financially related to one FRIA’s Declared Policies another as parent • Expresses the policy of the corporations, subsidiaries and State to encourage debtors, both affiliates; juridical and natural persons, b. Partnerships that are owned and their creditors to more than fifty percent (50%) collectively and realistically by the same person; and resolve and adjust competing c. Single proprietorships that claims and property rights. are owned by the same person • The State ensures a timely, fair and transparent, effective, and INSOLVENT efficient rehabilitation or Debtor is generally unable to pay liquidation of debtors. its or his liabilities as they • Main Factors: (a) ensure or fall due in the ordinary course of maintain certainty and business; OR his liabilities are predictability in commercial greater than his assets. affairs; (b) preserve and maximize the value of the assets LIABILITIES of these debtors; (c) recognize Monetary claims against a debtor, creditor rights; (d) respect including stockholder’s advances priority claims; and (e) ensure that have been recorded in the equitable treatment of creditors debtor’s audited financial who are similarly situated statements as advances for future • When rehabilitation is not subscriptions feasible, it is in the interest of the State to facilitate a ORDINARY COURSE OF BUSINESS speedy and orderly liquidation Transactions in the pursuit of the of the debtor’s assets and the individual debtor’s or debtor’s settlement of their obligations. business operations prior to rehabilitation OR insolvency KEY DEFINITIONS proceedings and on ordinary business terms. DEBTOR a. sole proprietorship duly CREDITOR registered with the DTI; A natural or juridical person which b. partnership duly registered by has a claim against the debtor that the SEC rose on or before the commencement c. corporation duly organized and date. existing under Philippine Laws d. individual debtor who has COMMENCEMENT DATE become insolvent Date on which the court issues the Commencement Order, which shall be retroactive to the date of the filing of the petition for voluntary or involuntary INDIVIDUAL DEBTOR proceedings. A natural person who is a resident and citizen of the Philippines that COMMENCEMENT ORDER shall become insolvent. • Appoints the rehabilitation receiver, and includes a stay order. The rationale of the stay Refers to the restoration of the order is to enable the debtor to a condition of successful rehabilitation receiver to focus operation and solvency, if it is on the rehabilitation of the shown that its continuance of debtor unhampered by court operation is economically feasible, suits. and its creditor can recover by way of the present value of payments SECURED CREDITOR projected in the plan. Refers to a creditor with a secured claim. Rehabilitation of SOLE Secured Claim – claim that is PROPRIETORSHIP, PARTNERSHIP and secured by a lien. CORPORATION – thru a petition Lien – refers to a statutory or contractual claim or Voluntary Rehabilitation Must judicial charge on real or establish the insolvency of personal property that legally the debtor and the viability entitles a creditor to resort of its rehabilitation to said property for payment Involuntary Rehabilitation of the claim or debt secured When: by such lien. a. NO GENUINE ISSUE OF FACT or law on the claim/s of GENERAL UNSECURED CREDITOR the petitioner/s and that Refers to a creditor whose claim or the due and demandable a portion thereof is neither payments have not been secured, preferred nor subordinated made for at least 60 days under the FRIA. OR that the debtor has failed generally to meet WHEN A GROUP OF CREDITORS MAY FILE: its liabilities as they One or more of its members fall due; OR foresee the impossibility of b. A creditor, other than meeting debts when they the petitioner/s, has respectively fall due, and the initiated foreclosure financial distress would proceedings against the likely adversely affect the debtor that will prevent financial condition and/or the debtor from paying operations of the other member its debts as they become of the group and/or due or will render it participation of the other insolvent members of the group is essential under the terms and REHABILITATION PLAN conditions of the proposed Plan by which the financial well- Rehabilitation Plan. being and viability of an insolvent debtor can be restored using EXCLUDED DEBTORS various means including but not 1. Banks limited to debt forgiveness, debt 2. Pre-Need Companies rescheduling, reorganization or 3. Insurance Companies quasi-reorganization, dacion en 4. National and Local Government pago, debt-equity conversion and Agencies or Units sale of the business, or setting up of a new business entity or other REHABILITATION similar arrangements as may be approved by the court or creditors. management of the debtor in the CRAM DOWN RULE following cases: The Rehabilitation Plan confirmed Actual or imminent danger of by the court shall be binding upon dissipation, loss, ow wastage the debtor and all persons who may of debtor’s assets or be affected by it, including properties creditors, whether or not such Paralyzation of the business persons have participated in the operations of the debtor proceedings, opposed the Plan or Gross mismanagement by the whether or not their claims have debtor, or fraud or other been scheduled. wrongful conduct or violation of the FRIA Law and Court STAY ORDER Orders suspends all actions and proceedings, including the COURT ACTION ON PETITION FOR enforcement of claims against REHABILITATION the debtor; The Court may either: suspends the enforcement of a. Give due course to the any judgement and other petition remedies against the debtor; b. Dismiss the petition prohibit the selling, c. Convert the proceedings to encumbering, transferring or liquidation proceedings disposing any of its • SUSPENSION OF PAYMENTS properties; • Only an individual debtor may Prohibit the debtor from file a petition for suspension making any payment of its of payment. liabilities outstanding “as • The debtor has sufficient of the commencement date” properties to cover all his debts but forsees the SUSPENDED CLAIMS impossibility of meeting his All claims of the government debts when they respectively (national or local) fall due Claims against directors and • The purpose is to suspend or officers of the debtor arising delay the payment of debts from acts done in the • The amount of indebtedness is discharge of their functions not affected (not reduced or falling within the scope of discharged) their authority • The number of creditors is immaterial • DISTINCTIONS: Suspension of Payment v. Liquidation WHO WILL MANAGE: • DISTINCTIONS: General Rule: The existing BOARD Suspension of Payment v. and/or MANAGEMENT of the debtor Rehabilitation shall continue. Exception: Management can be • SUSPENSION ORDER replaced. Upon Motion, the court • Upon motion filed by the may appoint either “Rehabilitation individual debtor, the Court may Receiver” or a “Management issue an order suspending any Committee” to undertake the pending execution against the individual debtor. • Properties held as security faith, or that the objection is not be secured creditors shall curable not be the subject of the 6. AT any time pending the court- suspension order supervised or pre-negotiated • The suspension order shall rehabilitation proceedings, the lapse when 3 months shall debtor may file a motion in the have passed WITHOUT the same court where the rehabilitation proposed agreement being proceedings are pending to covert accepted by the creditors or the proceedings into one for as soon as such agreement is liquidation denied 7. Upon recommendation by the • Creditors cannot sue or rehabilitation receiver institute proceedings to • Liquidation of INDIVIDUAL collect his claim from from DEBTORS may be (1) Voluntary OR; the debtor from the time of (2) Involuntary the filing of the petition • Involuntary Liquidation of for suspension of payments Individual Debtors vs. and as long as the Involuntary Liquidation Business proceedings remain pending. Organizations • EXCEPTIONS: • LIQUIDATION PROCESS 1) Creditors having claim for • This is the proceeding where personal labor, maintenance, claims are filed and the assets expense of last illness and funeral of the insolvent debtor are of the wife or children of the disposed and the proceeds are debtor incurred in the 6o days divided among the creditors. immediately prior to the filing of • The rules applies to individual the petition debtors, sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation. 2) Secured Creditors • Applies as well to both original • Instances when rehabilitation liquidation proceedings and proceedings may be converted proceedings that are originally into liquidation proceedings: rehabilitation proceedings but • The debtor is insolvent converted into liquidation • No substantial likelihood for proceedings. the debtor to be successfully • LIQUIDATION ORDER contains: rehabilitated; • Declaring that the debtor is • It no rehabilitation plain is insolvent confirmed within 1 year from • Ordering the liquidation of the date of the filing of the the debtor petition for rehabilitation • In case of juridical person, • If the termination of the declaring it as dissolved rehabilitation proceedings • Prohibiting payments and/or was due to failure of the transfer of property bybthe rehabilitation or dismissal debtor; and of the petition for reasons • Directing all claims to be other than technical grounds filed with the liquidator • Instances when rehabilitation • RIGHTS OF SECURED CREDITORS: proceedings may be converted • The Liquidation Order shall not into liquidation proceedings: affect the right of a secured 5. If the court determines that the creditor to enforce his lien in debtor or creditor supporting the accordance with the applicable Rehabilitation Plan acted in bad contract or law. The secured it as against another creditor. It creditor may: is not a question who takes or • Waive his right under the sells, it is one of the application security or lien, prove his of the proceeds after the sale—of claim in the liquidation payment of the debt proceedings and share in the • Continuation. . distribution of the assets of 4. The right of preference is the debtor one which can be made only by • Maintain his right under the being asserted and security or lien maintained. If the right • DISTRIBUTION OF ASSETS claimed is not asserted or • The assets of the insolvent maintained, it is lost. debtor shall be divided among 5. Where a creditor released the creditors in accordance with his levy, leaving the property the Liquidation Plan submitted in possession of the debtor, by the Liquidator and approved thereby indicating that he by the Court. didn’t intend to press his • The rules on Concurrence and claim further as to that Preference of Credit under the specific property, after that act, New Civil Code shall be observed his claim to preference, if one had in the Liquidation Plan. been asserted y him, could not exist because he had ceased to • CONCURRENCE AND PREFERENCE OF contest. CREDIT • • CONCURRENCE OF CREDITS WHEN RULE OF PREFERENCE -Implies the possession by two APPLICABLE or more creditors of equal rights or privileges over the • Apply only where two or more same property or all the creditors have separate and property of a debtor distinct claims against the same debtor who has an • PREFERENCE OF CREDIT insufficient property -Right held by a creditor to be • Is applicable when the preferred in the payment of his debtor is insolvent—having claim above others out of the more liabilities than his assets debtor’s assets • It is a matter of necessity and log that the question of preference should • NATURE AND EFFECT OF PREFERENCE arise only when the debtor’s 1. A preference is an assets are insufficient to pay exception to the general his debts in full rule. For this reason, the law as to preferences is strictly construed. • GENERAL PROVISIONS 2. Preference doesn’t create an interest in property. it Art. 2236. creates simply a right of one creditor to be paid first the The debtor is liable with all his proceeds of the sale of property property, present and future, for as against another creditor. the fulfillment of his 3. The law doesn’t give the obligations, subject to the creditor who has a preference a exemptions provided by law. (1911a) right to take the property or sell • REMEMBER that preference is • only given to #1 and the GENERAL CATEGORIES OF CREDIT rest shall be treated equally
1. Special preferred credits • Art. 2241. With reference to
listed in Articles 2241 and 2242 specific movable property of the debtor, the following claims or 2. Ordinary preferred credits liens shall be preferred: listed in Article 2244 (1) Duties, taxes and fees due thereon to the State or any 3. Common credits under Article subdivision thereof; 2245 (2) Claims arising from misappropriation, breach of trust, • or malfeasance by public officials NATURE OF CLAIMS OR CREDITS committed in the performance of IN their duties, on the movables, ARTICLES 2241 AND 2242 money or securities obtained by them; • Articles 2241 and 2242 (3) Claims for the unpaid price of apply only when there is a movables sold, on said movables, so concurrence of credits when the long as they are in the possession same specific property of the of the debtor, up to the value of debtor is subjected to the the same; and if the movable has claims of several creditors been resold by the debtor and the and the value of such property price is still unpaid, the lien may is insufficient to pay in full be enforced on the price; this all the creditors right is not lost by the • In such situation, the immobilization of the thing by question of preference will destination, provided it has not arise, there will be a need lost its form, substance and to determine which of the identity; neither is the right lost creditors will be paid ahead of by the sale of the thing together the others with other property for a lump sum, when the price thereof can be • determined proportionally; PREFERRED CREDITS WITH (4) Credits guaranteed with a RESPECT TO pledge so long as the things SPECIFIC MOVABLE PROPERTY pledged are in the hands of the creditor, or those guaranteed by a • Articles 2241 and 2242 don’t chattel mortgage, upon the things give the order of preference or pledged or mortgaged, up to the priority of payment value thereof; • They merely enumerate the (5) Credits for the making, repair, credits which enjoy preference safekeeping or preservation of with respect to specific personal property, on the movable movables or immovables thus made, repaired, kept or • With respect to the same possessed; specific movable or immovable, creditors with the exception of • Continuation. . the State, merely concur (6) Claims for laborers' wages, on the goods manufactured or the work done; (7) For expenses of salvage, upon architects, engineers and the goods salvaged; contractors, engaged in the (8) Credits between the landlord construction, reconstruction or and the tenant, arising from the repair of buildings, canals contract of tenancy on shares, on or other works, upon said the share of each in the fruits or buildings, canals or other works; harvest; (4) Claims of (9) Credits for transportation, furnishers of materials upon the goods carried, for the used in the construction, price of the contract and reconstruction, or repair of incidental expenses, until their buildings, canals or other works, delivery and for thirty days upon said buildings, canals or thereafter; other works; (10) Credits for lodging and (5) Mortgage credits supplies usually furnished to recorded in the Registry of travellers by hotel keepers, on the Property, upon the real estate movables belonging to the guest as mortgaged; long as such movables are in the (6) Expenses for the hotel, but not for money loaned to preservation or improvement of the guests; real property when the law (11) Credits for seeds and expenses authorizes reimbursement, upon the for cultivation and harvest immovable preserved or improved; advanced to the debtor, upon the (7) Credits annotated in fruits harvested; the Registry of Property, in (12) Credits for rent for one year, virtue of a judicial order, upon the personal property of the by attachments or executions, lessee existing on the immovable upon the property affected, and leased and on the fruits of the only as to later credits; same, but not on money or (8) Claims of co-heirs for instruments of credit; warranty in the partition of an (13) Claims in favor of the immovable among them, upon depositor if the depositary has the real property thus wrongfully sold the thing divided; deposited, upon the price of the (9) Claims of donors or sale. real property for pecuniary • Art. 2242. With reference charges or other conditions imposed to specific immovable upon the donee, upon the immovable property and real rights donated; of the debtor, the (10) Credits of insurers, following claims, mortgages upon the property insured, for the and liens shall be preferred, insurance premium for two years. and shall constitute an (1923a) encumbrance on the immovable or real right: (1) Taxes due upon the land or building; (2) For the unpaid price of real property sold, upon the immovable sold; (3) Claims of laborers, masons, mechanics and other workmen, as well as of