Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By
HARITHA D
A PROJECT REPORT
Submitted to the
of
in
OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE
HARITHA D, who carried out the work under my supervision. Certified further that
to the best of my knowledge the work reported herein does not form part of any other
project report or dissertation on the basis of which a degree or award was conferred
Certificate of Viva-voce-Examination
Name: Name:
Designation: Designation:
Address: Address:
Name :
Designation :
Address :
Date:
iv
ABSTRACT
Management decided to find the cause of productivity loss. One of the major cause found by
them was time wastage. Hence they decided to work on this. They monitored were the time was
wasted and found that time was wasted due to lack of resources, errors, machinery default,
transportation and time wasted by employees. It was decide by the board to reduce the wastage.
On viewing the factors it was concluded that the time wastage by employees can be reduced with
limited amount of money. Hence it was analyzed and concluded that the time wastage was more
due to non productive activities and breaks taken by team members. The only way to monitor
employee data was through time sheets filled by employee, swipe in/out, biometry and pulse tool
but only employee presence can be monitored through these process.
Hence management decided to find a solution and decided to redesign the process. Business
Process Reengineering involves the radical redesign of core business processes to achieve
dramatic improvements in productivity, cycle times and quality. First, they redesign functional
organizations into cross-functional teams. Second, they use technology to improve data
dissemination and decision making. A tool which can be used by all process was designed and
managers were given permissions to use the tool and monitor the complete activities of team
members. The managers were selected because the complete process/projects are handled by
them, so they will be able to find exactly where the time wastage occurs and also they will
handle the data in secured way. Initially the redesigning was carried out in a team which has less
members. This was initially implemented in 2 projects and results were successful, after which it
was implemented in few more projects.
v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to thank a number of people who have helped and supported me in
completing my project work. At the outset, I am very grateful to theCoordinator, Centre for
Distance Education, College of Engineering Guindy (CEG), Anna University, Chennai - 25
for providing the encouragement andmotivation to take up this project.
HARITHA D
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
NUMBER TITLE NUMBER
ABSTRACT iv
LIST OF TABLES viii
LIST OF FIGURES ix
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 RESEARCH BACKGROUND 1
1.2 PROBLEM IDENTIFIED 5
1.3 NEED FOR THE STUDY 5
1.4 OBJECTIVES & SCOPE OF STUDY 6
1.5 SCOPE OF STUDY 7
1.6 DELIVERABLE 7
2 LITERATURE SURVEY
2.1 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 8
2.2 RESEARCH GAP 13
2.3 SUMMARY 13
3 METHODOLOGY
3.1 INTRODUCTION 14
3.2 DATA REQUIREMENT 19
3.3 RESEARCH INSTRUMENT 19
3.4 SAMPLING FRAMEWORK AND SAMPLING SIZE 20
3.5 LIMITATIONS 20
3.6 TOOLS FOR ANALYSIS 20
3.7 DATA PRESENTATION 23
vii
CHAPTER PAGE
NUMBER TITLE NUMBER
5 CONCLUSIONS
5.3 CONCLUSIONS 45
APPENDIX 46
REFERENCES 48
viii
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
The research topic namely “Study on Business Process Re engineering to improve the
Productivity with reference to an organisation” is a study conducted at Capgemini Technology
Services India Limited, Chennai. In this study researcher has analyzed that how utilization of
time(allocated working hours) correctly helps to improve the productivity. Monitoring the idle
time of employee, the time wasted by employees on breaks , involving themselves in online
activities and accessing applications which are not related to work helps to utilize the correct
timing and process the requests on time.
In all companies, attendance is calculated by swipe in swipe out, time sheets, biometric device
and smart location based time and attendance tracking system using android application. But the
time wasted by each employee is not monitored. Human resource work is to recruit the employee
as per requirement, deploy them at site, calculate the attendance based on their presence using
the above methods. But they are not strong or don’t have much idea about entire process and
work carried out by each project. Only Engagement and operations manager will have a clear
picture about the process. They used a tool called pulse which had details about employee login,
logout and shift timings. They were able to view time wastage but did not have data to speak
with team members. Hence our company decided to implement a tool which monitors each and
every activity performed by employees , hence designed a tool which monitors each and every
activity performed by employee and the activity report can be fetched by admin(i.e.Engagement
managers) from tool. With this report bi weekly meetings are conducted to reduce time wastage,
effective usage of time and improve the productivity. Hence usage of pulse by engagement
managers is redesigned and implemented a tool called prompt. This also helps to let the
managers know whether they are sharing any secured information to other companies as we were
given access to communicate with few companies related to work.
2
Capgemini Invent is Capgemini's premium management consulting and digital innovation brand.
Currently employing around 6,000 employees globally, Capgemini Invent was created in
September 2018 to encompass its old consulting brand, Capgemini Consulting, as well as other
recently acquired digital marketing agencies and innovation consultancies, including Fahrenheit
212, LiquidHub, Idean, Adaptive Lab, and Backelite, and is intended to provide end-to-end
digital transformation capabilities to CxOs of companies. Capgemini Invent is one of Europe's
biggest management consulting companies.
The Capgemini Group Executive Committee consists of 18 members. Paul Hermelin serves as
the Group Chairman and CEO. He joined Capgemini in 1993 and was appointed as its CEO in
2002. In May 2012, Hermelin became chairman and CEO of the Capgemini Group.He
succeeded Serge Kampf, who served as the Vice Chairman of the Board until his death on March
15, 2016.
3
Africa
Morocco
South Africa
Americas
Argentina
Brazil
Canada
Chile
Colombia
Guatemela
Mexico
United States
Asia Pacific
Australia
China
India
Japan
New Zealand
Phillippines
Singapore
Taiwan
Vietnam
Europe
Austria
4
Belgium
Czech Republic
Denmark
Finland
France
Germany
Hungary
Italy
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Norway
Poland
Portugal
Romania
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
United kingdom
Middle East
To meet its strategic objectives, the Company provides a range of services using appropriate
delivery models which are chosen to leverage its core competencies to deliver as per customer
needs. The Company provides these services in a variety of computing environments, using the
latest advancements in client/server architectures object oriented programming, distributed
databases and networking and communication technologies.
There are three strategic business units. While investigating why there was productivity loss it
was identified that the service is not delivered on time and there were errors. The management
investigated why this occurred and found that was non productive works were carried out during
working hours and the process was done in haste at the end. Hence they worked out on the issue
and found a way to fix this. Office hours is 9 hours, in that one hour is allocated for break.
Managers from each team were asked to monitor the employee activities in a team. Managers
could see that lot of time were wasted on non productive works because of which the WIs were
not processed on time in financial sector which is the starting step , other process are also
delayed as starting step had a delay. When it comes to IT, support team tickets were not handled
on time. Hence it was concluded that utilization of time is one of the reason for client
dissatisfaction, SLA breach and non delivery of projects on time. Hence they decided to do
Business Process reengineering. Pulse is an application which was used to check the employee
presence but it does not have an option to monitor the activities of employees, hence they
decided to redesign the process.
Internet. While computer applications have created many opportunities to improve productivity,
the prevalence of such computer applications has made it increasingly difficult to monitor
employee behavior. Historically, a manager could monitor productivity, as well as compliance
with policies and rules, through direct observation of work being per formed. Physical
observation is no longer effective, however, because, for example, many employees work from
home or from remote locations. Even where employees are physically present, it is not
convenient for a manager to monitor an employee's computer usage at all times. As a result, an
employee may covertly Surf the Internet, chat in Internet chat rooms, play computer games, or,
in worse cases, access forbidden files, violate company policies, or even commit crimes.
In order to calculate the ideal time, time wastage, productive and non productive works carried
out by employee, a tool is implemented, which captures all the work performed by employee in
the computer. Hence, if any non productive work is done or if the breaks are taken for a long
time employee can be questioned by the managers with the reports fetched from the tool which
shows the complete data of employee activity in computer. In subsequent meetings conducted by
managers of each department we could see drastic change in the output of the employee as time
is effectively used. Because of this productivity increases. Work given to employees are
completed on or before the SLA period which creates good impression among clients and leads
us to get new projects from same clients.
To reduce the idle time of employee in an organization and utilize the time effectively
which helps to complete the work on or before the deadline.
7
To monitor the employee activity , categorize it as productive and non productive work
and avoid non productive activities carried by employees.
To utilize the efficiency of the employee. and the productivity.
To improve standard of the organization. and achieve client satisfaction.
To meet its strategic objectives, the Company provides a range of services using appropriate
delivery models which are chosen to leverage its core competencies to deliver as per customer
needs. The Company provides these services in a variety of computing environments, using
the latest advancements in client/server architectures object oriented programming, distributed
databases and networking and communication technologies.
Time wasted by team members in a project by doing non productive activities is measured and
the way to effectively utilize the time is analyzed.
1.6 DELIVERABLE
The outcome of the study will help to know how the redesign or changes made in business
process activities helps in avoiding the time wastage and how productivity gets improvised
which will also lead to achievement of client satisfaction.
8
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE SURVEY
The business Process reengineering is a tool to achieve dramatic output for any business. The
main focus is controlling of the process related with time, where time has been more important
element to control the process. This paper has related to survey of a BPR tool used for dramatic
changes in the business[1]
Shermin Sultana1, Asma Enayet1 and Ishrat Jahan Mouri1 designed aA SMART,
LOCATION BASED TIME AND ATTENDANCE TRACKING sYSTEMUSING
ANDROID APPLICATIONpublished in International Journal of Computer Science,
Engineering and Information Technology (IJCSEIT), Vol. 5,No.1
Over the years the process of manual attendance has been carried out which is not only time
consuming but also provides erroneous result. Automated time and attendance monitoring
system provides many benefits to organizations. This reduces the need of pen and paper based
manual attendance tracking system. Following this thought, we have proposed a smart location
based time and attendance tracking system which is implemented on android mobile pplication
on smartphone reducing the need of additional biometric scanner device. The location of an
organization has a specific location, which can be determine by the GPS. Each employee’s
9
location can be determined by the GPS using smartphone. This location is defined as a key of
time and attendance tracking in our paper [2]
Methods and Systems are provided for capturing usage data from a user computer, processing a
Subset of Such data to form output, and offering access to Selective views of Such output, Such
as to assist a company's management in monitoring computer usage in a work environment. The
output may be processed and viewed according to Software appli cation, device, or Specified
user. The output, or a report generated the refrom, may be accessible in differing degrees to
individuals having appropriate levels of permission[3]
Majed Al-Mashari, Zahir Irani, Mohamed Zairi in the study of Business process
reengineering : a survey of international experience – Business Process management
Journal, vol 7 No 5
Despite the widespread adoption of business process re‐engineering (BPR), it has in many
cases repeatedly failed to deliver its promised results. The lack of integrated implementation
approach to exploiting BPR is seen as one of the important reasons amongst others, behind
BPR failures. Yet, a relative void in the literature remains the scarcity of suitable models and
frameworks that address the implementation issues surrounding BPR. This motivates the
presented study to attempt to provide a “frame of reference” with which current practices can
be re‐positioned. A survey was therefore designed to collect data from a sample of
organizations in the USA and Europe. The survey assesses the level of importance placed on
the essential elements of integrated BPR implementation. In doing so, the study was also able
to identify the level of maturity of BPR concepts within organisations. Empirical findings are
then discussed in the context of other studies [4]
Abstract: A method and system for automatically collecting and for analyzing information about
time and work performed on a computer includes the following elements: data collector means
for monitoring certain portions of a user's computer activity; data collector means for logging
into a log file those certain portions of a user's computer activity; data analyzer means for
determining, by means of user-defined rules, which portions of those certain portions of a user's
computer activity constitutes continuous work activities and how this work should be categorized
by project and task with project; and external interface means for building the rules defining
work. The data collector means for monitoring certain portions of a user's computer activity
includes a resident module, such as a TSR (terminate-and-stay-resident) module, which extends
the file system of the computer so that detailed records are kept of file activities. The data
collector means for monitoring certain portions of a user's computer activity includes means for
routing information about file activity to the data collection means and includes
means for tabulating and writing such information to a user's disk periodically. The data collector
means for monitoring certain portions of a user's computer activity includes means for routing
information about keyboard activity to the data collection means and includes means for
periodically tabulating and writing such information to a user's disk [5]
As U.S. industries procure more high-skill labor to meet the need for custom goods and services,
reducing the cost and labor-time of such employees becomes absolutely essential for an
industry’s success. The high-skill labor needed to do custom work costs more than minimum
wage. Therefore, any reduction in labor-time spent turns into a significant cost savings for the
employer, a quicker response to the customer, and a greater capacity for work. Any improvement
plan to reduce the labor-time spent on a job must be checked to quantify the actual reduction.
Such a rapid and precise comparison demands a rapid and precise work measurement* tool. The
problem surfaces when an organization tries to find such a tool. The search often starts and stops
with a traditional time study*, more commonly known as the stopwatch and clipboard method.
Ever since the early 20th century, organizations have used this tool to time a manual labor
process. This report will discuss ways to decrease the chance of this failure so that the need for
11
custom work measurement can still be met. First, the report will specify barriers a traditional
time study faces in today’s custom, high-skill labor environment. After defining these barriers,
the best work measurement methods for addressing them will be discussed. The report will then
conclude with an easily referenced summary of these methods, so that an organization who
wishes to start a work measurement program can quickly choose the method that is best for their
situation. response to the customer, and a greater capacity for work [6]
Michael J. Earl, Jeffrey L. Sampler & James E. Short published the topic Strategies for
Business Process Reengineering:Evidence from Field Studies on 11 th Dec 2015 in Journal of
Management Information Systems
12
This paper reports on early results from case study research into the relationship between
business process reengineering (BPR) and strategic planning. First a framework for analysis is
proposed based on the concept of alignment. This "process alignment model" comprises four
lenses of enquiry: process, strategy, information systems, and change management and control.
Four case studies are then described, selected from a wider sample to demonstrate variation
across the four domains. A taxonomy of strategies for BPR is derived from the case studies. This
taxonomy suggests a richer variety ofBPR practice than has been documented to date and
provides an opportunity and platform for further research [8]
Peter O’Neill, Amrik S. Sohal from Department of Management, Monash University, P.O.
Box 197, Caulfield East, Vic. 3145, Australia gave Business Process Reengineering A review
of recent literature
The purpose of this paper is to help demystify the confusion on Business Process Reengineering
(BPR). This is achieved through a review of the literature covering the period from the late
1980s to 1998. Articles published in the leading business journals and the more popular business
magazines were included in the review, as well as books published on the topic. The paper first
discusses the need for reengineering and then reviews the literature under the following
headings: definition of BPR, BPR tools and techniques, BPR and TQM co-existence,
understanding organizational processes, the reengineering challenge, and organisational redesign
using BPR. The review shows that considerable confusion exists as to exactly what constitutes
BPR. Authors place different emphasis on the definition of BPR and the many outcomes possible
with BPR. The paper concludes with suggestions for future research [9]
Mohsen Attaran from School of Business and Public Administration, California State
University, Bakersfield, 9001 Stockdale Highway,Bakersfield, CA 93311-1099, USA
presented a paper on the topic Exploring the relationship between information technology
and business process reengineering
13
This study examines a series of relationships between information technology (IT) and business
process reengineering (BPR).Specifically, it argues that those aspiring to do business process
reengineering must begin to apply the capabilities of information technology. This paper
provides a summary of IT roles in initiating and sustaining BPR and examines several companies
that have successfully applied IT to reengineering. The paper also addressees barriers to
successful implementation of reengineering and identifies critical factors for its success [10]
The business Process reengineering is a tool to achieve dramatic output for any business. The
main focus is controlling of the process related with time, where time has been more important
element to control the process. In all the process/companies time wasted in breaks are alone
calculated but the time wasted during process or nonproductive works were not found and also
the work performed by employee in person are not monitored .
2.3 SUMMARY:
In this chapter detailed review has been discussed and it gives analysis on how Business
process re engineering helps the organization to increase the productivity and profit. The
following chapter describes methodology applied for this study.
14
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
3.1 INTRODUCTION
Research can be defined as “an activity that involves finding out, in a more or less systematic
way, things you did not know “Methodology is the philosophical framework within which the
research is conducted or the foundation upon . The framework which is associated with a
particular set of paradigmatic assumptions that we will use to conduct our research
Exploratory research, as the name implies, intends merely to explore the research questions and
does not intend to offer final and conclusive solutions to existing problems. This type of research
is usually conducted to study a problem that has not been clearly defined yet.
In order to determine the nature of the problem, exploratory research is not intended to provide
conclusive evidence, but helps us to have a better understanding of the problem. When
conducting exploratory research, the researcher ought to be willing to change their direction as a
result of revelation of new data and new insights
Exploratory research design does not aim to provide the final and conclusive answers to the
research questions, but merely explores the research topic with varying levels of depth. It has
been noted that “exploratory research is the initial research, which forms the basis of more
conclusive research.”
Exploratory research “tends to tackle new problems on which little or no previous research has
been done Unstructured interviews are the most popular primary data collection method with
exploratory studies. Exploratory studies can potentially save time and other resources by
determining at the earlier stages the types of research that are worth pursuing The differences
between qualitative and quantitative research to the distinction between exploratory (qualitative)
and confirmatory (quantitative) analysis. When there is little theoretical support for a
phenomenon, it may be impossible to develop precise hypotheses, research questions, or
15
operational definitions. In such cases qualitative research is appropriate because it can be more
exploratory in nature
Exploratory research is characterized by its flexibility. When a problem is broad and not
specifically defined, the researchers use exploratory research as a beginning step. Exploratory
studies are a valuable means of understanding what is happening; to seek new insights; to ask
questions and to assess phenomenon in a new light
Exploratory research has the goal of formulating problems more precisely, clarifying concepts,
gathering explanations, gaining insight, eliminating impractical ideas and forming proposition.
Literature research, survey, focus group and case studies are usually used to carry out
exploratory research.
FORMULATING PROBLEMS
CLARIFYING CONCEPTS
GATHERING EXPLANATIONS
GAINING INSIGHT
IMPRACTICAL IDEAS
FORMING PROPOSITION
LITERATURE RESEARCH
FOCUS GROUP
CASE STUDIES
16
ANALYSIS
FINDINGS
Technology
Consulting
Outsourcing
This reengineering is carried out inside the organization. Here we will be studying about how the
internal changes made, help the organization to increase productivity. Below flow chart describes
about employees inside the organization providing internal support and internal employees
working for client.
There are 90 clients. I have taken 2 teams to explain the process in flowchart and the explanation
of how it helps is shown in the flow chart below.
ALLIANZ
Process
Good receipt
PO NON PO Indexing and posting
Good receipt
Process
Literature research
Collection of data
Findings
PROCESS
Transition team
P1- 2 hours
Incident Management Team P2- 4 hours
P3- 24 hours
P4- 48 hours
Research instrument are the instruments which is used for gathering or collecting
information. The research instrument that was used for Primary data collection is a
Questionnaire. The questionnaire circulated is provided in the Appendix.
20
Data will be collected from organization using the tool designed. Since 90 projects are there, a
single client and support team is selected and 3-4 months data will be fetched from database and
discussion with team manager is done, based on which the research is carried out.
3.5LIMITATIONS
Out of 90 clients single project is taken, data collection and analysis is done for one
project.
3.6.1PERCENTAGE ANALYSIS
It is used to easily find relative differences in the data collected for the three tools.
This method is used for analysis of which tool is being used widely by the respondents and also
to determine the distribution of the number of projects in which the tool is used. The formula
used is given by below equation
21
A cause and effect diagram examines why something happened or might happen by
organizing potential causes into smaller categories. It can also be useful for showing
relationships between contributing factors. One of the Seven Basic Tools of Quality, it is
often referred to as a fishbone diagram or Ishikawa diagram.
One of the reasons cause & effect diagrams are also called fishbone diagrams is because
the completed diagram ends up looking like a fish's skeleton with the fish head to the
right of the diagram and the bones branching off behind it to the left.
Below figure shows the fishboneor Ishikawa or cause and effect diagram.
A decision tree is a decision support tool that uses a tree-like model of decisions and their
possible consequences, including chance event outcomes, resource costs, and utility. It is one
way to display an algorithm that only contains conditional control statements.Decision trees are
commonly used in operations research, specifically in decision analysis, to help identify a
strategy most likely to reach a goal.
22
Pareto Analysis is a statistical technique in decision-making used for the selection of a limited
number of tasks that produce significant overall effect. It uses the Pareto Principle (also known
as the 80/20 rule) the idea that by doing 20% of the work you can generate 80% of the benefit of
doing the entire job. Take quality improvement, for example, a vast majority of problems (80%)
are produced by a few key causes (20%). This technique is also called the vital few and the
trivial many
The Pareto Principle has many applications in quality control. It is the basis for the Pareto
diagram, one of the key tools used in total quality control and Six Sigma.
CHAPTER 4
DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
The questionnaire was prepared and the hard copy was circulated to all the
respondents for this study. Responses were collected over a period of two weeks. The entire
responses are available as hard copies. The respondents are selected from various departments
and with varying experience in their function. The summary of respondents is as below
Total of 20 users of varying experiences were surveyed and responses were collected.
Research is carried out based on the secondary data collected. Secondary data is collected from
the organization.
Below data is collected after BPR i.e after the tool implemented in the organization.
Below diagram shows how the tool works.
Below data shows the list of inactivities. In this the admin will be given rights to categorize the
productive and non productive works. In a project to give KT L2 level employee would be away
from the machine during that period skype will be away, those will be categorized as productive
25
as it is essential for the project where as if L1 is away that will be categorized as non productive
as he/she will not be given the privilege.
Type Task
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y CAM Manually Cash Application
Inactivit
y CAM Manually Cash Application
Inactivit
y Processing Non PO invoice
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y CAM Manually Cash Application
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Assistance to Other Teams
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Query handling
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Processing Non PO invoice
Inactivit
y Break
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Query handling
Inactivit
y Processing Non PO invoice
Inactivit
y Break
Inactivit
y Voluntary Separation (eNate submission)
Inactivit
y Break
Inactivit
y Customer Clearing
26
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Cash Application
Inactivit
y Customer Clearing
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Voluntary Separation (eNate submission)
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Processing Non PO invoice
Inactivit
y Break
Inactivit
y Processing Non PO invoice
Inactivit
y Transaction Audit(Per transaction)
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Query handling
Inactivit
y Transaction Audit(Per transaction)
Inactivit
y Outgoing Mail
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Weekly Payment
Inactivit
y Weekly Payment
Inactivit
y CO Local Collection
Inactivit
y Audit
Inactivit
y Email Query Solving/Query Handling – Major
27
Inactivit
y Training
Inactivit
y Weekly Payment
Inactivit
y Query handling
Inactivit
y Supervision
Inactivit
y Process PO Inv 3 way match
Inactivit Support Central workflow - Add supplier /Site with
y Bank
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Training
Inactivit
y Email Query Solving/Query Handling – Major
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Prepare Annual Budget file
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Supervision
Inactivit
y Training
Inactivit
y Daily Reports
Inactivit
y Indexing in Instream Regular/ Rush Invoices
Inactivit
y Indexing
Inactivit
y Supervision
all engagements cannot be taken for demonstration, I have taken an engagement similar to
Allianz process and fetched the data.
8 2
201 448
3 8 3 not_acceptable
201 448
3 8 4 not_acceptable
201 448
3 8 5 not_acceptable
201 448
3 8 6 target_value
201 448
3 8 7 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 5 ng
201 448
3 8 9 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 0 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 1 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 2 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 3 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 4 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 5 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 1 ng
201 449
3 8 7 target_value
201 449
3 8 8 not_acceptable
201 449
3 8 9 not_acceptable
201 450
3 8 0 target_value
201 450
3 8 1 not_acceptable
201 450
3 8 2 not_acceptable
201 450
3 8 3 not_acceptable
3 201 450 target_value
8 4
31
201 450
3 8 5 not_acceptable
201 450
3 8 6 not_acceptable
201 450
3 8 7 target_value
201 450
3 8 8 not_acceptable
201 450
3 8 9 not_acceptable
201 451
3 8 0 not_acceptable
201 451
3 8 1 not_acceptable
201 459
3 8 6 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 0 ng
201 456
3 8 9 not_acceptable
201 444
3 8 3 not_acceptable
201 432
3 8 0 not_acceptable
201 473
3 8 4 not_acceptable
201 483
3 8 7 not_acceptable
201 454
3 8 9 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 6 ng
201 473
3 8 5 not_acceptable
201 476
3 8 6 not_acceptable
201 544
3 8 0 target_value
201 522
3 8 1 target_value
201 463
3 8 6 not_acceptable
201 477
3 8 3 not_acceptable
3 201 475 not_acceptable
32
8 9
201 522
3 8 2 target_value
201 522
3 8 6 target_value
201 437
3 8 8 not_acceptable
201 464
3 8 3 not_acceptable
201 498 close_monitori
3 8 8 ng
201 530
3 8 2 target_value
201 481
3 8 2 not_acceptable
201 492
3 8 8 not_acceptable
201 498 close_monitori
3 8 9 ng
201 497
3 8 6 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 4 ng
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 3 ng
201 467
3 8 9 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 2 ng
201 535
3 8 0 target_value
201 485
3 8 7 not_acceptable
201 511
3 8 8 target_value
201 492
3 8 2 not_acceptable
201 499 close_monitori
3 8 7 ng
201 465
3 8 0 not_acceptable
201 519
3 8 5 target_value
3 201 498 close_monitori
8 5 ng
33
201 496
3 8 2 not_acceptable
201 526
3 8 9 target_value
201 493
3 8 2 not_acceptable
201 496
3 8 0 not_acceptable
201 494
3 8 5 not_acceptable
201 495
3 8 2 not_acceptable
Table 4.1.2 Number of Work items Processed
5450 is the target value. The value between 5000-5450 is acceptable as it can be achieved in 2
more days.
Values between 4980 and5000 are close monitoring.
Values below 4980 are not acceptable.
Below tabulation shows the data of 3 months before the implementation of the tool.
July(22
Non productive works days) August(23 days) September(20 days)
Break 2310 2415 2100
Usage of chrome 880 920 800
Online activities(Eshopping/ebilling) 120 150 120
Accessing personal mails 40 50 40
70%
70%
Inference
25% of respondents strongly agree and 65% of respondents agree that they are accessing
personal mails during working hours.
Q no 4 Do you use online websites for e-shopping, e-payment and surf other websites
Inference
10% of respondents strongly agree and 50% of respondents agree that they are involved in
online activities not related to work.
Strongly agree 0 0%
Agree 8 40%
Neutral 2 10%
Disagree 3 15%
Strongly disagree 7 35%
Total 20 100%
Table 4.2.5 Percentage analysis on whether everyone knows complete process in team
35% of respondents strongly disagree and 15% of respondents disagree that they are accessing
personal mails during working hours
Q no 6 Is the right person given rewards and are they recognized
Inference
40% of respondents strongly disagree and 10% of respondents disagree that the rewards are
going to the right person in team.
70%
Inference
45% of respondents disagree that they are completing tasks within SLA and 25% of the
respondents were neutral.
Q no 8 If your system activities are completely monitored will you control non productive
activities
Strongly agree 1 5%
Agree 2 10%
Neutral 14 70%
Disagree 3 15%
Strongly disagree 0 0%
Total 20 100%
Table 4.2.8 Percentage analysis on monitoring system activities controls non productive
activities
40
Figure 4.2.8 Analysis on monitoring system activities control non productive activities
Inference
70% of respondents were neutral as they were not sure whether this will work out or not.
Post this survey organization decided to redesign the process and implemented tool to monitor
the activity of team members.
Cause and Effect Analysis is a technique that helps you identify all the likely causes of a
problem.The diagrams you create with this type of analysis are sometimes known as fishbone
diagrams, because they look like the skeleton of a fish. The technique was developed by
professor Ishikawa in the 1960s.
41
In this case the major problem is productivity loss. When we tried to find the cause of it through
fish bone diagram, the major cause of it was wastage of time, proper KT was not given , SLA
breach etc. The above analysis gives clear picture of the causes. In order to sort out the problem
caused, we had gone for BPR where the result was great. The analysis is shown using pareto
chart.
42
A decision tree is a decision support tool that uses a tree-like model of decisions and their
possible consequences, including chance event outcomes, resource costs, and utility. It is one
way to display an algorithm that only contains conditional control statements.
INFERENCE:
From the decision tree it is inferred that increase in human resource and reduction on time
wastage are the main factors to be concentrated and worked upon. Increase in human resource
involves cost i.e salary should be given every month, but reducing time wastage involves
implementation cost alone. Hence this one is the best way to increase the productivity.
Pareto analysis is a formal technique useful where many possible courses of action are
competing for attention. In essence, the problem-solver estimates the benefit delivered by each
action, then selects a number of the most effective actions that deliver a total benefit reasonably
close to the maximal possible one
I have taken data of 3 months before carrying out business process reengingeening and afte
implementation of the this.
Pareto analysis is made, which is shown below.
Time was wasted on non productive activities. Below chart shows the time wasted clearly.
Engagement : Allianz- From July 2018 – September 2018(Before BPR)
Non Productive works July Aug Sept Time Time Cumulative Percentage
(22 (23 (20 wasted wasted
days) days) days) in before
mins BPR in
hours
Break 2310 2415 2100 6825 113.75 113.75 69%
Usage of Chrome 880 920 800 2600 43.333 157.083 95%
Online 120 150 120 390 6.5 163.583 99%
activities(shopping/ebilling)
Accessing personal mails 40 50 40 130 2.17 165.753 100%
165.75
3
Before BPR
113.75 95% 99% 100%
100 100%
80 69% 80%
60 60%
43.333
40 40%
% of tim wasted
20 20%
Time wasted
6.5 2.17
0 0%
Percentage
After the business process reengineering there was drastic change which is shown below
Engagement : Allianz- From July 2018 – September 2018(Before BPR)
Non Productive works Oct Nov Dec Time Time Cumulativ Percentage
(23 (20 (21 wasted wasted e
days) days) days) in before
mins BPR in
hours
Break 1610 1200 1155 3965 66.083 66.083 78%
Usage of Chrome 460 200 105 765 12.75 78.833 93%
Online activities 230 0 0 230 3.8333 82.6663 98%
(shopping/ebilling)
Accessing personal mails 60 40 0 100 1.667 84.3333 100%
84.3333
INFERENCE:
From the above data it is inferred that165.753 hours were wasted by employees by doing non
productive activities. This is the data of single engagement.
After reengineering the process time wastage was bit reduced, in the upcoming months there was
a drastic change. Time wastage reduced to 84.3333
For few cases chrome will be used for analyzing those will be categorized as productive tasks by
admin while categorizing the work done.
Since the major cause of productivity loss is break below graph shows how BPR helped to
decrease time wastage
0
) ) ) ) ) )
ys ys ys ys ys ys
da da da da da da
22 3 0 3 0 1
ly( st(2 er(2 er(2 er(2 er(2
Ju gu b b b b
Au tem O cto vem cem
p De
Se Working days in month No
For one month 3240 additional work items and invoices are processed after redesigning the
process. This is for single engagement. For 40 engagements the result will be 129600.
When it comes to support teams number of ticket resolution increased drastically for a day an
average of 360 tickets were processed. After implementation of this 420 were processed and
results were fantastic. Two more application came to us in scope and transition is going on.
Chart of an Engagement
Undefined
13% Away
18% Non Productive
works
2% Away
Non Productive works
Productive works
Undefined
Productive works
67%
The above chart shows the complete engagement worked hours and the tasks done by them as a
whole.The undefined part is the task which is not been given any name or the task which is not
allocatedin any category by admin
Above chart is taken after BPR where the Away percentage and non productivity percentage is
reduced.
47
5000
4000
Number of WI's processed
3000
2000
1000
0
ke c
ka
a
M s
ks
sw s
ex s
s
La k
bu v
u
tu
pk vi
ad
po l
k
h
20
ka r
e
e
ke
s
n
ek
tri
iva
sz
tro
ish
vit
als
rth
h
pr
ro
ng
lo
ro
va
sh
um
att
rit
slu
pa
slo
Lin
ka
ca
Sh
Sh
kr
ca
User ID
CHAPTER 5
CONCLUSIONS
One of the major cause of productivity loss is time wastage .Effective utilization of time will
lead to productivity increase.
Conducting meeting without proper data will not create impact in teams. Proper tool or
methods should be used to monitor the activities of employees. With the biometric devices,
swipe in swipe out, smart location based time and attendance tracking and time sheets, only
employees presence and login/logout time is monitored. Time wasted during the process ,
time wasted by engaging themselves in non productive activity measured helps to increase
productivity.
HR department did not know the process followed by each employee.Tools existed were
used by HR department for employee management.
If existing yield is same or lesser than the target , then redesigning should be done to meet
the requirements and perform in an effective way.
Redesigning may not give positive results hence management decided to begin with single
team consisting of 30 members where the results were greater than the management’s
anticipation.Hence started implementing in rest of the team in financial sector across APAC
region. In this way it should be carried out step by step.
If team members have consciousness that they are been monitored by the person who is
strong in process, they will complete the work in a correct way and on time.
49
Redesigning a process should be started from the scratch. Each and every
departments activity should be noted , analysis should be made whether it will lead to
success.
Time wastage involved on breaks and involving themselves in non productive works
can be reduced and production can be increased by utilizing the working hours.
If Strong skilled person monitors- Errors can be reduced and on time delivery.
Managing Security in an enterprise by detecting periodic intervals events that
correspond touser interactions with computers connected to a network of the
enterprise,Storing Such events in a data facility,organizing the events by user, by
computer and by eventtype.
5.3 CONCLUSION
The Study found that redesigning the business process in proper way helps organizations growth
and increases the productivity by reduction of time wastage . This will also help to achieve
client satisfaction and acquire new projects.Monitoring the activities of team members reduces
security breach and reduction in errors.
The key requirement is that managers understand in detail the currentbusiness processes before
embarking on a BPR project.The application of IT can provide major improvementsin the
performance of business systems, and while considereda major part of the reengineering activity,
mustbe integrated with the needs of all stakeholders in mind. This tool is implemented only in
few sectors, this can be implemented in all departments for activity monitoring. Extra features
supporting the process can also be designed.
50
APPENDIX
SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
This survey is aimed at employees of Capgemini specialized in multiple domains at
different cadres to understand their views on productivity increase.
Name:
Organisation:
Department:
Designation:
51
By using the tool implemented we can monitor the following actions done by employee and
based on which the data is collected, time consumption by an employee and team as a whole has
been analyzed.
Email Chats/IM
Skype tracking
monitoring monitoring
Search
Websites Social network
keyword
monitoring monitoring
tracking
Files and Encoded
Clipboard
folders network traffic
monitoring
monitoring monitoring
The tool aggregates the following statistics: what applications were launched, what websites
were visited, and how much time these actions took in both – absolute and relative terms. This
will help you to analyze the real work time of your employees.
Actions blocking:
USB-
Website Application
devices
blocking blocking
blocking
52
REFERENCES
[2] Samali Violet Mlay, Irina Zlotnikova and Susan Watundu Makerere University Business
School,” A Quantitative Analysis of Business Process Reengineering and Organizational
Resistance: The Case of Uganda” Research Paper Volume X,Issue X, Month YYYY, ISSN
1936-0282
[4] Majed Al-Mashari, Zahir Irani, Mohamed Zairi in the study of Business process
reengineering : a survey of international experience – Business Process management Journal, vol
7 No 5 , 2005
[5] Sedrine, Adnane Ben. “Abstract of a Comparative Study of Work Measurment Software.”
Industrial Engineering and Mathematics Department, Université de Montréal, April 2005. pg 10,
11.
[6] Elliott, Richard. “Quantifying quality”. Industrial Engineer. Norcross: April 2005. Vol. 37,
Iss. 4, pg. 40, 45.
[7] Shermin Sultana1, Asma Enayet1 and Ishrat Jahan Mouri1 designed aA SMART,
LOCATION BASED TIME AND ATTENDANCE TRACKING sYSTEM USING ANDROID
APPLICATION (2015) published in International Journal of Computer Science, Engineering and
Information Technology (IJCSEIT), Vol. 5,No.1, February 2015
53
[8] Eric John Anderholm, La Crosse, WI Webrid published METHODS AND SYSTEMS FOR
MONITORING USER, APPLICATION OR DEVICE ACTIVITY(2005)-United states –Pub
no:US2005/ 0183143 A1
[9] Majed Al-Mashari, Zahir Irani, Mohamed Zairi in the study of Business process
reengineering : a survey of international experience – Business Process management Journal, vol
7 No 5 , 2005
[10] Mohsen Attaran from School of Business and Public Administration, California State
University, Bakersfield, 9001 Stockdale Highway,Bakersfield, CA 93311-1099,
USA(2004)presented a paper on the topic Exploring the relationship between information
technology and business process reengineering
[12] Michael J. Earl, Jeffrey L. Sampler & James E. Short published the topic Strategies for
Business Process Re engineering: Evidence from Field Studies on 11 th Dec 2015 in Journal of
Management Information Systems