Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Accounting information
systems
5th edition
by
Prepared by
Alison Parkes
Discussion questions
10.1 Berwick Ltd has always had a strategy of cost leadership; that is, selling high
volumes of low-cost products at a competitive price. During a recent sales slump,
Berwick Ltd saw its sales revenues drop dramatically and has decided to move
strategically to a product differentiation strategy; that is, to sell lower volumes of
high-quality products at a premium price.
(a) What are the implications of this strategy change for the revenue cycle?
(LO1)
(b) What changes would you expect to see in the revenue cycle?
(LO4)
(c) What are the implications of this strategy change in terms of the
usefulness of historical sales data for decision making?
(LO3)
(a) This strategy change will have big implications for the revenue cycle, which is
fundamentally driven by the level of sales. All existing policies and procedures will be geared
around volume, and pricing targets flowing from the cost leadership (high volume / low
price) strategy. To move to a product differentiation (high price / high quality) strategy
requires revisiting and realigning existing policies and procedures. In particular quality
control should receive more attention than under the previous strategy.
(b) Assessing changes in the order of the processes in the revenue cycle:
1.1 The inventory check would be performed as described however the policy relating to
tolerances on inventory decisions may alter, allowing Berwick Ltd to reject orders that they
may previously have processed. The logic behind this is that under a cost leadership strategy
customer service, while still important, may be overridden by desire to maintain sales volume
however a product differentiation strategy promotes a desire to maintain high levels of
customer satisfaction and service. Risking offending a customer by supplying goods of
insufficient quality may be acceptable under cost leadership, but is less acceptable under
product differentiation. As an example, using a product differentiation strategy Berwick
Ltd.’s policy may indicate that if there are less than 2 of a requested item on hand the
customer should be advised that stocks are low and there is a small possibility of a delay.
Under cost leadership this policy may change to indicate that staff should accept all orders
where stock available is greater than zero.
1.2 Using a similar logic to 1.1 – the policy establishing the tolerance levels for credit limit
acceptance / rejection may be tightened to allow only suitable orders to progress to
fulfilment.
1.3. The only activity potentially affected here is the notification to the customer. While still
important, the procedural aspects may be changed to endorse a lower cost alternative. As an
example a customer previously advised via an automatically generated non-personalised
email notification could now receive a phone call from their dedicated sales representative
2.1, 2.2, & 2.3. The activities around picking, packing and shipping the goods would all be
affected by volume and speed considerations. Handling lower volumes of goods may require
changes to be made to physical working spaces and the related logistics considerations. It
may be effective to introduce quality assurance technology to manage some previously
manual functions, such as picking goods (robots), or checking shipment quantities (bar codes
and scanners). Policies would need to be reviewed to check for the presence of internal
controls designed to promote high quality outcomes as it will become more important to
ensure compliance with these policies so only high quality products are delivered. Human
resource policies should also be checked to ensure that any motivators offered for staff
conducting these activities are aligned to the new strategy.
3.1 & 3.2. Volume considerations as discussed in relation to process 2.0 would also be a
consideration here. Depending on how automated the billing cycle currently is at Berwick Ltd
they may need to consider introducing a higher degree of data integration and automation for
billing to ensure the timeliness and completeness of invoices raised. Berwick Ltd may also
need to consider a complete revamp of their billing system. Introducing a post-billing system
(if not already in place) may be highly desirable, particularly given the move to less
customers and sales for higher price which would tend to reduce the incidence of non-
payment or late payment.
4.1 & 4.2. Receiving and recording payments will be affected by sales volume as the
customer base is likely to end up consisting of a moderate level of customers with repeated
buys. Berwick Ltd should spend some time analysing the likely outcome in order to guide
planning before making any policy or procedural changes. Irrespective of the volumes
expected, Berwick Ltd should consider offering less expensive payment channels such as
online payments, if these are not already made available to customers; they may also wish to
issue electronic, rather than paper based, customer statements. Any opportunity to improve
customer service should be taken, as this will improve their ability to price goods higher than
competitors in the marketplace. If credit policies have been relaxed then the procedures for
detection and follow up of outstanding customer accounts should be examined with the
intention of ensuring early follow up and debt resolution, given the potential liquidity
problems associated with higher levels of bad debts.
(c) Careful modelling and analysis would be required before historic sales data would be
suitable for use in any decision making task. Sales data is used in decisions relating to
marketing, production, purchasing and human resource related activities, so the implications
of the strategy change are immense. Berwick Ltd may need to adopt a heuristic to deal with
this issue, for example they may assume that volumes under a differentiation strategy are
likely to be historic volumes reduced by a factor of x and adjust all analysis to allow for this.
In addition pricing decisions should be altered to include consideration of the ability of the
market to bear a particular price, rather than being based solely on costs of production as is
common under a cost leadership strategy. Berwick Ltd would need to be very careful
whatever approach they take; as even a slightly incorrect assumption abut [pricing levels
could have an unpredictably large effect.
10.2 Mascolo Ltd has decided to introduce PayPal to allow their customers to pay for
goods they have bought online.
(a) What controls would you expect to see introduced to ensure the safety of
Mascolo’s customer data?
(LO5)
(b) Which activities in the receive and record payment process will be
affected?
(LO2, LO4)
(c) What changes would you expect to see in these activities?
(LO4)
(d) What metrics could you use to measure the success of this initiative post
implementation?
(LO6)
(a) Mascolo Ltd should ensure that they limit access to the PayPal account to those staff who
genuinely need this access to perform their regular duties.
(b) Both Receiving (4.1) and Recording (4.2) of payments would be affected.
(c) The most important change is that payments will be received by the PayPal account, not
credited directly to the company bank account. Cash held in the PayPal account needs to be
regularly transferred across to the company bank account. The company also needs to create
well controlled processes covering when and how payments are receipted. Presumably this
will happen on arrival in the PayPal account so regular reconciliations of the PayPal account
transactions, bank account transfers and total receipted would be required.
(d) Average payment times, number of bad debts, accounts receivable aging.
10.3 Stannus Ltd has just realised that it has a problem with sales data as its sales
order system records sales to customers that subsequently fail a credit check.
(a) What decisions made during the revenue cycle would be affected by this
data problem?
(LO3, LO4)
(b) How would those decisions be affected? How would this data problem
affect the performance of the revenue cycle?
(LO3, LO4, LO6)
(c) How would this data problem affect other processes at Stannus Ltd?
(LO1, LO3, LO4, LO6)
(a) The decision whether to approve a sale would be affected. If a sale can be recorded before
the credit check completes then there is a strong possibility that sales are being approved
which should not be. The only way to correct this would be to cancel the sale after the failed
credit check occurs, which is not only inefficient, it could also lead to customer
dissatisfaction.
(b) The revenue cycle would be affected as Sales would be overstated, and there is a risk that
Accounts Receivable levels will increase, along with an increase in bad debts. Also the
efficiency of the process will be compromised if these invalid sales have to be subsequently
detected and corrected.
(c) The main impact of this data problem is potentially on the revenue process however
liquidity and cash planning functions may also be affected depending on the volume of
invalid sales involved.
10.4 Prior Ltd has a reconciliation problem. The amount of cash receipted and
banked by the cashier does not seem to agree with the amount allocated against
open invoices in the accounts receivable customer records. Prior Ltd seems to
have good controls — it separates the receipting and recording of cash, and it
regularly conducts a reconciliation.
(a) Which internal controls might be missing?
(LO5)
(b) What documentation would you examine in order to investigate this
problem?
(LO4)
(a) Prior Ltd should look at internal controls around cash receipting. Specifically they should
check for reconciliations between cash receipted and cash allocated. Prior Ltd should check
that cash receipts are checked and reconciled against hash or batch totals, and that customers
receive regular account statements.
(b) Cash receipts reports, accounts receivable (receipt allocation) batch input reports
10.5 Dowling Ltd has a new Sales Manager who is keen to improve process efficiency.
She has reviewed the process documentation for the sales cycle and has asked
you to remove the credit check as it is slowing down the sales process and she is
concerned Dowling Ltd is losing sales as a result.
(a) Should you agree to remove the credit check? Why or why not?
(LO1, LO3, LO5)
(b) If you do not agree with removing the credit check, how would you
explain this decision to the CEO?
(LO1, LO5)
(c) If you do agree with removing the credit check, how would you justify
this change to the Accounts Receivable Manager?
(LO1, LO5)
(d) If you remove the credit check, will you need to measure the process
performance differently?
(LO1, LO6)
(a) You should not agree to remove this credit check – the risk is too high. This is a vital
internal control and removing it will likely lead to high levels of default on account payments
and potentially liquidity and cash flow problems.
(b) The Sales Manager needs to understand that this control is in place specifically to
safeguard against payment defaults, and that to remove it risks damaging cash flows and
liquidity.
(c) The justification for the change to the Accounts Receivable Manager would need to be
framed around changing the responsibility for ensuring payment of accounts. To function
properly this responsibility would ideally need to be assigned to the Sales Manager who
removed the credit check.
(d) Performance expectations for the Accounts Receivable and Sales managers would need to
be changed to reflect the removal of the credit check but in reality the Accounts Receivables
manager’s performance is always going to be assessed on rates of recovery and levels of bad
and doubtful debts.
Problems
The case narrative below (AB Hi-Fi) will be used to complete problems 10.1–10.14.
Make sure you read and understand the activities and the case thoroughly before you
commence work on the problems.
Problems 10.1 -10.14 diagram solutions are included below. All diagrams are indicative
only. In addition to the diagrams a table is included for each sub process that identifies
and explains the flows depicted in the various diagrams.
Carrier (3.2)
(2.14)
Online Sales
Revenue Cycle (3.3)
Bank
(4.1)
10.2 Prepare a level 0 logical DFD for the revenue process at AB Hi-Fi.
(LO4)
(a)
AB Hi Fi Revenue Cycle
Inputs delivery
Browse online Purchase Inputs sales Order
and credit card
store product? order data correct?
details
Computer
Picking tickets
printed
(b)
AB Hi Fi Revenue process
Collects picking
Picks goods
tickets
Shipping Clerk
Indicates
Scans sales Correct Payment Attaches
shipping
order number items? made? delivery slip
complete
Computer
Updates Sales
Retrieves sales Creates delivery
Order and
order details slip
Inventory data
Function
Collects goods
for delivery to
customer
(c)
AB Hi Fi Revenue Process
Sends credit
card check file
Creates credit
Bank
Credit ok?
report
Receivable Clerk
Accounts
Receives
marked up
credit report
(d)
AB Hi Fi Revenue process
Transfers funds
Bank
Updates Cash
receipts
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(a)
(1.1) Product
(1.3)
(1.9)
Customer
(1.4)
(1.5) (1.2)
(1.6)
(1.12)
(1.7)
(1.13)
(1.8) AB Computer
(1.10)
(1.11) Sales order
(1.14) (1.15)
(1.16)
(1.18)
(1.19)
(1.17)
Picking
Packing &
Shipping
Credit card
Inventory
check
(b)
Processing the
sales order
Warehouse
(2.1)
Clerk
(2.5)
Billing the
(2.4) (2.10)
customer
(2.6) Computer
(2.8)
Shipping Clerk (2.9)
(2.11)
(2.12)
(2.14)
Inventory
Carrier
(c)
(3.2)
Credit Card
Bank
check
(3.1)
(3.3)
Computer
(3.6)
(3.5)
(3.4)
Accounts
Receivable
clerk
(3.7)
(3.9)
Credit status
Picking
Packing &
Shipping
(d)
Bank
Cash receipts
(4.1)
Computer (4.6)
(4.2) (4.5)
Credit status
Accounts
(4.3) receivable
clerk
(a)
(b)
At 8am daily
(2.1)
Scans
Picking Ticket (2.4)
Extracts sales
order
(2.5) (2.6) Sales order
Error routine not
documented Picks
Goods
Checks
item, sales
(2.2) order,
Sales Order
picking
Highlighted Credit
Billing the
(2.3) status report (2.8)
customer
Shipping complete
(2.11)
Inventory Delivery slip
(c)
(3.2)
(3.1) Create bank report
Credit card check Bank
3)
(3.
Credit card Prepare credit
(3.4)
Status status report
Credit status
(3.7) report 2
(3.6)
Credit Status
Report
1
Credit status
Highlights
invalid
credit
(3.8)
Highlighted credit
(3.9) status report
Picking packing
and shippng
(d)
Bank
Credit status
(4.3) report
Credit status
Compares
totals
10.7 10.7 Table 10.3 identifies 11 risks typically encountered when processing a sales
order.
Required
(a) Analyse the degree of exposure to each of these risks for the sales process
at AB Hi-Fi.
(b) Determine how many of the common controls described in table 10.3 are
present in the sales process at AB Hi-Fi.
(c) Prepare a short report suitable for senior management to explain how
risky you think the sales process is, and how comprehensive the current
internal controls are.
(d) Prepare a recommendation describing any changes you would like to
make to the sales process at AB Hi-Fi in order to reduce the level of risk.
(LO5)
(a)
Risk Exposure
1 Selling goods that are not available to be High – no inventory check is conducted before sale
shipped is approved / processes
2 Poor decision making — allowing an Partial - Applicable to AB as order can proceed
order to proceed when goods are not without goods being available, as no inventory check
available, or rejecting an order when conducted all orders accepted so no risk of
goods are available incorrectly rejecting an order
3 Selling goods to a customer who won’t / High – no credit check conducted at time of sale
can’t pay for the goods
4 Poor decision making, accepting a non–
Partial - Applicable to AB as order can proceed for
credit worth customer, or rejecting a
non-creditworthy customer, as no credit check
creditworthy customer conducted all orders accepted so no risk of
incorrectly rejecting a creditworthy customer
5 Creating fictitious sales High – no customer validation check conducted
6 Failure to process valid sales request Minimal – on line real time transaction processing
received from customer with outcome monitored by customer via order
confirmation while online
7 Incorrect decision outcome advised. Not applicable to AB’s online sales
8 Customer not advised of outcome Not applicable to AB’s online sales
9 Incorrect sales advised, resulting in Unable to assess – narrative does not disclose
under/ overpayment of commissions to whether commission payments are made
sales staff.
10 Incorrect goods included on picking Minimal – automated using real time data
ticket
11 Warehouse not advised of the picking Some - picking tickets may not print, or may be lost
ticket details as left on printer overnight
(b)
Control Present?
Performing inventory checks No
Unable to assess – revenue narrative
Maintaining accurate and timely perpetual inventory records,
periodically conducting physical inventory checks. does not disclose
Exception reporting for management of any sales rejected No - not applicable to AB’s online
sales
Performing credit checks No
Independent maintenance of customer accounts and credit No - not applicable to AB’s online
limits, pre-billing systems. sales
Exception reporting for management of any sales rejected. No - not applicable to AB’s online
sales
Regular monitoring of accounts receivable balances and age No
Signed purchase order form from customer No
confirming customer accounts regularly via statements of No
account
Entering data physically close to where order request is Yes – data entry performed by
received; entering data in a timely manner customer
Automation via pre-devised workflow Some automation re picking etc., but
limited on payment processing
Exception reporting of customer orders not acknowledged No - not applicable to AB’s online
within a reasonable timeframe sales
Automation using sales order data Yes
Obtaining approval from sales manager before commissions Unable to assess – revenue narrative
are paid does not disclose
Exception reporting of sales No
orders with no picking ticket generated
(c) Reports should identify that lack of inventory and credit checks increases risk, and that
internal controls in this area are deficient. Also they should be able to work out that the credit
card status is checked too late in the process to make it useable, increasing risk greatly.
(d) Should recommend that they need to check credit card status before processing sale –
particularly important in an online sales environment such as this, and in an organisation
where picking packing and despatching is automated based on the sales order acceptance.
10.8 Table 10.4 identifies eight risks typically encountered when despatching a sales
order.
Required
(a) Analyse the degree of exposure to each of these risks for the goods
despatch process at AB Hi-Fi.
(b) Determine how many of the common controls described in table 10.4 are
present in the goods despatch process at AB Hi-Fi.
(c) Prepare a short report suitable for senior management to explain how
risky you think the goods despatch process is, and how comprehensive the
current internal controls are.
(d) Prepare a recommendation describing any changes you would like to
make to the goods despatch process at AB Hi-Fi in order to reduce the
level of risk.
(LO5)
(a)
Risk Exposure
1 Picking the wrong goods Low – picked goods are double checked by shipping clerk
2 Theft of inventory High – loose picking error process when goods are not
available could lead to opportunistic theft
3 Goods packed incorrectly Low – packed goods are double checked by shipping clerk
4 Goods labelled incorrectly Low – picked goods are double checked by shipping clerk
5 Slow/non-shipment of goods High – no way of identifying slow orders in current process,
back orders not recorded. Partial orders not dispatched
6 Theft of goods High – shipping clerk could easily steal goods
7 Goods delivered incorrectly Low – delivery slips used to identify destination
8 Theft of goods High – goods placed on dock for courier pick up, no evidence
of goods being monitored
(b)
Control Present?
Checking goods to picking ticket by an independent staff No
member
Restricting warehouse access No
Conduct random periodic physical stocktakes Unable to assess – revenue narrative
does not disclose
Independent check of packed goods to picking ticket No
Using of barcode scanners to check goods No
Firmly attaching shipping label to goods after packing Yes
Independent check of goods to picking ticket and shipping Yes
label
Exception report of goods picked but not shipped within a No
reasonable timeframe
Independent shipping authorisation check Yes
Restricted access to packed goods waiting to be delivered No
Separately and clearly packaging and labelling each order Yes
Requiring delivery driver to provide valid customer No
signature for each delivery made
(c) Report should identify that current risk is low due to checking of goods etc., controls are
good but could be made more comprehensive.
(d) Monitor goods until collected by courier. Require receipt of delivery signature.
10.9 Table 10.5 identifies three risks typically encountered when billing a sale.
Required
(a) Analyse the degree of exposure to each of these risks for the billing process at
AB Hi-Fi.
(b) Determine how many of the common controls described in table 10.5 are
present in the billing process at AB Hi-Fi.
(c) Prepare a short report suitable for senior management to explain how risky
you think the billing process is, and how comprehensive the current internal
controls are.
(d) Prepare a recommendation describing any changes you would like to make to
the billing process at AB Hi-Fi in order to reduce the level of risk.
(LO5)
(a)
Risk Exposure
1 Failure to bill customers Low – requires credit card input before sale can be processed
2 Billing customers when no goods High – customers must input credit card before goods are
have been shipped shipped – also issue with back order handlings and no
inventory check increases risk
3 Invoice errors — both Low - outcome monitored by customer via order confirmation
overbilling and under-billing while online
(b)
Control Present?
Separation of billing and shipping Yes
functions
Pre-numbering shipping documents and No
reviewing any shipping documents not
invoiced
Use of a pre-billing system (vs. a post- No – although a pre billing type system exists the credit
billing system status is not checked until very late – then it is a manual
check and the data used is not timely
Reconciliation of sales order to shipping No – billed before shipping
documents
Using independent pricing data and/or Yes
fixed price lists
Populating price data with data from those Yes
price lists
Confirming customer accounts regularly No
(c) Report should identify billing is risky and controls not comprehensive.
(d) Automated credit card check to be conducted before sales order can be accepted.
10.10 Table 10.6 identifies three risks typically encountered when receiving and
recording payments.
Required
(a) Analyse the degree of exposure to each of these risks for the receiving
payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(b) Determine how many of the common controls described in table 10.6 are
present in the receiving payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(c) Prepare a short report suitable for senior management to explain how
risky you think the receiving payments process is, and how
comprehensive the current internal controls are.
(d) Prepare a recommendation describing any changes you would like to
make to the receiving payments process at AB Hi-Fi in order to reduce
the level of risk.
(LO5)
(a)
Risk Exposure
1 Late/slow/non-payment of High – credit status checked too late in process
accounts
2 Theft of cash and/or cheques Low – direct credit to bank account from cardholders account
3 Incorrect recording of customer High –manual highlighting of credit status report will lead to
accounts errors
(b)
Control Present?
Prompt invoicing, and setting suitable No – not applicable
payment terms
Regularly and consistently following up of No
overdue accounts
Removing credit facilities for any non- No
payers
Minimising the cash handling points and No – not applicable
the numbers of people handling cash
Entering cash receipts close to where Yes
received
Using lockboxes or safes and bank No – not applicable
regularly
Immediate/prompt cheque endorsement No – not applicable
and immediate separation of remittance
advice and cheques
One-for-one checking of deposit slip and No – not applicable
cheques
Regular bank reconciliations by an No- no evidence of this
independent person
Limiting access to online banking No- no evidence of this
Creating batch or hash totals of cash No – but the total transferred is checked to the credit status
receipts and reconciling inputs to accounts report
receivable
Issuing regular customer statements, No – not applicable
incorporating use of turnaround documents
(c) Process risk is fairly low due to electronic payment processing, but risky in terms of
identification of non-payers; internal controls are not comprehensive in these areas.
(d) Record orders as unpaid until payment is actually received, then check and reconcile to
individual customer accounts.
10.11 AB Hi-Fi has adopted a cost leadership strategy. Its overall plan is to undercut
competitors on pricing and so gain market share.
(a) How well does its current revenue cycle align with this business strategy?
(b) Are there any opportunities to improve the degree of alignment between
the revenue cycle and the business strategy? Explain what you would
change and how this would improve the strategic alignment.
(LO1)
(a) Revenue cycle is fairly well aligned to a cost leadership strategy, operations are
reasonably efficient so costs can be contained and savings passed on to consumers; accepting
all orders improves market share but has risks attached.
(b) Consider introducing more stringent credit requirements and also improving picking
process relating to handling partial order fulfilment. Would align strategically to reduce costs
and therefore price point in order to generate additional market share.
10.12 (a) Identify and describe the technologies that AB Hi-Fi uses in its revenue
cycle activities.
(b) For each of those technologies you identified in part (a), how well does AB
Hi-Fi use the technology? Could you suggest a way to improve the
business benefit obtained by use of any of these existing technologies?
(c) Are there other suitable technologies available that AB Hi-Fi could be
using for the revenue cycle activities? What additional technologies could
AB Hi-Fi implement? What business benefit would these additional
technologies provide?
(LO2)
(c) CRM would help with customer focus and potentially improve level of sales; picking
could be automated to cut warehouse labour costs.
10.13 During process 2.0 Pick, pack and ship the goods at AB Hi-Fi, a shipping officer
has to decide whether to complete the shipment of goods to a customer. Take a
moment to review this section of the narrative before you complete the following
questions.
Required
(a) What data does the shipping officer draw on when making the decision?
(b) Where do the data you identified in part (a) come from?
(c) Are these data reliable, that is, is there any possibility that there could be
errors in the data?
(d) Are these data sufficient to make the decision, or can you identify
additional data that the officer should consider when making the
decision?
(e) What would be the consequences of an incorrect decision?
(LO3)
(a) Data in the Credit status report, picking ticket, sales order.
(b) Picking ticket and sales order data internally generated from AB computer, credit status
report data from bank.
(c) Credit status report is manually checked and highlighted, high risk of errors. Sales order
and picking ticket data have little or no risk of error.
(e) Goods would be shipped to customer who cannot/ will not pay for goods.
10.14 Explain how you would measure performance of the revenue cycle at AB Hi-Fi,
specifically:
(a) What metrics would you use to measure performance?
(b) For each metric, explain where you would obtain the data required for
that metric.
(c) For each metric, explain why it is a good metric to help measure how well
the revenue cycle is meeting its objectives.
(LO6)
(a) (b) (c)
Customer complaints/satisfaction Customer survey Would measure
complaints only, the
primary cycle risk is
shipping goods not paid
for so which would not
decrease customer
satisfaction.
Cycle time to fill and deliver orders Subtract date/time that Short cycle times indicate
delivery slip is printed efficiency in cycle
from the date/time the
sales order was accepted
% of sales on back order Check contents of Would show what
awaiting goods folder in proportion of sales orders
warehouse are waiting for inventory
items – would expect this
to be fairly high as no
inventory check
conducted
Number of bad debts written off Financial/general ledger Identify consequences of
reports lack of credit check,
determine efficiency of
current pre billing system
The case narrative below (AB Hi-Fi) will be used to complete problems 10.15–10.22.
Make sure you read and understand the activities and the case thoroughly before you
commence work on the problems.
Problems 10.15 -10.22 diagram solutions are included below. In addition to the
diagrams a table is included that identifies and explains the flows depicted in the
various diagrams.
10.15 Prepare a context diagram for the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(LO4)
Cashier
(1)
Recording
payments
process
10.16 Prepare a process map for the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(LO4)
AB Hi Fi Revenue process
Forwards
receipts report
Receivable clerk
Accounts
10.17 Prepare a level 0 logical DFD for the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(LO4)
Cashier
(1)
1.0
Input receipts (3)
(6)
Cash Receipts
(11)
Accounts
Receivable
(12)
2.0
(13) Update (16)
receipts
(19)
Receipts
reports
10.18 Prepare a physical DFD for the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(LO4)
Cashier
(1)
(19)
Accounts (2)
Receivable
Clerk
(4)
(5)
(12)
Receipts
reports
Cash Receipts
(7)
(8)
(10)
Computer (3)
(11)
(14) (16)
(15)
(13)
(6)
(17)
Accounts
Receivable
10.19 Prepare a systems flowchart for the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(LO4)
Customer
Cashier (1) Receipts
Log in request
batch
Validate login
(2)
Create batch
Cash receipt
(4)
batch
Extract oipen
(5)
Customer number invoices
(3)
(6)
Open invoices (7)
(9)
Selected invoice
(8) Calculates total
Check
total
(13)
Records total
(11) (12)
authorisation updates status
Cash Receipts
Customer
Cash receipts
Receipts (17)
Print report
Attaches
(18)
Receipt
reports Customer
Receipts
(19) Cash receipts
10.20 Table 10.5 identifies three risks typically encountered when receiving and
processing a payment.
Required
(a) Analyse the degree of exposure to each of these risks for the recording
payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(b) Determine how many of the common controls described in table 10.5 are
present in the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi.
(c) Prepare a short report suitable for senior management to explain how
risky you think the recording payments process is, and how
comprehensive the current internal controls are.
(d) Prepare a recommendation describing any changes you would like to
make to the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi in order to reduce
their level of risk.
(LO5)
(a)
Risk Exposure
1 Late/slow/non-payment of Unable to assess from given section of narrative
accounts
2 Theft of cash and/or cheques Unable to assess – cash handling not included in narrative
section which addresses cash receipt allocation only
3 Incorrect recording of customer High – receipt allocation appears to be conducted without
accounts reference to a remittance advice, leaving the clerk unable to
accurately determine exactly which invoices are being paid.
(b)
Control Present?
Prompt invoicing, and setting suitable payment No – not applicable
terms
Regularly and consistently following up of No – not applicable
overdue accounts
Removing credit facilities for any non-payers No – not applicable
Minimising the cash handling points and the No – not applicable
numbers of people handling cash
Entering cash receipts close to where received Yes
Using lockboxes or safes and bank regularly No – not applicable
Immediate/prompt cheque endorsement and No – no evidence of this
immediate separation of remittance advice and
cheques
One-for-one checking of deposit slip and No – not applicable
cheques
Regular bank reconciliations by an independent No – not applicable
person
Limiting access to online banking No – not applicable
Creating batch or hash totals of cash receipts Yes
and reconciling inputs to accounts receivable
Issuing regular customer statements, No – not applicable
incorporating use of turnaround documents
(c) Recording payments does not have high risk; controls are comprehensive but could be
improved.
(d) One should recommend that risk would be reduced if accounts receivable clerk received a
detailed remittance advice instead of a report containing only the total amount paid by the
customer.
10.21 During the recording payments process at AB Hi-Fi the accounts receivable
clerk has to decide which open invoices to allocate the cash receipts amount
against. Take a moment to review this section of the narrative before you
complete the following questions.
Required
(a) What data does the accounts receivable clerk draw on when making the
decision?
(b) Where does the data you identified in part (a) come from?
(c) Is this data reliable, that is, is there any possibility that there could be
errors in the data?
(d) Is this data sufficient to make the decision, or can you identify additional
data that the clerk should consider when making the decision?
(e) What would be the consequences of an incorrect decision?
(LO3)
(c) As only totals are included, and no reconciliation is evident to amounts banked or
customer remittance advices received, the data could be erroneous.
(d) Insufficient data is presented, a detailed list of exactly how much was remitted against
each invoice should be considered.
(e) Invoice status may be incorrectly updated to paid and paid invoices may be left as unpaid,
resulting in potential for confusion when next statement is issued to the customer.
10.22 Consider how you would measure performance of the recording payments
process at AB Hi-Fi; specifically:
(a) What metrics would you would use to measure performance?
(b) For each metric, explain where you would obtain the data required for
that metric.
(c) For each metric, explain why it is a good metric to help measure how well
the revenue cycle is meeting its objectives.
(LO6)
(a) The standard performance metrics of aged accounts receivable reporting, number of bad
debts written off and average payment times would not be helpful for this part of the payment
process as any errors potentially would reside at transaction level rather than customer level.
To measure performance of the recording payments process the best option would be to
monitor the level of customer complaints, or the number of correcting entries made to
customer accounts.
(b) Customer complaints could be logged via a help desk or hotline number; correcting
entries to accounts receivable accounts could be identified and reported by transaction type.
(c) Minimal customer complaints and adjustments mean that receipt allocation is performing
well in terms of accuracy and completeness.
The case narratives below for Yayy Online will be used to complete problems 10.23–
10.37. Make sure you read and understand the activities and the case thoroughly before
you commence work on the problems.
Yayy is a specialised online store that sells only one product each day. In addition to
selling only one product each day, Yayy offers the product of the day for sale until their
stock runs out, or until the end of the day, whichever comes first. Typical Yayy
products are inexpensive (generally between $15 and $50), and are mostly technology-
related gadgets.
Problems 10.23 -10.27 diagram solutions are included below. In addition to the
diagrams a table is included that identifies and explains the flows depicted in the
various diagrams.
Customers browse the web site and if The product page is displayed for browsing (2)
23 they wish to purchase the product for and the customer clicks sell it button (3)
the day select a “sell it to me” button.
Once this button is clicked a login The computer needs to extract the login web page
45 file (4) before it can display it (5)
screen is presented.
Existing customers will key in their The solution shows the most frequent situation –
username and login, new customers are the customer is new to Yayy. The customer clicks
67
routed to a registration screen to input on the new button (6) a registration screen is
89
their name and address details and extracted (7) then displayed (8). the customer
10
create a login. Most customers are new keys in their details (9) they are saved to the
11
customer file (10) and then the product page is re-
to Yayy. presented (11)
After the customer has successfully
logged in, they type in the number of
12
products they want to purchase, and
select their preferred payment option.
Once the number of products required The sale is saved (13) before the total cost is
has been input and saved the total cost calculated and displayed (14)
13 of the order is calculated and displayed.
14 Yayy charges a flat rate for shipping
within Australia, which is added onto
the price of the product/s.
Yayy offers payment via credit card or The solution shows the most frequent situation –
PayPal; most customers choose to pay the customer pays via credit card. The customer
15 via credit card. After the customer keys inputs their card details (15) and then the
16 in their payment details the data are computer send the data to the bank for
sent to the bank (or PayPal) for verification (16)
verification
²⁹Give unto the Lord the glory due unto his name:
The Lord reigneth] i.e. the Lord is claiming His kingdom over the
earth by coming to judge the earth; compare verse 33. Contrast
Habakkuk i. 14, where the prophet complains that Jehovah is not
asserting Himself as the ruler of men.
³³Then shall the trees of the wood sing for joy before
the Lord,
37‒43.
The Service before the Ark and the Service at Gibeon.
the tabernacle of the Lord in the high place that was at Gibeon]
See prefatory note to chapter xiii.; and 2 Chronicles i. 3.
Chapter XVII.
1‒27 (= 2 Samuel vii. 1‒29).
God’s Answer to David’s expressed desire to build a Temple.
David’s Thanksgiving.
but have gone from tent to tent, and from one tabernacle to
another] Samuel but have walked in a tent and in a tabernacle. The
Hebrew text of Chronicles defies translation; that of Samuel is better.
⁶In all places wherein I have walked with all
Israel, spake I a word with any of the judges of
Israel, whom I commanded to feed my people,
saying, Why have ye not built me an house of
cedar?
6. the judges] A better reading than the tribes (Samuel).
10. build thee an house] Samuel make thee an house, the house
meant being a dynasty, and not a building.
from him that was before thee] Samuel from Saul whom I put
away before thee. The reading in Chronicles is to be preferred.
sat before the Lord] So LXX. and 2 Samuel vii. 18. The Targum
rightly paraphrases, “and tarried in prayer before Jehovah.”
21. what one nation in the earth is like thy people Israel] Better as
margin, who is like thy people Israel, a nation that is alone in the
earth. Compare Targum a people unique and chosen in the earth.
24. And let thy name ... magnified] Better, as margin, Yea, let it
be established, and let thy name be magnified.
This chapter like the last is taken from 2 Samuel with a few
omissions and variations. The Chronicler paraphrases (verses 1,
17), omits (verse 2), has a different reading (verses 4, 8, 10, 12). In
some cases the better reading is in Chronicles.