Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kirkendall 2007
Kirkendall 2007
62
Function and biomechanics
64nm
Collagen
More than 12 different types of collagen have been
recognized, but it is easy to think of collagen as either
fiber forming or non-fiber forming. Types I, I1 and
I11 are fiber-forming collagens and make up most of
i$ Hole Zone
! I '
the tendon collagen secreted into extracellular spaces,
which eventually forms fibrils. Of these, type I makes
Packing of
MoleCuleS
-
-I-
-
-;
up about 90% of the collagen in the body and is the
primary collagen of tendons. The other collagens are
non-fiber-forming collagens. Articular cartilage has
Collagen 280nrn
primarily type I1 collagen. Types IV and V make up Molecule '
,-I
I
basement membrane collagens.
The tenocyte produces a precursor molecule, pro-
collagen, that is secreted, then cleaved to form tropo-
collagen. Collagen fibrils are then assembled via non- a2
covalent cross-links. Covalent cross-links then bind
fibrils into the typical triple helix yielding the body's
strongest protein (Fig. 2).
Triple a,
Helix
at 1
1.5nm
Elastin
Elastin is required in structures that undergo great
changes in length in the absence of any permanent
change in structure. There is only a small amount of a Collagen a-chain (purity 10 molecules)
elastin in the tendons of the extremities and much Structure of Collagen
more in places like the ligamentum nuchae. In ten- Fig. 2. The microstrucure of collagen. Three alpha chains coil
dons, elastin is less than 1% of dry weight (versus the to form a triple-stranded helical rod (from ref. 1).
aorta where elastin makes up 30-60% of dry weight).
The unique properties of elastin are due to the link-
age of unique, copper-dependent, amino acids, de-
smosine and isodesomosine, to lysine residues. synthesis as opposed to areas that undergo frictional
and compressive forces (2).
A secondary component of tendons is proteo-
Ground substance glycan, which comprises 1-209'0 of the dry weight of
Much of the viscoelastic properties of tendon are due tendon, depending on factors such as age, site, and
to its ground substance. The water-binding capacity the history of mechanical loading. Proteoglycans rep-
of proteoglycans, glycosaminoglycans, plasma pro- resent a diverse family of glycosylated proteins that
teins, and other small molecules help stabilize the col- contain numerous sulfated polysaccharides (glycosa-
lagen skeleton of tendon. Those portions of the ten- minoglycans, or GAGs). The predominant proteo-
don that experience the greatest tensile forces have glycan component in tendon is a low molecular
low proteoglycan content and high rates of collagen weight dermatan sulfate. Larger molecular weight
proteoglycans are present in the fibrocartilaginous re-
gions of the tendon, which are placed under compres-
sive loads in vivo.
The physical properties of proteoglycans are dic-
tated by the presence of a large number of negatively
charged GAGs, which attract counter-ions and water
molecules in the tissue. These characteristics are be-
lieved to contribute to the tissue's compressive prop-
.~ ,
Paratenon
Ep,tenon i Peritendon erties and viscoelastic behavior.
Endofenon
~Fibroblesl
. . ~i
~~
~~
Fiber bundle
Fiber Tendon biomechanics
Fibnl
~ Microfibril
Tendons must be able to transmit high muscle forces
to the skeleton for movement, and the parallel ar-
Fzg I Structural model of a tendon. rangement of fiber bundles is quite efficient at this
63
Kirkendall & Garrett
bone unit fails, the typical locations are bone, bone-
tendon junction or muscle-tendon junction. How-
ever, diseased tendon can fail. Kannus & Jozsa (4)
showed that 97% of nearly 900 patients with spon-
taneous ruptures of tendon exhibited degenerative
changes in the ruptured tendon (e.g. hypoxic degener-
Deformation ( ative tendinopathy, mucoid degeneration, tendolipo-
Itime
matosis or calcifying tendinopathy).
Tendons function to transfer tension from muscle
to bone. According to Cutts et al. ( 5 ) , when the
muscle contracts, the resulting stretch by the tendon
leads to three definite outcomes.
Deformation First, compliance of a tendon makes it difficult to
hold a joint steady as changes in force lead to changes
I in tendon length. Conversely, control of fine motor
tasks is easier because the force necessary for change
is reduced from small changes in muscle length.
stress Second, stretched tendons store elastic energy that
Stress relaxation is released upon recoil effectively reducing the work
of the muscle.
time Third, stretching of the tendon requires that the
Fig. 3. Graphic representation of the biomechanical properties
muscle may have to shorten more than might nor-
of tendon demonstrating the concepts of creep and stress-relax- mally be necessary. Therefore, this extensibility can
ation (from ref. 1). be considered advantageous, such as when the tendon
acts like a spring, or disadvantageous, as when energy
is being transfered to an external system.
Ker et al. (6) argue that tendon function should
function. However, tendons have a low resistance to be considered in concert with muscle function and
shear forces. Thus, tendons are designed to transmit describe a combined mass of the muscle and tendon.
forces with minimal deformation or energy loss. Thin tendons (those which stretch the most) require
Collagenous tissues such as ligament and skin longer muscle fibers to yield the ideal ratio of muscle
show a similar stress-strain relationship to that of mass to tendon mass. Their optimum ratio of 34
tendon. Two primary features are stress-relaxation yields a stress of 10 MPa, which is well below the 100
(decreased stress over time with constant deforma- MPa breaking point for normal tendon, demonstrat-
tion) and creep (increased length over time with a ing that mammalian tendons are far thicker than
constant load) (Fig. 3). These properties lead to a necessary.
load-deformation relationship for tendon that is de- Ker et al. (6) also point out that the safety factor
pendent on the activities prior to assessment (history-
dependent properties).
A typical load-deformation curve is presented in
Fig. 4. Four distinct features of the curve can be dis-
cussed in light of anatomic microstructure (3). The
initial ‘toe’ region corresponds to the arrangement of
the fibers with the direction of the stress,
straightening out the initial ‘waviness’ of the fiber
bundles. The linear portion of the curve (the elastic
stiffness of the tendon) is a result of the elongation of
the helical structure. At the end of the linear portion,
unpredictable failure begins, leading to eventual rup-
ture and a recoil of tendon at the ruptured end. In
vivo, there is some margin for error as the maximum
isometric force of a muscle is about one-third that
necessary for tendon failure. However, repetitive sub-
maximal loading and fatigue can lead to tendon ELONGATION
failure. Fig. 4 . A typical load-elongation curve demonstrating the ‘toe’
It should be noted that normal tendon does not or primary region (l), the ‘linear’ or secondary region (2) and
fail in response to strain. When this muscle-tendon- the end of the secondary region (3) (from ref. 1).
64
(the difference between tendon stress and breaking
point) is reduced in muscles that supply elastic recoil
during locomotion. For example, they report that the
stress on the Achilles tendon is as high as 67 MPa,
t
I
- Decrease
Immobilization
tress
I
Increase
Stress
Physiologic
Activities I
-
Function and biomechanics
Exercise
Plasticity of tendon
A variety of conditions may alter the normal charac-
teristics of tendon. These might include immobiliza-
tion, exercise, aging and medications.
Immobilization
STRESS AND STRAIN
Like ligament, immobilization results in profound re- DURATION
ductions in the mechanical properties of tendon. Fig. 5. The hypothetical relationship of the effects of stress and
Most noticeably, there is a decrease in tendon motion on the responses of soft connective tissues (from ref.
strength along with an increase in collagen turnover 14).
(7, 8). Like so many other tissues, tendon is inti-
mately affected by immobilization.
spontaneous rupture of tendons does not occur in the
absence of some pre-existing histopathological con-
Exercise ditions (4). In nearly 900 patients, degenerative
The literature on the effects of exercise training on changes were seen in practically all those with spon-
tendon function is indecisive. Some studies have taneous rupture (4). The most common conditions
shown increases in tendon strength (9-1 1) while a seen were hypoxic degenerative tendinopathy (44%),
long-term study (1 year) of training in pigs showed no mucoid degeneration (21%), tendolipomatosis (8%)
change in the mechanical properties, area or collagen and calcifying tendinopathy (5%).
content of flexor tendons (12), while improvements in
strength, area and collagen content were demon-
Medication
strated in extensor tendons (1 1). Further, while an
increase in load to failure was found in the tendons Corticosteroids. Glucocorticoids are frequently used
of trained animals, no differences were seen for in the treatment of sports injuries due to their potent
weight, water or collagen content (10). Structurally, anti-inflammatory effects. Glucocorticoids inhibit the
there appears to be an increase in collagen synthesis, synthesis of collagen (18) and occasionally local injec-
as smaller fibril bundles have been documented (13). tions around patellar and Achilles tendons may pre-
Woo et al. (14) proposed a model of the mechanical cede a tendon rupture (19, 20). The systemic effects
responses of tendon to immobilization and exercise of oral glucocorticoid treatment have been demon-
(Fig. 5). They suggest that tendon undergoes pro- strated in patients with bilateral Achilles tendon rup-
found insult as a result of immobilization, but train- ture (21, 22).
ing has little or no effect on these mechanical prop- Laboratory studies are less conclusive due to the
erties. common variables of dosage, duration of therapy,
location of injection, or type of drug. For example,
local injection of hydrocortisone acetate (20 mg/kg)
Aging every third day for 24 days showed increases in pero-
Tensile strength reaches a plateau after collagen neal tendon strength in the absence of changes in col-
maturation and declines with age. This decline is re- lagen content, while the same injection schedule into
lated to a decrease in both insoluble and total colla- knee joints lead to reduced tensile strength of the in-
gen content (15). The loss of collagen and its cross- terface between the posterior cruciate ligament and
linking leads to an increase in tendon stiffness (16, bone (23). Daily injections of prednisolone (2 mg/kg)
17). A variety of degenerative conditions can affect near the peroneal tendons for 2 weeks increased the
the function of tendon. Of interest is the fact that maximum load; stress and energy absorption were in-
65
Kirkendall & Garrett
creased as was elastic stiffness, the latter due to more 9. Tipton CM, Schild RJ, Tomanek RJ. Influence of physical
stable cross-linking within the tendon (24). Longer activity on the strength of knee ,ligaments in rats. Am J
Physiol 1967: 212: 783-7.
term injection schedules (10 mg/kg cortisone every 10. Viidik A. The effects of training on the tensile strength of
third day for 55 days) did not alter mechanical prop- isolated rabbit tendons. Scand J Plas Reconstr Surg 1967:
erties, but the hydroxyproline content was reduced 1: 14147.
(25). 11. Woo SL-Y, Ritter MA, Amiel D et al. The biomechanical
and biochemical properties of swine tendons. Long-term
It is likely that corticosteroids impact tendinous effects of exercise on the digital extensors. Connect Tissue
tissue in two ways. During the first week or two, corti- Res 1980: 7: 177-83.
costeroid injection induces a rapid increase in the ten- 12. Woo SL-Y, Gomez MA, Amiel D et al. The effects of exer-
don’s mechanical stability due to a change in the cise on the biomechanical and biochemical properties of
cross-linking pattern. Then, an inhibition of protein swine digital flexor tendons. J Biomech Eng 1981: 103: 51-
6.
synthesis leads to collagen thinning, to a progressive 3. Michna H. Morphometric analysis of loading-induced
reduction in collagen content (1, 25). changes in collagen-fibril populations in young tendons.
Cell Tissue Res 1984: 236: 465-70.
4. Woo SL-Y, Gomez MA, Woo Y-K, Akeson WH. Mechan-
Non-steroidal anti-inflammatovy agents. It is well ical properties of tendons and ligaments. 11. The relation-
known that indomethecin increases the tensile ships of immobilization and exercise on tissue remodeling.
strength of tendons and total collagen content (26). Biorheology 1982: 19: 397408.
Similar results were found in tendons undergoing re- 5. Vogel HC. Influence of maturation and age on mechanical
and biochemical parameters of connective tissue of various
pair (27), suggesting that much of the increase in ten- organs in the rat. Connect Tissue Res 1978: 6: 161-6.
don strength is due to improved collagen cross- 16. Bailey AJ, Robins SP, Balian G. Biological significance of
linking (1). the intermolecular crosslinks of collagen. Nature 1984:
251: 105-9.
17. Eyre DR. Crosslinking in collagen and elastin. Ann Rev
Biochem 1984: 53: 71748.
Acknowledgement 18. Nimni ME, Bavetta LA. Collagen synthesis and turnover
The authors wish to acknowledge the contribution of Dr Far- in the growing rat under the influence of methylprednis-
shid Guilak in the Orthopedic Research Laboratoy of the Divi- olone. Proc SOCExp Biol Med 1964: 117: 618-23.
sion of Orthopedics at Duke University Medical Center for his 19. Lee HB. Avulsion and rupture of the tenocalcaneus after
assistance in the preparation of this manuscript. injection of hydrocortisone. Br Med J 1957: 2: 395.
20. Oxlund H. Changes in connective tissues during cortico-
tropin and corticosteroid treatment. Thesis. Aarchus: Insti-
References tute of Anatomy, University of Aarchus, 1983.
21. Lee MLH. Bilateral rupture of Achilles tendon. Br Med J
1. Best TM, Garrett Jr WE. Muscle and tendon. In: Delee 1961: 1: 1829-30.
JC, Drez D, ed. Orthopaedic sports medicine: principles 22. Melmed EP. Spontaneous bilateral rupture of the calcaneal
and practice. Philadelphia, PA: WB Saunders, 1994: 1-59. tendon during steroid therapy. J Bone Joint Surg 1965:
2. Banes AJ, Link GW, Bevin AG et al. Tendon synovial cells 47B: 1 0 4 5 .
secrete fibronectin in vivo and in vitro. J Orthop Res 1988: 23. Oxlund H. The influence of a local injection of cortisol on
6: 73-82. the mechanical properties of tendons and ligaments and
3. Abrahams M. Mechanical behavior of tendon in vitro: a the indirect effect on skin. Acta Orthop Scand 1980: 51:
preliminary report. Med Biol Engr 1967: 5: 3 3 4 3 . 231-8.
4. Kannus P, Jozsa L. Histopathological changes preceding 24. Oxlund H, Manthorpe R, Viidik A. The biomechanical
spontaneous rupture of a tendon. J Bone Joint Surg 1991: properties of connective tissue in rabbits as influenced by
73-A: 1507-25. short-term glucocorticoid treatment. J Biomech 1981: 14:
5. Cutts A, Alexander RM, Ker RF. Ratios of cross-sectional 129-33.
areas of muscles and their tendons in a healthy human 25. Oxlund H. Long-term local cortisol treatment of tendons
forearm. J Anat 1991: 176: 13347. and the indirect effect of skin. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg
6. Ker RF, Alexander RM, Bennett MB. Why are mam- 1982: 16: 61-6.
malian tendons so thick? J Zoo1 1988: 216: 309-24. 26. Vogel HC. Mechanical and chemical properties of various
7. Amiel D, Woo SL-Y, Harwood FL, Akeson WH. The ef- connective tissue organs in rats as influenced by nonster-
fect of immobilization on collagen turnover in connective oidal antirheumatic drugs. Connect Tissue Res 1977: 5: 91-
tissue: a biochemical-biomechanical correlation. Acta Or- 5.
thop Scand 1982: 53: 325-32. 27. Carlstedt CA, Madsen K, Wredmark T. The influence of
8. Noyes FR. Functional properties of knee ligaments and indomethecin on tendon healing. A biomechanical and
alterations induced by immobilization. Clin Orthop 1977: biochemical study. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 1986: 105:
123: 21042. 332-6.
66