Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Community College
Taylor Rainville
Pamela Shea
Table of Contents
Introduction......................................................................................................................................1
Literature Review............................................................................................................................2
Cultural Systems Approach.............................................................................................................3
Marketing........................................................................................................................................3
Behavioural Intentions....................................................................................................................4
Self and Social Signalling................................................................................................................4
Reinforcement..................................................................................................................................5
Method.............................................................................................................................................6
Participants.....................................................................................................................................6
Design..............................................................................................................................................7
Setting and Materials......................................................................................................................7
Measures.........................................................................................................................................7
Procedures.......................................................................................................................................8
Results -Analysis Strategy...............................................................................................................9
Survey..............................................................................................................................................9
Cano Co Data..................................................................................................................................9
Conclusion/ Discussion -Limitation (Ethical Issues)....................................................................10
Summary........................................................................................................................................10
Limitations.....................................................................................................................................10
Ethical Issues.................................................................................................................................11
Practical Application....................................................................................................................11
References......................................................................................................................................13
Appendix A: Information Letter....................................................................................................17
Appendix B: Consent and Survey for Cafeteria Staff...................................................................20
Appendix C: Cano Initiative Timeline..........................................................................................21
1
Using a Cultural Systems Approach to Increase the Use of Reusable Containers within a
Community College
There has been a growing realization that the consequences of human behaviour are a
significant driver for most environmental problems, specifically increasing levels of greenhouse
gases (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [IPCC], 2023). Human behaviours linked to
climate change include deforestation, burning fossil fuels, energy production, landfill/waste
disposal, and recycling (Erying et al., 2021 & IPCC, 2022). Landfill, aquatic landfills, and waste
disposal methods have led to the waste breakdown that has contributed to more than 20% of
methane emissions and 35.6 million tons of waste in 2018 alone (Yilmez et al., 2021; Anderson,
2017 & Statistics Canada, 2022). Increasing methane levels is the greatest contributor to climate
change, meaning this is a significant problem and the fastest opportunity for humans to slow the
rate of global warming (Environmental Defence Fund, 2023). Understanding and targeting
human behaviour that could potentially reduce environmental negative impacts can lead to a
for achieving environmental sustainability in various settings (Gladman & Thina, 2018). PEB is
any behaviour that could help reduce environmental harm (Lui et al., 2020 & Unsworth et al.,
2013). Cano Co, a reusable packaging company, has created an application to encourage
individuals to reuse hard plastic containers instead of disposable cardboard, increasing PEB.
Given that food packaging creates 50% of the waste collected in cities and it is projected that by
2050, food packaging will cause more than 15% of the global greenhouse gas emissions, Cano
through a cultural systems approach. Cultural systems approach is modifying cultural practices
contingencies (Mattaini, 2022). This approach provides a tool to understand the dynamics within
and between groups and social reinforcers maintained by these dynamics. Contingencies such as
marketing and reduction of effort level of consumers of reusable containers are important
networks. Increasing reinforcement through self and social signalling (engaging in behaviour
consistent with one’s own values), behavioural intentions (tendency to engage in behaviour
consistent with one’s own values) of consumers and increasing reinforcement for staff
implementing the container program create important contingencies which affect the culture of
This research aims to expand current literature surrounding the field of cultural-
behavioural science. The research will integrate behaviour science using a cultural systems
approach and Cano containers into a college community and examine if these principles increase
the pro-environmental behaviour of using reusable containers. The research will include
consumers of Cano containers. It is hypothesized that these strategies will increase the use of
Cano containers and reduce food packaging waste within the community college.
Literature Review
There has been an increase in research examining human behaviour's impact on climate
change. ICPP has stated that the globe is now 1.1 degrees warmer than 200 years ago, leading to
drastic environmental impacts such as glacier melting, droughts, high winds, and higher
organizations, such as ICPP, have been created to try and combat climate change and greenhouse
gas emissions, there is still a need for more research and information to support successful
behaviour change. It is important to consider how simple human behaviours can be altered to
create a larger impact. One strategy to examine how to change complex human behaviour is
A cultural systems approach provides strategies to understand and address larger social
challenges and cultural practices. Aspholm & Mattaini (2017) analyzed the behaviour systems
surrounding gang participation and found dynamics within and between groups including
histories of poverty, economic exclusions, racial denigration, and physical insecurity. The
authors went on to identify cultural practices in key community sectors that could used to change
these trajectories (Aspholm & Mattaini, 2017). Examining the behavioural contingencies within
the cultural systems provides opportunities to change cultural practices to create more pro-
contingencies such as rule governance, reinforcing and aversive contingencies, and motivating
operations requires targeting many systems or elements (Mattaini, 2020). Some of the tools
within behavioural science may be effective in addressing these such as: framing through
Marketing
The goal of marketing is seen by many as incompatible with the goals of sustainability.
Typically, marketing encourages growth and obtaining all our needs and wants (White et al.,
2019). Therefore, much literature focuses on ways consumers can still obtain these goals while
promoting a sustainable environment. Smith (2011) conducted a study to examine the use of
digital marketing with millennials to reach their target goals. The study found that graphics are
4
highly effective in grabbing millennial's attention (2011). The study found that Millennials
frequently visit a sight with incentives, such as a discount or reward (Smith, 2011). Another
Behavioural Intentions
Baca-Motes et al. suggest that using a commitment from the individual at the beginning
increases the chances of individuals staying committed (2013). Ajzen (2002) found that residual
impact of past behaviour is reduced when measures of intention are behaviour are compatible
and vanishes when intentions are well formed. There is research to support the effects of
behavioural intentions in many areas such as smoking, condom use, exercise, donating behaviour
Beliefs about what is socially appropriate and approved of in a given context can have a
powerful influence on sustainable consumer behaviors (White et al., 2019). Baca-Motes et al.
(2013) found that when people had to make brief but specific commitments and receive an
incentive to symbolize their commitment, they were 25% more likely to engage in the behaviour
modification.
Reinforcement
Typical behaviour is motivated by natural and artificial consequences. Hirsh et al. (2015)
discussed that engaging in pro-sustainable behaviour has the ability to be encouraged through
reinforcement. Bolderdijk et al. (2013) examined how PEB can be encouraged through a reward
and penalty system. Bolderdijk et al. (2013) was able to increase a natural reward by changing
and adding reinforcement to everyday actions. Adding these motivating factors, there is a
Food packaging negatively impacts the environment. Literature demonstrates that PEBs
can be increased within different populations and increase sustainable procedures. Research has
suggested that marketing, behavioural intentions, self and social signaling, and positive
reinforcement can increase PEB. It can thus be theorized that behavioural science strategies will
be used to address the complex and competing sets of behavioural contingencies surrounding
Method
Participants
This study will include students and staff currently enrolled at St. Lawrence College
(SLC). The college has approximately 6,700 full-time students and 20,000 part-time registrants
in 89 academic programs and employs 829 full- and part-time staff; this includes 414 faculty (St.
Lawrence College, 2023). Inclusion includes all individuals at the college site who voluntarily
Convenience sampling will be used within the survey research. Staff from the college
cafeteria will be asked to participate in this research through an email survey. Only staff at the
main Cafeteria will be included in this research. All other venues will be excluded. A survey link
will be sent out to all staff at Browns cafeteria. Responses to the survey will be voluntary,
providing a voluntary response sample. Incentives in the form of entering a draw for two $50
Informed Consent
An application will be sent to the St. Lawrence College Research Ethics Board (SLC-
REB) for approval to analyze the data and conduct the survey with staff. Student participant’s
6
data will be aggregated products (the number of Cano containers used) being analyzed and not
For the survey, formal consent will not be collected because this is deemed as providing a
higher risk related to collecting personal data on the consent form. Since the questionnaire is
anonymous, this will create no data risk. Before starting the survey, the cafeteria staff
participants will review the information letter (Appendix A). The information letter will provide
the participants with an overview of the purpose, risks, benefits, and procedures to maintain
anonymity and confidentiality. The participants can put their names into a lottery to win a $50
dollar gift card. The low cost of the prize is meant as an encouragement for participating but
needs to be larger to be coercive. Participants will be asked to click on a link and add their email
address to enter the draw. Thus, no personal identifiers will be on the survey. The emails will be
kept in a password-protected computer in a locked office until the draw, and then these emails
will be deleted.
Design
group design. The dependent variable to increase will be the number of Cano containers used. A
second dependent variable will be the amount of garbage produced. The independent variable
includes the three treatment conditions: marketing, behavioural intention, self/social signaling,
Materials needed will be the booth, media marketing items, Cano products, spinning
Survey Monkey will be used to create and collect information from the survey. The
survey will be sent out via email. A computer will analyze the weekly data collected from the
Cano Company.
Measures
Data on the amount of Cano containers used will be examined through the aggregated
data provided by the Cano Company. Data will be delivered daily via shared Excel files. Data on
Survey
A survey will be given to the cafeteria staff to gain insight into potential barriers to the
Cano procedures and potential reinforcers for staff (Appendix B). Open-ended and Likert scales
will be used. The 5-point Likert scale questions will consist of the following rank system: 1 = "I
do not like it" to 5 = "I like it very much". The questions will focus on the potential barriers and
reinforcers for the respondents. Descriptive stats and an analysis of common responses to open-
ended questions will summarize the data once collected. The results will help create effective
Procedures
Pending approval from the SLC-REB, the intervention will be conducted at a booth in the
cafeteria three times a week for two hours each time (Appendix C).
Baseline
The baseline will be collected in September (three weeks). After the baseline is collected,
Phase One
Phase one will last three weeks and include a booth to educate participants about the
Cano application. This will include showing participants how to download and operate the
8
application. As well as show them the reward system within the app. The participants will spin a
Phase Two
Phase two will last three weeks and consist of a booth to discuss the Cano application's
environmental impact. At the booth, there will be visuals to demonstrate the application's impact.
Garbage waste, air emissions, and financial savings will be demonstrated visually. Once a
participant wants to commit to being a climate champion, they will receive a “Climate
Champion” sticker for a water bottle to show they are an environmental champion, then have
their picture taken and posted on an environmental board to show their commitment to using
Cano containers.
Phase Three
The final phase will last three weeks and consist of a reinforcement system for the
cafeteria staff to promote the Cano containers. Staff will be educated on the importance of the
Cano project, and they will be asked to promote the Cano container by asking students, "Would
you like that in a Cano container?". Rates of Cano use will be posted on the staff bulletin board
with a goal number of Cano containers posted. If the staff can reach these goals by the end of
each week, the staff will earn a reinforcer. The survey results will inform the reinforcer.
Survey
The results will be expressed using descriptive statistics with graphs and tables
containing the mean, median, and standard deviation. Then, an analysis of common points within
Cano Co Data
Raw data will be collected automatically by the Cano Company in an Excel file. Then,
the data will be presented in a summary table with mean, median, and standard deviations. This
will be done for the baseline and intervention of three treatment phase results. The percent
increase in using Cano and the percent decrease in wastage will be calculated for each treatment
to determine the impact of the intervention. Data will then be displayed in figures. A bar graph
will be created with the total Cano use for each treatment phase, to demonstrate the changes in
data in each phase. A second bar graph will be created with the garbage use for each treatment
phase to demonstrate the changes in data in each phase. A line graph demonstrating the weekly
changes over time across each phase will include a visual analysis of levels of trend. This will
effectively show if the trend is increasing or decreasing while transitioning through the
intervention. Three unpaired t-tests for each of the conditions and the baseline will determine if
Summary
The research will integrate behaviour science using a cultural systems approach and Cano
containers into a college community and examine if these principles lead to an increase in the
pro-environmental behaviour of using reusable containers. The research will include conditions
increase consumers of Cano containers. It is hypothesized that these strategies will increase the
use of Cano containers and reduce waste within the community college.
The presented thesis will determine if integrating behaviour science using a cultural
systems approach can increase the use of Cano containers and decrease the use of food
10
packaging waste in a community college. Based on previous literature, PEB can effectively
reduce waste and greenhouse emissions. Many strategies such as reinforcement, behavioural
intentions, and social/self signally have yielded positive results and can easily be applied to a
systems-level approach to changing behaviour. Therefore, applying these approaches could help
participants regulate how they produce waste and help a small community do its part in cutting
methane emissions.
Limitations
There have been two limitations identified in this study. First, a group design in a college
community is generalizable to similar populations, such as other college campuses; however, this
cannot be generalized to other general populations. Second, within the large environment, there
Ethical Issues
Respect for persons is considered as this is a voluntary service to sign up for; therefore,
participants will be fully informed on the application and study being conducted. Concerns for
welfare are considered; participants' welfare is protected in all aspects, and there is no possible
harm to students or other participants within the community. It can be acknowledged that the
Browns staff may experience some discomfort during the survey, or intervention would lead to
anxiety. This will be mitigated by encouraging staff to come forward about concerns. Finally, the
participants' justice can be determined as the risks and benefits have been identified, and there is
a guarantee that the participants will not endure risks from this intervention, and many will find a
benefit. Along with the benefit to the environment and school community if the intervention is
successful.
11
Practical Application
target, as the benefits of waste reduction leave a lasting impact on the greater population. Using
the Cano application, in the long run, can help the individual and community financially and
community environment and these pro-environmental behaviours may generalize to other pro-
environmental behaviours. Lastly, this research has the potential for dissemination, which could
lead other communities to apply these concepts, creating a larger cumulative effect on the
environment. Overall, this research will be used to expand previous literature surrounding
sustainable solutions being integrated into communities to fight the climate crisis our world is
facing.
References
Anderson, K. (2017). Synthetic seas: The great pacific garbage patch. Hohonu, 15.
https://hilo.hawaii.edu/campuscenter/hohonu/volumes/documents/SyntheticSeasTheGreat
PacificGarbagePatch.pdf
Ajzen, I. (2002). Residual Effects of Past on Later Behavior: Habituation and Reasoned Action
https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327957PSPR0602_02
Aspholm, R. R., & Mattaini, M. A. (2017). Youth activism as violence prevention. The Wiley
https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119057574.whbva104
Baca-Motes, K., Brown, A., Gneezy, A., Keenan, E. A., & Nelson, L. D. (2013). Commitment
and behavior change: Evidence from the field. Journal of Consumer Research, 39(5),
1070-1084.
behaviour with rewards and penalties. In L. Steg, A. E. van den Berg, & J. I. M. de Groot
Cihon, T. M., & Mattaini, M. A. (Eds.). (2020). Behavior science perspectives on culture and
community. Springer.
de Leeuw, A., Valois, P., Ajzen, I., & Schmidt, P. (2015). Using the theory of planned behavior
128–138. https://doi-org.stlawrence.idm.oclc.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2015.03.005
Environmental Defense Fund (2023) Methane: A crucial opportunity in the climate fight.
https://www.edf.org/climate/methane-crucial-opportunity-climate-fight#:~:text=Methane
%20has%20more%20than%2080,by%20methane%20from%20human%20actions.
Eyring, V., N.P. Gillett, K.M. Achuta Rao, R. Barimalala, M. Barreiro Parrillo, N. Bellouin, C.
Cassou, P.J. Durack, Y. Kosaka, (Eds.), Climate change 2021: The physical science
Doi.10.1017/9781009157896.005
Granato, G., Fischer, A. R. H., & van Trijp, H. C. M. (2022). A meaningful reminder on
https://doi-org.stlawrence.idm.oclc.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2021.101724
Hirsh, J. L., Costello, M. S., & Fuqua, R. W. (2015). Analysis of Delay Discounting as a
Psychological Measure of Sustainable Behavior. Behavior and Social Issues, 24(1), 187–
202. https://doi.org/10.5210/bsi.v24i0.5906
IPCC, 2022: Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of climate change. contribution of working group
iii to the sixth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change [P.R.
(eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK and New York, NY, USA. doi:
10.1017/9781009157926
14
Liu, P., Teng, M., & Han, C. (2020). How does environmental knowledge translate into pro-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.138126
Monika Lisjak, Jonathan Levav, and Derek D. Rucker (2014), Compensatory consumption as
June Cotte, Stacy Wood, and , Duluth, MN : Association for Consumer Research, Pages:
156-162.
63). Springer.
Statistics Canada. (2020). Survey of Canada's Critical Public Infrastructure: Solid Waste and
Asset Management.
https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/221028/dq221028b-eng.htm
Smith, K. T. (2011). Digital marketing strategies that millennials find appealing, motivating, or
org.stlawrence.idm.oclc.org/10.1080/9065254X.2011.581383
Unsworth, K. L., Dmitrieva, A., & Adriasola, E. (2013). Changing behaviour: Increasing the
https://doi.org/10.1002/job.1837
15
van de Wetering, J., Leijten, P., Spitzer, J., & Thomaes, S. (2022). Does environmental education
https://doi-org.stlawrence.idm.oclc.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2022.101782
Webb, T. L., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Does changing behavioral intentions engender behavior
249. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.132.2.249
White, K., Habib, R., & Hardisty, D. J. (2019). How to SHIFT Consumer Behaviors to be More
22–49. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022242919825649
Yilmaz, M., Tinjum, J. M., Acker, C., & Marten, B. (2021). Transport mechanisms and emission
of landfill gas through various cover soil configurations in an MSW landfill using a static
111677.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2020.111677
16
Invitation
You are being invited to take part in a research study. I am a student in my 4th year of the
Honours Bachelor of Behavioural Psychology at St. Lawrence College. I am currently on
placement at St. Lawrence College with Sustainability. While I am at this placement, I am
completing an applied thesis research project as part of my college program. The information in
this form will help you understand my research. Please read the information carefully and ask all
the questions you might have before you decide if you want to participate.
If you choose to take part in the survey, you will have to answer five questions about your
opinions on the Cano application. Including possible barriers to promoting Cano. Click the link
provided at the bottom of this email. The link will take you to the survey. The survey will also
provide instructions to enter a draw to win a prize. The survey is expected to take no longer than
10 minutes maximum.
By participating you will help the school understand motives and barriers behind promoting
Cano. As well as feedback that we can use to help make promoting Cano more successful. Also,
by participating in this research you have the capabilities to improve future environmental
research. This will help the field of behavioural psychology expand into the area of
environmental change and other larger populations.
17
Although risks are minimal, responding to some of the questions may make you feel
uncomfortable. Everything remains anonymous so there is no data risk to the survey. If you wish
to be entered into the draw to win a prize your email may be noted for you to collect your prize.
If when filling out the questionnaire some of the questions make you feel uncomfortable, you can
skip the question. If you need to talk to someone, you may talk to myself, Jadon Hook
(Sustainability Coordinator), or my college supervisor Pamela Shea
Will the information you collect from me in this research be kept private?
Your privacy and confidentiality are important to us. We will take every reasonable step to keep
any information that identifies you confidential unless required by law. All survey results will be
stored on the placement student laptop in a secure folder for up to one year after the survey and
will then be deleted and destroyed. The results from the research are part of my thesis, and my
thesis will be made available at the St. Lawrence College library. The results will also be
presented at St. Lawrence College’s Behavioural Psychology Poster Gala, but any such
presentations will be of general findings and will never breach individual confidentiality.
Taking part is voluntary. It is up to you to choose whether you wish to participate in this research
or not. If you agree to take part, you will be asked to click the I consent box. Since this data is
anonymous, it is not possible to withdraw or remove the data collected up to the point of
withdrawal. Choosing not to participate at a later time won’t have any impact on your current job
at Browns Cafeteria. Data will be stored virtually on the thesis student’s computer for up to one
year after the survey has concluded. The data will then be permanently deleted. Anonymous data
will be used to provide information for the thesis. The thesis may be subject to review and
publications and could be used in a poster presentation and/or conferences.
This research has received ethical clearance from the Research Ethics Committee for
Behavioural Psychology (REC-P) under the authority of the St. Lawrence College Research
Ethics Board (SLC-REB). The project was developed under the supervision of Pamela Shea, my
supervisor from St. Lawrence College. Thank you for your consideration. If you have more
questions, feel free to ask me, Taylor Rainville, at taylor.rainville@student.sl.on.ca. You can also
ask my college Supervisor, Pamela Shea at pshea@sl.on.ca . If you have any worries about the
way this research is being conducted or about your rights as a participant, you may contact the
SLC-REB Chair at reb@sl.on.ca .
Consent
By clicking this box, I am acknowledging that I have read and understood the above information.
I understand that this survey is voluntary and anonymous.
I consent
18
The purpose of collecting this information is to provide insight into the education and motivation
behind the staff at Browns who are promoting Cano. This information will be used for my St.
Lawrence College dissertation, and any responses will remain anonymous within the report.
There will be no personal information or identifiable characteristics collected nor released
within the report. Thank you.
Have you heard of the Cano containers and system used at St. Lawrence College?
o Yes
o No
*If answer no educate staff on Cano and continue with questions.