Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This document is provided by the Canadian Standards Association (operating as "CSA Group") as a
convenience only.
In publishing and making this document available, CSA Group is not undertaking to render professional
or other services for or on behalf of any person or entity or to perform any duty owed by any person or
entity to another person or entity. The information in this document is directed to those who have the
appropriate degree of experience to use and apply its contents, and CSA Group accepts no
responsibility whatsoever arising in any way from any and all use of or reliance on the information
contained in this document.
Intellectual property rights and ownership
As between CSA Group and the users of this document (whether it be in printed or electronic form), CSA
Group is the owner , or the authorized licensee, of all works contained herein that are protected by
copyright, all trade-marks (except as otherwise noted to the contrary), and all inventions and trade
secrets that may be contained in this document , whether or not such inventions and trade secrets are
protected by patents and applications for patents . Without limitat ion, the unauthor ized use , modification,
copying, or discl os ure of this document may violate laws that protect CSA Group 's and/or others'
intellectual property and may give rise to a right in CSA Group and/or ot hers to seek legal redress for
such use , modification, copying , or disclosure. To the extent permitted by licence or by law, CSA Group
reserves all intellectual property rights in this document.
Patent rights
Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this document may be the subject of
patent rights. CSA Group shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights. Users
of this document are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any such patent rights is
entirely their own responsibility.
The List ID that you will need to register for updates to this publication is 2022158 .
Visit CSA Group's policy on privacy at www .csagroup .org/legal to find out how we protect your
personal information .
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11
Pressure regulators, overpressure
•
protection, meters, and fuel
•
containers
CSA
GROUP TM
To purchase standards and related publications, visit our Online Store at store.csagroup.org
or call toll-free 1-800-463-6727 or 416-7 4 7-4044.
ISBN 978-1-4883-2382-9
Contents
Overview .................................. ..................................... ..................................... ......................... 7
Purpose ......................... ................................. .................................................... ............ 7
Objective s .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ..... .. ... .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. ... .. .. 7
Gas trad e trainin g and Red Seal alignm e nt ............... ................................... ................. 7
Fuel containers ....... .. ............ .. ......... ....... ... .. .. . ...... ... .. .. ....... ....... ... .. .. ....... ... .... ....... ....... ... .. .. .. 107
Ove rview ...... ....... ....... ....... ....... ....... ..... .. ....... ............................................................. . 107
Cylinders , tanks , and accessori es ........ .............. ................................... ..................... 107
Sizing and installing cylinders and tank s ................................... ................................. 123
Appendix A: vapouri zation rates for tanks and cylinders ........................................... 133
Appendix B : Install ation clearances for tank s and cy linders ...................... ............... 135
Figures
Figure 1-1 - Propane installatio n ...................... ............................ ............................ ............... 12
Figure 1-2 - Natural gas installation showing loc ation of service regulat or and line pressure
regulators ....... ............... ....................................... ......................................... ....... 13
Figure 1-3 - Direct-operated regulator ............... ......................................... ............. ................ 14
Figure 1-4 - Graph depicting the performance of a typical regulat or ...................................... 17
Figure 1-6 - Regulator thre aded remova ble orifi ce ................................................................. 20
Figure 1-7 - Adjusting regulat or ................... ....................... ................ ..................................... 2 1
Figure 1-8 - Ve nt limiting orifice .......................................................... ....................... .............. 22
October 2019 1
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
2 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
October 2019 3
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Acknowledgements
The Manager , Gas Information Products , CSA , wishes to acknowledge the following individuals
who contributed as members of a review panel during the development of the original edition of
these materials . In addition, British Columbia Institute of Technology (BCIT) is acknowledged for
its work in the technical development and editing of the original edition.
Individual Organization
Frank Boone Apprenticeship Gas Technician Instructor ,
NSCC
Barry Bowman Instructor,
Conestoga College
Joel Crook JTAC/U .A. Local 787
Eli DiCredico Coordinator, Engineering Technologies ,
Direct Energy
Ellie Oldacre Team Leader , Technical Training Dept.,
Direct Energy
Steve Perdeaux Training Supervisor,
(Continued)
October 2019 5
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
(Continued)
Individual Organization
Clarke Petty Technical Coordinator, Oxford County Division,
Fanshawe College
Gary Prentice Instructor,
Georgian College
Greg Taylor Senior Facilitator ,
Durham College
6 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Overview
Purpose
Before the installation of any piping and appliance systems inside a building , gas technicians/
fitters must plan the location of gas meters, propane storage containers , and gas pressure
regulators. These are key elements in the supply of fuel gas to the installation and will determine
many important aspects of the work that follows. This unit deals with the nature of these items
and the installation and maintenance procedures that apply to them .
Objectives
At the end of this unit, you will be able to :
• choose and install the correct gas pressure regulator for a system ;
• explain the need for overpressure protection and how to achieve this;
• read and clock meters ; and
• identify and plan for the correct use of propane cylinders and tanks.
October 2019 7
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
~ g~~up · CSA Group Ga5 'fr ade ·r rainiug .Mate riab - Red Seal Alignmem
f
I., c
e... £ =
ii
1£.
;; 3 i .. Ill
.
It
2014R•d i.,e- ..
t
,B"
~ I,;. C
0
; ! ii,
<(
"' ..
1 :i- ~,.. ..
-~
2014R.d SNI Blocl<. s..t r.u. > C .:: i.. 2 l!' ~ 8 .ii>
~I ..: ;-
Tnk ;;_ ~ ~ ~
0.., i Ji
ti) -0
i u
"':; :z: u,
1 C
~
·j ...
"' Iii
~
"Iii - >, 0
·;.
"5 ~
2' ... ~
~
0.
_!;
; ,,
.. ¥ e iiii
"' 1!
C:
~ ~ ~
< ti ID
C
t
i E
ii
:;;:
1 i a.
<(
£"'
~ ;.;
i ~
'ii
i i.. 1t
ul :;.
=i 1
~ ti
a."' "'
~
u
~
I-
0
0 0
f
3
u
•
1i
;i; X
§
en
I!'
... ·>i g
...
X
.ii
rT~ I l'c~s.."lfc 1y ,cl.;lcd 1~()0$
J!M
a:; rr~,
~ II)
,1a~ 11ns 304'u,es toolsord
equ pme,ti
l
✓
.8 rTml:3
Pbll.•ood p~
38Moeandmsnlemooe
for .n!IIAIL'lliM
,
ti~ rT~5
3')'3lenn
Fitspbsticpii:c~ 91s pipi,u
~ it J ITmA:6 """
Fib"""'
PP" far 9"' PP."el••r,lem•
1!lael
rrm1c1 ln,bils 'INlting ✓
~ >f~il
.. "'
rrm1:aln.•I~•:ir ""R'i)'"l""!m
ld.9 ln,tal, thll oorMJI.Mlsrm
✓ ✓
S.lec:bandmla lb ekidrmc
~ i ld. 10
wmpcmni> .
✓ ✓
=i
:g rTd:11
SelEctsand mt. lb elf!drx>I
I ✓ ✓
8 11 wo~ ,i.
,; ;; laot 12
1!131
1113 81l
brnMJO'I
""'">fl""'
''"l'lfl
81d
<mlml,,.,..,.,.,
✓ ✓
t!
-'!i
w
rs
-- f ~
,ff
IJ.r;t.14
!Tret.15
11'$ 6,w ~-,.w,n
1,.,1;11,
~ $lc,;JiJ')
10$1;-11$
.-,;,,~
oo,rporeub
a" d hardir<J
✓
f
.....
.lo 1 ~
f .!'j !
rT3'1.16 l ass~ firodsyslems ✓
✓ ✓
✓ ✓ ✓
. J-.
c:, J:I I:. 1Tn 19 R,pall!l gas.-firad sy,1em9 ✓
-'l c:, w Tn20 !Joa,, 111"""0'" g..,..f,,vd 01'1Wl1IO. ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
8 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Pressure regulators
Overview
Purpose
Pressure regulators are installed in a gas piping system to reduce and maintain the downstream
pressure and flow rate that allow downstream appliances to operate safely and efficiently. A
thorough understanding of the principal elements of pressure regulators and their operation is
necessary in order to properly install and service gas equipment.
Objectives
At the end of this chapter, you will be able to :
• describe the need for pressure regulators ;
• describe the basic operation of a regulator;
• locate the codes and regulations pertaining to regulators ;
• distinguish between the different types of regulators ;
• describe the selection requirements ;
• describethe locationand pipingpractices; and
• troubleshoot common regulator problems.
Terminology
Term Abbreviation Definition
(Symbol)
An air/gas proportioning Is similar to a zero regulator , except that air
regulator (ratio regulator) pressure is applied to the vent opening on the
spring side of the diaphragm through a sensing
line connected to an air supply line delivering
co mbustion air to the nozzle mix burner
Droop and offset The downstr eam pressure drop below setpoint
Lockup The pressure above setpoint that is used to shut
the regulator off tight
Servo A mechanism set in operation by other
mechanisms
Setpoint Th e desired outlet pressure
Zero governor (regulator) Designed to deliver an outlet pressure
equivalent to atmospheric pressure
October 2019 9
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Purpose
Gas pressure regulators have two main purposes, namely:
• reduce and maintain a safe operating pressure for the building and/or connected appliances
regardless of changes in the gas flow or upstream pressure ; and
• provide a means by which the pressure to connected appliances or burners can be adjusted ,
set , and maintained .
If .. . Then .. .
The inlet pressure to the regulator is The regulator must provide an additional function to
over 0.5 psi (3.5 kPa) act as a positive shut-off device to ensure that
downstream pressure does not build up to unsafe
levels under no flow conditions.
A gas appliance receives too much It will overtire .
fuel because the gas pressure is too
great
If the gas appliance receives too little It will underfire .
fuel
If an appliance is overtired or • It will produce too much (overtired) and too little
underfired (undertired) heat.
• Combustion characteristics could change , resulting
in carbon monoxide generat ion.
• The appliance may not work properly or efficiently.
Main categories
There are four categori es of gas pressure regulators that a gas technician/fitter encounters, each
used to serve a specific purpose :
10 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Category Description
First-stage regulators • Used in all permanently installed propane systems to
reduce the propane container pressure to service line
pressure delivered to the second stage regulator
• See Figure 1-1
Service regulators (commonly • Used in both natural gas and propane systems to
called second-stage regulators in reduce the service line pressure to building line pressure
propane systems)
at the gas meter set
• See Figure 1-2
• Commonly called second-stage regulators in line
propane systems
• See Figure 1-1
Line pressure regulators • Used to reduce the building line pressure in a branch
line where the pressure required by appliances or
equipment on that branch line is less than the pressure
in the main building line
• See Figure 1-2
• Referr ed as "syste m regulat ors" in the Gas Code, prior
to 2005
Appliance regulators • Used to reduce low (max 0.5 psi) building or branch line
pressure to the pressure required by the appliance
• Often built into a combination control
Also see the definitions provided in the CSA B 14'9.1, Natural gas and propane installation code.
October 2019 11
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-1
Propane installation
Service regulator
Propane (also called second-
container stage regu lato r)
12 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-2
Natural gas installation showing location of service regulator and line pressure
regulators
Service/
regulator
Line pressure
regulato r Appliances
Service regulator
Building
wall ,......,P,.,,:..,,,g,.....-1:K:1-----::-
7-,-in-w-
.c-..... (§
Meter
60
ps1g
7 inw.c.
2
7 inw.c.
Direction of flow
When installing a pressure regulator , the direction of gas flow is critical for proper operation of the
regulator . An arrow on the regulator casing indicates the direction of flow . Be certain that you
install the regulator so the flow arrow points in the direction of flow . (Direction of flow will be
covered in more detail later in this chapter.)
Knowing these two commonly used terms is important since they are used often to exp lain where
to place appliances. These refer to the placing of an item in the system according to the flow of
the gas:
• downstream; and
• upstream.
October 2019 13
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Flow Description
Gas downstream of the Refers to the gas flow after it has passed through the regulator
regulator
Gas upstream of the regulator Refers to the gas flow before it passes through the regulator
This level of training focuses on the operation of direct operated regulators , although , it covers
servo regulation , which by definition is a type of pilot operated control , as it applies to the
appliance regulators built into combination gas valves .
A direct-operated regulator is defined as any self-contained valve and actuator combination that
automatically adjusts the flow in direct response to changes in downstream pressure , thereby
matching the gas demand . Figure 1-3 illustrates a direct-operat ed regulator .
Figure 1-3
Direct-operated regulator
Loading
eleme nt
Measuring
element
Restrict ing
element
As shown in Figure 1-3, these regulat ors have four essential elements.
14 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Element Description
Loading element Usually a spring
Measuring element Usually a diaphragm
Restricting element An orifice and valve seat
Atmospheric vent A vent on the atmospheric side of the
diaphragm
The amount of spring pressure on the diaphragm determines the position of the restricting
element.
Changing the spring load can adjust the amount of flow through the regulator.
October 2019 15
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
16 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-4
Graph depicting the performance of a typical regulator
,----- Lockup
, ''
'
Setpoint
Droop
(offset)
...
CV
::,
VI
VI
...
CV
a.
E
n:J
...
CV
....
VI
C
Wide open
~
0
Cl
Flow rate
The diaphragm is attached by a stem to the restricting element so that they both move together .
Made of neoprene , it is extremely flexible and usually is supported by a metal plate that allows
downstream pressure to act upon the diaphragm evenly.
The diaphragm is slightly permeable to gas , so it is not unusual to detect a slight odour of gas at
the vent opening . Howeve r, a significant odour around the regulator may indicate a damaged
diaphragm . Diaphragms do wear out and may crack or tear due to age or exposure to chemi cals .
Usually , the restricting element is a valve and orifice that together control the amount of flow
through the orifice opening.
It is important that the orifice and seat are properly maintained. They must be smooth and
undamaged so that the seat may seal the orifice. If dirt such as pipe dope or tape or metal
cuttings from threading operations lodges between the orifice and the valve seat , the regulator
ca nnot shut off.
Upstream pressure will leak downstream when the appliances are shut off. This may damage
downstream components or ca use gas to escape through burners and build up in the heat
exchanger and vent.
October 2019 17
Pressure regulators , overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
If the vent were partially blocked or restricted, the air movement would be delayed as the
diaphragm attempts to force air out and pull air through the vent opening. This would in turn
cause wide swings in downstream pressure above and below the setpoint known as "hunting or
cycling".
Most small appliance regulators vent to the indoors through a very small (#78 drill size) opening
that is considered safe and acceptable by appliance standards as long as the regulator is located
in a ventilated area.
Older appliances may have the appliance regulator vented into the appliance combustion
chamber adjacent to the continuous pilot.
Newer appliances are usually vented outdoors or have the vent equipped with a leak limiter as
discussed later in this section.
The vent also allows gas to escape if the diaphragm ruptures or an internal relief valve (installed
in some regulators) opens. Safety measures are required to control this escaping gas as
discussed later in this section .
Performance characteristics
The amount of flow it can pass for a given amount of droop determines the accuracy of a
regulator. The closer the regulator is to setpoint, the more accurate it is. The following four factors
mainly affect droop:
• spring rate;
• diaphragm area;
• orifice size; and
• inlet pressure.
Spring rate
The control springs for regulators are rated by the amount of force required to compress it one
inch. For example, a spring with a rate of 25 pounds per inch (lbs/in) needs 25 pounds of force to
compress it one inch , 50 pounds of force to compress it two inches , etc. This force is opposing
the total force created by the setpoint pressure spread over the area of the diaphragm.
Adjustable regulators usually have a selection of springs to choose from in order to achieve the
desired setpoint for each application . The spring ranges often have overlap within the range of
settings each can deliver. Since a lighter spring is more sensitive to changes in downstream
pressure , choosing the lightest available spring rate causes the least droop and the most
accurate pressure control.
18 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
For example, in the spring chart shown in Figure 1-5, there are several spring ranges available
for this model of regulator . If our system required a setpoint of 12 inches water column (w.c.), the
spring with a pressure range of 4 - 12 inches w.c would be more accurate for our application and,
therefore , has less droop than the spring with a pressure range of 10 - 22 inches w.c .
Figure 1-5
Spring selection chart
Diaphragm area
Because a larger diaphragm area produces more force change for a given change in
downstream pressure (F = P x A ), larger diaphragms are often used in applications that require
minimum droop and, therefore , better accuracy.
Orifice size
As shown in Figure 1-6, moving the valve disc away from the orifice increases the flow rate of the
regulator only to a certain point. Once the restrict ing element is wide open (when the disc clears
the orifice by a distan ce equal to 1/4 of the orifice diameter) , the orifice size and the pressure
difference on either side of the orifice dictate the maximum flow capacity of the regulator . In many
models of service and line pressure regulators , you can change the flow capacity by changing the
orifice size .
October 2019 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-6
Regulator threaded removable orifice
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
When changing the orifice size, you must be careful not to oversize it, as this can lead to unstable
operation and faster wear.
Inlet pressure
As mentioned , the orifice size and the pressure difference on either side of the orifice dictate the
maximum flow capacity of the regulator. The pressure differen ce is determined by the outlet
pressure and the operating inlet pressure . It is important when selecting a regulator that its
maximum capacity be determined by analy zing the minimum inlet pressure . The minimum inlet
pressure will be during operation and will be a result of the piping pressure losses at maximum
design conditions .
Unless a gas technician/fitter is authorized to do so by the distributo r, the Gas Code prohibits a
gas technician /fitter from working on a servi ce regulator that is part of the distributor 's system.
Before beginning any adjustments on non-utility regulators , consult the manufa cturer 's
instructions for the regulator and for the appliance(s) served by the regulator , and take note of the
following:
• Adjustments should only be made to meet appliance manufactur er's pressure specifications
using the adjustment method recommended by the regulator manufacturer.
20 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
• Always use the proper tools and make sure that your pressure measurement instrument has
the proper range and accuracy for the job .
Adjusting pressure
If the pressure from the regulator is too high or too low, use the following procedure to change the
pressure setting:
1) Turn off the gas.
2) Install the pressure test equipment to sense downstream pressure.
3) Remove the regulator adjusting screw cap.
4) Turn on the gas.
5) Turn the equipment on, allowing the gas to flow.
6) Look at the pressure and make the appropriate adjustment (Figure 1-7).
Figure 1-7
Adjusting regulator
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
October 2019 21
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Safety features
A number of safety devices form part of the regulator.
If the diaphragm ruptures , the leakage is limited to less than 1 ft3/h (0.02832 m3/h) at 7 inches w.
c. (1.74 kPa) gas pressure . The vent opening (especially on combination gas valves) is usually
covered by a loose-fitting cap to prevent dirt from plugging the opening [Figure 1-8(b ) and (c)].
Figure 1-8
Vent limiting orifice
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Regulalor blee d ve nt dust caps
(a) lntegral vent orifice (b) Dust cap partiall y remo ved for viewing (c) Vent dust cap
As the regulator size increases, the larger diaphragm will need to move more air through the vent
opening , and an integral orifice restriction will affect the reactions time of the regulator . In some
cases , the manufacturer may offer a fixed orifice accessory that can be installed , but the
individual load capacity of the regulator will need to be reduced. Figure 1-9 shows a fixed vent
limiting orifice accessory sitting on the regulator , the orifice opening is difficult to see as it is on
the side of the body under the hex head. You can also see that the bleed vent hole in the
regulator is much larger than the #78 integral orifice . If this regulator was required to respond at
its full capacity for a single applian ce, then the vent limiting orifice could not be used and the vent
would need to terminate outside or use an automati c vent leak limiting device.
22 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-9
Vent limiting orifice accessory
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
In this device , a ball check or disc check allows free movement of air at atmospheric pressure
above the diaphragm to ensure fast regulator response . However , if the diaphragm ruptur es, the
high pressure flow of gas causes the ball check or disc check to limit the flow of gas to a
maximum flow rate of 2.5 ft3/h (0.0706 m3/h) for natural gas or 1 ft3/h (0.02832 m3/h) for propane ,
as allowed by the Gas Code. In most cases, the opening in the leak limiter is a #78 drill size.
A regulator equ ipped with a leak limiter must be in a ventilated space. Keep the small opening on
the leak limiter free of dirt or paint. Do not use vent limiting devices outdoors; if they are exposed
to the environment, they may become clogged by moisture or insects. You can only install vent
limiters in regulators for which they are certified. Install them directly into the vent connection of
the regulator without intermediate pipe or fittings . Manufacturers may have more than one lea k
limiter available that fits the regulator . It is important that you use the proper model specified by
the manufacturer.
October 2019 23
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GA S TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-10
Leak limiting devices
Courte sy of Maxitrol Company
2 psig regulato r
• ~
."
f
l
f
12A09 12A3
9 12A49
Wh en using ball check vent limiters, mount the regulator in the horizo ntal position to keep the
ve nt limiter in the ve rtical up position. Some manufa cturers have regulator des igned with two ve nt
co nnections that enable the regulat or to be installed either ve rtically or horizo ntally using th e
appropri ate location for the ve nt limiter and a plug in the other (Figure 1-11 ).
24 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-11
Multi position 2 psi regulator
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Performance features
Besides the four performance factors previously mentioned , there are additional features that are
used to improve regulator performance . Two common ones (Figure 1-12) include :
• pitot tubes; and
• levers .
The pitot tube design is used to decrease regulator droop. Inside the regulator , the pitot tube
connects underside of the diaphragm to an area called the vena contracta, which has a lower
pressure when exposed to increased gas velocity. By sensing the setpoint pressure at this point ,
the diaphragm will be tricked into opening wider, therefore , responding quicker to increase
demands. This phenomenon - the reverse of droop - is called boost.
Lever controlled regulators provide increased force necessary for lockup against higher inlet
pressures. The extra mechani cal force also keeps the disk in a stable position, thereby opposing
tendencies of the disk to cycle or buffet.
October 2019 25
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-12
Pitot tube and lever features
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Diaphragm
Lever
Pitot tu be
Figure 1-13
Regulator with internal relief valve
Tamper-resistant nut holds
designed tens ion on the
relief valve spring
Vent must
termi nate
elief valve
outdoors
Outlet ~ ~ Inlet
26 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
The set pressure for the relief cannot be adjusted and is an important factor in selecting a
regulator . Under full flow cond itions from the relief valve and relief piping , the regulator outlet
pressure must never exceed the pressure rating of the weakest component downstream .
Review manufacturer 's specifications for both the regulator and the downstream components
when determining if the relief capacity is sufficient. Remember that the piping attached to the
relief vent must never reduce the relief capacity or exert back-pressures on the regulator .
Where large volume relief of gas pressure is required to protect components, a separate relief
valve may be installed on the piping system. These automatically reset valves function in the
same way as the internal relief device in regulators . Set pressures are established by a spring
holding down a valve seat. Within the range of the valve, the set pressure can be adjusted to
relieve pressure before damage occurs to the downstream components .
October 2019 27
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-14
Regulator with overpressure shut-off and two-way stabilizer vent valves
OPSO
Two-way stabilizer
vent with flappers Relief valve stem
closed
Turbo-booster tube
Internal relief
Reset pin
Materials of construction
Regulators are made from corrosion-resistant materials. Typical construction materials are
shown in Table 1-1.
28 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Table 1-1
Typical regulator construction materials
Part Material
Body Cast aluminum
Cast iron
Steel
Spring case, lower diaphragm casing, union ring, seat ring, Aluminum
disk holders
0-ring , disks , diaphragms Nitrile
Closing cap gasket , relief valve pad Neoprene
Diaphragm head , adjusting screw Delrin™
Aluminum
Relief/monitor piston ring Graphite
Vent flappers CycolacTM
Nylon
Other metal parts Aluminum
Brass
Cast iron
Monel TM
Steel
Stainless steel
Zinc
Codes
The applicable code requirements for regulators are in the Natural gas and propane installation
code (CSA 8149.1) and the Propane storage and handling code (CSA 8149 .2). This section
identifies the key requirements and explains some of the reasons for these requirements. Unless
otherwise stated, code references are to the most current version of CSA 8149.1. Refer directly
to the Clauses identifi ed since the prese ntation usually paraphras es the Code and it is important
that you become familiar with the layout of the Code.
Prohibited work
Clause 4 .6.2 states that no person other than an employee or person authorized by the supplier/
distributor shall perform work on the supplier/distributor system. The service regulator on natural
gas systems is part of the supplier/distributor system.
October 2019 29
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
The system regulator (or second stage regulator) and the first stage regulator may be considered
part of the propane supplier /distributor system in some areas . Check with the propane distributor
and/or authority having jurisdiction before working on these regulators.
For natural gas installations , the distributor determines and sets the building pressure in
compliance with Table 5.1. For propane systems where the first and/or second stage regulators
are not considered part of the distributor's system, it is the responsibility of the gas technician /
fitter to set the building line pressure so it meets appliance requirements but does not exceed the
maximum pressures set in Table 5.1.
In both natural gas and propane systems , the maximum pressures allowed by Code are seldom
employed for safety reasons .
Clause 5.2.1 .1 contains some relatively new requirements that first appeared in the 2007
Supplements to the CSA B 149.1 Code . Although it has always been required that a regulator be
certified and be of sufficient size to provide the required flow of gas at the extremes of inlet
pressures to which the regulator can be exposed , the reference to three recognized standards is
new. When installing a new regulator that is not approved as part of the appliance approval ,
check that it is certified to a recogn ized standard .
Any regulator in the gas supply line shall not be installed in any of the following three locations
(Clause 5.2.1 .6):
• where it is inaccessible for repair , replacement , servi cing, or inspection ;
• in a concealed location ; or
• where it could be reasonably expected to be subject to physical or chemical damage .
Clauses 5.2 .1.5 and 6.18.2 require that pressur e regulators have a manual shut-off valve
install ed upstream. This valve is necessary for servicing and for emergency response .
These regulators are only used on piping systems where the building pressure exceeds 0.5 psi
(3.5 kPa). As such , the code requirement (Clause 5.2 .1.4) stating that a line pressure regulator
30 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
with an inlet pressure over 0.5 psi (3.5 kPa) be a positive shut-off type applies to all line pressure
regulators.
Clause 5.2.1 .5 requires that a line pressure regulator be equipped with a line relief device or an
overpressure protection device. However , an exception is allowed in Clause 5.2 .2.4 for propane
systems and in Clause 5.2.3.1 for natural gas systems when the line pressure regulator is
equipped with a leak limiting device (as discussed previously) .
For piping systems with a supply pressure over 2 psi , a line pressure regulator must be equipped
with either a line relief device or an overpressure protection device (see definition in the CSA
B149.1 Code). These devices are covered in the Overpressure protection> Relief valves section .
When installed outdoors and subject to inclement weather , the regulator has to be protected as
necessary from exposure to weather conditions. A regulator installed outdoors or in an unheated
area must be positioned so that the bonnet vent opening discharges vertically downward. Clause
5 .2.2.3 allows two exceptions to this requirement.
All permanent propane installations must employ two-stage regulation (see Figure 1-1 ).
Reducing container pressure in two stages ensures a much more consistent delivery pressure to
appliances compared to single-stage regulation . It also reduces the chan ce of internal freeze-ups
caused by large drops in pressure through the small orifice required in a single-stage regulator.
As previously discussed , line pressure regulators on a piping system operating at 2 psi (14 kPa)
or less do not have to be vented outdoors if the regulator is equipped with a leak limiter . In the
case of propane systems , the leak limiter must limit escaping gas from a ruptured diaphragm to
no more than 1 ft 3/hour (0 .0283 m3/h). Clause 5.2.2.4 requires that a regulator with a leak limiter
be installed in a ventilated space only.
A hydrostatic relief device is required on liquid propane systems where the propane can be
trapped between two valves. If liquid propane is trapped between two closed valves in piping or a
hose, it will expand as its temperature increases . The hydrostatic relief device relieves this
pressure , thus preventing the piping from bursting. The minimum relief pressur e setpoint is 375
psi (2500 kPa) and the maximum is 500 psi (3500 kPa) . See Clause 5.4 .1 of the CSA B149 .1
Code.
There is a Claus e in the CSA B149 .1 Code that allows the use of leak limiters on natural gas
systems operating above 2 psi , provided that the system has an overpressure prote ction device
October 2019 31
Pressure regulators , overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
set to a pressure either below 2 psig (14 kPa) or 2 times the delivery pressure on the system and
that the regulator is certified to ANSI Z21.80/CSA 6.22, Line pressure regulators. There is no
similar allowance for propane systems operating above 2 psi.
Venting of regulators
When venting a regulator vent outdoors , a techn ician/fitter must pay special attention to Clause
5.5 of the CSA B149.1 Code. It specifies the material that can be used for the vent , the size of
single and combined vents , and the permissible locations for vent terminations. Compliance with
the regulator manufacturer's instructions is also required.
The vent line shall be made of steel pipe , copper, seamless aluminum, or steel tubing that meets
the standards specified in Clause 6.2. However, aluminum vents are not allowed on combined
vent systems with an inlet pressure over 0.5 psi (3.5 kPa).
For dedicated vents serving a single regulator, the vent size must be at least that of the nominal
pipe size of the vent outlet of the pressure regulator, but its inside diameter must not be less than
0.25 inches (6 mm). Individual vent lines may be connected to a single vent line, but the size of
the common vent depends on the types of devices that are common vented and the inlet
pressure to these devices; refer to Clauses 5.5.3 to 5.5.5.
If specific manufacturer's instructions are not provided giving details on the sizing of the vent line,
increase the vent line by one pipe size diameter for every 50 ft (15 m) or part thereof that the vent
line extends beyond the initial 50 ft (15 m). This increase must be made at the regulator vent
outlet.
The Code also defines how and where the vent terminates outdoors.
The vent must terminate outdoors pointing downwards and have a means to prevent the entry of
water, insects, or foreign material.
Clauses 5.2.1.2, 7.4.4, and 7.5.2 and Table 5.2 require that a regulator vent terminating outside
be at least 3 ft (1 m) from the moisture exhaust duct of a domestic clothes dryer and at least 10 ft
(3 m) from the moisture exhaust duct of a commercial clothes dryer. This requirement applies to
gas-fired and electric clothes dryers and is intended to prevent the moist air from the dryer from
damaging the regulator or freezing on the regulator vent screen.
Figure 1-15 provides a visual representation of the vent termination requirements established in
Table 5.2. The overpressure protection device described in the first column of the table are of the
OPSO type. These installations have lesser clearance requirements, as the device will be
completely shutting of the flow of gas when activated.
32 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-15
Allowed locations for vent terminations per Table 5.2 of CSA 8149.1
Clearances from j : ; : : : : : : : : : j : j : j : : : : : : : : : j : j
Mecha nical air intake 3 ft
vent termination Appliance air intake 1 ft
for nat ural gas
relief devices from
OPSOregulators
Appliance vent out let 1 ft 0
having a relief
A/C~
capacity of unit~
50 scf/h or less openi ng
1 ft
j : i :::::::j : j : j : j : j : : : : : j : j : j
Appliance air int ake 3 ft Mechanical air intake 10 ft
Clearances from
vent ter mination
Appliance vent out let 3 ft @
for nat ural gas
relief devices
EE Buildi ng
open ing 3 ft
Propane
Clearances from
vent termination
for propane
relief devices
Propane appliances must have an appliance regulator and a separate pilot regulator when the
supply pressure to the appliance could be subjected through supply pressure , design , creepage,
or fluctuation to propane pressure in excess of that for which the appliance is rated.
Since older propane appliances may not have a11appliance regulator , a gas technician/fitter must
ensure that either the second-stage regulator provides a consistent pressure within the pressure
October 2019 33
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
rating of the appliance or appliance and pilot regulators are installed in accordance with Clauses
5 .6.1.1 and 5.6.1.2 .
To comply with the code requirements that apply to regulators, a technician/fitter must fully have
a sound understanding of how regulators work .
Appliance regulators
The appliance regulator works on the same principle as all other regulators . Appliance regulators
are designed to reduce the inlet pressure of an appliance to the appropriate manifold pressure for
proper burner operation. Most natural gas appliances require a manifold pressure of 3 - 4 inches
w .c. while propane appliances typically require 10 - 11 inches w.c. The appliance regulator
typically has a maximum inlet pressure of 0.5 psi. The appliance input determines the type of
appliance regulator required.
Regulator Description
Low-capacity-type • Used to provide safe and uniform gas pressure to residential gas
appliance regulator appliances.
• May be used on smaller input appliances for supplying gas to either
the main burner or pilot burner or both burners.
• Usually have a high resistance to flow through the regulator but
provide fine pressure control.
High-capacity-type • Used on larger residential and commercial appliances.
appliance regulator
• Are only used to regulate the gas pressure to higher input burners .
• Usually have a low resistanc e to flow through the regulator by
employing a large orifice in the restricting element or a straight-
flow-through design .
Regulator component • Performs the same fun ction as a low capacity type appliance
of a combination gas regulator except that it forms part of the combination control valve .
control valve
• May be a simple direct-a cting regulator or a servo regulat or.
• A combination gas valve usually consists of a manual shut-off
valve, pilot gas control devi ce, main gas pressure regulator , as well
as one or two automatic safety shut-off valves .
• Gas flow to the pilot burner is controlled by a throttling valve
(needl e valve) , sometimes called the B cock .
34 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-16
Low capacity appliance regulator
Courtesy of Camosun College, Rod Lidstone CC BY
October 2019 35
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-17
High input boiler valve train
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rod Lidstone CC BY
Separatelow
capacity pilot
regulator
Figure 1-18
Appliance regulator in a combination gas valve
Servo
appliance
regulator
36 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
2) Inlet gas pressure passes through the restrictor and down the bleed line to build pressure
under the main valve diaphragm . The gas pressure is equal above and below the
diaphragm.
3) The force of the spring and the fact that the area of the lower diaphragm surface is greater
keep the valve closed .
Figure 1-19
Combination gas valve with servo-operated regulator
Bleed valve Regulator
(closed) adjustmen t screw t
5ervo regu 1a or
Bleed valve
operator I valve (wide open)
Regulator vent
(leak limited)
Inlet
Main valve
(closed)
4) When there is a call for heat, the bleed valve operator opens the bleed valve. This allows gas
from below the main valve to escape through the servo regulator restricting element , which is
wide open because there is no downstream pressure . As a result, the main gas valve starts
to open allowing gas to the burner (Figure 1-20) .
5) As gas pressure downstream of the main valve starts to build (due to restrictions in flow
through the orifice and burner ports), this back-pressure acts upon the diaphragm in the
servo regulator , causing it to move upward and reducing the flow rate through the servo
regulator 's restricting element. The upstream gas pressure that cannot pass through the
servo regulator again starts to flow into the chamber below the main valve, causing it to
close.
6) The servo regulator restricting element stops moving when the force of the downstream gas
pressure equals the force of the spring in the servo regulator. This maintains the main valve
in a position necessary to reduce the upstream gas pressure (usually 7 inches. w.c. for
natural gas systems and 13 inches w.c . for propane systems) to the manifold pressure
(usually 3.5 inches w.c. for natural gas systems and 11 inches w.c. for propane systems).
Essentially , the servo regulator causes the main valve to act as a restricting element to
regulate gas pressure to the burner .
October 2019 37
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-20
Combination gas valve with servo-operated regulator (open)
Bleed valve
operat or
Restrictor
Inlet
7) When the call for heat is satisfied, the bleed valve operator closes the bleed valve and the
upstream pressure flows only to the chamber below the main valve, causing it to close . Most
combination gas valves have a second solenoid operated main valve for added safety.
A gas technician/fitter can adjust the spring on the servo regulator to increase or decrease
downstream pressure to meet the appliance ma11ufacturer's specifications. Like most small input
regulators , servo regulators cannot be repaired. If they fail , the entire combination gas valve must
be replaced.
Some modulating appliances achieved their firing rate modulation by way of connecting an
electronic stepper motor at the servo regulator adjustment screw. This motor operator rece ives a
signal from the controller and adjusts the setting of the servo regulator to the required manifold
pressure. These valves ca n achieve a full range of modulation from 35 - 100% with 1%
increments .
38 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-21
Electronic modulating servo-regulated combination gas valve
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
October 2019 39
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-22
Combination gas valve
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Balanced regulators
A balanced-type regulator is designed to have the inlet pressure acting in two opposing directions
on the orifice seat(s) , thus producing a balancing effect that prevents an increase in set pressure
through an increase in the inlet pressure .
Large changes in the inlet pressure make it difficult for a regulator to maintain constant
downstream pressure . Many regulators therefore add a second diaphragm or port to create a
balanced regulator. Balanced regulators are classified as :
• single-ported; and
• double-ported.
40 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-23
Single-ported balanced regulator
Loading
element
Vent
Measuring
element
Balancing
diaphragm
Pitot tube
Disk
and seat ~
Inlet
October 2019 41
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-24
Double-ported balanced regulator
--==-- /D ust cap
Adju sting
Vent nut
Measuring
element
Sense line
Double seat
connectio n
and disks
The shaft connecting the two disks or plugs to the main diaphragm is sealed with an O-ring where
it passes through the valve body . The double-ported regulator does not use a pitot tube to sense
outlet pressure . Instead , a tapping is provided under the main diaphragm , which must be
connected to the downstream piping.
Balanced regulators allow for more stable operation and precise control of pressure.
Zero governors
Zero governors , or regulators , are designed to deliver an outlet pressure equivalent to
atmospheric pressure. They are normally double-diaphragm units equipped with an O-ring seal
diaphragm (balancing diaphragm), as shown in Figure 1-25. This isolates the inlet gas pressure
from the lower chamber of the main control diaphragm.
The balancing diaphragm is set so that its effective area equals the effective area of the valve
disk .
The spring of these regulators counterbalances the weight of the internal parts. This provides just
enough additional tension to close the valve.
42 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-25
Zero governors
Measuring
element
Balancing
diaphragm
Pitot
tube
c:::::>
Inlet 7\i~t
LJ Restricting
element
As the spring always just counterbalances the inte rnal parts, the outlet pressure of the governor
will always be the same pressure that is applied to the top side of the main diaphragm . Since the
vent above the diaphragm is open to the atmosphere (Figure 1-25) , the zero governor is also
called an atmospheric regulator . It can be adjusted to provide gas pressure at a slight negative or
slight positive pressure , but is usually employed for supplying gas at atmospheric pressure . If you
look closely at the regulator shown on the right of Figure 1-25, you can see that this manufacturer
has simply taken their balanced diagram design and added a counterbalance spring to the
underside of the valve.
A zero governor is connected to an air-gas mixer in a burner system that employs a mechanical
device (i.e., blower) to deliver air under pressure . The blower or a venturi-type mixer creates
suction on the outlet of the atmospheri c regulato r. This suction on the bottom of the main
diaphragm causes it to open the regulator and try to bring the outlet pressure back up to zero.
The more suction applied to the outlet, the more the regulator opens to increase the flow .
October 2019 43
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-26
Zero governor
Courtesy of Fives North American Combustion Inc.
Contro l
valve
Air_____.
Air and gas
mix in ventur i
Gas Mixer _
Built-in
limit ing
orifice
~ Atmospheric
"" Drip
leg
(0) pressure
Air/gas ratio
regulator
By changing the air flow through the blower or mixer, the gas flow through the zero governor
changes automatically. These systems are ideal for modulating premix burner systems. Although
Figure 1-26 shows a large zero governor normally used on industrial appliances , a zero governor
can be incorporated into a combination gas valve for smaller input premix modulating burners, as
shown in Figure 1-27.
44 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-27
The combination gas valve on a Viessmann matrix burner incorporates a zero
governor
October 2019 45
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GA S TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-28
Air/gas ratio regulator on a nozzle mix burner
Air---e►
Manua l
valve
valve
Burner
4 pipe
Gas dia. (min.) Limit ing
10 pipe orifice va Ive
dia. (min .)
Ratio
regulato r
Alth ough Figure 1-28 shows a ratio regulator arrangement normall y used on industri al
appliances , a gas/a ir ratio regulator can be incorporated into a combination gas valve for small er
input premix modulating burners, as shown for the boiler burner in Figure 1-29 .
46 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-29
Gas/air ratio controller on a Lochinvar modulating condensing boiler
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Propane storage container pressures may vary from as low as 8 psig (55 kPa) in winter to as high
as 220 psig (1500 kPa) in summer due to changes of temperature around the container.
The propane regulator system must compensate for this variation and deliver a steady pressure.
The regulator must also be able to handle the problems that result from the intermitten t use of the
appliances attached to it.
Although single-stage regulator systems are still used on portable propane appliances or on older
permanent installations, the Code has required all permanent installations use two-stage
regulator systems since 1995.
Two-stage regulator systems have a numb er of advantages over single-stage systems, including
the following :
• They deliver a more uniform appliance pressure because the second-stage regulator receives
a relatively uniform gas flow from the first-sta gie regulator .
October 2019 47
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
• They reduce the possibility of internal freeze-ups caused when moisture in the gas is emitted
as water and freezes as it drops in pressure (and therefore temperature) through the small
orifice of a single-stage regulator . Two-stage regulator systems have larger orifices and lower
pressure drops through each orifice compared to single-stage systems .
• There is an economy of installation since the li ne between the first- and second-stage
regulators is much smaller than in single-stage systems .
• The allowance for future appliances is enhanced , as additional second-stage regulators may
be added if the first-stage regulator still has additional capacity .
These systems should also be used in non-permanent installations to get full and proper use
from the connected appliances .
48 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-30
Typical first- and second-stage propane regulators
(a) High pressure first-stage regulator (b) Low pressure second-st age regulator
October 2019 49
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-31
A typical high to low twin-stage propane regulator
Copyright Engineered Controlls International Inc. (RegO)
Clause 5.1.2 of the CSA B149.1 Code requires that the outlet pressure of the first-stage regulator
shall not exceed 1O psi (70 kPa) when supplying a residential installation. However , this
maximum allowed pressure should be reduced to 5 psi in colder climates, such as in Northern
Ontario, to prevent the vapour from changing into liquid when the temperature is low .
The maximum allowed outlet pressure of the second-stage regulator is given in Table 5.1 of the
Code. Although the maximum building pressure allowed inside a residence is 2 psi, most
residential systems are provided with 11 inches w.c. (2 .7 kPa} , except in recreational vehicles
where the pressure must be maintained at 13 inches w.c. (3.25 kPa) in accordance with the CSA
2240 RV Series.
50 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-32
Two-stage regulator installation
First-stage
regulat or
Second-stage
0000
regulato r
□
Usually
10 psig
Single-stage regulator
A single-sta ge regulator is used to reduce tank or cylinder pressures to applian ce inlet pressure
- usually 11 inches w.c. (2.7 kPa). A typical singl e-stage regulator is shown in Figure 1-33. As
previously mentioned , the use of a single-stage regulat or is only allow ed on portable propane
appliance s.
Figure 1-33
Single-stageregulator
Travel stop on closing
cap opens interna l relief
valve in emerg ency
~
Inlet
Orifice t ube wi t h
straight-through
flow design
Copyright Fisher Controls International Inc.
Reprinted with permission
October 2019 51
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
They automatically change the supply over from the "service" to the "reserve" cylinder when the
"service" cylinder is empty. This happens without interruption to the flow.
These regulators also allow the refilling or replacement of the empty cylinders without interruption
of the supply to the system. They come with indicators that let you know the status of the tank the
arrow is positioned to and also allows the reserve cylinder to supplement the flow of gas from the
in-service cylinder during extreme load of severe cold conditions.
Figure 1-34
Rego automatic changeover regulator
Courtesy of Rego Products
Selection requirements
Selecting the correct gas regulator depends upon a number of factors. The main factors relate to
the rate of flow , type of gas, maximum and minimum gas inlet pressu res, outlet gas pressure , and
pipe or tubing size. These factors need to be taken into account before choosing a regulator .
Selection factors
Before you can select a regulator for a particular application, take into account the following
factors relating to the piping system. First , complete and size a sketch of the piping system, then
get the following information:
52 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Information Description
Rate of flow The rate of flow through the regulator is determined by the
number of appliances connected to the downstream piping
system . This flow rate is usually expressed in standard cubic
feet per hour or standard cubic metres per hour.
The type of gas Ensure that the regulator is designed for use with the intended
fuel gas (natural gas or propane) as the flow rate is effected by
the specific gravity of the gas.
Inlet gas pressure Regulators are manufactured with a maximum and minimum
inlet pressure rating. Select the regulator that is designed to
handle the possible range of inlet pressures. The maximum inlet
pressure is a factor in determining overpressure protection
requirements . The minimum available inlet pressure is an
important factor in determining the rate of flow (capacity) the
regulator can deliver.
Outlet gas pressure The outlet gas pressure is the downstream system-operating
(setpoint) pressure. This pressure is usually adjustable within a small
range and is necessary to select the proper spring. Outlet
pressure is also a factor that effects the flow rate through the
regulator, as the difference between it and the operating inlet
pressure determine the allowable pressure drop through the
regulator.
Piping or tubing size The inlet and outlet pipe or tube size is a factor in determining
how to select the regulator body size .
Sizing factors
The following are general guidelines for sizing regulators. When sizing any regulator, always
consult experienced personnel or the manufacturer.
Information Description
Body size The regulator body size should never be larger than the pipe
size. However , a properly sized regulator can be one or two
sizes smaller than the pipe.
Construction The regulator should be constructed from materials compatible
with the nature of the gas, the gas flow, and the temperature
used. Also ensure that the regulator is available with the desired
end connections.
Pressure ratings Pressure-reducing regulators are sized by using minimum inlet
pressure to ensure that they can provide full capacity under all
conditions. It is also very important to take note of the maximum
inlet and outlet ratings. Downstream pressures significantly
higher than the regulator pressure setting may damage soft
seats and other internal regulator parts.
October 2019 53
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Information Description
Spring pressure range If two or more springs have pressure ranges that include the
desired pressure setting, use the spring with the lower range for
more accuracy.
Spring performance The full published range of a spring can generally be used
without sacrificing performance or spring life .
Orifice diameter The recommended orifice size is the smallest diameter that
handles the flow. This benefits operation by:
54 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Most regulator manufacturers offer a range of models to supply the required flow rate depending
on inlet pressures and outlet pressures. Larger regulators may have the option of replaceable
orifices and a range of springs that may be selected for each model of regulator depending on the
particular application. When you are to make choices, always select the smallest orifice size that
will provide the required flow rate, largest practical diaphragm, and the lightest spring rate. These
guidelines will provide the best regulator performance.
The selection process can seem very complexed if you were to try and look at all of the
specifications for each model of regulator available. To streamline the process, the first step is to
narrow the choices down to a few models by applying the selection factors related to your piping
system. You can apply these factors to a Model Selection Guide or what is more commonly used
today is an online sizing program. Figure 1-35 shows a snapshot of the computer screen in which
the initial section factors have been inserted into the appropriate fields of the Itron online
program.
Figure 1-36 shows the on line software results for the information that was given. If you were to
compare with the charts supplied in the appendix, you would get a similar result. In Figure 1-37, a
portion of the B-42 capacity table is shown. Since this table does not include an inlet pressure of
2.5 psig, you should use the 2-psi column to ensure that you do not undersize the regulator.
According to the tables, this regulator is supplied with a 5/16-inch orifice and 385 SCFH of natural
gas. This is lower than what the online software predicted but do remember that the online
software enables us to use a higher inlet of 2.5 psig.
Notice that the left side of the chart also indicated the standard spring supplied (Silver). If we look
at the spring selection chart (Figure 1-38) for this regulator, you will see that the blue spring is the
lightest spring that will achieve the desired setpoint off 14" w.c., which is consistent with the
online results.
The model ending in the Letter "R" would be chosen as it has the necessary internal relief.
October 2019 55
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GA S TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-35
Itron regulator online sizing application - Parameters screen
Courtes y of Itron Inc.
Step 2: Parameters
[1111l1WC.;•
,..,,mun, lnr1tPNsswe
,,
M-AXfflllffllftilt PrfflUN
Figure 1-36
--
Itron regulator online sizing application - Results screen
Courtesy of Itron Inc.
Selected Regulators
Cldt tier• 1Dr ._,.
""""' ,.,.
i,IJDnn.aDon
Odnce :
'!OSC>C
H(N_ G,,i ___ __,
1'Jlio,ctW\.
BIUF
Ill Ft-MMIZI
Figure 1-37
B42 14" w.c. outlet pressure capacity table
Courtes y of Itron Inc.
B42 Series commercial regulator , models N and R
14" w.c. (34 mbar) capacity table (2" droop) ,¾" outlet valve bodies
Capacities in SCFH of 0.6 S.G. gas ; base condit ions of 14.7 PSIA and 60°F.
Typical capacity info.
Manufa cturer I Itron
56 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-38
B42 spring selection chart
Courtesy of Itron Inc.
Spring data , spring colour outlet pressure range
Colours Outlet pressure range* *
Standard spring data
Green 5 - 7" w.c.
Brown 6 - 8" w.c.
Blue 8 - 14" w .c.
Silver 12 - 28" w .c.
Yellow /Black 1 - 2 PSIG
Purple 1.5 - 2 .25 PSIG
Alternate spring data
Orange 5.5 - 9" w .c.
Dark green 4 - 9" w.c.
High pressure spring data
October 2019 57
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Yellow 2 - 4 PSIG
White 4 - 5 PSIG
Relief spring data
Purple 7" w .c. above set point
Table 1-2 lists the approximate vapour pressures corresponding to a range of temperatures.
Table 1-2
Approximate vapour pressures of propane
58 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
If using propane for space heating , select the lowest temperatures the storage containers are
likely to be exposed to over a 24-hour period. Consult with the local propane distributor for a
reasonable design temperature that reflects past experience.
It is also important to check the maximum temperature so that the full range of storage container
vapour pressure is known.
Next , determine the maximum load in Btu/h (or kW) by adding all the inputs from all of the
appliance rating plates connected in the system. Also take into account seasonal demands.
Always use the peak demand.
Now use a regulator manufacturer's performance curves to select the appropriate first- and
second-stage , or integral twin-stage regulators. shows a typical performance curve for an integral
twin-stage regulator.
Figure 1-39
Performance curve for a twin-stage regulator
1
14 _150 ps\g (1030 kPa) inl~t
C:
-
_In iti al setting I I I
I 100 psig (690 kPa) inl et _
... E::,
QI 13 '
'I
~ 8 12 , .I /
7
75 psig (515 kPa) inlet
~ ai 11 - ~ • I
-- • ,,
~
C.
~ ~ 10,(.:; ~ -- --- l L)
QI
=>
....
0
V, 9
~ - I
~~ I
I
I 50 ps1g{345 KPaJinlet
~ 8 L 10 ps1g 69 KPa) niet
I
cu ft/h 50 100 150 200 250 (:.)300 350 400 450 500
I I I I I
MBtu/h 250 500 750 1000 1250
~ Range of acceptable
de livery pressure
The following are the three steps in using the performance curve:
1) Start at the bottom of the chart, using the maximum connected load from appliances and
equipment. In the above chart , a maximum load of 700 000 Btu/h has been assumed (point 1
on the graph) .
2) Draw a line straight up that intersects the lowest expected vapour inlet pressure. In this case,
the 75-psig inlet pressure curve was used (point 2) based on the lowest expected tank
operating temperature of 1O °C.
3) Draw a horizontal line from this intersection point to the delivery pressure scale at the left
side of the chart (point 3). In this case, a delivery pressure of 10.5 inches w.c. results , which
is within the acceptable range of 8 to 11 inches w.c .
The process is similar when first- and second-stage regulators are being sized. The first-stage
regulator is sized the same way as the twin-stage regulator. The second-stage regulator is sized
using the delivery pressure from the first-stage regulator as its inlet pressure.
October 2019 59
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Preliminary planning
Make sure that the regulator is properly installed the first time.
To ensure that the regulator is installed properly, properly plan the installation process .
If all the steps are planned properly, the installation process will usually proceed smoothly.
On-site considerations
First , make sure that you have chosen the correct regulator for the system. It must have the
correct orifice and control spring .
Read the manufacturer 's guidelines for installing the type of regulator chosen . As part of the
process of choosing the correct regulator , use a sketch of the piping system . This sketch will also
help to determine what supplies , equipment , and tools you need to complete the job .
When arriving at the site , check the sketch to ensure that the intended location of the regulator is
suitable.
Regulator location
Place the regulator so that it can be easily serviced . There must also be enough room above the
regulator to allow for the removal of the actuator or the spring casing from the body.
Finally , ensure that there is enough room to install a vent and sensing line if they are required .
Check the following items to ensure that the basic requirements for the piping have been met:
• Approved materials have been used for the piping .
• The piping is in an appropriate location.
• The sizing is adequate for present and future applianc es.
Extensive details on approved piping , tubing , and hose systems are in the Code .
Piping connections
1) First , check that there are no misaligned piping conn ections that produ ce strain on th e body
of the regulator . This could crack or warp the body of the regulator and prevent it from
operating corre ctly or cause it to leak gas. Ensure that the piping has proper support so that
it is properly align ed and does not put stress on the regulator .
60 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
2) Use threaded fittings on pipe sizes up to 2 inches to connect a regulator to the piping . On
larger pipe sizes, use flanged connections.
3) If using threaded joints, clean the pipe threads and apply pipe lubricant sparingly to male
threads, being careful to start a few threads from the end of the pipe.
a) Do not tighten the piping into the regulator body so that it causes stress on the regulator .
b) Do not over tighten the pipe threads into the regulator, as this can damage the regulator
body.
The flow direction is shown by an arrow or by the words "inlet" and "outlet" at each end of the
regulator .
If ... Then .. .
A regulator is installed Full inlet pressure will enter the diaphragm casing and will
backwards hold seat closed resulting in no flow .
This pressure is high enough The diaphragm casing may rupture , causing regulator
failure, damage to downstream equipment , and possib ly a
fire and explosion.
Troubleshooting of regulators
Most troubleshooting depends on the type of regulator and is normally covered in the
manufactur er's literature . Never repair or change parts in a regulator unless specifically allowed
in the manufa cturer's certified instructions . Always use the manufacturer's approved
replac ement parts.
Before beginning any tests, check that the regulat or is installed in the line properly and that the
pressure conditions and flow rates are within the design limitations of the regulator. Many
problems may also result from misalignm ent of parts due to the rough handling of the regulator.
If the regulator has a bottom plug (Figure 1-40), remove it and work the valve mechanism up and
down with your finger . The valve should move freely .
October 2019 61
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 1-40
Regulator with bottom plug
Problem Solution
Obstructed vents Clear obstructions.
Foreign material lodged between the seat Remove the material and clean.
and disk
Wrong regulator installed for the Replace the regulator .
application
Failure of mechanical parts due to Replace the parts if allowed by the manufacturer's
corrosion certified instructions. Most residential and light
commercial regulators are non-repairable and
must be replaced.
Table 1-3
Troubleshooting pressure regulators
(Continued)
62 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
(Continued)
October 2019 63
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
64 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
so
B-531-N-R-IM-IMV
B-838-N-R-O-M
3-838-N-R-D-M
50 000 1 - 3- 4 m Yes B-838-IM IMV
56 000 2-3- 4 m S.O B-838-tM-UIAV
A mn 1/d . 1 . 11/4 11< 190 CL-31~"R-IM-IMV
7 'l'ln 1 1/d . I ln.7 17~ 2nn "L2J l-N-R
20000 I 1/2 • 2 150 50 :'.:1,-34-1
D-M-IM-NV
80 000 I tn - 2 150 600 ~1,-3~.2 D-M-IM-NV
40 000 I tn -2 !50 50 " L-'l8-I D-M-IM-IMV
~nnnn I 1/'l.? ,<n ~11n □ -38-lD·M·IM·LvlV
itnnnn l- 3 - 4 1<n ~n '.:1-838-1 D-M-IM-CMV
130.D0
O 2- 3-4 150 300 Cl,.838-l D-M-IM-CMV
600D0O 2-] 275 ]0 0 :W 4000Sc:ne
s
I00D0O I In 230 "'""
Ye:1 ]60 ~ 1700Se:1es
October 2019 65
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
"Pie B42 is a spr ng 1oads<jself-operatedregula:orwith internalrsief opt on. The 842 lea:Jres a molded
diaphragm,6:1 leverratioand one nd'l vent. Tne benefit s a hghte<r>'orecompact LA'lt tnat providesthe
pol'.rer,capacty and re 1elperformanceof largerregu ators.
SP[CrrlCATIONS
66 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Manufacturer In-on PSIG BAR 118" 1/8x3M6'' 3/16" 114" ~ 16'' 318" ·1/2" 112x 9t16''
Type and model 942 R 0.5 0.038 55 [1.6) 60(17) 70 (2 OJ 80(2 .3) 95 (2.7) 210 (59) 270 (7 6) 280 (7 9)
Regu lator 0.069 60 :1 .7) 80 (2 3) 65 (2 4) 200 (5.7) 275 [7.8) 3 00 [8 5) 360( 10.2) Z85 (10 9)
lnlot SIZO. 3/4" I\ PT 2 0.1 60( 2.3) 95 (2 7) 225 (6.A) 250 (7. 1) 365 (10.3) 425 (12.0) 495 (14.0) 485 (13. 7)
Outlet size 314" NPr 3 0.2 105 (3,0) 225 (6.4) 290 (8.2) 350 (9.9) 470 (13.3) 525 (14.9) 595 (16.S) 595 (16.S)
Spr ng oolnr RrO\'-"l 5 03 2 10 (5 9) 280 fl !'I) 4:0 (11 3) r,r.o (14 2l 600 (17 0) 7 15 (?O?) 805c;,:;>II) 830 (73 5)
Position 5 10 0.7 340 (9.6) 390 :11.0) 6:lO (17.0J 850 (24 .1) 940 (26.6) 1085 [30. 7) 1300 (36.8) 13 10 [37. 1)
15 1 .0 425 (12.0 ) 470{13 .J ) 6-"'0 (24. 1) 1 100(31 1) 130 0 (36.8) 1415 (40. 1)
In let E:llect A (on;;hesw.c.) 01 0.2 O.~ 0.4 0.4 0.6 0.6 1.0
Loci< Up B (incheswc.j 04 0.4 0.4 0.5 0.6 06 09 , 1
Not!>S·
A. Charigein outet pressure'or 10 PSIG ,nletpressurechange
8 . Outlet pressure inc rease required for oc< up
•1ndiv idual reg ulatc· performance M.li' vary 'ror, data sh:,w•1.
,
/Iron I B42 Senes Res.denta l Regulator 7
October 2019 67
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Typ e and mo de l ~2 N. R 0.06 9 10!>(30} 2/ 0 (7.6} 23 0 (8.!l) 385 (10 .3) 4 20 ( 11 .9)
Regulato r 2 0 .1 100 (2.8) 220 (62) 300 (8.$) 385 (10.9) 4 50 ( 12.7) 550 (15.6) 590 (18 .7)
lnle:sze 314 NPT 3 0 .2 95 (2.7) 110(3 .1) 270 (7.6) •1<15(12.6) 4<15 (12 .6) 5 15 (14 .6) 600 (18 .4) 720(20 .4)
O ut et size Jl<l"NP T 5 0 .4 100 (4 .2) 280 (7.9) 390 (1 1 0) 5 40 (15.3) 625 (17.7) 7<10 (21 .0) aoo12<1.9) 930 (26 .J)
Son ng colo r Silv er 10 0.7 360 (10 .2) 390( 11 0) 570 (161) 820 (23-2) 960 (27.2) 1 100 (3 1 ") 122:3 (34 7) "27 0 (350)
Pc:sition 5 15 1 .0 460 (13.0) 500 (14 2) 780 (221) 1070 (30 .3) 1250 (35.4) 1550 (38 .2)
20 1.4 560 (15.9) 590 (18 7'J ,coo(28 3) 1320 (374) 1425 (.:0.4) 1575 (44 .6)
.:o 2 .8 9 10 (25 .8) 920 (26.1) 1 600 (45.3) 19SC (55 .2)
60 4 .1
• I-idi, idual ·egu l3X>r peio r,n ance may vary from d 31a sho'l,n .
68 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
srancial'dSpringDa ta
Green
Brrn.•m 6-S"w .c
'Note Ranges a re approximations. Pleese oontad msnufsc:urer to ob:ai n tt-e b est spri ng for your app liostion.
"'Vl/arrung A<l_u&na nl son rigs aro nol ,ntorch angoa b lo bot.•.oon 8 42 a"d e42HP.
ORIFICE DATA , WIDE OPEN FLOW COEFFICIENTS AND MAXIMUM PRESSURES
EmergencyOutlet?tes,;ure (PSIO)
Orifice Si,., ( incJie,;) K - Factor MAOP Emergency Inlet Pressure(PS IGJ
"'°damage++ Contl ln ment++
118 3D 125PS IG 300 30 60
1/8 X 3/16 30 125PS IG 300 30 &J
3116 7"1 125PS IG 200 30 00
October 2019 69
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
325-LSERIES
LeverActingDesignfor 2 psiPipingSystems
M axilrof·s us . L Seri~ fin<-pr('s.~ur('
t('gul,11ois ,UP 1012 psi
riping sy<tf'tn< 12, SPrif'< rf'j\1Jl.1•or< ilff' ior l,<f'<Jn r..s;<lpn ti,11,
, ctmmrrt·1,1I, ,1ncfinrfu~rn,1
1ap p :.c:,1~um<.
.
Specifications
PipeSi7l'S............................. "Ill:!"tn 2" thrP.ir!P<IrnnnP<"tirm, wnh 'IP I or IS07 I th•i>,iri<.
Opt ional ...... ... . •............ 1/8" ,'IPT outlet pre«ure IJP' on 325.7, 325-9, and 325-1 r
..............................J25-Jl, 325-Sl, J25-7Al, 325-9l, 325-1 '1l : A 'I Si Z21.80lCSA6.22 l ine f>re:;s:ire
Certific.1tioos Reguk,tor).
Emergency Exposure Li,nits... .... . 65 psi t43il kP.ii :i,dd , it.le or ,I) ,
M.uimom lndi., id ual load ........ ldri,e,I ~i11gh• l liy lh1• n'l!ulJlur: 125-Jl: 140,000 BII.Jh;
"flfll1dr11.eS<'M:<
l.l C,-·,L: 42,.UUO fltu,11;IL, •7;\L: 1,L,U ,UOORtu1l1; ur,.<Jl: .1.,.1.C,0,0l)!I
RIL./h;
i2 5- 11: ·1,-150,000 R11,.'h
Capa(ily ....... ................... .... ..... lr>:dl ln,1cfoi mu:1rplP.app liEtnc:Pcomh:n P.d
.1}5-.!I rva~,If)"); }50,000 IH1Jh;
315-5L ( 1/2";, 300,000 llt:.i/h: 325-SL 0/1", l '1: 600,000 lltlL'h;
32S-7Al (I l/4", I 1irJ: 1,250,000 B:ull·; 323-9 l :11/2", 2"1:2,250,COOBl~1h:325-11
4.450,CCOOluih
NOTE: C1p~nt i>< ,1•p ;i,.,cf Ill rll'!PrrriN' :hf' m~xcmum muhcplP applian<"Plmrl. Thf' IM};i>'I
sin~lt>ap 11:iJr<:e serve<!O}' tbe r~u:Jtor , bou:d not t'~l"t'<:'<Ithe m ,1x1mu'll indrv ·dua[ load
sl)('lified above,
Ambient Temperature Ranges . -40 10 205 F •:-40to 96 'C
...............Sui1,1bleior pilot flow ,,pplic,1tionc ®
Min imum Regul,1tio11 :o rd<' r110.1 ~ CFH NGi
lmbl ue Technology'' ........... ..... .lH- IL, ·u 5-Sl. !!5-7:\ l. l.!5-'JLmCld d~ m,))' b<.-orckt<YI w ill ' hrblUC' -:-cchnologyr., .. lmb lu<,
T,'<·~n(llog~·'''
inrrt•.:t"<~, <' ,1ncf prov<r
n,rrt1i;1on r<'"i,'it,,n< h~ f'xtrtt r rot1-<: 1ir,t rh,~
t1on ,1g.,
Plf'mPnt, fnr rPf\Hlatnrs11,P<Iin rn.trlnnr ,1ppli1-.111on,.Add ,:iii ix IPIIPr "I!" Tomorlf'I numb,,..
whPn or rfpnnq .
46
Courtesy of Maxitrol Company Inc
70 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
LINE
REGULATORS
Capacities
Capacil 1e. exp1 essedin CFH (m•,11_1~ 0.64 sp gr gas
- - -
Op erat ing Inlet Pn.-ssure
OuU P-1 fN-liCiilU rf'
Moru-1 Pi)ll' Si>I' .5 ps i .75 p,i 1 psi 1., psi 2 psi
S..t P,1int
C:
Ukl'ill (, .2 I.P.i) (C..9kt'al ( 10 .3 ld'al {1l .8 1Pa)
,~
l,'i. 11
.\.·'II~ :c 1::r
,...~.' 1:i-
I U' ,,.._.
C
, 1./ ~P.,1
l lJ.(!"w.C.
H '.1
• · I\
Ill)
. l l'
•.,_.,.,
I ll(!
2.)1.1
; ll
131)
1~0
c-.11
~'lt
...,.,.•
25(1
lSoJ
:;_ .> ~PJJ 1.~---1.
, •:.,.1· , :~-!;_, , ,.11 . ... I:•
.rn..ri :no
HI I L l.·T, 1:2 ·
:,
:; O" w.1
i ,PJJ
lU>
,1() •1 ill, I •l 4 ?·,
;,1n
;14 ~J
,r;(.-1
1l.ol !I
l2S•7AL
1 ,.,..• , 1 1,r
I 1/ri< I 1,r
-1 l ', Pa't •>I ,1 1->P11
~,.,. ,·1,; ""·' :\; "'' t ~'i .a,
,;,.
10 1)' ,, r i,',; 1 1·); 1 ''ii'l
·'.1.5 ~t',\I •l "l 111 1l5 SI •J I." '• :.tl.-lJ •.15 11
;, f),.. 'J: r 1'9 0 ' •1~0 ').'i i) ,,,;o ,,;n
l2VlL
I 1.'2· x I ·,2· · 1.7 ~l'J I ·.lq 41 ~111'!1 ·.f,1.7• n1.11 l·l.1 ~I
:.::· ~ J,,. 10 .0· ., ...:, w.,u 1~blJ l!!J U 'l?SO 22.,IJ
~, 'i ~P:1 ,)q ·:1 {Ai (JI .''i~., .. :( , \,l) 11,l :,I
7 tl"' Y.-.L li iULI 2;,o .l'l~ll I ;D.l HUD
1 v.r ~1 1/l" , I ./ ~P.1) ,·,;1 n1 r;1H 1 .:~1
...0'. ;I); 41 ,;17l .4,
H H ll .r ~1· 10 (1" , ·•• c . I~ -n ,, no 1,qn 4, ;r....-
1 • ;no
•:2:, -~,\J ·1 1 11 1◄111· •1 ,l)IJ ,_!'• •J U ◄! :1:?;,1'-
PressureDrop in r.m
: llxrrP.s~rnd (m3/ hl al O.G4sp 9rnas
dl'I l\ uniher
MA> J .0* \\'. C. (1. , lrf'a) .5 l'"i (3 .4 l<Pa
) .i5 psi (.\ lrPaJ
p:;, . 1,1 14.S ,_L4
.iT1 ,,14 1.6l ,,,1(i vi
U5-' l l
Ub ll •$t>S1
.1,1u •~,.u·,
111.i [.) lt _fft
( e11if i,.rf ~prirr, . . ..... ..... .. ....... 7" tn I I " w.c. : I .7 tn ·•.7 k~)
mAXIT'RC>L.: 47
Courtesy of Maxitro l Compa ny Inc
October 2019 71
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
SPRING
SELECTIUN
CHART
~ ,::
k l 11 IU-U lte~.11.,1
~
Rfj1 It...} ':.
Kbl lC• ll i ..
rJ.ri,,i
v,~le
, n·:<>
.•1
1 D :,n
)1 0(;7
~,,or.1c,1 Cr11 nti ·H
: ,h\'l"
Plnrl t. '>'f.t'
&"! ·
Rr, 1 ,c.•,cr-> Rivi h1~ :"'' ,,_..
, ...
R[, l l( ...1"i,l.(J
Kbl lC-1:~ l
,~ , 11,....
l1k;c~
15 t-.1 -~~)
l(I h.~· 2
)laJ7 R 111 IO ]. ~
~? l• IJl 'IL
R:q,Jl,,t~
,.,~unte·
J· ~t \'t 'l"
~,, •J 2 ,,,. ~t':"'
R \ ~.'".r 1n.·.-I I \Vr "• ~ r,·:, 11
K'•I lC-25 ~1,1..i l I) :,.'i.t.1
R~l l( .• <1'>- Vii:::I<
"' • r,·,,1,
.u.:;q K111lC-l :U2 Kt,J 1( 1h.~ ~2
Rq 1 1(.• 1 "ii.t, ,~, 11,A' 1~ h: "./.
1
W•I 1(:..1:) 2 Uk,.;-~ 2( 11,'1 l
IC!25JIC•: 1 I '.Vi'h ! , .ll :,11
• '\t.1-,,b-'11 ~I''•~
l'ilrtNuml,..,
Min t
Mu
lolor
C"A
1de
,....,.....
U..llel
(In. lv.i•.)
.. I P • h.:1: 1',..>! 1,<•d w it:! :I"!'' -n1r,im.1m ~rin ~•
r - ,1r f,fl '11lft fl in,·, p c.1
~{ · CIUl:l" l) H tl l "< S !o:t:.e
l 3.(1 :u 5.C
MR~IC1R
lOI ~.1.,.. Pl,'11v1 n 1 ·,t .. NCllf : ="•>'•~ 1rpp IMzth 1c r:• .'P,..
.,,;
.1.. a , r, ~,rhP p.1.rp1,cr
" ~-'11nR.,f•I 1-1 ,..1i:n V4'h1·, '} ,; •,: >.'i idt'f'l"iri,-:."t.'i,1, M l y \': 1ri/ -S,1,.,_,,t + 1., ", :1l•hn.,(, h lf\l :0:1'1~·.
t!t
1v,R:.a1<1Al t'II \•hf'\ Pl- Ii ':t •,1 ,)
\ ,1' 1illln~\~ 4 11, ~t :'!h~.--'thec.nr-_;r~.,(J>
.-:-i,.., 1ff .;r lh1c-;
"' -''11•~-,1111 M ,< \:-., 'r.PI -1t1• , 1fi (
N'1INl ,101l11 \.-iir Oluc 1.,1~., 1.ll
~, . , 111
1;, 1111. 1 j\~:)< v,•h1·e ' 11'u .>.~'
4 I ,10I •11- I
~·1R: "-iir- n.ltr.· ,\1~" ] .!l
"-iil"I ~l,11-'.,
~..:._',
il ll t; l JII I M~c ~ ::-'eel _, fl ·u .>.''
1v·,R~I,lrl IQI "-iir r,.-m~,n.J~" .>
~..:..S
•IUt:I l.•11-1 j\~ ;) c V\'h1'e l J ·u '-.J
MR~ I,VJhll \ 1iJ"I r1.i11•.d fl..1 ~II • )
~<.."';.:IO
R nll "-': ii.. L '; ~, , t ,.(.
s' ,li.51(11.!llll-l \i ii\ s ·"'"''
l'l.u<J I.Cl :ul.~l
~~~ i"r(l f:; (JI 1-1
,' ,RSl(ll.lllll ·I
,.._,~, ll
\i ii~ ~,...
\f\•h1•r ~ (I
I .(I
•114 , ';
:u 1.~;
,..,,~
( bla c'..;
mAXITROL: 57
72 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
GOVERNOR Pietro
Standard Model Fiorentini~
CAPACITY IN C FH FOR .60 SPECIFIC GR AVITY GAS WITH FILTER (CAPAC ITY INITHCUTFILTER I\J BRACK ET S)
1 PSIO 2rs 1n
306 (JOO) !152 (649) 78 !1 ~23)
218 (255) 511 (00 11 788 (827)
• ~
~· ~..-
•/.(', S.179 (5854) 9.339 (10,557) 13.278 (1::,,OJ9;
October 2019 73
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
PSIG
Over Pressure Device (C.PD)Model
MainFeatures
■ \•\lorker & Monnor !or adc,;c Saf,aty
■ CSA Certifed 6.22a -2005 ANSI Z21 .80.A2005 Oa% I fo1outlet Ov!lrProssuro Oovico [CPO} Model
lnla:t=-'t"t~l•''" P.;v1!l•
>: 7 · Vt/.c': tv :;P61G
t fl'£GGu1es uµ tu 5 PSIG
01essur;,s up In 1,\ ' 'IN.C c.l'<Jh119
■ CSA CeM6ed S 22E-20'.l5 Al\ SI Z21 BCA2005 Class I for outl;;t
pre-3sL-re3up to 1 !"S IG a~d irlet p•es3ures up too 1-'SIG
■ lntegra Vent Umi:er
■ CSA ;ippr o',oo Extcr!'al Vent Li1"1
rtcr 10 ·,unt line rc,quroo-
■ Pusit r, a '00% bubble liflh l lock1..1
p
■ In let·RM O,Jll,;f fe<d rorts
■ 5CO lo 1 - urnd own
Specflcatloos
■ Sultc1ble for use ·.-Atn\latu ,al 3as,
LPG. <1J1,; ct~er ncn-,;01rc<:: r-,-e, clwn gas
Ven:Slz.es
■ 1/4" NP- 11?" -1 ·
■ Ir.et PrsssJ·a : 7 ' W.C. to 5 PStG CS;l,.~pp-oved
■ 1/2" NP- 1 1.h ' - 4"
■ lo/bx. Inlet 7,25 F-31~for non-CSA
■ Outlet prero ure: 2 · 1N,C. to · 4" WC. fo• CS/1Class I Outlet Spring Range
Outlet p i;w u1e: 2 ' W.C. lo • PSIG 1or CSA Clw,;,,;II
■ Gree11 2" W C. to 6: " WC.'
Outlet prescure: 2' W .C. to 4 25 PSIG for 1,)1-CSA
■ Red 2.7:5"'I·,'.c. to 7.87'' W,G'
■ TeP1perature raf(le -40' F I<• 1[-O"F ■ Bl.:.J<6''1N.C. bJ 14' W.C.'
■ Gonnecli om : ,., .. thru 4"
■ Yellcw 9 8" W.C. tc, 27 :3" V• ! .C.'
■ t•1tlximu11::me-gency Inlet Expo~ure: P·essure: 80 PSIG ■ Vc 'ot 23 .6" WC. to :,,rw.c.Of 0.8:0 to 2 • 3 PSIG •
■ Suiwble for l~ooo r or Gv tcoo r lri;ta .ation ■ Ora,~G t,:, ' w.c. to • • 8" \IV C. 0' 2 to 4 .2 6 PSIG
74 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
GOVERNOR Pietro
Over Pressu re Device {OPD) Model Fiorentini•
C APACITY IN CFH FOR .60 SPECIFIC GRAVITY GAS WITH f ll TE R (CA 0 ACI-Y W ITHOUT FILTER N BRACKETS }
October 2019 75
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Overpressure protection
Overview
Purpose
An overpressure condition occurs when the pressure downstream of a regulator exceeds the
maximum pressure rating of any downstream components. If the pressure regulator should
happen to fail , components downstream that are not rated for the pressure upstream could be
damaged . Due to the importance of protecting the system , overpressure protection should be a
primary consideration in the design of any piping system.
Objectives
At the end of this chapter, you will be able to :
• describe overpressure protection ;
• describe relief valves;
• describe the function and types of pressure limiting systems; and
• describe security shut-off systems.
Terminology
Term Abbreviation Definition
(symbol}
Pressure buildup over For the relief valve to fully open, the pressure
setpoint (buildup) must build up to some level above the setpoint
of the relief valve.
Introduction
Overpressure occurs when pressure downstream of a regulator exceeds the maximum pressure
rating of any downstr eam component. It indicates a failure in the system that could result in a
dangerous condition. Overpressure protection is a primary consideration in the design of any gas
piping system.
The objective in providing overpressure protection is to maintain the pressure downstr eam of the
regulator at a safe maximum value. This means ident ifying the weakest part in the pressure
system, then limiting overpressure to that component's maximum pressure rating .
76 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
• the piping.
The lowest maximum pressure rating of any of these components is the maximum allowable
pressure .
The worst-case conditions of regulator failure are those in which the regulator fails in either a fully
closed or wide-open position .
Position Description
A fully closed regulator • Produces an underpressure condition .
• This is not damaging to equipment but may create
dangerous conditions in the combustion chamber .
• This condition can be detected with pressure switches that
will shut the equipment down until gas pressure is restored .
A fully open regulator • Causes excessive pressure conditions that are damaging to
equipment and create a potentiall y dangerous situation.
• These conditions can be controlled by using some form of
overpressure protection .
There are three selection criteria to evaluate the various methods of overpressure protection:
With this in mind , briefly examine the advantag es and disadvantages of the three methods of
overpressure protection as shown in Table 2-1.
October 2019 77
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Table 2-1
Advantages and disadvantages of different methods of overpressure protection
Relief valves
Relief valves maintain the pressure downstream of a regulator at a safe maximum value using
any device that vents fluid to a lower pressure system (often the atmosphere). They are
considered to be one of the most reliable types of overpressure protection available and are
popular for several reasons, including the following:
• They do not block the normal flow through a line .
• They do not decrease the capacities of regulators they protect.
• The noise and the odour act as an alarm if they vent to atmosphere.
Pressure buildup
A relief valve has a setpoint at which it begins to open.
For the valve to fully open, the pressure must build up to some level above the setpoint of the
relief valve. This is known as pressure buildup over setpoint, or more simply , buildup (Figure 2-1 ).
78 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-1
Pressure buildup
Pressure
buildup
Relief valve
_______________________ • setpoint
~
::I
"'
"'
...
Q)
Cl.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Regulator
setpoint
Lockup Droop
Flow
Figure 2-2
Pop-type relief valve
Loading
spring
Poppet
Seat
ring
October 2019 79
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Operation
Pop-type designs register pressure directly on a spring opposed poppet , as shown in Figure 2-2 .
The poppet assembly includes a soft disk for tight shut-off against the seat ring.
When the inlet pressure increases above the relief valve's set pressure , the poppet assembly is
pushed away from the metal seat. As the poppet rises , pressure registers against a greater
surfac e area of the poppet. This dramatically increases the force on the poppet , so the poppet
tends to travel to th e fully open position until the overpressure condition is reduced.
This style of relief valve does not throttle the flow over a pressure range. Because of its on/off
nature , it may create pressure surges in the downstream system .
If the relief valve capacity is significantly larger than the failed regulator's capacity , the relief valve
may overcompensate each time it opens and closes, causing downstream pressure to become
unstable.
Setpoint
The setpoint of a pop-type valve cannot be adjusted by the user. This is a safety measure that
prevents tampering with the relief valve setpoint. A pinned spring retainer, initially loaded by the
manufacturer , keeps the spring in position.
Application
This type of relief valve is almost exclusively used by natural gas distributors upstream of the
building meter set where venting to the atmosphere is acceptable and where relief pressure
variations are allowable . It is low in cost and its small size allows installation where space is
limited .
This relief valve looks like an ordinary direct operated regulator , except that it senses upstream
pressure rather than downstream pressure . It also uses a spring close action and contains the
same essential elements as a direct operated regulator (Figure 2-3) :
Element Description
Diaphragm Measures the system pressur e
Loading spring Provid es the initial load to the diaphragm and is used to
establish relief setpoint
Restri cting element Throttles the flow
80 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-3
Direct operated relief valve
Diaphragm
Valve
ow<;>
D System pressure
D
Lower-pressure area
(usually atmosphere)
October 2019 81
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-4
Pitot tube operated relief valve
Loading
Diaphragm
Application
Direct operated relief valves are commonly used in natural gas systems supplying commercial
enterprises like restaurants and laundries , and in industrial furnaces.
Element Description
Loading element Its own light-loading spring
Measuring element Shares the main measuring diaphragm
Restricting element Located in the centre of the main measuring diaphragm
82 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Operation
When no gas is flowing and the downstream pressure is normal, both the internal relief valve and
the valve disk are closed (Figure 2-Sa).
During normal operation of the regulator , the underside of the main diaphragm senses
downstream pressure , while the main loading spring applies a loading force to the top side . The
small loading spring of the relief valve has no effect on normal regulator operation.
Changes in downstream pressure alter the force applied to the underside of the main diaphragm.
This produces movement in the position of the diaphragm and a corresponding change in the
position of the disk and seat in the restricting element.
Overpressure conditions develop when the downstream pressure increases above the setpoint of
the regulator . This is usually a result of dirt lodging between the disk and seat , or of internal
component failure. When an overpressure condi tion develops , the downstream pressure lifts the
main diaphragm until the relief valve seat com es in contact with the pusher post (Figure 2-Sb). At
this point , any increase in downstream pressure compresses both the main and relief loading
springs. When sufficient force is applied, the main diaphragm and the relief valve seat separates
and allows gas flow to pass through the centre opening in the diaphragm to the relief valve
opening.
The amount of pressure buildup over setpoint depends on the spring rate of the relief valve spring
and the size of the main regulator orifice . Remember that to keep pressure buildup to a minimum ,
the main regulator orifice should be the smallest size that maintains the maximum required flow
rate .
October 2019 83
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GA S TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-5
Internal relief valve
Diaph ragm
Int ernal relief Valve
valve disk
Pusher pos
Seat ring
1f
(b) Internal relief in operation due to high
downstream pressure
Application
Internal relief valves are used in se rvice regulat ors, line pressur e regulat ors, and appliance
regulators for industrial equipment.
84 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Once the type of system and the pressure ranges that the system can safely handle are
established , consult manufacturers ' tables before choosing a relief valve.
Note: You should be able to set the pressure on a pressure relief valve at a higher value than the
pressure on the regulator, but it should still be in the range of downstream pressure limitati ons.
Vent ing of relief valves is also covered extensive ly in the Code . Check the Code for all the
relevant regulations before planning a venting system for a pressure relief valve .
In particular , sizing relief valve vents are covered in Clause 5.5 of the CSA B149 .1 Code . The
manufacturer's rule of thumb for sizing relief valve vents is that it must be the size of the outlet if
the termination point is less than 1Oft (3 m) away from the relief valve . For every addit ional 1Oft
(3 m) farther away it is, the vent outlet must increas e one size . A 90° elbow has an equivalent
length of 3 ft (1 m). For long lengths , conta ct the manufacturer or the authority having jurisdiction.
Figure 2-6
Manufacture 5 psi line pressure regulator assembly
Courtesy of Pietro Fiorentini S.p .a.
October 2019 85
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-7
2 psi meter set
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Wide-open monitors
Wide-open monitor regulator systems are simply a pair of regulators piped in series , with both
regulators sensing pressure downstream of the second regulator , as shown in Figure 2-8.
86 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-8
Monitor regulator system
Worker Monitor
regulator regulato r
(b)
One of the regulators is known as the monitor and the other as the worker. Under normal
operating conditions, the monitor regulator is always wide open because the monitor regulator
setpoint is slightly higher than the worker regulator setpoint. The monitor regulator only starts
regulating if the worker regulator fails.
The terms refer to the location of the monitor regulator in reference to the worker regulator.
Figure 2-7(a) shows an upstream wide-open monitor, and Figure 2-6(b) shows a downstream
wide-open monitor .
Systems can be changed from upstream to downstream mon itors and vice versa, simply by
reversing the setpoints of the two regulators.
October 2019 87
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Series regulation
Series regulation is also known as two cut systems (Figure 2-10) . Like the monitor system, they
have two regulators set in the same pipeline and are available as preassembled units for 5 psi
line pressure regulators (Figure 2-9).
Figure 2-9
Maxitrol 5 psi line pressure regulator assemble
Courtesy of Maxitrol Company
325-3L47
The first unit maintains an inlet pressure to the second valve that is within the maximum allowable
operating pressure of the downstream system. Under this setup, if either regulator should fail , the
resulting downstream pressure maintained by the other regulator would not exceed the safe
maximum pressure.
Figure 2-10
Series regulation system schematic
_ ± _____.____
I J: _____.___I
__
Working monitors
Working monitors use design elements from both series regulation and wide-open monitors . In a
working monitor installation , the two regulators work continuously as series regulators to take two
pressure cuts (Figure 2-11). Because both regulators are working, both are less likely to become
clogged , sluggish, or stuck.
88 October 2019
Pressure regulators , overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-11
Working monitor
orker
pilot
p int-ermediate
The worker pilot is connected as in series regula tion and controls the intermediate pressure . Its
setpoint is at some intermediate value that allows the system to take two pressure drops .
The monitor pilot is in series ahead of the worker pilot and is connected so that it senses
downstream pressure . Its setpoint is set slightly higher than the required pressure.
When both regulators are performing properly , downstream pressure is below the setting of the
monitor pilot, so it is fully open , trying to raise system pressure. Standing wide open, the monitor
pilot allows the worker pilot to control the intermediate pressure. As demand changes, the
downstream regulator adjusts flow and causes some change in the intermediat e press ure. The
worker pilot on the upstream regulator senses the change in the intermediate pressure and
ca uses a repositioning of the upstream regulator. In this way, both regulators can work in
response to changes in the pressure demand.
Automatic shut-off
Also known as overpressure shut-off (OPSO) or slam-shut (Figure 2-12), this devi ce was
previously introduced in the "Safety features " section of the previous chapter.
As with pressure, limiting the shutoff device also accomplishes overpressure protection by
containment. In this case, the gas is shut off completely until the cause of the malfun ction is
determin ed and the device is manually reset. Many gas distribution companies use this as an
added measure of protection for places of public assembly such as schools, hospitals , churches ,
and shopping centers . In those cases, the shutoff device is a secondary form of overpressure
protection . Shutoff valves are also commonly used by boiler manufactur ers in combustion
systems .
October 2019 89
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-12
Fisher CS8600 series regulator
Courtesy of Emerson Automation Solutions
The regulator typically has a token internal relief to avoid nuisance trips of the slam-shut
mechanism due to a small pressure increase from minor orifice damage or a small obstruction
(Figure 2-13) .
Figure 2-13
Token relief releasing gas
Courtesy of Emerson Automation Solutions
The integral slam-shut trips in the event of overpressure conditions. The safety plug is forced
onto the slam-shut seat, providing complete shutoff of the gas flow to the downstream system
(Figure 2-14) .
90 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 2-14
Slam-shut activated
Courtesy of Emerson Automation Solutions
Some models also slam-shut if an under pressure condition occurs . This is referred to as under
pressure cut-off (UPCO)
Meters
Overview
Purpose
A gas technician /fitter routinely measures gas flow rates to determine inputs . Calculating flow
rates accurately requires a thorough knowledge of gas meter types , their operation, gas
measurement standards, and correction factors .
Objectives
At the end of this chapter, you will be able to :
• describe types of meters ; and
• determine gas flow rates .
October 2019 91
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Terminology
Term Abbreviation Definition
(Symbol}
Burner input See Firing rate (e.g ., Btu/h , kW)
Clocking a meter Using a meter to determine the input of a gas
appliance
Firing rate Amount of heat in the combustion chamber
Standard cubic foot SCF Quantity of gas contained in a cubic foot at the
base temperature of 60 °F and base pressure of
14 .73 psia
Standard cubic metre SCM The quantity of gas contained in a cubic metre
at the base temperature of 15 °F and base
pressure of 101.325 kPa
MBH Thousands of BTUs per hour
Types of meters
Each piece of gas equipment is designed to produce a specific amount of heat in the combustion
chamber. This amount of heat is called the firing rate or burner input.
Gas regulations require that the burner input be checked to ensure that it conforms to the
equipment manufacturer's specifications. These are found on the rating plate attached to the
appliance.
The common meters used in gas measurement may be grouped into two categories:
Meter Description
Displa ce ment • Measure the total quantity, or volume, of gas that has passed
meters through the meter at the time of the reading
• Can be adapted to provide rate of flow
Rate of flow meters • Measure the instantaneous gas flow rate
• Can have totalizers to provide total volume flow
Displacement meters
Displa cement meters operate on the principle of positive volumetric displa cement. A precise
volume of gas passing through the meter is meas ured.
Two common types are used in the residential and commercial markets. These are:
• diaphragm (bellows) meter ; and
• rotary (geared or lobed impeller) meter.
92 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Two bellows alternately fill and empty as the gas flows through the meter. The movement of the
bellows is transferred through a series of linkages and gears that record the move ment as a
volume of gas on the display.
Diaphragm meters have capacities of up to 10 500 cu ft/h (300 m3/h) when the piping system
operates at less than 10 inches w.c. (2.5 kPa).
Figure 3-1
Diaphragm meter
Inlet
A temp erature co rrection device (Figure 3-2) monitors the temperature of the gas flowing through
the meter and causes the display dials to move slower in response to thinner hot gas or faster in
response to denser cold gas, such that the end result is that the reco rded gas volume is
corrected to standard conditions of 1 ft3 at 60 °For 1 m3 at 15 °C.
October 2019 93
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 3-2
Curved bimetallic temperature correction device
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Figure 3-3
Rotary meter
Figure 3-4 shows the cross-section of a rotary meter at two stages of impeller movement. The
two impellers are synchronized to rotate within a close-fitting housing. As the impellers turn , they
displa ce a fixed volume of gas with each revolution , causing a slight differential pressure across
the rotor. This allows a measured volume of gas to be discharged through the bottom of the
meter.
94 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
A gear train transmits the number of rotations to a dial that displays the gas volume discharged.
Figure 3-4
Cross-section of rotary meter shows two stages of impeller movement
Inlet Inlet
Measuring
Lobed compartment
impeller
(a) (b)
Rotary meters are oil filled , and the oil must be changed at least every two years.
Orifice meters
Orifice meters can be used for measuring air and gas flows on large commercial and industrial
appliances . They simplify th e combustion setup adjustments made on nozzle mixing burners.
The meter consists of the primary flow element and a differential flow transmitt er. The primary
element in these meters is an orifice plate in the pipe, which creates a differential pressure that
varies in relation to the rate of flow (see Figure 3-5) as per Bernoulli 's principle.
October 2019 95
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 3-5
Orifice meter with differential pressure measured on a manometer
--~
__________
---- --=
----- -- --
~
-
A differential pressure flow transmitter converts the differential pressure across the ports into an
electronic signal (Figure 3-6). To obtain an accurate reading , there should be a suitable
straightening of the gas flow upstream of the orifice .
96 October 2019
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 3-6
Orifice flow meter
Gas meters are usually rated in metric or imperial units , and a gas technician/fitter should be able
to convert between the two.
Being able to read and understand the reading on the meter gives the technician/fitter an
indication as to whether the appliance is operating properly.
October 2019 97
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
To make accurate calculations of the quantity of heat in the combustion chamber , identify the
calorific value of the gas in the piping system . If the calorific value is unknown , contact your local
gas utility company .
The gas industry usually accepts the following calorific values for the three main fuel gases :
• natural gas -1000 Btu/cu ft or 10.35 kW/m 3
• propane - 2520 Btu/cu ft or 26 kW/m3
• butane - 3260 Btu/cu ft or 33.7 kW/m 3
Display Description
Dial-type • The dial type meters are read according to the manufacturer's design
of the display to determine the overall consumption of gas through
the meter.
. However, there are one or two additional test dials located on dial-
type meters that a gas techni cian/fitter can use to check the piping
system for leaks and check the input of individual appliances .
• The latter procedure is often called "clocking the meter " .
Direct reading-type • Direct reading type of meters are easier to read than dial types
because the actual reading is displayed as a number indicating cubic
meters or cubic feet of gas .
• However, like the dial-type meter , the diaphragm direct reading type
of meter has one or two test dials on it that a gas technician /fitter can
use to check th e piping system for leaks and check the input of
individual appliances .
Information on reading the meters is available from the local gas utility .
98 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 3-7
Gas meter displays
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
1 B 7 S X 10 0 •
Modern rotary meters typically have an LED direct read display with multiple readout screens for
different functions . Instead of test dials , the scroll pushbuttons are used to access the flow rate
screen . Figure 3-8 shows the consumption screen on the left and the flow rate screen on the
right.
Figure 3-8
Electronic rotary meters
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Dial-type meter
There are two types of dials on a dial-type gas meter :
October 2019 99
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Dial Description
Consumption dials Indicate the amount of gas that has been consumed and provides
information to the gas utility for billing purposes
Test dials Are used to determine the input to appliances and to indicate if there
are any downstream leaks in the gas line
Figure 3-9 shows a typical dial-type gas meter and how the dials are read .
Note: Figure 3-9 show s a meter that measures in cubic feet. Meters may also measure in cubic meters.
Figure 3-9
A dial-type gas meter
1.,00 0
~ Consumption
v.-dials
l>f "' P. t. ~
0
CUBIC
FEET
TEMPERATURE
COMPENSATED
6) Using the Imperial or metric formula given below , determine the volume of gas that would
pass through the meter in one hour . Convert this volume to the amount of Btu/h that would
be produced by that type of gas (i.e ., multiply by 1000 Btu/ft3 for natural gas or 2500 Btu/ft3
for propane) and compare this to the input rating of the appliance given on the rating plate .
The measured input of an appliance should not exceed the rated input or be less than 90% of its
rated input.
For example , if the average time for one revolution of a 0.5 ft3 natural gas meter dial was 30
seconds , the imperial formula is:
At other times, an appliance rated in Btu may be connected to a meter showing its gas flow in
cubic meters - or vice versa. In such cases , you use conversion factors to determine burner
input in Imperial or metric values . Table 3-1 shows the Imperial and metric equivalences used in
converting between the measurements.
Table 3-1
Equivalences
Based on natural gas having a calorific value of 1000 Btu per cu ft , Table 3-2 shows conversion
factors used in calculating burner input.
Table 3-2
Burner input conversion factors
Btu/h kW
1 cu ft/h 1,000 0 .293
1 m3/h 35 ,310 10.35
Where Description
Q Flow rate (cu ft/h or m3/h)
3600 Seconds per hour (constant)
V Volume of test dial (cu ft or m3)
t Time per revolution of test dial (in seconds)
Pa Local atmospheric pressure (psia or kPa)
Pw Working pressure of gas in meter (psia or kPa)
Ps Standard pressure (14.73 psia or 101.325 kPa)
Example
The 2 cu ft test dial takes 18 seconds to complete one revo lution.
Calculate the flow rate to a burner in standard cubic feet if the working pressure in the meter is 5
psig and the local atmospheric pressure is 14.35 psia.
Solution
0=[36 00><2c:u ji- - 14.35psi(J+5p.~ig
- 18 .~l!c _ l 14.73psia
Most gas meters are equipped with temperature compensating dev ices to correct the actual
volume of gas that passes through the meter to a standardized volume measurement at a
standardized temperature (1 cubic foot at 60 °For 1 cubic metre at 15.4 °C).
When temp erature is a factor in measuring flow rate with gas pressures over 0.5 psig , and the
meter is not corrected, use the following formula to calculate the flow rate.
Where Description
Ts Base temperature (60 °F or 15 °C in absolute units)
T Temperature of gas at meter in absolute units
Example
A 5 cu ft test dial takes 20 seconds to complete one revolution.
The local atmospheric pressure is 14.55 psia and the pressure of the gas in the gas meter is 10
psig.
Solution
) = [3600 x .fou Ji- - 14.55psw + 10psig ] 60 " F + 460)p R
{ 20 sec _ 14.73 f!.~ia 45 " F + -160r R
=900 c:uji/hxJ.66xJ,(i2
= 154-1
.49 Sid rn.f(/h
The local weather bureaus generally report barometric pressures that are corrected to sea level.
In the above equation, the actual barometric pressure must be used . This can be obtained from
the weather bureau.
Electronic correctors
Electronic metering systems do all the things mechanical devices do (Figure 3-10) , plus they
have many more features such as continuous temperature , pressure , correction factor readouts,
indications of gas flow conditions , and storage of load survey data. Some of this information can
be accessed by the gas fitter using the scroll buttons , whereas more detailed information requires
a computer connection with the appropriate software. The amount of information that can be
accessed depends on the type and complexity of the device.
Figure 3-10
Electronic volume device for a gas rotary meter
Electronic metering devices are typically found on large commerc ial and industrial installations .
Electronic correctors employ a magnetic sensing device to sense each rotation of the meter that
represents the non-compensated (UNG-un corrected) meter gas volume . The volumetric input
pulses are also converted to base measurement conditions (CCR-corrected) .
A TCI converts gas volume from operating condi t ions to reference temperature conditions . The
temperature is measured by a temperature sensor located in the temperature well of the meter . A
pressure transducer is also mounted inside the meter or as a separate piping connection .
An EVC converts gas volume from operating conditions to reference pressur e and temperature
conditions. The temperature is measured by a temperature sensor located in the temperature of
the meter . A pressure transducer is also mounted inside the meter or as a separate piping
connection.
The pressure and temperature correction factors are calculated by the same formulas previousl y
mentioned . Depending on how the utility has set up the meter display, there are many parameters
that could be viewed . Figure 3-11 shows the gas temperature and the calculated correction factor
for a TCI. Because this meter is located indoors , the gas temperature is above the 15 ° C base
conditions; therefore, the correction factor is less than one. Notice that the temperature correction
factor is quite small unless the temperatures are very extreme .
104 October 20 19
Pressure regulators , overpress ure protection , meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Figure 3-11
TCI temperature displays
Courtesy of Camosun College, Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
~\
~~ C>:n1l E":K9 Lt.cl
LR59121
Al,l 0414
1
~
Ai\ I:• a E C M 2 14
lltCTRON ICA LLY COMPENSArED METf:R
In Figure 3-12, the two screens of an EVC unit show the absolute pressure on the left and the
pressure correction factor on the right.
Figure 3-12
EVC pressure factor display
Courtesy of Camosun College, Rodney Lidstone, licenced under CC BY
R
L 1:.d .
AdEm -Prz
,_.
._
- ..........
aDC.,_A
Wll'IMa
.. .......,...~
C....OUf'Vl'IIU.H:VOlT~
.....,,...IUIINII:
IEl ........
••Jrf"C~-. ,.,
.--.,w•
..........
~
,OII IN
f!Ar~~
ALLAOfrllDYl,
."
O ... ..a,o.o
• rtwn- .. ~ '
When using EVC unit for clocking purposes, the test dial display, also known as the live flow rate ,
may or may not be corrected depending on the parameter settings. You may have to contact the
utility or meter manufacturer to verify which parameters are being displayed. The meter shown in
Figure 3-13 is displaying the live corrected flow rate in cu ft/h for a 55 MBH appliance . This is
useful for checking the appliance input , as there is no need to clock the meter or perform any
correction factor calculations. You only need to multiply the flow rate by the appropriate CV of the
gas for that area. Be aware that the utility could have the meter set up to display the live flow rate
as cu ft/h or m3/h.
Figure 3-13
Live corrected flow rate in cu ft/h
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
i
L td .
ANADA
AdEm -Prz
;==:
===~
_ _ ___ ! SIN
__, !I II
..,__..
-D
Y S#E
"-OIi$
!i&CU"'T£ lloT-QOE FOA US(
-- ...LA.!s-:-s'r,w:":.=~~~~~:r1.!:',
"•~ ~-1.t
Condu ct the following steps to use a diaphragm meter to leak test a piping system:
1) Turn off all gas consuming devices (appliances and pilots) as close to the appliance as
possible.
2) Mark the position of both test dials on the meter display using a non-p ermanent marker. See
Figure 3-9.
3) After waiting at least ten minutes, check to see if either dial has moved from the marked
position.
Movement of the test dials indicates that gas has passed through the meter and is leaking from
the pipe (if all gas-consuming devices have been completely shut off). The source of the leak
must be inve stigated and corrected.
Both test dials are marked during the meter leak test in case one dial moves back to its original
position at the end of the test. Since the two dials are moving at different speeds , they are
unlikely to both return to their original position.
Fuel containers
Overview
Purpose
Propane gas equipment is normally supplied from either a cylinder or a tank . To ensure a steady
supply of gas , the container and accessories must be sized and installed to meet the appliance
needs under all temperature and weather co nditions.
Objectives
At the end of this chapter, you will be able to :
• describe cylinders , tanks , and accessories ; and
• describe how to size and install cylinders and tanks .
Terminology
Term Abbreviation Definition
(Symbol)
Prestolite threaded POL Fitting unique to vapour service that cannot
connection accidentally be connected to a liquid line
Service con nection Outl et of the service valve
Wetted surface area Specific area of the tank that comes in contact
with the propane liquid
Natural gas is normally suppli ed from a natural well. It trav els from the well through a large
pipeline to a city or town gate station operated by local utility . From here it is distributed to each
building via service piping. It passes through a meter set before it reaches the consumer. A
steady supply of natural gas is ensured if the piping and tubing systems, as well as th e required
pressure regulators, are operating correctly .
For propane , sufficient storage capacity is required to meet the total demand of installed
appliances and equipment , especially during cold weather. It is thus extremely important to select
the correct propane container .
Propane companies normally lease propane tanks and cylinders to customers and then provide a
filling service for the tank and an exchange service for the cylinder .
Propane cylinders are intended for transportation both empty and filled, and tanks are intended to
remain stationary once they are placed in service and filled.
Due to the need for safety , a number of standards and regulations that govern the type , location ,
and size of propane storage containers are in place. Refer to CSA B149 .2 , Propane storage and
handling code , for these requirements .
Cylinders
The CSA B149.2 Code states that all cylinders must be fabricated , tested , inspe cted , and legibly
marked in accordance with CSA B339 , Cylinders , spheres , and tubes for the transportation of
dangerous goods , and the Transportation of Dangerous Goods Regulations from Transport
Canada (www.tc.gc .ca) .
Refillable cylinders will have the important information shown in Figure 4-1 stamped on their
protective collar .
Figure 4-1
Typical propane cylinder markings
A B C D
---
F SJN - 1234 21.6 L
H I 04 0 4
\.. RETEST
108 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Information Description
Construction Standard Only TC standards are currently acceptable in Canada. However ,
older cylinders may reference CTC or DOT (e.g. , CTC/DOT 240
4BA) .
Note: "M" at the end indicates metr ic units.
Manufacturer 's name Such as : Worthington , Manchester , etc .
Date of manufacture Such as : 1210 or Dec 10
Date of re-inspection Cylinders with a water capacity of 240 lb or less must be recertified
within 10 years of the date of manufacture or date of re-inspection .
The cylinder recertification facility must stamp the collar with the
cylinder's identifi cation number and date of recertification (e.g.,
MO311096).
Note: Prior to June 1994 , it was acceptab le to simply stamp the date of re-
inspecti on followed by an "E" meaning visual re-inspection.
Tare weight of the When using a scale to fill, note that the weight of the cylinder and
cylinder valves when empty is added to the weight of propane put into it.
Some cylinders have a "spit valve" for filling without a scale. The
spit valve is a small orifice threaded valve equipped with a dip tube
that extends down to the 80% level of the tank . When the spit valve
is manually opened during filling operations , it will start to spit liquid
propane when the liquid level reaches 80% at which time the filling
operation must be stopped.
Cylinders manufactured after January 1, 2008, with a capacity of
40 lb (18.2 kg) or less were required to have an overfill prevention
device (OPD) in compliance with UL 2227 , Standard for Overfilling
Prevention Devices. An OPD , as shown in Figure 4-2 , preven ts
filling beyond the 80% capacity.
Working pressure rating Usually given as 375 psig (2586 kPa) since the relief set point of
cylinder relief valves is 375 psig
Figure 4-2
Overfill preventi ,on device (OPD)
Cylinders come in a variety of size s. Figure 4-3 s hows the common sizes as we ll as compon ents
of a typical propane cylinder .
Figure 4-3
Sizes of propane cylinders
Neck ring
Service valve
wi th integ ral
-J 1--...~.-.H,,.-.:--
pressure relief
device
Cylinder
Seam
lOOlbs
lOOlbs
Foot ring
Table 4-1 lists some of the co mmon propane cylinders, together with their applications and
characteristics.
Table 4-1
Common propane cylinders - applications and characteristics
(Continued)
Tanks
When a larger installation is planned , propane storage tanks are often required to deliver a
sufficient flow of propane to meet the demand of connected appliances. Tanks may also be
preferred when the number of cylinders required is inconvenient to handle or when the delivery
schedule is not frequent enough to ensure a continuous supply.
As with propane cylinders, propane storage tanks have a label attached to them to identify their
characteristics . A typical ASME propane storage tank nameplate is shown in Figure 4-4.
Figure 4-4
Typical ASME propane storage tank nameplate
■
ANYTOWN, ONTARIO, CANADA
I
SH. THK .
S/N
CRN
HD. THK.
SIZE
0.1.N.
Information Description
MAWP • Gives the maximum allowable working pressure
• Minimum is 250 psig
CAP • Gives the tank capa city in US wat er gallons
CRN • The Canadian registration number
112 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Information Description
• Indicates compliance with the Code and the regulations
0 .1.N. (in Ontario) • In Ontario , the 0.1.N. indicates compliance with Ontario
regulations for pressure vessels.
Above ground or underground • The label will also state whether it is for above-ground
service or unde rground service.
The style of the nameplate varies among manufacturers and between the US and Canada.
Table 4-2 lists the applications and characteristics of some common ASME propane storage
tanks.
Table 4-2
Common ASME propane storage tanks - types and characteristics
(Continued)
Figure 4-5
Stationary cylinder valves
Courtesy of Camosun College, Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Service valve
Safety pressure relief valve
Filler valve
Portable cylinders have only one opening in the service end. A combination service valve is
usually installed in this opening .
POL valves are the oldest standard for propane tank connections. They have a left-hand thread
on the inside of the valve outlet (Figure 4-6) . The POL fitting is unique to vapour service and
cannot accidentally be connected to a liquid line.
Figure 4-6
POL thread for vapour service
Left-hand
thread
ace connection used for Acme valves (Figure 4-7) differs from POL valves in its size and use of
external threads. Easier to use ace connection ca n be tightened by hand . Acme propane valves
are also compatible with appliances that have POL connections, as they also have the internal
left-hand threads. A big advancement over the POL valve is the addition of a built-in safety device
that allows gas to flow only when the tank is attached to a device , preventing accidental leakage
while being stored.
Figure 4-7
Acme service valve
Courtesy of Camosun College , Rodney Lidstone , licenced under CC BY
Liquid service connections usually have a special thread (Figure 4-8) designed by the
Compressed Gas Association (CGA). This unique fitting prevents the valve from being
accidentally connected to a vapour service valve. Unlike the vapour withdrawal valve, the liquid
withdrawal valve has a right-hand thread.
Figure 4-8
CGA thread for liquid service
Nipple
Cylinders and tanks may also have changeover manifold assemblies attached to them (Figure 4-
9) . These devices are used in installations where ther e are two cylinders or tanks in use. It allows
the propane supply to be switched from the supply tank to a reserve tank when the propane
pressure in the supply tank drops below a certain point. This changeover is done without
disrupting the supply.
The main supply tank can then be refilled while the reserve tank continues to supply propane to
the attached systems. The manifold assembly has a method of indicating that it has switched the
supply from one tank to another.
There are many different types of changeover manifold assemblies , but they all perform the same
operation. For information on specific manifold assemblies, consult the manufacturer 's
instructions.
Figure 4-9
Auto changeover valve
Courtesy of Rego Products
Connectors
A common type of connection on propane tanks and cylinders is a pigtail (Figure 4-10). This type
of copper tubing forms part of the vapour withdrawal system. It allows for flexibility in movement
of the rest of the piping in the system.
Figure 4-10
A pigtail
--
'
I
'
._ __ ---I
I' 1----"""" ""<1
Filler valve
Stationary tanks and cylinders and tanks , rather than filling through the service valve, will have a
separate filler valve to prevent interruption of service. The double check valve design allows fuel
to enter the tank but prevents the propane from escaping when the fill hose is disconnected.
Figure 4-11
Double back-check filler valve
Protective cap
Upper check
closing spring
Uppe r
back-check
(soft seating)
Lower
back-check
Lower check (hard seating)
closing spring
Figure 4-12
External safety relief valve
Spring retainer
Spring
Valve body
Weep hole
eat disc
Figure 4-13
Float gauges
Courtesy of Rotarex SGR
Figure 4-14
Fixed liquid level gauge
Plug
Restricting
orifice
Body
Figure 4-15
Excess flow valve
Courtesy of Rego Products
The most common combination is the service and safety relief valve.
The service and safety relief combination valve comes in two distinct forms: one for vapour
service, the other for liquid service. Each combination valve is des igned to be used solely with
either vapour or liquid containers.
Vapour service
The combination valve shown in Figure 4-16 is designed for vapour service only. On portable
cylinders, the outlet connection will be used for both service and filling . This combination valve is
also equipped with a relief valve and a fixed liquid level gauge. The relief valve is only designed
to relief gas; therefore , it is important that portable tanks with this type of valve be installed and
transport in the upright position .
Figure 4-16
POL combination valve
Courtesy of Rego Products
All small capac ity cylinders (4# to 40#) now come from the factory equipped with an OPD. A
cylinder that comes with an OPD can be recognized by the unique triangular-shaped hand wheel
(Figure 4-17) as well as by the letters OPD stamped on the valve and the valve handle.
Figure 4-17
OPDvalve
OPD handle
Typical
old style handle
Liquid service
A combination valve used for liquid withdrawal is shown in Figure 4-18. It is designed for liquid
service since it comes with a CGA 555 connection.
Figure 4-18
Combination valve for liquid service
Liquid service
outlet (CGA 555)
Vapour
(to relief
Excess-flow I valve only)
valve
I
I
I
I
Liquid withdrawal-(]
dip t ube I
I
The excess-flow valve protects the container against uncontrolled discharge of LP-gas in case
the gas line breaks. The excess-flow valve is installed in the liquid dip tube. The dip tube
completely isolates LP-gas liquid from the inlet to the relief valve. But vapour is free to flow
around the dip tube to the inlet of the safety relief valve.
You will briefly review the propane vapourization process before discussing the procedures for
sizing propane co ntainers. Knowing how propane reacts under temperature and pressure
changes will increase your understanding of the factors that influenc e container sizing .
Propane vapourization
Propane is made up of hydrogen and carbon atoms . Under normal atmospheric pressure ,
propane is a vapour. To store propane, the vapour is pressurized and stored as a liquid . Although
it is stored as a liquid , when filled to capacity, only 80% of the container is filled with liquid , the
rest of the container is filled with vapourized gas . Overfilling the storage container reduces the
volume available for vapourization and may result in liquid withdrawal or a hydrostatic pressure
buildup.
The relationship between the propane liquid and vapour is constant unless the temperature of the
propane changes or the pressure inside the container changes .
When the temperature of propane liquid inside a pressurized container increases, the liquid boils
and vapourizes . This vapourization increases the pressure in the container. Since there is a
relationship between temperature and pressure , this boiling continues until the temperature and
pressure reach equilibrium at a new point (Figure 4-19).
Another way to make the liquid boil is to release some pressure. When the supply valve opens
and discharges vapour , a drop in pressure occurs . As a result , the liquid immediately boils off,
trying to re-establish the same pressure that was in the container before the valve was opened.
When the valve closes, the liquid continues to boil off until the cylinder is re-pressurized.
Figure 4-19
Propane vapourization point
200
180
160
..
QI
:::J
140
120
Saturated va~our in
propane cy inder
"'
"'
ai-
.. bl)
a.:;;; 100
.. 0.. Propane in
:::,- 80
0 liquid state
0..
nl 60
>
40
Propane in
20 vapour stat e
0
--44 - 30 - 20 - 10 0 10 20 30 40 so 60 70 80 90 100
boil ing
point
Temperature {°F)
Vapourization rate
The vapourization rate of a container is the volu me of propane that can be boiled off inside the
container during a period of time . The vapourization rate is expressed in cubic feet or cubic
meters of vapour per hour. When sizing a container for vapour service , always ensure that the
container 's vapourization rate is equal to , or greater than , the demand for propane . If it is smaller ,
the applian ces will not operate at their rated inputs due to low pressur e.
124 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpressure protection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
There are six basic factors that affect the vapourization rate of a propane container.
These factors either slow down the boiling rate or speed it up.
As a result , the vapourization rate either increases or decreases due to these factors .
Figure 4-20
Liquid propane boiling inside pressurized chamber
Cylinder
service valve High pressure
App liance burner
propane gas
Low pressure
propane gas
Propane vapo ur
Propane liquid
Propane cylinder
c::::)
Sizing a container
When sizing containers, there are five important steps to ensure the factors that affect the
vapo urization rate are taken into account. Each of the following steps is extremely important in
properly sizing the tank or cylinder:
1) Determine the total demand of all present and future appliances.
2) Determine the total effective load on the container.
3) Determine the most severe weather conditions under which the container must operate.
If you still cannot determine the input rating of the appliances , use Table 4-3 as a guide to various
input ratings. This table shows common domesti c , comm ercial, industrial , and agricultural
appliances and their respective input ratings . However , try to determine the exact rating before
referring to Table 4-3.
Table 4-3
Average appliance input ratings and load factors
(Continued)
For example , an 80 000 Btu furnace requires 32 cu ft of propane every hour to operate
continuously . However , a properly sized furna ce that is installed in a well insulated home will
normally cyc le on and off five or six times each hour . As a result, the main burner operates for
approximately 30 minutes out of each hour.
This on and off cycling means that the supply withdrawn from the propane container is not
continuous.
In order to properly size a container , you need to know what gas supply is actually required for.
Where ...
Input rating Is that shown on the appliance rating plate
Load factor Is the actual amount of gas used , divided by the maximum amount of propane
that the appliance would use if it operated co ntinuously
Where ...
The right-hand column of Table 4-3 contains the average load factors for
various appliances.
If the load factor for a particular application cannot be determined , use an
average load factor for the relevant type of appliance or equipment. The
following load factors are "safe" average load factors for individua l appliances :
• domestic 0.5
• commercial 0.5
• industrial 0.75
• agricultural 1.0
In the 80 000 Btu/h furnace example, the propane container only boils off half
(30 minutes) of the vapour that it requires to operate continuously . The load
factor is therefore 0.5.
Multiple appliances
Since the propane container may be supplying gas to many appliances , all loads must be added
together to find the effective load on the container. Use the following procedure :
1) Determine the input rating for each appliance or piece of equipment.
2) Multiply the input rating of each appliance by its proper load factor (Table 4-3) .
3) Add the effective loads of each of the appliances together to determine the total effective
load on the container .
For example , determine the total effective load of three domestic appliances , namely :
• domestic water heater (35 000 Btu/h);
• gas range (45 000 Btu/h); and
• central heating system (80 000 Btu/h) .
To properly size a container for vapour withdrawal , always size the container so that it provides
propan e under the most difficult weath er conditions.
1) Determine the times when the container normally provides propane vapour to applian ces
(i.e ., morning only , summer only).
2) Determine the lowest outside temperature that occurs during a normal operating period .
There are three tables for sizing containers , all located in Appendix A:
2) Based on the lowest temperature for the operating season of the tank , select the appropriate
temperature column in the table.
3) Read down the temperature column until you locate a Btu rating that is equal to, or greater
than , the effective load of the application .
4) Read across to the Tank capacity (gallons w.c .) column to locate the required tank size.
130 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers
Note: The temperature column only lists 50 °F. Regardless of the time of year, the earth surrounding an
underground tank usually remains around 50 °F.
Note: The moisture content of the so il has been averaged out.
1) To select the proper size of an underground tank, read down the 50 °F column until you find
a rating that is equal to, or greater than , the effective load of the application .
2) Read across to the left to determine the proper size tank capacity (gallons w.c.) .
If the tank is undersized , a frost line could develop on the tank and the vapouri zation rate will drop
off to zero . If this occurs , the tank must be dug up and a larger tank set in, resulting in a waste of
time and money.
This table is different from the others because each cylinder has four different vapourization
rates:
• two ratings for winter ; and
• two ratings for summer.
Further , the summer and winter ratings are divided into low and high humidity :
Because of the low capacities of cylinders , a 10% difference in humidity or temperature does not
greatly change the vapourization rate of the cylind er.
Propane vapourizers can be used when equipment or applian ce demand exceeds the natural
vapouri zing capacity of the tank and placing a much larger tank , with higher vapourization
capacity would not be practical.
Direct fired propane vapourizer shown in Figure 4-21 , uses a flame that directly heats the liquid
propane which turns it to gas for use in downstream , high vapour demand equipment. Liquid
propane is piped from the tank to the vapourizer where it is then heated and in turn , the propane
gas vapourization is accelerated. The vapourizer is essentially a boiler that does not build
pressure .
Figure 4-21
Propane direct fire vapourizer
Vapour line
Shut-off
valve Vapour
inlet
To service
line
Gas service line
Regulator
---.--..-7 ~
L1qu1dline
Thermostat
control Burner 10 to 40 ft _____..-
Ther mocouple
lead
Pilot Support and
protect pipes
-----
Container sizing for liquid withdrawal
Sizing LP-gas containers for vapourizers, liquid burner applications, and stationary engines is a
simple proced ure. Basically , the size of the container is based on two considerations:
• liquid withdrawal rate each day ; and
• minimizing th e number of gas deliveries to the customer.
In order to properly size containers for these applications , determine the daily withdrawal rate for
the application . Stationary engines are rated in the number of US gallons (litres) that they use in
one continuous hour of operation (gal/hr, I/hr). To size the container, determine the expected
number of hours that the engine must operate under normal conditions.
Installation clearances
Before planning the location of a propane container , check all code requirements fo r clearance
information . The diagrams and tables in App endix B serve only as a guide for approximate
clearance information. Refer to CSA B149 .2 , Propan e storage and handling code, for additional
information.
The key thing to remember is that propane is flammable . Sparks from electric motors and
switches, for examp le, can transfer enough heat to cause co mbustion. Even the heat from a lit
ciga rette or a ve hicle exhaus t pipe can ignite a flammable mixture of propane and air.
Table 4A-1
Vapourization rate of aboveground ASME tanks (Btu/h)
Humidi- Tank Capacity so°F 40°F 30°F 20°F 10°F 0°F -10°F -20°F -30°F
ty
(Gallons W.C.)
120 46,326 39,651 35,745 31,970 29,951 27,920 27,920 25,570 23,470
150 57,424 49,145 44,299 39,629 37,123 24,616 34,089 31,688 29,431
250 76,937 65,842 59,358 53,096 49 ,729 46,376 45,699 42,460 39,440
a-60%
500 127,919 109,472 98,694 88,279 82,697 77,102 75,927 70,600 64,567
1,000 227,834 194,975 175,787 157,232 147,276 137,319 135,227 125,748 116,782
6,000 750,944 624,661 579,380 518,240 485,432 452 ,623 445,727 414,451 384,909
120 30,475 29,951 26,187 22,503 20,586 18,706 18,416 15,130 14,900
150 37,775 37,060 32,400 27,890 25,520 23,230 22,830 18,760 18,470
250 50,612 49,670 43,420 37,380 34,200 31,130 30,580 25,140 24,750
b - 70%
500 84,150 82,550 72,170 62,130 56,840 51,740 50,820 41,780 41,140
1,000 149,878 147,040 128,550 110,670 101,250 92,160 90,580 74,420 73,280
6,000 494 ,002 485,545 242,497 364,772 333 ,716 303,225 298,530 245,266 241,536
120 27, 199 25,536 16,433 12,923 12,706 12,507 9,235 9,123 7,476
150 33,714 33,000 20,360 16,020 15,760 15,510 11,460 11,290 9,270
250 45, 171 44,230 27,290 21,480 21,120 20,790 15,360 15,130 12,420
c-80%
500 75, 103 73,510 45360 35,700 35,100 34,550 25,530 25,150 20,640
1,000 133,764 130,940 80,790 63,580 62,530 61,540 45,480 44,800 36,770
6,000 440,822 431,369 266,379 209 ,554 226 ,005 202 ,779 149,785 147,970 121,197
Table 4A-2
Vapourization rate (Btu/h) of underground ASME tanks
(Gallons w.c.)
120 35,391
150 43 ,879
250 58,777
500 97,727
1,000 174,061
6,000 573,723
Note:
1) All ratings based on tanks being 1/4 full.
For tanks 1/3 full, multiply Btus by 1.144
For tanks 1/2 full, multiply Btus by 1.41
Table 4A-3
vapourization rate of common DOT/TC cylinders (Btu/h)
Figure 4B-1
Installation clearances for aboveground ASME tanks
For exceptions, see locat ion
of consumer tanks in t he
Propane Code Sources
of ignition
*Building openings
include windows,
doors, combustion
and fresh air intakes
~
~
----~
-- ----------
Figure 48-2
Installation clearances for underground ASME tanks
Min. 10 t
Min. SOft -J- (Note 1) Crawl
(Note 1) ',------,_~_
~-,r 1----.._ space
~~
t,_~-- ------_: ------ Min. 10 ft
-~--- (Note 1)
2,000 gal w .c.
I
, -- ---- ._-_.._,!
.J,_ ..
or less
' - - - - - .. Min. SOft
I '
'.. ' (Note 1)
-~,;;-
,~ ....... ,'
- ;~~~ --- '
2,000 gal w .c. to
30,000 gal w.c.
Figure 48-3
Installation clearances for DOT/TC cylinders
Mi nimum 10 f t from
any air intake or
source of ignition For full requirements , see
(air condi tio ner) Installation of Cylinders,
Clause 11.3, in the B149.2
any bui lding opening
Propane Storage and
Firm, level, weatherproof below the level of the
Handling Code
base located on consolidated relief valve discharge
ground at grade level
Table 48-1
Minimum distance requirements of ASME tanks
(Continued)
(Continued)
138 October 20 19
Pressure regulators, overpr essure pro tection, meters, and fuel
GAS TRADE TRAINING UNIT 11 containers