You are on page 1of 17

Cracked tooth syndrome.

in brief
• Updates and clarifies the definition of

Part 1: aetiology and diagnosis the term ‘cracked tooth syndrome’,

PraCtiCe
including an overview of the typically
associated signs and symptoms of this
syndrome complex.
S. Banerji,1 S. B. Mehta2 and B. J. Millar3 • Provides an account of the epidemiology,
aetiology and diagnosis of the condition,
including a description of available special
Verifiable CPD PaPer clinical tests to form a positive diagnosis.
• Details the factors which may influence
the prognosis of affected teeth.

Symptomatic, incompletely fractured posterior teeth can be a great source of anxiety for both the dental patient and den-
tal operator. For the latter, challenges associated with deriving an accurate diagnosis together with the efficient and time
effective management of cases of cracked tooth syndrome are largely accountable for the aforementioned problem. The
aim of this series of two articles is to provide the reader with an in-depth insight into this condition, through the under-
taking of a comprehensive literature review of contemporarily available data. The first article will provide details relating
to the background of cracked tooth syndrome including the epidemiology, patho-physiology, aetiology and diagnosis of
the syndrome, together with a consideration of factors which may influence the prognostic outcome of teeth affected
by incomplete, symptomatic fractures. The second article will focus on the immediate and intermediate management of
cracked teeth, and also provide a detailed account of the application of both direct and indirect restorations and restora-
tive techniques used respectively in the management of teeth affected by this complex syndrome.

introDuCtion ‘split tooth syndrome’ have also been


The term ‘cuspal fracture odontalgia’ was used synonymously.5
first used by Gibbs in 1954,1 to describe a Patients suffering from cracked tooth
condition which is better now known as syndrome (CTS) classically present with a
‘cracked tooth syndrome’ or ‘cracked cusp history of sharp pain when biting, or when
syndrome’. The latter concept was coined consuming cold food/beverages.6 It has
by Cameron in 1964,2 who proceeded to been suggested that the symptom of pain
define the condition as ‘an incomplete frac- on biting increases as the applied occlusal fig. 1 Shows an example of a tooth with
a vertical root fracture, where the patient
ture of a vital posterior tooth that involves force is raised.7 A detailed assessment of the initially presented with symptoms of cracked
the dentine and occasionally extends to symptoms may reveal a history of discom- tooth syndrome. any delays in instituting
the pulp’. In more recent times the defi- fort that may have been present for several therapy may result in such an outcome, which
may happen where there is doubt over the
nition has been amended to include, ‘a months previously. Other symptoms may
diagnosis of the condition
fracture plane of unknown depth and include pain on release of pressure when
direction passing through tooth structure fibrous foods are eaten, ‘rebound pain’.8
that, if not already involving, may progress Pain may also be elicited by the consump- as shown by Figure 1. Table 1 provides
to communicate with the pulp and or tion of sugar containing substances5 and a summary of the commonly associated
periodontal ligament’.3 also by the act of tooth grinding or during signs and symptoms associated with CTS.
The term ‘incomplete fracture of poste- the undertaking of excursive mandibular The physiological basis of pain on chew-
rior teeth’ is often used interchangeably movements.9 While some patients are able ing has been hypothesised by Brannstrom
with that of cracked tooth syndrome,4 to specify the precise tooth from which the et al.10 to be accounted for by the sud-
while the terms ‘green-stick fracture’ or symptoms may be arising, the latter is not den movement of fluid present in dentinal
a consistent feature. The absence of heat tubules which occurs when the fractured
induced sensitivity may also be a feature. portions of the tooth move independently
1
Senior Clinical Teacher; 2General Dental Practitioner
and Clinical Teacher, 3*Professor, Consultant in Restora- Where the fracture line may eventually of one another. It is thought that the lat-
tive Dentistry, Department of Primary Dental Care, propagate into the pulp chamber (‘complete ter results in the activation of myelinated
King’s College London Dental Institute, Bessemer Road,
London, SE5 9RW fracture’), symptoms of irreversible pulpitis A-type fibres within the dental pulp,
*Correspondence to: Professor B. J. Millar or apical periodontitis may ensue, while thereby accounting for the acute nature of
Email: brian.millar@kcl.ac.uk
fractures which progress further towards the pain. It has also been suggested that the
Refereed Paper the root may be associated with areas of perception of hypersensitivity to cold may
Accepted 25 March 2010
DOI: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2010.449 localised periodontal breakdown or at occur as a result of the seepage of noxious
© British Dental Journal 2010; 208: 459–463 worst culminate in vertical tooth fracture5 irritants through the crack, which results

BRItIsh DentAl JOuRnAl VOLUME 208 NO. 10 MAY 22 2010 459

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PraCtiCe

in the subsequent release of neuropeptides table 1 the commonly presenting signs and symptoms seen in cases of cracked
which cause a concomitant lowering in the tooth syndrome (CtS)
pain threshold of unmyleinated C-type Sudden, sharp pain on biting/chewing and in some cases on release: ‘rebound pain’
fibres within the dental pulp.11
An alternative hypothesis has been Sensitivity to cold thermal stimuli; in some cases hyper-reactivity to hot/sugary stimuli may also occur
proposed, whereby it has been postu- Symptoms may be present for periods ranging from weeks to months
lated that the symptoms are caused by the
Inconsistent ability to localise the affected tooth
alternating stretching and compressing of
the odontoblast processes located within Pain may be elicited by lateral cusp pressure, as evoked by ‘bite tests’ and tooth grinding
the crack.12 Fracture lines may be seen clinically (sometimes upon removal of the restoration), aided by magnification,
The aim of this article is to provide an dyes or transillumination
overview of the condition of ‘cracked tooth Positive response to vitality tests; exaggerated response to cold thermal stimuli
syndrome’, with regards to its epidemiol-
Radiographs; usually inconclusive
ogy, aetiology and diagnosis.
Figure 2 illustrates a tooth which has an
incomplete fracture, which was revealed While incomplete posterior tooth frac-
upon the removal of an existing silver tures are most likely to be seen to be occur-
amalgam restoration. An incomplete tooth ring in teeth which have carious lesions
fracture is often difficult to visualise before or contain dental restorations, a study
a restoration is removed, but transillumi- by Hiatt 13 reported that 35% of the cases
nation can be used from different aspects presenting with CTS among their sample
to show the presence of an interface within were among teeth which were sound and
the tooth (Fig. 3). Tooth fractures can be caries free. a
highlighted by the use of stains although Mandibular molar teeth appear to be the
this may be difficult to remove and colour most commonly involved teeth by this con-
the final aesthetic restoration. dition,13 followed by maxillary premolars
and maxillary molar teeth - while mandibu-
ePiDemiology of lar premolar teeth seem to be least affected.
CraCkeD tooth SynDrome It has been hypothesised that since lower
Epidemiological studies of the incidence of first molar teeth are usually the first per-
cracked tooth syndrome are conflicting;13,14 manent teeth to erupt into the dental arch,
however, it would be appropriate to state they are most likely to be affected by the b
that CTS is a condition which generally condition of dental caries, followed by the fig. 2 Shows an example of a tooth which
affects adult dental patients, typically in need of subsequent restorative interven- has an incomplete fracture (a) which
the age range of 30 to 60 years. While tion.14 These teeth are therefore more likely was revealed upon removal of an existing
silver amalgam restoration; (b) the arrows
the results of an early epidemiological sur- to be rendered with large, deep restorations,
illustrates the path of the fracture line
vey by Cameron in 19766 seemed to sug- making them more vulnerable to the proc- running around the mesiopalatal cusp
gest that the condition was much more ess of subsequent fracture. It has also been
prevalent among female dental patients, proposed that the ‘wedging effect’ inflicted
it has since been shown by more recent upon lower first molar teeth from the prom-
studies that both sexes seem to be equally inent mesio-palatal cusp of maxillary first
affected.15 molar teeth may also be contributory.14
Geursten et al.16 have reported that tooth
fractures are a potential major cause of aetiology of CraCkeD
tooth loss in the industrialised world. tooth SynDrome
The availability of incidence data on the The aetiology of incomplete fractures of
condition of cracked tooth syndrome is posterior teeth is multi-factorial. In an
largely lacking. A study by Krell et al.17 article by Guersten et al.14 it is stated that
has reported an incidence rate of 9.7% ‘excessive forces applied to a healthy tooth fig. 3 transillumination of cracked cusp
showing mesial midline and lingual fractures.
among 8,175 patients referred to a private or physiologic forces applied to a weak- the transmission of the light beam has been
endodontic practice over a period of six ened tooth can cause an incomplete frac- ‘stopped’ mesio-lingually by the presence of
years. It would be logical to assume that as ture of enamel or dentine’. the fracture
more patients are retaining their teeth into Lynch et al.18 have subdivided the causes
older age incomplete fractures of posterior of cracks into four major causative cat- ‘Restorative procedures’ such as the
teeth are more likely to be observed to be egories, hence: ‘restorative procedures’, placement of ‘friction lock’ or ‘self thread-
occurring at an even higher frequency in ‘occlusal factors’, ‘developmental condi- ing dentine pins’,19 the non-incremental
the future. tions’ and ‘miscellaneous factors’. application of composite resin, excessive

460 BRItIsh DentAl JOuRnAl VOLUME 208 NO. 10 MAY 22 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PraCtiCe

hydraulic pressure when luting inlays, that the ratio of force on molars, premolars patients referred to specialist endodontists
onlays, crowns or bridges5 (in particular and incisors is 4 : 2 : 1 respectively, with with diagnostic uncertainties are eventu-
where the restorations may be ‘tight- far higher forces being applied the closer ally diagnosed with incomplete tooth frac-
fitting’), can all induce stresses onto the the tooth is to its posterior occlusal deter- tures. The importance of an early diagnosis
residual tooth structure culminating in a minant, (the temporo-mandibular joint).29 has being linked with successful restora-
possible fracture.20 Likewise, the place- Occlusal interferences on vulnerable cusps tive management and prognosis.35
ment of poor quality dental amalgam can also lead to eventual fractures as may A careful history and assessment of the
alloys, the contamination of freshly placed do non-working side occlusal interfer- symptoms, in particular that of cold sen-
dental amalgam by moisture and exces- ences.30 The loss of anterior guidance may sitivity and sharp pain on biting hard or
sive condensation pressures when plac- also lead to the generation of harmful tough food which ceases on the release
ing amalgam may also induce fractures.21 eccentric forces. of pressure, is an important indicator.
It is ironic, however, that dentine pins Parafunctional tooth grinding habits Symptoms may vary according to the
are often used to restore fractured cusps may also lead to the generation of con- depth and orientation of the crack.4
among teeth which have been lost through siderable occlusal forces, in particular the According to Homewood,36 fractures
cracked tooth syndrome. habit of nocturnal bruxism, possibly due tend to occur in a direction parallel to
Other aspects of ‘restorative practice’ to cortical inhibitors being suppressed dur- the forces on the cuspal incline; thus with
which may contribute to crack formation ing sleep, thus allowing greater forces to larger restorations, cracks tend to be more
include the excessive removal of tooth be applied.31 superficial and thereby produce fewer
tissue during cavity preparation which So called ‘developmental factors’ include symptoms, while with smaller restorations
indeed has been shown to significantly the possibility of areas of localised struc- cracks tend to be deeper and closer to the
lower tooth rigidity.22 Deep cusp-fossa tural weakness within a tooth, arising as pulp. It has also been suggested that most
relationships which arise as a result of a result of the incomplete fusion of areas cracks tend to run vertically (as opposed
the over-contouring of restorations may of calcification.13 to horizontally).33 Vertical cracks usually
also contribute to the fracture of the non- Morphological factors associated with run in a mesio-distal direction along the
functional cusp.5 The preparation of vital the increased risk of cracked tooth syn- occlusal surface and may involve one or
teeth to receive MOD amalgam restorations drome include deep occlusal grooves, both of the marginal ridges respectively.33
(with the loss of both marginal ridges) has pronounced vertical radicular grooves or Diagnosis is often complicated by the
been shown to significantly reduce rela- bifurcations, extensive pulp spaces, steep fact that several other dental conditions
tive cuspal rigidity, on average by 63%.23 cusp angles, prominent mesio-palatal cusps may readily be mis-diagnosed as cracked
It has been proposed that a cavity of width of upper maxillary first molars as well as tooth syndrome. Such conditions include:
in excess of one quarter of the intercuspal the presence of lingually inclined man- acute periodontal disease, reversible pulpi-
distance should be considered to be at an dibular molar teeth, which are thought to tis, dentinal hypersensitivity, galvanic pain
increased risk of fracture.24 be the be most likely to suffer the complete associated with the recent placement of
Ratcliff et al.25 have estimated that the loss by fracture of both lingual cusps.32 silver amalgam restorations, post-opera-
presence of an intra-coronal restoration Under the category of ‘miscellane- tive sensitivity associated with micro-
can predispose the tooth to a risk of frac- ous factors’ are included factors such as leakage from recently placed composite
ture 29 fold times greater than that of a the effect of lingual barbells; the crack- resin restorations, fractured restorations,
healthy, un-restored tooth! Differences ing/crazing of tooth tissue which arises ‘high spots’ or areas of hyper-occlusion
in the co-efficients of thermal expansion from the use of high speed rotary instru- from dental restorations, occlusal trauma
between that of the tooth tissue and restor- ments; erosive tooth wear and the factor from the process of parafuntional tooth
ative material may also have the potential of thermal cycling, which may induce grinding, orofacial pain arising from con-
to induce fracture.26 enamel cracks. ditions such as trigeminal neuralgia and
‘Occlusal causitive factors’; Trucshowksy5 An ageing dentition may also be more psychiatric disorders such as atypical
has stated that the most common cause of predisposed to cracking as dental hard facial pain.20
cracked tooth syndrome is that of ‘a mas- tissues become more brittle and less elas- While occasionally cracks may be
ticatory accident’ - biting suddenly on a tic with age, whereby forces applied may detected by visual inspection, they are not
hard object such as bone with excessive exceed the elastic limits of dentine.7 always readily apparent. The use of mag-
force. Other commonly attributing food nifying loupes and trans-illumination with
items/objects include betel nut chewing, the DiagnoSiS of the aid of a fibre-optic device (Fig. 3) may
inadvertent biting of lead shot, cherry CraCkeD tooth SynDrome be helpful.18 The use of a sharp straight
stones and ‘granary’ bread.27 The diagnosis of cracked tooth syndrome probe may also help detect ‘catches’ in the
Trauma from the occlusion may also is often problematic and has been known cracks, while the application of the latter
lead to fracture. Helkimo et al.28 deter- to challenge even the most experienced of dental instrument at the margins of heav-
mined the maximum biting force between dental operators, accountable largely by ily restored teeth which are suspected to
natural molars to range from 10 to 73 kg the fact that the associated symptoms tend be involved by an incomplete fracture
with an average of 45.7 kg for males and to be very variable and at times bizarre.33 may elicit symptoms of sharp pain should
36.4 kg for females. It has been estimated Indeed it has been reported34 that 20% of a fracture be possibly present. The removal

BRItIsh DentAl JOuRnAl VOLUME 208 NO. 10 MAY 22 2010 461

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PraCtiCe

of existing restorations may also help to and the patient asked to bite; by the sub-
reveal fracture lines. sequent application of the stick to each
An un-authenticated technique, which individual cusp in turn it may be possible
has often been used by the authors of this to localise the affected cusp. The use of
article particularly where there may be cotton wool rolls involves placing the roll
doubt over the precise diagnosis, is one on the suspected tooth and requesting the
which involves the placement of compos- patient to bite down and then suddenly
ite resin over the affected tooth without releasing the pressure. Pain perceived upon
etching and bonding; material is added release of pressure has been suggested fig. 4 tooth Slooth (Professional results,
uSa)
at a minimal thickness of 0.5 mm and by Kruger 38 to confirm the diagnosis of
wrapped over across the external line cracked tooth syndrome. The use of rubber
angles of the tooth onto the axial walls. plungers of anaesthetic carpules suspended of an incomplete fracture of a posterior
The set material acts as a splint and the from a length of floss, to be used in a simi- tooth, have been discussed in more detail
patient can bite down on this with an lar fashion to cotton wools rolls, to aid in in second of the two articles on cracked
intervening bite test; although high, it the diagnosis of cracked tooth syndrome, tooth syndrome.
may result in greatly reduced symptoms has also been described.39
as the fracture no longer opens on clench- Commercially available diagnostic tools the PrognoSiS of teeth
ing, perhaps confirming the diagnosis of to undertake ‘bite tests’ include products affeCteD by CraCkeD
an incomplete fracture. It must be empha- such as ‘Fractfinder (Denbur, Oak Brook,
tooth SynDrome
sised, however, that there is no evidence in IL, USA) and ‘Tooth Slooth II’ (Professional The prognosis of teeth affected by CTS
the available literature (to the knowledge Results Inc., Laguna Niguel, California, is dependent on a multitude of factors.
of the authors) to scientifically validate USA). Figure 4 shows the Tooth Slooth The location and extent of the crack is
this approach. which comprises two small plastic pyrami- a key determinant. It has been reported
The use of stains to highlight fracture dal plastic bite blocks attached to a handle that incomplete cracks generally run in a
lines such as gentian violet or methyl- at either end (20 by 10 mm). One block has mesio-distal direction (81.1%); rarely are
ene blue33 have been described by several a small concavity at its apex which can vertical or orovestibular cracks seen,41 For
authors. However, it is imperative to note accommodate the cusp of a tooth.40 The cracks that are confined to the dentine
that the technique of using stains to delin- slooth is placed either between the cusps of layer, that run in a horizontal direction
eate cracks may take several days to be a tooth or onto the cusp tip and the patient not involving the dental pulp, or for those
effective and may require the placement is asked to close together. Pain on biting fractures which are limited to a single mar-
of a provisional restoration in the cavity, or release on the specific cusp identifies ginal ridge which do not extend more than
which may further undermine the struc- the offending/involved cusp. Ehrmann et 2-3 mm below the periodontal attachment,
tural integrity of the tooth and thereby al.37 have advocated the use of this method the prognosis has been reported by Clark et
aid in the process of crack propagation. as one with a higher level of sensitivity al.42 to be ‘excellent’; while the prognosis
Another complication with the use of than that associated with the use of wood for fractures that involve both marginal
delineation dyes is the subsequent diffi- sticks; furthermore, it is thought to allow ridges, communicating with the dental pulp
culty associated with the placement of a for the more accurate identification of the or those fractures that extend vertically
definitive aesthetic restoration. Periodontal affected/involved cusp. through the pulp or involve the sub-pulpal
probing may also be helpful, as localised Vitality tests for involved teeth are usu- floor has been described as being ‘poor’.
isolated periodontal probing defects may ally positive,5 although sometimes affected Affected teeth which present with com-
be seen where fracture lines may have teeth may display signs of hypersensitivity plete mesio-distal fractures, or one where
extended subgingivally. to cold thermal stimuli due to the presence the fractured segment cannot be removed
The use of so called ‘bite tests’18 to mimic of pulpal inflammation; a feature that may or be exposed by gingivoplasty or by an
the symptoms associated with incomplete help to confirm a diagnosis of CTS. Teeth alveoplasty procedure, have been described
fractures of posterior teeth may also prove affected by the condition are seldom tender as having a ‘hopeless prognosis’.42
helpful. However, it is important to gain to percussion (when percussed apically). Other factors which may impact on the
prior consent from the patient as the use Radiographs tend to be of limited use prognosis include the anatomy of the tooth
of such a test may cause cuspal fragmenta- as fractures tend to propagate in a mesio- and roots, the previous operative/restora-
tion! Objects that have been traditionally distal direction,18 parallel to that of the tive history of the tooth and the functional
used for this purpose include: orange wood plane of the film. However, they may be forces applied to the tooth (during both
sticks, cotton wool rolls, rubber abrasive of value in detecting more rarely occur- functional and parafunctional activity).18
wheels such as a Burlew wheel or the head ring fractures which may be running in a Early recognition will also help to pre-
of a number 10 round bur in a handle of bucco-lingual direction and for excluding vent further cracking, in particular, helping
cellophane tape. other dental pathology.20 to avoid propagation of the crack into the
The technique for the use of wood sticks The use of copper rings, stainless steel pulp chamber or sub-gingivally. It has been
has been described.37 It is advocated that orthodontic bands and acrylic provi- postulated that the loss of pulp vitality will
the stick is rested on the suspected tooth sional crowns to confirm the diagnosis have a poor effect on the prognosis of the

462 BRItIsh DentAl JOuRnAl VOLUME 208 NO. 10 MAY 22 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PraCtiCe

tooth, as endodontically treated cracked 11. Davis R, Overton J. Efficacy of bonded and non- 27. Talim S T, Gohil K S. Management of coronal frac-
bonded amalgams in the treatment of teeth with tures of permanent posterior teeth. J Prosthet Dent
teeth have been shown to display a rela- incomplete fractures. J Am Dent Assoc 2000; 1974; 31: 172-178.
tively high failure rate of 14.5% after an 131: 496-478. 28. Helkimo E. Bite force and functional state of the
12. Dewberry J A. Vertical fractures of posterior teeth. masticatory system in young men. Swed Dent J
evaluation period of two years.43 Indeed, it Lieve F S(ed). Endodontic therapy, 5th ed. pp 71-81. 1978; 2: 167-175.
has been reported that approximately 20% St Louis: Mosby, 1996. 29. Arnold M. Bruxism and the occlusion. Dent Clin
13. Hiatt W H. Incomplete crown-root fractures in North Am 1981; 25: 395-407.
of teeth with cracked tooth syndrome will pulpal periodontal disease. J Periodontol 1973; 30. Sweptson J H, Miller A W. The incompletely frac-
require root canal therapy.44 The skill and 44: 369-379. tured tooth. J Prosthet Dent 1986; 55: 413-415.
14. Geurtsen W. The cracked tooth syndrome: clini- 31. Attansio R. Nocturnal bruxism and its clinical man-
experience of the operator are also impor- cal features and case reports. Int J Periodontics agement. Dent Clin North Am 1991; 35: 245-252.
tant factors.18 Restorative Dent 1992; 12: 395-405. 32. Bader J D, Martin J A, Shugars D A. Incidence rates
15. Roh B D, Lee Y E. Analysis of 154 causes of teeth for complete cusp fracture. Community Dent Oral
Finally, the technique used to manage with cracks. Dent Traumatol 2006; 22: 118–123. Epidemiol 2001; 29: 346-353.
the condition will also have an important 16. Geurtsen W, Garcia-Godov F. Bonded restorations 33. Liu H H, Sidhu S K. Cracked teeth – treatment
for the prevention and treatment of the cracked rational and case management: case reports.
impact on the ultimate prognosis of the tooth syndrome. Am J Dent 1999; 11: 266–270. Quintessence Int 1995; 26: 485-492.
affected tooth. The second paper in this 17. Krell K, Rivera E. A six year evaluation of cracked 34. Brady B V, Maxwell E H. Potential for tooth fracture
teeth diagnosed with reversible pulptitis; treatment in restorative dentistry. J Prosthet Dent 1981;
series will discuss the latter issue in con- and prognosis. J Endod 2007; 33: 1405-1407. 45: 411-414.
siderable detail. 18. Lynch C, McConnel R. The cracked tooth syndrome. 35. Agar J R, Weller R N. Occlusal adjustments for
J Can Dent Assoc 2002; 68: 470-475. initial treatment and prevention of cracked tooth
1. Gibbs J W. Cuspal fracture odontalgia. Dent Dig 19. Fuss Z, Lustig J, Katz A, Tamse A. An evaluation of syndrome. J Prosthet Dent 1988; 60: 145–147.
1954; 60: 158-160. endodontically treated vertical root fractured teeth: 36. Homewood C I. Cracked tooth syndrome – inci-
2. Cameron C E. Cracked tooth syndrome. J Am Dent impact of operative procedures. J Endod 2000; dence, clinical findings and treatment. Aust Dent J
Assoc 1964; 68: 405-411. 27: 46-48. 1998; 43: 217-222.
3. Ellis S G. Incomplete tooth fracture - proposal for a 20. Turp C, Gobetti J. The cracked tooth syndrome: 37. Ehrmann E H, Tyas M J. Cracked tooth syndrome:
new definition. Br Dent J 2001; 190: 424-428. an elusive diagnosis. J Am Dent Assoc 1996; diagnosis, treatment and correlation between
4. Geurtsen W, Schwarze T, Gunay H. Diagnosis, 127: 1502-1507. symptoms and post-extraction findings. Aust Dent J
therapy and prevention of the cracked tooth syn- 21. Rosen H. Cracked tooth syndrome. J Prosthet Dent 1990; 35: 105-112.
drome. Quintessence Int 2003; 34: 409-417. 1982; 47: 36-43. 38. Kruger B F. Cracked tooth syndrome. Letter to the
5. Trushkowsky R. Restoration of a cracked tooth 22. Goel V, Khera S, Gurusami S, Chen R. Effect of cav- editor. Aust Dent J 1984; 29: 55.
with a bonded amalgam. Quintessence Int 1991; ity depth on stresses in a restored tooth. J Prosthet 39. Liebenburg W H. Esthetics in the cracked tooth syn-
22: 397-400. Dent 1992; 67: 174-183. drome: steps to success using resin bonded ceramic
6. Cameron C E. The cracked tooth syndrome: addi- 23. Plotino G, Buono L, Grande N, Lamorgese V, Soma restorations. J Esthet Dent 1995; 7: 155-166.
tional findings. J Am Dent Assoc 1976; 93: 971-975. F. Fracture resistance of endodontically treated 40. Fox K, Youngson C C. Diagnosis and treatment of
7. Signore A, Benedicenti S, Covani U. Ravera G. molars restored with extensive composite resin the cracked tooth. Prim Dent Care 1997; 4: 109-
A 4 to 6 year retrospective clinical study of restorations. J Prosthet Dent 2008; 99: 225-232. 113.
cracked teeth restored with bonded indirect 24. Mondelli J, SteagallL, Ishikiriama A. Fracture 41. Mittal N, Sharma V, Minocha A. Management of
resin composite onlays. Int J Prosthodont 2007; strength of human teeth with cavity preparations. cracked teeth - a case report. Endodontology
20: 609–616. J Prosthet Dent 1980; 433: 419-422. 2007; 39-44.
8. Stanley H R. The cracked tooth syndrome. J Am 25. Ratcliff S, Becker I, Quinn L. Type and incidence of 42. Clark L L, Caughman W F. Restorative treatment for
Acad Gold Foil Oper 1968; 11: 36-47. cracks in posterior teeth. J Prosthet Dent 2001; the cracked tooth. Oper Dent 1984; 9: 136-142.
9. Griffin J. Efficient, conservative treatment of 86: 168-172. 43. Tan L, Chen N N, Poon C Y, Wong H B. Survival of
symptomatic cracked teeth. Compendium 2006; 27: 26. Bearn D, Saunders E, Saunders W. The bonded root filled cracked teeth in a tertiary institution. Int
93-102. amalgam restoration – a review of the literature Endod J 2006; 39: 886-889.
10. Brannstrom M, Astrom A. The hydrodynamics of and report of its use in the treatment of four cases 44. Gutman J L, Rauskin H. Endodontic and restorative
dentine: its possible relation to dentinal pain. Int of cracked tooth syndrome. Quintessence Int 1994; management of incompletely fractured molar teeth.
Dent J 1972; 22: 219-227. 25: 321-326. Int Endod J 1994; 27: 364–365.

BRItIsh DentAl JOuRnAl VOLUME 208 NO. 10 MAY 22 2010 463

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


Cracked tooth syndrome. IN BRIEF
• Includes a consideration of means available

Part 2: restorative options to provide acute care for a patient

PRACTICE
suffering from cracked tooth syndrome.
• Provides a comprehensive review of the

for the management of available literature of both direct and


indirect restorations/restorative materials
to manage an incompletely fractured
posterior tooth.
cracked tooth syndrome • Introduces the concept of the direct
coronal splint as a novel approach for the
management of this distressing condition.
S. Banerji,1 S. B. Mehta2 and B. J. Millar3

VERIFIABLE CPD PAPER

The second of this two part series on ‘cracked tooth syndrome’ will focus on the available methods for the immediate,
intermediate and definitive management of patients affected by this condition. Included in this article is a comprehensive
account of the relative merits/drawbacks of various restorative materials and their respective techniques of application for
the treatment of symptomatic, incompletely fractured posterior teeth.

PRINCIPLES FOR THE propagation of the crack and reduce the Table 1 Immediate treatment options
MANAGEMENT OF ingress of bacterial microorganisms into
for CTS
CRACKED TOOTH SYNDROME Occlusal adjustment – destructive, short term
the dental pulp.2
It is apparent from the first article of this Historically a plethora of different ‘forms’ Remove segment – highly destructive
series that the diagnosis of cracked tooth of dental restorations have been advocated
syndrome can pose a major challenge to to ‘splint teeth’ affected by incomplete Immobilisation of segment:

the dental operator. It would also be fair to fractures. This paper will divide these into Copper ring difficult and
state that the management of the condition four broad categories. Hence: periodontally damaging
is by no means always a simple straight- • Immediate Orthodontic time consuming,
forward matter. • Direct restorations placed intra- band possibly not available
While it would appear that there is no coronally without cuspal coverage Temporary highly destructive,
crown time consuming
universally accepted restorative proto- • Direct restorations, which provide
col, it is generally agreed that the aim cuspal coverage Direct quick, low cost, readily
composite splint available and non-invasive
of restorative therapy is to immobilise • Indirect restorations placed intra-
the segments of the tooth that move on coronally without any cuspal support
loading. The latter may be achieved in and indirect restorations which provide crack propagation but also relieve the
a limited number of cases simply by the cuspal coverage (onlays and full associated symptoms.3
removal of the affected cusp and restoring coverage restorations). However, it has been argued that sim-
the defect with an appropriate material, or ply grinding the tooth out of occlusion
in the majority of cases by the placement The aim of this article is to review the is likely to be only of limited benefit as
of a restoration that prevents independent available literature on the above restora- the tooth may still be critically stressed
movement of the tooth segments on either tions when used to treat cases of cracked by a food bolus to such an extent that
side of the crack, thereby ‘splinting’ the cusp syndrome, with emphasis placed the process of flexure will still continue
tooth together.1 on the efficacy, efficiency, economic on loading.4 Furthermore, occlusal adjust-
The process of splinting should minimise viability and biological cost of each of ment may not only involve the removal
flexure of the compromised cusp, therefore the above. of healthy sound tooth tissue, but when
not only aiming to alleviate the symptoms undertaken without analysing the effects
of pain on biting but also prevent further IMMEDIATE THERAPY OF CTS on the residual dentition may also lead to
It is generally accepted that the more rap- unwanted occlusal interferences elsewhere
idly a tooth with a crack is treated, the in the dental arch.
1,
Senior Clinical Teacher; 2General Dental Practitioner
and Clinical Teacher, 3*Professor and Consultant in easier it will be to avoid irreversible dam- Fox et al.5 have recommended that fol-
Restorative Dentistry, Department of Primary Dental age. Table 1 provides a list of the pos- lowing a positive diagnosis of a cracked
Care, King’s College London Dental Institute, Bessemer
Road, London, SE5 9RW sible immediate treatment options. As tooth where a pre-existing restoration is
*Correspondence to: Professor B. J. Millar an ‘immediate’ or remedial approach a present, it should be removed to assess
Email: brian.millar@kcl.ac.uk
number of authors have advocated the the full extent of the fracture. Often dur-
Refereed Paper undertaking of occlusal adjustments upon ing this process the affected cusp may
Accepted 25 March 2010
DOI: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2010.496 affected teeth, to reduce the stress on the ‘splinter off’ and the remaining defect
© British Dental Journal 2010; 208: 503–514 tooth, so as to not only prevent further managed accordingly.

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010 503

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

Where there has been no splintering off way. The placement of such restorations
the affected portion of the tooth, immedi- while effective are however, time con-
ate immobilisation by means of an ‘imme- suming, biologically invasive and costly.
diate extra-coronal circumferential splint’ Furthermore, rarely in the opinion of the
may be applied. The latter may take the authors is it possible to prepare a tooth to
form of a copper ring or a stainless steel receive a full coverage provisional crown
orthodontic band, both of which should when a patient first presents with CTS on
be tight fitting, contoured to not interfere the same appointment. It is worthwhile
with the occlusion and cemented using noting however that any delay in institut- a
zinc-polycarboxylate cements.6 ing immediate therapy may lead to further
It is generally agreed however that stain- progression of the fracture and in the worst
less steel orthodontic bands are the pre- scenario culminate in tooth loss as well.
ferred option, as they can be contoured A novel concept which has yet to be
more effectively so as to inflict less irrita- fully supported by a clinical trial is the
tion/damage to the gingival/periodontal placement of bonded composite resin
tissues. Upon review, following a period directly over the surface of the tooth to
of two to four weeks after the application splint across the fracture and immobi-
of the immediate splint, the absence of lise the segments (Fig. 1). The splinting
pain has been described to indicate not method is used by all the authors and is b
only a correct diagnosis but also success- referred to as a ‘direct composite splint’
ful immobilisation.7 Where symptoms of (DCS). It can be used with minimal tooth
thermal sensitivity persist, endodontic reduction of the functional areas of the
therapy may need to be considered.7 In occlusal surface but the authors now prefer
such cases, the splint may remain in situ to use it as a non-invasive splint with no
until the completion of root canal therapy tooth reduction, creating a flat splint in a
and the eventual application of the defini- supra-occlusal position. Resin composite is
tive restoration. applied to a thickness of 1.0-1.5 mm over
While the placement of copper rings and the occlusal surface of the affected tooth,
stainless steel bands have been suggested and finished just beyond the external line c

to be a clinically effective, minimally angles of the affected tooth. The restora-


invasive and a cost effective immediate tion should be contoured to display the
treatment modality for teeth affected by absence of occlusal contacts in either lat-
cracked tooth syndrome,7 in the opinion of eral or protrusive mandibular movements
the authors, the technique of placing the (which may require the addition of resin
latter may be time consuming and techni- composite to guiding teeth).
cally challenging. Furthermore, with the The above approach of placing a res-
advent of adhesive dentistry, many dental toration in supra-occlusion follows the
operators may not have acquired the tech- principles of the well documented Dahl
d
nical experience needed with the place- concept 9-11 whereby it would be expected,
ment of copper rings; indeed, copper rings in cases other than those with limited erup- Fig. 1 A tooth with amalgam restoration
and a mesial crack (a). Air abrasion was
may not always be readily available in the tive potential, that through the combined used to augment micro-mechanical
modern general dental practice. Likewise, process of dento-alveolar segment intru- retention (b) and a direct composite
many general dental practitioners may sion and extrusion respectively, occlusal splint was placed in supra-occlusion (c)
without any tooth preparation which is
not have the technical expertise or ready contacts would be re-established after a
designated as an immediate option for the
access to stainless steel orthodontic bands. suitable period of time. management of an incompletely fractured,
Discomfort associated with the application A DCS has the potential, in theory, to be symptomatic lower right second molar
of copper rings and their tolerance may used as both an immediate and intermedi- tooth. (d) demonstrates the importance
of ensuring that the splinted tooth is free
be other complicating factors. In addition ate restorative option. It has the potential
of occlusal contact on mandibular lateral
patients may object to the aesthetics where of being biologically conservative, aes- excursive movement
the band is visible. thetic, efficient to apply, reversible and an
The preparation and placement of full inexpensive restorative modality, which
coverage acrylic provisional crowns has also offers the potential to offer imme- literature review has been published by
been described by Gutherie et al.8 as a diate pain relief and assist in diagnosis Poyser et al.12 documenting the principles
predictable, ‘immediate splinting’ option (particularly where there may be doubt). of the Dahl concept.
for the management of incompletely frac- However, careful case selection and the A DCS may also be used before the
tured teeth. Preformed crowns of differing attainment of patient consent are very application of an adhesive onlay (Fig. 2),
varieties may also be applied in a similar important factors to consider. A detailed where the desired inter-occlusal space for

504 BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

the definitive restoration may be accom-


plished by the process of controlled intru-
sion and extrusion of the dento-alveolar
segments. The application of DCS restora-
tions does however require considerable
further research to validate its application
in every day dental practice.

THE USE OF DIRECT/PLASTIC c


INTRA-CORONAL RESTORATIONS
(WITHOUT CUSPAL COVERAGE)
TO TREAT CASES OF CTS
Dental amalgam
(conventional/bonded)

Dental amalgam, composite resin and


glass-ionomer cements are among three
a d
of the most commonly used plastic, direct
restorative materials in contemporary den- Fig. 2 An example of a case where a
tal practice. In principle, their use intra- fractured tooth (a) is treated initially with
a provisional direct supraocclusal splint
coronally in the management of cases of
shown in (b) before the definitive gold
CTS (in the absence of any splintering) is adhesive onlay has been placed, initially in
based on their ability to attach themselves supra-occlusion, and now shown at three
to the areas of tooth tissue located either month review where the occlusal contacts
have re-established (c, d)
side of the fracture and thereby prevent
independent movement of either fragment
upon loading. In doing so, it would be
hoped that these materials would restore
the fracture strength of the tooth equiva-
lent to that of a sound caries free tooth.13
Longitudinal studies on the performance
of extensive amalgam restorations have
confirmed amalgam’s success as a direct,
b
plastic restorative material.14,15.However,
the fact that dental amalgam lacks intrin-
sic adhesive potential would infer that it
would have little effect on ‘binding’ frac- suffering from CTS that had been managed examples of direct composite resin used
tures or restoring fracture resistance unto by the application of bonded amalgam to restore fractured teeth. In Figure 3 con-
teeth affected by CTS (without the need of restorations, bonded using Panavia EX ventional tooth reduction was carried out
auxiliary retentive aids). (Kuraray, Japan).19 before composite placement. Figures 4 and
It has been shown that fresh dental Panavia EX is a chemically active resin 5 show cases where only minimal reduc-
amalgam can be bonded to etched enamel that bonds to both enamel and metal.20 tion was carried out and the composite
and dentine with an ‘adhesive liner’,16 Bonds strengths of 8.8-14.2 MPa have was placed at the original vertical dimen-
hence the concept of the ‘bonded amal- been reported to develop between etched sion. Figure 6 shows a similar case with
gam restoration’. Two case reports have enamel and Panavia EX,19 versus that of no occlusal reduction where the composite
been published involving the successful 18-20 MPa between composite resin and resin was placed in supra-occlusion.
application of bonded amalgam restora- etched enamel. The results of in vitro studies regarding the
tions for patients presenting with CTS. In vitro studies have reported the fracture ability of resin composite to restore cuspal
The first, a single clinical case involving strength of molar teeth containing bonded stiffness are conflicting in outcome; while
the use of ‘Amalgabond’;17 the adhesive amalgam MOD restorations to be signifi- some have reported little marked improve-
agent present in Amalgabond contains cantly higher than when compared to con- ment23 others have shown that the place-
4-META (4-methacryloxylethyl-trimelli- ventional MOD amalgam restorations.21,22 ment of composite resin restorations has the
tate anhydride). 4-META has been shown potential to restore fracture strength, and in
to have the capacity to bind with colla- Directly bonded resin composites some cases to a level superior to that of a
gen fibrils present in the organic compo- Composite resin offers an aesthetic alterna- healthy, un-prepared tooth.24
nent of dentine and to metallic ions.18 The tive to silver amalgam for the restoration Opdam et al.25 investigated the short term
second case report included four patients of posterior teeth. Figures 3-6 illustrate clinical efficacy of bonded (direct) composite

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010 505

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

a d

Fig. 3a Illustrates the same case as in


Figure 1 and is an example of a tooth
with CTS which has been managed by
the means of a direct resin composite
onlay and a conformative approach. (b) b e
illustrates the case immediately post-op
and (c) is three years post-operatively Fig. 4 Illustrates an example of a tooth
with amalgam restoration and cusp
fracture (a). Following the removal of
the existing amalgam restoration (b)
resin when placed intra-coronally for the the fracture line is visible (see arrows),
treatment of 21 painful, cracked teeth. The the occlusal surface has been reduced
authors concluded that direct composite resin by 0.5 mm and a bevelled finish applied
circumferentially (c). Resin composite has
restorations without cuspal coverage can be been applied using an incremental ‘build-up
effective in treating cases of CTS (75% of technique’ (d). A pre-operative silicone
cases reported alleviation of symptoms when matrix can also be used to fabricate the
occlusal anatomy of the restoration. A
verbally questioned). Opdam et al.26 have
c direct placement supraocclusal restoration
also published a report in 2008, document- (DCS) has been placed in supra-occlusion
ing the results of a seven year evaluation of with minimal tooth preparation, which may
the efficacy of direct composite resin when be retained as an intermediate restoration
in the short to medium term (e)
used to restore painful cracked teeth (pre-
viously containing amalgam restorations).
The results of the latter study displayed an
annual failure rate of 6%.
It has been postulated that in the absence to effectively splint the tooth.26 The latter secondly due to the presence of a pre-exist-
of cuspal coverage, repeated loading of the effect may be exaggerated in cases of CTS ing fracture, cuspal flexibility would have
restoration or residual tooth tissue may by two factors; firstly, CTS is often seem already been increased when compared to
stress the ‘adhesive layer’ and ultimately among patients who display parafunctional a healthy un-fractured, sound tooth, plac-
lead to its breakdown, with the concomi- grinding habits who would be more likely to ing further greater strain on a progressively
tant failure of the ability of the restoration apply higher loads to the restored tooth, and weakening adhesive layer.

506 BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

It has been reported that resin bonded


composites (and bonded amalgam restora-
tions) are less effective in restoring fracture
resistance where cavities are greater than
half of the intercuspal width (without the
use of cuspal coverage).23 The incremental
application of composite resin to a cav-
ity (versus bulk placement) also has a sig-
nificant impact on improving the ultimate
fracture resistance of a restored tooth.27
Polymerisation shrinkage is a factor
commonly cited as an important cause for
the higher reported failure rate associated
with large composite resin restorations.28
Shrinkage may also cause the flexion of
the cusps towards the bulk of the material
which may further accentuate the fracture,
a c
and also induce stresses in the material
and the adhesive layer, which would in
turn lead to the failure of the ability of the
material to immobilise the crack.
The feature of polymerisation shrink-
age may, however, be vital to the suc-
cess reported for direct resin composite
onlays, as it may help to splint the crack by
effectively embracing the cusps together,
d
as polymerisation shrinkage will cause
the material to shrink towards the cen- Fig. 5 Amalgam removed (a) and tooth
tre of the restoration and add up to the prepared with minimal cuspal reduction
(b), then restored with direct composite
bonded surface.29
resin (c) at correct occlusal height and at
Other factors which should also be taken review (d)
into consideration when considering the
application of resin composite in poste-
b
rior teeth include, the risks of restoration
bulk fracture and accelerated wear. The
attainment of high quality proximal con-
tact points and occlusal anatomical form (cermets), however, have been reported to complete a complex composite resin res-
may also be a concern when using direct restore prepared teeth to a strength equiva- toration compared to similar amalgam res-
composite. lent to that of sound teeth or those restored torations,33 it still takes less time than to
with resin composite.31 The poor aesthetics complete an indirect restoration. All too
Glass ionomer cements (GICs) associated with cermets is a concerning often, where a patient has had to return
The role of glass ionomer cements (GICs) in factor. following a diagnosis of an incomplete
the management of cases of incompletely GICs may have a role to play in the man- fracture for the preparation of an indirect
fractured posterior teeth to the knowledge agement of cases of CTS as base materi- restoration, the fracture may have pro-
of the authors has not been extensively als under extensive direct composite resin gressed to the pulp or culminated in the
documented. It has been suggested that fillings thereby reducing the volume of loss of an extensive amount of the tooth.
while GICs have the capacity to increase resin required and the associated levels of According to a leading authority,
tooth stability among teeth with class polymerisation shrinkage.32 cracked teeth should be considered to be
II posterior cavities, they offer a lower In summary, direct plastic restoratives at an increased risk of pulpal complica-
bond strength to both enamel and den- (bonded amalgam and resin composite tions (in particular, where there has been
tine when compared to resin composite.30 restorations), when applied without cus- thermal sensitivity);26 the preparation of
Furthermore, due to their inferior wear pal coverage to manage cases of cracked such teeth to receive indirect restorations
and fatigue properties (compared to silver tooth syndrome, have the potential to would not only result in the loss of more
amalgam and composite resin), they are provide a conservative, cost effective and sound tooth tissue but necessitate the use
not the first choice of material for applica- time efficient option to the use of indirect of a provisional restoration. Both the lat-
tion in stress bearing posterior cavities.30 alternatives. While it has been proposed ter factors will increase the risk of pulpal
Silver reinforced glass ionomer cements that it takes 2.5 times longer to place and complications.

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010 507

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

a b c

Fig. 6 A cavity showing amalgam removed and crack visible (see arrow) on distal margin (a). The tooth was restored without cusp reduction
and directly placed composite as a supraocclusal composite splint. (b) shows immediate post-op view and (c) is three years post op

It has been reported by Gutmann et al.34 in cold sensitivity was observed to occur in end of the observation period, a survival
that approximately one fifth of all teeth the group treated by the means of bonded rate of 100% was elucidated; all 21 cases
diagnosed with cracked tooth syndrome amalgam overlays following a two week reported the elimination of symptoms of
will eventually require endodontic ther- post-operative period (while the baseline thermal sensitivity and pain on biting
apy; furthermore the prognosis of endo- levels for thermal sensitivity remained when asked verbally. Similar results were
dontically treated, cracked teeth appears unchanged for the non-bonded group). The published by Homewood.37
to be relatively poor. A study by Tan et latter observation may be accounted for by The application of resin composite over
al.35 reported a failure rate of 14.5% for the ability of the resin liner to seal patent the affected cusp in cases of CTS appears
cracked, root filled teeth after a relatively dentinal tubules, but also by the fact that to reduce the stress on the weakened cusp,
short evaluation period of just two years. the non-bonded group required 4 mm of possibly by a combination of factors such
Caution does need to be exercised when tooth reduction of the involved cusp (to as composite resin itself having some level
considering the use of either direct bonded accommodate the pin[s]) as opposed to 2 of ‘shock absorbing effect’25 by increas-
amalgams or resin composites for cavities mm for the bonded group, which may have ing cuspal stiffness and by re-distribut-
which are greater than half the intercuspal made a difference in the pulpal response ing occlusal loads away from the crack
width in cases of CTS,23 and perhaps among to cold. towards the axial walls and down the long
patients who display signs of bruxism. The results of both studies37,38 have indi- axis of the tooth. A reduction in the height
cated a possible role for amalgam over- of the affected cusp may also reduce its
DIRECT RESTORATIONS lays in the management of incomplete level of flexion upon loading, which may
WITH CUSPAL COVERAGE; fractures in posterior teeth (at least in the also help in the management of symptoms
DIRECT OVERLAYS/ONLAYS short term), particularly where a bonded but also reduce the stress on the adhesive
Direct amalgam overlays amalgam restoration is applied. layer, and thereby enhance the longevity
(conventional/bonded) of the restoration.
Directly bonded resin Figure 3 shows an example of a tooth
36
Hood et al. in 1991 reported that teeth composite onlays with CTS, which has been managed by the
restored with amalgam overlays had ‘frac- According to the results of an in vitro means of a direct resin composite onlay
ture energies equivalent to that of intact study, where premolar teeth were assessed and a conformative approach. Figure 3c
teeth’. Accordingly, Homewood37 has advo- for fracture resistance where composite has been taken of the same restoration,
cated the overlaying of the cusps of teeth resin restorations had been placed both three years post-operatively.
affected by CTS as a primary mode of with and without cuspal coverage, cases A success rate of 72.7% has been
treatment for such cases. The latter under- with cuspal coverage displayed a signifi- reported for teeth restored by means of
took an analysis to assess the perform- cantly higher fracture resistance.39 direct composite resin inlays/onlays (over
ance of conventional amalgam overlays The above was reflected in two clinical a period of 11 years); fracture, occlusal
for the management of cases with CTS, studies by Opdam et al.25,26 In both stud- wear and secondary caries were the prime
and reported a very high success rate (in ies, following the removal of the existing causes of failure.28 However, Bartlett et al.40
excess of 93%).37 amalgam restoration, the cusps of affected have contraindicated the use of direct (or
Davis et al.38 have also published the teeth (as opposed to the entire occlusal sur- indirect) composite resin for the treatment
results of a clinical study to compare the face) were reduced by 0.5-1.0 mm coro- of worn posterior teeth.
efficacy of conventional pin retained nally from the onset of the micro-crack In summary, it would appear that the
complex amalgam fillings versus bonded and the resulting cavity outline finished use of plastic materials (bonded amalgams
amalgam restorations. A similarly high with a bevelled margin (before the applica- and bonded resin composite) when placed
proportion of cases displayed resolution tion of direct composite resin). over the affected cusp in cases of cracked
of symptoms as reported by Homewood.37 In the more recent of the two studies, tooth syndrome seems not only to be time
Interestingly, the results of the study by cases that were included were evaluated and cost effective but also clinically suc-
Davies et al.38 showed a further reduction for a period of six to seven years.26 At the cessful in the alleviation of associated

508 BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

symptoms. Further studies are however painful, cracked teeth. Their application invasive, indirect restoration that has been
required to assess the long term efficacy is time consuming, sometimes necessitat- used to treat cases of cracked tooth syn-
of bonded amalgams in cases of CTS. ing the use of a provisional inlay (which drome’.46,47 Examples are illustrated in
Pulpal involvement does not appear to be may further accentuate the crack) and Figures 2 and 7.
a major issue either where direct overlays require the removal of healthy hard tissue Yap47 has presented a case report docu-
have been applied to manage CTS, which undercuts, which is biologically invasive. menting the application of a resin bonded
is a concern where indirect methods are Furthermore, a five year study by Wassell (adhesive) metal onlay for the management
used. Should endodontic therapy, however, et al.,43 when comparing the failure rates, of a patient presenting with CTS, involv-
be required where a plastic direct mate- wear rates and other aspects of clinical ing the placement a cast cobalt chromium
rial has been applied, the cost implications performance of direct composite inlays alloy (Degussa, Germany). The prepara-
are minimal and access to the pulp would versus conventional composite resin res- tion involved the reduction of the occlu-
be relatively straightforward, as opposed torations placed incrementally, revealed no sal surface by 1.0 mm over the functional
to in the presence of an indirect casting, significant statistical difference between cusps and 0.7 mm over the non-functional
which may need to be re-fabricated fol- the two forms of dental restorations. cusps; a shoulder design finish line was
lowing the completion of root canal ther- applied circumferentially, 1.2 mm beneath
apy (while the direct restoration may be INDIRECT RESTORATIONS the prepared occlusal surface. The resto-
readily repaired). WITH CUSPAL COVERAGE ration was reported to be in place for a
The prime concern with the applica-
(ONLAYS AND FULL/PARTIAL period of at least one year and the tooth
COVERAGE CROWNS)
tion of direct overlays is the level of tooth described to be asymptomatic. The use of
reduction, the need for considerable opera- While direct restorations placed intra- cobalt-chromium alloys on account of
tor skill and the longevity of these restora- coronally (without cuspal coverage) have a their extreme rigidity permits an ultra-
tions, particularly among bruxists. role in the management of cracked painful conservative preparation.
teeth, consensus opinion is that for wider The successful application of resin
INDIRECT RESTORATIONS cavities in particular, there is a need for bonded alumina abraded type III cast
Inlay restorations cuspal coverage to further protect and gold alloy onlays (luted with Panavia
(conventional and adhesive) strengthen the residual tooth structure.23 EX, Kuraray, Japan) to treat six cases of
The fabrication of direct restorations which CTS has also been described.46 In the lat-
Conventional intra-coronal inlay restora- provide cuspal coverage is considerably ter study, all affected teeth were prepared
tions utilise the concept of ‘wedge reten- demanding of operator skill; the longev- to accommodate metal to the thickness of
tion’, which has the potential of exerting an ity of direct plastic restorative materials 1.5-1.0 mm and restorative margins were
outward pressure on the tooth.41 Pressure may also be a concern. The remainder of finished on enamel tissue, with a ‘small
may be exerted not only upon trial of the this article will focus on indirect restora- chamfer’ placed 1-2 mm circumferen-
restoration (pre-cementation) but also dur- tions which provide cuspal coverage for tially below the prepared occlusal surface.
ing its functional lifespan, where cyclical the treatment of CTS. Restorations were evaluated for a mean
occlusal loads are applied. Consequently, service period of 48 months; no failures
conventional inlays have absolutely no ONLAY RESTORATIONS were noted.
role in the treatment of cases of CTS. Conventional/adhesive metal onlays Figure 7 shows an incompletely frac-
With an increase in the demand by den- tured symptomatic lower molar tooth
tal patients for more aesthetic, predict- The procedure for the preparation of a which has been restored by the application
able posterior tooth restoratives, ceramic tooth to receive a conventional cusp cov- of a gold adhesive onlay. The tooth has
inlays and indirect composite inlays have ered gold onlay has been meticulously been prepared to receive a cast type III gold
become commonplace in contemporary described and has been advocated for the adhesive onlay; the occlusal surface has
dental practice as an alternative to direct conservative management of damaged been reduced by 1.0-1.5 mm and a cham-
composite resin. occlusal surfaces of posterior teeth.44 While fer margin applied circumferentially. This
To the authors’ knowledge, to date there historically they have been widely used for cast gold overlay was conformative and
have been no reports published document- the management of CTS, there appears to fitted to the existing vertical dimension.
ing the efficacy of adhesive aesthetic (resin be little clinical data to document their The use of type III or type IV cast gold
or ceramic inlays) for the treatment of CTS. effectiveness in this application. alloys offer the merits of favourable wear
An in vitro analysis has shown that bonded The advent of newer generation dentine characteristics, ease of casting and finish-
MOD ceramic (Cerec) inlays and laboratory bonding systems and the availability of ing, high corrosion resistance and ease of
fabricated indirect resin bonded composite low viscosity chemically active cements burnishing.46 The formation of an oxide
inlays have the potential to increase the to bond tooth structure to either metals, layer on the fit surface of gold alloy adhe-
fracture strength of human molar teeth ceramic or composite resin, has paved the sive onlays by heat treatment at 650°C for
with wide cavities to values of similar way for restorations which may be used ten minutes or tin plating is thought to
strength to that of sound, healthy teeth.42 to treat dental conditions in a very ‘mini- increase adhesion with the chemically
The use of adhesive inlays may only mally invasive manner’.45 The adhesive active resin lutes.48
have a limited role in the management of metal onlay ‘is an example of a minimally The adhesive onlay restoration quite clearly

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010 509

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

a d

e i

c f j

Fig. 7 (a) shows an incompletely fractured symptomatic lower molar tooth, (b) shows the presence of a canine guided occlusion despite
marked canine wear. (c) shows that the tooth has been prepared to receive a cast type III gold adhesive onlay with the occlusal surface
reduced by 1.0-1.5 mm and a chamfer margin applied circumferentially. (d) shows the bonded metal onlay restorations in situ. (e) shows
the upper molar tooth with a leaking posterior composite restoration and this tooth has also been prepared (f) to receive an adhesive onlay
restoration (g) with occlusal contacts shown in (h). Canine guidance is shown in (i) and this was modifed by the addition of resin composite to
ensure posterior disclusion upon lateral excursive movements, to provide protection to the recently placed restorations (j)

offers the advantage of being biologically prognosis of endodontically treated, frac- onlay restorations is also economically
conservative of tooth tissue. Additionally, tured teeth is relatively poor.35 costly and time consuming. The use of
it would also be reasonable to presume that The application of provisional adhesive adhesive metal onlays is also contra-indi-
trauma to the pulpal tissues (which would metal onlay restorations may, however, cated among patients who display signs
result from the process of tooth preparation) be challenging, as may be the presence of poor motivation and plaque control
would be less likely from the effects of less of close proximal contact points, where it respectively, where there are high aes-
invasive tooth preparations (than would be may be necessary to extend the prepara- thetic demands and where there is the
the case from more aggressive tooth reduc- tion beneath the contact area.47 The prepa- poor availability of tooth enamel at the
tions). It has been well documented that the ration and placement of metal adhesive restorative margins.47

510 BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

The placement of metal adhesive onlays coverage restoration. The application of an value. However, their application is time
in supra-occlusion may be a possible vari- indirect ceramic would also necessitate the consuming (even with single visit restora-
ation on the approach adopted by Chana et use of a provisional restoration. The need tions) and costly.
al.,46 permitting a possible ‘ultra-conserv- for a provisional restoration in cases of Of particular concern to the present
ative approach’ to treat CTS (utilising the CTS has been postulated to increase the authors is the high biological cost in terms
well documented Dahl concept), although risk of pulpal complications.25 of occlusal surface reduction, which may
it is imperative that a positive diagnosis is However, with the advent of contem- be concomitantly associated with a higher
derived, and careful case selection under- porary computer aided design/computer risk of irreversible pulpal damage (than
taken where the placement of a restoration aided manufacturing (CAD/CAM) systems, may be the case with a metal adhesive
in supra-occlusion has been planned. such as Cerec (Sirona, USA), it is possible onlay preparation). The need to undertake
Figure 2 illustrates a case where a gold to complete a restoration in one visit. The endodontic treatment may not only com-
adhesive onlay has been placed initially advantages of a CAD/CAM porcelain par- promise the longevity of the affected tooth,
in supra-occlusion for a tooth which has tial onlay restorations in cases of CTS, in but also require re-making of the ceramic
been affected by an incomplete fracture. particular where acute thermal symptoms onlay prosthesis. The latter is not only eco-
The occlusal contacts have re-established are present according to Griffin1 include, nomically costly, but will also involve the
by the three month review. This is in agree- the absence of irritation from temporary further loss of healthy tooth tissue.
ment with studies where crowns are inten- fabrication and cementation, reduced risk
tionally fitted high to avoid the need for of salivary and bacterial ingress from less Indirect bonded resin
occlusal reduction.10 than ideal provisional restorations (which composite onlays
may show signs of fracture, leakage or The bonded indirect composite onlay res-
Ceramic onlays displacement) and the absence of pulpal toration offers an alternative treatment
(conventional/CAD-CAM) stresses from a second visit which would option to the use of either direct composite
The ability to etch and bond ceramic include restoration ‘try-in’, cementation, onlays or ceramic onlays in the treatment
materials to tooth enamel offers a possi- further tooth desiccation and bacterial of CTS. Indirect composite onlay restora-
ble aesthetic alternative to the use of metal exposure or possible hand-piece trauma. tions have been shown to be effective for
onlays. With the advent of more recent A report has been published describing the treatment of painful, cracked teeth.49
leucite reinforced ceramics it has been two cases of CTS which were successfully Depicted by Figure 8 is an example of a
possible to fabricate all porcelain resto- managed for a period of at least two years symptomatic fractured, vital posterior tooth
rations with a higher fracture resistance post restoration by the application of CAD/ which has been restored by the means of
and increased flexural and compressive CAM generated partial coverage bonded an indirect resin composite onlay. Note the
strengths respectively.2 porcelain onlays.1 It is important to note need for a more aggressive level of tooth
Liebenberg 2 has published a report that though that many practitioners may not reduction, when compared to the prepara-
describes the protocol for the fabrication of have ready access to CAD/CAM facilities; tion for a tooth to receive a cast adhesive
‘partial coverage porcelain onlays’ to treat furthermore the inability to use ‘layer- gold onlay, as shown by Figure 7.
cases of cracked, painful teeth. The use of ing techniques’ culminates in restorations Deliperi et al.50 state that in compari-
such restorations is claimed to be very which may not carry optimal aesthetic son to direct composite resin onlays, the
effective in the treatment of CTS based value. Technique sensitivity is a feature indirect technique allows for restorations
on anecdotal evidence of treating several commonly seen as a drawback to the use which have more favourable anatomical
cases over a period of at least five years.2 of CAD/CAM manufacturing systems. form, a more accurate occlusal prescription
Tooth preparation to receive the above While dental porcelains can be used to and more predictable proximal contact
form of restoration essentially involves produce restorations of a high aesthetic anatomy. It has been well documented that
the reduction of the weakened cup by 2.0 value, their property of low critical strain the feature of polymerisation shrinkage is
mm, followed by the placement of a cham- in tension culminates in a relatively brit- a major drawback associated with the use
fer/rounded shoulder of 2 mm in width tle material which may display signs of of direct composite restorations. The latter
applied just beneath the prepared occlusal fracture with little or no plastic deforma- complication is largely negated with the
surface(s).2 Emphasis has been placed on tion. Processing flaws within the material use of indirect techniques (as much of this
the presence of enamel around the entire substructure may also lead to eventual takes place extra-orally); however, polym-
peripheral margin and accurate prepara- cracking. Occlusal adjustments of ceramic erisation shrinkage occurring at the level of
tion/impression making. restorations may initiate micro-fractures, the resin lute may still feature. According
The use of ceramic onlays clearly involves render the exposure of unglazed ceramic to Wendt,51 on account of a higher level
a greater level of tooth reduction than that (which may cause wear of the opposing of polymerisation conversation attain-
advocated for the placement of metal adhe- dentition) and repair of ceramic restora- able with indirect methods, such restora-
sive onlays. As discussed above, this would tions may be challenging. tions can be expected to display improved
culminate in a preparation approach that Porcelain bonded partial coverage mechanical and physical properties such
is less biologically conservative than that onlays offer a more conservative alterna- as strength and wear resistance.
for the preparation for an adhesive metal tive to full coverage restorations for the When compared to bonded porcelain
onlay, yet less invasive than that for a full management of CTS, with high aesthetic onlays, both form of restoration require the

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010 511

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

same level of tooth reduction. However, form of restoration may represent a suc-
indirectly bonded resin composite onlay cessful method of treating incompletely
restorations offer the merits of ease of fractured posterior teeth.
repair (with direct materials) and adjust- Indirect resin composite onlays appear
ment respectively. They are also less abra- to have a role in the management of
sive towards opposing occlusal surfaces. CTS. They can provide an effective treat-
The potential to add direct composite may ment option and can overcome many of
be crucial in cases of CTS, where loss of the drawbacks associated with the use of
a
vitality may precede the cementation of directly bonded composite onlays. While
the definitive restoration, as the latter their placement requires more tooth prepa-
can be readily repaired post-endodontic ration, they are more conservative than
therapy, without the need for a remake. full coverage restorations and offer the
Furthermore, the indirect composite onlay potential for effective repair. Cost and
will continue to serve its purpose as a time factors, together with the need for
splint, while root canal therapy is being temporisation, are obvious disadvantages.
undertaken (particularly in cases where Caution may need to be applied when con-
b
treatment may be more than one visit). sidering their placement among patients
Indirect composite onlays have been who display signs of tooth wear.40 Fig. 8 An example of a symptomatic
fractured, vital posterior tooth (a) with a
shown to display a greater capacity mesial fracture (see arrow) which has been
to absorb compressive loading forces, Full coverage crowns restored by the means of an indirect resin
thereby reducing the impact force on the Based on their observation that cracks on composite onlay (b)
underlying tooth structure by 57%, when posterior teeth typically extend from the
compared to dental porcelain. The latter occlusal incline to the cervical third of the
property is thought to be accounted for clinical crown, Gutherie et al.8 have advo- The efficacy of full coverage acrylic
by the lower elastic modulus presented by cated the use of full coverage crowns to be provisional crowns in the management of
composite resin. A reduction in the load the most appropriate form of restoration to cases suffering from CTS was evaluated
transmitted to a fractured flexible tooth manage cases of cracked tooth syndrome. by Gutherie et al.8 A failure rate of 11%
is critical in preventing further progress It has been argued that the resistance form was reported; all of the failures required
of the crack. Brunton et al.49 showed that provided by a full coverage restoration endodontic therapy.
premolar teeth restored by the means of enables occlusal forces to be distributed In a more extensive study, where 127
composite onlays exhibited higher levels over the entire prepared tooth, thereby cases of posterior teeth with cracks with
of fracture resistance than equivalent teeth minimising stresses which would otherwise concomitant symptoms of reversible
restored with ceramic onlays. be relayed to the crack; while the reten- pulpitis were restored with full cover-
It would appear that the weak link tion form of the crown through the process age definitive crowns, a staggering 21%
associated with the use of indirect of frictional contact and by the action of of cases were reported failed within the
resin composite restorations is the resin the cement lute helps to splint the tooth first six months of evaluation; all cases
based lute.50 fragments, thereby minimising their inde- required subsequent root canal therapy.53
Signore et al.52 have published the results pendent movement when occlusal forces Cases with single marginal ridge fractures
of a six year retrospective study describing are released.8 (either mesial or distal) were reported to
the clinical performance of bonded indi- A modified preparation to the con- be more likely to be in need of endodontic
rect composite onlays for the treatment of ventional full coverage preparation (for treatment. The proportion of teeth (with
43 cracked, painful teeth. For cases where either a full veneer preparation or that CTS) with the subsequent need of further
cavity widths were less than half the dis- for a metallo-ceramic crown) has been endodontic therapy 8,53 is significantly
tance from the central fossa to the cusp described, which is thought to reduce the higher following the application of full
tip, only the involved cusp was reduced; functional stresses applied to the fractured coverage crowns than among those cases
for larger cavities, complete cuspal cover- segments.56 These modifications include: a which have been splinted by other restora-
age was undertaken. All cavities were first further reduction of the involved cusp with tive means as described above.
pre-restored with a directly bonded resin the application of a subsequent bevel, the Various studies have reported the loss
composite, followed by a reduction by 1.5- avoidance of the placement of boxes and of vitality following the application of full
2.0 mm of the occlusal surface; all margins grooves on or adjacent to the fractured coverage single unit crowns to be in the
were placed on sound enamel and usu- aspects of the tooth, placement of margins range of 15 to 19%.54,55 Loss of pulpal vital-
ally placed supra-ginigivally. Onlays were more apically (which will improve bracing ity is an obvious problem following the
cemented using a 3-step total etch system of the crown by the surrounding tooth), the preparation of teeth to receive the latter
with the use of a dual cured low viscos- use of adhesive core materials, the use of form of restoration; the problem appears
ity composite cement (Variolink, Ivoclar, thicker die spacers to permit the fabrica- to be further compounded in cases of CTS,
Vivadent). A favourable survival rate of tion of a passively fitting restorations and where reversible pulpitis would generally
93.02% was reported, suggesting that this the use of low viscosity cements. be an already pre-existing condition. It has

512 BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

been reported by Tan et al.35 that endo- restorations, cost and time factors are also future. Br Dent J 2005; 198: 669-676.
13. Geurtsen W, Garcia-Godov F. Bonded restorations
dontically treated, cracked teeth have a obvious drawbacks to the use of conven- for the prevention and treatment of the cracked
relatively poor long term outlook. tional indirect restorations. tooth syndrome. Am J Dent 1999; 11: 266-270.
14. Plasmans P J, Breugers N H, Mulder J. Long term
In cases where root canal treatment is Adhesive metal and indirect resin com- survival of extensive amalgam restorations. J Dent
indicated following the application of a posite onlays may in time show some Res 1998; 77: 453-460.
15. Van Nieuwenhuysen J P, D’Hoore W, Carvahlo J,
definitive crown, this may necessitate the level of considerable promise for improv- Quist V. Long term evaluation of extensive
remaking of the crown which further adds ing the prognosis of teeth affected by CTS, restorations in permanent teeth. J Dent 2003;
131: 395-405.
to the cost of the procedure. The prepa- and form excellent definitive, long term 16. Staninec M, Holt M. Bonding of amalgam to tooth
ration of teeth to receive full coverage restorative options for the treatment of structure: tensile adhesion and microleakage tests.
J Prosthet Dent 1988; 59: 397-402.
crowns is also time consuming. teeth affected by this condition, in par- 17. Trushkowsky R. Restoration of a cracked tooth
ticular where affected teeth may have been with a bonded amalgam. Quintessence Int 1991;
SUMMARY 22: 397-400.
intruded by ultra-conservative restorations 18. Ueno Y. A clinical evaluation of adhesive amalgam
A number of definitive different restora- placed in supra-occlusion. A more biologi- lining with 4 META/MMA TBB adhesive resin
without anaesthesia. J Jpn Soc Adhes Dent 1989;
tions/restorative techniques have been cally conservative tooth preparation will 73: 181-189.
described for their respective use to treat without doubt help to prolong the longev- 19. Bearn D, Saunders E, Saunders W. The bonded
amalgam restoration – a review of the literature
posterior teeth affected by CTS. However, ity of the tooth but also help to prevent and report of its use in the treatment of four cases
there is only very limited clinical evidence irreversible pulpal damage. of cracked tooth syndrome. Quintessence Int 1994;
25: 321-326.
available in the dental literature to sub- Of the limited data available, it would 20. Omura I, Yamauchi J, Harada I, Wada T. Adhesive
stantiate the use of any of them. be fair to conclude that direct restora- and mechanical properties of a new dental adhe-
sive. J Dent Res 1984; 62: 233.
The prognosis of a tooth affected by tions with cuspal coverage, in particular 21. Eakle W S, Staininec M, Lacy A M. Effect of bonded
CTS is determined by three principal fac- bonded composite restorations appear to amalgam on the fracture of teeth. J Prosthet Dent
1992; 68: 257-260.
tors, hence: the extent and location of the be the most beneficial when considering 22. Oliveira J P, Cochran M A, Moore B K. Influence
fracture, the point in time when restora- prognostic outcome of teeth restored for of bonded amalgam restorations on the fracture
strength of teeth. Oper Dent 1996; 21: 110-115.
tive intervention is initiated and thirdly the purposes of incomplete posterior tooth 23. Geurtsen W, Orth M, Gartner A. Fracture resistance
by the type of restoration applied to splint fractures.25,26 Furthermore, their application of human maxillary molars with MOD amalgam
or composite fillings. Dtsch Zahnarztl Z 1989;
the fracture. is cost effective, efficient and they also 44: 108-110.
The prognosis of teeth involved by permit an aesthetic outcome with limited 24. Ausiello P, DeGee A S, Rengo S et al. Fracture
resistance of endodontically treated premolars
CTS, where the presenting cavity is not damage inflicted upon the dental pulp.26 adhesively restored. Am J Dent 1997; 10: 237-241.
in excess of one half of the bucco-lini- However, the placement of direct composite 25. Opdam N J, Roeters J J. The effectiveness of bonded
composite restorations in the treatment of painful,
gual width when restored by the means of onlay restorations is very dependent upon racked teeth: six month evaluation. Oper Dent 2003;
directly bonded plastic restorations with- operator skill, and furthermore, some level 28: 327-333.
26. Opdam N J, Roeters J J, Loomans R A, Bronkhorst
out cuspal coverage, appears to be reason- of tooth preparation is still required. E. Seven year clinical evaluation of painful, cracked
ably acceptable. The preparation of teeth teeth restored with a direct composite restoration.
1. Griffin J. Efficient, conservative treatment of J Endod 2008; 34: 808-811.
to receive such restorations is biologically 27. Weiczkowski G, Joynt R B, Klockowski R et al. Effects
symptomatic cracked teeth. Compendium 2006;
conservative, with the subsequent loss 27: 93–102. of incremental versus bulk fill technique on resistance
2. Liebenberg W H. Partial coverage indirect tooth to cuspal fractures of teeth restored with posterior
of pulp vitality not being an associated composites. J Prosthet Dent 1988; 60: 283-288.
coloured restorations; steps to clinical success.
primary concern. The prognosis of root Am J Dent 1999; 12: 201–209. 28. Van Dijken J W V. Direct resin composite inlays/
3. Agar J R, Weller R N. Occlusal adjustments for onlays: an 11 year follow up. J Dent 2000;
filled cracked teeth in the longer term 28: 299-300.
initial treatment and prevention of cracked tooth
appears poor.35 syndrome. J Prosthet Dent 1988; 60: 145-147. 29. Stavridakis M M, Kakaboura A I, Ardu S, Krejci I.
4. Hiatt W H. Incomplete crown-root fractures in Marginal and internal adaptation of bulk filled
According to a leading authority, teeth class I and cuspal coverage direct resin composite
pulpal periodontal disease. J Periodontol 1973;
affected by CTS should be initially restored 44: 369-379. restorations. Oper Dent 2007; 32: 515-523.
5. Fox K, Youngson C C. Diagnosis and treatment of the 30. Hoffman W, Just N, Haller B, Hugo B, Klaiber B. The
by means of bonded direct restorations as a effect of glass ionomer cements or composite resin
cracked tooth. Prim Dental Care 1997; 4: 109-113.
means of immediate/intermediate therapy; 6. Geurtsen W. The cracked tooth syndrome; clini- bases on restoration of cuspal stiffness of endodn-
cal features and case reports. Int J Periodontics tically treated premolars in vitro. Clin Oral Investig
where an indirect restoration is indicated 1998; 2: 77-83.
Restorative Dent 1992; 12: 395-405.
from the outset, such a restoration should 7. Ehrmann E H, Tyas M J. Cracked tooth syndrome: 31. McCullock A S, Smith B G N. In vitro studies of
diagnosis, treatment and correlation between cuspal reinforcement with adhesive restorative
only be placed after having managed the symptoms and post-extraction findings. Aust Dent J materials. Br Dent J 1986; 161: 450-452.
immediate symptoms.25,26 1990; 35: 105-112. 32. Krejci I, Lutz F, Krejci D. The influence of different
8. Gutherie G C, Difiore P M. Treating the cracked base materials on marginal adaptation and wear of
Conventional full coverage crowns and tooth with a full crown. J Am Dent Assoc 1991; conventional class II composite resin restorations.
conventional onlays have been utilised as 122: 71-73. Quintessence Int 1988; 19: 191-198.
9. Dahl B, Krogstad O, Karlsen K. An alternative treat- 33. Roulet J F. Benefits and disadvantages of tooth
a historical gold standard for the above ment of cases with localised attrition. J Oral Rehabil coloured alternatives to amalgam. J Dent 1997;
purpose.57 With the former, the copious 1975; 2: 209-214. 25: 459-473.
10. Hemmings K W, Darbar U R, Vaughan S. Tooth wear 34. Gutmann J L, Rakusin H. Endodontic and restorative
loss of tooth tissue and high risks of loss treated with direct composite restorations at an management of incompletely fractured molar teeth.
of pulp vitality respectively are major increased vertical dimension: results at 30 months. Int Endod J 1994; 27: 343-348.
J Prosthet Dent 2000; 83: 287-293. 35. Tan I, Chen N N, Poon C Y, Wong H B. Survival of
concerns, which may impart a consid- 11. Gerasimidou O. Tooth mobility, movement and root filled cracked teeth in a tertiary institution. Int
erable negative effect on the prognostic symptoms caused by occlusal changes. PhD Thesis. Endod J 2006; 39: 886-889.
King’s College London, 2009. 36. Hodd J A A. Biomechanics of the intact, prepared
outcome of teeth affected when treated by 12. Poyser N J, Porter R W J, Briggs P F A, Channa H S, and restored tooth; some clinical implications. Int
such an approach. The need for provisional Kelleher M G D. The Dahl concept: past, present and Dent J 1991; 41: 25-32.

BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010 513

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved


PRACTICE

37. Homewood C I. Cracked tooth syndrome – inci- composite inlays versus conventional composite res- report. Oper Dent 2009; 30: 143-150.
dence, clinical findings and treatment. Aust Dent J torations: 5 year follow up. J Dent 2000; 28: 375-382. 51. Wendt S L Jr. The effect of heat used as secondary
1998; 43: 217-222. 44. Rosenstiel S F, Land M F, Fujimoto J. Contemporary cure upon the physical properties of three com-
38. Davis R, Overton J. Efficacy of bonded and non- fixed prosthodontics, 3rd ed. pp 230-261. posite resins. II. Wear, hardness and color stability.
bonded amalgams in the treatment of teeth Mosby, 2001. Quintessence Int 1987; 18: 351-356.
with incomplete fractures. J Am Dent Assoc 2000; 45. Behle C A. Conservative direct and indirect resin 52. Signore A, Benedicenti S, Covani U. Ravera G. A 4
131: 496-478. posterior restorative alternatives for racked denti- to 6 year retrospective clinical study of cracked
39. Fennis W M, Kuijs R H, Kreulen C M, Verdonschot N, tion. Pract Periodontics Aesthet Dent 1997; teeth restored with bonded indirect resin composite
Creugers N H. Fatigue resistance of teeth restored 9: 405-413. onlays. Int J Prosthodont 2007; 20: 609-616.
with cuspal coverage composite restorations. Int J 46. Chana H, Kelleher M, Briggs P, Hopper R. Clinical 53. Krell K, Rivera E. A six year evaluation of cracked
Prosthodont 2004; 17: 313-317. evaluation of resin bonded gold alloys. J Prosthet teeth diagnosed with reversible pulptitis: treatment
40. Bartlett D, Sundaram G. An up to 3 year random- Dent 2000; 83: 294-300. and prognosis. J Endod 2007; 33: 1405-1407.
ized clinical study comparing indirect and direct 47. Yap A U J. Cuspal coverage with resin bonded metal 54. Saunders W P, Saunders E M. Prevalence of
resin composite used to restore worn posterior onlays. Dent Update 1995; 22: 403-406. periradicular periodontitis associated with crowned
teeth. Int J Prosthodont 2006; 19: 613. 48. Tanaka T, Atusuta M, Nakabayashi M, Masuhara E. teeth in an adult Scottish subpopulation. Br Dent J
41. Shillingburg H T, Hobo S H, Lowell D W, Jacobi R, Surface treatment of gold alloys for adhesion. 1988; 185: 137-140.
Brackett S. Fundamentals of fixed prosthodontics, J Prosthet Dent 1988; 60: 271-279. 55. Cheung G S, Lia S C, Ng R P. Fate of vital pulps
3rd ed. pp 171–180. Quintessence Publishing, 1997. 49. Brunton P A, Cattell P, Burke F J T, Wilson N H F. beneath a metal ceramic crown or a bridge retainer.
42. Roznowski M, Bremer B, Geurtsen W. Fracture resis- Fracture resistance of teeth restored with onlays Int Endod J 2005; 38: 521-530.
tance of human molars restored with various filling of three contemporary tooth-coloured resin- 56. Casciari B J. Altered preparation design for cracked
materials. In Moermann W H. Proceedings of the bonded restorative materials. J Prosthet Dent 1999; teeth. J Am Dent Assoc 1991; 130: 571-572.
international symposium on computer restorations. 82: 167-171. 57. Christensen G J. The cracked tooth syndrome: a
pp 559–566. Chicago: Quintessence, 1991. 50. Deliperi S, Bardwell D N. Direct cuspal coverage pragmatic treatment approach. J Am Dent Assoc
43. Wassell R W, Walls A W G, McCabe J F. Direct posterior resin composite restorations: a case 1998; 124: 107-108.

514 BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 208 NO. 11 JUN 12 2010

© 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved

You might also like