9L9GEHJ KKAGFE @9FAKEKAF9FAFL DDA? FL # 9DL@?9L O9Q Gje Gje A 9Degfalgjaf?9Hhda 9lagfk

+JG;=<A9GEHML=J.;A=F;= Y

OOO =DK=NA=J ;GE DG;9L= HJG;=<A9
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
+JG;=<A9GEHML=J.;A=F;= Y
OOO =DK=NA=J ;GE DG;9L= HJG;=<A9
ScienceDirect
Procedia Computer Science 175 (2020) 578–584
$FL=JF9LAGF9D2GJCK@GHGFJLA>A;A9D$FL=DDA?=F;=$FL=JF=LG>/@AF?K$G/
M?MKL '=MN=F =D?AME
$FL=JF9LAGF9D2GJCK@GHGFJLA>A;A9D$FL=DDA?=F;=$FL=JF=LG>/@AF?K$G/
9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL
M?MKL '=MN=F =D?AME #=9DL@?9L=O9Q
>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?9HHDA;9LAGFK
9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q
>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?9HHDA;9LAGFK
(GKL9>9#9FGMF= (=RMA Q9Z9"MQ'QKEGK
'140(0.154'2 %+'/%'"/+6'23+48#33#/0(#3#$-#/%#
(GKL9>9#9FGMF= (=RMA Q9Z9"MQ'QKEGK
#%5-480(4*' %+'/%'3'/ +,62+33-#24+ +&+4*.#/'#3#$-#/%#020%%0
'140(0.154'2 %+'/%'"/+6'23+48#33#/0(#3#$-#/%#
#$"$ #%5-480(4*' %+'/%'3'/ +,62+33-#24+ +&+4*.#/'#3#$-#/%#020%%0
$FL@AK9JLA;D= O=HJ=K=FL<9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?

#$"$
9HHDA;9LAGFK LG AEHJGN= L@= ;GDD=;LAGF 9F< HJG;=KKAF? G> <9L9 AF L@= ;GFL=PL G> E=<A;9D KMJN=ADD9F;= /@=K=
E=;@9FAKEK OADD FGL GFDQ GHLAEAR= L@= <9L9 KLGJ9?= KH9;= J=IMAJ=< :Q L@= ?9L=O9Q :ML 9DKG LG 9;;=D=J9L= L@=
$FL@AK9JLA;D= O=HJ=K=FL<9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?
HJG;=KKAF?G>L@=<9L9>DGO>GJL@=>9KL9F<DGKKD=KKLJ9FK>=JG><9L9GFL@=2.)2AJ=D=KK.=FKGJ)=LOGJC9F<
9HHDA;9LAGFK LG AEHJGN= L@= ;GDD=;LAGF 9F< HJG;=KKAF?
2')2AJ=D=KK'G;9DJ=9)=LOGJCF=LOGJCK G> <9L9 AF L@= ;GFL=PL G> E=<A;9D KMJN=ADD9F;= /@=K=
E=;@9FAKEK OADD
$F 9<<ALAGF 9DD G> FGL GFDQ GHLAEAR=
L@= EG<=JF L@= <9L9 KLGJ9?=
<9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF KH9;= J=IMAJ=<
E=;@9FAKEK HJ=K=FL=<:QAFL@= ?9L=O9Q
L@AK :MLL@=
9JLA;D= 9J= 9DKG LG 9;;=D=J9L=
>GDDGOAF? L@=
!GJ=;9KL
HJG;=KKAF?G>L@=<9L9>DGO>GJL@=>9KL9F<DGKKD=KKLJ9FK>=JG><9L9GFL@=2.)2AJ=D=KK.=FKGJ)=LOGJC9F<
;GEHJ=KKAGF .9EHDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGF .;@=<MDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGF <AKLJA:ML=<;GEHJ=KKAGF 2=9HHDQKGE=>GJE9LKG>
2')2AJ=D=KK'G;9DJ=9)=LOGJCF=LOGJCK
DGKKD=KK<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF9D?GJAL@EKLGL@=K=E=;@9FAKEK'5 '5*9F<RAH LG=KL9:DAK@9;GEH9J9LAN=KLM<Q
$F 9<<ALAGF
:=LO==F 9DD G> L@=MKAF?
E=;@9FAKEK EG<=JF <9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF
E=LJA; E=;@9FAKEK
H9J9E=L=JK /@= HJ=K=FL=<
AEHD=E=FL9LAGF G> AF L@AKE=;@9FAKEK
L@=K= 9JLA;D= 9J= L@=
AF>GDDGOAF?
L@= KE9JL !GJ=;9KL
?9L=O9Q
;GEHJ=KKAGF .9EHDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGF .;@=<MDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGF <AKLJA:ML=<;GEHJ=KKAGF 2=9HHDQKGE=>GJE9LKG>
@A?@DA?@LK9F9<N9F;=<$FL=JF=LG>/@AF?K<9L9HJG;=KKAF?KQKL=E>GJ@=9DL@9F<E=<A;9DKMJN=ADD9F;= :9K=<GF9
DGKKD=KK<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF9D?GJAL@EKLGL@=K=E=;@9FAKEK'5
;GEHJ=@=FKAN=9F<=>>A;A=FLKLM<QG>9<N9F;=<<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFL=;@FAIM=K '5*9F<RAH LG=KL9:DAK@9;GEH9J9LAN=KLM<Q
:=LO==F
E=;@9FAKEK MKAF? E=LJA; H9J9E=L=JK /@= AEHD=E=FL9LAGF G> L@=K= E=;@9FAKEK AF L@= KE9JL ?9L=O9Q
@A?@DA?@LK9F9<N9F;=<$FL=JF=LG>/@AF?K<9L9HJG;=KKAF?KQKL=E>GJ@=9DL@9F<E=<A;9DKMJN=ADD9F;=
:9K=<GF9
;GEHJ=@=FKAN=9F<=>>A;A=FLKLM<QG>9<N9F;=<<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFL=;@FAIM=K

U /@=ML@GJK +M:DAK@=<:Q DK=NA=J 1
© 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. ) )DA;=FK=@LLH ;J=9LAN=;GEEGFK GJ? DA;=FK=K :Q F; F<
/@AKAK9FGH=F9;;=KK9JLA;D=MF<=JL@=4
This J=NA=OMF<=JJ=KHGFKA:ADALQG>L@=GF>=J=F;=+JG?J9E@9AJK
+==J
is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)

Peer-review under responsibility of the Conference Program Chair.
/@AKAK9FGH=F9;;=KK9JLA;D=MF<=JL@=4 ) )DA;=FK=@LLH ;J=9LAN=;GEEGFK GJ? DA;=FK=K :Q F; F<
'8702&3$FL=JF=LG>L@AF?K@=9DL@;9J=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF.E9JL"9L=O9Q<9L9HJG;=KKAF?GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEK.=FKGJKF=LOGJC
+==J J=NA=OMF<=JJ=KHGFKA:ADALQG>L@=GF>=J=F;=+JG?J9E@9AJK
'8702&3$FL=JF=LG>L@AF?K@=9DL@;9J=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF.E9JL"9L=O9Q<9L9HJG;=KKAF?GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEK.=FKGJKF=LOGJC

GJJ=KHGF<AF?9ML@GJ
/=D
.#+-#&&2'33?J9;=E=RMA?E9AD ;GE

U /@=ML@GJK
GJJ=KHGF<AF?9ML@GJ +M:DAK@=<:Q
/=D DK=NA=J 1
/@AKAK9FGH=F9;;=KK9JLA;D=MF<=JL@=4
.#+-#&&2'33?J9;=E=RMA?E9AD ;GE ) )DA;=FK=@LLH ;J=9LAN=;GEEGFK GJ? DA;=FK=K :Q F; F<
/@AKAK9FGH=F9;;=KK9JLA;D=MF<=JL@=4 ) )DA;=FK=@LLH ;J=9LAN=;GEEGFK GJ? DA;=FK=K :Q F; F<
1877-0509 © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.

This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Peer-review under responsibility of the Conference Program Chairs.
10.1016/j.procs.2020.07.083
Mostafa Hanoune et al. / Procedia Computer Science 175 (2020) 578–584 579
'95+8#;#5883.0320%'&+#0.154'2 %+'/%' :
$" %$
=J? $FKA?@L HJ=<A;LK L@9L L@= FME:=J G> H9LA=FLK LJ=9L=< J=EGL=DQ 9L @GE= NA9 ;GFF=;L=< E=<A;9D <=NA;=K OADD
J=9;@ EADDAGFAF 9F9N=J9?=9FFM9D?JGOL@J9L=G> :=LO==F 9F< 67 O@A;@J=HJ=K=FLK9
J=9DA?9L9;@9DD=F?= O@A;@:=;GE=K=KK=FLA9DLGKLGJ=9F<HJG;=KK9DDL@=<9L9OAL@9F=;=KK9JQ@AKLGJA;9D<=HL@
$L AK AF L@AK H=JKH=;LAN= L@9L O= HJ=K=FL AF L@AK 9JLA;D= <9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF E=;@9FAKEK AF 9F AFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@
?9L=O9Q >GJ E=<A;9D EGFALGJAF? 9HHDA;9LAGFK LG GHLAEAR= L@= <9L9 KLGJ9?= KH9;= J=IMAJ=< :Q L@= ?9L=O9Q 9F< LG
KH==< MH L@= HJG;=KKAF? G> <9L9 >DGO >GJ >9KL 9F< DGKKD=KK LJ9FK>=J G> <9L9 GN=J 2.) 9F< 2') F=LOGJCK *MJ
KE9JL?9L=O9Q@9K;GFKLJM;LAN=;GFLJGDGN=J2)2AJ=D=KKG<QJ=9)=LOGJC 2.) 2')9F<GN=J$G/
<9L9HJG;=KKAF? K==!A? 67
!A? $G/.QKL=E
/@=KQKL=E9DDGOKL@=;GDD=;LAGF 9F9DQKAK HJG;=KKAF?G>E9KKAN=9EGMFLKG>@=L=JG?=F=GMK9F<;GFLAFMGMK<9L9

>JGE K=FKGJK AF J=9D LAE= /@AK K=FKALAN= <9L9 ?=F=J9L=< :Q L@= K=FKGJK AK FGL <AJ=;LDQ K=FL LG L@= ;DGM< GJ J=EGL=
K=JN=J >GJJ=9KGFKG>K9LMJ9LAGFG>L@=F=LOGJC:9F<OA<L@9F<AF>GJE9LAGFK=;MJALQ9F<KLGJ9?=KH9;= #GO=N=J L@AK
<9L9AK>AJKL;GEHJ=KK=< HJG;=KK=<9F<L@=FK=FLLGL@=;DGM<GJJ=EGL=K=JN=J
/@=E9AF;GFLJA:MLAGFG>L@AK9JLA;D=AKL@=AEHD=E=FL9LAGFG>=>>A;A=FL<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAFJ=D9LAGF
LGL@=@9J<O9J=H=J>GJE9F;=G>L@=KE9JL?9L=O9Q9F<L@=GHLAEAR9LAGFG>L@=KLGJ9?=KH9;=ALJ=IMAJ=K
/@=J=KLG>L@=9JLA;D=AKGJ?9FAR=<9K>GDDGOK.=;LAGFADDMKLJ9L=KL@=KGMJ;=KG>AFKHAJ9LAGF>GJL@AKOGJC9F<L@=
9D?GJAL@EA;>GJE9LKL@9LO=@9N=L9C=F9KJ=>=J=F;=K.=;LAGF=PHD9AFKL@=<A>>=J=FL<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEK
.=;LAGFJ=HGJLKGFL@=J=KMDLKG:L9AF=<AFGMJ=N9DM9LAGF;9EH9A?F 9F<?AN=K9FGN=JNA=OG>L@=:=KLK=D=;LAGFG>
;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE ;GEH9JAKGFG>H=J>GJE9F;=9F<J=KMDLKGFL@=J=9DK;=F9JAGF<>AF9DDQK=;LAGFO@A;@
;GF;DM<=KL@=<G;ME=FLOAL@KGE=>MLMJ=J=E9JCK
$& "#
!*'3052%'30(+/31+2#4+0/
MJAF? L@AK L@=KAK OGJC O= @9< L@= GHHGJLMFALQ LG L9;CD= K=N=J9D HJGB=;LK J=D9L=< LG GMJ J=K=9J;@ OGJC 2=
HJ=K=FL@=J=KGE=G>L@=K=OGJCK
/@= >AJKL GF= AK >JGE EAJ (G@9EE9< -9@E9FA )9F<9 &ME9J /@9FA?9AN=D9F /M9F )?MQ=F "A9 %GK=
"J9F9<GK =@9ADM)=?9K@ +9KA'ADB=:=J?9F<#9FFM/=F@MF=FAFW.E9JL= #=9DL@"9L=O9QJAF?AF?$FL=DDA?=F;=
LG$FL=JF=L G> /@AF?K9K=<0:AIMALGMK#=9DL@;9J=.QKL=EKX67 /@=Q@9N=K=LMH9KE9JL?9L=O9QMF<=JL@=F9E=
G>0/ "/ LGG>>=JK=N=J9D@A?@=J D=N=DK=JNA;=KKM;@9KDG;9D<9L9KLGJ9?=9F<J=9D LAE=<9L9HJG;=KKAF? *F=G>
L@=LJ=9LE=FLKAKL@=;GEHJ=KKAGFG>L@=<9L9;GDD=;L=<>JGEL@=?9L=O9QFG<=K 9F<L@=FK=F<L@AK<9L9<AJ=;LDQLG
L@=J=EGL=K=JN=J9F<L@=K=;GF<AKLG;GDD=;LL@=<9L9AFL@=>GJEG>FG<=K9F<K9N=L@=;GEHJ=KK=<<9L9AFL@=>AD=K
O@A;@OADD:=K=FLLGL@=J=EGL=K=JN=J
/@=K=;GF<AKL@9LG>.L=>9F&9JDKKGF9F< JAC#9FKKGFAFW'GKKD=KK(=KK9?=GEHJ=KKAGFX L@=QHJ=K=FL9
DAL=J9DKLM<QGFDGKKD=KK<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFMKAF?L@=;GEHAD9LAGFG>L@='5* '5!3 '52 '5( :RAH9F<'5
9D?GJAL@EKAF'$)39K9F9<<ALAGF9DD9Q=JLGKMHHGJLL@=DGKKD=KK;GEHJ=KKAGFE=KK9?= /@=L=KLAFNGDN=<K=F<AF?
580 Mostafa Hanoune et al. / Procedia Computer Science 175 (2020) 578–584
'95+8#;#5883.0320%'&+#0.154'2 %+'/%' :
E=KK9?=KOAL@J=9DL=D=;GE<9L9:=LO==FLOGFG<=KGF9<=<A;9L=<F=LOGJC OAL@<A>>=J=FLF=LOGJC;GF>A?MJ9LAGFK
9F<E=KK9?=KAR=K67
/@= L@AJ< AK L@9L G> @GF? 'MG !=F? 2M %MF .MF 9F< @9F? O=F @=F AF W GEHJ=KKAN= <9L9 ?9L@=JAF? >GJ
D9J?= K;9D=OAJ=D=KKK=FKGJF=LOGJCKX /@=QHJ=K=FLL@=>AJKL;GEHD=L=<=KA?FLG9HHDQ;GEHJ=KKAN=K9EHDAF?L@=GJQ
LG K=FKGJ <9L9 ?9L@=JAF? >GJ D9J?= K;9D= OAJ=D=KK K=FKGJ F=LOGJCK /@=Q ;GFKA<=J=< L@= K;=F9JAG AF O@A;@ 9 D9J?=
FME:=JG>K=FKGJFG<=K9J=<=FK=DQ<=HDGQ=<9F<K=FKGJJ=9<AF?K9J=KH9LA9DDQ;GJJ=D9L=<67
!AF9DDQL@9LG>(-9RR9IM= @JAKD=9CD=Q9F<.AEGFG:KGFAFWGEHJ=KKAGFAFOAJ=D=KKK=FKGJF=LOGJCK
KMJN=Q 9F< ;GEH9J9LAN= =N9DM9LAGF X /@=Q HJ=K=FL 9 J=NA=O G> L@= DAL=J9LMJ= AF L@= >A=D< G> ;GEHJ=KKAGF 9F<
;GEHJ=KKAGF>J9E=OGJCKAFL@=2.) ;GEH9J9LAN=KLM<QG>L@=<A>>=J=FL9HHJG9;@=KO9K9DKGHJGNA<=<67
DDL@=K=OGJCK<A>>=JAF9>=OHGAFLK:ML9DD;GFN=J?=GF9KAF?D=G:B=;LAN= LGK=LMH9?GG<<9L9>DGOHJG;=KKAF?
KQKL=E
112012+#4'&#-)02+4*.3
$F L@AK K=;LAGF O= <=K;JA:= L@= 9D?GJAL@EK L@9L O=J= MK=< O@=F =N9DM9LAF? GMJ <9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF E=;@9FAKEK
/@=K=9J=L@=9D?GJAL@EKL@9LO=J=EGKLG>L=FMK=<AFJ=D9L=<OGJC

• $LAK9F9D?GJAL@E<=N=DGH=<:Q( *:=J@ME=J O@A;@AK<=KA?F=<>GJ>9KL;GEHJ=KKAGF9F<<=;GEHJ=KKAGF
$L MK=K '5 OAL@ 9 KE9DD @9K@ L9:D= LG H=J>GJE K=9J;@=K GEHJ=KKAGF J=IMAJ=K & G> E=EGJQ <MJAF?
<=;GEHJ=KKAGFJ=IMAJ=KFG9<<ALAGF9DE=EGJQ67
• (! $L AK 9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF HJG?J9E :9K=< GF L@= MJJGOK 2@==D=J 9D?GJAL@E $L ?=F=J9DDQ ;GEHJ=KK=K >AD=K
:=LO==F 9F< O@AD=:=AF?9:GMLLOA;=9K>9KLAF;GEHJ=KKAGF9F<KAPLAE=K>9KL=JAF<=;GEHJ=KKAGF $L
;GEHJ=KK=K>AD=KMKAF?>GJO9J<<AKHD9;=E=FLLJ9FK>GJE9LAGF D=F?L@=F;G<AF?9F<#M>>E9F=F;G<AF?67
• 9 N=JQ >9KL ;GEHJ=KKAGF 9D?GJAL@E :9K=< GF '5 9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF OAL@ '5 AK N=JQ >9KL :ML <9L9
<=;GEHJ=KKAGFAK=N=F>9KL=J9F<;9FJ=9;@KH==<KG>MHLG" K =KH=;A9DDQ>GJ:AF9JQ<9L967
!"## ##$#"$$&'
9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKLJ9FKD9L=AFLGL=;@FAIM=K>GJJ=<M;AF?L@=<9L9LG:=HJG;=KK=<AFL@=AFL=DDA?=FL
?9L=O9Q /@=Q9AELGJ=<M;=L@=9EGMFLG><9L9LG;GEHJ=KK9F<LJ9FKEALLGL@=J=EGL=K=JN=J /@=K=L=;@FAIM=K
;9F:=;D9KKA>A=<AFLGL@J==;9L=?GJA=K!GJ=;9KL;GEHJ=KKAGF .9EHDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGF9F<.;@=<MDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGF
#GO=N=J KGE= AG KA?F9D E=9KMJ=< :Q :AG 9EHDA>A=J <G FGL ;@9F?= :=LO==F LOG K9EHD=K L@AK AK L@= ;9K= G> 9F
=D=;LJG;9J<AG?J9E "9F<=D=;LJGEQG?J9E ("
02'%#34%0.12'33+0/
>GJ=;9KLAF? EG<=D AK =KL9:DAK@=< <MJAF? L@= ?AN=F >DGO K9EHD=K KG L@9L >MLMJ= N9DM=K ;9F := HJ=<A;L=< OAL@
KGE=HJ=;AKAGF /@AK9HHJG9;@=PHDGALKL@=EG<=DG:L9AF=<LGJ=<M;=L@=FME:=JG><9L99;IMAJ=<>GJ;GEHJ=KKAGF
9F<L@=9EGMFLG><9L9LG:=;GEHJ=KK=< K==!A?

!A? !GJ=;9KL;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE
'95+8#;#5883.0320%'&+#0.154'2 %+'/%' :
!A?MJ=K@GOKL@9L=9;@<9L9FG<=AK;@9J9;L=JAR=<:Q9>GJ=;9KL<9L9EG<=D9F<E9F9?=<:Q9EG<=DE9F9?=J
9;;GJ<AF?LGL@=E=9KMJ=E=FLH9J9E=L=JK
0.12'33+0/$83#.1-+/)
$L AK :9K=< GF HJ=;GF;=AN=< <9L9 ;GDD=;LAGF ;JAL=JA9 LQH=K G> <9L9 ;GDD=;LAGF LAE= 9F< KAR= G> L@= <9L9 LG :=
;GDD=;L=< K9EHD=EG<=DAK=KL9:DAK@=<<MJAF?L@=>AJKL<9L9;GDD=;LAGFK KGL@9L>MLMJ=N9DM=K;9F:=9;;MJ9L=DQ
HJ=<A;L=< /@AK 9HHJG9;@ J=<M;=K L@= FME:=J G> <9L9 K9EHD=K 9F< L@= 9EGMFL G> <9L9 LG := ;GEHJ=KK=< >GJ =9;@
K9EHD= .==!A?

!A? GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE:QK9EHDAF?

2=;9FG:K=JN=AF!A?MJ=L@=MK=G>L@=LOGK9EHDAF?E=L@G<K/@=>AJKLAK9>AP=<HJGHGJLAGFG><9L9 O@A;@
J=LMJFK9H=J;=FL9?=G>L@=K=LG>K=D=;L=<<9L9 G>9DD<9L9 F<L@=K=;GF<9>AP=<K9EHD=KAR=O@A;@J=LMJFK9
K=D=;L=< FME:=J G> <9L9 AFKL9F;=K AFKL9F;=K >GJ KAEHDA;ALQ 9F< LAE= ;GFKLJ9AFL ;GEH9J=< LG L@= $
KL9F<9J<GFL@=E9PAEMED9L=F;QG>E=<A;9D<=NA;=KO@A;@EMKL:=DGO=J9L EK6 7
0.12'33+0/$83%*'&5-+/)
$L ;GFKAKLK >AJKL AF J=EGNAF? L@= J=<MF<9FL AF>GJE9LAGF >JGE L@= K=FKGJK 9F< E=J?AF? L@= J=E9AFAF? <9L9
.=;GF<DQ K=F<9KAF?D=<9L9KLJ=9ELG:=;GEHJ=KK=<>GJ9?JGMHG>K=FKGJKAFKL=9<G>=9;@K=FKGJK=F<AF?ALK<9L9
AF<ANA<M9DDQ /@MK L@=FME:=JG>H9;C=LKK=FLAKJ=<M;=<>GJ;GEHJ=KKAGF $FK;@=<MDAF?;G<AF? FG<=KK=F<L@=AJ
H9;C=LKLG9KAF?D=FG<=;9DD=<GEHJ=KKAGFFG<= /@=H9;C=LLG:=;GEHJ=KK=<AK;GFKLJM;L=<>JGE;GE:AF9LAGFKG>
H9;C=LKJ=;=AN=<>JGEK=N=J9DFG<=K .==!A?

!A? GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE:QK;@=<MDAF?

$F9<<ALAGF =9;@FG<=AK;GFLJGDD=<:Q9;GFLJGDDAF?9?=FL O@A;@9DGF=CFGOKL@=KAR=G>L@=H9;C=L /@=K=FG<=K
L@=F;GEEMFA;9L=L@=AJD=F?L@LG9HJGLG;GD O@A;@EMKLK;@=<MD=L@=ELGEAFAEAR=L@=HJG;=KKAF?LAE=
'95+8#;#5883.0320%'&+#0.154'2 %+'/%' :
#%$#
/@AK K=;LAGF >G;MK=K GF L@= =N9DM9LAGF 9F< ;GEH9JAKGF G> L@= <A>>=J=FL <9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF E=;@9FAKEK K==F AF
K=;LAGF /@=;GEH9JAKGFG>L@=E=;@9FAKEKOADD:=:9K=<GFL@=<A>>=J=FLE=LJA;KG>L@=;GEHJ=KKAGF9D?GJAL@EK
KLM<A=< AF K=;LAGF /@= K=;LAGF OADD := <ANA<=< AFLG L@J== H9JLK L@= >AJKL OADD HJGNA<= L@= <=>AFALAGF G> E=LJA;
=N9DM9LAGFH9J9E=L=JK 9KO=DD9KKGE=9<<ALAGF9D;GF;=HLK>GJ=N9DM9LAGFL@=K=;GF<OADDHJ=K=FLL@=H=J>GJE9F;=
J=KMDLK L9:D=K >GJ =9;@ E=;@9FAKE 9;;GJ<AF? LG E=LJA; H9J9E=L=JK 9F< 9L L@= =F< L@= L@AJ< O= OADD E9C= 9
;GEH9J9LAN=<=<M;LAGFJ=D9LAF?LGL@=J=KMDLKG>L@=L9:D=K
-=?9J<AF? L@= <9L9 K=LK MK=< LG L=KL L@= H=J>GJE9F;= G> GMJ ;GEHJ=KKAGF E=;@9FAKEK O= ;GFKA<=J=< LOG <9L9
K=LK L@=>AJKLG>O@A;@O9KG:L9AF=<>JGE9<9L9?=F=J9LGJ9F<L@=K=;GF<>JGE9:AGE=<A;9D@=9JLJ9L=K=FKGJ
'(+/+4+0/0(.'42+%'6#-5#4+0/1#2#.'4'23
/@=E=LJA;KO=;GFKA<=JAFL@AK9JLA;D= LG9KK=KKL@=H=J>GJE9F;=G>GMJE=;@9FAKEKMKAF?DGKKD=KK;GEHJ=KKAGF
9D?GJAL@EK9J=9K>GDDGOKH=J;=FL9?=;GEHJ=KKAGFJ9LAG ;GEHJ=KKAGFLAE=9F<H=J;=FL9?=;GEHJ=KKAGF?9AF KC
, ;GEHJ=KKAGF IMGLA=FL / H=J;=FL9?= ;GEHJ=KKAGF J9LAG " H=J;=FL9?= ;GEHJ=KKAGF ?9AF 2= OADD L@=J=>GJ=
@9N=L@=>GDDGOAF?J=D9LAGFK@AHK6 7

/

ALAKL@=LAE=L9C=FLG;GEHJ=KKL@=<9L9AKN=JQAEHGJL9FL =;9MK=A>L@=LAE=>GJJ=;=ANAF?<9L9
>JGEL@=J=EGL=K=JN=JAKD=KKL@9F EK6 7 L@=FL@AKAEHDA=KL@9L L@=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF9D?GJAL@EAK9;;=HL9:D=
>GJL@=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE
2'3'/4#4+0/0('6#-5#4+0/4#$-'3
$FL@AKH9JL O=HJ=K=FLL9:D=KKMEE9JARAF?L@=J=KMDLKG:L9AF=<<MJAF?L@=9HHDA;9LAGF9F<L=KLK 2=MK=<L@J==

DGKKD=KK;GEHJ=KKAGF9D?GJAL@EK'5 '5* 9F<RAHLG=N9DM9L=L@=E=;@9FAKEK9F<L@J==<9L9K=LK " LPL
G<Q8L=EH LPL9F<DGG<HJ=KK /@=>AJKLLOG9J=>JGE9<9L9?=F=J9LGJKAEMD9LAF?L@=DGG<+J=KKMJ=9F<G<Q
/=EH=J9LMJ=K=FKGJK 9F<L@=K=;GF<AKG:L9AF=<>JGE9J=9D LAE=#=9JL-9L=K=FKGJ

/9:D= !GJ=;9KL;GEHJ=KKAGF

GEHJ=KKAGF GEHJ=KKAGF !AD=.AR= GEHJ=KK=< GEHJ=KKAGF GEHJ=KKAGF +JG;=KKAF?
>GJE9LK FG<=K :QL=K !AD=KAR=:QL=K -9LAG ?9AF /AE=EK
" LPL

'5* G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
" LPL
'5 G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
" LPL
RAH G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL

'95+8#;#5883.0320%'&+#0.154'2 %+'/%' :

/9:D= GEHJ=KKAGF:QK9EHDAF?

" LPL

'5* G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
" LPL
'5 G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
" LPL
RAH G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL

/9:D= GEHJ=KKAGF:QK;@=<MDAF?

" LPL

'5* G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
" LPL
'5 G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
" LPL
RAH G<Q8/=EH LPL
DGG<8+J=KK LPL
0.1#2#4+6'#/#-83+3
$FL@AKH9JL O==KL9:DAK@;GEH9JAKGFK:=LO==FL@=<A>>=J=FL<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAFGJ<=JLG@A?@DA?@L
L@=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF>GJE9LK:=KLKMAL=<LG=9;@E=;@9FAKE
/@=J=KMDLKG>L@=L9:D=KK@GOMKL@9LL@=;GEHJ=KKAGFJ9L=AK9;;=HL9:D=>GJ9DD<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEK
:=;9MK=L@=;GEHJ=KKAGF>9;LGJ?9AFAF;GEHJ=KKAGFAK?J=9L=JL@9F 67 #GO=N=J GMJ;GEH9J9LAN=9F9DQR=K
OADD:=:9K=<GFL@=HJG;=KKAF?LAE= L@=E9PAEMEN9DM=G>O@A;@AK>AP=<9LEK

2=;9FK9Q9L>AJKLL@9LL@=RAH;GEHJ=KKAGF>GJE9LAK:=LL=JKMAL=<LGL@=HJ=<A;LAN=;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE
=;9MK=AL@9KGF9N=J9?=9K9LAK>9;LGJQ;GEHJ=KKAGFJ9L=G> 9F<9>9NGJ9:D=E9PAEMEHJG;=KKAF?LAE=G>
EK O@A;@ AK D=KK L@9F EK 0FDAC= L@= ;GEHJ=KKAGF E=;@9FAKEK :Q K9EHDAF? 9F< K;@=<MDAF? O@A;@ @9N= 9F
9N=J9?= ;GEHJ=KKAGF J9LAG G> 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ :GN= 9DD E9PAEME HJG;=KKAF? LAE=K G> EK 9F<
EK O@A;@9J=?J=9L=JL@9FEK
'95+8#;#5883.0320%'&+#0.154'2 %+'/%' :

.=;GF<DQ L@='5*9F<'5;GEHJ=KKAGF>GJE9LK9J=:=KLKMAL=<>GJL@=;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEK:QK9EHDAF?
=;9MK=L@=AJ9N=J9?=;GEHJ=KKAGFJ9L=K9J=9;;=HL9:D=O@A;@9J=9JGMF< 9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ9F<L@=AJ
E9PAEME HJG;=KKAF? LAE=K J=E9AF K9LAK>9;LGJQ EK 9F< EK EK /@AK AK FGL L@= ;9K= >GJ RAH OAL@ 9
;GEHJ=KKAGFJ9L=G> 9F<E9PAEMEHJG;=KKAF?LAE=G>EK?J=9L=JL@9FEK

!AF9DDQ L@='5*;GEHJ=KKAGF>GJE9LAK:=LL=JKMAL=<LGL@=K;@=<MDAF?;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKE =;9MK=AL@9K
GF9N=J9?=9K9LAK>9;LGJQ;GEHJ=KKAGFJ9L=G> 9F<9>9NGJ9:D=E9PAEMEHJG;=KKAF?LAE=G>EK O@A;@AK
D=KK L@9F EK 0FDAC= L@= '5 9F< RAH ;GEHJ=KKAGF >GJE9LK O@A;@ @9N= 9F 9N=J9?= ;GEHJ=KKAGF J9LAG G>
9F< J=KH=;LAN=DQ :GN=9DD E9PAEMEHJG;=KKAF?LAE=KG>EK9F<EK O@A;@9J=?J=9L=JL@9F
EK
%#
0DLAE9L=DQ L@=AEHD=E=FL9LAGFG><9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9D

EGFALGJAF?9HHDA;9LAGFKAK9E9BGJ9<N9FL9?=>GJHJG;=KKAF?<9L9AFJ=9DLAE= /@=E9AFA<=9L@9LO9KL@=KM:B=;LG>
GMJ KLM<Q O9K LG @A?@DA?@L 9 K=L G> <9L9 ;GEHJ=KKAGF L=;@FAIM=K LG GHLAEAR= L@= KLGJ9?= KH9;= J=IMAJ=< :Q L@=
?9L=O9Q 9F< LG KH==< MH <9L9 HJG;=KKAF? AF J=9D LAE= ;GEAF? >JGE L@= K=FKGJK /@= ;GEH9J9LAN= KLM<Q G> L@=
;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKK==FAFK=;LAGFE9<=ALHGKKA:D=FGLGFDQLG@A?@DA?@LL@=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF>GJE9LK:=KL
KMAL=<LG=9;@E=;@9FAKE :ML9DKGLGGHLAEAR=L@=<9L9HJG;=KKAF?LAE= *MJ>MLMJ=J=K=9J;@OADD>G;MKGFL@=MK=G>
L@=K=<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKLG<=N=DGHL@=<9L9;D9KKA>A;9LAGFKQKL=EAFL@=;GFKLJ9AF=<H9JLG>L@=2')
F=LOGJC AFGJ<=JLGGHLAEAR=;GEEMFA;9LAGF:=LO==FGMJ?9L=O9Q9F<L@=J=EGL=K=JN=J
"#
67 *J9F?= :MKAF=KK #=9DL@ ;GFF=;L=< 9HHDA;9LAGFK 9F< G:B=;LK !=:JM9JQ DAF9R (#14 #=9DL@ @LLHK OOO GJ9F?=
:MKAF=KK ;GE >J :DG?K 9HHDA;9LAGFK =L G:B=LK ;GFF=;L=K =F K9FL=
67 . 0- ) .! /4 # '/# - (*)$/*-$)" . *) $*/ ..-" $FL=JF9LAGF9D %GMJF9D G> GEHML=J .;A=F;= 9F<
F?AF==JAF?..-" $%. .H=;A9D$KKM=$-/- /(9J
67 GF>=J=F;= L@ FFM9D $ GFKME=J GEEMFA;9LAGFK 9F< )=LOGJCAF? GF>=J=F;= ) L 0. 1GDME= %MDQ
OAL@ -=9<K *$ )
67 (G<=JF'GKKD=KKGEHJ=KKAGF/=;@FAIM=K-=NA=O GEH9JAKGF9F<F9DQKAK GF>=J=F;=+9H=J[!=:JM9JQ *$ $ /

67GEHJ=KKAN=<9L9?9L@=JAF?>GJD9J?= K;9D=OAJ=D=KKK=FKGJF=LOGJCK (G:AGE +JG;==<AF?KG>L@=L@9FFM9DAFL=JF9LAGF9D;GF>=J=F;=
GF(G:AD=;GEHMLAF?9F<F=LOGJCAF?.=HL=E:=J +9?=KY @LLHK <GA GJ?
67(%GMJF9DK (/J9FK9;LAGFKGF.=FKGJ)=LOGJCK 1GD )G GEHJ=KKAGFAFOAJ=D=KKK=FKGJF=LOGJCKKMJN=Q9F<;GEH9J9LAN=
=N9DM9LAGF =;=E:=J JLA;D=)G @LLHK <GA GJ?
67(9JCMK*:=J@ME=J '5*9L9GEHJ=KKAGF'A:J9JQ@LLH OOO G:=J@ME=J ;GE GH=FKGMJ;= DRG
67%MDA9F.=O9J< HJG?J9E9F<DA:J9JQ>GJ<9L9;GEHJ=KKAGF @LLH OOO :RAH GJ?
679L9GEHJ=KKAGF=NA;=:9K=<GF(G<A>A=<'5D?GJAL@E$ /J9FK9;LAGFKGFGFKME=J D=;LJGFA;K
@LLHK <GA GJ? /
6 7$ .L9F<9J<>GJ(=<A;9D=NA;=GEEMFA;9LAGF *N=JNA=O9F<!J9E=OGJC $F$.* $ GEEALL==
67$<9(=F?QA+MMLL=JOGJL@ #=AF=E9FF H9?=KAF!MF<9E=FL9D9L9GEHJ=KKAGF
67)GLAGFKMJD9;GEHJ=KKAGF<=K<GFF=K<9FKD=K9HHDA;9LAGFKEMDLAET<A9K"TJ9J<+MAE9LLG;=FLJ=F9LAGF9D=<=<G;ME=FL9LAGFHT<9?G?AIM=
@LLHK OOO >AD MFAN DADD= >J SO=?JRQFG HGJL9AD G<9?= G; AN=JK )+ ;GEHJ=KK H<>
67 'GKKD=KK GEHJ=KKAGF /=;@FAIM= >GJ -=9D /AE= +@GLGHD=L@QKEG?J9H@A; (=9KMJ=E=FLK $F $ /J9FK9;LAGFK GF $FKLJME=FL9LAGF 9F<
(=9KMJ=E=FL [*;LG:=J OAL@ -=9<K *$ /$(

9L9GEHJ KKAGFE @9FAKEKAF9FAFL DDA? FL # 9DL@?9L O9Q Gje Gje A 9Degfalgjaf?9Hhda 9lagfk

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

9L9GEHJ KKAGFE @9FAKEKAF9FAFL DDA? FL # 9DL@?9L O9Q Gje Gje A 9Degfalgjaf?9Hhda 9lagfk

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

$FL@AK9JLA;D= O=HJ=K=FL<9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?

1877-0509 © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.

$" %$

/@=KQKL=E9DDGOKL@=;GDD=;LAGF 9F9DQKAK HJG;=KKAF?G>E9KKAN=9EGMFLKG>@=L=JG?=F=GMK9F<;GFLAFMGMK<9L9

!"## ##$#"$$&'

$FL@AKH9JL O=HJ=K=FLL9:D=KKMEE9JARAF?L@=J=KMDLKG:L9AF=<<MJAF?L@=9HHDA;9LAGF9F<L=KLK 2=MK=<L@J==

" LPL

" LPL

DGG<8+J=KK LPL

" LPL

0DLAE9L=DQ L@=AEHD=E=FL9LAGFG><9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9D

You might also like

9L9GEHJ KKAGFE @9FAKEKAF9FAFL DDA? FL # 9DL@?9L O9Q Gje Gje A 9Degfalgjaf?9Hhda 9lagfk

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

9L9GEHJ KKAGFE @9FAKEKAF9FAFL DDA? FL # 9DL@?9L O9Q Gje Gje A 9Degfalgjaf?9Hhda 9lagfk

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

   

   

$FL@AK9JLA;D= O=HJ=K=FL<9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?

1877-0509 © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.

$" %$ 

/@=KQKL=E9DDGOKL@=;GDD=;LAGF 9F9DQKAK HJG;=KKAF?G>E9KKAN=9EGMFLKG>@=L=JG?=F=GMK9F<;GFLAFMGMK<9L9

 !"## ##$#"$$&'

$FL@AKH9JL O=HJ=K=FLL9:D=KKMEE9JARAF?L@=J=KMDLKG:L9AF=<<MJAF?L@=9HHDA;9LAGF9F<L=KLK 2=MK=<L@J==

     

" LPL       

" LPL       

DGG<8+J=KK LPL       

" LPL       

0DLAE9L=DQ L@=AEHD=E=FL9LAGFG><9L9;GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9D

You might also like

$FL@AK9JLA;D= O=HJ=K=FL<9L9GEHJ=KKAGFE=;@9FAKEKAF9FAFL=DDA?=FL #=9DL@?9L=O9Q>GJE=<A;9DEGFALGJAF?

$" %$

!"## ##$#"$$&'

" LPL

" LPL

DGG<8+J=KK LPL

" LPL