Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 1350448794901058 Main
1 s2.0 1350448794901058 Main
1994
Copyright 0 1994Elsevier science Ltd
Printed in Great Britain. All rights reserved
1350-4487/!74 37.00+ .oo
13504487(94)E0043-Y
N. A. SPOONER*
Research Laboratory for Archaeology and the History of Art, University of Oxford, 6 Keble Road,
Oxford OX1 345, U.K.
Abstract-A series of experiments were conducted on the optical dating signal from quartz. Results are
presented showing the quantitative equivalence of the light sums of the optically stimulated luminescence
(OSL) emitted by quartz under exposure to 514.5 nm light and that of the quartz “325°C” thermo-
luminescence (T’L) peak. Discrepancies observed between the OSL and TL light sums under “typical”
measurement conditions (i.e. when OSL is measured at -293 K and the 325°C TL peak is measured at
~600 K, in both cases observing ultraviolet emissions) are attributed to thermal quenching of lumines-
cence at the recombination centres (non-radiative recombination). The bleach response spectrum (using
bleaching wavebands ranging from 400.6 A 10.1nm to 899.1 A 13.2 nm) of OSL from quartz (514.5 nm
stimulation) was measured and found, within experimental errors, to be indistinguishable from that
previously measured for the 325°C TL peak of quartz Also measured was the thermal dependence of
the OSL signal under stimulation by various wavebands ranging from 480.9 A 6.8 nm to 861.1 A 12.5 nm,
in the temperature range from u 100 to m 500 K. Strong thermal assistance was found for all wavebands
tested, with the magnitude of thermal assistance increasing as stimulation wavelength increased-
behaviour not inconsistent with photoionization. Supplementary work showed that OSL production
involves a single-photon-absorption untrapping step. It is concluded that the OSL emitted by quartz under
exposure to visible light, and the 325°C TL peak of quartz, originate from one and the same trapped
electron population. Furthermore, optical untrapping of this trapped charge. population, resulting in both
the bleaching of the 325°C TL peak and the prompt emission of OSL, proceeds by the same mechanism:
single-photon-absorption photoionization direct to the conduction band.
*Present address: Division of Archaeology and Natural History, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian
National University, Canberra, A.C.T.. 0200, Australia.
593
N. A. SPOONER
TL glow curves of both samples are of similar However, given the infeasibility of measuring OSL
form, displaying a high degree of sensitization with at temperatures exceeding 3OO”C,it was necessary to
prominent 325°C TL peaks; both samples also emit “move” the 325°C TL peak to lower temperatures
intense OSL. Typical natural glow curves of each are to create a range of temperature overlap in which to
shown in Fig. l(a) and Roberts et al. (1994, Fig. 3), compare the light sums. Using the peak shift method,
respectively. For both samples, measurements were at sufficiently slow heating rates the 325°C TL peak
performed only on the natural luminescence from can be shifted to temperatures sufficiently low to
sedimentary quartz of 90-125 pm diameter separated attain a temperature overlap with the OSL measure-
using the procedures described in Roberts et al. ments, and thereby reveal the extent of thermal
(I 994). The absence of a detectable infrared-stimulated quenching. Slow heating rates were facilitated by an
luminescence (IRSL) signal under exposure to 800 A Alldred-type glow oven controlled by a purpose-built
80nm stimulation was interpreted as indicating an servo capable of heating rates ranging from 10 K s-l
absence of significant feldspar contamination in the to 0.001 K s-‘. Measurements were made on the
final “pure” quartz extracts (Spooner and Questiaux, natural TL (NTL) of mass-normalized aliquots of
1989). Chaperon Rouge quartz loaded onto rhodium-plated
copper discs and heated in flowing N, . To assess the
residual TL, portions of sample were drained of the
2. EXPERIMENTAL DESCRIF’TIONS AND 325°C TL peak component by cycles of bleaching,
INSTRUMENTATION using an Oriel solar simulator filtered to remove
ultraviolet and blue light. The residual TL was then
2.1. Comparison of OSL and 325’C TL peak light
measured using the same procedure as for the un-
bleached discs. Normalized glow curves representative
A series of measurements were conducted to exam- of both sets of discs are shown in Fig. l(a)-(c), along
ine quantitatively the hypothesized equivalence of the with the “separated ” “325°C” TL peaks obtained
325°C TL peak source population with that giving by subtraction of the bleached glow curves from the
rise to the OSL signal. The reports of Wintle (1975) corresponding unbleached glow curves. The set of
on thermal quenching of the 325°C TL peak, and B. separated “325”C”, TL peaks is shown overlain in
W. Smith (personal communication) of similar be- Fig. 2.
haviour exhibited by quartz OSL, led to the supposi- Isothermal OSL measurements were performed on
tion that most, if not all, of the discrepancies fresh portions of the same sample, with optical
observed between OSL and 325°C TL peak signal stimulation using the 514.5 nm line from an Ar-ion
intensities were due to thermal quenching. To test laser system (Smith et al., 1986) interfaced to a
that supposition, isothermal OSL decay curves (i.e. modified Alldred-type TL glow oven. Illumination
curves of OSL intensity vs exposure energy) were to power at the sample was 20 mW cm-*, and cumulat-
he measured at various temperatures and the light ive exposures varied from 24 to 64 J total deposited
sums compared with those for the 325°C TL peak. energy. To permit quantitative intercomparison of
The prediction is that the TL and OSL light sums the light sums, the same photomultiplier tube (PMT)
would trend towards the same value at any given (an EMI 92354) and filters (2 mm Schott BG39 plus
temperature. 5.1 mm Coming 7-5 1) were used for both the TL and
3soo
-2500
NTl..BLEACH
%
2
1500
'oQo.-3e7nPEAK.
Nn-tNn.El.EAcn)
I
i A I
FIG. I. Glow curves of both natural and bleached quartz measured at heating rates of (a) IO K s-‘,
(b) 0.2 K s-’ and (c) 0.01 K s-‘. Overlain are the separated “325°C” TL peaks, obtained by subtraction
of the bleached glow curves from the corresponding unbleached glow curves.
OPTICAL DATING SIGNAL FROM QUARTZ 59s
66660
T-P--CC)
FIG. 2.Shown overlain are the separated “325°C” TL peaks obtained by subtraction of bleached from
unbleached glow curves for each of the heating rates used, and normalized by sample mass.
OSL measurements. Finally, the two glow ovens used 2.2 The bleaching response spectrum of quartz OSL
were intercalibrated for temperature and light collec- Previous work (Spooner et al., 1988) reported a
tion efficiency. measurement of the bleach response spectrum of the
Representative OSL decay curves are shown 325°C TL peak. Here the bleaching response spec-
in Fig. 3, and the light sums compared with those trum of 514.5 nm-stimulated OSL from Deaf Adder
of the separated “325°C” TL peak in Fig. 4. These quartz was determined. The bleaching wavebands
data demonstrate the equivalence of the OSL and were selected from the output of an 800 W halogen
TL light sums over a range of comparable tempera- lamp by various narrow-band [ - 10 rmr full-width
tures. half-maximum (FWHM)] interference filters. The
progression of bleaching of the 514.5 nm-stimulated
signal was monitored using short exposures from an
Ar-ion laser interfaced by the author to an Elsec Type
9010 reader (Spooner, 1993). The emitted lumines-
cence was detected by an EM1 9235QPMT with
2 rmn Schott BG39 and 5.1 mm Corning 7-51 filters.
The OSL decay curves in Fig. 5 represent the
bleaching of the 514.5 nm-stimulated OSL signal by
the various wavebands shown. These curves are
equivalent to the decay CUNes generated using the
corresponding wavebands for stimulation, as verified
at three wavebands (514.6 A 7.2 nm, 589.4 A 8.9 nm
and 639.2 A 9.6 nm; Spooner, unpublished data).
These data demonstrate the progressively greater
bleaching efficiency of shorter wavelengths, in accord
with the previous findings for quartz TL.
The energies required at the various bleaching
wavebands to reduce the OSL signal to 5%, 50% and
95% of its initial value are shown in Fig. 6. Also
shown are data from Spooner et of. (1988) on the
energies required for “complete removal** of the
325°C TL peak and to reduce the 370 and 480°C TL
1 10 100 1000
peaks to 80% of their initial NTL levels. It should be
lllumlnW3n lima (oeconds) noted that the slopes of the OSL and 325°C TL peak
FIG. 3. A representative selection of isothermal OSL decay
are congruent for wavelengths exceeding 4OOnm,
curves, obtained using 514.5 nm stimulation (20 mW cme2 whereas at ultraviolet wavelengths a steeper slope is
incident on sample) on separate sample ahquots, held at the seen for all three NTL peaks, with the data for
temperatures shown (“C). Data are normalized by 0.4mJ the 370 and 480°C TL peaks overlying within errors.
short exposures made at 20°C and are directly comparable. These results are taken as demonstrating the bleach-
(Note the increase in the initial count rate and the initial
decay rate with increasing temperature up to - 1SOC, while ing of two, at least, separate trapped charge popula-
simultaneously the total light sum is in fact decreasing as tions that contribute to the natural luminescence of
thermal quenching becomes increasingly effective.) quartz.
596 N. A. SPOGNER
Temperature (K)
FIG. 4. The light sums of the isothermal OSL decay curves (see Fig. 3) are shown overlain with the light
sums of the separated “325°C” TL glow peaks (see Fig. 2). All data are normalized using the light sum
of the OSL decay curve measured at 20°C (4.123 x lo6 counts). [Note the logarithmic normalized
luminescence scale, and the apparent onset of thermal quenching at temperatures at least as low as 30°C
(303 K).]
2.3. Dependence of the OSL signal intensity on photon been proposed that involve the absorption of a single
jkx density photon only (H&t et al., 1988) or multiple photons
(Godfrey-Smith et al., 1988). Resolution between
Various mechanisms exist by which charge may be these mechanisms is possible from the form of the
untrapped by photo-absorption. Mechanisms have OSL intensity dependence on photon flux density.
100 ___&_.
8QQ.lnm
--Ir 031.3 nm
.-_o-.
90 799.9 nm
-0..
750.1 nm
* 720.6 nm
80 __,-
695.3 nm
- 539.2 nm
- 900.0 nm
70 ___m
559.4 nm
. ..e..
591.1 lull
. ..Q..
60 565.7 nm
..e..
.
559.9 nm
- 549.1 rim
So -..*-.
541.onm
___*-.
533.3 nm
“‘9.’
520.4 nm
40 -
514.6 nm
-
500.5 nm
30 . ..w..
489.5 nm
-
mm.- iii.lz~
20 . ..*..
449:5 nm
_._*_.
441SIMll
10 . ..-..
431.5nm
-- 420.2 nm
- 400.6 nm
0 -
F 0
8
Encrgy(mJcm-*)
FIG. 5. Bleaching of the 514.5 nm-stimulated OSL by various narrow wavebands (_ 10 nm FWHM) of
near-infrared and visible light. Individual aliquots were used for each bleaching waveband and all are
normalized by short exposures (514.5 nm) given before any bleaching exposures. Data have had the
background count rate subtracted (mostly PMT dark noise plus scattered stimulation photons) and are
corrected for depletion due to the cumulative monitoring short exposures (514.5 nm). The bleaching curves
are plotted against energy deposited in that waveband. The transects allow determination of the total
energies required for 5%. 50% and 95% reduction of the OSL for any given waveband.
OPTICAL DATING SIGNAL FROM QUARTZ 597
influence of thermal quenching, as discussed in detail likelihood of this is annulled by the congruence of
by Spooner (in preparation). Another explanation for the optical bleaching response spectra of the two
the agreement between the OSL and 325°C TL peak signals. Spooner (1987) showed the existence of two
light sums is that the magnitude of the hole popu- distinct bleaching regimes in quartz NTL. The first,
lation limits the observed luminescence. However, the in the ultraviolet region (< 400 nm), indicated that
g *...
E
Q
1000
I
100
f
3
10
FIG. 8. The thermal dependence, over temperatures ranging from - 100 to - 500 K, of the OSL stimulated
by a variety of narrow wavebands (- 10 nm FWHM) from 480.9 A 6.8 nm to 861.1 A 12.5 nm. Data have
background count rates subtracted (Predominantly PMT noise and scattered stimulation photons) and
are corrected for depletion by the cumulative short exposures. Data are not normalized for incident beam
power. The same emission wavelengths were monitored in all cases. [Note that detectable luminescence
is stimulated by even the near-infrared waveband (861.1 A 12.5 nm) at temperatures 270°C. Weaker
infrared-stimulated luminescence is presumed also to occur at lower temperatures, but is below the
detection threshold of this apparatus.]
OPTICAL DATING SIGNAL FROM QUARTZ 599
@ 0.05 -
e
0.00 . " ' . ' . ' . '
1.6 1.7 1.6 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
Optical Stimulation photon energy (eV)
FIG. 9. The thermal assistance (activation) energies measured for each stimulation waveband plotted
against the mean photon energy of the corresponding waveband.
bleaching of the _ 370°C and 480°C TL peaks is well type expression also gives a good fit to the OSL data
described by a single Urbach-type expression shown in Fig. 6, and the bleaching susceptibility of
(Urbach, 1953), whereas the 325°C TL peak shows a the OSL signal accords with that observed by
bleach response in the ultraviolet region intermediate Spooner et al. (1988) for the 325°C TL peak.
between its response to visible wavelengths and the The photoeviction mechanism is consistent with
ultraviolet response of the two higher-temperature a single-photon photoeviction process, as inferred
NTL peaks. This behaviour is consistent with a com- from Fig. 7. Thermal dependence of OSL intensity
bination of direct photoionization from the 325°C TL was found to be of the form E,,,_., &,,_) =
peak traps and the neutralization of the relevant 4.26 exp[ - 1.59E~,timtitifupho,,,~o.)l,
where the energies are
recombination centres by charge untrapped by ultra- in electron volts. Such an exponential relationship
violet photons from a deep thermally disconnected eliminates the possibility of untrapping via an excited
trap population, as postulated by McKeever (1991). level of the bound state and is instead consistent with
In the second TL bleach regime (-400-700 mn), photoionization directly to the conduction band. A
only the 325°C peak is seen to bleach. Previous work simplified configuration coordinate diagram illustrat-
(Spooner, 1987) reported the bleaching response of ing this mechanism is shown in Fig. 10.
the 325°C TL peak to be reasonably well described by
the Urbach exponential relationship, although with a
different bleaching susceptibility to that observed in 4. CONCLUSIONS
the ultraviolet region. The different susceptibilities The data sets presented here are interpreted as
are evidence of the bleaching of two, at least, separate verifying the hypothesis that the quartz 325°C TL
populations of trapped charge, in accord with the peak and OSL represent one and the same trapped
model proposed by McKeever (1991). An Urbach- electron population. Trivial contributions to the OSL
may originate from traps associated with the other
NTL peaks but the quartz OSL signal (514.5mn
E . . stimulation) appears overwhelmingly dominated by
--_
contributions from the source traps giving rise to the
325°C TL peak. The differences in light sum between
E photon
TL measurements of this trapped charge population
and OSL measurements are primarily attributed to
thermal quenching at the recombination centres.
Furthermore, as both modes of untrapping (thermal
and optical) result in emission spectra compatible
with the use of the same population of recombination
centres, it is postulated that thermally and optically
r untrapped electrons proceed via the same pathway,
FIG. 10. A simplified configuration coordinate diagram namely through the conduction band, to these re.-
representing the photoionization process responsible for combination centres. This photoeviction mechanism
the production of quartz OSL (under stimulation by near- is a single-photon-absorption process involving direct
infrared and visible light) and also the bleaching of the
325°C TL peak. (Note that details of the bound state energy photoionixation to the conduction band. The tem-
level distribution and the conduction band density of states’ perature dependence observed in the production of
distribution are unknown.) OSL is inherent to the photoionization mechanism.
600 N. A. SPOONER