Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Crisis
Committee:
Introduction,
History,
Structure
and
Procedures
Historical
Security
Council
19611
Introduction
to
TCMUN’s
Crisis
Committee
Teton
County
Model
United
Nations
(TCMUN)
is
pleased
to
announce
that
it
will
offer
a
crisis
committee
for
the
first
time
at
its
2014
conference.
Crisis
committees
present
their
participants
with
particularly
challenging
and
enjoyable
learning
opportunities
at
many
Model
UN
conferences
throughout
the
world.
Participants
need
to
do
in-‐depth
research
and
have
command
of
the
topics
likely
to
be
discussed
in
a
crisis
committee.
They
will
be
pushed
to
use
their
imaginations
and
assume
leadership
roles
during
the
committee’s
debates
and
negotiations.
Due
to
the
committee’s
small
size
and
dynamic
pace,
delegates
will
have
ample
occasion
to
speak,
get
involved,
and
develop
leadership
skills.
A
crisis
committee
is
usually
comprised
of
20
or
fewer
delegates
who
respond
to
emerging
issues—either
current
or
historical.
TCMUN
14’s
crisis
committee
will
simulate
a
historical
Security
Council
meeting
in
1961.
Unlike
regular
MUN
committees
that
deal
with
pre-‐
assigned
topics,
crisis
committees
address
issues
announced
during
the
committee’s
session.
Consequently
delegates
must
be
generally
well
informed
about
the
world
in
1961,
and
be
ready
to
make
quick
decisions
about
crisis
such
as
wars,
revolutions,
natural
disasters,
or
economic
collapse
that
might
occur
during
their
committee
sessions.
The
crisis
committee
at
TCMUN
’14
will
open
in
January
1961
with
a
debate
about
the
situation
in
Congo,
a
former
colony
of
Belgium
that
became
independent
on
June
30,
1960.
From
this
initial
discussion,
various
crises
will
emerge
that
will
be
conceived
and
announced
by
the
committee’s
crisis
staff.
The
committee
will
consider
these
crises
and
try
to
develop
strategies
and
measures,
expressed
in
resolutions,
directives,
press
releases,
and
communiqués
for
managing
or
solving
them.
To
participate
effectively
in
this
committee,
delegates
should
have
researched
and
developed
a
good
grasp
of
the
background
of
this
particular
crisis.
In
addition
to
the
Congo
crisis,
committee
delegates
should
be
prepared
to
debate
and
negotiate
resolutions
and
directives
about
other
events
that
the
Security
Council
considered
in
1961.
Both
the
Congo
crisis
and
other
global
issues
considered
by
the
Security
Council
in
1961
are
discussed
in
a
1
This
background
guide
was
prepared
by
InterConnections
21
with
input
from
the
1
companion
document
available
for
this
committee:
The
Historical
Security
Council
1961
(prepared
and
copyrighted
by
AMUN).
History
and
Structure
of
the
Security
Council
up
until
1961
The
Security
Council
of
the
United
Nations
(UN)
was
established
on
October
24,
1945,
when
the
UN
Charter
was
ratified
and
the
UN
came
into
existence
with
51
Member
States.
Created
at
the
end
of
World
War
II,
the
UN
was
the
successor
organization
to
the
League
of
Nations,
which
had
failed
to
keep
peace
after
World
War
I
in
part
due
to
the
non-‐
participation
of
the
United
States.
The
UN
was
set
up
with
the
following
four
purposes:
1. To
maintain
international
peace
and
security,
and
to
that
end:
to
take
effective
collective
measures
for
the
prevention
and
removal
of
threats
to
the
peace,
and
for
the
suppression
of
acts
of
aggression
or
other
breaches
of
the
peace,
and
to
bring
about
by
peaceful
means,
and
in
conformity
with
the
principles
of
justice
and
international
law,
adjustment
or
settlement
of
international
disputes
or
situations
which
might
lead
to
a
breach
of
the
peace;
2. To
develop
friendly
relations
among
nations
based
on
respect
for
the
principle
of
equal
rights
and
self-‐determination
of
peoples,
and
to
take
other
appropriate
measures
to
strengthen
universal
peace;
3. To
achieve
international
co-‐operation
in
solving
international
problems
of
an
economic,
social,
cultural,
or
humanitarian
character,
and
in
promoting
and
encouraging
respect
for
human
rights
and
for
fundamental
freedoms
for
all
without
distinction
as
to
race,
sex,
language,
or
religion;
and
4. To
be
a
centre
for
harmonizing
the
actions
of
nations
in
the
attainment
of
these
common
ends.2
The
UN
Charter
established
six
principal
organs:
the
Security
Council,
the
General
Assembly,
the
Economic
and
Social
Council,
the
Trusteeship
Council,
the
International
Court
of
Justice
and
the
Secretariat.3
Of
these,
the
Security
Council
has
always
had
primary
responsibility
for
the
maintenance
of
global
peace
and
security
and
been
the
most
powerful.
Chapters
VI
and
VII
of
the
Charter
outlined
the
role
of
the
Security
Council
in
maintaining
peace
and
security.
Chapter
VI,
entitled
“Pacific
Settlement
of
Disputes,”
gives
the
Council
the
right
to
“investigate
any
dispute,
or
any
situation
which
might
lead
to
international
friction
or
give
rise
to
a
dispute."4
If
peaceful
means
cannot
be
found
to
settle
disputes,
Chapter
VII
of
the
Charter
authorizes
the
Security
Council
to
take
measures
such
as
issuing
ceasefire
directives
and
sending
military
observers
or
peacekeeping
forces
to
the
scene
of
2
United
Nations,
“Charter
of
the
United
Nations,”
26
June
1945,
Chapter
I,
Article
1,
http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/chapter1.shtml.
3
United
Nations,
“Charter
of
the
United
Nations,”
26
June
1945,
Chapter
3,
Article
7.
4
United
Nations,
“Charter
of
the
United
Nations,”
Chapter
VI,
Article
34.
2
the
dispute.5
It
can
also
pass
resolutions
to
try
to
restore
peace
through
the
application
of
economic
sanctions,
the
setting
up
of
a
blockade,
or
collective
military
action.6
Unlike
the
measures
of
other
UN
organs
which
are
considered
as
recommendations,
Security
Council
resolutions
are
binding
for
all
UN
Member
States.
At
its
founding,
the
Security
Council
had
five
permanent
members—the
five
victorious
allies
in
World
War
II—that
were
given
a
veto
over
all
matters
not
considered
procedural.
These
were
China,
France,
the
United
Kingdom,
USA
and
the
USSR
and
are
often
referred
to
as
the
P5.
In
addition,
six
rotating
members,
who
served
without
a
veto,
were
elected
for
two-‐year
terms
up
until
1966,
when
the
number
of
rotating
members
was
increased
to
ten.
For
procedural
matters,
seven
votes,
irrespective
of
a
possible
P5
veto,
were
sufficient
to
move
a
measure
forward
up
until
1966.7
The
Security
Council
first
met
in
London
on
January
17,
19468.
It
convened
in
New
York
City
at
Hunter
College
in
April
1946
and
moved
into
its
present
headquarters
in
Manhattan
in
April
19529.
It
has
been
on
call
on
at
all
times
over
the
years
to
meet
and
deal
with
urgent
matters
related
to
international
peace
and
security.
The
General
Assembly,
comprised
of
all
Member
States
of
the
UN,
meets
only
once
a
year
in
the
autumn.
Each
Member
State
has
one
vote
irrespective
of
its
size,
population
or
contribution
to
the
UN’s
budget.
The
General
Assembly
resolutions
are
not
considered
legally
binding
under
international
law.
In
1961,
there
were
104
UN
Member
States
represented
in
the
General
Assembly.
10
Due
to
the
Cold
War
that
froze
relations
between
the
US
and
the
USSR
shortly
after
the
UN
came
into
existence,
effective
action
by
the
Security
Council
was
limited
until
the
breakup
of
the
USSR
in
1989.
Though
the
UN
played
an
active
role
during
the
Korean
War
and
peace-‐keeping
forces
were
dispatched
to
try
to
calm
the
Suez
and
Congo
crises,
vetoes
by
the
one
or
several
of
the
permanent
Security
Council
members
prevented
the
Security
Council
from
taking
action
in
many
significant
disputes
and
conflicts
that
occurred
during
the
Cold
War
such
as
the
Hungarian
Revolution
in
1956,
the
Vietnam
War
and
the
Cuban
Missile
Crisis.
11
Committee
Structure,
Definitions
and
Procedures
5
United
Nations,
“Charter
of
the
United
Nations,”
Chapter
VII,
Articles
41
and
42.
6
United
Nations
Security
Council,
“About,”
http://www.un.org/en/sc/about/
7
Paul
Kennedy,
The
Parliament
of
Man:
The
Past,
Present,
and
Future
of
the
United
Nations.
http://www.un.org/en/aboutun/history/1941-‐1950.shtml.
9United
Nations
Security
Council,
“Home”,
http://www.un.org/en/sc/.
10
“Growth
in
United
Nations
membership,
1945-‐present.”
Available
at
http://www.un.org/en/members/growth.shtml.
11
Kennedy,
The
Parliament
of
Man:
The
Past,
Present,
and
Future
of
the
United
Nations,
pp.
54-‐62.
3
At
the
meetings
of
TCMUN’s
crisis
committee,
each
student-‐delegate
will
represent
one
of
the
eleven
members
of
the
1961
Security
Council
or
a
country
invited
by
the
Security
Council
in
1961
to
provide
information
related
to
the
crisis
at
hand
(e.g.
Belgium,
Congo,
and
Cuba).
Five
of
the
eleven
countries
were
the
permanent
members
with
vetoes.
The
remaining
six
member
countries
were:
Ceylon
(now
Sri
Lanka),
Chile,
Ecuador,
Liberia,
Turkey,
and
the
United
Arab
Republic
(currently
Egypt
and
Syria).
Throughout
the
crisis
simulation,
the
TCMUN
Crisis
Staff
(the
TCMUN
Secretary-‐
General,
the
Crisis
Committee
Chair
and
Co
–chair
and
the
Crisis
Director)
will
create
a
storyline
of
made-‐up
occurrences
emerging
from
significant
real-‐life
events
that
took
place
in
1961.
It
will
be
the
delegates’
task
to
react
to
these
dynamic
situations,
trying
their
best
to
find
a
peaceful
solution
while
representing
their
nations’
interests
and
maintaining
their
foreign
policy
goals.
The
procedures
governing
a
crisis
committee’s
deliberations
are
similar
to
most
other
MUN
committees.
Delegates
will
work
extensively—mainly
in
moderated
or
unmoderated
caucuses-‐-‐
to
write
and
pass
resolutions
and
directives
to
respond
to
the
events
made
up
and
announced
by
the
Crisis
Staff.
Resolutions
prepared
by
the
Crisis
Committee
acting
as
the
Security
Council
in
1961
will
use
the
same
procedures
as
those
used
by
a
current
Security
Council.
They
will
be
binding
and
the
most
impactful
measure
that
the
committee
can
take
over
the
long
term.
Their
formatting
will
be
the
same
as
the
formatting
used
in
all
TCMUN
’14
committees.
For
tips
on
resolution
writing,
please
see
http://www.ic21.org/assets/523/Lesson__8.pdf?1351029866.
Directives
are
action
plans
that
the
entire
committee
wishes
to
take
and
are
one
of
the
main
forms
of
writing
in
a
crisis
committee.
Less
emphasis
is
put
on
wording
and
vocabulary
in
directives
than
in
resolutions.
Directives
issues
orders
for
official
action
to
be
taken
in
response
to
the
crisis
at
hand.12
They
should
be
clear,
realistic
and
feasible
to
be
accepted
by
the
TCMUN
Crisis
staff.
Besides
resolutions
and
directives,
there
are
three
other
forms
of
documents
often
crafted
in
crisis
committees:
press
releases,
communiqués,
and
individual
action
orders
or
portfolio
requests.
Press
releases
are
documents
prepared
and
voted
by
the
entire
committee
to
inform
the
public
about
the
crisis
under
consideration
and
to
shape
world
opinion
about
it.
Communiqués
are
formal
messages
about
the
crisis
drafted
and
voted
by
the
committee
and
addressed
to
countries,
organizations
or
people
not
represented
on
the
12
Boston
Invitational
Model
United
Nations
Conference,“BosMUN
XIII
Crisis
Committee
4
committee.
They
can
foster
dialogue
and
negotiations
with
important
parties
involved
in
the
crisis
and
not
on
the
committee.
13
Finally,
individual
action
orders
or
portfolio
requests
are
“secret”
measures
put
forward
by
a
single
delegate
in
pursuit
of
his
or
her
country’s
foreign
policy
goals
and
in
response
to
the
crisis
at
hand.
Actions
that
delegates
choose
to
take
on
their
own
will
be
sent
to
the
Chair
of
the
committee
and
then
approved
or
rejected
by
the
Crisis
Staff.
Such
actions
must
be
realistic
and
feasible.
Individual
actions
are
a
vehicle
for
delegates
to
use
their
creativity,
yet
delegates
must
keep
in
mind
that
consequences
will
follow
every
action
taken.
At
TCMUN,
delegates’
individual
actions
will
be
very
limited
because
collaboration
and
actions
taken
by
the
whole
committee
can
produce
more
effective
solutions
to
conflict.
14
Preparation
for
the
TCMUN
Crisis
Committee
The
documents
entitled
“Security
Council:
Committee:
History
and
Structure”
and
“TCMUN
Historical
Security
Council
1961”
provide
essential
background
information
for
effective
participation
in
the
crisis
committee
of
TCMUN
’14.
Delegate
should
have
a
good
command
of
the
situation
in
Congo
in
1961,
i.e.
events
leading
up
to
and
just
following
Congo’s
independence
in
1960,
the
geography
of
the
region,
a
map
of
the
country
in
1961,
and
the
names
of
personalities
and
places
that
played
prominent
roles
in
the
unfolding
drama.
In
addition,
delegates
should
be
familiar
with
other
events
that
the
Security
Council
dealt
with
in
1961.
As
in
all
TCMUN
committees,
it
is
important
that
crisis
committee
delegates
be
familiar
with
the
rules
of
their
committee
and
“stay
in
character,”
representing
the
views
and
interests
of
their
assigned
countries
in
1961.
Since
the
specific
crises
that
the
committee
will
be
debating
will
not
be
announced
until
the
committee
has
begun
its
general
debate
about
the
Congo
situation
in
January
1961,
delegates
must
be
prepared
to
be
flexible
and
nimble
in
their
reactions.
Finally,
while
individual
action
orders
or
portfolio
requests
are
a
special
feature
of
crisis
committees,
delegates
should
give
priority
to
collaborating
with
their
colleagues
to
develop
strong
resolutions
and
directives,
which
have
the
potential
for
greater
long-‐term
impact.
In
addition
to
the
bibliographies
provided
in
the
two
documents
mentioned
just
above,
the
works
recommended
below
offer
insights
and
information
relevant
to
the
committee’s
work.
13
Boston
Invitational
Model
United
Nations
Conference,“BosMUN
XIII
Crisis
Committee
5
Recommended
Reading
• Adams,
Karen
Ruth
et
al.
“Security
Council:
Committee
History
and
Structure.”
Background
Guide
for
TCMUN.
September
1,
2014.
Available
at
http://interconnections21.edublogs.org/files/2013/09/TCMUN-‐SC-‐14-‐history-‐
structure1-‐copy-‐u1odo0.pdf.
• Boston
Invitational
Model
United
Nations
Conference,“BosMUN
XIII
Crisis
Committee
Briefing,“
2011.
Available
at:
http://bosmun.org/wp-‐
content/uploads/2013/05/BosMUN-‐XIII-‐Crisis-‐Committee-‐Briefing-‐PDF.pdf
• Boston
Invitational
Model
United
Nations
Conference.
“How
to
BarMUN:
A
Comprehensive
Guide.”
Available
at:
www.barmun.org/wp-‐
content/uploads/2011/06/BarMUN-‐Guide.docx.
• Cornell
MUN
Conference.
“
CMUNC
Guide
to
Crisis
Committees.”
Available
at
http://www.cmunc.net/Files/Crisis%20Guide.pdf.
• Devlin,
Lawrence.
Chief
of
Station,
Congo:
Fighting
the
Cold
War
in
a
Hot
Zone..
NY,
Public
Affairs,
2007.
Available
in
Kindle
edition.
• Kennedy,
Paul.
The
Parliament
of
Man:
the
Past,
Present
and
Future
of
the
United
Nations.
NY,
Random
House,
2006.
Available
in
paperback
(Penguin)
and
in
Kindle
(vintage)
editions.
• Romais,
Michael.
“Thomas
Jefferson
Model
United
Nations
Introductory
Packet:
The
Crisis
Committee.”
Available
at
http://activities.tjhsst.edu/mun/guides/ccintro.pdf
• “The
Charter
of
the
United
Nations.”
Available
online
at
http://www.un.org/en/documents/charter/.
• United
Nations.
“United
Nations
Security
Council.”
Available
at
http://www.un.org/en/sc/.
• Weissman,
Stephen
R.
“What
Really
Happened
in
Congo,”
Foreign
Affairs,
July/August
2014,
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/141523/stephen-‐r-‐
weissman/what-‐really-‐happened-‐in-‐congo.
6