Biological Species Concept

What are the different species concepts?

1. Biological species concept

2. Morphological species concept

3. Phylogenetic species concept

4. Ecological species concept

5. Evolutionary species concept

6. Cohesion species concept

7. Genealogical species concept

What is the morphological species concept?

This concept defines a species based on physical characteristics and morphology.
Under this concept, a species is a group of organisms that look similar and can be
distinguished from other groups by their physical characteristics. This concept is
often used in the study of fossils, but it can be difficult to apply to organisms that
have a lot of variation within a species.

What is the evolutionary species concept?

This concept defines a species as a group of organisms that have evolved to the
point where they are distinct from other groups. This concept is based on the idea of
evolutionary divergence, or the process by which populations of organisms become
distinct from one another over time. This concept is useful for understanding the
evolutionary history of organisms, but it can be difficult to apply to organisms that
are not well-studied or to extinct organisms.

What is the phylogenetic species concept?

This concept defines a species as a group of organisms that share a common
ancestor and have diverged over time to become reproductively isolated from other
groups. This concept is based on the idea of speciation, or the process by which

Biological Species Concept 1

 new species arise. This concept is useful for understanding the evolutionary
relationships between organisms, but it can be difficult to apply to organisms that
are not well-studied or to extinct organisms.

What is the ecological species concept?

This concept defines a species based on their ecological niche and role in the
ecosystem. Under this concept, a species is a group of organisms that occupy a
unique ecological niche and play a unique role in the ecosystem. This concept is
useful for understanding the relationship between organisms and their environment,
but it can be difficult to apply to organisms that have similar ecological niches.

What is the cohesion species concept?

This concept defines a species as a group of organisms that can be distinguished

from other groups by a combination of genetic, morphological, ecological, and
behavioral characteristics. This concept is based on the idea that a species is a
cohesive unit, characterized by a combination of genetic, morphological, ecological,
and behavioral characteristics. This concept is useful for understanding the
evolutionary relationships between organisms, but it can be difficult to apply to
organisms that are not well-studied or to extinct organisms.

What is the genealogical species concept?

The Genealogical Species Concept (GSC) is a species concept that defines a

species as a group of organisms that share a common genealogy. This means that
the members of a species are more closely related to one another than they are to
members of any other species.

The GSC is based on the idea that speciation is a process of lineage branching,
where one lineage splits into two or more descendant lineages, each of which
becomes reproductively isolated from the others. The GSC defines a species as the
smallest group of organisms that share a common ancestor and are reproductively
isolated from other lineages.

The GSC is similar to the Phylogenetic Species Concept (PSC) in that it is based on
evolutionary relationships between organisms, but the GSC is more focused on the
process of lineage branching and the concept of reproductive isolation, while the
PSC focus on the evolutionary divergence.

Biological Species Concept 2

 The GSC is useful for understanding the evolutionary relationships between
organisms, and it is particularly useful for organisms that are not well-studied or for
extinct organisms. It's also useful for organisms that reproduce asexually. However,
as with other species concepts, it can be difficult to apply to organisms that have a
lot of genetic variation within a species, or to organisms that have recently diverged
and are not yet reproductively isolated.

What is the Biological species concept?

The Biological Species Concept (BSC) is a widely accepted species concept that
defines a species as a group of individuals that can interbreed and produce fertile
offspring. This means that members of the same species are capable of mating with
one another and producing viable offspring that are also capable of reproducing.
This concept was first proposed by Ernst Mayr in 1942.

One of the key features of the BSC is that it emphasizes the importance of
reproductive isolation in maintaining the boundaries between different species.
Reproductive isolation refers to the mechanisms that prevent members of different
species from interbreeding and producing viable offspring. These mechanisms can
include physical barriers, such as geographic distance or differences in mating
behavior, as well as genetic incompatibilities that prevent successful fertilization or
result in sterile offspring.

The BSC is widely used in the study of sexually reproducing organisms, such as
animals and plants, and it is the most widely accepted species concept among
biologists. It is widely accepted as it is the most practical way to identify and delimit
species, because it is the easiest to observe.

However, the BSC has some limitations. For example, it is not applicable to
organisms that reproduce asexually, such as bacteria, fungi, and some plants. In
these cases, other species concepts such as the Phylogenetic Species Concept or
the Cohesion Species Concept may be more appropriate.

Another limitation of BSC is that it doesn't work well with fossils or organisms that
don't interbreed in nature. In addition, the BSC does not take into account the
genetic or morphological differences between individuals of the same species that
can lead to speciation, it only considers the potential to interbreed.

Another limitation of BSC is that it doesn't account for hybrid speciation, which is
when two different species interbreed to form a new hybrid species that is

Biological Species Concept 3

 reproductively isolated from its parent species. This is because, while the offspring
of hybrids may be infertile, the hybrid population can still establish itself as a new
reproductively isolated species.
Overall, while the Biological Species Concept is widely accepted and widely used, it
is not without its limitations, and other species concepts may be more appropriate in
certain contexts, or in combination with BSC.

Characteristics of a biological species?

Some of the key characteristics of a biological species include:

1. Reproductive Isolation: Members of a biological species are reproductively

isolated from members of other species, meaning that they cannot interbreed
and produce viable, fertile offspring.

2. Genetic Similarity: Members of a biological species are genetically similar to

one another, and they share a common gene pool.

3. Common Ancestry: Members of a biological species share a common ancestor,

and they have evolved from a single, ancestral population.

4. Ecological Niche: Members of a biological species occupy a specific ecological

niche and they have adaptations that allow them to survive and thrive in that
specific environment.

5. Similar Morphological and/or Behavioral Traits: Members of a biological species

often have similar morphological and/or behavioral traits, which can be used to
identify and distinguish them from members of other species.

6. Evolutionary Lineage: Members of a biological species have an evolutionary

lineage that can be traced back to a common ancestor. This lineage can be
reconstructed through the study of genetics, morphology, and fossils.

7. Variations in Gene Pool: Members of a biological species may have variations

in their gene pool, but these variations are typically limited and do not result in
significant differences in fertility or viability of offspring. In other words, even
though there may be genetic variation within a species, members of the species
can still interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring.

8. Sympatry or allopatry: The distribution of organisms within a species can be

either sympatric (living in the same area) or allopatric (living in different areas).

Biological Species Concept 4

 Sympatry may give rise to reproductive isolation and speciation.

9. Adaptive radiation: A biological species may have variations in morphological,

behavioral and ecological traits that are adaptations to specific environments,
this is known as adaptive radiation.

10. Epigenetic modifications: Epigenetics refers to changes in gene expression or

regulation that do not involve changes to the underlying DNA sequence.
Epigenetic modifications can play a role in the development and adaptation of
organisms within a species.

11. Microbiome : Microorganisms that live in and on an organism, can also play a
role in the development and adaptation of organisms within a species.

12. Inter-individual variations: Some organisms may show variations in their

phenotype, genotype, and/or behavior that can be influenced by environmental
factors, genetic drift, mutation, or epigenetics.

What are the advantages of the Biological species concept?

1. Reproductive isolation: The BSC focuses on reproductive isolation as the key

criterion for defining a species, which is a useful concept because it can be
directly observed and tested, and it is a fundamental characteristic of most
species. Reproductive isolation occurs when members of different species are
unable to interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring. This is a clear and
objective way of distinguishing between different species.

2. Clarity and simplicity: The BSC is clear and simple to understand, which makes
it easy to apply to a wide range of organisms. The concept is based on a single
criterion, reproductive isolation, which is straightforward to observe and test.
This makes it a useful tool for classifying organisms in the field or lab, and for
communicating scientific findings to a wide audience.

3. Universality: The BSC can be applied to all organisms, including plants,

animals, and microorganisms, which makes it a universal concept. This is
important because it allows for comparisons to be made across different groups
of organisms and for a more complete understanding of the diversity of life.

4. Reproductive isolation: The BSC focuses on reproductive isolation as the key

criterion for defining a species, which is a useful concept because it can be
directly observed and tested, and it is a fundamental characteristic of most

Biological Species Concept 5

 species. Reproductive isolation occurs when members of different species are
unable to interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring. This is a clear and
objective way of distinguishing between different species.

5. Clarity and simplicity: The BSC is clear and simple to understand, which makes
it easy to apply to a wide range of organisms. The concept is based on a single
criterion, reproductive isolation, which is straightforward to observe and test.
This makes it a useful tool for classifying organisms in the field or lab, and for
communicating scientific findings to a wide audience.

What are the limitations of the Biological species concept?

1. Asexual organisms: The BSC is based on the idea of reproductive isolation,

which is the inability of members of different species to interbreed and produce
viable, fertile offspring. This concept is not applicable to asexual organisms,
such as bacteria and some protists, which do not reproduce sexually and
therefore do not have the concept of reproductive isolation.

2. Hybridization: The BSC assumes that members of different species do not

interbreed, but in reality, hybridization between different species can occur and
can result in the production of viable, fertile offspring. This can make it difficult
to apply the BSC to certain groups of organisms, such as plants, where
hybridization is common.

3. Cryptic species: The BSC is based on the ability to observe and test the
reproductive isolation of different organisms, but sometimes, organisms that
belong to different species may look very similar and be difficult to distinguish
based on morphological characteristics alone. This can make it difficult to apply
the BSC to certain groups of organisms, such as insects, where cryptic species
are common.

4. Fossil organisms: The BSC is based on the ability to observe and test the
reproductive isolation of different organisms, but it is not possible to observe the
reproductive isolation of extinct organisms. This can make it difficult to apply the
BSC to fossil organisms, which are important for understanding the evolutionary
history of life.

5. Ring species: In some cases, populations of a species that are geographically

separated will interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring with adjacent
populations, but will not interbreed with populations that are more distantly

Biological Species Concept 6

 separated. This can create a "ring" of interbreeding populations that surround a
barrier to interbreeding, making it difficult to identify where one species ends
and another begins.

6. Inconsistency with genealogy: The BSC relies on the presence of reproductive

isolation, which can be difficult to measure, and it can be inconsistent with the
genealogy of populations.

What is speciation?

Speciation is the process by which new species evolve from existing ones. It is the
divergence of one population into two or more reproductively isolated populations,
which can no longer interbreed and produce fertile offspring. This isolation can
occur due to a variety of factors, including geographical isolation, changes in mating
behaviors or habitats, or the evolution of reproductive barriers.
The process of speciation is a gradual one that can take place over many
generations. As populations become reproductively isolated, genetic differences
between them begin to accumulate, leading to the development of distinct physical
and behavioral characteristics. These differences can eventually become so
pronounced that the populations can no longer interbreed, and they become distinct
species.
There are several different modes of speciation, including allopatric speciation,
sympatric speciation, adaptive speciation, peripatric speciation, and hybrid
speciation. Each mode of speciation is characterized by a different set of factors
that lead to the divergence of one population into two or more reproductively
isolated populations.

Explain the different modes of speciation.

1. Allopatric speciation: This occurs when a population becomes geographically

isolated, preventing gene flow between the isolated population and the parent
population. For example, a river may form a physical barrier that separates a
population of animals living on one side of the river from a population of animals
living on the other side. Over time, genetic differences can accumulate between
the isolated population and the parent population due to genetic drift, mutation
and natural selection, leading to the formation of a new species. This process
can happen relatively quickly, especially if the isolated population is small.

Biological Species Concept 7

 2. Sympatric speciation: This occurs when a new species arises within the
geographical range of the parent species. This can happen through
mechanisms such as polyploidy (the duplication of chromosomes within a single
organism), or the evolution of reproductive barriers within the same population.
For example, a mutation in a flower that changes the shape of its pistil (female
reproductive organ) could prevent pollen from one flower from fertilizing the
ovules of another flower, leading to the formation of a new species.

3. Adaptive speciation: This occurs when natural selection favors different traits in
different environments, leading to the formation of two or more reproductively
isolated populations. For example, a population of birds living in a forest may
evolve a different beak shape than a population of birds living in an open field.
Over time, these differences may become so pronounced that the two
populations can no longer interbreed, leading to the formation of two separate
species.

4. Peripatric speciation: This occurs when a small population becomes isolated

from a larger population, leading to genetic drift and rapid evolution of the small
population. This can happen when a small group of individuals becomes
isolated from the main population due to a natural disaster or other event, such
as a volcanic eruption. The small population may then evolve quickly, leading to
the formation of a new species.

5. Hybrid speciation: This occurs when two different species interbreed and
produce a hybrid offspring that is reproductively isolated from both parent
species. Over time, the hybrid population can evolve into a new species. This
process can happen when two closely related species come into contact and
interbreed, or when two species that were previously separated come back into
contact after a period of isolation. The hybrid offspring may be better adapted to
its environment than either of its parent species, leading to the formation of a
new species.

Biological Species Concept 8