Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Symmetry Elements
Symmetry elements are defined as imaginary geometrical entities such
as points, lines and planes that are present in a molecule, about which when
symmetry operations are performed, the molecule presents an indistinguishable
configuration. The nature of symmetry elements present in any molecule
depends on its geometry.
What are indistinguishable configurations?
These are spatial arrangements which cannot be distinguished from
one another. The two configurations are alike in all respects (but are not
exactly identical) and it is difficult to predict if any change has been carried
out or not. However, they can be differentiated by introducing appropriate
suffixes in the form of numbers or letters. For example, configurations I and
II (Fig.1) are indistinguishable but for the suffixes 1 and 2 on the B atoms.
Fig. 1
Symmetry Operations
These are simple geometric operations such as reflection, rotation or
inversion which when performed on the molecule, give rise to an
indistinguishable configuration of the same molecule. Thus, the presence of
symmetry elements in a molecule can be identified by performing the
appropriate symmetry operations (Table 1).
Table 1: Types of symmetry elements and their corresponding
symmetry operations
Symmetry element Corresponding symmetry operation
Identity element (E) or (I) doing nothing (360° rotation)
Plane of symmetry () reflection
Centre of symmetry (i) inversion of all coordinates
Proper axis of symmetry (Cn) rotation through an angle of (360/n) about
an axis where n is the order of the axis
Improper axis of symmetry rotation through an angle of (360/n) about
(Sn) an axis followed by reflection about a plane
perpendicular to the original axis
1
Identity Element (E)
The identity element is present in all molecules. Identity is the
operation of not doing anything. When a molecule is not operated upon by
any symmetry element, the system is left unchanged and the configuration of
the molecule is identical with the original configuration. Thus, the molecule
is said to possess the identity element. It is denoted by the symbol E. Though
it may appear that this element does not have any significance, its
mathematical relevance will be clear as we proceed further.
Plane of Symmetry ()
When reflection is carried out about an imaginary plane in a molecule
and if the molecule presents an indistinguishable configuration, the plane is
called a plane of symmetry. It is represented by . A molecule may have one
or several planes of symmetry or may not have any such plane. Let us identify the
symmetry planes present in molecules possessing different geometrics.
Note: All linear molecules have an infinite number of planes of symmetry.
AB2 (Bent)
All molecules of this type possess two planes of symmetry. An example
of such a molecule is H2O.
(i) One plane of symmetry passes through atom A and
bisects the line joining the two B atoms which are identical (Fig. 2).
But for the subscripts, the atoms B 1 and B2 in the two configurations
cannot be distinguished.
Fig. 2
(ii) The molecular plane: It is the plane in which the molecule
lies. When reflection is done about this plane, the molecule reflects
onto itself and presents an indistinguishable configuration.
Note: All planar molecules have the molecular plane as one of the planes
of symmetry.
AB3 (Planar)
A triangular planar molecule will have the following planes of symmetry.
(i) A molecular plane (since it is planar);
(ii) A plane passing through one of the B atoms (say B1) and A
which bisects the line joining the other two B atoms (B2 and B3).
Similarly, there are two other planes of symmetry, that is, a plane
passing through A and B2 which bisects the line joining B1 and B3, and
a third plane passing through A and B3 which bisects the line joining B1
and B2 (Fig. 3). An example of this type of molecule is BCl3.
2
Fig. 3
Thus, a tetra atomic AB 3 planar molecule has four (1 + 3) planes of
symmetry.
AB3 (Pyramidal)
This type of molecule has three planes of symmetry. Each plane passes
through A and one of the B atoms (B1, B2 or B3) and bisects the line joining
the other two B atoms (Fig. 4). There is no molecular plane of symmetry. An
example of this type of molecule is NH3.
Fig. 4
AB4 (Square planar)
In a square planar molecule, the following planes of symmetry exist
(Fig. 5 and Fig. 6).
Fig. 5 Fig. 6
(i) A molecular plane (since the molecule is planar);
(ii) Two planes of symmetry exist, each passing through atom
A and bisecting the line joining the adjacent B atoms on either side.
(iii) Two diagonal planes each passing through A and the two
diagonally opposite B atoms.
Thus, such a molecule will possess a total of five (1+2+2) planes. An
example of this type of molecule is [PtCl4].
AB4 (Tetrahedral)
In a tetrahedral molecule, there is no molecular
plane. There are six planes of symmetry, each passing
through A and two B atoms (AB1B2, AB2B3, AB3B4, AB4B1,
AB2B4, AB1B3) (Fig. 7). An example of this type of
molecule is CH4.
Fig. 7
3
AB5 (Pentagonal)
In a pentagonal molecule, the following planes of
symmetry exist (Fig. 8).
(i) Molecular plane;
(ii) Five symmetry planes each passing
through A and one of the B atoms and bisecting
the line joining adjacent B atoms on the opposite
face. Fig. 8
Thus, the molecule has a six (1 + 5) planes of
symmetry. This type of molecule is hypothetical.
AB5 (Trigonal bipyramidal)
A trigonal bipyramidal molecule has the following
planes of symmetry (Fig. 9).
(i) A plane of symmetry passing through A
and the three equatorial B atoms (B1, B2, B3);
(ii) Three planes of symmetry, each passing
through A, the two axial B atoms (B4 and B5) and
one equatorial B atom.
Thus, the molecule has four (1 + 3) planes of Fig. 9
symmetry. An example of such a molecule is PCl5.
AB5 (Square pyramidal)
In a square pyramidal molecule, the planes of
symmetry that exist are as follows (Fig. 10).
(i) Two planes of symmetry, each passing
through A and the axial B(B1) which bisects the line
joining adjacent B atoms on both sides;
(ii) Two diagonal planes of symmetry,
each passing through A, the axial B and the two Fig. 10
diagonally opposite equatorial B atoms.
Thus, the molecule has four (2+2) planes of symmetry. An example of
such a molecule is IF5.
AB6 (Octahedral)
In an octahedral molecule, the following planes of symmetry exist
(Fig. 11).
(i) Six planes passing through the opposite edges of the
octahedron;
(ii) Three planes passing through A and the
four equatorial B atoms and bisecting the line joining the
axial B atoms.
Thus, the molecule will have a total of nine (6+3)
planes of symmetry. An example of this type of molecule is
[Cr(CO)6]. Fig. 11
4
Centre of symmetry (I)
When the coordinates (x, y, z) of every atom in a molecule are changed
into (x, y, z) and even after that, if the molecule presents an
indistinguishable configuration, then the point of origin (0, 0, 0) is called the
centre of symmetry of the molecule. That is, if an imaginary line is drawn
from an atom to the centre of the molecule and extended on the other side by
the same distance and meets a similar atom, the molecule is said to possess a
centre of symmetry or a centre of inversion. For example a cube, a sphere
and an octahedron possess a centre of symmetry whereas a triangle and a
pyramid do not.
Whenever diagonally opposite atoms are the same in a molecule, the
molecules will have a centre of symmetry and vice versa.
Proper axis of symmetry (Cn)
A proper axis of symmetry is defined as an imaginary axis present in a
molecule about which, when the molecule is rotated through an angle of
(360/n)°, the molecule presents an indistinguishable configuration. Here, n
represents the order of the axis and can take whole number values. When n = 2,
the axis is referred to as the C2 or the diad axis; when n = 3, the axis is
referred to as the C3 or the triad axis and so on.
The nature of Cn axis present in a molecule varies with its geometry.
All linear molecules, when rotated through any angle with respect to their
bond axis, present an indistinguishable configuration and hence possess an
axis of symmetry which is called the C axis. An example of this kind of
molecule is HCl.
AB2 (Bent)
Such a molecule has a C2 axis of symmetry (Fig. 12). An example of
this kind of molecule is H2S.
Fig. 12
AB3 (Planar)
Such a molecule possesses one C3 axis of symmetry and three C2 axes
of symmetry.
Fig. 13
5
An example of this kind of molecule is BCl3.
Fig. 14
AB3 (Pyramidal)
Such a molecule possesses only the C3 axis of symmetry.
Fig. 15
AB4 (Square planar)
This molecule has one C4 axis of symmetry and four C2 axes of
symmetry. The C4 axis is the imaginary line passing through A and
perpendicular to the molecular plane (Fig. 16).
Fig. 16
As already pointed out, this molecule has four C2 axes of symmetry.
Out of these, two pass through A and bisect the line joining adjacent B atoms
on both sides (Fig. 17).
The remaining two C2 axes pass through A and two diagonally
opposite atoms (Fig. 18). All the four C2 axes lie in the molecular plane and
are perpendicular to the principal C4 axis. An example of this type of
molecule is PtCl4.
6
Fig. 17 Fig. 18
Note: When a molecule has more than one Cn axis, the highest ordered
axis is referred to as the principal axis of symmetry.
AB4 (Tetrahedral)
This type of molecule has four C3 axes of symmetry and three C2 axes
of symmetry. For example, the axis passing through B1 and A is a C3 axis and
there are four such axes present in the molecule. (Fig. 19)
Fig. 19
Three C2 axes are present in the molecule; two are shown (Fig. 20). An
example, of this type of molecule is [Ni(CO)4].
AB5 (Pentagonal)
Thus type of molecule has one C5 axis of
symmetry and five C2 axes of symmetry. The C5 axis is
the imaginary line passing through A and is
perpendicular to the molecular plane (Fig. 21). Fig. 20
Fig. 21
7
The C2 axis is the imaginary line passing
through A and one of the B atoms (say, B1) in the
molecular plane and it bisects the line joining the two
B atoms (B3 and B4) on the opposite side. It lies in the
molecular plane (Fig. 22).
There are five such axes present in this molecule
and they are perpendicular to the principal C5 axis. Fig. 22
AB5 (Square pyramidal)
This type of molecule has a C4 axis. This is an imaginary line that
passes through A and the axial B atom (B5 in Fig. 23). It is perpendicular to
the square plane of the molecule. An example of this type of molecule is IF5.
Fig. 23 Fig. 24
AB6 (Planar)
This type of molecule has one C6 axis of symmetry and six C2 axes of
symmetry. The C6 axis is the imaginary line passing through A and is
perpendicular to the molecular plane (Fig. 24).
There are six C2 axes present in this molecule. Out of these, three are
imaginary lines that pass through A and two B atoms lying opposite to each
other (Fig. 25). That is, they pass through B1 – A – B4, B2 – A – B5 and
B3 – A – B6.
Fig. 25 Fig. 26
The remaining three C2 axes pass through A and bisect the line joining
two adjacent B atoms on both sides (Fig. 26). All the six C2 axes lie on the
molecular plane.
8
AB6 (Octahedral)
This molecule has three C4 axes of symmetry,
four C3 axes of symmetry and six C2 axes of symmetry.
The C4 axis is the imaginary line passing though A
and two diagonally opposite B atoms. There are
three such axes present. They are, the lines passing
through B5 – A – B6, B2 – A – B3 (Fig. 27).
The C3 axis is the imaginary line passing
through A and the centres of the two triangles (two
faces of the octahedron) opposite to each other. Fig. 27
There are eight triangular faces in an octahedron
and hence four C3 axes are present in this molecule.
The C2 axis is the imaginary line passing through A and bisecting the
line joining the two adjacent B atoms on opposite sides. That is, it passes
through A and two opposite edges of the octahedron. Since there are twelve
edges in an octahedron, six C2 axes exist in the molecule.
Improper axis of symmetry (Sn)
When a molecule is rotated about an axis through an angle of 360°/n,
followed by reflection about a plane perpendicular to the originally chosen
axis, if it presents an indistinguishable configuration, it is said to possess an
improper axis of symmetry. This axis is represented by Sn. Molecules having
an improper axis of symmetry can be classified into two types.
Molecules having both, an axis of symmetry (Cn) and a
perpendicular plane of symmetry ().
Molecules having neither an axis of symmetry nor a plane of
symmetry but having only an
improper axis of symmetry (Sn).
An example for the first type is
BCl3 (Fig. 28). In this molecule, the
C3 axis is perpendicular to the molecular
plane. Rotation through 120° (C3)
followed by reflection about the
molecular plane gives an indistinguishable
configuration. Hence, the molecule is
said to possess an improper axis of Fig. 28
symmetry (S3). Hence the C3 axis is
also the S3 axis.
An example for the second type is, the staggered conformation of
ethane. Consider the end-on view (Newmann Projection) of the staggered
conformation of ethane (Fig. 29).
9
Fig. 29
Rotation about the C–C bond through an angle of 60° followed by
reflection about a perpendicular plane at the centre of symmetry gives an
indistinguishable configuration. Hence the C–C bond axis is the S6 axis.
Associated Operations of Sn
Rotation about an axis through an angle of (360/n)° followed by
reflection about a perpendicular plane can lead to an indistinguishable
configuration but not the original configuration. However, by repeating the
two processes many times, the original configuration can be arrived at. The
number of times the process has to be repeated to get the original
configuration is referred to as the associated operations of the Sn axis. The
total number of associated operations of the Sn axis depends on whether n is
even or odd. An assumption is made that Cn and n commute which is true in
most cases.
Example: Associated operations of the S2 axis
Mathematically, the associated operations of the S2 axis are represented
as follows.
;
Associated operations of the S4 axis
Mathematically, the associated operations of the S4 axis are represented
as follows.
;
;
Thus, an even-ordered improper axis of symmetry is associated with n
number of operations where n is the order of the axis. It is interesting to note
10
that the associated symmetry operations of the Sn axis (where n is even)
include the associated symmetry operations of the Cn/2 axis. That is, the Cn/2
axis is also the Sn axis when n is even.
Associated operations of the S3 axis
Mathematically, the associated operations are represented as,
;
;
Thus, the S3 axis is associated with six symmetry operations.
Associated symmetry operations of the S5 axis
The associated operations are represented as,
;
;
Thus, the S5 axis is associated with 10 symmetry operations. In
general, the Sn axis of odd order is associated with 2n number of symmetry
operations. The associated operations of the odd ordered Sn axis include the
associated operations of the Cn axis. This indicates that the Cn axis of odd
order is also the Sn axis of the same order.
Horizontal planes (h), Vertical Planes (v) and dihedral planes (d)
The various symmetry planes present in molecules of different shapes
have already been discussed in detail. These planes can be classified into
three types-horizontal planes (h), vertical planes (v) and dihedral planes (d).
Horizontal planes (h)
Horizontal planes are those planes that are perpendicular to the
principal axis of the molecule. For example, in the BCl3 molecule, the C3 axis
is the principal axis. It passes through boron and is perpendicular to the
molecular plane. Hence, the molecular plane becomes the horizontal plane as
it is perpendicular to the principal axis.
Vertical Planes (v)
Planes containing the principal axis are referred to as vertical planes.
For example, in the water molecule, the principal axis is the C2 axis passing
through oxygen. Both the molecular plane and the other plane passing
through oxygen and bisecting the line joining the two hydrogen atoms
contain the C2 axis and are thus referred to as vertical planes.
11
Dihedral planes (d)
Planes bisecting two C2 axes are referred to as dihedral planes. For
example, the planes that exist in the staggered conformation of ethane are
dihedral planes.
The effect is the same as a single rotation by 180° about the y axis.
Limitation: The limitation of this method is that it cannot be applied to
products involving higher ordered proper axis of symmetry (Cn).
Method 2
A molecule that has both the symmetry operations for which the
product has to be determined, is chosen. The desired symmetry operations are
12
performed one after another in the respective order and the new configuration
is obtained for the molecule. Now, a single symmetry operation which can
directly transform the molecule from configuration I to configuration III has
to be identified which is the product of the two symmetry operations. For
example, to find the product of C3(z) followed by v1. Consider the ammonia
molecule since it contains both C3 and v.
Fig. 44
v1 is the plane passing through nitrogen and the hydrogen on the left
and v2 is the plane passing through nitrogen and the hydrogen at the back.
v1 C3(2) = v2
13
Group Postulates and Types of Groups
1. Two elements of a group combine to give the third element of
the group.
2. An element combines with itself to form another element of the
group.
3. Every group consists of one element which commutes with all
the elements and leaves them unchanged. This element is known as the
identity element E.
4. Every element of the group obeys the associative law of
combination.
If A, B & C are three elements of the group then (AB)C = A(BC).
5. Every element has an inverse or reciprocal which is also an
element of the group. The element and the inverse combine to give the
identity element.
6. Addition or multiplication of a symmetry operation can be the
combination process of the elements of a group.
Multiplication table, subgroups and classes
The elements of group can be listed in a table known as the
multiplication table. This table reveals the different relations between the
elements of a group.
(eg.) symmetry operations of water.
E C2' v'
E E C2' v v'
C2' C2' E v' v
v v v' E C2'
v' v' v C2' E
Subgroups
Any subset of a collection of elements which forms a group is called a
subgroup. The elements of a sub group should obey the following conditions.
1. The elements should satisfy all the rules of the group.
2. If g is the order of the group and s is the order of sub group
then g/s is a natural number.
(eg.) consider H2O.
The subgroups in this molecule can be identified using the multiplication
table for H2O molecule, there are 4 subgroups.
(1) E (2) E & C2' (3) E & v (4) E & v'
Classes
1. Two elements A and B in a group form a class if they are
conjugate to each other.
14
2. Conjugate elements are related by the equation X1AX = B where
X is another element of the group.
15
Similarity Transformation
If A & X are the two elements present in the P then X-1 AX = B is the
similarity transform of A by X. X is known as the similarity transform
element.
X is known as the similarity transform’ element. The similarity
transform” of one element by another may be used to find whether a set of
elements form a class.
(eg) H2O the similarity transform of a particular operation is obtained
with all the operations as follows
; ; ;
16
Symmetry Elements and Point Groups
Group
A group is defined as any set or collection of elements which obey a
certain set of mathematical rules and are related to each other by certain
rules. The elements could be numbers, matrices, vectors, roots of an equation
or symmetry elements. For example,
All positive and negative whole numbers together with zero
form a group under the combining operation of addition.
Elements 1, 1, i, i (where i= ) form a group under
multiplication.
All powers of two ..., 2 2, 21, 20, 21, 22,... form an infinite group
under multiplication.
Mathematical Rules for the Formation of a Group
The elements of any group must obey the following rules.
The combination of any two members of a group and the square
of every member of a group should also be a member of that group (this is
known as the closure property). Let A and B be the members of a group
under the multiplication operation. If A multiplied by B gives C, A
multiplied by A gives D, and B multiplied by B gives G, then C, D and G
should also be members of the group. (C, D and G can also be the same as
A or B).
The group must contain one and only one identity element (E)
which has the property AE = EA = A for all elements of the group.
The associate law of combination should hold good. (i.e) A(BC)
= (AB)C.
The inverse of every element should also be a member of the
group. The inverse of any element X is denoted by X1 which when
combined with the element itself results in the identity element. It can be
represented by the following equation.
X1X = XX1 = E
Let the inverse of be 1 Therefore, 1 = E according to the
definition. Since it has already been proved that 2 = E, 1 = .
Similarly, we can prove that the inverse of i is i itself, and C2 is C2 itself.
But the inverse of C3 is since =E. In general, the inverse of any Cn is
(Cn) and the inverse of any Sn is (Sn) when n is even and (Sn)2n1 when n is
n1 n1
odd.
Definition and Classification of Point Groups
A point group is a collection of the symmetry elements present in a
molecule that obeys the mathematical rules for the formation of a group.
During the application of various symmetry operations in a molecule, the
centre of mass does not shift and therefore all the axes, points and planes of
17
symmetry of the molecule intersect at one common invariant point (center of
mass) and hence the term point group is used. The point groups are
represented by Schoenflies symbols. Table 2 summarises the various point
groups and their corresponding symmetry elements.
Table 2: Point groups and their symmetry elements
Point
Symmetry Elements
group
C1 E
Cs E,
Ci E, i
C2 E, C2
C3 E, ,
C4 E, , ,
C5 E, , , ,
C6 E, , , , ,
C2v E, C2, v1, v2
C3v E, , , v1, v2, v3
C4v E, , , , v1, v2, v3, v4
C5v E, , , , , 5v
C6v E, , , , , , 6v
Cv E, C, infinite number of v
C2h E, C2, h, i
C3h E, , , h, ,
C4h E, , , , h, ,
C5h E, , , , , h, , , ,
C6h E, , , , , h, , , i, ,
D2 E, C2, 2 C2
D3 E, , , 3 C2
D2h E, C2, 2 C2, 2h, 2v, S2 = i
D3h E, , , 3C2 C3, h, , ,i
D4h E, , , , 4C2 C4, h, 4v, , ,i
D5h E, , , , , 5C2 C5, h, 5v, , , ,
D6h E, , , , , , 6C2 C6, h, 6v,
, , i, ,
18
Dh E, C, infinite number of C2, h infinite number of , i
D2d E, 2d, 3 mutually C2, ,
D3d E, , , 3C2 C3, 3d, , ,i
D4d E, , , , 4C2 C4, 4d, , , ,
D5d E, , , , , 5C2 C5, 5d, , , , ,i
D6d E, , , , , , 6C2 C6, 6d, ,
, , , ,
S4 E, C2, ,
S6 E, , , , ,i
Td E, 8C3, 3C2, 6S4, 6d
Oh E, 6C4, , 8C3, 6C2, 3h, 6d, I, 8S6, 6S4
Ih E, , , 20C3, 15C2, 15d, 20S6, , i,
22
Search of minimum
Complete list
S. symmetry elements for Point
Molecule of symmetry
No. identification of point group
elements
groups
Cl
H
6
1 H C2 axis bisects the C2, C3
2 bond on one side and the C5,
5
3 C6 on the other), h is the
4
H H molecular plane
Cl
One C3 present (passes
through the C–C bond), 3C2
Eclipsed ethane
HH to C3 (every C2 axis E, , ,
bisects one front and one
31. D3h 3C2 C3, 3v,
back H atom on both sides),
h is present (passing h, ,
HH HH
through the plane bisecting
the C–C bond)
One C3 present (passes
Staggered through the C–C bond), 3C2
ethane to C3 (every C2 axis E, , ,
H H H bisects one front and one
32. D3d 3C2 C3,
back H atom on both sides),
3d (passing through the 3d, ,
H H
H front –CH and back –CH
and bisecting the two C2 axes)
Ferrocene One C5, 5C2 to C5 present E, , ,
42. (neither eclipsed (as before), h absent, v D5 , ,
nor staggered) absent
5C2C5
24
The matrix represents the position corresponding to the new
25
The transformation matrix for i = and i = -3.
26
Transformation Matrix for Axis of Symmetry
Consider Figure 45. Let a vector have a magnitude ‘t’ and derive
an angle respect to the x axis. Assume that is rotated about the z axis
in the clockwise direction through an angle of . The new vector ,
derives an angle ( - ) with the x axis. The z coordinates of the points do not
change and z2 = z1.
Fig. 31
From the figure, we can see that,
OM = x1 = r cos OM' = x2 = r cos( - )
PM = y1 = r sin P'M' = y2 = r sin( - )
Using the identities,
cos(A – B) = cos A cos B + sin A sin B
sin(A – B) = sin A cos B – cos A cos B
the relationship between (x2, y2, z2) and (x1, y1, z1) can be expressed as,
x2 = r cos cos + r sin sin
y2 = r sin cos - r cos sin
z2 = z1
Substituting for r cos and r sin as x1 and y1, we obtain,
x2 = x1 cos + y1 sin
y2 = -x1 cos + y1 sin
z2 = z1
Then, the new position of the vector can be expressed in terms of the
original coordinates as,
x2 = x1 cos + y1 sin + 0 z1
y2 = -x1 sin + y1 cos + 0 z1
z2 = 0 x1 + 0 y1 + 1 z1
27
These three simultaneous equations can be expressed in terms of a matrix
equation as follows,
and C2 = 1.
When n = 3, = 360°/3 = 120°, the 3 3 transformation matrix is given by,
and C3 = 0.
When n = 4, = 360°/4 = 90°, the 3 3 transformation matrix given by,
C4 = 1.
Transformation Matrix for Improper Axis of Symmetry
The Sn operation involves rotation about an axis followed by reflection
about a plane perpendicular to that axis. The transformation matrix for S n can
be obtained by finding the product of the transformation matrices of C n(z)
and xy.
Sn = xy Cn(z)
Transformation matrix of
Sn =
28
=
yz xz =
Matrix Representation
A collection of such matrices corresponding to every symmetry
element present in a point group is referred to as the matrix representation of
a point group.
Characteristics of Matrix Representations
Matrix representations of point groups should obey the following
mathematical rules.
(i) The product of any two matrices and the square of any
matrix belonging to the point group, should also be a matrix that belongs to
the point group.
(ii) There should be one matrix, which when combined
with any other matrix, leaves that matrix unchanged.
(iii) Associative law should hold good.
(iv) The inverse of every matrix of the point group
should also be present in the representation for that point group.
Thus, the collection of matrices corresponding to each symmetry element of
a point group which obeys all the four mathematical rules for the formation
of a group, and produces a group multiplication table identical to that derived
from the symmetry operations is called a matrix representation of a point group.
Classification of Representations
Representations are classified into reducible and irreducible representations.
The definitions of these representations and the differences between them are
highlighted in Table 4.
Table 4: Reducible and irreducible representations
Reducible Representation Irreducible Representation
If dimensions of representations can Irreducible representations are those
be reduced either using the similarity representations whose dimensions
transformation method or the block cannot be reduced by any of the
factoring method, they are referred to mathematical methods like the block
29
Reducible Representation Irreducible Representation
as reducible representations. factoring or the similarity transformation
methods.
They can be expressed as a They cannot be expressed as
combination of various irreducible combinations of any other representations.
representations that are possible for
a group.
Reducible representations are derived Irreducible representations are derived
for the product or for the combination for fundamental bases.
of fundamental bases.
=0 ...(1)
=0 ...(2)
=0 ...(3)
If i = j, m = m, n = n', then,
...(4)
Equations (1), (2), (3) and (4) are simplified expressions of the
orthogonality theorem.
Consequences of the Orthogonality Theorem
30
(i) The sum of the squares of the dimension of all the IRs
that are possible for a point group should be equal to the order of the
group.
That is,
= =0
= (2 cos 240°) + 1 = = 0.
(v) The total number of IRs that are possible for a point group
is equal to the total number of classes present in a point group. For
example, the number of classes for the C2 point group is 2. That is, C2
and E. Hence, the number of IRs = 2. Similarly, for the C 3v point group,
31
the number of classes is 3; E, 2C 3 and 3v. Hence, the number of IRs =
3.
D2h: 8 classes, 8 IRs
C8 : 2 classes, 2 IRs
32
Character Tables
A character table contains four main areas and gives information about the
following.
(i) The name of the point group with the possible
symmetry elements classified under appropriate classes.
(ii) The number of IRs possible for a point group.
(iii) The character corresponding to various classes of
symmetry elements for all the IRs that are possible for a point group.
(iv) The symmetry and corresponding fundamental
bases for every IR.
(v) The respective combined bases for the various IRs
of a point group.
For example, the character table for a C2V point group is given below.
Area
Area II Area I Area IV
III
C2V E C2(z) xz yz
A1 1 1 1 1 Z x2,y2,z2
A2 1 1 -1 -1 R(z) xy
B1 1 -1 +1 -1 y, Rx yz
B2 1 -1 -1 +1 x, Ry xz
From the character table, we can see that Area I contains the list of
symmetry elements possible for a point group with appropriate classes. It
also gives the respective characters of each IR possible for a point group and
is mainly derived from the orthogonally theorem. Area II contains the
Mulliken symbols which indicate the symetry of the various IRs that are
possible for a point group. In Area III, the corresponding fundamental bases
for the various IRs are listed. Area IV contains the combined bases for the
various IRs.
Construction of Character Tables
Area I of the character table can be derived using the orthogonality
theorem as given below.
(i) The total number of IRs of a group is equal to the
total number of classes present in the group in accordance with the
axiom derived from the orthogonally theorem which states that the
number of IRs is equal to the number of classes in the group.
(ii) The dimensions of the various IRs can be derived
using the following axiom derived from the orthogonality theorem,
33
and
34
(iii) Since the character corresponding to the
identity element is the dimension of the representation, in all the four
IRs, E = 1. The characters corresponding to C2(z), xz and yz will be (x1,
y1, z1), (x2, y2, z2), (x3, y3, z3) and (x4, y4, z4) respectively for the four
IRs.
(iv) The square of the character representation is
equal to the order of the group.
12 + + + =4
where, i = 1, 2, 3 or 4 corresponding to the four IRs.
As xi, yi and zi cannot exceed the value 1,
xi = 1, yi = 1 and zi = 1.
(v) To decide the sign of the characters (x i, yi,
zi), the expression
is used.
Substituting the characters from four different IRs of the group, we get
1 1 + (x1 x2) + (y1 y2) + (z1 z2) = 0
1 1 + (x1 x3) + (y1 y3) + (z1 z3) = 0
1 1 + (x1 x4) + (y1 y4) + (z1 z4) = 0
All these equations will be simultaneously satisfied when all the
characters are positive in the first IR, and in the remaining IRs, the
characters of two symmetry elements are positive, and the characters
of two IRs are negative.
Therefore, Area I of the C2V character table is
E C2(Z) xz yz
I 1 1 1 1
II 1 1 -1 -1
III 1 -1 1 1
IV 1 -1 -1 -1
The highlights of Area II are,
(i) Among the four one dimensional IRs, two are symmetric
(+ve character) with respect to the principal C 2 axis and are hence
labelled as A. The remaining two IRs that are antisymmetric with
respect to the principal C 2 axis (-ve character) are labelled as B
representations.
(ii) Representations that are symmetric to v(yz) are
indicated as A1 and B1 whereas representations that are antisymmetric
to v are labelled as A2 and B2 respectively.
The highlights of Area III are,
35
The symmetry of the fundamental bases can be
determined by performing the symmetry operations of a group on them
and arriving at the corresponding characters using the following short
method.
R = Number of bases which do not change position and direction –
Number of bases which do not change position but reverse the
direction
Choosing as base,
E = 1 – 0 = 1
=1–0=1
=1–0=1
=1–0=1
has A1 symmetry. Similarly it can be shown that has B1
symetry and has B2 symmetry. Choosing Rx as base,
E = 1
= –1
= –1
=1
Rx has B1 symmetry. Similarly, Ry has B2 symmetry and Rz has A2
symmetry.
Note: The character table of the C 2h group is similar to that of the C 2V
group except for the Mulliken’s symbols.
Character Table for the C3V Point Group
(i) The total number of IRs possible for the C3V point group is
three since this point group contains three classes of symmetry
operations.
(ii) Let the dimensions of the three IRs be l 1, l2 and l3, and the
order of the group be six.
=6
As the dimensions cannot be zero, the only possible solution is
and = 4.
That is, l1 = l2 = 1 and l3 = 2.
36
Thus, among the three IRs, two are one-dimensional representations
and one is a two-dimensional representation.
(iii) The character corresponding to the identity element in any
representation is the dimension of that representation.
E = 1 for one-dimensional representations and E = 2 for two-
dimensional representations. The characters corresponding to the C 3
and v classes of the C 3V group will be (x 1, y1), (x2, y2) and (x3, y3)
respectively in the three IRs.
37
(i) The one-dimensional IR symmetric to C 3(Z) and v is
labelled as A1 and the other one symmetric to C 3(Z) and antisymmetric to v
is indicated as A2.
(ii) The two-dimensional representation is labelled as E.
The highlights of Area III are
The symmetry of the fundamental bases [ and Rx, Ry, Rz] can be
determined by performing symmetry operations of a group and then arriving
at the corresponding characters using a short method. Choosing as the
base,
E = 1 – 0 = 1
=1–0=1
=1–0=1
has A1 symmetry.
The X and Y axes are inseparable in the C 3V point group due to the C3
operation (since the new position of and can be expressed only by the
combination of original and ).
Thus, choosing and together as the base,
E = 2 – 0 = 2
= 2 cos 120° + 1 = –1
=1–1=0
and together have ‘E’ symmetry. Similarly Rx and Ry
together have ‘E’ symmetry and Rz has A2 symmetry.
Projection Operators
The generating operator or the projection operator for the jth irrep is
defined as
... (1)
th
where lj is the dimensionality of the j irreduible representation. Though
equation 1ooks somewhat formidable, it is easy to use. Let us consider the
trans-1,3-butadiene molecule which belongs to C2h point group:
= ... (2)
= ... (3)
= ... (4)
... (5)
... (6)
Here we have ignored the numerical factors in front of the various
symmetry orbitals since we are interested only in their functional form.
39
1.2. CHEMICAL KINETICS
40
E1 – activation energy of reactants
E2 – activation energy of products
Mathematical (Thermodynamic) Treatment of Transition State Theory
Conventional Transition State Theory (CTST)
The great value of CTST is that the resulting rate equation, although
simple, provides a framework in terms of which even quite complicated
reactions can be understood in a qualitative way. There are various assumptions
and approximations involved in this theory. The main assumptions of CTST are:
1. Molecular systems that have surmounted the col in the direction
of products can not turn back and form reactant molecules again.
2. The energy distribution among the reactant molecules is in
accordance with the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. Furthermore, it is
assumed that even when the whole system is not at equilibrium, the
concentration of those activated complexes that are becoming products
can also be calculated using equilibrium theory.
3. It is permissible to separate the motion of the system over the
col from the other motions associated with the activated complex.
4. A chemical reaction can be satisfactorily treated in terms of
classical motion over the barrier, quantum effects being ignored.
Derivations of the rate equations
The rate equation for a bimolecular reaction, derived by the methods of
conventional transition state theory is
... (1)
... (2)
... (3)
where E0–difference between the molar zero point energy of the activated
complexes and that of the reactants. This energy is the hypothetical
activation energy at absolute zero.
The partition function in the above expression must be evaluated
with respect to the zero point levels of the respective molecules.
If molecule A contains NA atoms & molecule B contains NB atoms, the
activated complex X contains NA + NB atoms.
If the complex is nonlinear,
rotational degrees of freedom = 3
vibrational degrees of freedom = 3(NA + NB) – 6
if linear, vibrational degrees of freedom = 3(NA + NB) – 5
One of these has a different character from the rest. Since it
corresponds to such a loose vibration that there is no restoring force the
complex can form products without any restraint. For this one degree of
freedom, the partition function is (1 – eh/kT)1.
The value of the function is calculated in the limit at which
approaches zero. This is obtained by expanding the exponential and taking
only the first term,
... (4)
q = ... (5)
... (6)
42
On rearranging,
... (7)
... (10)
qt = ... (1)
Thus the total partition function q for the activated complexes may be
written as
q = ... (2)
where q is p.f for all the motions except that over the col.
Introducing (2) into (3) in I derivation (i.e.) consider
... (4)
This is the frequency with which the activated complex passes over potential
energy barrier in unit time. (i.e)
= ... (5)
... (6)
44
... (7)
is substituted in , we get .
(i.e.) in equation ,
... (1)
where
mA & mB - atomic masses
I - moment of Inertia of diatomic activated complex
The first term – contribution from the three degrees of translational freedom.
45
Second term – for rotation.
... (2)
where dAB = distance between the centres of the atoms in the activated
complex.
The atoms A and B have only translational degrees of freedom so that
the respective partition functions are
... (3)
... (4)
... (5)
... (6)
46
Reactions between Molecules
The equations for reactions between molecules are more complicated,
and a simplified treatment is first given by Bawn. The approximation was
made such that the partition function for a given type of energy has the same
value for each degree of freedom. In reality the values of the partition
functions do not vary greatly with the molecular masses, moment of inertia or
vibrational frequencies so that the procedure of treating them as equal does
not involve a great error.
The partition functions for simple translational, rotational and
vibrational degrees of freedom are written as qt, qr and qv respectively. For
reaction between two atoms
, ,
as the complex is linear.
... (1)
Significance
activated complex, two degrees of rotational freedom are gained and three
degrees of translational freedom are lost.
If A & B are complex non linear molecules,
47
The rate constant is
... (2)
Reaction Coordinates
It is an abstract one dimensional coordinate which represents progress
along a reaction pathway. It is usually a geometric parameter that changes
during the conversion of one or more molecular entities.
The reaction coordinate plots are very useful in showing 1. whether a
reaction is endothermic or exothermic process 2. which reaction pathway is
faster & 3. which products are kinetic and thermodynamic controlled
products.
The reaction coordinates are chosen from a measurable coordinate
such as bond length, bond angle, a combination of bond length and bond
angle or bond order. The reaction coordinates are often plotted against energy
to show an energy profile of a reaction.
Fig. A
On the left hand face, the B – C distance may be considered
sufficiently great. That means we are dealing only with the diatomic
molecule A – B. The curve shown on that face is thus the potential energy
curve for the molecule A – B and atom C has no effect on the energy of the
system. In that curve, point Q corresponds to classical ground state and point
R corresponds to dissociation of the molecule. Similarly on the right hand
face the potential energy curve is for the diatomic molecule B – C, because
the distance A – B is sufficiently great and atom A has no effect on the
energy of the system. The classical ground state of B – C is indicated by the
point P.
49
The course of the reaction is represented by the motion of system on
potential energy surface from P to Q. The system travels along paths where
the energy is not high. The potential energy surface can be represented by the
perspective drawing and by the contour diagram. In these potential energy
surfaces, moving in from P or from Q, there are two valleys. From point P,
on moving in, is the reactant valley. From point Q, on moving in, is the
product valley. The two valleys meet at a col or saddle point. For the system
to pass from P to Q during the reaction, the system travels up the reactant
valley, reaches the col. passes over the col and then goes into the product
valley. The paths of steepest descent from the col into the reactant valley and
into the product valley is together called minimum energy path (MEP). The
actual reaction paths are not the same as this MEP.
A section of the minimum – energy path is known as potential energy
profile. The maximum point in this profile or (at the col in the potential
energy surface) is a position of maximum energy along the minimum energy
path (diagram B).
System in a small region around this maximum point are known as
activated complex and their state is referred to as transition states of the
reaction.
Potential energy surfaces for reactions involving more than 3 atoms are
hyper surfaces in multi-dimensional space. These surfaces can be constructed
only by holding all variables constant except 2. Therefore, in such reactions,
groups of atoms are treated as single particles. CH 3 + H2 CH4 + H is
treated as A + BC system.
Most of the work on potential energy surfaces has been done on
bimolecular system such as
H + H - H H - H + H
The 3H atoms are labelled as , & . The rate of this reaction is
measured by measuring the rate of conversion of ortho-hydrogen to para-
hydrogen.
Frotz-London has discussed chemical reactions from the stand point of
molecular structure. He suggested that quantum mechanical methods can be
used to calculate the energies of reaction intermediates such as activated
complexes. Heitler and London have given quantum mechanical treatment of
the H2 molecule. The allowed energies of the H2 molecule are the sum and
difference of 2 integrals.
E=A+
A – Coulombic energy Classical energy of system
exchange energy
A electrons are indistinguishable, they are not localised on any
particular nucleus. They can be exchanged is used.
50
At internuclear distances A and are –ve. E is lowest energy
corresponding to a stable state if E = A + .
For a triatomic species, from quantum mechanical treatment, E is
given by London equation as
Fig. B
51
The predominant factor in isotope effect is the zero point energy which
is strongly affected by atomic masses. When an atom is replaced by an
isotope there is no change in the classical potential energy surface. But there
are changes in vibrational frequencies. Due to the change in vibrational
frequency, there will be change in zero-point energy. The zero point energy
for H2 is 26.1 kJ/mol and that of O 2 is 18.5 kJ/mol. At relatively low
temperatures, including temperatures around room temperature, H 2 and O2
molecules are largely at their zero point levels. Thus at the initial state of the
reaction, H2 has 7.6 kJ/mol more zero point energy than a O 2 molecule.
Hence it tends to react more rapidly and its reactions will have a higher
equilibrium constant.
Primary Kinetic Isotope Effect
The treatment of equilibrium isotope effect can be carried out
satisfactorily whereas the treatment of kinetic isotope effect is very difficult
due to 2 main reasons.
1. The structure and properties of the activated complexes are
involved and for a detailed knowledge of these, it is necessary to
calculate a reliable potential energy surface. A reliable potential energy
surface can be calculated only for the simplest type of reactions.
2. Quantum-mechanical tunneling does not affect equilibrium
constants, but it has important influence on the rates of reactions
involving H atoms or its ions H + or H. As there is no satisfactory
treatment of tunneling, there is uncertainty, in kinetic isotope effects in
reactions involving H, H+ or H-.
Semiclassical Treatment
As a first approach to the problem of kinetic-isotope effect, it is
convenient to neglect quantum mechanical tunneling and procedures that do
so are referred to as semiclassical treatments. Such treatments are reasonably
satisfactory for atoms heavier than H. Even when H, H + or H- is involved,
neglect of tunneling may not introduce much error at higher temperatures, At
temperature below about 350 K, however tunneling becomes significant and
neglect of tunneling introduces much error in kinetic isotope effect.
A simplified semiclassical discussion of kinetic-isotope effect in hydrogen
atom transfer process is given first. Consider the abstraction reactions in
which H or D atom is transferred from one carbon atom to another.
R – H + R' (R ... H ... R') R + H – R'
R – D + R' (R ... D ... R') R + D – R'
a) The situation is simple if R and R' are much heavier than either
H or D. The partition functions for R – H and R – D are then
practically the same. Also the partition functions for the activated
52
complexes (R – ... H ... R') and (R – ... D – ... R') are
same. To compare energy consider the vibrational frequencies. Also
the relevant vibrational frequencies in the activated complexes are
almost the same for the 2 forms. For eg, the symmetry vibrational
frequencies depend largely on the masses of R and R' and much less on
the central masses of H or D. As R and R' are same in the 2 activated
complexes, their symmetry vibrational frequencies are close to one
another. As R and R' are heavier than H or D, the central H or D is not
displaced.
The same is true for bending frequencies. The asymmetric vibrational
frequencies are neglected in the transition state theory. As the vibrational
frequencies are same, the zero-point energies for the activated complexes are
much the same for H and D. The partition functions (where the main
distribution is from translational motion) for the two isotopic forms in the
initial state R – H or R – D and in the activated complexes R ... H ... R' &
R ... D ... R' are practically the same. Therefore, the rate constants will differ
only due to zero point energy difference in the initial state. The semiclassical
ratio is determined by this zero-point energy difference in the initial state.
ratio less than 6.1. Quantum mechanical tunneling increases this ratio.
c) In unsymmetrical systems,
H – H + R' (H ... H ... R') H + H – R'
H – D + R' (H ... D ... R') H + D – R'
There is a difference between the zero point levels in the 2 activated
53
tunneling. The ratio is different for transfer of H or D from a different atom
such as N, O or S.
54
Potential Energy Profiles
55
eg. SN1 substitution reactions.
The rates of these reactions are controlled by an ionization process
such as
#
+
C X C - - - X C+ +X
state. The result is small +ve kinetic isotope effect. ratio is 1.3 – 1.4.
56
Principle of Microscopic Reversibility and Detailed Balance
This principle relates to the behaviour of systems at equilibrium. It was
formulated by Tolman. The principle of microscopic reversibility at equilibrium
can be expressed as follows.
In a system at equilibrium any molecular process and the reverse of
that process occur on the average at the same rate.
The principle of detailed balance at equilibrium applied by Fowler
states that in a system at equilibrium each collision has its exact counterpart
in the reverse direction and the rate of every chemical process is exactly
balanced by the rate of the reverse process. These two principles can be
applied in CTST.
1. In terms of transition state theory, it follows from the
principles that when a system is at equilibrium the flow of systems
over a potential energy surface must be exactly balanced by a flow in
the opposite direction.
2. In particular the most probable path in one direction must
also be the most probable path in the opposite direction. The activated
state for a reaction in one direction must be the same as the activated
state in the other direction.
3. The rate of a reaction in one direction depends on the
increase in Gibbs energy in going from the initial state to the activated
state. Since the activated states must be the same in both the directions,
it follows that for an elementary reaction, the Gibbs energy difference
in the 2 directions must be equal. As Gibbs energy of activation is
equal in both the directions, the rate of the reaction is same in both the
directions. Thus for a reaction A + B C + D, at equilibrium
k1[A] [B] = k2[C][D]
Thus the ratio of the rate constants must be equal to the equilibrium
constant.
These principles must not be applied to reactions that are not
elementary and reactions which are not at equilibrium. Change in pH and
change in dielectric constant do not affect the rate constants in forward and
reverse directions in the same way. The forward and reverse reactions have
different dependences in these cases.
57
Application of the Principles of Microscopic Reversibility and Detailed Balance
For an elementary reaction, the equilibrium constant must be the ratio
of the rate constants in the forward and reverse directions. Thus consider the
process A+B Y+Z in which the reactions in the forward and reverse
directions are elementary.
The rates in the two directions are
and
Example
Consider a reaction that occurs in two or more stages.
H2 + 2ICl I2 + 2HCl
This reaction occurs in 2 steps. At equilibrium the processes are
occurring at equal rates in the forward and reverse directions.
1. H2 + ICl HI + HCl
2. HI + ICl I2 + HCl
Thus at equilibrium
k1[H2] [ICl] = k-1 [HI] [HCl]
k2[HI] [ICl] = k-2[HCl] [I2]
The equilibrium constant for each reaction is thus
where Kc is the equilibrium constant for the overall reaction. For any
mechanism involving any no. of elementary and consecutive steps, the
overall equilibrium constant is the product of the equilibrium constants for
the individual steps. It is also the product of the rate constants for the
reactions in the forward direction divided by the product of the rate constants
for the reverse direction.
58
If a reaction occurs by a composite mechanism and we measure a rate
coefficient k1 for the overall reaction from left to right and also measure a
rate coefficient k-1 for the overall reaction from right to left at the same
temperature, the ratio is not necessarily the equilibrium constant for the
overall reaction.
An example for a reaction where the ratio of the rate constants is not
the equilibrium constant, is given below. Consider the reaction system
k1, the first order rate constant. Similarly starting with pure Z, initial
rate of consumption of Z is measured. The rate constant is k-2. In general the
ratio is not equal to the equilibrium constant Kc. This is because the
initial rate constants measuring k1 and k-2 are not the rate constants that apply
when the system is at equilibrium. When the system is at equilibrium,
59
The first term is the rate of the reaction from left to right and the
the equilibrium constant. Thus if the rate constant that are measured for
forward and reverse directions are those that apply when the system is at
equilibrium, their ratio gives the equilibrium constant for the reaction. For a
system not at equilibrium, the rate constants intermixed away from equilibrium
may be very different from the equilibrium constant.
Gas-Phase Combustion
The gas-phase reactions between oxygen and various substances such
as hydrogen, CO, phosphorous and PH3 have a special characteristic under
some conditions of temperature and pressure. They occur in a normal way,
but a slight change in temperature or pressure may cause the reaction mixture
to explode. The reaction between PH3 and O2 was studied in detail and it was
noted that sometime a decrease in pressure at constant temperature caused a
steady reaction to change into an explosion. Under certain conditions an
explosion in a gaseous mixture is accompanied by an explosion wave which
means a sudden pressure change and this is called detonation.
H2 – O2 Reaction
The reaction between H2 and O2 is a good example where a steady
reaction changes into explosion.
1. A stoichiometric mixture of the 2 gases explodes spontaneously
at any pressure if the temperature is above about 600°C.
2. A stoichiometric mixture gives no explosion at any pressure if
the temperature is below about 460°C unless a spark is passed through
the mixture or a flame is introduced in the mixture.
3. Between 460°C and 600°C the stoichiometric mixture explodes
spontaneously at certain pressures but not at other pressures.
The schematic diagram for the behaviour of a stoichiometric mixture
60
If the pressure is below ~ 2 mm Hg, there is steady reaction, but if the
pressure is increased to 2 mm, an explosion occurs. If the pressure is initially
maintained at about 230 mm Hg, there is again a steady reaction. But if the
pressure is reduced, the rate decreases to an extremely low value until about
100 mm Hg pressure is reached. Then the mixture explodes. Thus at 500°C
there is a pressure region (2 mm to 100 mm Hg) within which there is
explosion but above and below this pressure region there is steady reaction.
The lower limit at which explosion occurs is 2 mm Hg called first limit and
the upper limit is 100 mm Hg called 2 nd limit. At still higher pressures, the
reaction rate becomes very high that the heat evolved causes a substantial
increase in temperature. This causes explosion beyond a high pressure limit
called third limit. Beyond the third limit as explosion occurs due to rise in
temperature, this explosion limit is called thermal limit and the explosion
under such conditions is called thermal explosion.
The explosion occurring between the second and first limits occur in
systems where there is no temperature rise. Such explosions are called
isothermal explosions. In H2 – O2 system, the explosion occurring beyond the
third limit is not a thermal explosion. But it is due to an increase in the
concentration of free radicals and not due to rise in temperature.
Chain branching mechanism
The kinetic behaviour of such systems can be explained by branched
chains suggested by Thompson and Hinshelwood.
When a pair of ordinary chain propagating steps occurs, there is no
change in the number of chain carriers. When a branching chain occurs, there
is an increase in the no. of chain carriers.
For eg., 1. H + O2 OH + O
2. O + H2 OH + H
In each of these reactions, 2 chain carriers are formed from one. These
two reactions are examples of chain propagating steps in branched chain
process.
Adding together these 2 reactions,
H + O2 + H2 2OH + H
61
H atom is regenerated but 2 OH radicals are produced which can
undergo further reactions. When such chain branching occurs, the number of
atoms and free radicals in the system can increase extremely rapidly and an
explosion may result. Suppose each OH radical produced in the above pair of
processes undergoes the reaction,
3. OH + H2 H2O + H
then, each time the pair of reactions (1) & (2) occurs, reaction (3) occurs
twice, the overall reaction
H + O2 OH + O
O + H2 OH + H
62
The steady state equation for R is
63
The rate of formation of the product Z is
64
Elementary Reactions in Solution
When a reaction takes place in solution the solvent is usually present in
much larger amounts than the reactants. The solvent concentration therefore
remains unchanged during the course of the reaction. Therefore the effect of
solvent on rate of the reaction cannot be understood.
For many reactions, the stoichiometric equation does not involve the
solvent. That means, the solvent has an environmental effect, it only acts as a
medium. If the solvent is involved in the stoichiometric equation, then it
means that the solvent takes part in the chemical change and it is regenerated
at the end of the reaction. Then the solvent has chemical effect as well as
environmental effect.
Two types of investigations can be done to know the influence of
solvent on reactions in solution.
(i) If a reaction occurs both in solution and in the gas phase,
the influence of solvent on the reaction in solution can be understood.
Such reactions are very few. Eg. Thermal decomposition of N 2O5. The
rate constants, preexponential factors and activation energies are the
same in various solvents as in the gas phase. Thus a solvent plays a
subsidiary role. Reactions that occur in the gas phase as well as in
solution show similar behaviour in solution as in the gas and the reaction
is not affected by the solvent.
(ii) If a reaction does not occur in the gas phase the influence
of solvent on the reaction can be studied, by comparing the kinetics of
reactions in different solvents. Eg., reaction between triethylamine &
ethyliodide has been studied in 22 different solvents by Menschutkin. It
is found that k, A and Ea vary considerably from solvent to solvent. A
similar wide variation was found in the reaction between pyridine and
methyl iodide.
Factors determining reaction rates in solution
A reaction between 2 molecules in solution involves 3 steps:
1. Diffusion of the reactant molecules towards each other.
2. Actual chemical transformation and
3. Diffusion of the products away from each other.
In most of the reactions, chemical transformation is the slow rate
determining step. If diffusion step would be slow, the activation energy will
be lower (not greater than 20 kJ mol-1). Most of the chemical reactions have
high Ea values.
Activity Coefficients (Application of Transition state theory to reactions in
solution)
Transition state theory was applied to reactions in solution by Wynne-
Jones, Eyring, Evans & Bell. As it is difficult to formulate partition functions
for substances in the liquid solution, it is convenient to use CTST-thermodynamic
65
derivation which will involve activity coefficients in order to estimate the
rate constant of a reaction in solution.
Consider a reaction A + B X in which the reactants A & B are in
quasi equilibrium with the activated complex. Then the equilibrium constant
of the reaction is
Thus
(or)
... (1)
... (3)
66
This equation (3) relates the rate constant for a reaction in solution to
the rate constant of the same reaction in gas phase. Also this equation relates
the rate constant for a reaction in any solution to that in a very dilute solution
where substances behave ideally.
If rates in solution and in gas phase are to be equal, the activity
coefficient factor must be unity. This happens in an unimolecular reaction
A polar solvent solvates the activated complex more than the reactant if the
reactions involves formation of ions.
Consider the reaction
I=
where ci is the concentration of each ion present in the solution and zi is the
charge number.
The rates of II order reactions between charged species are strongly
affected by ionic strength of the solution. When the reacting species are of
the same sign, an increase in ionic strength increases the rate. When the ions
are of opposite sign, the rate decreases with increasing ionic strength.
Consider the reaction
... (1)
Taking log10,
log10k = log10k0 + log10yA + log10yB – log10yX
substituting for log10y from (2),
68
log10k = log10k0
= log10k0
= log10k0
= log10k0 + 2BZAZBI1/2
= logk0 + 1.02ZAZBI1/2 B = 0.51
1/2
= 1.02 ZAZB I
69
(A) Co(NH3)5Br2+ + Hg2+
(B)
... (1)
70
The work done on the system in moving the ions together from infinite
distance (x = ) to form the double sphere activated complex in which
x = dAB is given by integration of (1).
L = Avogadro number
The total molar Gibbs energy of activation is the sum of electrostatic
and non electrostatic contributions.
by RT,
( )
71
Reaction between bromoacetate and thiosulphate ions in aqueous
Significance
1. Calculation of dAB
all other terms except dAB are known in this slope, dAB can be calculated from
experimental slope. In a number of cases, the values obtained in the order of
a few hundred picometers are reasonable.
2. Preexponential Factors
The electrostatic contribution to entropy of activation,
As
72
In equilibrium = 78.5 and = 0.0046 k-1 over a
Pre-exponential factor
... (3)
Now G = H – TS
G = E + PV + TS
dG = dE + PdV + vdP – TdS – sdT
Since dq = dE + PdV = TdS
dG = VdP
At constant, dT = 0
(dG)T = VdP
=V
= V
k=
ln k = ... (6)
74
Differentiating equation (6) w.r.t. P at constant temperature,
= ... (7)
from (5)
= substitute in (7)
= ... (8)
Integrating (8)
ln k =
when p = 0, k = k0
ln k0 = constant
= .
V = slope RT
75
Case 1
When V is negative
From equation (9), the rate constant k will increase with increase in P.
This is seen in those reactions where an increase in electrical charge takes
place in going from reactants to activated complex.
Eg. First order SN1 solvolysis and reactions of alkyl halides with amines.
These type of reactions are known as slow reactions.
Case 2
V is negligibly small
Hence
ln k = ln k0 = constant
(i.e.) reaction rate (k) is almost independent of pressure. This happens in
those reactions in which the activated complex possesses the same charge as
the reacting species.
Eg. SN2 reaction between OH and primary alkyl halides
OH- + R – X [HO- ... R – ... X] HO – R + X-
Such reactions occur at normal rates.
Case 3
When V is positive
According to equation (9), ln k will decrease with an increase in P.
This arise in those reactions involving oppositely charged ions such that the
charge decreases from reactants to transition state. For eg.,
[Co(NH3)5Br]2+ + OH- [HOCO(NH3)5Br]+ [Co(NH3)5OH]2+ + Br-
These type of reactions are generally fast.
Significance of V
1. For reactions between opposite ions
In such reactions, oppositely charged reacting ions transition state
products.
The transition state will have weaker electrical field, resulting into
release of the solvent molecules from its coordination which give rises
to +ve V and S values.
2. For reactions between ions of same sign charges
In such reactions the transition state will have stronger electrical field
than that of reacting ions. This causes a decrease in volume and also a
loss of degree of freedom and hence causing a decrease of entropy
(i.e.) S = -ve.
3. Establishing the mechanism of reactions
The V has been used for establishing the mechanism of reactions by
providing the concept about the nature of transition state.
76
Catalysis by Enzymes
Enzymes are biological catalysts. They are more specific than by acids
and bases. Some enzymes show absolute specificity.
Lower degree of specificity is shown by proteolytic enzymes which
catalyze the hydrolysis of peptide linkage provided that certain structural
conditions are satisfied in the neighbourhood of the linkage. This is known as
group specificity.
Some catalysts catalyse the reactions of one stereo chemical form and
not the other. They are known to have stereo chemical specificity. Eg. The
proteolytic enzymes catalyse the hydrolysis of peptides made from amino
acids in the L configuration.
The enzymes are proteins associated with nonprotein substances
(known as coenzymes or prosthetic group) that are essential to the action of
the enzyme.
The catalytic activity of enzymes is due to a relatively small region of
the protein molecule. This region is referred as active centre.
ES E+P
Applying steady state principle
77
k1[E] [S] – k-1[ES] – k2[ES] = 0 ... (1)
In enzyme reactions [subs] >> [E]. Only a small proportion of the
substrate is bound to the enzyme.
Hence
[E0] = [E] + [ES]
[E] = [E]0 – [ES]
substitute in (1)
k1([E]0 – [ES]) [S] – k-1 ES – k2[ES] = 0
k1[E]0 [S] – k1[ES] [S] – (k-1 + k2) [ES] = 0
k1[E]0 [S] = (k1[S] + (k-1 + k2)) [ES]
= ... (4)
by k1
u=
v=
v= ... (8)
where
V = k2[E]0
78
V is limiting rate at high substrate concentration. It is often known as
maximal velocity.
when [S] = km, (8) becomes
v= ... (9)
... (10)
by km,
79
slope m =
intercept =
Eadie Plot
Example of Mechanism
E+S
v= ... (11)
V= ... (12)
and
80
km = ... (13)
In this case the intermediate ES' exists only at very low concentrations
and can be neglected so that the mechanism reduces to the simple one
intermediate mechanism.
where k0 is the rate constant for the reaction of the substrate in the bulk phase
and km is the rate constant for the reaction of the substrate in the micelle. The
overall rate constant for the reaction kp is then given by the expression
from which
81
Since
and
Hence,
Since the overall rate constant for the reaction kp and the rate constant
for the reaction in the absence of micelles k0 are readily obtained from kinetic
data, a plot of 1/(k0 kp) versus [1/c CMC], which should be a straight line
with slope = N/K(k0 km) and intercept = 1/(k0 km), allows the calculation of
km, the rate constant for the substrate complexed with the micelles and K, the
binding constant of the substrate to the micelle.
EXERCISE
1. Identify the symmetry elements and assign the point group in
trans-dichloroethylene.
2. Write a short note on direct product?
3. What is meant by a class of a group?
4. State and explain great orthogonality theorem.
5. Deduce the character table for C2v point group.
6. Explain the application of CTST to reaction kinetics.
7. Write briefly about the potential energy surfaces.
8. What is meant by primary and secondary kinetic isotope effect?
9. Derive Bronsted Bjerrum equation.
10. Deduce Michaelis Menten equation.
11. Discuss the mechanism of H2 – O2 explosion reaction.
12. State the principle of microscopic reversibility.
82