Professional Documents
Culture Documents
India needs
modern power quality
monitoring systems
October - December 2019
heavy rains.
It is quality, rather than quantity, that drives a nation's
economy as quality adds to efficiency, productivity This should change if India aspires to compete
and safety. In India, however, very often this is not the globally, particularly in industrial manufacturing
case. Most businesses are focused on the low-cost- and education fields. The new business paradigm
large-quantity model. The low-cost-low-quality and for Digital India should be Quality-driven so that
large-quantity approach has not only resulted in poor efficiency and productivity can be scaled up to
quality of power supply adding to the bad quality of contribute to the growth of the economy and the
infrastructure in cities causing traffic congestion, employability of our youth. This is very similar to
the 'Smell of Place' as articulated by the late Prof. consistently across sectors for more than a decade.
India needs modern power quality monitoring systems
Bharat' and 'Swachh Air' for creating Clean Cities. and IT services, malls, institutions and even residential
Clean Power is essential for both Clean Air & Clean customers had to use UPS or diesel power generators
Cities and is possible to deliver in India as some to address this problem. But these are only temporary
Asian countries have done for long time not just in solutions and are not sustainable in the long term
developed countries. India is way behind in especially for future Digital India and Smart Cities.
implementing international power quality standards There is no improvement in quality of life if power
quality remains poor and inadequate.
Table 1: Power supply quality index [2, 3]
In addition, customers are responsible for harmonics It is observed from Table 5 that majority of the PQ
and utilities are responsible for PQ disturbances disturbances are voltage sag as the measurement
shown in Figure 1. According to 'Swachh Power was done on transmission network at 765 kV, 400 kV
Report 2015', Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. and 220 kV. Though monitoring on LV distribution
installed 500 PQ monitors in 175 cities across the highlighted THD within limits but exceeds for a very
34 country at various substations between April 2014 and short period. The PGCIL study highlights that
a quarterly magazine of the society of energy engineers and managers / India
May 2015 as shown in Figure 2 [6]. The results as harmonics are the major issue in western, southern
shown in Table 4 contain two parts (a) short and eastern regions but sag and voltage unbalance
disturbances in grey color and (b) continuous are the issues in northern and north-eastern regions.
distortion as harmonics/unbalance/DC offset.
Figure 2. Power quality monitoring sites in India [5] w Provide access to PQ monitoring data on the
website similar to Electrotek PQ monitoring site.
1 Voltage Sag 12 29 13 12 7 73
2 Voltage Swell 0 4 1 4 2 11
3 Interruptions 0 0 2 3 3 8
4 Unbalance 13 27 9 16 14 79
5 Voltage Harmonics 0 17 12 18 18 65
6 Current Harmonics 0 11 11 10 6 38
7 DC Offset 0 4 1 2 3 10
Table 5: PQ Issues across India [5] w Benchmark electricity power supply quality across
the states and reward best DISCOMs.
Sl. No Region Name Power Quality Issue
w Benchmark electricity power supply quality with
1 Western Harmonics different countries.
2 Southern Harmonics w Conduct power quality research and participate in
3 Eastern Harmonics & Sag the development of Supraharmonics standards.
4 Northern Sag & Voltage Unbalance w Apply IoT and Machine Learning to develop PQ &
CM state-of-the-art solutions for Smart Grid.
5 North Eastern Sag & Voltage Unbalance
w Contribute to the development of Indian Smart 35
Grid and Smart Cities mission and standards.
by consumers and take necessary steps to reduce LabVIEW-based real-time and remote power quality
the downtime. It also helps in monitoring energy monitoring and analysis system (Figure 3, 4 and 5) is
consumption and improving energy efficiency through useful in energy monitoring and management as well
energy audit and implementing best practices. With as condition monitoring of electrical equipment. With
advancement in IoT and Machine Learning, it is recent advancements in Deep Learning and Machine
possible to integrate power quality, energy and Learning, it is possible to develop advanced
condition monitoring effectively to develop diagnostic diagnostic tools for electrical substation equipment.
36
a quarterly magazine of the society of energy engineers and managers / India
37
(b)
October - December 2019
(c)
(d)
Figure 7. (a) Power quality disturbances waveforms (b) magnitude w.r.t. time (c) time-frequency (d) time-frequency-magnitude plot
Moreover, they are responsible for failure of issues due to EV charging and smart appliances (e)
India needs modern power quality monitoring systems
capacitors and other electronic components in home Demand response implementation using smart meter
appliances connected to LV distribution. (f) Smart home energy management and (g)
Transactive energy control under dynamic pricing.
An interesting pattern recognition tool for detection
Smart Microgrids are helpful in improving power
and classification of power system transients was
supply reliability, quality and sustainability in Smart
developed by Tan Sih Sin et al. (Figure 7 & 8). The
Communities and Smart Cities as emergency backup
tool was effective in detection and classification of
power supply during natural disasters with the help of
various PQ disturbances, including (a) capacitor
Renewable Energy and Storage. In addition, it is
switching (b) back-to-back capacitor switching (c)
useful for conducting IoT, Machine Learning, Block
lightning and (d) motor switching transients. The tool
Chain and Deep Learning for Smart Grid research.
can also perform very well under noisy conditions
(Table 7). It can also plot the PQ disturbances on
CBEMA curve which will help in assessing the power
Cost of power quality
supply quality at a given site or customer location. In
the future, this tool will be extended for the study of Power quality problems are very complicated and
"Supraharmonics" in Smart Microgrid. involve facility wiring, lightning phenomena and
equipment interaction, grounding and power grid.
Table 6: Supraharmonics Emission [6] Industrial, commercial and medical equipment are
designed to operate safely with good power supply.
Sl.No Equipment Frequency But that is often not the case as sometimes
1 Industrial converters 9 kHz - 150 Hz neighborhood customer equipment may cause
interference resulting in equipment failures. Though
2 Street lamps 2 kHz - 20kHz
power quality standards exist, its enforcement in
3 EV chargers 15 kHz - 150 kHz many countries is slow, especially in India.
4 PV inverters 4 kHz - 20 kHz It is very important to look at the recent power quality
38
disturbance and their consequences on industrial and
5 Household appliances 2 kHz - 150 kHz
a quarterly magazine of the society of energy engineers and managers / India
Noisy Sine - 48 1 1 - - - 96
C1(a) - - 45 - - - 5 90
C1(b) - - - 47 - - 3 94
C2 - - - - 50 - - 100
October - December 2019
C3 - - - - - 50 - 100
C4 - - 1 1 - - 48 96
private hosted cloud, the customers and other Jackson Atlanta International Airport cost Delta
infrastructure services as well [14]. Airlines almost $50 Million in Pre-Tax revenue as per
the Airlines [21].
In November 2015, Telecity faced two outages on its
London data centre. Telecity's Sovereign House
suffered a power outage in all four floors and failure PQ cost estimation
to repair the UPS resulted in another outage and the
site was left with no primary or secondary backup In this article, we attempt to suggest a few methods
power [15]. of estimating the cost of power quality from the
perspectives of different consumers. Current PQ cost
In September 2016, a power outage at Europe's estimate is only based on utilities. The cost of PQ
largest data center, Global Switch 2, lasted 222 varies for (a) utilities (b) commercial (c) industrial (d)
milliseconds. The interruption was due to a fault in the critical and (e) residential consumers.
HV cable end-box of the output circuit breaker system
[17].
Verizon data centre. Reports suggest that maintaining w Cost of service delays = Cb
a failover site for customer services could have
w Cost of repair and restoration = Cc
prevented the flight delays and cancellations [16].
w Cost of PQ audit and solution = Cd
In May 2017, power outage in British Airways' UK
data centre resulted in around 672 flight w Cost of business loss = Ce
cancellations, and it cost £58 Million ($ 75 Million) to
Total PQD Cost, CPQ$ = Ca + Cb + Cc + Cd + Ce
the airline. This outage was triggered by a power
surge which caused infrastructural damage and also
led to failure of the IT systems. The airline's backup Critical Customer
system had also failed. Such outages are due to the
power interruptions which not only hinder the Cost of kWh/kVA generated by UPS &DG = Ca
consistent working of the electrical equipment at the Cost of service interruption = Cb
centers, but also damage them over time leading to
production loss. Thus, there is a need to monitor the Cost of repair and restoration = Cc
power quality supply and eliminate unscheduled Cost of PQ audit and solution = Cd
downtimes.
Cost of insurance = Ce
October - December 2019
Cost of business reputation = Cf Thus,
From the data obtained from the industry, the cost of Cost of service or product damage, Y = E x F
power quality disturbance can be computed in the
Cost of restarting, W = G x H x (C+D) + (I + F)
following ways:
Soft costs, Z = J x K
w Money invested in the backup systems to avoid Cost of ICT service interruption = Rb
the disturbances due to the voltage fluctuation.
Cost of equipment damage = Rc
w Cost of labour including the costs to redo the lost
Cost of business loss and service delays = Rd
data records and the clean-up operations that
decrease productivity. Total PQD Cost, RPQ$ = Ra + Rb + Rc + Rd
w Soft or hidden costs such as loss of sales, This article aimed to highlight the importance of
premature equipment failure (due to the harmonic power quality to India, particularly against the
distortions and phase unbalance) and poor backdrop of the 'Digital India' and 'Make in India'
initiatives of the government and in the context of the
41
reputation and delivery.
F= cost per unit of service lost or product repaired Nanotechnologies but also in power system
due to power disruption infrastructure, especially in power quality
enhancement at the distribution level.
G= the restart time (in hours)
failure/95255.fullarticle
[4] Hartmut Kiank, Wolfgang Fruth, Planning Guide for Power
Distribution Plants - Design, Implementation and Operation of [16] http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/content-tracks/security-
Industrial Networks, SIEMENS, 2011. risk/verizon-data-center-failure-causes-jetblue-air-travel-
delays/95538.fullarticle
[5] Swachh Power - A Glimpse of Power Quality in India, PGCIL,
September 2015. [17]https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/09/20/high_voltage_fault_blam
ed_for_gs2_outage/
[6] Sarah Ronnberg, Math Bollen, Propagation of Supraharmonics in
the LV Grid, Report 2017. [18] http://www.datacenterknowledge.com/archives/2017/05/30/
british-air-data-center-outage-feeds-outrage-at-airline-cost-cuts/
[7] Phang Yoke Yin, M V Chilukuri, Real-Time Power Quality Monitoring
and Analysis System Using LabVIEW, IEEE International Conference on [19] http://searchdatacenter.techtarget.com/news/4500272147/
Instrumentation and Measurement (I2MTC), 5 - 7 May 2009, Minute-by-minute-data-center-outage-costs-stack-up
Singapore.
[20] http://www.powerqualityworld.com/2011/04/cbema-curve-power-
[8] M V Chilukuri, Tan Sih Sin, Pattern Recognition Tool for Detection quality-standard.html
and Classification of Power System Transient, Proceedings of IEEE
[21]https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/03/delta-atlanta-power-outage-
TENCON, 17 - 20 October 2019, Kochi, India.
cost-it-up-to-50-million.html
[9] http://www.newindianexpress.com/states/tamil-
nadu/2017/mar/10/three-on-dialysis-die-after-puducherry-hospital- Dr M V Chilukuri is Associate
power-failure-1579759.html Professor and Head, Power Quality
& Condition Monitoring Research
[10] http://www.datacenterknowledge.com/archives/2017/03/31/data- Group at the School of Electrical
center-cooling-outage-disrupts-azure-cloud-in-japan/ Engineering, Vellore Institute of
Technology. He is senior member of
[11] http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/content-tracks/colo-
IEEE and a member of IEEE P825
cloud/lightning-sparks-1m-singapore-exchange- Working Group on Transactive
outage/91339.fullarticle Energy.
[12] http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/content-tracks/colo-
Prerna Sarkar is a B.Tech
cloud/amazon-web-services-us-east-1-goes-down-errors-cause-
(Electrical and Electronics
outage/97892.article Engineering) student at Vellore
[13] http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/content-tracks/colo- Institute of Technology.
42 cloud/microsoft-confirms-azure-outage-was-human-
error/92880.fullarticle
a quarterly magazine of the society of energy engineers and managers / India
[14] http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/content-tracks/power-
cooling/data-center-outage-disrupts-fujitsu-cloud-in-the-
us/94724.fullarticle
October - December 2019