Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7
OBJECTIVES
7.1 INTRODUCTION
Exterior lighting design is an important aspect of illumination engineering. Lighting design for
exterior application will have to consider the following aspects of lighting.
Figure 7.1
Street side (SS): The space located on the street side of o MH LRL.
Lonbgitud inal distance (LD): A distance measured between two TRL in a direction parallel to the
cur .
Transvers e distance (TD): A distance measured between two LRL in a direction perpendic ular
to the curb.
Luminaire
Max. CP < 2.5 % Rated Lume ns (Cutoff)
CP < 5 % Rated Lume ns (Semi-Cutoff)
CP = No limit (Non-Cutoff)
0° (Nadir)
MH
r
~
Houseside
+ Street side SS
180°
I
UPHS
I UPSS
I
~
U pward
t 90°
t
Downward
I
I
House side - - - 1- -- Street side
0° <Nad ir}
The le~el of illu~ina~on is the density of luminous flux on the road surcace on the assumption
t~at t~e light flux 1s uniformly distributed. The average level of illumination to be provided is
given m ISS 1944 (part I and II). The luminance-is defined as the luminous flux per unit projected
-- - ---------------------
---- - ~ E ~ X ~ T ~ ER
~ l~O~R~L~IG~H~T~I~NG~_:2~5~9
area in the direct ion ?f the observ_er. u..,umi nance is the produ ct of illum
reflecti~n fa~tor a nd is meas ured m cande la per squar e metre. It w
such a ll?htm g level on ~he road way such that all objects are seen
ination and the road surfac e
ould be too expen sive to provi de
and recognised . Therefore, road
lighting 1s norm~ lly desig n~d such that an object on the road is seen
or silhou ette agam st the bnght road surfac e. by the driver as a dark outlin e
The unifo rmity of illum inatio n is requi red to provi de visua l comfo
rt tc the drive r and to make
the objects on the roadw ay d istinc tly visible. There fore longi tudin
al as well as transv erse unifor mity
is very impor tant. The level of unifo rmity can be expre ssed as the
ratio of m aximu m or minim um
illumi nation to the mean illum ination on the road surfac e. As per
ISS 1944, the ratio of minim um
illumi nation to the mean illum inatio n shall not be less than 0.4. This
is made possib le by choos ing
the right kind of light fixtur e and the optim um spacin g to moun ting
heigh t ratio.
The glare on the road origin ates from the light fixtures. There
are two types of glare. The
disability glare and the d iscom fort glare. Disab ility glare reduc es
the ability to see prope rly while
discom fort glare produ ces a sense of disco mfort witho ut reduc
ing signif icantl y the ability to see.
The amou nt of glare can be minim ised by select ing the right type
of cut off fixtur es and choos ing a
highe r level of moun ting the light fixtures.
Optic al guida nce is requi red firstly to recog nise the borde r line betwe
en the road surfac e and the
foot path (espe cially on curve s) and secon dly to recog nise from
a distan ce, the road inters ection s,
round about etc. This is also requi red to get a clear distin ction betwe
en major roads and secon dary
roads . Proper locati on of the street light poles will provi de excell
ent optica l guida nce.
7.3.3 Class ificat ion of Road s
Road s are classi fied based on the volum e of traffic, speed and
comp ositio n of the traffic. The
Natio nal Electr ic Code classi fies the roads into seven group s. The
listing is giv en in Table 7.1.
Typic al arran geme nt of lamp posts for road lighti ng is show n in
Figur e 7.5. For roads of width
rangi ng from 6 to 9 metre s it is econo mical to arran ge the lamp posts
on side of the road. For roads
of width rangi ng from 9 to 12 metre s, zigza g spaci ng is recom mend
ed to get a more or less unifo rm
distri butio n of light on the road surfac e. For the roads of width
from 12 to 20 metre s, face to face
spaci ng of lamp posts on both sides of the~road becom es neces sary.
For multi lane roads , spaci ng
of the lamp posts on the media n, or on the media n plus the curbs
on both sides may have to be
chose n, depen ding on the numb er of lanes of traffic, plann ed for
the road.
s-
r
9!012111
l_ __ _
2B
,- k= s~ _ =rr= _ n _
12 to 20 m
J_ u- -o := -= n= -u -
2c
zF
Figure 7.5 Details of lam p spa cing for
different classes of roa ds (NE C 2011).
7.3.4 Selection of lig ht sources
Ov er the pas t century, roa d ligh ting sys
tem s hav e gon e thr oug h the complete
commercially available, fro m the inc and ran ~e of_ light ~ourc_es
esc ent thr oug h the flu ore scent to the
charge lamps. The gro win g dem and for hig h mte nsity dis-
ene rgy con ser vat ion has for ced the des
HID sources as the onl y alte rna tive. ign ers to choose the
Use of incandescent lam ps for the roa
d ligh ting is the mo st ine fficien t sol
avo ide d as far as possible. This is bec aus uti on and sho uld be
e the incand esc ent lam ps h ave the low
per wa tt out put ) and shortest life spa n. est efficacy (lumens
sho rt life spa n, ma inte nan ce cos t can be Even tho u gh the ir init ial cos t is ver y low , b ecause of their
hig h.
Fluorescent lam ps hav e bet ter efficacy
and life spa n wh en com par ed to inc
their main dra wb ack s are difficulty in ligh and esc ent lam ps. But
t con trol , rela tive ly lar ge siz e and sen
For externa l use, these ligh t sou rces hav siti ve to tem peratu re.
e to be enc los ed in sealed housing .
Me ~cur~ vap our la~ ps hav ~ been in use
for years pri ma rily bec au se of the ir
But the ir effwacy and ligh t qua lity are not ext rem ely JongJife.
so goo d when comp ared to other H igh
lam ps (HID). '!'hi s ligh t sou rce has alre ady In ten sity Discharge
bee n pha sed out bec au se of the rea son
Me tal Ha lide la mp s _offer goo d col our s m ent ion ed above.
qua lity and effi cac y. Bu t the y h ave
iha n when com pared with Me rcu ry vap rela tive ly low er life
our lam ps and Hig h Pressu re Sod ium
esel _sources are howeve r the bes t choice vap ou r lam ps (HPS).
cq ua imp orta nce . wh en col our ren derin g and ene rgy
con servat ion are of
Hig h Pressu re Sod ium vap our lam ps offe
and have ext rem ely lon g li'fe The · r the ma . . , . .
· 1r 1
for mo st of the exteri or..-a pplica tions. co ou r ren d ·
xim um effi cac y am ong the w hite hgh t, sou rces
·
enng is term ed as gol den white an
d is accep table
R L IGHTI NG
- - - - - _ ExTE 261
RIO
- - - '
re So di um (L PS )-l
Low Pr es su ps h ave the highest effica b ut the .ir bi
.1 co Iour. w I11c. I .1s m on o ch ro m am t· cy, gg est
ct· dvantage is
isa
ts 1 a 1c ye l!o un de r wh i ch all co l tha 11
th w, ou rs othe r ay,
k B
bro wn or1· blac. . eca us
e of this ' c use of LPS
in ter io r ap pl ica tio n is ruled n ye ow loo k gr
for out. However, they
.. d colo ur rend er in .
tm ap p ica tio n "':'here is no w bo d g IS no t of much importance.
A ll roa~ w ay lig ht in g ed
ces Wh
by...M.H, HPS or LPS so ur lo.ur edre c?lo~r rende ring and
po rta nt M H · n
energ y sa vm g are im f IS prhobably· the only
solution If co
· ren en ng 1s notL1 ·
gy sa vi ng an d lo ng ,l1' d to HP S ;portant,
but ener e ar e t e am concern, the choice is limite
. e be in g co ns id e d fm e of th . . h erenor ~-_Power
LE D lig ht ~o ur ce s ar
. or exter na l lig ht in g be ca us e1r m t qu ali ties like
lo w po w e re
,·ery long hfe an d r co ns um pt io n.
7.3.5 D es ig n considerations
in ai re s ca n be d t . method .
The sp ac in g be tw ee n lu
m
m in ed us in g the eq ua tions of average lumen
e er
lu x x area
Total initial lum en L11 _-- = -- --
C U xL LF
Where,
ad in metre
W = W id th of th e ro
= Sf ac in g be tw ee n la
m p poles.
S
r
LLF = Li gh t lo ss facto
ilisation
CU = Coefficient of ut _
lu m en de pr ec iat io n (LLD) an d lamp dirt de pre
o components, lamp
. !he lig ht lo ss fa ct or ha s tw
ci at io n (LDD).
LLF = LL D x LD D
Th er ef or e, xL LF xC U
.
S = sp ac m g be tw ee n po
les =L 11
1ux xW l
e sp ac in g be tw ee n po les is directl y proportiona
ow n, it is ev id en t th at th ge lamp will space the lam
ps
If all pa ra m et er s ar e kn us e of th e hi gh es t wa tta
eoretically speaking, e, uniformity of light an
d glare will
to th e la m p !um.ens. Th as ib le so lu tio n be ca us
ity this is no t a fe
fa rth es t ap ar t. In re al .
a de ci di ng ro le ov er the pe rm issible sp acing ill um inance directly un de r the
lu minaire
ha ve ce ss ar y th at th e
iformity, it is ne tes a luminaire
In or de r to ge t p er fe ct un th e po les . Sa tis fy in g this condition necessita
id w ay be tw ee n downwards.
be th e sa m e as th at m sid ew ay s rather than directly ad . As a
th at em its hi gh er am ou nt of lig ht
pr ov id e pe rfe ct un ifo rmity of light on the ro
impossible to imum is at the
In re al ity it is al m os t rn ea th th e luminai1:e an~ ~e min
n~1ty _1s expressed a~~
cu rs un de ratio
im um lig ht oc
ge ne ra l ru le, th e m ax ce pt ab le ~e gr ee of um for
poles. A m ea su re of ac IES th e ratio of average
to mm1mum
m id po in t be twee n th e els . Ac co rd m g to s
of th e av er ag e to m in im
um illuminance lev
t of th e ap pl ica tio ns . For residential areas, thi
mos
t be g reater tha n 3 for
ill um in an ce sh ou ld no
6.
ra tio ca n be as hi gh .a s
262 ELECTR ICAL SYSTEM S D ES IG N
Design a road way lightin g schem e with the follow ing data.
Width of the road way = 12 m
Illumi nation requir ed = 15 lux
Moun ting heigh t of poles = 9 m
Arm length =2 m
(Assu me that the lamps are placed on one side of the road.)
90 12500
LPS 0.3 0.95 135 21500
180 33000
Soluti on:
Table 7.3 Guidelines for group A and group Broads (NEC 2011)
l"",:t-
• •
22.s.j.__q.s-J- 45
•
',.
•
q.s-l-22.s
l 0
00
l
""
I"-
i_
• • • •
,---------- 180--------__;
Figure 7.6
AxE
Lumen output of each lamp =-----
NxCUxLLF
80 X 180 X 15
= x _ x _ = 22714 lurnens.
16 0 7 0 75
From the given data, 250W HPS lamps with a lumen output of 26000 lumens w ill satisfy the
design requirement.
Case 2:
If Low Power Sodium vapour lamps are considered,
AxE
Lumen output of each lamp
Nx CUxLLF
180 X 80 X 15
= 16 x 0.65 x 0.95 = 21862 lurnens.
From the given data, 135W LPS lamp with an initial lumen output of 21500 lumens will satisfy
the design requirement.