Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Xiong 1996
Xiong 1996
144 01996, Elsevier Science Ltd Trends in Food Science & Technology April 1996 [Vol. 71
nature and comprehensiveness of the background information. Unfortunately, meat science and meat manufactur-
subjects covered and the currentness the book contains very few graphic ing processes from a broad perspec-
of the information contained in the illustrations or tables to show results tive. Key references and related read-
book make it timely and useful to from exemplary studies. Thus, those ing, most being important reviews in
academia, industry and regulatory readers who are used to reading sci- the area of muscle foods, are cited,
services. entific journals might find the book less providing the reader with easy access
Meat and Meat Products: Tech- straightforward or self-explanatory to pertinent material. The authors
nology, Chemistry and Microbiology than some other food science books. have also compiled a detailed index
differs from most other meat science The book is rather technological; of the various subjects, which greatly
books in writing style. In addition to the discussion of the principles of facilitates the search for specific top-
the features already described above, meat science is done by linking the ics of interest to the reader. In conclu-
each of the chapters also contains fundamental concepts of muscle sion, this is a very informative meat
so-called information boxes, which chemistry, microbiology and process- science and technology book, and it
give extra information related to the ing technology to the actual manufac- should be extremely useful to food
subject under discussion in a humor- turing processes in the current meat scientists, meat processors and uni-
ous, entertaining and story-telling-like industry. Differences and similarities versity students.
manner. Furthermore, footnotes, which in meat processing practices em-
are either abstracted from recent studies ployed by different countries as well Youling 1. Xiong
or descriptions of certain concepts or as regulations adopted are discussed, Department of Animal Sciences,
phenomena, are also used to highlight thus allowing the readers to gain an 907 W.P. Garrigus Building, University of Kentucky,
the most important points and provide understanding and appreciation of Lexington, KY 40546.0215, USA.
It is claimed
The Food System:
on the back cover
A Guide ‘makes
that
an The Food System: A Guide
ideal text for students working on any
by Geoff Tansey and Tony Worsley, Earthscan Publications, 1995. f15.95 (xi t 259 pages)
aspect of food - from agriculture and
ISBN 1 85383 277 4
food technology, management, retail-
ing, catering and consumer studies, to
politics and development’, and I can matters’ includes chapters dealing purpose of the book. The first thing
well believe that many students will with ‘Food and the biosphere’, one reads on turning the cover is:
find it provides a useful overview of ‘Modern food - where did it come ‘Frank, devastatingly honest and ex-
a vast array of material. However, if from?’ and ‘Food, culture and human pertly researched, this is the essential
they are tempted to use the text as a needs’. The text ranges, inter alia, guide for anyone seeking to under-
substitute for more detailed and sys- from a discussion of the carbon cycle, stand the global food jigsaw. It re-
tematic study their trust will be mis- through land degradation and the veals the lunacies of marketing, the
placed. Inevitably, given the breadth concept of sustainability, the domesti- greed, the corruption, the hidden
of the subject matter addressed, the cation of animals, to nutrition guide- deals that control the way the world
depth of its coverage was bound to lines, toxicity testing and social influ- is fed. If you want to understand why
be thin, and at worst misleadingly ences on food intake. Part 2 outlines the world feeds itself in the way it
superficial. For example, I would not the roles of farmers and farm work- does, you must read this book.’
recommend that readers view this ers, food processors, distributors and Fortunately, the text itself failed to
text as an authoritative source on caterers, and consumers. Apparently, live up to these words of praise from
the enclosure movement, the poten- ‘People in urbanized, industrialized Derek Cooper. Whilst the style verges
tial benefits of R&D, or the recently societies are called consumers. This on the polemical, the object of the
concluded Agreement on Agriculture reflects the affluence and dominance authors’ ire is never particularly clear,
in the GATT (General Agreement on of money in these societies and the but a mistrust of industry and govern-
Tariffs and Trade) Uruguay Round. importance of the continuing con- ment prevails. Economists are cer-
Readers of this review might be inter- sumption and growth of goods and tainly not favoured, although, as an
ested to learn that ‘the limited liability services in the market economies. But economist, I would argue that the
status of companies means, for ex- “consumer” is a dehumanizing term text could have been much improved
ample, that they do not have to take that reduces a person to a single, if its economics content had been
any responsibility for the social, en- somewhat passive, aspect of human strengthened. Despite an attractive
vironmental or economic impact of life - the ability to use money to con- presentation, and its seemingly inex-
their actions’. In a total muddle, mix- sume goods and services’ (p. 142). haustible marshalling of facts, Tansey
ing the problem of externalities with Part 3 includes a chapter that outlines and Worsley’s text remains an enigma.
limited liability status, the paragraph the roles of science, technology, in- Its most serious shortcoming, how-
runs on ‘They can treat these costs as formation and management as ‘tools ever, is its lack of rigorous analysis.
external to their operations’ (p. 228). for control’; a chapter on food law
Despite the title, many of the ex- and food policy; and concludes with Alan Swinbank
amples in the book come from the a chapter entitled ‘Food policies for a Department ofAgricultural Economics and
UK, although other developed - and new millennium’. Management, University of Reading,
indeed developing - countries are Despite the wealth of information 4 Farley Gate, Whiteknights Road,
mentioned in the text. Part 1, ‘Food reported, it is difficult to discern the PO Box 237, Reading, UK RG6 2AR.
Trends in Food Science & Technology April 1996 [Vol. 71 01996, Elsevier Science Ltd 145