You are on page 1of 87

The life cycles of viscous decretion

disks around Be stars: fundamental


disk parameters in the SMC

Leandro Rocha Rı́mulo

Departamento de Astronomia
Instituto de Astronomia, Geofı́sica e Ciências Atmosféricas
Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil

19 June 2017
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 1/49
Introduction

Small Magellanic Cloud (Credits: Davide De Martin)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 2/49
Introduction

Massive stars (M & 8M )

The main components of the


visible Universe and our
main sources of information
about it!
Harder to form and
short-lived;
The main sources of
luminosity in the spiral arms
and their supernovae are
responsible for the chemical
enrichment of the Universe;

HR-Diagram of 23000 nearby stars.

(Credits: http://www.atlasoftheuniverse.com)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 3/49
Introduction
Be stars

3M . M . 17M ,
non-supergiant;
“Spectrum has, or
had at some time,
Balmer lines in
emission” ⇒
circumstellar
material;
Are not rare!
Represent 10% to a
few dozens of the B
typed stars
(depending on
region)
The seven main stars of the Pleiades cluster.

(Credits: http://www.astrosurf.com/buil/us/bestar.htm)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 4/49
Introduction

Be stars
Understanding of Be stars leaped in
the last 10 years (advances in
observing and computational
techniques).

Disk-like (polarization,
spectrointerferometry);
double-peaked emission ⇒
essentially rotating disk;
the disk is completely ionized
and devoid of dust ⇒
chemically simpler than the
YSO disks!
Near-Keplerian (V/R
Schematic view of a Be star.
variations and
(Rivinius et al., 2013A&ARv..21...69R)
spectrointerferometry)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 5/49
Introduction
Be stars

Light curve of 28 CMa, over 33 years.

(M. Ghoreyshi, priv. comm.)

Be stars are quite variable in several timescales.


The disk is fed by injections of matter from the central star.
Be stars with disk are active. Be stars without disk are inactive.
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 6/49
Introduction
Be stars are fast rotators

The fastest rotators


among non-degenerate
stars.
Rotation is described by
veq
W = vorb ;
All Be stars:
W & 0.7
hW i = 0.81 ± 0.12
Fast rotation reduces geff
at the equator and, thus,
must be fundamentally
W = 0.62 vs
W = 0.90.
linked to the matter
Evolutionary tracks (Z = 0.014). ejection episodes.
(Rivinius et al., (Georgy et al.,
2013A&ARv..21...69R) 2013A&A...553A..24G)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 7/49
Introduction
Be stars are fast rotators

Two proposed mechanisms for


the rotation of Be starsa
1 core contraction +
internal AM
redistribution = enhance
Ωsurf
Be stars are
natural outcomes
of fast rotators at
the ZAMS
2 enhancement of Ωsurf by
mass transfer from
W = 0.62 vs binary companion
W = 0.90.
Evolutionary tracks (Z = 0.014). a
Ekström et al. 2008A&A...478..467E;
(Rivinius et al., (Georgy et al., Georgy et al. 2013A&A...553A..24G
2013A&ARv..21...69R) 2013A&A...553A..24G)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 7/49
Introduction

Therefore,
With their gaseous disks and fast rotation, Be stars turned
out to be fundamental laboratories to test the physical
mechanisms relevant for the upper main sequence!

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 8/49
Introduction
The Viscous Decretion Disk (VDD)
The VDD is the only theory
capable of describing the
observed features of the disks of
Be stars.
VDDs are accretion disks
with an inner source of mass
and AM.
The “Be mechanism”
(pulsation?) puts
material in orbit near
the stellar equator;
Scheme of the VDD.
The viscous
mechanism
(Porter & Rivinius, 2003PASP..115.1153P)
(magnetorotational
instability - MRI?)
diffuses part of that
material outwards.
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 9/49
Introduction
The Viscous Decretion Disk (VDD)
The steady-state VDD has been successful in modeling the
observables of Be stars.
Example:

VDD model of ζ Tau.

(Carciofi et al., 2009A&A...504..915C)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 10/49
Introduction

The Viscous Decretion Disk (VDD)


But... Several Be stars are far from steady-state.

Examples of OGLE light curves showing complex activity.1

1
Mennickent et al., 2002A&A...393..887M
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 11/49
Introduction
The Viscous Decretion Disk (VDD)
But... Several Be stars are far from steady-state.

A precious fraction of light curves of Be stars show bumps and dips and
clear inactive phases.1

1
Mennickent et al., 2002A&A...393..887M
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 11/49
Introduction

The Viscous Decretion Disk (VDD)


The bumps and dips resemble
Bump (pole-on): the photometric predictions of
simple dynamical VDDs with
on/off mass injection rates.

Dip (edge-on):

Theoretical bump.

(Haubois et al., 2012ApJ...756..156H)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 12/49
Introduction
The Viscous Decretion Disk (VDD)
The α parameter is an important and largely unknown physical
parameter!
Realization: The α viscosity parameter is the main responsible
for the timescale of the variations!
Carciofi et al., 2012ApJ...744L..15C estimated, for the first
time, α ≈ 1 for a Be disk (recently revisited to α ≈ 0.21).

First determination of α for a Be star.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th


(Carciofi et, 2017
al., 2012ApJ...744L..15C)
Dynamical viscous decretion disks 13/49
Introduction

The realization that the light curves of Be stars offer


the key for measuring α directly provided the main
motivation of this work.

This thesis studies the two main ingredients of the VDD:


The “Be mechanism”: the source of mass and angular
momentum at the base of the disk
The viscous mechanism, which is responsible for the
diffusion of mass and angular momentum outwards,
creating the gaseous disk.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 14/49
A study of the dynamical
VDD

HDUST image of the VDD of ζ Tau (in 2.16µm).

(Carciofi et al., 2009A&A...504..915C)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 15/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

Physical description of the VDD

∂ρ
+ ∇ · (ρv) = S , Mass continuity equation
∂t
and
 
∂v
ρ + v · ∇v = F ∗ − ∇P + ∇ · W , Equation of motion
∂t

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 16/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

Physical description of the VDD

∂ρ
+ ∇ · (ρv) = S , Mass continuity equation
∂t
and
 
∂v
ρ + v · ∇v = F ∗ − ∇P + ∇ · W , Equation of motion
∂t

Assuming a thin and axisymmetric disk


F ∗ = −ρ GM
r2
r̂ (circumstellar disk)
kT
P = c2s ρ, where c2s = µmH (ideal gas)
WRφ = −αP (viscosity parameter)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 16/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

Physical description of the VDD


 1 !  
∂Σ 2 ∂ R 2 ∂ 2 2  S
= αcs R Σ +Σ ⇐ SINGLEBE
∂t R ∂R GM ∂R ρ

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 17/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

Physical description of the VDD


 1 !  
∂Σ 2 ∂ R 2 ∂ 2 2  S
= αcs R Σ +Σ ⇐ SINGLEBE
∂t R ∂R GM ∂R ρ

Be mechanism:

 
S δ(R − Rinj )
Σ = Ṁinj (t)
ρ R

Torque-free inner and outer boundaries:


Σ(Req , t) = Σ(Rout , t) = 0

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 17/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

Example of dynamical VDD producing complex light curves:

 1 !
∂Σ 2 ∂ R 2 ∂ 2 2  δ(R − Rinj )
= αcs R Σ + Ṁinj (t) , Req < R < Rout
∂t R ∂R GM ∂R R

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 18/49
A study of the dynamical VDD
1. Timescale and time parameters
Realization: With the scaling in time and spatial dimensions of the disk
equation, it is possible to generate dynamical models independent of
the stellar and disk parameters M , Req , Teff and α(t). They are left to
be determined by the observations.

 1 !
∂Σ 2 ∂ R 2 ∂ 2 2  δ(R − Rinj )
= αcs R Σ + Ṁinj (t) , Req < R < Rout
∂t R ∂R GM ∂R R

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 19/49
A study of the dynamical VDD
1. Timescale and time parameters
Realization: With the scaling in time and spatial dimensions of the disk
equation, it is possible to generate dynamical models independent of
the stellar and disk parameters M , Req , Teff and α(t). They are left to
be determined by the observations.

 1 !
∂Σ 2 ∂ R 2 ∂ 2 2  δ(R − Rinj )
= αcs R Σ + Ṁinj (t) , Req < R < Rout
∂t R ∂R GM ∂R R

Assuming isothermal disk and α(R, t) = α(t):

( ! )
δ(R̃ − R̃inj )
 
∂Σ 1 2 ∂ 1 ∂
 τ (t)Ṁinj (t)
⇒ = R̃ 2 R̃2 Σ + 2
, 1 < R̃ < R̃out
∂t τ (t) R̃ ∂ R̃ ∂ R̃ 2πReq R̃

where R̃ = R/Req and


 3  12 2
1 Req vorb
τ (t) = , timescale parameter
α(t) GM c2s
and τ̃ (t) is the time parameter, such that dτ̃ = dt/τ (t)
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 19/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

2. The problem of R̃inj


!
δ(R̃ − R̃inj )
 
∂Σ 2 ∂ 1 ∂  2  τ (τ̃ )Ṁinj (τ̃ )
= R̃
2 R̃ Σ + 2
, 1 < R̃ < R̃out
∂ τ̃ R̃ ∂ R̃ ∂ R̃ 2πReq R̃

⇒ We don’t have direct means for measuring Rinj !

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 20/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

2. The problem of R̃inj


!
δ(R̃ − R̃inj )
 
∂Σ 2 ∂ 1 ∂  2  τ (τ̃ )Ṁinj (τ̃ )
= R̃2 R̃ Σ + 2
, 1 < R̃ < R̃out
∂ τ̃ R̃ ∂ R̃ ∂ R̃ 2πReq R̃

⇒ We don’t have direct means for measuring Rinj !


Based on the steady-state solution of the VDD:

 
Req  1

2πReq Σ0 (τ̃ ) = Ṁinj (τ̃ ) R̃inj 2 − 1
τ (τ̃ )
where Σ0 is the asymptotic surface density, which means that
!
δ(R̃ − R̃inj )
 
∂Σ 2 ∂ 1 ∂
 Σ0 (τ̃ )
⇒ = R̃ 2 R̃2 Σ + 1 , 1 < R̃ < R̃out
∂ τ̃ R̃ ∂ R̃ ∂ R̃ R̃inj 2 − 1 R̃

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 20/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

3. Relevant steady-state physical quantities


 
  1
Req
2πReq Σ0 τ
2
= Ṁinj R̃inj − 1 : asymptotic surface density;
1
 
Req
−J˙std = Λ (GM Req ) 2 2πReq Σ0 τ
: steady-state stellar AM loss
rate

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 21/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

3. Relevant steady-state physical quantities


 
  1
Req
2πReq Σ0 τ
2
= Ṁinj R̃inj − 1 : asymptotic surface density;
1
 
Req
−J˙std = Λ (GM Req ) 2 2πReq Σ0 τ
: steady-state stellar AM loss
rate

One long bump: −J˙std is a good measure of the


instantaneous stellar AM loss rate in

a dynamical disk!

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 21/49
A study of the dynamical VDD

4. The mass reservoir effect

The longer the build-up time, the larger is the external mass
reservoir ⇒ makes reaccretion appear slower.
New parameter: τ̃bu : the scaled build-up time.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 22/49
A model grid of bumps

Alphacrucis cluster (IAG-USP) (Credits: http://jornal.usp.br)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 23/49
A model grid of bumps

Motivation: To extract from bumps/dips like these:

...all the relevant physical quantities for better understanding


the Be mechanism and the viscous mechanism.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 24/49
A model grid of bumps

Radiative transfer models of bumps


MCRT code HDUST;
Geneva tracksa :
Z, M, t/tMS , W →
Req , Teff , etc;
Grav. darkening
β b
(Tsurf ∝ geff ) ;
Absolute magnitudes in
4 standard filters: MB ,
Simulated frequency domain. MV , MR , MI .
a
Georgy et al. 2013A&A...553A..24G
b
Espinosa-Lara & Rieutord 2011A&A...533A..43E

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 25/49
A model grid of bumps
Radiative transfer models of bumps

Table: Representative grid of photometric bumps


Star i [deg] Σ0 [g cm−2 ] τ̃bu
Star 1 00.0 0.30 00.15
Star 2 21.8 0.41 00.45
Star 3 31.0 0.56 00.75
38.2 0.75 01.50
44.4 1.01 02.25
50.0 1.37 03.00
55.2 1.85 04.50
60.0 2.50 06.00
64.6 09.00
69.1 15.00
73.4 30.00
77.6
81.8
85.9
90.0

Star Z M [M ] W t/tMS ατ [d]


Star 1 0.002 7 0.81 0.5 90.4
Star 2 0.002 11 0.81 0.5 103.3
Star 3 0.002 15 0.81 0.5 118.9

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 26/49
A model grid of bumps

An empirical law for pole-on and edge-on


light curves
Motivation: Empirical formulas that are good approximations of the
simulated light curves allow an easy comparison between the real light
curves and the simulated light curves.

Build-up: Dissipation:
   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd

h i
∞ 1−
Continuity condition: ∆Xd0 = ∆Xbu 1
1+(ξbu τ̃bu )ηbu

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 27/49
A model grid of bumps
Examples of computed light curves and empirical law fittings:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 28/49
A model grid of bumps
Examples of computed light curves and empirical law fittings:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 28/49
A model grid of bumps
Examples of computed light curves and empirical law fittings:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 28/49
A model grid of bumps
Examples of computed light curves and empirical law fittings:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 28/49
A model grid of bumps

   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd


∆Xbu (Star, cos i, Σ0 )
Maximum excess
produced by the disk

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 29/49
A model grid of bumps

   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd

ξbu (Star, cos i, Σ0 )


Regulates the rate of
photometric build-up
“Pole-on disks appear to
build-up faster”
Σ0 has little effect on ξbu

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 30/49
A model grid of bumps

   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd

ξd (Star, cos i, Σ0 , τ̃bu )


Regulates the rate of
photometric dissipation
“Pole-on disks appear to
dissipate faster”
“Denser disks appear to
dissipate slowly”
Reservoir effect: disks
with bigger τ̃bu appear
to dissipate slowly

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 31/49
A model grid of bumps

   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd

ξd (Star, cos i, Σ0 , τ̃bu )


Regulates the rate of
photometric dissipation
“Pole-on disks appear to
dissipate faster”
“Denser disks appear to
dissipate slowly”
Reservoir effect: disks
with bigger τ̃bu appear
to dissipate slowly

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 31/49
A model grid of bumps

A fitting pipeline for bumps


   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd

2
as suggested by Ghoreyshi et al. 2017.
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 32/49
A model grid of bumps

A fitting pipeline for bumps


   
∞ 1 1
∆Xbu = ∆Xbu 1− ∆Xd = ∆Xd0
1 + (ξbu τ̃ )ηbu 1 + (ξd (τ̃ − τ̃bu ))ηd

From τ̃ to t: We assume α(t) = αbu during build-up and


α(t) = αd during the dissipation2
3  12 2
αbu t−t
 
ατ
1
, t1 ≤ t < t2 Req vorb
τ̃ = −t1 , where ατ =
αbu t2ατ + αd t−t
ατ
2
, t ≥ t2 GM c2s

2
as suggested by Ghoreyshi et al. 2017.
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 32/49
A model grid of bumps
A fitting pipeline for bumps

1 Find a light curve of a Be star that contains at least one clear inactive
phase and one complete bump;

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 33/49
A model grid of bumps
A fitting pipeline for bumps

1 Find a light curve of a Be star that contains at least one clear inactive
phase and one complete bump;
2 Subtract the magnitudes X∗ and describe the bump by ∆X(t);

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 33/49
A model grid of bumps
A fitting pipeline for bumps

1 Find a light curve of a Be star that contains at least one clear inactive
phase and one complete bump;
2 Subtract the magnitudes X∗ and describe the bump by ∆X(t);

3 Fit the “bump equation” and obtain the parameters ∆Xbu , Cbu , Cd ,
t1 and t2 ;

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 33/49
A model grid of bumps
A fitting pipeline for bumps

1 Find a light curve of a Be star that contains at least one clear inactive
phase and one complete bump;
2 Subtract the magnitudes X∗ and describe the bump by ∆X(t);

3 Fit the “bump equation” and obtain the parameters ∆Xbu , Cbu , Cd ,
t1 and t2 ;
4 Transform the apparent magnitudes X∗ to absolute magnitudes MX∗ ;

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 33/49
A model grid of bumps
A fitting pipeline for bumps

1 Find a light curve of a Be star that contains at least one clear inactive
phase and one complete bump;
2 Subtract the magnitudes X∗ and describe the bump by ∆X(t);

3 Fit the “bump equation” and obtain the parameters ∆Xbu , Cbu , Cd ,
t1 and t2 ;
4 Transform the apparent magnitudes X∗ to absolute magnitudes MX∗ ;
5 Estimate the stellar parameters, the geometric parameter (cos i) and
the bump parameters (Σ0 , αbu , αd ) based on the measured
parameters and our grid of models.
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 33/49
A model grid of bumps
Our approach: Fitting using MCMC
sampling
Spoilers:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 34/49
A model grid of bumps
Our approach: Fitting using MCMC
sampling
Spoilers:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 34/49
A model grid of bumps
Our approach: Fitting using MCMC
sampling
Spoilers:

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 34/49
Estimating fundamental disk
parameters with light curves

OGLE Warsaw Telescope (Las Campanas - Chile)

(Credits: http://naukawobiektywie.us.edu.pl/2014/galeria/zd27_3.jpg)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 35/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves
OGLE II + III light curves from the SMC
Mennickent et al.a
selected ∼ 1000 light
curves of Be candidates
from OGLE
microlensing survey;
Bumps and dips roughly
correspond to their
type-1 and 2 light curves
(belong to early B stars
with circumstellar
emission - Paul et al.b ).
In this work, we selected
54 light curves with 81
OGLE II and OGLE III fields in the SMC
bumps.
(Wyrzykowski et al. 2011MNRAS.416.2949W)
a
Mennickent et al. 2002A&A...393..887M
b
Paul et al. 2012MNRAS.421.3622P
th
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19 , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 36/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves

Example:

One bump of
SMC SC5 65500.

−2
Σ0 = 1.7+0.6
−0.4 g cm

αbu = 0.7+0.38
−0.34

αd = 0.26+0.13
−0.1

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 37/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves
Whole sample - Mass distribution
Our sample is biased
towards more massive stars!

Blue: distribution of M
for our sample;
Green: IMF weighed by
fraction of Be stars from
the SMCa
Possible reasons for bias:
Uncertainties
increase with
magnitude;
Galactic late Be stars
are less dense and
variable.
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017
a Dynamical viscous decretion disks 38/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves
Whole sample - Asymptotic surface density

Slight trend: Σ0
increases with M ;
Our sample is biased
towards high disk
density (in comparison
with Vieira et al.a ).
Our sample must represent
the upper limit for disk
densities in the SMC.
a
Vieira et al. 2017MNRAS.464.3071V

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 39/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves

Whole sample - Disk life cycles


The duration of the bumps
diminish towards massive
stars. This suggests that early
Be stars from the SMC are
more variable, just like the
Galactic ones.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 40/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves

Whole sample - Viscosity parameter


First note: there was a
large variability in our
determinations of α.
hαbu i = 0.63+0.52
−0.39
and
hαd i = 0.29+0.61
−0.20 .
Agreement with
disks of dwarf
novae!
Disagreement
with usual models
with MRI
predictions!

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 41/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves
Whole sample - Angular momentum loss
Simultaneous
determinations of Σ0
and αbu allow the
determination of the
steady-state AM loss
rate −J˙std .
Typical −J˙std for our
dense disks are
∼ 5 × 1036 g cm2 s−2 .
Disagreement: Geneva
modelsa of early Be
stars predict AM loss
rates ∼ 10 times bigger
than the obtained by
our densest disks!
a
Granada et al. 2013A&A...553A..25G
th
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19 , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 42/49
Estimating fundamental disk parameters
with light curves

Whole sample - Angular momentum loss


Granada et al.a showed
that reducing WMAX ,
they generate disks for
longer periods, but the
AM loss rates are
negligibly affected!
Therefore, our
results for AM
loss indicate that
their assumed
internal
coupling isn’t
too strong!
a
Granada et al. 2013A&A...553A..25G

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 42/49
Conclusions

OGLE Warsaw Telescope (Las Campanas - Chile)

(Credits: Ewa Zegler-Poleska)

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 43/49
Conclusions

Be stars can be selected from the bulk of surveys by their photometric


variability. Some precious! light curves present clear bumps/dips
and clear inactive phases, making them specially easy to model.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 44/49
Conclusions

Be stars can be selected from the bulk of surveys by their photometric


variability. Some precious! light curves present clear bumps/dips
and clear inactive phases, making them specially easy to model.
We presented a new method to model the bumps and dips from the
light curves. The method uses a time-scaled pre-computed grid
Be light curves, calculated using the alpha-disk theory and
non-LTE radiative transfer simulations.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 44/49
Conclusions

Be stars can be selected from the bulk of surveys by their photometric


variability. Some precious! light curves present clear bumps/dips
and clear inactive phases, making them specially easy to model.
We presented a new method to model the bumps and dips from the
light curves. The method uses a time-scaled pre-computed grid
Be light curves, calculated using the alpha-disk theory and
non-LTE radiative transfer simulations.
We found two empirical laws that describe well the
simulated bumps and dips. They allowed simplification of
the fitting process.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 44/49
Conclusions

Be stars can be selected from the bulk of surveys by their photometric


variability. Some precious! light curves present clear bumps/dips
and clear inactive phases, making them specially easy to model.
We presented a new method to model the bumps and dips from the
light curves. The method uses a time-scaled pre-computed grid
Be light curves, calculated using the alpha-disk theory and
non-LTE radiative transfer simulations.
We found two empirical laws that describe well the
simulated bumps and dips. They allowed simplification of
the fitting process.
The α parameter is the most important in controling the
observed rates of build-up and dissipation, but it is not the
only one. Other parameters (M , Req , cos i, Σ0 , etc.) are
also important and they must be estimated in order to
estimate α.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 44/49
Conclusions

Be stars can be selected from the bulk of surveys by their photometric


variability. Some precious! light curves present clear bumps/dips
and clear inactive phases, making them specially easy to model.
We presented a new method to model the bumps and dips from the
light curves. The method uses a time-scaled pre-computed grid
Be light curves, calculated using the alpha-disk theory and
non-LTE radiative transfer simulations.
We found two empirical laws that describe well the
simulated bumps and dips. They allowed simplification of
the fitting process.
The α parameter is the most important in controling the
observed rates of build-up and dissipation, but it is not the
only one. Other parameters (M , Req , cos i, Σ0 , etc.) are
also important and they must be estimated in order to
estimate α.
We identified the “mass reservoir effect”, which can also
affect determinations of α.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 44/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);
The most massive stars appear to be more variable;

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);
The most massive stars appear to be more variable;
We measured α for the first time for a statistically
significant sample of Be stars.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);
The most massive stars appear to be more variable;
We measured α for the first time for a statistically
significant sample of Be stars.
Viscosity during the build-up is frequently bigger than
+0.52
during dissipation (hαbu i = 0.63−0.39 and hαd i = 0.29+0.61
−0.20 ).

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);
The most massive stars appear to be more variable;
We measured α for the first time for a statistically
significant sample of Be stars.
Viscosity during the build-up is frequently bigger than
+0.52
during dissipation (hαbu i = 0.63−0.39 and hαd i = 0.29+0.61
−0.20 ).
Determinations of α challenge models based on the MRI!;

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);
The most massive stars appear to be more variable;
We measured α for the first time for a statistically
significant sample of Be stars.
Viscosity during the build-up is frequently bigger than
+0.52
during dissipation (hαbu i = 0.63−0.39 and hαd i = 0.29+0.61
−0.20 ).
Determinations of α challenge models based on the MRI!;
We draw attention to the AM loss of Be stars and
measured AM loss rates for a statistically significant sample
of Be stars.

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Conclusions
We applied our pipeline to 54 selected light curves from the SMC
(low metallicity) containing 81 bumps/dips.
Fundamental parameters for individual stars had large
uncertainties;
Study of the whole sample showed that we selected
early Be stars with the densest disks
(hΣ0 i = 1.44+1.01
−0.75 g cm
−2
);
The most massive stars appear to be more variable;
We measured α for the first time for a statistically
significant sample of Be stars.
Viscosity during the build-up is frequently bigger than
+0.52
during dissipation (hαbu i = 0.63−0.39 and hαd i = 0.29+0.61
−0.20 ).
Determinations of α challenge models based on the MRI!;
We draw attention to the AM loss of Be stars and
measured AM loss rates for a statistically significant sample
of Be stars.
Determinations of AM loss by Be stars challenge the
assumptions of internal coupling of AM in stellar
evolutionary models!
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 45/49
Perspectives

(Credits: Boris Dmitriev)


Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 46/49
Perspectives

Observational perspectives
Modeling bumps/dips from the light curves of the LMC, selected by
Sabogal et al.3 . (Currently working!);

3
Sabogal et al. 2005MNRAS.361.1055S
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 47/49
Perspectives

Observational perspectives
Modeling bumps/dips from the light curves of the LMC, selected by
Sabogal et al.3 . (Currently working!);
Obtain spectroscopic and photometric data of Be stars with bumps
belonging to star clusters. Constraining stellar parameters will allow
better constraints on disk parameters! (SOAR proposal sent!);

3
Sabogal et al. 2005MNRAS.361.1055S
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 47/49
Perspectives

Observational perspectives
Modeling bumps/dips from the light curves of the LMC, selected by
Sabogal et al.3 . (Currently working!);
Obtain spectroscopic and photometric data of Be stars with bumps
belonging to star clusters. Constraining stellar parameters will allow
better constraints on disk parameters! (SOAR proposal sent!);
Try to remove the bias of densest disks! The disks are brighter in
the IR. Why not combine OGLE-IV light curves (V and I bands)
with VISTA-VMC light curves (J, H, Ks bands)?

3
Sabogal et al. 2005MNRAS.361.1055S
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 47/49
Perspectives

Observational perspectives
Modeling bumps/dips from the light curves of the LMC, selected by
Sabogal et al.3 . (Currently working!);
Obtain spectroscopic and photometric data of Be stars with bumps
belonging to star clusters. Constraining stellar parameters will allow
better constraints on disk parameters! (SOAR proposal sent!);
Try to remove the bias of densest disks! The disks are brighter in
the IR. Why not combine OGLE-IV light curves (V and I bands)
with VISTA-VMC light curves (J, H, Ks bands)?
Extend our study to Galactic Be stars showing bumps/dips and
take advantage of the photometric surveys using smaller telescopes
(e.g., ASAS, HATNet, KELT, SuperWASP, etc.). Try to crossmatch
with GAIA distances. (Contact with KELT team has been made!);

3
Sabogal et al. 2005MNRAS.361.1055S
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 47/49
Perspectives

Observational perspectives
Modeling bumps/dips from the light curves of the LMC, selected by
Sabogal et al.3 . (Currently working!);
Obtain spectroscopic and photometric data of Be stars with bumps
belonging to star clusters. Constraining stellar parameters will allow
better constraints on disk parameters! (SOAR proposal sent!);
Try to remove the bias of densest disks! The disks are brighter in
the IR. Why not combine OGLE-IV light curves (V and I bands)
with VISTA-VMC light curves (J, H, Ks bands)?
Extend our study to Galactic Be stars showing bumps/dips and
take advantage of the photometric surveys using smaller telescopes
(e.g., ASAS, HATNet, KELT, SuperWASP, etc.). Try to crossmatch
with GAIA distances. (Contact with KELT team has been made!);
Polarimetry can constrain the inclination angle! Follow Galactic Be
stars with our polarimetric campaigns at OPD.

3
Sabogal et al. 2005MNRAS.361.1055S
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 47/49
Perspectives

Theoretical perspectives
The determinations of α could be affected by our assumption of
isothermal disk! Adapt SINGLEBE and HDUST to operate in a
non-isothermal treatment of the disk evolution. (I’d love to
participate on that!)

4
Kee et al. 2016MNRAS.458.2323K
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 48/49
Perspectives

Theoretical perspectives
The determinations of α could be affected by our assumption of
isothermal disk! Adapt SINGLEBE and HDUST to operate in a
non-isothermal treatment of the disk evolution. (I’d love to
participate on that!)
Try to adress (even with approximations) the problem of the
line-driven wind raised by Kee et al.4 . How important is the radiative
wind?

4
Kee et al. 2016MNRAS.458.2323K
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 48/49
Perspectives

Theoretical perspectives
The determinations of α could be affected by our assumption of
isothermal disk! Adapt SINGLEBE and HDUST to operate in a
non-isothermal treatment of the disk evolution. (I’d love to
participate on that!)
Try to adress (even with approximations) the problem of the
line-driven wind raised by Kee et al.4 . How important is the radiative
wind?
Can we collaborate with the Geneva team in adressing the
angular momentum lost by the stars, which is transported by the
disks?

4
Kee et al. 2016MNRAS.458.2323K
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 48/49
Perspectives

Theoretical perspectives
The determinations of α could be affected by our assumption of
isothermal disk! Adapt SINGLEBE and HDUST to operate in a
non-isothermal treatment of the disk evolution. (I’d love to
participate on that!)
Try to adress (even with approximations) the problem of the
line-driven wind raised by Kee et al.4 . How important is the radiative
wind?
Can we collaborate with the Geneva team in adressing the
angular momentum lost by the stars, which is transported by the
disks?
Can we collaborate with turbulence theoreticians in building a
VDD from MHD simulations?

4
Kee et al. 2016MNRAS.458.2323K
Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 48/49
Thank you!

Leandro R. Rı́mulo — Jun 19th , 2017 Dynamical viscous decretion disks 49/49

You might also like