSPGQSJWBUFCVTFTSPTFCZBMNPTU
UXJDFBTNVDI ZJFMEJOHBOFUQFSDFOUJODSFBTF "TTPDJBUJPOPG4UBUF3PBE5SBOT
QPSU6OEFSUBLJOHT

&IGURE 'ROWTH IN 3UBURBAN 2AIL 4RAVEL IN )NDIAN #ITIES

TO IN MILLIONS OF PASSENGER KM
4PVSDF*OEJBO3BJMXBZT
#VTFT DBSSZ NPSF UIBO QFSDFOU PG QVCMJD USBOTQPSU JO *OEJBO DJUJFT *OEFFE
NPTU*OEJBODJUJFTIBWFOPSBJMUSBOTQPSUBUBMMBOESFMZJOTUFBEPOBDPNCJOBUJPO
PGCVTFT NJOJWBOT BVUPSJDLTIBXT DZDMFSJDLTIBXT BOEUBYJT&WFOJONPTUPGUIF
MBSHFTUDJUJFT SBJMUSBOTQPSUDBSSJFTMFTTUIBOBUIJSEPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUQBTTFOHFST
ʾFPOMZFYDFQUJPOJT.VNCBJ XIJDIIBT*OEJBTNPTUFYUFOTJWFTVCVSCBOSBJMOFU
XPSL DBSSZJOHNPSFUIBONJMMJPOQBTTFOHFSTBEBZQFSDFOUPGUPUBMQVCMJD
USBOTQPSUQBTTFOHFSTJOUIFSFHJPO WTCZCVT BOEQFSDFOUPGUPUBMQBT
TFOHFSLN WTCZCVT #SJIBONVNCBJ&MFDUSJD4VQQMZBOE5SBOTQPSU
*OEJBO3BJMXBZT
*OHFOFSBM UIFMBSHFSUIFDJUZTJ[F UIFIJHIFSUIFQFSDFOUBHFPGVSCBOUSJQTTFSWFE
CZQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUJO*OEJBQFSDFOUJODJUJFTXJUIQPQVMBUJPOCFUXFFOBOE
NJMMJPO QFSDFOUGPSDJUJFTXJUIQPQVMBUJPOTCFUXFFOBOENJMMJPO BOE
QFSDFOU GPS DJUJFT XJUI QPQVMBUJPOT PWFS NJMMJPO 4SFFEIBSBO ʾVT UIF
FTQFDJBMMZSBQJEHSPXUIPGMBSHFDJUJFTTVHHFTUTBGVSUIFSSJTFJOGVUVSFEFNBOETGPS
QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUJO*OEJB
"TTIPXOCZ'JHVSF IPXFWFS UIFSFJTTVCTUBOUJBMWBSJBUJPOBNPOHDJUJFTPGUIF
TBNF TJ[F DBUFHPSZ "MNPTU QFSDFOU PG BMM USJQT JO ,PMLBUB BSF CZ TPNF GPSN

PGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU DPNQBSFEUPBCPVUQFSDFOUJO.VNCBJ BOEQFSDFOU

JOCPUI$IFOOBJBOE%FMIJ%JĊFSFODFTJOMBOEVTFBOESPBEXBZTVQQMZFYQMBJO
TPNFPGUIFWBSJBUJPO%FMIJBOE$IFOOBJBSFMPXFSEFOTJUZ NPSFQPMZDFOUSJD BOE
NPSFTQSFBEPVUUIBO.VNCBJBOE,PMLBUB%FMIJBMTPIBTBQBSUJDVMBSMZFYUFOTJWF
SPBEXBZOFUXPSL XIJMFUIFTVQQMZPGSPBEXBZTJOPUIFSMBSHF*OEJBODJUJFTJTNVDI
NPSFMJNJUFE'PSFYBNQMF QFSDFOUPG%FMIJTUPUBMMBOEBSFBJTEFWPUFEUPSPBET
DPNQBSFEUPPOMZQFSDFOUJO.VNCBJBOEQFSDFOUJO,PMLBUB.VNCBJBOE
,PMLBUBBMTPIBWFNPSFSFTUSJDUFEHFPHSBQIJFT TJODFCPUIBSFTJUVBUFEPOQFOJO
TVMBTUIBUDIBOOFMUSBWFMBOEMBOEVTFEFWFMPQNFOUJOPOMZBGFXEJSFDUJPOT4VDI
GPDVTFE USBWFM DPSSJEPST FTQFDJBMMZ FODPVSBHF TVCVSCBO SBJM VTF BT JO .VNCBJ
%FMIJIBTOPTVDIHFPHSBQIJDSFTUSJDUJPOTBOETQSBXMTPVUJOBMMEJSFDUJPOTʾVT
%FMIJDVSSFOUMZSFMJFTQSJNBSJMZPOBVUPSJDLTIBXT NPUPSDZDMFT UBYJT BOEQSJWBUF
DBSTUPTFSWFUIFNVMUJEFTUJOBUJPOBM MFTTGPDVTFEUSBWFMQBUUFSOTPGJUTSFTJEFOUT
&IGURE 0ERCENT $ISTRIBUTION OF 5RBAN 4RIPS BY -EANS OF 4RAVEL

FOR 3ELECTED )NDIAN #ITIES
4PVSDFT1FOEBLVSBOE8PSME#BOL

ʾF SBOHF PG QVCMJD USBOTQPSU TFSWJDFT BWBJMBCMF BMTP WBSJFT DPOTJEFSBCMZ FWFO
BNPOHUIFMBSHFTUDBUFHPSJFTPGDJUJFT0OMZ.VNCBJ ,PMLBUB BOE$IFOOBJIBWF
FYUFOTJWF TVCVSCBO SBJM TFSWJDFT %FMIJ IBT MJNJUFE TVCVSCBO SBJM TFSWJDFT 6OUJM
SFDFOUMZ ,PMLBUBIBE*OEJBTPOMZVOEFSHSPVOENFUSPTZTUFN SPVUFLN CVU
%FMIJJTDVSSFOUMZDPOTUSVDUJOHBGBSNPSFFYUFOTJWFNFUSP SPVUFLN %FMIJ
.FUSP3BJM$PSQPSBUJPOB $IFOOBJIBTBIZCSJETVSGBDFBOEFMFWBUFENFUSP
EFTJHOBUFEBT.BTT3BQJE5SBOTQPSU4ZTUFN XIJDIDVSSFOUMZFYUFOETLNBOEJT
CFJOHFYQBOEFECZBOPUIFSLN 4PVUIFSO3BJMXBZ 'JOBMMZ ,PMLBUBIBT
*OEJBTPOMZSFNBJOJOHUSBNTZTUFN BLNEPVCMFUSBDLOFUXPSLPGPME TFSJPVTMZ
EFUFSJPSBUJOHUSBDLTBOEWFIJDMFT
"T OPUFE QSFWJPVTMZ CVTFT BDDPVOU GPS NPTU QVCMJD USBOTQPSU TFSWJDFT FWFO JO
UIFTFMBSHFDJUJFT BOEGPSWJSUVBMMZBMMQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFTJODJUJFTXJUIMFTT
UIBONJMMJPOSFTJEFOUT.PSFPWFS BMM*OEJBODJUJFTGFBUVSFMBSHFOVNCFSTPGBVUP
SJDLTIBXT XIFFMFE NPUPSJ[FE NJOJDBST UBYJT BOE DZDMF SJDLTIBXT IVNBO
QPXFSFEDBSUT
0ROBLEMS AND #HALLENGES

ʾFTIBSQMZSJTJOHEFNBOETGPSQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUIBWFPWFSXIFMNFEUIFFYJTUJOH
QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNTJO*OEJB5SBJOTBOECVTFTJONPTUDJUJFTBSFEBOHFSPVTMZ
PWFSDSPXEFE 0O TVCVSCBO SBJM MJOFT JO .VNCBJ QFBLIPVS USBJOT NVTU DBSSZ
NPSFUIBOUXJDFUIFJSNBYJNVNEFTJHODBQBDJUZ MFBEJOHUPJOIVNBOUSBWFMJOH
DPOEJUJPOT XJUI TPDBMMFE iTVQFS EFOTF DSVTI MPBETw PG UP TUBOEJOH QBT
TFOHFSTQFSTRVBSFNFUFSPGnPPSTQBDF 7BSTIOFZB +BJO BOE4BIBJ.JOJTUSZ
PG3BJMXBZT 0OQFBLIPVSUSBJOT NBOZQBTTFOHFSTBSFGPSDFEUPIBOHPVU
EPPSTBOEXJOEPXTPSUPSJEFCFUXFFOUSBJODBSTPSFWFOIBOHPOUIFPVUTJEFTPG
DBST4VCVSCBOUSBJOTBOETUBUJPOTTFFNIPQFMFTTMZPWFSDSPXEFEBOEEFTQFSBUFMZ
OFFEFYQBOEFEDBQBDJUZ
#VTFT JO *OEJBO DJUJFT BSF EPVCMZ EJTBEWBOUBHFE CZ DPOHFTUFE DPOEJUJPOT #VTFT
UIFNTFMWFTBSFTFSJPVTMZPWFSDSPXEFE XJUITPNFQBTTFOHFSTGPSDFEUPSJEFPOUIF
PVUTJEFTPGWFIJDMFT*OBEEJUJPO IPXFWFS CVTFTNVTUOFHPUJBUFFYUSFNFMZDPO
HFTUFE OBSSPXTUSFFUT XJUIOPTFQBSBUFSJHIUTPGXBZBUBMM IBWJOHUPmHIUXJUIB
NJYFEBSSBZPGBOJNBMESBXODBSUT NJOJWBOT DBST UBYJT NPUPSJ[FEUXPXIFFMFST
BVUPSJDLTIBXT QFEFTUSJBOT DZDMJTUT BOETUSFFUWFOEPST4FWFSFSPBEXBZDPOHFT
UJPOIBTTMPXFEEPXONPTUCVTFTUPBDSBXMEVSJOHNVDIPGUIFEBZBTTMPXBT
UPLNQFSIPVSJONBOZMBSHFDJUJFT (BLFOIFJNFSBOE;FHSBT

ʾFTFDPOHFTUFEDPOEJUJPOTJOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUWFIJDMFT TUBUJPOT BOESJHIUTPG

XBZOPUPOMZTMPXEPXOUSBWFMCVUNBLFJUPVUSJHIUEBOHFSPVT5FOTPGUIPVTBOET
PGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUQBTTFOHFSTBSFLJMMFEPSJOKVSFEFWFSZZFBSJOBDDJEFOUT.BOZ
CVTFTBOEUSBNTEPOPUFWFOIBWFEPPSTBOEXJOEPXTUIBUDBOCFDMPTFE BOE
UIBU POMZ FODPVSBHFT QBTTFOHFST UP SJEF CZ QSPUSVEJOH GSPN JOTJEF UIF WFIJDMF
PSCZIBOHJOHPOGSPNPVUTJEF$MFBSMZ SJEJOHPOUIFSPPGTPSTJEFTPGCVTFTBOE
USBJOTJTJOIFSFOUMZVOTBGFBOESFTVMUTEJSFDUMZGSPNUIFTFWFSFVOEFSDBQBDJUZPG
QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNTJO*OEJB4MPX VODPNGPSUBCMF VOEFQFOEBCMF BOEVOTBGF
DPOEJUJPOTJOUIFFBSMZTMFEUPSJPUTPGQBTTFOHFSTQSPUFTUJOHUIFTFJOIVNBOF
DPOEJUJPOT GPSDJOH TPNF PG UIF TFSWJDF FYQBOTJPO FĊPSUT EFTDSJCFE MBUFS JO UIJT
BSUJDMF "DIBSZB
0OF DPOTFRVFODF PG JOTVċDJFOU TFSWJDF RVBOUJUZ BOE UFSSJCMF TFSWJDF RVBMJUZ JT
UIBU QVCMJD USBOTQPSU IBT CFFO MPTJOH NBSLFU TIBSF JO NBOZ DJUJFT %JTTBUJTmFE
QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUQBTTFOHFSTBSFJODSFBTJOHMZUVSOJOHUPUIFQSJWBUFDBS BOEFWFO
NPSFESBNBUJDBMMZ UPUIFSFMBUJWFMZMPXDPTUNPUPSJ[FEUXPXIFFMFST XIJDIIBWF
FYQFSJFODFEBCPPNJOPXOFSTIJQBOEVTFJOUIFQBTUZFBST"TTIPXOJO'JHVSF
UIFUPUBMOVNCFSPGQSJWBUFDBSTBOENPUPSJ[FEUXPXIFFMFSTJODSFBTFESPVHIMZ
GPVSUJNFTGBTUFSUIBOUIFOVNCFSPGCVTFTPWFSSFDFOUEFDBEFT 8PSME#BOL
.JOJTUSZPG3PBE5SBOTQPSUBOE)JHIXBZT 'PSNVDIPGUIF*OEJBONJEEMF
DMBTT UIF NPUPSDZDMF PĊFST BO BĊPSEBCMF GBS NPSF nFYJCMF DPOWFOJFOU GBTUFS
BOENPSFEFQFOEBCMFXBZPGHFUUJOHBSPVOEUIBOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU'PSBČVFOU
*OEJBOT UIFQSJWBUFDBSPĊFSTBOFWFOIJHIFSMFWFMPGDPNGPSUBOEHSFBUFSQSFTUJHF
BMUIPVHIJUJTNPSFMJLFMZUIBOUXPXIFFMFSTUPCFTMPXFEEPXOCZSPBEXBZDPO
HFTUJPO
ʾFEFUFSJPSBUJOHRVBMJUZPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFSFJOGPSDFTUIFJNQBDUPGUIF
SBQJEEFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPOPG*OEJBODJUJFT#PUIUSFOETFODPVSBHFBTIJGUBXBZGSPN
TQBDFTBWJOH QVCMJD USBOTQPSU UPXBSE JOEJWJEVBM NPUPSJ[FE USBOTQPSU ʾBU IBT
HSFBUMZJODSFBTFESPBEXBZDPOHFTUJPO GVSUIFSSFEVDFEUSBWFMTQFFET BOEBHHSB
WBUFEUSBċDTBGFUZQSPCMFNT1FSIBQTCFDBVTFPGJUTTFQBSBUFSJHIUTPGXBZBOE
UIVTIJHIFSTQFFET TVCVSCBOSBJMDPOUJOVFTUPFYQFSJFODFTUSPOHHSPXUIJOQBT
TFOHFSMFWFMT JOTQJUFPGDSPXEFEWFIJDMFTBOETUBUJPOTBOEVOEFQFOEBCMFTFSWJDF
#ZDPNQBSJTPO CVTTZTUFNTJOTPNFDJUJFTIBWFTVĊFSFEMPTTFTPGQBTTFOHFSTJO
SFDFOUZFBST BTUIFJSPWFSDSPXEFECVTFTHFUCPHHFEEPXOJOTMPXFSBOETMPXFS
USBċD
"OPUIFSDSVDJBMQSPCMFNPG*OEJBOUSBOTQPSUJTJOFċDJFODZ MBDLPGQSPEVDUJWJUZ
PWFSTUBċOH FYDFTTJWFMZIJHIPQFSBUJOHDPTUT BOEMBSHFTVCTJEZOFFET&TQFDJBMMZ

&IGURE 'ROWTH OF )NDIAS -OTOR 6EHICLE &LEET BY 4YPE OF 6EHICLE

IN THOUSANDS OF VEHICLES
4PVSDF.JOJTUSZPG3PBE5SBOTQPSUBOE)JHIXBZT
TJODFUIFNJET PQFSBUJOHEFmDJUTIBWFCFFOSJTJOHSBQJEMZ'PSCVTTZTUFNT
JOUIFMBSHFTUDJUJFT UIFDPNCJOFEPQFSBUJOHEFmDJURVBESVQMFE "TTPDJBUJPOPG
4UBUF3PBE5SBOTQPSUC BOEGPS*OEJBO3BJMXBZT UIFBOOVBMPQFSBUJOHEFm
DJUUSJQMFE"TTIPXOJO'JHVSF NPTUQVCMJDMZPXOFECVTTZTUFNTJOMBSHFDJUJFT
HFOFSBMMZDPWFSBCPVUUPQFSDFOUPGPQFSBUJOHDPTUT NVDIIJHIFSUIBOMBSHF
QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNTJO8FTUFSO&VSPQFʾFNPTUVOQSPmUBCMFCVTTZTUFNJT
JO,PMLBUB XIJDIDPWFSTPOMZQFSDFOUPGDPTUTUISPVHIQBTTFOHFSGBSFT XIJMF
%FMIJ BOE.VNCBJ DPWFSBCPVUUISFFGPVSUITPGDPTUT"UUIFIJHI
FOE PG UIF TDBMF #BOHBMPSF JT BDUVBMMZ QSPmUBCMF BOE )ZEFSBCBE
BMNPTU CSFBLT FWFO *U JT OPUBCMF UIBU CPUI PG UIF QVCMJDMZ PXOFE CVT mSNT JO
#BOHBMPSFBOE)ZEFSBCBEDPOUSBDUNBOZPGUIFJSTFSWJDFTUPQSJWBUFMZPQFSBUFE
DPNQBOJFT XIJDIQSPCBCMZFYQMBJOTUIFCFUUFSFDPOPNJDQFSGPSNBODF

&IGURE 0ROPORTION OF /PERATING %XPENSES #OVERED BY 0ASSENGER

2EVENUES FOR 3ELECTED #ITIES IN )NDIA n
4PVSDF"TTPDJBUJPOPG4UBUF3PBE5SBOTQPSU6OEFSUBLJOHT
$MFBSMZ NVDIDPVMECFEPOFUPJNQSPWFUIFFċDJFODZPGCPUICVTBOESBJMPQFSB
UJPOT NPTUPGXIJDIBSFQVCMJDMZPXOFE PQFSBUFE BOESFHVMBUFEʾFSFBSFNBOZ
JOTUJUVUJPOBM PCTUBDMFT UP BOZ GVOEBNFOUBM DIBOHFT JODMVEJOH QPXFSGVM MBCPS
VOJPOTSFQSFTFOUJOHFNQMPZFFT XIJDIIBWFCMPDLFEDIBOHFTUIBUXPVMEEJTBE
WBOUBHFUIFN
0RIVATIZATION
0OFQPTTJCMFTPMVUJPOUPNBOZPGUIFTFQSPCMFNTNJHIUCFUIFTFMFDUJWFQSJWBUJ[B
UJPOPG*OEJBTQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFDUPSʾBUDPVMECFEPOFFJUIFSUISPVHIPQFOJOH
VQUIFNBSLFUUPQSJWBUFmSNT XIPXPVMEPXO NBOBHF PQFSBUFBOEmOBODFUIFJS
PXOTZTUFNT PSCZIBWJOHQVCMJDBHFODJFTDPOUSBDUXJUIQSJWBUFmSNTUPPQFSBUF
TFSWJDFTPOBTZTUFNXJEFCBTJT GPSTFMFDUJWFSPVUFT PSGPSTFMFDUFEGVODUJPOT MJLF
NBJOUFOBODF 3BJMTZTUFNTIBWFPOMZSBSFMZCFFOQSJWBUJ[FEBOZXIFSFJOUIFXPSME
FYDFQUGPSDFSUBJOOBSSPXGVODUJPOT XIJMFUIFSFJTDPOTJEFSBCMFFYQFSJFODFXJUI

CVTQSJWBUJ[BUJPOʾVT QSJWBUJ[BUJPOTFFNTBOPQUJPOPOMZGPSCVTTFSWJDFT CVU

UIFZBDDPVOUGPSNPSFUIBOQFSDFOUPG*OEJBTQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU
1SJWBUJ[BUJPOPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUJO*OEJBXBTTUSPOHMZFODPVSBHFECZUIF8PSME
#BOL XIJDIBDDVTFEQVCMJDMZPXOFEBOEPQFSBUFETZTUFNTPGCFJOHJOFG
mDJFOU BOE IJHIMZ VOQSPmUBCMF QSPWJEJOH JOTVċDJFOU BOE MPXRVBMJUZ TFSWJDFT
BOE GBJMJOH UP SFTQPOE UP NBSLFU EFNBOET "MUIPVHI UIFSF XFSF TPNF NJOPS
BUUFNQUTBUQSJWBUJ[BUJPOJOUIFT UIFmSTUMBSHFTDBMFQSJWBUJ[BUJPOPGCVTFT
PDDVSSFEJO%FMIJJO XIFOOVNFSPVTTNBMM QSJWBUFCVTmSNTFOUFSFEUIF
NBSLFU6OGPSUVOBUFMZ UIFOFXQSJWBUFPQFSBUPSTXFSFOPUBEFRVBUFMZSFHVMBUFE
BOE DPPSEJOBUFE MFBEJOH UP DPNQMFUF DIBPT ʾF OFX QSJWBUF TFSWJDFT UPSUVSFE
QBTTFOHFSTXJUIMFOHUIZ [JH[BHSPVUFT MPOHXBJUJOHUJNFT DPNQMFUFMZVOSFMJBCMF
TFSWJDF FYUSFNFPWFSDSPXEJOH VORVBMJmFEESJWFST TQFFEJOHBOESFDLMFTTESJWJOH
mHIUTBNPOHDPNQFUJOHCVTFT BOEFWFOSVOOJOHEPXOQBTTFOHFSTXBJUJOHBUCVT
TUPQT.PSFPWFS UIFQSJWBUFCVTFTXFSFPGUFOQPPSMZNBJOUBJOFE VOTBGF OPJTZ
BOEIJHIMZQPMMVUJOH BEEJOHUPUIFBMSFBEZTFWFSFDPOHFTUJPO TBGFUZ BOEBJSQPM
MVUJPOQSPCMFNTJO%FMIJ
*OUIFZFBSTTJODF SFHVMBUJPOTIBWFCFFOTUSFOHUIFOFEBOECFUUFSFOGPSDFE
.PSFPWFS UIF NBOZ QSJWBUF CVT PQFSBUPST BSF OPX NVDI CFUUFS DPPSEJOBUFE
UIBOBUUIFPVUTFU4FSWJDFRVBMJUZQSPCMFNTTUJMMSFNBJO CVUQSJWBUJ[BUJPOBQQFBST
UPIBWFCSPVHIUTPNFTVCTUBOUJBMFDPOPNJDCFOFmUT*OBDPNQBSJTPOPGQVCMJD
BOEQSJWBUFCVTPQFSBUPSTJO%FMIJ UIF8PSME#BOLGPVOEUIBUQSJWBUFCVTmSNT
DBSSJFEUXJDFBTNBOZQBTTFOHFSTQFSCVTQFSEBZ WT FBSOFEUXJDFBT
NVDISFWFOVFQFSCVTQFSEBZ WT 3VQFFT SFRVJSFEMFTTUIBOIBMGUIF
TUBċOHQFSCVT WTFNQMPZFFT DPTUMFTTUIBOIBMGBTNVDIQFSCVTLN
WT3VQFFT BOEBDUVBMMZNBEFBQSPmU 3VQFFTQFSCVTLN XIJMF
UIFQVCMJDCVTmSNTSBOBMPTT 3VQFFTMPTTQFSCVTLN .BSXBI 4JCBM BOE
4BXBOU
ʾFTF mOBODJBM DPNQBSJTPOT CFUXFFO QVCMJD BOE QSJWBUF CVTFT BSF TPNFXIBU
FYBHHFSBUFE TJODFQSJWBUFmSNTDBOVTVBMMZTFMFDUQSPmUBCMFSPVUFT XIJMFQVCMJD
mSNTBSFPGUFOSFRVJSFEUPQSPWJEFVOQSPmUBCMFTFSWJDFTPOMJHIUMZVTFESPVUFTUP
BDIJFWFTPDJBMPCKFDUJWFTBOEFOTVSFDPNQSFIFOTJWFDPWFSBHFUPUIFFOUJSFDJUZ
.PSFPWFS QSJWBUFCVTDPNQBOJFTPĊFSUIFJSFNQMPZFFTNVDIMPXFSXBHFT MFTTKPC
TFDVSJUZ BOEMFTTHFOFSPVTGSJOHFCFOFmUTTVDIBTQFOTJPOTBOEIFBMUIJOTVSBODF

ʾVT UPTPNFFYUFOU UIFQSJWBUFCVTmSNTIBWFMPXFSDPTUTEVFUPMPXFSTBMBSJFT

GPSUIFJSXPSLFST
,PMLBUBDVSSFOUMZIBTBMBSHFOVNCFSPGQSJWBUFMZPQFSBUFECVTFTBTXFMM BCPVU
QSJWBUF WT QVCMJD BOE BT JO %FMIJ UIFZ IBWF GFXFS FNQMPZFFT QFS
CVT MPXFSDPTUT BOENVDIIJHIFSDPTUDPWFSBHFUISPVHIGBSFSFWFOVFTUIBOUIF
QVCMJDMZPQFSBUFECVTFT1SJWBUJ[BUJPOJO#BOHBMPSFBOE)ZEFSBCBEIBTTPGBSCFFO
MJNJUFEUPUIFDPOUSBDUJOHPVUPGDFSUBJOSPVUFTUPQSJWBUFPQFSBUPST CVUTUJMMXJUI
UIFPWFSBMMDPPSEJOBUJPOPGBQVCMJDBHFODZ
*U BQQFBST UIBU QSJWBUJ[BUJPO EPFT JOEFFE IBWF NVDI QPUFOUJBM UP JNQSPWF Fċ
DJFODZ CVUUIBUJUNVTUCFBDDPNQBOJFECZTUSJDUSFHVMBUJPOT QFSGPSNBODFTUBO
EBSET BOE PWFSBMM DPPSEJOBUJPO UP FOTVSF BO JOUFHSBUFE OFUXPSL PG TFSWJDFT *O
MJHIUPGUIFUSBOTQPSUGVOEJOHDSJTJTJO*OEJBODJUJFT UIFZNBZIBWFMJUUMFDIPJDFCVU
UPTFFLUIFDPTUTBWJOHTQPTTJCMFXJUIQSJWBUJ[BUJPOBOEJODSFBTFEDPNQFUJUJPO
&UNDING
4JODF QBTTFOHFS SFWFOVFT EP OPU DPWFS UIF GVMM DPTUT PG PQFSBUJPO BOE DBQJUBM
JOWFTUNFOUPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU HPWFSONFOUmOBODJBMBTTJTUBODFJTPCWJPVTMZDSV
DJBM"TPXOFSPG*OEJBO3BJMXBZT UIF$FOUSBM(PWFSONFOUNVTUCFBSXIBUFWFS
PQFSBUJOH EFmDJU SFNBJOT BGUFS UIF TVCTUBOUJBM DSPTTTVCTJEJFT GSPN QSPmUBCMF
GSFJHIUTFSWJDFT*OUIFQBTU UIF$FOUSBM(PWFSONFOUBMTPCPSFNPTUPGUIFDPTUT
PGDBQJUBMJOWFTUNFOU CVUJOSFDFOUZFBST TUBUFHPWFSONFOUTIBWFmOBODFEHSPX
JOH QPSUJPOT PG UIFTF DPTUT FTQFDJBMMZ GPS UIF FYQBOTJPOT BOE JNQSPWFNFOUT PG
TVCVSCBOSBJMTZTUFNTJO.VNCBJ $IFOOBJ ,PMLBUB BOE)ZEFSBCBE .JOJTUSZPG
3BJMXBZT 5PFODPVSBHFNPSFTUBUFDPOUSJCVUJPOT *OEJBO3BJMXBZTOPXHJWFT
QSJPSJUZUPQSPKFDUTXJUIVQUPUXPUIJSETTUBUFHPWFSONFOUGVOEJOH
'VOEJOHGPSOFXBOEFYQBOEFENFUSPSBJMTZTUFNTDPNFTGSPNUIF$FOUSBM(PW
FSONFOU BT XFMM BT TUBUF BOE MPDBM HPWFSONFOUT CVU UIFSF JT OP FYBDU GPSNVMB
BOEUIFEJTUSJCVUJPOPGDPOUSJCVUJPOTWBSJFTGSPNDBTFUPDBTFʾF8PSME#BOL
UIF+BQBOFTF#BOLGPS*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PPQFSBUJPO +#*$ BOEPUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBM
MFOEJOH BHFODJFT IBWF BMTP QSPWJEFE MPBOT GPS MBSHF JOGSBTUSVDUVSF QSPKFDUT 'PS
FYBNQMF B+#*$MPBOJTGVOEJOHUXPUIJSETPGUIFDBQJUBMDPTUPGCVJMEJOHUIF%FMIJ
.FUSP %FMIJ.FUSP3BJMC 3BJMTZTUFNPQFSBUJOHEFmDJUT IPXFWFS BSFQSJ
NBSJMZCPSOFCZMPDBMHPWFSONFOUT
.PTUCVTTFSWJDFTBSFTUJMMQVCMJDMZPXOFEBOEPQFSBUFECZ456T 4UBUF5SBOTQPSU
6OEFSUBLJOHT XIPTF PQFSBUJOH BOE DBQJUBM JOWFTUNFOU DPTUT BSF DPWFSFE CZ B

DPNCJOBUJPOPGTUBUFBOEMPDBMHPWFSONFOUTVCTJEJFT HSBOUT BOEMPBOTUIBUWBSZ

GSPNTUBUFUPTUBUF
4JHOJmDBOUMZ OPHPWFSONFOUMFWFMIBTBOZEFEJDBUFEUBYFTXIPTFQSPDFFETXPVME
CFBVUPNBUJDBMMZFBSNBSLFEGPSQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUʾVT mOBODJBMTVQQPSUGPSQVCMJD
USBOTQPSUJTUFOVPVT EFQFOEJOHPOBOOVBMCVEHFUBSZBQQSPQSJBUJPOT8JUIDSJUJDBM
TIPSUBHFTPGSFWFOVFTBUFWFSZHPWFSONFOUMFWFM QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUNVTUDPNQFUF
FBDIZFBSXJUINBOZPUIFSVSHFOUOFFETGPSQVCMJDGVOETʾFXJMMJOHOFTTPGUIF
$FOUSBM BOE TUBUF HPWFSONFOUT UP GVOE QVCMJD USBOTQPSU DBO WBSZ TVCTUBOUJBMMZ
PWFSUJNF NBLJOHMPOHUFSNQMBOOJOHWFSZEJċDVMU
2ECENT AND 0LANNED )MPROVEMENTS

*O TQJUF PG TFWFSF TIPSUBHFT PG CPUI QVCMJD BOE QSJWBUF mOBODJOH GPS JNQSPWJOH
QVCMJDUSBOTQPSU TFWFSBM*OEJBODJUJFTIBWFCFFOUSZJOHUPQSPWJEFNPSFBOECFUUFS
TFSWJDFTUPNFFUCVSHFPOJOHUSBWFMEFNBOETʾFNPTUFYUFOTJWFJNQSPWFNFOUT
BSFJO.VNCBJ'PSFYBNQMF *OEJBO3BJMXBZTIBTBMSFBEZPQFOFEUXPOFXTVCVS
CBOSBJMMJOFTBOEIBTQMBOTGPSBEEJUJPOBMFYUFOTJPOT4FWFSBMFYJTUJOHMJOFTIBWF
CFFOWBTUMZJNQSPWFECZDPOTUSVDUJOHBEEJUJPOBMUSBDLT GSPNPOFUPUXPUSBDLT
BOE GSPN UXP UP GPVS USBDLT UP QFSNJU TFQBSBUJPO PG MPDBM BOE FYQSFTT USBJOT
.PSFPWFS DBSTIBWFCFFOBEEFEUPUSBJOT BWFSBHFTQFFETIBWFJODSFBTFE BOEGSF
RVFODZPGTFSWJDFIBTBMTPSJTFONFBTVSFTBJNFEBUNJUJHBUJOHUIFPWFSDSPXEJOH
QSPCMFN#ZSFMPDBUJOHNPSFUIBO JMMFHBMTMVNEXFMMJOHTUIBUFODSPBDIFEPO
MBOEEJSFDUMZBEKBDFOUUPSBJMXBZUSBDLT *OEJBO3BJMXBZTJODSFBTFETFSWJDFEFQFOE
BCJMJUZ TQFFE BOETBGFUZ .VNCBJ.FUSPQPMJUBO3FHJPO%FWFMPQNFOU"VUIPSJUZ

"OFTQFDJBMMZJOOPWBUJWFJOJUJBUJWFJTUIFQMBOOFE4LZ#VTTZTUFN XIJDIXJMMGFB
UVSFTFWFSBMMJOFTPGFYQSFTTCVTFTPOFMFWBUFEHVJEFXBZTʾFJOJUJBMQIBTF XIJDI
FYUFOETLN TDIFEVMFEGPSDPNQMFUJPOCZ TIPVMEIFMQUPSFMJFWFUIFNPTU
DPOHFTUFETVCVSCBOSBJMBOECVTSPVUFTJOUIFTBNFDPSSJEPST ,POLBO3BJMXBZ
$PSQPSBUJPO -UE 'JOBMMZ UIF NBJO CVT PQFSBUPS JO .VNCBJ #&45 IBT
BMSFBEZJOUSPEVDFETNBSUDBSETGPSGBSFDPMMFDUJPOPOTPNFQSFNJVNCVTTFSWJDFT
BOEBMTPQMBOTUPJOUSPEVDFMPXnPPSCVTFTUPGBDJMJUBUFUSBWFMCZQBTTFOHFSTXJUI
EJTBCJMJUJFT #SJIBONVNCBJ&MFDUSJD4VQQMZBOE5SBOTQPSU
%FMIJIBTCFFOJOOPWBUJWFPOBUMFBTUUISFFEJĊFSFOUGSPOUT*UIBTCFFODPOTUSVDU
JOHBOFXNFUSPTZTUFNXJUIUISFFMJOFT CVUPOMZBTNBMMTFDUJPOJTDVSSFOUMZJO
TFSWJDF8IFODPNQMFUFE JUXJMMIBWFLNPGVOEFSHSPVOEMJOFTBOELNPG

TVSGBDFPSFMFWBUFEMJOFT#ZUIFZFBS UIF%FMIJ.FUSPJTFYQFDUFEUPDBSSZ
NPSFUIBOUXPNJMMJPOQBTTFOHFSTBEBZ %FMIJ.FUSP3BJM$PSQPSBUJPOD
%FMIJIBTBMTPCFFOBUUIFGPSFGSPOUPGJOOPWBUJPOTJOCVTTFSWJDFT CPUICZSFRVJS
JOHBDPNQMFUFTXJUDIPWFSUPOPOQPMMVUJOH$/(CVTFTBOECZJOUSPEVDJOHQSJWB
UJ[BUJPOBOEJODSFBTFEDPNQFUJUJPOBNPOHCVTmSNTUPSFEVDFDPTUT"TOPUFE
FBSMJFS CPUIPGUIPTFQPMJDZDIBOHFTDBVTFEFOPSNPVTEJTSVQUJPOTJOTFSWJDFGPS
TFWFSBMUSBOTJUJPOBMZFBST CVUUIFPWFSBMMSFTVMUIBTCFFOQPTJUJWF
,PMLBUBJTDVSSFOUMZFYUFOEJOHJUTFYJTUJOHLNVOEFSHSPVOENFUSPCZBOPUIFS
LN .FUSP3BJMXBZ,PMLBUB
$IFOOBJDPNQMFUFEUIFmSTUQIBTFPGJUT.BTT3BQJE5SBOTJU4ZTUFNJO XIJDI
JODMVEFTLNPGFMFWBUFEUSBDLBOELNPGTVSGBDFUSBDL$VSSFOUMZ UIFTZTUFN
JTCFJOHFYUFOEFECZBOPUIFSLN XJUIBUMFBTULNPGGVUVSFFYQBOTJPOT
QMBOOFE 4PVUIFSO3BJMXBZ ʾFJOJUJBMQIBTFXBTEJTBQQPJOUJOHCFDBVTFJU
XBTOPUXFMMDPPSEJOBUFEXJUICVTBOETVCVSCBOSBJMTFSWJDFT CVUUIPTFQSPCMFNT
BSFDVSSFOUMZCFJOHIBOEMFEUISPVHITJHOJmDBOUJNQSPWFNFOUTJOQBSLJOHBOECFU
UFSDPOOFDUJPOTUPCVTBOETVCVSCBOSBJM$POOFDUJPOTBSFBMTPCFJOHJNQSPWFE
CFUXFFOUISFFPGUIFTVCVSCBOSBJMMJOFTJO$IFOOBJ XJUIQIZTJDBMMJOLTOPXQPT
TJCMFUIBOLTUPHBVHFDPOWFSTJPOTGPSDPNQBUJCJMJUZ'JOBMMZ $IFOOBJIBTQMBOTUP
JOUSPEVDFQSJWBUJ[FE DPNQFUJUJWFCVTTFSWJDFTPOSPVHIMZIBMGJUTCVTSPVUFT GPM
MPXJOHUIFFYBNQMFPG%FMIJBOEUIFSFDPNNFOEBUJPOTPGUIF8PSME#BOL
#BOHBMPSFIBEQMBOOFEBOFXMJHIUSBJMTZTUFN CVUJUIBTCFFOJOEFmOJUFMZQPTU
QPOFEEVFUPBTIPSUBHFPGGVOET*OTUFBE BMFTTFYQFOTJWFTZTUFNPGHSBEFTFQB
SBUFE CVTXBZT BOE IJHIDBQBDJUZ BSUJDVMBUFE CVTFT BSF CFJOH DPOTJEFSFE (BVS

ʾFTVCVSCBOSBJMTFSWJDFTJO)ZEFSBCBEBSFCFJOHFYQBOEFEBOEJNQSPWFE XJUI
B TQFDJBM GPDVT PO VQHSBEJOH TUBUJPO BSFBT BOE FOIBODJOH TBGFUZ *O BEEJUJPO
USBOTGFSTCFUXFFOCVTBOESBJMTFSWJDFTBSFCFJOHGBDJMJUBUFECZCFUUFSDPPSEJOBUJPO
CFUXFFOUIFDJUZCVTTFSWJDFTBOE*OEJBO3BJMXBZT
2ECOMMENDED 0OLICY 3HIFTS

(JWFOUIFSBQJEHSPXUIPG*OEJBTMBSHFTUDJUJFTBOEUIFEFTQFSBUFOFFEGPSCFUUFS
BOEFYQBOEFEQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU JUJTDSVDJBMUIBUQPMJDJFTDIBOHFUPJNQSPWFUIF
FOUJSFSBOHFPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFTPĊFSFE6OGPSUVOBUFMZ UIF*OEJBOHPW
FSONFOUIBTCFFOFNQIBTJ[JOHJOTUFBEUIFOFFEUPGVSUIFSEFWFMPQUIFOBTDFOU
BVUPNPCJMFJOEVTUSZJO*OEJBBOEIBTBDUVBMMZFODPVSBHFENPSFQSJWBUFDBSPXOFS

TIJQBOEVTF*OEJBODJUJFTBSFTJNQMZOPUFRVJQQFEUPIBOEMFJODSFBTFEWPMVNFT
PGQSJWBUFWFIJDMFVTF3PBEXBZTBSFBMSFBEZIPQFMFTTMZDPOHFTUFE XJUIBWFSBHF
TQFFET EFDMJOJOH FBDI ZFBS &WFO GPS BVUPNPCJMF VTFST JU XJMM CF JNQPSUBOU UP
JNQSPWFQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU JGPOMZUPSFNPWFTPNFUSBċDGSPNUIFTUSFFUTBOEUIVT
SFEVDFDPOHFTUJPOUPNBOBHFBCMFMFWFMTBOEJODSFBTFUSBWFMTQFFET
$MFBSMZ QVCMJDUSBOTQPSUNVTUCFHJWFOQSJPSJUZBUUFOUJPOUPBWPJEGVSUIFSEFUF
SJPSBUJPOPGBJSRVBMJUZ USBċDTBGFUZ DPOHFTUJPO BOEOPJTFJO*OEJBODJUJFT8IJMF
TPNFJNQSPWFNFOUTDBOCFNBEFFWFOXJUIFYJTUJOHGVOEJOHMFWFMT NPTUXPVME
SFRVJSFNBTTJWFJOGVTJPOTPGOFXGVOEJOHGPSFYQBOEFEBOENPEFSOJ[FECVTBOE
SBJM TZTUFNT &RVBMMZ JNQPSUBOU TUBUF BOE MPDBM HPWFSONFOUT NVTU HJWF USBċD
QSJPSJUZUPCVTFT CPUIUISPVHITQFDJBMCVTMBOFTBOETJHOBMQSJPSJUZPWFSQSJWBUF
USBOTQPSU
8JUINPSFUIBOQFSDFOUPGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUQBTTFOHFSTJO*OEJBODJUJFTSFMZJOH
POCVTFT JUJTFTQFDJBMMZJNQPSUBOUUPVQHSBEFCVTTFSWJDFTUISPVHINPEFSO TBGF
WFIJDMFTBOEQSJPSJUZPOUIFDPOHFTUFESPBEXBZTʾFIFBWZ IJHInPPSCVTFTDVS
SFOUMZJOTFSWJDFJONPTUDJUJFTBSFOPJTZ QPMMVUJOH GVFMJOFċDJFOU BOEVOTBGFʾFZ
BSFCVJMUPOUSVDLDIBTTJTXJUITVDIIJHInPPSTUIBUCPBSEJOHJTTMPXBOEEJċDVMU
.PSFPWFS UIFZIBWFTMPXBDDFMFSBUJPOBTXFMMBTQPPSGVFMFDPOPNZEVFUPUIFJS
XFJHIU BOEBSFJOBQQSPQSJBUFUPVSCBOVTF.BOZCVTFTEPOPUFWFOIBWFDMPTBCMF
XJOEPXTBOEEPPSTUPQSPUFDUQBTTFOHFSTGSPNUIFXFBUIFSBOEGSPNGBMMJOHPVUPG
UIFWFIJDMF*UJTFTTFOUJBMUPSFQMBDFUIFTFPVUEBUFECVTFTXJUINPEFSO TBGF DMFBO
BOEGVFMFċDJFOUWFIJDMFT
*NQSPWJOHBOEFYQBOEJOHSBJMTZTUFNTJTBMTPDSVDJBM TJODFUIFZBSFJOTVMBUFEGSPN
UIFDPOHFTUJPOEFMBZTDBVTFECZSPBEXBZUSBċD6OGPSUVOBUFMZ UIFZBSFVTVBMMZ
WFSZFYQFOTJWF BOEJUJTOPUSFBMJTUJDUPFYQFDUUIBUFWFONPTUMBSHF*OEJBODJUJFT
XJMM CF BCMF UP BĊPSE OFX SBJM TZTUFNT .PSFPWFS GPS NFEJVN BOE TNBMM DJUJFT
XIFSFQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFTBSFFJUIFSOPOFYJTUFOUPSWFSZJOGSFRVFOU BTXFMM
BT TMPX BOE DSPXEFE JNQSPWFE CVT TFSWJDF JT UIF POMZ GFBTJCMF PQUJPO 1SJWBUF
WFIJDMFTIBWFBNVDIIJHIFSTIBSFPGUPUBMUSJQTJOTNBMMBOENFEJVNTJ[FEDJUJFT
QSFDJTFMZCFDBVTFUIFCVTTFSWJDFTUIFSFBSFTPJOBEFRVBUF
8JUIJO UIF DVSSFOU GVOEJOH MJNJUT JU XPVME TUJMM CF QPTTJCMF UP WBTUMZ JNQSPWF
UIFUSBOTGFSDPOOFDUJPOTCFUXFFOSBJMBOECVTMJOFT BTXFMMBTUPJOUSPEVDFJOUF
HSBUFEUJDLFUJOHGPSBMMQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUNPEFT*OBEEJUJPO UIFQSJWBUJ[BUJPOBOE
JODSFBTFEDPNQFUJUJPOBNPOHCVTTFSWJDFTBMSFBEZJNQMFNFOUFEJO%FMIJBOEB
GFXPUIFSDJUJFTNJHIUCFBEPQUFENPSFXJEFMZ BTJUXPVMEJODSFBTFFċDJFODZBOE
SFEVDFDPTUTʾBUXPVME IPXFWFS IBWFUPCFBDDPNQBOJFECZTUSJDUSFHVMBUJPO

BOEFOGPSDFNFOUPGTBGFUZBOEQPMMVUJPOTUBOEBSETDPNCJOFEXJUIPWFSBMMSFHJPO
XJEFDPPSEJOBUJPOPGBMMQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTFSWJDFT*UXBTUIFGBJMVSFUPSFHVMBUFBOE
DPPSEJOBUFUIFOFXQSJWBUFCVTPQFSBUPSTJO%FMIJUIBUMFEUPUIFTFSJPVTQSPCMFNT
PGVOTBGF PWFSDSPXEFE VOQSFEJDUBCMF BOEVODPPSEJOBUFEQSJWBUFCVTFT
ʾFNBJOQSPCMFNJO*OEJBODJUJFT IPXFWFS JTmOBODJBM5PTPNFFYUFOU PQFSBU
JOH SFWFOVFT PG QVCMJD USBOTQPSU mSNT DPVME CF HSFBUMZ FOIBODFE CZ UBSHFUJOH
GBSFTVCTJEJFTUPMPXJODPNFQBTTFOHFSTBOESBJTJOHDPOTJEFSBCMZUIFGBSFTGPSUIF
NJEEMFBOEVQQFSDMBTTFT"TOPUFEFBSMJFS GBSFTPONPTUTZTUFNTBSFFYUSFNFMZ
MPXBOEQBTTFOHFSWPMVNFTBSFFYUSFNFMZIJHITPUIBUFWFONPEFTUJODSFBTFT
NJHIU ZJFME TVCTUBOUJBM SFWFOVFT GPS TZTUFN NBJOUFOBODF NPEFSOJ[BUJPO BOE
FYQBOTJPO 'BSFT DBOOPU CF SBJTFE UPP IJHI IPXFWFS FWFO BNPOH NJEEMFDMBTT
SJEFST TJODFUIFZNJHIUUIFOCFEJWFSUFEUPQSJWBUFUSBOTQPSUNPEFT XIJDIDBVTF
UIFNPTUVSCBOUSBOTQPSUQSPCMFNTʾVT MBSHFSTVCTJEJFTGSPNUIFQVCMJDTFDUPS
XJMMCFFTTFOUJBM
6OUJMBMMMFWFMTPGHPWFSONFOUJO*OEJBEFWPUFUIFOFDFTTBSZGVOEJOHUPFYQBOEJOH
BOEJNQSPWJOHQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU JUXJMMSFNBJOPWFSDSPXEFE VOTBGF VOEFQFOE
BCMF BOE VOQMFBTBOU UIVT FODPVSBHJOH FWFS NPSF *OEJBOT UP UVSO JOTUFBE UP
QSJWBUFDBSTBOENPUPSDZDMFT XIJDIXPVMEMFBEUPFWFONPSFTFSJPVTDPOHFTUJPO
BOEQPMMVUJPOQSPCMFNTJO*OEJBODJUJFTʾFJEFBMTPVSDFPGTVDIGVOEJOHXPVME
CFTPNFTPSUPGEFEJDBUFEHBTPMJOFPSQSJWBUFNPUPSWFIJDMFUBYXIPTFSFWFOVFT
XPVMECFEFWPUFETQFDJmDBMMZUPUIFJNQSPWFNFOUPGVSCBOUSBOTQPSUDPOEJUJPOT
JODMVEJOHCFUUFSSPBEXBZT CFUUFSCJDZDMJOHBOEXBMLJOHGBDJMJUJFT BOEBCPWFBMM
CFUUFSCVTBOESBJMTFSWJDFT.BOZPGUIFXPSMETEFWFMPQFEDPVOUSJFTIBWFVTFE
TVDIEFEJDBUFEHBTPMJOFBOENPUPSWFIJDMFUBYFTGPSEFDBEFTUPGVOEUIFJSQVCMJD
USBOTQPSUJNQSPWFNFOUT*O*OEJB JUXPVMECFEPVCMZCFOFmDJBM4VDIBUBYXPVME
EJTDPVSBHFOPOFTTFOUJBMQSJWBUFDBSPXOFSTIJQBOEVTF.PSFPWFS UIFCVSEFOPG
UIFUBYXPVMEGBMMPOSFMBUJWFMZBČVFOU*OEJBOT TPUIBUUIFPWFSBMMJNQBDUXPVME
CFRVJUFQSPHSFTTJWFʾFTPMVUJPOUPQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUTmOBODJOHQSPCMFNJO*OEJB
TFFNTRVJUFDMFBS CVUEPFTUIF*OEJBOHPWFSONFOUIBWFUIFQPMJUJDBMXJMMUPJNQMF
NFOUJU

2EFERENCES
"DIBSZB 3*OEJBOSBJMXBZT8IFSFUIFDPNNVUFSJTLJOH+BQBO3BJMXBZTBOE
5SBOTQPSU3FWJFX 0DUPCFSo
"TTPDJBUJPOPG4UBUF3PBE5SBOTQPSU6OEFSUBLJOHTʾFQFSGPSNBODFPG456T
BUBHMBODFGPSUIFQFSJPEoUPo%FMIJ *OEJB"4356"DDFTTJCMF
BUIUUQXXXBTSUVPSHEBUB1%'
"TTPDJBUJPOPG4UBUF3PBE5SBOTQPSU6OEFSUBLJOHTC456QPMJDZJTTVF%FMIJ
*OEJB "4356 "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXBTSUVPSHTUV@QPMJDZIUN "DDFTTFE
/PWFNCFS
#FSUBVE "ʾFFDPOPNJDJNQBDUPGMBOEBOEVSCBOQMBOOJOHSFHVMBUJPOTJO
*OEJB6OQVCMJTIFENBOVTDSJQUBDDFTTJCMFBUIUUQXXXBMBJOCFSUBVEDPN
JNBHFT"#@*OEJB@6SCBO@-BOE@3FGPSNEPD
#SJIBONVNCBJ &MFDUSJD 4VQQMZ BOE 5SBOTQPSU 0SHBOJTBUJPOBM JOGPSNBUJPO
.VNCBJ *OEJB "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXCFTUVOEFSUBLJOHDPNPSH@JOGPBTQ
"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS
$FOUSBM*OUFMMJHFODF"HFODZʾF$*"XPSMEGBDUCPPL8BTIJOHUPO %$$*"
"DDFTTJCMFBUIUUQXXXDJBHPWDJBQVCMJDBUJPOTGBDUCPPLHFPTJOIUNM
%FMIJ.FUSP3BJM$PSQPSBUJPO-UEB1SPKFDUVQEBUF/FX%FMIJ *OEJB%FMIJ
.FUSP 3BJM $PSQPSBUJPO "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXEFMIJNFUSPSBJMDPNIPNF
QSPKFDU6QEBUFIUN"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS
%FMIJ.FUSP3BJM$PSQPSBUJPOC$PTUBOEGVOEJOHQMBO/FX%FMIJ *OEJB%FMIJ
.FUSP 3BJM $PSQPSBUJPO "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXEFMIJNFUSPSBJMDPNIPNF
.FUSP'BTU'BDUT$PTUIUN"DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ
%FMIJ.FUSP3BJM$PSQPSBUJPO-UED)JTUPSZ/FX%FMIJ *OEJB%FMIJ.FUSP
3BJM $PSQPSBUJPO "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXEFMIJNFUSPSBJMDPNIPNFIJTUPSZ
IUN"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS
(BLFOIFJNFS 31MBOOJOHUSBOTQPSUBUJPOBOEMBOEVTFGPSDJUJFTJO*OEJB$BN
CSJEHF .".BTTBDIVTFUUT*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZ
(BLFOIFJNFS 3 BOE$;FHSBT5SBWFMEFNBOEESJWFST.VNCBJBOE$IFO
OBJ *OEJB(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE8PSME#VTJOFTT$PVODJMGPS4VTUBJOBCMF%FWFM
PQNFOU

(BVS .%FMIJUPHFUOFXCVTXBZ*O*OTUJUVUFGPS5SBOTQPSUBUJPOBOE%FWFM
PQNFOU1PMJDZ4VTUBJOBCMF5SBOTQPSUFVQEBUF/P.BZo+VOF"WBJM
BCMFBUIUUQXXXJUEQPSH45F45FJOEFYIUNMEFMIJ"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS

*OEJBO3BJMXBZT"OOVBMTUBUJTUJDBMTUBUFNFOUT o/FX%FMIJ*OEJBO
3BJMXBZT
*OEJBO3BJMXBZT:FBSCPPLo/FX%FMIJ*OEJBO3BJMXBZT
,POLBO3BJMXBZ$PSQPSBUJPO-UE4LZCVTʾFVSCBOUSBOTQPSUUFDIOPMPHZ
GPSUIFOFXNJMMFOJVN/BWJ.VNCBJ *OEJBʾF,POLBO3BJMXBZ$PSQPSBUJPO
-UE"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXLPOLBOSBJMXBZDPNXFCTJUFFIUNTLZ@CVTIUN
"DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ
.BSXBI #3 7,4JCBM BOE44BXBOU#VTUSBOTQPSUJO%FMIJ*O.PSSJT
4FCBTUJBO FE *OEJB*OGSBTUSVDUVSF3FQPSU/FX%FMIJ *OEJB0YGPSE6OJ
WFSTJUZ1SFTT
.FUSP 3BJMXBZ ,PMLBUB 4UBUVT PG POHPJOH QSPKFDUT ,PMLBUB *OEJB .FUSP
3BJMXBZ ,PMLBUB "WBJMBCMF BUIUUQCVTJOFTTWTOMDPNNFUSPSMZTUBUVTIUNM
"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS
.JOJTUSZ PG 3BJMXBZT 4UBUVT QBQFS PO *OEJBO SBJMXBZT *TTVFT BOE PQUJPOT
/FX%FMIJ(PWFSONFOUPG*OEJB .JOJTUSZPG3BJMXBZT .BZ"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXJOEJBOSBJMXBZTHPWJOSBJMXBZTUBUVTQBQFSQEG"DDFTTFE+BOVBSZ

.JOJTUSZPG3PBE5SBOTQPSUBOE)JHIXBZT.PUPSUSBOTQPSUTUBUJTUJDT/FX
%FMIJ *OEJB"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQNPSUIOJDJONUTIUN"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS

.JOJTUSZPG3PBE5SBOTQPSUBOE)JHIXBZTBOE)BOECPPLPOUSBOTQPSU
TUBUJTUJDT JO *OEJB %FMIJ *OEJB 5SBOTQPSU 3FTFBSDI 0ċDF .JOJTUSZ PG 3PBE
5SBOTQPSUBOE)JHIXBZT
.VNCBJ .FUSPQPMJUBO 3FHJPO %FWFMPQNFOU "VUIPSJUZ .VNCBJ VSCBO
USBOTQPSUQSPKFDU.VNCBJ *OEJB..3%""WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXNNSEB
NVNCBJPSHNVUQIUN"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS

0ċDFPGUIF3FHJTUSBS(FOFSBMPG*OEJBi6SCBOBHHMPNFSBUJPOTDJUJFTIBWJOH
QPQVMBUJPOPGNPSFUIBOPOFNJMMJPOJOwJOʾF$FOTVTPG*OEJB/FX
%FMIJ *OEJB "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXDFOTVTJOEJBOFUSFTVMUTNJJMJPO@QMVT
IUNM"DDFTTFE/PWFNCFS
1BEBN 4 BOE4JOHI 4,6SCBOJ[BUJPOBOEVSCBOUSBOTQPSUJO*OEJBʾF
TLFUDIGPSBQPMJDZ1VOF *OEJB5SBOTQPSU"TJB1SPKFDU8PSLTIPQ"DDFTTJCMF
BU IUUQXXXEFBTIBSWBSEFEV5SBOTQPSU"TJBXPSLTIPQ@QBQFST1BEBN
4JOHIQEG
1FOEBLVS 7 4 " QPMJDZ QFSTQFDUJWF GPS TVTUBJOBCMF DJUJFT /PONPUPSJ[FE
USBOTQPSUJO"TJB7BODPVWFS $BOBEB6OJWFSTJUZPG#SJUJTI$PMVNCJB
3BNBDIBOESBO 36SCBOJ[BUJPOBOEVSCBOTZTUFNTJO*OEJB0YGPSE6OJWFS
TJUZ1SFTT 0YGPSE &OHMBOE
4PVUIFSO3BJMXBZ1SPKFDUT$IFOOBJ *OEJB4PVUIFSO3BJMXBZ"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXTPVUIFSOSBJMXBZPSHBCPVUVTQSPKFDUTBTQ "DDFTTFE /PWFNCFS

4SFFEIBSBO&/FFEGPSVSCBONBTTUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNGPSPVSDJUJFT/FX%FMIJ
*OEJB1SFTT*OGPSNBUJPO#VSFBV (PWFSONFOUPG*OEJB
7BSTIOFZB +BJO BOE4BIBJ4USBUFHZGPSTPMWJOHUSBOTQPSUQSPCMFNTJO.VN
CBJ.VNCBJ *OEJB*OEJBO3BJMXBZT
7BTDPODFMMPT &6SCBOUSBOTQPSU FOWJSPONFOUBOEFRVJUZʾFDBTFGPSEFWFM
PQJOHDPVOUSJFT-POEPO 6,&BSUITDBO1SFTT
8PSME#BOL*OEJBTUSBOTQPSUTFDUPSʾFDIBMMFOHFTBIFBE8BTIJOHUPO %$
ʾF8PSME#BOL
!BOUT THE !UTHOR

+Ġęğ1ĦĔęĖģ QVDIFS!SDJSVUHFSTFEV JTQSPGFTTPSPGVSCBOQMBOOJOHBOEQVCMJD
QPMJDZBU3VUHFST6OJWFSTJUZJO/FX#SVOTXJDL /FX+FSTFZ)FTQFDJBMJ[FTJODPN
QBSBUJWFSFTFBSDIPOUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNT USBWFMCFIBWJPS BOEQVCMJDQPMJDJFTJOUIF
6OJUFE4UBUFT $BOBEB BOE&VSPQF
/ĖĖğĦ*ĥĥĪĖģĒę OFFOVJUUZFSBI!IPUNBJMDPN JTBTFOJPSUSBOTQPSUNBOBHFSGPS
UIF*OEJBO3BJMXBZT DVSSFOUMZJODIBSHFPGUIFGSFJHIUPQFSBUJPOTBOEJOGPSNBUJPO

TZTUFNJOUIF4PVUIFSOBOE4PVUIXFTUFSO;POFT4IFTQFOUUIFoBDBEFNJD
ZFBSBU3VUHFST6OJWFSTJUZBTB)VNQISFZ'FMMPXPGUIF644UBUF%FQBSUNFOU
/ĚĤęĒ,ĠģĒĥĥĪĤĨĒģĠĠġĒĞ OJTIBL!FEFOSVUHFSTFEV JTB1I%DBOEJEBUFBU
&EXBSE+#MPVTUFJO4DIPPMPG1MBOOJOHBOE1VCMJD1PMJDZ 3VUHFST6OJWFSTJUZ /FX
#SVOTXJDL /FX+FSTFZ)FSSFTFBSDIJOUFSFTUTJODMVEFVSCBOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUBUJPO
BOEUSBOTQPSUBUJPOJOEFWFMPQJOHDPVOUSJFT

The Crisis of Public Transport in India - Overwhelming Needs But L

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Crisis of Public Transport in India - Overwhelming Needs But L

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

ʾF$SJTJTPG1VCMJD5SBOTQPSUJO*OEJB

4HE #RISIS OF 0UBLIC 4RANSPORT

4RENDS IN 0OPULATION AND ,AND 5SE

4RENDS IN 0UBLIC 4RANSPORT

&IGURE 'ROWTH IN 3UBURBAN 2AIL 4RAVEL IN )NDIAN #ITIES

PGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU DPNQBSFEUPBCPVUQFSDFOUJO.VNCBJ BOEQFSDFOU

&IGURE 0ERCENT $ISTRIBUTION OF 5RBAN 4RIPS BY -EANS OF 4RAVEL

0ROBLEMS AND #HALLENGES

ʾFTFDPOHFTUFEDPOEJUJPOTJOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUWFIJDMFT TUBUJPOT BOESJHIUTPG

&IGURE 'ROWTH OF )NDIAS -OTOR 6EHICLE &LEET BY 4YPE OF 6EHICLE

&IGURE 0ROPORTION OF /PERATING %XPENSES #OVERED BY 0ASSENGER

CVTQSJWBUJ[BUJPOʾVT QSJWBUJ[BUJPOTFFNTBOPQUJPOPOMZGPSCVTTFSWJDFT CVU

ʾVT UPTPNFFYUFOU UIFQSJWBUFCVTmSNTIBWFMPXFSDPTUTEVFUPMPXFSTBMBSJFT

DPNCJOBUJPOPGTUBUFBOEMPDBMHPWFSONFOUTVCTJEJFT HSBOUT BOEMPBOTUIBUWBSZ

2ECENT AND 0LANNED )MPROVEMENTS

2ECOMMENDED 0OLICY 3HIFTS

!BOUT THE !UTHOR

You might also like

The Crisis of Public Transport in India - Overwhelming Needs But L

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Crisis of Public Transport in India - Overwhelming Needs But L

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

ʾF$SJTJTPG1VCMJD5SBOTQPSUJO*OEJB

4HE #RISIS OF 0UBLIC 4RANSPORT

4RENDS IN 0OPULATION AND ,AND 5SE

4RENDS IN 0UBLIC 4RANSPORT

&IGURE  'ROWTH IN 3UBURBAN 2AIL 4RAVEL IN )NDIAN #ITIES

PGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU DPNQBSFEUPBCPVUQFSDFOUJO.VNCBJ BOEQFSDFOU

&IGURE  0ERCENT $ISTRIBUTION OF 5RBAN 4RIPS BY -EANS OF 4RAVEL

0ROBLEMS AND #HALLENGES

ʾFTFDPOHFTUFEDPOEJUJPOTJOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUWFIJDMFT TUBUJPOT BOESJHIUTPG

&IGURE  'ROWTH OF )NDIAS -OTOR 6EHICLE &LEET BY 4YPE OF 6EHICLE

&IGURE  0ROPORTION OF /PERATING %XPENSES #OVERED BY 0ASSENGER

CVTQSJWBUJ[BUJPOʾVT QSJWBUJ[BUJPOTFFNTBOPQUJPOPOMZGPSCVTTFSWJDFT CVU

ʾVT UPTPNFFYUFOU UIFQSJWBUFCVTmSNTIBWFMPXFSDPTUTEVFUPMPXFSTBMBSJFT

DPNCJOBUJPOPGTUBUFBOEMPDBMHPWFSONFOUTVCTJEJFT HSBOUT BOEMPBOTUIBUWBSZ

2ECENT AND 0LANNED )MPROVEMENTS

2ECOMMENDED 0OLICY 3HIFTS

!BOUT THE !UTHOR

You might also like

&IGURE 'ROWTH IN 3UBURBAN 2AIL 4RAVEL IN )NDIAN #ITIES

PGQVCMJDUSBOTQPSU DPNQBSFEUPBCPVUQFSDFOUJO.VNCBJ BOEQFSDFOU

&IGURE 0ERCENT $ISTRIBUTION OF 5RBAN 4RIPS BY -EANS OF 4RAVEL

ʾFTFDPOHFTUFEDPOEJUJPOTJOQVCMJDUSBOTQPSUWFIJDMFT TUBUJPOT BOESJHIUTPG

&IGURE 'ROWTH OF )NDIAS -OTOR 6EHICLE &LEET BY 4YPE OF 6EHICLE

&IGURE 0ROPORTION OF /PERATING %XPENSES #OVERED BY 0ASSENGER

CVTQSJWBUJ[BUJPOʾVT QSJWBUJ[BUJPOTFFNTBOPQUJPOPOMZGPSCVTTFSWJDFT CVU