You are on page 1of 9

  !

  " 




+IB85F=*5A56<CH@5(<   +H9D<9B 5MB9(<  


+9B=CF%9A69F! +9B=CF%9A69F!
/CF79GH9F(C@MH97<B=7!BGH=HIH9 ,9L5G,97<-B=J9FG=HM
/CF79GH9F%-+ $I66C7?,0-+
GH9D<9B 65MB9HHI 98I
GF5A56<CH@5KD= 98I


 !  !&,*'-,!'&
          ! "
,<99@97HF=7DCK9F=GH<9@5F;9GHGMGH9AK<=7<=ADFCJ98H<9
       ! "     
  "    !  !  "  EI5@=HM C: A5B?=B8 ;F95H@M  ,<9 <=;< JC@H5;9 5@H9FB5H=B;
             7IFF9BH=GK=89@MIG9857FCGGH<9KCF@8HF5BGA=GG=CBC:DCK9F 
"      "    %C89FBDCK9FGMGH9AG<5J979FH5=B7CBGHF5=BHG@=?9G97IF=HM
!       "  ! F9@=56=@=HM5B8DCK9FEI5@=HMC:DCK9FGIDD@M ,<989D@9H=CBC:
 ! "! "  :CGG=@:I9@G5B8H<9=F9::97HCBH<99BJ=FCBA9BH@98HC5@H9FB5H9
! "   "        A9H<C8G C: DCK9F ;9B9F5H=CB 3 4  ,<9 F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M
 ! "   " GCIF79G =BH9;F5H=CB =BHC H<9 DCK9F GMGH9A 75IG98 H<9
  "        !   "  HF5BG:CFA5H=CBC:H<98=GHF=6IH=CB;F=8GHC57H=J9B9HKCF?G:FCA
       D5GG=J9B9HKCF?G ,<=G<9@DGHC57<=9J9H<96=8=F97H=CB5@5B8
     7CBHFC@@98DCK9F:@CKC:H<99@97HF=7=HM=BH<9DCK9FGMGH9A
   "  ! "    
3 4 34  ,<9 D9B9HF5H=CB C: F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M GCIF79G 5B8
 "         
9@97HF=7DCK9FGMGH9AF9GHFI7HIF=B;@98HCH<9=AD@9A9BH5H=CB
         # 
"
C: G97IF9 @9GG 7CGH 5B8 =ADFCJ98 F9@=56=@=HM  =;  69@CK
 =@@IGHF5H9G H<9 HCH5@ KCF@8 9B9F;M 7CBGIADH=CB 6M H<9 M95F
        "  "  
! " ""
   



=;  CBGIADH=CBC:@97HF=7=HM7FCGGH<9/CF@83 4

 A=7FC;F=8 =BH9;F5H9G =GHF=6IH98 B9F;M *9GCIF79G AC89 C: CD9F5H=CB  ,<9 7F=H=75@ @C58 GIDD@=9G DCK9F =B H<9
*G5@CB;K=H<H<9CBHFC@@56@95B8-B7CBHFC@@56@9@C58G =G@5B898AC89HCH<97F=H=75@@C58G  I;958J5BH5;9G9L=GH:CF
5B8 GIDD@=9G H<9 DCK9F HC H<9 @C58G @C75H98 B95F6M   H<9 A=7FC;F=8 @=?9 A5L=A=N98 F9@=56=@=HM @CK CD9F5H=B; 7CGH
A=7FC;F=87CBB97HGHCH<9DCK9F;F=8K=H<H<9<9@DC:(C=BHC: =B7F95G9=BH<997CBCAM5B8F9J9BI9=ADFCJ9;F=8F9G=@=9B7M
CAACBCID@=B;( %=7FC;F=8CD9F5H9G=BHKCAC89G 9H7  34 3 4  ,<9 9BH=F9 A=7FC;F=8 5@CB; K=H< H<9 8=GHF=6IH98
;F=87CBB97H985B8=G@5B898AC89G /<9B5:5I@HC77IFGH<9 9B9F;MGCIF79G5F97CBHFC@@986M%=7FCGCIF79CBHFC@@9F5B8
A=7FC;F=8=BH<9;F=87CBB97H98AC897<5B;9GHCH<9=G@5B898 9BHF5@CBHFC@@9FG 




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
%=7FC;F=8=GCB9C:H<9ACGHDF9:9FF98:CFH<958J5B79A9BH =G C: ;F95H 89A5B8 6975IG9 C: =HG 58J5BH5;9G @=?9
C::IHIF9DCK9FGMGH9AG8I9HCH<9=B7F95G9=BH<9=BH9;F5H=CB 9BJ=FCBA9BH5@@M :F=9B8@M =B B5HIF9 @9GG CD9F5H=CB 5B8
C: *G 5B8 89A5B8 F9GDCBG9 7CBHF=6IH=CB :FCA H<9 A5=BH9B5B797CGHBC75F6CB9A=GG=CB5B85@GCG=B79H<9:CGG=@
7IGHCA9FG  +CA9 7F=H=75@ @C58G F9EI=F9 H<9 DCK9F GIDD@M :I9@G5F9C:<I;9DF=79 ,<9=B7F95G9=BDCDI@5H=CB=G5@GC?9M
IB=BH9FFIDH98@M K<=7< A5B85H9G H<9 CD9F5H=CB C: GA5FH 75IG9C:DCK9F89A5B857FCGGH<9KCF@8 
A=7FC;F=834 9B9F5H=CBH<FCI;<F9B9K56@99B9F;MF9GCIF79G



=;  ,MD=75@%=7FC;F=8+HFI7HIF9!B7@I8=B;$C58G5B8*-B=HG+9FJ=7986M5=GHF=6IH=CB+MGH9A

=;   56CJ9 =@@IGHF5H9G H<9 A=7FC;F=8 5F7<=H97HIF9 K=H< 5@@ 9H7 ,<=G75B69D9F:CFA98K=H<CIH7CBG=89F=B;H<9B9HKCF?98
H<9=GHF=6IH98B9F;M*9GCIF79G*G5B8@C58G3 4 ,<=G 7CB:=;IF5H=CB5B8F9GHF=7H98HF5BG:9F75D57=HM34 
D5D9F =G CF;5B=N98 5G :C@@CKG !B G97H=CB !!  F9J=9K CB !B 34 5 A=7FC;F=8 =G 7CBG=89F98 K=H< J5F=56@9 GD998
F9@=56=@=HM C: A=7FC;F=8 7CBG=89F=B; J5F=CIG H97<B=EI9G 5B8 ;9B9F5HCF=G9J5@I5H98:CF;9B9F5H=CB5B8F9@=56=@=HMC:DCK9F
A9H<C8G  @GC H<9 7<5@@9B;9G 5B8 GC@IH=CBG 5F9 9@56CF5H98 GIDD@M@C75H985H9FA9IG9&9K:CIB8@5B85B585 CFH<9
:FCA H<9 =AD@9A9BH5H=CB C: J5F=CIG CDH=A=N5H=CB H97<B=EI9G F9@=56=@=HM 9J5@I5H=CB C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 5 *9@=56=@=HM @C7?
:CF H<9 A=7FC;F=8 GMGH9AG 5B8 H<9 D5D9F 7CB7@I89G K=H< H<9 =5;F5A*7CB79DH=G89J9@CD985@CB;K=H<H<9F9@=56=@=HM
F9:9F9B79G  AC89@ C: 5@@ GI6 GMGH9AG =B H<9 %/ DCK9F F5H98 J5F=56@9
 GD998 K=B8 ;9B9F5HCF  ,<9 F9@=56=@=HM AC89@ C: H<9 J5F=56@9
!!  *$!!$!,1 GD998K=B8;9B9F5HCF=G89J9@CD986M7CBG=89F=B;H<99::97HC:
*9@=56=@=HM=GCB9C:H<9A5=B7F=H9F=5F9EI=F98:CFGIDD@M=B; H<9 J5F=56@9 K=B8 GD998  ,<9 89J9@CD98 A=7FC;F=8 AC89@ =G
H<9DCK9FHCH<9@C75@7IGHCA9FG@=?9 G7<CC@G<CGD=H5@G9H7  H<IG 7CBG=89F98 :CF 9J5@I5H=B; H<9 F9@=56=@=HM GHI8M K=H< H<9
5B8<5G5<I;99::97HCB;F=897CBCAM5B8G97IF=HM *9G95F7< <9@D C: H<FCI;< %CBH9 5F@C G=AI@5H=CB IG=B; %,$ 
=G69=B;9L97IH98CBH<9AC89@=B;5B875@7I@5H=CBC:F9@=56=@=HM IF=B;H<9;F=87CBB97H98AC89H<9F9@=56=@=HMD9F:CFA5B79C:
C: ID7CA=B; A=7FC;F=8 8=GHF=6IH=CB GMGH9AG @=?9 8=GHF=6IH98 ;9B9F5H=CB 5B8 GIDD@M DCK9F =B H<9 A=7FC;F=8 C6H5=BG 
;9B9F5H=CB ,<9G=AI@5H=CBH97<B=EI9G5B88=G7IGG=CBCB IB89F J5F=CIG CD9F5H=CB5@ AC89@G K<9F95G =B H<9 =G@5B898
H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 5F9 H5?9B =BHC 7CBG=89F5H=CB  AC89H<9F9@=56=@=HMC6H5=B98=G IB89FG5A975G9GHI8M 
,<=G D5D9F DFCJ=89G 5 F9J=9K CB F9@=56=@=HM C: A=7FC;F=8 ,<=G=AD@=9GH<5HH<9F9@=56=@=HMC:H<9A=7FC;F=8=G<=;<=B6CH<
7CBG=89F=B; J5F=CIG H97<B=EI9G 5B8 A9H<C8G  ,<9 GC@IH=CBG H<9 75G9G C: ;F=8 7CBB97H98 5B8 =G@5B898 AC89G  ,<=G =G
5@CB; K=H< H<9 7<5@@9B;9G 5F9 F9J=9K98 :CF H<9 A=7FC;F=8G C6H5=B98K=H<H<9=AD@9A9BH5H=CBC:H<9A5L=A=N98F9B9K56@9
=BH9;F5H98 K=H< H<9 *9B9K56@9 B9F;M +CIF79G @=?9 GC@5F DCK9F :FCA H<9 J5F=56@9GD998 K=B8 ;9B9F5HCF 5B8 9B9F;M
K=B8B9F;M+HCF5;9G@=?9:I9@79@@65HH9FM I@HF575D57=HCFG GHCF5;9GMGH9A ,<9A5=B58J5BH5;9C:H<=GF9@=56=@=HM




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
CDH=A=N5H=CB A9H<C8 =G H<5H =H 75B 69 =AD@9A9BH98 :CF 5GD97H C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 5HH5=BG  HCBG C: '  K<=7< =G
F9@=56=@=HMCDH=A=N5H=CBC:H<9A=7FC;F=8K=H<H<9=BH9;F5H=CBC: @9GG9B986M% ((5B8 HCBGC:' 897F95G986M%/((
=BH9FA=HH9BHF9B9K56@99B9F;MGCIF79@=?9GC@5F9B9F;M=BH<9 5B8  HCBGC:'  897F95G986M+((:CF=B8=J=8I5@ACBH<
6CH<AC89GC:CD9F5H=CB34  AC89F5H9@M  ,<9 A=7FC;F=8RG =BGH5@@98 =B H<=G 5F95 75IG98 HC
!B 34 5 A=7FC;F=8 =G 7CBG=89F98 K<=7< =G =BH9;F5H98 K=H< F98I79H<9'  :CF56CIHHCBG  ,<9@C75@97CBCAM5HH5=BG
CA6=B98 95H5B8DCK9FGC@5F9B9F;MK=B89B9F;MB5HIF5@ =ADFCJ9A9BH 5B8 <5G DCG=H=J9 9BJ=FCBA9BH =AD57H 6M
;5G ;9B9F5HCF 65HH9FM 9B9F;M GHCF5;9 5B8 7F=H=75@ @C58  (, =BGH5@@=B; 5 A=7FC;F=8 =B 5 F9ACH9 5F95 #C7<= F9;=CB "5D5B
/=B8 +C@IH=CBG =G IH=@=N98 HC 9J5@I5H9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM 5B8 34 
5J5=@56=@=HMC:H<9A=7FC;F=8=B=G@5B898AC89CD9F5H=CB =FGH !B 34 5 ;F=8 C: A=7FC;F=8 =G 7CBG=89F98 K=H< :CIF +A5@@
H<9:5I@HGHF99G5F9GHI8=98:CF957<9B9F;MGCIF795B8F9GI@HG +75@9 B9F;M 2CB9G ++2G  57< ++2G 7CBG=GHG C: 5
5F9 C6H5=B98 :CF 5 H=A9 C:    G97CB8G  CF F9@=56=@=HM A=7FC;F=8 =BH9;F5H98 K=H< ;9B9F5HCFG GHCF5;9 GMGH9AG K<=7<
9J5@I5H=CB C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 F9@=56=@=HM =B8=79G @=?9 75B 9L7<5B;9 DCK9F K=H< CH<9F ++2G 5G K9@@ 5G HC H<9
IB5J5=@56=@=HM C: @C58 :5=@IF9 F5H9 5B8 F9D5=F H=A9 5F9 8=GHF=6IH98B9HKCF?=BCF89FHC5JC=8H<9@C58G<988=B; ,<=G
7CBG=89F98 ;F5D<:CFIB5J5=@56=@=HM5B8H<9D9F79BH5;9:CF =AD@=9GH<5HH<9++2GDCGG9GG6=8=F97H=CB5@DCK9F:@CKK=H<
F9@=56=@=HM5B85J5=@56=@=HM=G5HH5=B985G  ,<9A=B=A5@ 957<CH<9F5B8H<9IDGHF95A;F=8 IFH<9FF9G95F7<GHI8M75B
7IHG9HG=ADCFH5B79:CFK=B89B9F;M=G<=;<H<IGG<CKGH<5H =BJC@J9 K=H< @5F;9 BIA69F C: ++2G 5B8 9J5@I5H98 :CF H<9
H<9 DFC656=@=HM C: H<9 K=B8 9B9F;M :5=@IF9 =G <=;<  $5H9F H<9 F9@=56=@=HM 7F=H9F=5  !B H<=G F9G95F7< 5@@ ++2G 5F9 7CBB97H98
7CADCB9BHGK<=7<5F95H;F95H9FF=G?5F9:CIB86M75@7I@5H=B; HC;9H<9F9L79DH:CFH<9HKCO% 5B8% 
H<9 =ADCFH5B79 A95GIF9G  ,<9 *=G? 7<=9J9A9BH /CFH<  A=7FC;F=8 K=H< =BH9FA=HH9BH GCIF79G @=?9 K=B8 5B8 GC@5F
*/ =G 57<=9J98 <=;< :CF H<9 7=F7I=H 6F95?9F 57FCGG H<9 9B9F;M5F97CBG=89F98 ,<9F9@=56=@=HM5GG9GGA9BH=GD9F:CFA98
7F=H=75@ @C58 K<=7< =B8=75H9G H<5H H<9 7=F7I=H 6F95?9F 7CI@8 :CFH<9A=7FC;F=8<CK9J9F8I9HCH<9J5F=56@9CIHDIHDCK9F
75IG9H<9CIH5;95HH<97F=H=75@@C58 ,<IGH<97=F7I=H6F95?9F :FCA H<9G9 GCIF79G H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 697CA9G
AIGH 69 A5=BH5=B98 K9@@ GC H<5H H<9 F9@=56=@=HM K=@@ BCH ;9H =BGH56@9 ,<=G=GGI975B69588F9GG98K=H<H<9<9@DC:%CBH9
5::97H98  ,<9 7F=H=75@=HM =ADCFH5B79 GD97=9G H<9 7CADCB9BHRG 5F@CGH5H9G5AD@=B;G=AI@5H=CB5B8H<9F9@=56=@=HMA9HF=7G5F9
F9@=56=@=HM5B8=BH<=GF9G95F7<H<9A=7FC;F=8=G<I;9@M5::97H98 9J5@I5H98 IG=B; H<9 5B5@MH=75@ A9H<C8G  ,<9 7F=H=75@ @C58
6M H<9 K=B8 9B9F;M K<=7< <5G <=;< 7F=H=75@ =ADCFH5B79  ,<9 57<=9J9G H<9 <=;<9GH F9@=56=@=HM C: 5@@  FCA H<9 5B5@MH=75@
<=;< 7F=H=75@ =ADCFH5B79 75IG9G H<9 <=;< F=G? 5B8 9::97HG H<9 A9H<C8G=AD@9A9BH5H=CBH<9F9GI@HG89D=7HH<5HH<9F9@=56=@=HM
F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8  IGG9@.9G9@M =ADCFH5B79 =B8=79GC:H<9GMGH9A=BH9;F5H98K=H<H<9GC@5F5B8K=B89B9F;M
GD97=:=9GH<9HCD9J9BHC77IFF9B79C:H<965G=75B8=BH9FA98=5H9 5F9 =ADFCJ98  $5H9F H<9 G9BG=H=J=HM 5B5@MG=G =G 5DD@=98 HC
7CADCB9BHGK<=7<89BCH9GH<5HH<9MAIGH69GIGH5=B98K9@@HC D9F:CFA H<9 :5=@IF9 9::97HG C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 =B H<9 =G@5B898
A5L=A=N9H<9F9@=56=@=HM *=G?*98I7H=CB/CFH<**/5=8GHC AC893 4 
=ADFCJ9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM 6M :=B8=B; H<9 7CADCB9BHG H<5H 5F9 /=B8 GD998 5B8 GC@5F F58=5H=CB DFC656=@=GH=7 8=GHF=6IH=CBG
F98IB85BH5B8=BH<=GF9G95F7<**/=GC6H5=B98<=;<:CFH<9 5F9 5DD@=98 HC GHI8M H<9 9::97H C: 89A5B8 G=89 A5B5;9A9BH
K=B89B9F;M  5DDFC57< CB H<9 A=7FC;F=8RG F9@=56=@=HM =B8=75HCFG K<=7< =G
A=7FC;F=8=BH9;F5H98K=H<F9B9K56@99B9F;MGCIF79G@=?9 G=HI5H98=B5FF5BEI=@@5C@CA6=5 ,<9:=FGH:9KACBH<GC:
K=B8 GC@5F 5B8 A=7FC <M8FC DCK9F ;9B9F5H=CB @C58G 5B8 H<99LD9F=A9BHF9GI@HGG<CK98H<5HH<9IB65@5B79=BH9FFIDH=CBG
65HH9FM 9A9FM GHCF5;9 =G 7CBG=89F98 5B8 9J5@I5H98 :CF H<9 C77IFF98K=H<K=B8GD9985H@CKF5H9 :H9F=AD@9A9BH=B;H<9
=AD57HC:H<9F9@=56=@=HM97CBCA=75B89BJ=FCBA9BH5@5GD97HG A5B5;9A9BHGHF5H9;=9GH<9CIH5;9G5B8@57?C:9B9F;MGIDD@M
CBH<9A=7FC;F=8 ,<9A=7FC;F=8K5G=BGH5@@98=B5F9ACH95F95 =G F98I798 K<9B 7CAD5F98 HC H<9 =B=H=5@ F9GI@HG  ,<9
#C7<= F9;=CB "5D5B  ,<9 $CGG C: $C58 (FC656=@=HM $'$( 8=G7CBB97H=CBC:J5F=CIG;FCIDG:FCAH<9A5=B6IG=G57<=9J98
5B8LD97H98B9F;M&CH+IDD@=98&+=B8=79G5F9IG98HC 6M9AD@CM=B;5GK=H7<=B;GMGH9A=BH<9IB65@5B79G=HI5H=CBC:
J9F=:M H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 GMGH9A K<=@9 H<9 97CBCAM =G ;9B9F5H=CB 89A5B8  %=7FC;F=8 K=H< 5 9A5B8 +=89
9L5A=B986M15F8GH=7?=B8=79GC:H<9&9HDF9G9BHJ5@I9&(. %5B5;9A9BH +% DFC8I79G 5 9A5B8 *9GDCBG9 *
5B8 H<9 9B9:=HCGH *5H=C * 5@CB; K=H< H<9 (5M657? K<=7< F98I79G H<9 @C58 7IFJ9 D95?G  %5B5;9A9BH +HF5H9;=9G
D9F=C8(( ,<99BJ=FCBA9BH:57HCF=G9J5@I5H98K=H<F9GD97H %+ 5GGIF9 H<9 DFC8I7H=CB C: <=;< ;9B9F5H=CB 75D56=@=HM
HC H<9 8=G7<5F;9 C: '  K<=7< =G @CK9F98 6M IG=B; H<9 8IF=B;H<9@CK5J5=@56=@=HM7CB8=H=CBG3 4 
F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M GCIF79G =B H<9 A=7FC;F=8  ,<9 F9@=56=@=HM /=B8 9B9F;M GC@5F 9B9F;M 8=9G9@ ;9B9F5HCF 5B8 5HH9FM
F9GI@H 57<=9J98 :FCA H<=G F9G95F7< =G =ADFCJ98 6M  C: 9B9F;M GHCF5;9 5@@ HC;9H<9F 5F9 7CA6=B98 HC :CFA 5 <M6F=8
$'$( 5B8   C: &+ 6M =BH9;F5H=B; 5 65HH9FM 9B9F;M A=7FC;F=8 ,<=GA=7FC;F=8GIDD@=9GDCK9FHCH<9=GC@5H98@C58
GHCF5;9=B5A=7FC;F=8GMGH9A ,<957<=9J98&(. H<9* K<=7<75B6957<=9J98=B GH9DG !BH<9:=FGHGH9D5@=B95F
5F9  5B8 :CF% ((%/((5B8+(( ,<9A=7FC;F=8 DFC;F5AA=B; AC89@ =G 89J9@CD98 H<5H =BJC@J9G H<9 5J9F5;9
K=@@;5=BDFC:=HG5:H9F5GI6GH5BH=5@H=A9C: M95FG:CF% (( D5HH9FBC:89A5B8:CFK=B85B8GC@5F9B9F;MGMGH9AGGCH<5H
 M95FG:CF%/((5B8 M95FG:CF+(( ,<99BJ=FCBA9BH5@ 5BCDH=A5@7CB:=;IF5H=CB75B69C6H5=B98  !BH<9G97CB8




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
GH9D57@IGH9F=B;5@;CF=H<A=G=AD@9A9BH98HC:=B8H<9A9H<C8G F9G95F7<5<M6F=8A=7FC;F=8=G=BH9;F5H98K=H<8=9G9@
HC 9B<5B79 H<9 GMGH9A F9@=56=@=HM 6M =B7F95G=B; H<9 65HH9FM ;9B9F5HCF (;5GHIF6=B9K=B8HIF6=B9GC@5F9B9F;MA=7FC
75D57=HM =B7F95G=B; H<9 F5H98 DCK9F C: 9=H<9F K=B8 CF GC@5F HIF6=B9:I9@79@@9@97HF=7J9<=7@95B865HH9FM9B9F;MGHCF5;9=G
9B9F;M FCAH<9F9GI@HG=H=GDFCJ98H<5HH<997CBCA=7K5MHC =AD@9A9BH98  ,<9 F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M GCIF79G @=?9 GC@5F 5B8
=B7F95G9H<9F9@=56=@=HMC:H<9GMGH9A=GHC=B7F95G9H<965HH9FM K=B857H5G5B5@H9FB5H9DCK9FGIDD@MHCH<97IGHCA9FG=BH<9
75D57=HM  @GC H<9 F9GI@HG 89D=7H H<5H H<9 ;5G 9A=GG=CBG 5B8 9A9F;9B7MG=HI5H=CB ,<9*5B5@MG=GK=H<F9@=56=@=HM5B5@MG=G
9B9F;M7CGHGF98I796M 5B8 F9GD97H=J9@M3 4  =GD9F:CFA985B85BCJ9@*=B89L=G5DD@=9875@@98LD97H98
HH<98=GHF=6IH=CBB9HKCF?@9J9@5B=BBCJ5H=J9A9H<C8C: B9F;M*9HF=9J98* BIA9F=75@GHI8M=G75FF=98CIHCB
G9FJ=B; @9L=6@9 *9@=56=@=HM * =G =AD@9A9BH98  ,<9 <=;< H<9585DH988=GHF=6IH=CBB9HKCF?C:6IGC:*CM=@@=BHCB,9GH
DF=CF=HM7IGHCA9FG=BH<97CBH=B;9B7MGH5H9G5F9GIDD@=98K=H< +MGH9A *,+  ,<9 *,+ 7CBG=GHG C:  @C58 6IG65FG 5B8
H<9DCK9F:FCAH<9;F=8 ,<=GD<9BCA9BCBC:H<9;F=8=G75@@98 8=GHF=6IH=CB GMGH9AG K<=7< =G IH=@=N98 =B F9@=56=@=HM GHI8=9G
@9L=6@9 *9@=56=@=HM  9D9B8=B; CB H<9 J5@I9 C: F9@=56=@=HM 5DD@=75H=CB 3 4  ,<9 =;   G<CKG H<9 AI@H=D@9 A=7FC;F=8
G9FJ=79H<9G9FJ=79HCH<97IGHCA9FG5F9DF=CF=H=N98 !B H<=G GHFI7HIF9=BH9F7CBB97H98HCH<9DCK9F;F=8 



=;  +A5FH8=GHF=6IH=CB;F=8K=H<&%G3 4

%5F?CJAC89@=G5DD@=98HC57<=9J9F9@=56=@=HM75@7I@5H=CB H<9 GMGH9A F9@=56=@=HM 5H GI=H56@9 @C75H=CBG 6M =BH9;F5H=B; H<9
C: B9HKCF? A=7FC;F=8 K=H< @C58 HF5BG:9F @=A=H98 7CB8=H=CBG  *G=BHCH<9DCK9FGMGH9A34 
,<9 7CBB97H=CB 69HK99B GCIF79 5B8 @C58 =G H<9 DF=B7=D5@  <I;9 7<5@@9B;9 =BJC@J9G K<9B 5 A=7FC;F=8 7CBG=GHG C:
69<=B8 H<9 KCF?=B; C: %5F?CJ AC89@ 5B8 75B 75@7I@5H9 H<9 BIA9FCIG *G  !B7F95G9 =B *G =B HIFB =B7F95G9G H<9
@C585B8A=7FC;F=8F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G $5H9FH<9=GHF=6IH=CB 9@97HF=75@ =BH9F:579G 5B8 7CAAIB=75H=CB 7CBB97H=CBG
$C58@CK$A9H<C8=G5DD@=98=BCF89FHC=ADFCJ=G9H<9 DFC8I7=B; 7CAD@=75H=CBG HC H<9 B9F;M %5B5;9A9BH +MGH9A
%5F?CJ AC89@ K<=7< F9@=9G CB H<9 HF5BG:9F 75D56=@=HM C: H<9 %+ *9G95F7<9FG5F9KCF?=B;CBH<=G7<5@@9B;9K<=@9H<9
A=7FC;F=8K<=7<C77IFG8IF=B;H<98=GHIF65B79G *,+IG  F9GI@HG75B69C6H5=B98=B K5MG79BHF5@=N985B88=GHF=6IH98
GMGH9A=G7CBG=89F98HC89ACBGHF5H9$A9H<C85B8H9GH98 %+A=7FC;F=8 'IHC:6CH<79BHF5@=N985B88=GHF=6IH98%+
CB8=::9F9BH75G9GHI8=98:CFD9F:CFA5B79 ,<9DF9G9B79C:5 8=GHF=6IH98%+=G7CBG=89F985G<=;<@M75D56@95B8F9@=56@9
;F95H9F BIA69F C: BC89G 5B8 @C58 DC=BHG 9::97H H<9 JC@H5;9 A9H<C8 HDF9G9BHH<9F9G95F7<9FG5F97CB79BHF5H=B;<=;<@MCB
K<=7< 897F95G9G HCK5F8 H<9 :9989F 9B8G  ,<9 IB89FJC@H5;9 A=7FC;F=8 D<MG=75@ @5M9F @=?9 *G CJ9F<958 @=B9G 7=F7I=H
7CB8=H=CBG75IG9HCF98I79H<98CKBGH5H9GK<=7<F9GI@HG=B@CK 6F95?9FG9H7 !BH<=GF9G95F7<H<9=GGI9GCB7CBHFC@@9F:5=@IF9
F9@=56=@=HM /<=@9=BH<9CH<9F75G9GH<9;FCKH<=BH<9JC@H5;9 5B8 %+ 657?;FCIB8 5F9 BCH DF9G9BH98  5G98 CB %CBH9
DFC:=@9G5B8F98I7H=CB=BH<9IB89FJC@H5;97CB8=H=CBGC77IFG 5F@CG GH5H9 G5AD@=B; A9H<C8 5 F9@=56=@=HM AC89@ =G
8I9 HC H<9 =BH9;F5H=CB C: H<9 =GHF=6IH98 ;9B9F5H=CB G  =AD@9A9BH98 HC GHI8M H<9 8=::9F9B79 =B H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C:
,<IG H<9 F9GI@HG C6H5=B98 89ACBGHF5H9G H<5H H<9 DFCDCG98 79BHF5@=N985B88=GHF=6IH98%+A=7FC;F=8 *9@=56=@=HMA9HF=7G
AC89@=G9::97H=J95B8577IF5H96975IG9C:H<9JC@H5;9DFC:=@9 @=?9 +MGH9A J9F5;9 !BH9FFIDH=CB F9EI9B7M !B89L +!!
7CADIH5H=CB 8IF=B; H<9 F9GHCF5H=CB DFC79GG C: H<9 GMGH9A 5B8 LD97H98 B9F;M &CH +IDD@=98 &+ 5F9 5DD@=98 HC
CIH5;9  9B79H<=GAC89@75B699::97H=J9@M5DD@=98HC9B<5B79 A95GIF9 5B8 5GG9GG H<9 F9@=56=@=HM   6IG F9G=89BH=5@
A=7FC;F=8=GIH=@=N98HC9J5@I5H9H<9F9@=56=@=HMC:79BHF5@=N98




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
5B8 8=GHF=6IH98 B9F;M %5B5;9A9BH +MGH9A %+  ,<9 =BH9F7CBB97H98A=7FC;F=8G ,<9=BH9FA=HH9B7M=BH<9F9B9K56@9
F9GI@HG C6H5=B98 =@@IGHF5H9G H<5H H<9 8=GHF=6IH98 %+ 5HH5=BG 9B9F;MGCIF79GC:A=7FC;F=875B695B5@MN986M=AD@9A9BH=B;
@9GG9F+!!5B8@9GG9F&+3 4  H<97@IGH9F=B;65G98A9H<C8 A=7FC;F=8GMGH9A=GCD9F5H98
,<9 9J5@I5H=CB C: F9@=56=@=HM =G D9F:CFA98 8IF=B; H<9 K=H< H<9 =BH9F7CBB97H=CB D@5BB=B; A9H<C8 5B8 H<9 D@5BB=B;
=G@5B898AC89C:A=7FC;F=85B85@GC8IF=B;H<9C77IFF9B79C: CIH7CA9G5F98=G7IGG98 CF5;FCIDC:A=7FC;F=8GH<9F9GI@HG
IDGHF95A;F=89FFCFG 7CBB97H=CBGA5HF=L:CFH<9@=B?5;9C: 89D=7H H<5H H<9 =BH9F7CBB97H=CB D@5BB=B; A9H<C8 :=B8 5B
7CADCB9BHG 5B8 5 @C58 DF=CF=H=N5H=CB A5HF=L :CF G=;B=:M=B; CDH=A5@HCDC@C;MDF97=G9@M5B89::97H=J9@M5B8H<IGJ9F=:=9G
@C58G =ADCFH5B79 K=H< H<9 DF=CF=H=N5H=CB 9::97HG CB F9@=56=@=HM H<5HH<9DFCDCG98A9H<C8C@C;M75B699AD@CM98:CFDF57H=75@
=B8=79G=G5DD@=98 IFH<9FACF95:5=@IF99::97HA5HF=L=G5@GC 5DD@=75H=CBGC:A=7FC;F=8G3 4 
=AD@9A9BH98:CF5:9989FCJ9F@C58GC:7CBH=;ICIG:9989FG ,<9 A=7FC;F=8=G=BH9;F5H9K=H<H<9*G@=?98=9G9@;9B9F5HCF
:5=@IF99::97HA5HF=L5@;CF=H<A=G5@GCC6H5=B98:CFH<9GHI8MC: K=B89B9F;M(.5B89@97HF=7GHCF5;9GMGH9A=G7CBG=89F98:CF
A=7FC;F=8 F9@=56=@=HM  +C :CF H<9 F9@=56=@=HM GHI8M 5 6IG 5HH5=B=B;<=;<F9@=56=@=HM5B8$CKCGHC:B9F;M'5B8
*,+ K=H< A=7FC;F=8 =G IG98 5B8 5B5@MN98 =B  AC89G   BBI5@=N98 CGH C: H<9 %=7FC;F=8 +  M =AD@9A9BH=B;
/=H<CIH A=7FC;F=8G   5 A=7FC;F=8 CD9F5H=B; =B =G@5B898 LD97H98 B9F;M &CH +9FJ98 &+ $CGG C: $C58
AC89 K=H<CIH H<9 DF=CF=H=N5H=CB C: @C58  5 A=7FC;F=8 LD97H5H=CB $'$ CGH C: $C58 $CGG $CGG C: $C58
CD9F5H=B; =B =G@5B898 AC89 K=H< H<9 DF=CF=H=N5H=CB C: @C58  (FC656=@=HM$'$(&9H(F9G9BHCGH&(BBI5@=G98I9@
@GCH<99::97HGC::5=@IF9=BH<9G9AC89G5F9GHI8=985@CB; CGH  BBI5@=G98 A=GG=CB CGH  BBI5@=G98
K=H<H<975@7I@5H=CBC:F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G ,<9F9GI@HG:FCAH<9 %5=BH9B5B79 CGH % BBI5@=G98 5D=H5@ CGH 
F9G95F7<=@@IGHF5H9GH<5HH<9AC89C:DF=CF=H=N5H=CBC:@C585B8 5B8BBI5@=N98*9D@579A9BHCGH*C:H<9GMGH9A ,<9
F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G5F9H<IG=ADFCJ983 4  9::97HGCBH<9F9B9K56@99B9F;MF9GCIF79G5F9:=;IF98CIH6M
 7CAAIB=75H=CB @9GG 8=GHF=6IH98 JC@H5;9 7CBHFC@ =G H<9G9 CD9F5H=B; D5F5A9H9FG  ,<9 F9@=56=@=HM =B8=79G C: H<9
=AD@9A9BH98:CF5AI@H=6IG=G@5B898A=7FC;F=8 .C@H5;9 GMGH9A 5F9 :CIB8 CIH 5@CB; K=H< H<9 %,$ GC:HK5F9 6M
F9GDCBG9GK=H<7CAAIB=75H=CB@9GG@=B?G75B69C6H5=B986M 5DD@M=B;H<9:A=B=7CBCDH=A=N5H=CBHCC@ ,<9F9GI@HG89D=7HH<5H
IG=B;5#5@A5B=@H9F65G98B9HKCF?JC@H5;99GH=A5HCF8IF=B; H<9 F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M F9GCIF79G <5J9 <=;< =AD57H CB H<9
H<9@C588=GHIF65B79G %(%C89@(F98=7H=J9CBHFC@K=H<5 F9@=56=@=HM5B8<9@DHC=ADFCJ9H<9F9@=56=@=HMK<=@9897F95G=B;
JC@H5;9 CDH=A5@ 7CBHFC@@9F =G =AD@9A9BH98 :CF H<9 CDH=A=N98 H<9+5B8'C:H<9A=7FC;F=8 ,<=GH97<B=EI9=GIG9:I@HC
JC@H5;9 7CBHFC@  &9HKCF? JC@H5;9 F9GDCBG9G 5F9 C6H5=B98 6M 5DD@M =B :IHIF9 DCK9F GMGH9AG HC F98I79 H<9 '% 7CGH 5B8
JC@H5;9 9GH=A5HCF H<FCI;< H<9 @C75@ JC@H5;9 5B8 7IFF9BH F9@=56=@=HMC:H<9DCK9FGMGH9AG3 4 
5GGC7=5H98 K=H< 957<  =BGH958 C: 89D9B8=B; CB =GHF=6IH98 9B9F5H=CB K<=7< =G GC@9@M 65G98 CB H<9
7CAAIB=75H=CBG9FJ=79G @GCH<9JC@H5;97CBHFC@A9H<C875B F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M F9GCIF79G 5 A=7FC;F=8 =G =AD@9A9BH98 =B
695DD@=98:CF6CH<C::G9H:F997CBHFC@:CFG=B;@96IG5B8AI@H= H<=G F9G95F7<   AC89@ :CF H<9 F9@=56=@=HM 5GG9GGA9BH C: H<9
6IGCDH=A5@7CBHFC@ !BH<=GK5MH<9F9@=56=@=HM5B8:@9L=6=@=HM A=7FC;F=8 =G 7CBG=89F98 K<9F9 H<9  H5?9 D5FH =B H<9
:CF H<9 A=7FC;F=8 =B =G@5B898 AC89 =G 9B<5B798 8I9 HC H<9 7CCF8=B5H=CB C: H<9 B9HKCF? CD9F5H=CB 5G 5B 57H=J9 5;9BH
7CAAIB=75H=CB @9GG CD9F5H=CB  ,<9 F9GI@HG :FCA H<9 <CK9J9FBCH5G58979BHF5@=N98;9B9F5H=CB5GH<9IH=@=HM8C9G
G=AI@5H=CBG 5F9 J9F=:=98 :CF H<9 9::=7=9B7M C: 7CAAIB=75H=CB BCH<5J97CBHFC@ ,<9;9B9F5H=CB5J5=@56=@=HMC:K=B85B8GC@5F
@9GG 8=GHF=6IH98 JC@H5;9 7CBHFC@  ,<IG H<9 DFCDCG98 A9H<C8 9B9F;M=GD9F:CFA986MH<9GHC7<5GH=7AC89@G +=B79K=B85B8
=ADFCJ9GH<9:@9L=6=@=HM5B8F9@=56=@=HMC:H<9A=7FC;F=8=BH<9 GC@5F9B9F;M5F9=BH9FA=HH9BH=BB5HIF9565HH9FM9B9F;MGHCF5;9
=G@5B898AC893 4  =GIG985G5657?ID5B8IG988IF=B;H<9IB5J5=@56=@=HMC:H<9
,<9 AI@H=A=7FC;F=8G =B 5B =BH9F7CBB97H98 B9HKCF? 5F9 GC@5F 5B8 K=B8 9B9F;M  ,<9 F9@=56=@=HM 9J5@I5H=CB C:
7CBG=89F98  ,<9 =BH9F7CBB97H=CB C: H<9G9 AI@H=D@9 A=7FC;F=8 8=GHF=6IH=CBB9HKCF?9::97H986MH<9A=7FC;F=8=G57<=9J986M
K=@@ =ADFCJ9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM 5B8 7CGH CD9F5H=CB C: A=7FC;F=8G 7CBG=89F=B; H<9 BCB:5=@IF9 DFC656=@=HM C: H<9 =G@5B898 AC89
7CAAIB=HM   DFC656=@=GH=7 A=B=A5@ 7IHG9H =H9F5H=CB =G CD9F5H=CB 5B8 5@GC H<9 9B9F;M GHCF5;9 9::97H CB H<9 DCK9F
=AD@9A9BH98 :CF CDH=A5@ D@5BB=B; C: A=7FC;F=8G 5J5=@56=@=HM3 4 
=BH9F7CBB97H=CBG K=H< J5F=56@9 F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M GCIF79G   GHC7<5GH=7 @=B95F DFC;F5AA=B; =G 5DD@=98 HC =GHF=6IH98
+9J9F5@ :57HCFG 5F9 7CBG=89F98 :CF H<=G A9H<C8 GI7< 5G B9F;M *9GCIF79G O IGHCA9F 8CDH=CB %C89@ 'D9F5H=CBG
F9@=56=@=HM 97CBCA=7G =BH9FA=HH9B7M C: F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M *% ,<=GDFC;F5AA=B;<9@DGHC57<=9J9H<9CD9F5H=B;
GCIF79G IB79FH5=BH=9G =B H<9 B9HKCF? 5B8 F9GCIF79G 5B8 G7<98I@9G C: 5 A=7FC;F=8 5H GD97=:=7 @C75@ 97CBCA=7 5B8
7CBG=89F=B; H<9 9L=GH=B; CD9F5H=B; 7CB79FBG  .5F=CIG 9BJ=FCBA9BH5@G=HI5H=CBG DF9J=CIGKCF?K5G7CB8I7H98CB
H97<B=EI9G F9@5H98 HC H<9 D@5BB=B; C: DCK9F GMGH9AG @=?9 CDH=A5@ G7<98I@9 C: 5 $=H<=IA !FCB (<CGD<5H9 65HH9FM
A=7FC;F=8 GH5HIG 5B5@MG=G F9@=56=@=HM 7CGH KCFH< 5B5@MG9G $=9('5H5BCIHDIHDCK9FC: %/AC@H9B75F6CB5H9:I9@
DFC656=@=HM 8=GHF=6IH=CB :IB7H=CB65G98 A9H<C8 %CBH9 5F@C 79@@@C75H98=B+5BH5*=H5"5=@A=7FC;F=85HI6@=B5@=:CFB=5 
G=AI@5H=CBG=AD@=:=98K=B8AC89@+/% CFH<9F9@=56=@=HM ,<9AC@H9B75F6CB5H9:I9@79@@K5GDFCJ98HC69IBF9@=56@95B8
5GG9GGA9BH5DDFCDF=5H9=B8=79G5F95@GC89J9@CD98:CFH<9 7CBG=89F985G5657?IDCDH=CBD5FH@M .5F=CIG75G9G5F9




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
9L97IH98K=H<8=::9F9BHGHC7<5GH=7*%CDH=CBGHC5HH5=B 5H@95GH=BHCA=7FC;F=8G IHIF9F9G95F7<GHI8=9G=B7@I89H<9
J5@I9G H<=G 5DDFC57<  ,<9 65HH9FM G7<98I@9 C: H<9 65HH9FM =ADFCJ9A9BH =B F9G=@=9B79 IB89F 9A9F;9B7M 7CB8=H=CBG 5B8
9B9F;MGHCF5;9=GC6H5=B98=B569B9:=7=5@K5M6MH<9GHC7<5GH=7 897@=B9 =B 7CADIH5H=CB5@ HCC@ DFC6@9A =B @5F;9 G75@9
5DDFC57< ,<9HCH5@9B9F;M7CGHD9FK99?75@7I@5H98=G<=;<9F 5DD@=75H=CBG3 4 
H<5B H<9 HCH5@ 7CGH 75@7I@5H9G IG=B; H<9 GHC7<5GH=7 5DDFC57<  B=BGH5@@5H=CBC:  ?/(.:CF8=G5GH9FF9@=9:G<9@H9FG
,<IG H<9 GHC7<5GH=7 5DDFC57< =B7F95G9G H<9 A=7FC;F=8 =B @CF=85 K=H< H<9 5=8 C: +IB+A5FH +7<CC@G A9F;9B7M
F9@=56=@=HM5B8H<997CBCA=7CD9F5H=CB3 4  +<9@H9F5B8+<9@H9F(@IG-(-H=@=HM(FCJ=89F(FC;F5AG=G
,<9 7CAD5F=GCB C: J5F=CIG A=7FC;F=8 HCDC@C;=9G K<=@9 577CAD@=G<98 6M @CF=85 +C@5F B9F;M 9BH9F +  ,<9
7CBG=89F=B;H<9F9@=56=@=HM5B87CGHCD9F5H=CB=GD9F:CFA98 ,<9 DFC>97H =G =BGH5@@98 HC 89J9@CD H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C: <M6F=8
7CADCB9BH 9::97H CB H<9 A=7FC;F=8 CD9F5H=CB =G 8=G7IGG98 =B D<CHCJC@H5=787A=7FC;F=8GMGH9AG:CF9A9F;9B7MG<9@H9FG5B8
89H5=@ FCAH<9F9GI@HG=H=GDFCJ9BH<5HH<9G=B;@95B8 CH<9F5DD@=75H=CBG FCAH<=GDFC>97HH<975F6CB:CCHDF=BH C:
K=F9B9HKCF?G5F9@958=B;CJ9FH<9CH<9FHKCA=7FC;F=8G@=?9 H<9G=H9K=@@69F98I7985B8H<9DCK9FGIDD@MHCH<97F=H=75@
G=B;@9  5B8 <M6F=8  A=7FC;F=8G  /<9B 7CAD5F98 @C58G=G=ADFCJ98 @5F;9 ?/(.GMGH9A7CA6=B98K=H<
K=H<5@@H<9HCDC@C;=9GC:H<9A=7FC;F=8H<9A=7FC;F=8<5G IB=BH9FFIDH98(.A=7FC;F=85F9=BH9;F5H98HC;9H<9FHC:CF
ACF9A5F?CD9F5H=CB69B9:=HGK<=HH<9K=F9B9HKCF?DCGG9GG DCK9F GIDD@M 5DD@=75H=CBG 5@GC HC =ADFCJ9 H<9 9B9F;M
<=;< F9@=56=@=HM 7<5F57H9F=GH=7G  ': 5@@ H<9 HCDC@C;=9G  9::=7=9B7M  #.(.GMGH9AGIDD@MDCK9FHCGK=H7<56@9@C58G
A=7FC;F=8 =G H<9 @95GH 9::97H=J9 HCDC@C;M K=H< <=;< DCK9F @=?9K5H9FDIAD=B;K<9F95GH<9IB=BH9FFIDH98<M6F=8(.
@CGG9G5B8@CKF9@=56=@=HM ,<97CAD5F=GCB=BH<9A=7FC;F=8G=G A=7FC;F=8GIDD@=98DCK9FHC65G9@C58G@=?9@=;<HB=B;@=?9@=;<H
65G98 CB   /<=@9 7CAD5F=B; H<9 8=::9F9BH A=7FC;F=8 9A=HH=B;8=C89G=BGHFIA9BHG9H7 'B97CBGHF5=BHC:+IBGA5FH
HCDC@C;=9GH<9DCK9F@CGG9GK<=7<C77IFG=BH<9B9HKCF?5F9 G7<CC@RG9A9F;9B7MGMGH9A=GH<9DCK9F7CBJ9FH9F:CF(.
BCH7CBG=89F98  !BH<9G5A9K5MH<9B9HKCF?F9@=56=@=HM=G GMGH9AK<=7<DFC8I79GH<9DCK9F=BHIFB7CBJ9FH98HC
BCH7CBG=89F98G=B79H<98=GHF=6IH=CB@=B9GA5M;9H5::97H986M DCK9F ,<=GDFC>97H:57=@=H5H9GHCDFC8I79A5L=AIADCK9F
H<9:5I@HG ,<97CGHG=B5@@H<9HCDC@C;=9GC:A=7FC;F=8:CF :FCA(.GMGH9A3 4 
9L5AD@9 H<9 =BGH5@@5H=CB 7CGHG 7CBJ9FH9F 7CGHG 9H7  5F9 BCH CF H<9 F9@=56=@=HM 9B<5B79A9BH 5  A=7FC;F=8 K=H< 5
8=G7IGG98=BH<=GF9G95F7<3 4  7CBHFC@A9H<C8=G=AD@9A9BH98 @CB;K=H<7F=H=75@@C58GH<9
,<9F9@=56=@=HMC:H<9A=7FC;F=8=B7F95G9GK<9B6CH<(.5B8 BCB7F=H=75@@C58GAIGH69GIDD@=98K=H<IB=BH9FFIDH56@9DCK9F
K=B8 9B9F;M DCGG9GG 657? ID GHCF5;9G  IF=B; H<9 @C58 =G H<9 ?9M C6>97H=J9 C: H<=G 9LD9F=A9BH  !AD@9A9BH5H=CB C:
89A5B8 589EI5H9 ;9B9F5H=CB =G F9EI=F98 HC GIDD@M DCK9F HC CD9F5H=CB5@A9H<C8=GD9F:CFA986M6IGG=;B5@=B;A9H<C8
H<9 7IGHCA9FG 9GD97=5@@M 8IF=B; H<9 7@CI8M 5B8 BCBK=B8M K<=@9  JC@H5;9 57HG 5G 5B =B:CFA5H=CB 75FF=9F  ,<9 
85MG  'DH=A5@ D@579A9BH C: 7CADCB9BHG =B A=7FC;F=8 =G JC@H5;9=G7CBHFC@@986M;F=8H=987CBJ9FH9FK<=7<65@5B79GH<9
B979GG5FM HC C6H5=B <=;< F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8  ,<9 A=7FC;F=8 DCK9F  CH< 7F=H=75@ 5B8 BCB7F=H=75@ @C58G 5F9
<M6F=8 A=7FC;F=8 7CADCB9BHG AIGH 69 CDH=A5@@M D@5798 HC CD9F5H98=B6CH<;F=87CBB97H985B8=G@5B898AC8C:A=7FC;F=8
GHI8M B9K 9B9F;M DF57H=79G C: 7CADCB9BHG  .5F=CIG 5F9CD9F5H989::=7=9BH@M CF7CBH=BICIGGIDD@MC:DCK9FHCH<9
CDH=A=N5H=CB H97<B=EI9G 5B8 A9H<C8C@C;=9G 5F9 5DD@=98 K=H< 7F=H=75@ @C58G H<9 BCB7F=H=75@ @C58G 5F9 8=G=BH9;F5H98
AC89@=B; C: F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M GCIF79G C: A=7FC;F=8  ,<9G9 89D9B8=B;CBH<9GD97=:=987CB8=H=CB 6IGG=;B5@=B;+
AC89@=B;H97<B=EI9G9B56@98HC=ADFCJ9H<97IFF9BHG79B5F=C K=H< 5 DFCDCFH=CB5@=BH9;F5@ (! JC@H5;9 7CBHFC@@9F =G
C:A=7FC;F=8CDH=A=N5H=CB !BBCJ5H=J9H97<B=EI9G@=?95FH=:=7=5@ 9AD@CM98 :CF CD9F5H=CB5@ GHF5H9;M  ,<9 + CD9F5H=CB5@
=BH9@@=;9B79 C::9F H<9 9B<5B798 F9GI@HG K=H< F9GD97H HC H<9 7<5F57H9F=GH=7GK5G:=FGH9J5@I5H98K=H<H<9=AD@9A9BH5H=CBC:
CD9F5H=CBG5B8CDH=A=N5H=CBC:A=7FC;F=8GK=H<CIH7CBG=89F=B; G=AD@=:=98  A=7FC;F=8  ,<=G 9LD9F=A9BH <9@D98 HC
@CB;H9FAK95H<9F85H53 4  =BJ9GH=;5H9H<9A=7FC;F=8K<=7<89D=7HGH<5HH<9A=B=AIA
,<9 CDH=A=N5H=CB C: A=7FC;F=8 G=N=B; 5B8 D@579A9BH 8CKBK5F8 5B8 IDK5F8 DCK9F 657?ID 75B 69 :CIB8 CIH :CF
7CA6=B98 K=H< F9@=56=@=HM C: A=7FC;F=8 =G =AD@9A9BH98 HC 957< CD9F5H=CB5@ NCB9  ,<9  JC@H5;9G NCB9G 5F9 GD97=:=98
F98I79 H<9 75G758=B; :5=@IF9G K<=7< 5F9 H<9 A5=B 75IG9 C: 65G98CBH<97<5F57H9F=GH=7GGHI8M ,<9GH5H97CBHFC@FI@9
6@57?CIHG  +9EI9BH=5@ %CBH9 5F@C G=AI@5H=CB HCC@ :CF H<9 :CF 657?ID ;9B9F5HCF 5F9 D@5BB98 5B8 H<9 BCB7F=H=75@ @C58G
CDH=A=N5H=CBC:A=7FC;F=8K=H<F9;5F8GC:F9B9K56@99B9F;M 8=G7CBB97H=CBFI@9:CFH<97CBH=BICIGGIDD@MC:DCK9FHCH<9
9B9F;M GHCF5;9 5B8 A=7FCHIF6=B9  =::9F9BH G79B5F=CG 5F9 7F=H=75@ @C58G  ,<9 7F=H=75@ @C58G F9@=56=@=HM 5B8 BCB7F=H=75@
7CBG=89F98 5B8 9J5@I5H98 5H :=L98 =BJ9GHA9BH  *CM =@@=BHCB @C58G F97CBB97H=CB FI@9 5F9 5@GC DFCDCG98  ,<9 7CBHFC@ FI@9G
H9GHGMGH9A*,+5B8H<9!F9@=56=@=HMH9GHGMGH9A*,+ DFCDCG98 :CF H<9 89J=79G CD9F5H=CB5@ AC89G C: A=7FC;F=8
5F99J5@I5H98 ,<97@IGH9F=B;A9H<C8;9B9F5H9G5G9HC:CDH=A5@ 5@CB; K=H< H<9 HF5BG=H=CB AC89G 5F9 8=G7IGG98 =B 89H5=@ 
75B8=85H9G 5B8 H<9=F F9DF9G9BH5H=J9G  ,<9 F9DF9G9BH5H=J9 =G (+ %,G=AI@5H=CBHCC@F9GI@HGJ5@=85H9H<9CD9F5H=CB
H9GH98IG=B;F9@=56=@=HMG=AI@5H=CBH<IGH<99::97H=J9F9GI@H75B 5B8 D9F:CFA5B79 C: H<9 CD9F5H=CB5@ GHF5H9;M 5B8 7CBHFC@
69C6H5=B98 ,<9G=AI@5H=CBH9GHG5GG9GGA9BHG89D=7HH<5HH<9 A9H<C8  ,<9G9 F9GI@HG DFCJ9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM K=@@ 69 =ADFCJ98
F9@=56=@=HM=ADFCJ9A9BHC77IFGK=H<H<9GA5@@D9B9HF5H=CBC: :CFBCB7F=H=75@@C58GK=H<H<9CD9F5H=CB5@GHF5H9;=9G3 4 




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
*97CB:=;IF56@9A=7FC;F=8G=BH9;F5H98K=H<D@I;=B9@97HF=7 <=9F5F7<=75@ G7<9A9G 5F9 IH=@=N98 :CF H<9 AI@H= A=7FC;F=8
J9<=7@9G (.G =G 57<=9J98 6M IG=B; *9ACH9@M CBHFC@@98 CD9F5H=CB 8IF=B; 7CBH=B;9B7=9G  -G=B; H<9G9 56CJ9 A9BH=CB
+K=H7<9G*+G ,<=G5=8GH<9D9B9HF5H=CBC:(.G5B8G G7<9A9GH<9@C587IFH5=@A9BHG5F9F98I798 ,<9!BC89
K<=@9CDH=A=N=B;H<9'%7CGH5B8F9@=56=@=HM ,<9J=H5@;C5@ 6IG=G7CBG=89F98:CFH<F99A=7FC;F=8G ,<9A=7FC;F=8=B7@I89
=GHCCDH=A=N9H<9HCH5@7CGHC:*GDCK9FGIDD@MIDGHF95A A=7FCHIF6=B9G K=B8 HIF6=B9 ;9B9F5HCFG D<CHCJC@H5=7 IB=HG
B9HKCF?9B9F;M9L7<5B;965HH9FM89;F585H=CB7CGH=B(.G ++G 5B8 @C58  ,<9 :9989F A=7FC;F=8 5B8 H<9 8=GHF=6IH=CB
F97CB:=;IF5H=CB GK=H7<=B; 7CGH =BH9FFIDH=CB 7CGH 9H7  (.G GMGH9AF9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G5F9C6H5=B98 FCAH<9G9F9GI@HGH<9
7<5F;=B;5B88=G7<5F;=B;J5@I9G5B8IB79FH5=BH=9G5F9C6H5=B98 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 7CBGIA9FG =B7F95G9G K=H< H<9 IG5;9 C:
6MG79B5F=C65G98GHC7<5GH=7:F5A9KCF?GC5GHC:=B8H<9<=;< 7CCF8=B5H98 CIH5;9 A5B5;9A9BH  ,<9 F9GI@HG 89D=7H H<9
@9J9@ IB79FH5=BH=9G  ,<9 H9GH A=7FC;F=8 =G IH=@=N98 HC 9L5A=B9 F9@=56=@=HM =ADFCJ9A9BH C: 7CCF8=B5H98 AI@H= A=7FC;F=8
H<9D9F:CFA5B795B8A9F=HGC:H<9F97CAA9B898AC89@3 4  GMGH9A ':H<9G9G7<9A9GH<98979BHF5@=N98G7<9A9C6H5=B98
,<9.9<=7@9HCF=8. H97<BC@C;M<9@DGHCC6H5=BH<9@95GH J5F=98 ;C5@G =B AI@H= A=7FC;F=8 7CAD5F98 HC H<9 79BHF5@=N98
7CGH C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 5@CB; K=H< H<9 GH5HIG C: H<9 9@97HF=7 G7<9A9 ,<98979BHF5@=N98A9H<C8=GACF95DDFCDF=5H9:CFH<9
J9<=7@9G (.  ,<9 B9HKCF? DCK9F :@CK =G F97CB:=;IF98 HC @5F;9AI@H=A=7FC;F=8GMGH9AG3 4 
897F95G9 H<9 HCH5@ DCK9F @CGG 5B8 A=7FC;F=8 7CGH  ,<9 ,<9 F9@=56=@=HM =ADFCJ9A9BH C: H<9 DCK9F GMGH9A 75B 69
F9B9K56@99B9F;MGCIF79GGIDD@MDCK9FHCH<9@C75@@C58G ,<9 =B7F95G98K=H<H<9=BH9;F5H=CBC:A=7FC;F=8 *CM=@@=BHCB,9GH
F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M . 5F9 K9@@ GIDDCFH98 =B H<9 A=7FC;F=8 +MGH9A*,+=G89J9@CD98:CFH<9F9@=56=@=HM5GG9GGA9BH6M
K<=7< K=@@ =B HIFB =ADFCJ9G H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8 IG=B; 5B 5GG9GGA9BH AC89@   7CAD5F=GCB H9GH :CF H<9
3 43 4 F9@=56=@=HM 5GG9GGA9BH =G D9F:CFA98 :CF H<9 *,+ K=H< 5B8
 7@IGH9F C: A=7FC;F=8 =G 7CBG=89F98 HC =ADFCJ9 H<9 K=H<CIHH<9A=7FC;F=8 ,<9=ADFCJ9A9BHC:F9@=56=@=HM=GK=H<
F9@=56=@=HM K<=7< =AD57HG H<9 9@97HF=7 DCK9F 8=GD5H7<=B; F9;5F8G HC H<9 =B7@IG=CB C: A=7FC;F=8  ,<9 F9@=56=@=HM
GHF5H9;M   8=GD5H7<=B; GHF5H9;M =G =AD@9A9BH98 :CF H<9 =ADFCJ9A9BH 5@GC J5F=9G K=H< F9GD97H HC H<9 B9HKCF? @=?9
A=7FC;F=87@IGH9F6M7CBG=89F=B;H<9GMGH9A:5I@HG %CBH9 :5=@IF97<5F57H9F=GH=7GF9D5=FF5H9GC:H<9G97H=CBG9H7 H<=G=G5
5F@C<=9F5F7<=75@8MB5A=7F9@=56=@=HMAC89@=G=AD@9A9BH98HC ?9M 5GD97H HC 69 7CBG=89F98 :CF H<9 A=7FC;F=8 D@5BB=B;  ,<9
9J5@I5H9H<9:5=@IF9F5H9G=AI@5H=CBC:H<9A=7FC;F=87@IGH9FHC A9HF=7 F9GI@HG 5F9 7CAD5F98 6M IH=@=N=B; H<9 5J5=@56=@=HM C:
=ADFCJ9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 @C58G C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8  ,<9 *,+ HC IB89FGH5B8 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM =ADFCJ9A9BHG K=H< H<9
F9GI@HG89D=7HH<5HH<9F9@=56=@=HMC:A=7FC;F=8=B7F95G9GK=H<H<9 =BH9;F5H=CBC:A=7FC;F=85@CB;K=H<*,+ ,<IGH<9F9@=56=@=HM
DFCD9F7CBGHFI7H=CBC:H<9HKCCFACF9A=7FC;F=8GHC;9H<9F5G =ADFCJ9A9BH =G D9F:CFA98 K<=7< 75B 69 =AD@9A9BH98 CB
57@IGH9F /=H<H<9CD9F5H=CBC:5A=7FC;F=87@IGH9FH<97F=H=75@ G9J9F5@CH<9F8=GHF=6IH=CBGMGH9AG3 4 
@C58G 5F9 5@K5MG GIDD@=98 K=H< DCK9F  ,<IG H<=G 75IG9 H<9 '::;F=8GC@5F<CA9GMGH9A+ +=BH9F7CBB97H98HC:CFA
=ADFCJ9A9BH=BH<9F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79GC:H<9A=7FC;F=87@IGH9F H<9A=7FC;F=8DFCJ=89GH<9CDH=A5@7CGHF9@=56=@=HMIH=@=N5H=CB
=B;F=87CBB97H98AC893 4  5B8GIGH5=B56=@=HM:CFDFCGIA9FG5B87CBGIA9FG ,<=G9B<5B79G
A=7FC;F=8=BH9;F5H98K=H<GC@5FD5B9@GDCK9FGHCF5;95B8 H<9 IH=@=N5H=CB C: ;9B9F5H=CB 5B8 657? ID GHCF5;9 57FCGG H<9
8=9G9@ ;9B9F5HCF 5F9 =AD@9A9BH98 HC 9J5@I5H9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM + +GMGH9A7CBG9EI9BH@MK=H<H<9F9@=56=@=HM5B85::CF856=@=HM
=GGI9G 5B8 HCD 9J9BH DFC656=@=HM C: H<9 GMGH9A  ,<9 )I5G= C: H<9 DCK9F GIDD@M  ,<9 ;9B9F5H=CB DFC:=@9G 5F9 C6H5=B98
MB5A=7 A9H<C8 =G 7CBG=89F98 HC G=AI@5H9 5B8 J9F=:M H<9 5@CB;K=H<H<989A5B8DFC:=@9G:CFH<9+ +GMGH9A=B5J=@@5;9 
A=7FC;F=8AC89@ 5I@H,F99B5@MG=G,89H9FA=B9GH<9 ,<9G=AI@5H=CB=GD9F:CFA98IG=B;+!%-$!&#5B8H<9F9GI@HG
DFC656=@=H=9G C: IB89G=F56@9 DFC656=@=HM 9J9BHG H<5H 75IG9 H<9 G<CK H<9 F9@=56=@=HM =ADFCJ9A9BH =B A=7FC;F=8 8IF=B; @CK
HCD 9J9BH :5=@IF9  ,<=G A9H<C8 =BJC@J9G H<9 EI5@=H5H=J9 5B8 ;9B9F5H=CB  CF H<=G G=AI@5H=CB H<9 H97<B=75@ @CGG9G 8IF=B;
EI5BH=H5H=J9 5B5@MG=G C: 7CADCB9BH :5I@HG  CF H<9 A=7FC;F=8 DCK9F 7CBJ9FG=CB  @GC H<9 9::=7=9B7M C: DCK9F 7CBJ9FH9FG
GMGH9A ,<9HCD9J9BHDFC656=@=HM=GC6H5=B985G  ,<9 5B8 9B9F;M GHCF5;9G 5F9 5GGIA98 HC 69  K=H<CIH 5BM
G=AI@5H=CB F9GI@HG <=;<@=;<H H<9 8=GHF=6IH=CB GMGH9A =B H<9 @CGG9G @GC575D57=HMA5B5;9A9BHGMGH9A=G=B7@I898:CFH<9
DF9G9BH 5B8 :IHIF9 GH5H9 C: F9@=56=@=HM  ,<9 65HH9FM GMGH9A 9B9F;MGHCF5;9HCBCH7<5F;9 8=G7<5F;9HCCEI=7?@M ,<IGK=H<
DFC656=@=HM=GC6H5=B98<=;<K<=7<K=@@BCH9::97HH<9HCD9J9BH 5@@ H<9 7CBG=89F5H=CBG H<9 + + =BH9F7CBB97H98 A=7FC;F=8
DFC656=@=HM C: H<9 GMGH9A  ,<9 8=GHF=6IH=CB GMGH9A AIGH 69 F9@=56=@=HM=ADFCJ9G9::97H=J9@M3 4 
9LH9B898K=H<H<9588=H=CBC:6IG9G5B8HF5BG:CFA9FG=BCF89F ,<9 :5=@IF9G :CF H<9 79BHF5@=N98 A=7FC;F=8G 5F9 8I9 HC H<9
HC=B7F95G9H<9BIA69FC:@C58G3 4  G=B;@9DC=BHC::5=@IF9 9BHF5@7CBHFC@@9F=GCB9C:H<9A5>CF
,<9 F9@=56=@=HM 5GG9GGA9BH C: AI@H= A=7FC;F=8 9L5AD@9G :CF H<=G G79B5F=C  ,<9 8979BHF5@=N98 C: A=7FC;F=8
%%8=GHF=6IH=CB GMGH9A =G 9J5@I5H98   G9EI9BH=5@ %CBH9 8C9G BCH =B7@I89 H<9 79BHF5@ 7CBHFC@@9F H<IG 5 D5F5@@9@
5F@C A9H<C8 =G 5DD@=98 :CF H<9 9J5@I5H=CB C: A=7FC;F=8 7CB:=;IF5H=CB =G C6H5=B98   8979BHF5@=N98 A=7FC;F=8 7CBHFC@
F9@=56=@=HM  .5F=CIG CD9F5H=CB AC89G 5F9 7CBG=89F98 6M 5F7<=H97HIF9 =G =AD@9A9BH98 :CF H<9 GHI8M C: F9@=56=@=HM =B
8=J=8=B;H<9AI@H=A=7FC;F=8=BHCGA5@@A=7FC;F=8G89D9B8=B; 79BHF5@=N98 5B8 8979BHF5@=N98 A=7FC;F=8G  ,<=G A9H<C8
CBH<9DFCH97H=CBGMGH9AG !B588=H=CBHCH<979BHF5@=N985B8 =ADFCJ9GH<9F9@=56=@=HM5GD97HG5ACB;H<9A=7FC;F=8G 




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
%5F?CJ <5=B %C89@ =G 9AD@CM98 :CF 5 G=B;@9 7CBHFC@@9F =B #5@A5B :=@H9FG  ,<9 #5@A5B :=@H9F =BGH5@@98 5H H<9 (C=BH C:
6CH<79BHF5@=N985B88979BHF5@=N98A=7FC;F=8G5B8H<9F9GI@HG CAACBCID@=B;C:H<9A=7FC;F=89J5@I5H9GH<9()=GGI9G
5F9 J5@=85H98  ,<9 7<5@@9B;9G 5F9 :CF 9AD@CM=B; H<9 D9F:CFA @C58 G<5F=B; D95? G<5J=B; 5B8 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9
8979BHF5@=N987CBHFC@5F7<=H97HIF95F98=G7IGG985B8H<9F9GI@HG A=7FC;F=8  %CF9 GHI8M AIGH 69 D9F:CFA98 :CF :IFH<9F
DFCJ9 H<5H H<9 <=;< F9@=56=@=HM J5@I9G 5F9 C6H5=B98 =B H<9 J5@=85H=CB6M9LD9F=A9BHG=AI@5H=CBG34 
8979BHF5@=N98 7CBHFC@ 5F7<=H97HIF9  CBG9EI9BH@M H<9 CF69HH9FD@5BB=B;5B8CD9F5H=CBC:IH=@=HM7CAD5B=9GH<9
<5F8K5F9=B@CCDG=AI@5H=CB=GD9F:CFA985B8H<9F9GI@HG5F9 F9@=56=@=HMF9GI@HG5F9J9FMG=;B=:=75BH !BHF58=H=CB5@A9H<C8G
8=G7IGG98:CF6CH<79BHF5@=N985B88979BHF5@=N9834  H<9:5=@IF9DFC656=@=HM=G7CBG=89F987CBGH5BH5B889H9FA=B98
.=5:9989F7CB:=;IF5H=CBH<9=ADFCJ9A9BH=BH<9F9@=56=@=HM 6MH<97CAD5BMA5BI:57HIF9F 8MB5A=7AC89@=B;C::5=@IF9
C:A=7FC;F=8G=GD9F:CFA98 @=B95F=N98B9HKCF?AC89@=B F5H9=G=AD@9A9BH986M!H9GHGMGH9A +9J9BC:!H9GH
DCK9F :@CK :CFA 5B8 @=B95F DFC;F5AA=B; AC89@ =G GMGH9A F9@=56=@=HM =B8=79G @=?9 +MGH9A J9F5;9 !BH9FFIDH=CB
=AD@9A9BH98   ;F5D< H<9CF9H=7 A9H<C8 =G IH=@=N98 :CF H<9 F9EI9B7M +!! +MGH9A J9F5;9 !BH9FFIDH=CB IF5H=CB
A=7FC;F=8 F58=5@ HCDC@C;=75@ GHFI7HIF9  -G=B; H<9 =BH9@@=;9BH +!! IGHCA9F J9F5;9 !BH9FFIDH=CB IF5H=CB !!
6=B5FMD5FH=7@9GK5FACDH=A=N5H=CBH<9G97H=CB5@=N=B;5B8H=9 J9F5;9 +9FJ=79 J5=@56=@=HM +! J9F5;9 +9FJ=79
GK=H7<9G CDH=A5@ GH5HIG =G 9J5@I5H98    ! 6IG GMGH9A -B5J5=@56=@=HM +-! B9F;M &CH +IDD@=98 &+ 5B8
A=7FC;F=8 =G IG98 HC D9F:IA9 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM GHI8M  -G=B; J9F5;9 B9F;M &CH +IDD@=98 &+ 5F9 7CAD5F98 5B8
A=B=A5@ 7IHG9HG H<9 DFC656=@=GH=7 F9@=56=@=HM 5GG9GGA9BH =G EI5BH=:=98 !B:=FGH5B5@MG=GB9KAC89@98:5=@IF9F5H9GF98I79
D9F:CFA98 ,<9G=AI@5H=CBF9GI@HG5F9C6H5=B98K<=7<89D=7HG H<9F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G5H5B5J9F5;9C:  !BH<9G97CB8
H<5H H<9 5BBI5@ IBB9FJ98 9B9F;M H<9 BIA69F C: 5::97H98 5B5@MG=G8=GHF=6IH98;9B9F5H=CBGCIF79GGI7<5G(.5B8K=B8
7IGHCA9FG5B85::97H98<CIG9<C@8G75B69897F95G98IG=B;H<9 =BH<9A=7FC;F=85B8H<9F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G5F9=ADFCJ985HH<9
DFC>97H98 A9H<C8  ,<=G A9H<C8 =G D5FH=7I@5F@M IG9:I@ :CF H<9 F5H9 C:    !B H<9 @5GH GH5;9 H<9 %/< 65HH9FM 9B9F;M
J5F=CIGDCK9FGMGH9AD@5BB=B;GHI8=9G34  GHCF5;9=G=BH9;F5H98=BHCH<9A=7FC;F=85B8F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G
77CF8=B; HC H<9 DCK9F GIDD@M F9@=56=@=HM 5 A=7FC;F=8 =B7F95G9G6M  +CH<9=FF9;I@5FDCK9F=B>97H=CBDFC:=@9
=BH9;F5H=B;H<9K=B8(.9B9F;MGHCF5;9=G=AD@9A9BH985B8 C: H<9 8=GHF=6IH=CB ;9B9F5H=CB 75IG98 8I9 HC J5F=56@9 CIHDIH
9J5@I5H98:CFH<9F9@=56=@=HMC:@C58G ,<=G5B5@MG=G=GD9F:CFA98 DFC:=@9C:K=B85B8GC@5F75B6965@5B79G=BH<=G75G93 4 
IG=B;%CBH95F@CG=AI@5H=CB6M5779GG=B;H<9A=7FC;F=8CF=B 
BCFA5@8=GHF=6IH=CBB9HKCF? B!*,+-+GMGH9A=G !!!  '&$-+!'&
=AD@9A9BH98 5B8 G=AI@5H=CB =G D9F:CFA98  ,<9 F9GI@HG G<CK ,<9D5D9F8=G7IGG9GH<9G=AI@5H=CBH97<B=EI9G5B88=G7IGG=CB
H<5HH<9F9@=56=@=HM=B89L5B8@C58:5I@HDFC656=@=HM:CF:=FGH7@5GG CBH<9F9@=56=@=HMC:H<9A=7FC;F=8 ,<9GC@IH=CBG5@CB;K=H<H<9
@C58 5F9 =ADFCJ98 =B BCFA5@ 8=GHF=6IH=CB B9HKCF? K<9B 7<5@@9B;9G5F9F9J=9K98:CFH<9A=7FC;F=8G=BH9;F5H98K=H<H<9
7CAD5F98 HC H<9 F9@=56=@=HM =B89L =B H<9 A=7FC;F=8  CF H<9 *9B9K56@9B9F;M+CIF79G@=?9GC@5FK=B8B9F;M+HCF5;9G
G97CB87@5GG @C58 H<9 F9@=56=@=HM =B89L =B 6CH< BCFA5@ @=?9 :I9@ 79@@ 65HH9FM I@HF575D57=HCFG 9H7  ,<9 7CBHFC@
8=GHF=6IH=CB B9HKCF? 5B8 A=7FC;F=8 5F9 G5A9  CF H<9 H<=F8 GHF5H9;=9GC:DCK9F9@97HFCB=789J=79G5F98=G7IGG98K=H<BCJ9@
7@5GG @C58 F9@=56=@=HM =B89L 5B8 DFC656=@=HM C: @C58 :5I@H A9H<C8G 5B8 =BBCJ5H=J9 =895G  ,<9 D5D9F F9J=9KG 56CIH
=ADFCJ98 <=;<@M =B H<9 A=7FC;F=8 K<9B 7CAD5F98 HC H<9 8=::9F9BH A=7FC;F=8 5F7<=H97HIF9G =BH9;F5H98 K=H< J5F=CIG
BCFA5@8=GHF=6IH98B9HKCF? ,<9G=AI@5H=CBF9GI@HGH<IG89D=7H 8=GHF=6IH98 ;9B9F5H=CB  %I@H=D@9 A=7FC;F=8 5F7<=H97HIF9 5F9
H<5HH<9H<=F87@5GG@C58=GACF95DDFCDF=5H9=BA=7FC;F=8K<9B 7CBG=89F98 5B8 H<9 9::97H C: F9@=56=@=HM =G 8=G7IGG98  ,<9
7CAD5F98HC:=FGH7@5GG@C5834  9::97H=J9 A9H<C8G :CF H<9 =ADFCJ9A9BH C: F9@=56=@=HM IG=B;
,<9F9@=56=@=HM9J5@I5H=CB=GD9F:CFA98=BH<9A=7FC;F=8=B J5F=CIG H97<B=EI9G 5F9 DFCDCG98  CF 957< A9H<C8 5B8
HKC 75H9;CF=9G IGHCA9F 5G98 !B8=79G 5B8 B9F;M 5G98 GHF5H9;MH<97<5@@9B;9G5B8=GGI9G5F9588F9GG985B8GC@IH=CBG
!B8=79G  ,<9 ;F=8 D9F:CFA5B79 =G 9J5@I5H98 6M H<9G9 =B8=79G  5F9F9J=9K98K=H<H<9G=AI@5H=CBF9GI@HG ,<9F9@=56=@=HM=B8=79G
,<9 A=7FC;F=8 =BH9;F5H98 K=H< F9B9K56@9 9B9F;M HCH5@ @C58G 75@7I@5H=CB =G D9F:CFA98 5B8 GHI8=98 :CF H<9 F9@=56=@=HM
5@CB;K=H<657?IDGHCF5;9G=G9J5@I5H98:CFF9@=56=@=HMGHI8M  9J5@I5H=CB 
88=B;H<9F9B9K56@99B9F;MGCIF79GK=@@<5J9@CK=AD57HCB
H<9GMGH9AF9@=56=@=HM9GD97=5@@M=BGA5@@G75@9A=7FC;F=8 !BH<9 -&!&
GA5@@G75@9A=7FC;F=8H<9=B8=79G75@7I@5H=CB89D9B8GCBH<9 ,<95IH<CFGF979=J98BC:=B5B7=5@GIDDCFH:CFH<9F9G95F7<
:5=@IF9 F5H9 C: H<9 A=7FC;F=8  !B @5F;9 G75@9 A=7FC;F=8 H<9 5IH<CFG<=D5B8 CFDI6@=75H=CBC:H<=G5FH=7@9 
7CADCB9BH:5=@IF9F5H9=G=;BCF9834 ,<9G=;B=:=75B79C:H<9 
:@9L=6@9578=GHF=6IH=CBGMGH9AK=H<F9GD97HHCH<9A=7FC;F=8=G **&+
7CBG=89F98  ,<9 DCK9F EI5@=HM 5B8 F9@=56=@=HM C: H<9 
8=GHF=6IH=CB GMGH9A 7CBB97H98 HC H<9 A=7FC;F=8 =G =ADFCJ98  3 4*5A56<CH@5+ PB9F;M%5B5;9A9BH=B%=7FC;F=8G Q(<  8=GG9FH5H=CB
,<9 :F9EI9B7M HF57?=B; 5B8 <5FACB=7 GD97HF5 C: H<9 @C58 ,9L5G,97<-B=J9FG=HMI;IGH 
7IFF9BHG5B8;F=8JC@H5;95F95GG9GG986MIG=B;H<9LH9B898




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
"CIFB5@C:F=H=75@!B:F5GHFI7HIF9G.C@  DD   
3 4+ <CK8<IFM+ ( <CK8<IFM5B8( FCGGG@9MP%=7FC;F=8G5B87H=J9
3 4&    <9F9 +  +7<@9=H< P*9@=56=@=HM C: M6F=8 (<CHCJC@H5=7 
=GHF=6IH=CB&9HKCF?GQH<9!BGH=HIH=CBC:B;=B99F=B;5B8,97<BC@C;M
%=7FCF=8 +MGH9AG :CF A9F;9B7M +<9@H9FG 5B8 'H<9F DD@=75H=CBG

(FC7998=B;GC:+(!.C@  DD      
34 &=?CG 5HN=5F;MF=CI P%=7FC;F=8G F7<=H97HIF9G 5B8 CBHFC@Q "C<B
3 4 (M9CB;!? K5B;9H 5@ %=7FC;F=8'D9F5H=CB5@%9H<C8:CF
/=@9M+CBG$H8 (I6@=G<98 6M"C<B/=@9M+CBG$H8 =FGH
B<5B798 +9FJ=79 *9@=56=@=HM -G=B;  IG +=;B5@=B;Q "CIFB5@ C:
8=H=CB8=H98  
@97HF=75@B;=B99F=B;,97<BC@C;M.C@   DD    
34+ *5A56<CH@59H 5@ P*9@=56=@=HM'DH=A=N5H=CB=BH<9!G@5B898%C89C:
3 4 #5JCIG=5F8 #<C859=P::=7=9BH!BH9;F5H=CBC:(@I;!B@97HF=7
%=7FC;F=8Q"CIFB5@C:B9F;M5B8(CK9FB;=B99F=B;.C@  DD  
.9<=7@9G.=5*97CB:=;IF56@9%=7FC;F=8GQ"CIFB5@C:B9F;M.C@ 
96   
DD   
34 $ <9 9H 5@  P'DH=A5@ !BH9F7CBB97H=CB (@5BB=B; C: CAAIB=HM
3 4<F=G%5FB5MP8898.5@I9C:*9@=56=@=HMHC5%=7FC;F=8+=AI@5H=CBG
%=7FC;F=8G /=H< *9B9K56@9 B9F;M +CIF79GQ ! ,F5BG57H=CBGCB
C:,<F995@=:CFB=5I=@8=B;GQ!*  
+A5FHF=8.C@ %5M  
3 4 0  )  I5B; P*9@=56=@=HM J5@I5H=CB C: %=7FC;F=8 @IGH9F 5G98 CB
34 %  @AI<5=B=   @+5??5: P%5F?CJ=5B %C89@ :CF *9@=56=@=HM
%CBH95F@C   =9F5F7<=75@   MB5A=7    *9@=56=@=HM    %C89@Q H<
GG9GGA9BH C: %=7FC;F=8G CBG=89F=B; $C58 ,F5BG:9F *9GHF=7H=CBQ
!BH9FB5H=CB5@ CB:9F9B79 CB 8J5B79G =B (CK9F +MGH9A CBHFC@
,IF?=G<"CIFB5@C:@97HF=75@B;=B99F=B;CADIH9F+7=9B79G.C@ 
'D9F5H=CB%5B5;9A9BH(+'%  &CJ 
DD    
3 4 .  GH5DCJ +  ,F5G<7<9B?CJ P9G=;B 5B8 *9@=56=@=HM J5@I5H=CB C:
34 *  <G<5B 9H 5@  P%=7FC;F=8 *9@=56=@=HM J5@I5H=CB CBG=89F=B; H<9
+H5B85@CB9 %=7FC;F=8Q H< !BH9FB5H=CB5@ +7=9BH=:=7 CB:9F9B79 CB
!BH9FA=HH9B7M ::97H C: *9B9K56@9 B9F;M +CIF79GQ !BH9FB5H=CB5@
@97HF=7(CK9FB;=B99F=B;(!  
"CIFB5@C:+A5FHF=85B8@95BB9F;MDD      
3 4 5FN=B9H 5@ P*C@9C:'IH5;9%5B5;9A9BH+HF5H9;M=B*9@=56=@=HM
34 +  1CI@= P::=7=9B7M C: %=7FC;F=8 K=H< +HCF5;9 5HH9FM =B *9@=56=@=HM
(9F:CFA5B79 C: %I@H=%=7FC;F=8 =GHF=6IH=CB +MGH9AGQ !
7CBCAM 5B8 BJ=FCBA9BH GG9GGA9BHGQ !BH9FB5H=CB5@ "CIFB5@ C:
,F5BG57H=CBGCB(CK9F+MGH9AG.C@ &C %5M 
@97HF=75@5B8(CK9FB;=B99F=B;.C@ DD     
3 4 + &=;5AP*9@=56=@=HMGG9GGA9BHC:5=GHF=6IH=CB&9HKCF?K=H<5
34 &  &=?A9<F +  *5J585B9;< P+HC7<5GH=7 *=G? 5B8 *9@=56=@=HM
%=7FC;F=8Q !&CFH<A9F=75B(CK9F+MADCG=IA&(+
GG9GGA9BHG C: B9F;M %5B5;9A9BH +MGH9A =B F=8 C: %=7FC;F=8G
 +9DH   
IB89F-B79FH5=BHMQ"CIFB5@C:(CK9F,97<BC@C;=9G.C@ DD O
3 4 +C@HCKG?=% C@5BP-G=B;+A5FH(CK9F%5B5;9A9BHCBHFC@HC
  
%5L=A=N9 B9F;M -H=@=N5H=CB 5B8 *9@=56=@=HM K=H<=B 5 %=7FC;F=8 C:
3 4 '  BG5F= 9H 5@  P*9@=56=@=HM GG9GGA9BH C: %=7FC;F=8 K=H<
!BH9F7CBB97H98+C@5F CA9+MGH9AGQ!  
*9B9K56@99B9F5H=CB5B8(F=CF=H=N98$C58GQ!F99BB9F;M5B8
34  5B=<A989H 5@ P*9@=56=@=HMB5@MG=GC:5979BHF5@=N98
+MGH9AGCB:9F9B79!+ 
%=7FC;F=8 CBHFC@ F7<=H97HIF9Q ! ,F5BG57H=CBG CB +A5FH F=8
3 4" .5@6I9B5PGG9GGA9BHCB%=7FC;F=8*9@=56=@=HMDD@M=B;9A5B8
"IB9 
+=89%5B5;9A9BH+79B5F=CGQ+!$DD   
34 +    @G5=5< 9H 5@  P %9H<C8 CF *9@=56=@=HM !ADFCJ9A9BH C:
3 4 68I@?5F=A9H 5@ %C89@:CF'DH=AIA9G=;BC:+H5B85@CB9 M6F=8
%=7FC;F=8GQ!(CK9F+MGH9AGCADIH5H=CBCB:9F9B79(+
*9B9K56@9B9F;M%=7FC;F=8GQ"CIFB5@C:IB85A9BH5@5B8DD@=98
 "IB9  
+7=9B79G.C@ DD  %5M  
34 $  2<5B; %   +IB P*9G95F7< CB H<9 ,MD9 C: $C58 C: 779GG=B; HC
3 4 ( ,  56C@= P@9L=6@9 *9@=56=@=HM %C89@=B; =B M6F=8 
%=7FC;F=8 5G98 CB *9@=56=@=HMQ B8 !BH9FB5H=CB5@ CB:9F9B79 CB
%=7FC;F=8Q"CIFB5@C:@97HF=75@+MGH9AG5B8+=;B5@G.C@  &C  
@97HF=75@CADIH9FB;=B99F=B;5B8@97HFCB=7G!  
DD   
34%    'A5F 9H 5@  P,97<B=EI9G C: !B7F95G=B; %=7FC F=8
3 4 2  <9B; 9H 5@  P*9@=56=@=HM GG9GGA9BH 5B8 CAD5F=GCB 69HK99B
*9@=56=@=HMQ !BH9FB5H=CB5@ "CIFB5@ C: +7=9BH=:=7  B;=B99F=B;
9BHF5@=N985B8=GHF=6IH98B9F;M%5B5;9A9BH+MGH9A=B!G@5B8=B;
*9G95F7<.C@IA9!GGI9 DD '7HC69F 
%=7FC;F=8Q&CFH<A9F=75B(CK9F+MADCG=IA&(+  
34 +  +<=B?<989 P(CK9F )I5@=HM 5B8 *9@=56=@=HM C: ,<9 'J9F5@@ (CK9F
3 4   %5@9?= 9H 5@  P%9H<C8 C: 9J5@I5H=B; F9@=56=@=HM C: A=7FC;F=8G =B
=GHF=6IH=CBC:%=7FC;F=8+MGH9AQ!BH9FB5H=CB5@"CIFB5@C:8J5B798
!G@5B8 AC89 6M IG=B; @C58 DF=CF=H=N5H=CBQ ,<9 H< @97HF=75@ (CK9F
*9G95F7< =B @97HF=75@ @97HFCB=7G 5B8 !BGHFIA9BH5H=CB B;=B99F=B;
=GHF=6IH=CBCB:9F9B79( %5M  
.C@ !GGI9 DD O"5BI5FM  
3 41 /5B;9H 5@ PCAAIB=75H=CB$9GG=GHF=6IH98.C@H5;9CBHFC@
34 %989=FCG *  0I 0   5B8 %5?F5A   GG9GGA9BH C: 'D9F5H=B;
+HF5H9;M:CF5%I@H=IG!G@5B898%=7FC;F=8Q!BH9FB5H=CB5@(CK9F
CB8=H=CB 9D9B89BH *9@=56=@=HM !B8=79G =B %=7FC;F=8G  "CIFB5@ C:
@97HFCB=7GCB:9F9B79!( =FCG<=A5 +!  
(CK9F5B8B9F;MB;=B99F=B;  
3 4 $ <9 9H 5@  P'DH=A5@ !BH9F7CBB97H=CB (@5BB=B; C: CAAIB=HM
34 +   *5A56<CH@5 9H 5@  *9@=56=@=HM 'DH=A=N5H=CB -G=B; 5I@H ,F99
%=7FC;F=8G /=H< *9B9K56@9 B9F;M +CIF79GQ ! ,F5BG57H=CBG CB
B5@MG=G =B H<9 F=8 CBB97H98 %C89 C: %=7FC;F=8 ! F99B
+A5FHF=8.C@ %5M  
,97<BC@C;=9GCB:9F9B79F99B,97<  
3 4, 89:5F5H=9H 5@ P*9@=56=@=HM5B897CBCA=79J5@I5H=CBC:5A=7FC;F=8
3 4$= 2  1I5B 1  $=   PJ5@I5H=B; H<9 *9@=56=@=HM C: !G@5B898
DCK9F GMGH9AQ H< !BH9FB5H=CB5@ CB:9F9B79 CB DD@=98 B9F;M
%=7FC;F=8 =B 5B A9F;9B7M %C89 Q !B (FC7998=B; C: H<9 H< !
!   I;IGH 5F8=::-# 
!BH9FB5H=CB5@-B=J9FG=H=9G(CK9FB;=B99F=B;CB:9F9B79 
3 4 5FA9B $  ,  CF;9G  8I5F8C 5BH5F=BC  P%=7FC;F=8G *9@=56=@=HM

J5@I5H=CB K=H< *9B9K56@9 =GHF=6IH98 9B9F5H=CB 5B8 +HCF5;9
H<
+MGH9AGQ(FC7998=B;GC:H<9  /CF@8CB;F9GG,<9!BH9FB5H=CB5@
989F5H=CBC:IHCA5H=7CBHFC@%=@5BC!H5@MI;IGH +9DH9A69F
 
3 4   5F8CGC5 9H 5@  P%=7FC;F=8 *9@=56=@=HM %C89@=B; 5B8 5HH9FM
+7<98I@=B; -G=B; +HC7<5GH=7 $=B95F (FC;F5AA=B;Q @97HF=7 (CK9F
+MGH9AG*9G95F7<.C@  DD  O  
3 4% 1 &;IM9B1 , 1CCB5PCAD5F=GCBC:%=7FC;F=8,CDC@C;=9G
CBG=89F=B;CH<%5F?9H'D9F5H=CBG5B8*9@=56=@=HMQ@97HF=7(CK9F
CADCB9BHG5B8+MGH9AG.C@  DD O%5F7<  
3 4 %  5KCI85 P M6F=8 *9B9K56@9 %=7FC;F=8 'DH=A=N5H=CB
,97<B=EI9G  *9J=9KQ *9B9K56@9 5B8 +IGH5=B56@9 B9F;M
*9J=9KG.C@  DD  O    
3 4 )  <9B $  %=@= P'DH=A5@ (@579A9BH 5B8 +=N=B; C: %=7FC;F=8G =B
CADCG=H9*9@=56=@=HMC:59F9;I@5H98(CK9F+MGH9AQ!BH9FB5H=CB5@




Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on August 29,2020 at 00:32:47 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like