Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article History: The partitioning coefficient is a physicochemical quantity which gives important information about the dis-
Received 16 December 2020 tribution and efficiency of bioactive compounds in various biological systems. The present work aims at
Revised 10 February 2021 detailed investigation of the partition process of drug naproxen between edible oils (olive, sunflower, ses-
Accepted 10 February 2021
ame) and water in the presence of two differently charged surfactants consisting of SDS (sodium dodecylsul-
Available online 13 February 2021
fate), DTAB (n-dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide) and non-ionic surfactant Brij 35 (polyethylene glycol
Keywords: dodecyl ether). The evaluation was done at atmospheric pressure and 25.0 °C by using UVVis spectrometric
Partition coefficient and shake-flask techniques. In this work, all the surfactants are used in a concentration below their CMC due
Naproxen to the turbidity that occurs in the biphasic oil-water systems in the concentrations above their CMC. The
Surfactant effect experimental results obtained indicate that the oil-water partition coefficient (Koil/w) of naproxen reduce
Edible oil-water system with rising the surfactants concentration in medium irrespective of the oil employed. Moreover, these values
Gibbs free energy of partitioning in the surfactant media are lower in comparison with surfactant free medium. The values of standard Gibbs
free energy of the transfer (DGBw ! oil ) calculated for all binary oil-water systems have negative sign which
indicates the preference of this drug for oil phase and thus spontaneous partitioning process. The surfactant
effect on the partition coefficients of drug is analyzed in terms of the intermolecular interactions such as
hydrogen bonding, dispersion and electrostatic forces between the drug and the surfactant.
© 2021 Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtice.2021.02.012
1876-1070/© 2021 Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
2 Y. Nachari and M. Jabbari / Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers 119 (2021) 15
Fig. 2. Calibration curves of NAP in (a) olive oil (b) sunflower oil (c) sesame oil phases and (d) aqueous phase at 25 °C and ionic strength of 150 mM NaCl.
Y. Nachari and M. Jabbari / Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers 119 (2021) 15 3
are 2229.2, 2840.0, 1706.9 and 5751.7 M 1 cm1 in olive, sunflower, Table 2
sesame oils and water phases, respectively. The partition coefficient and standard Gibbs free energy of partitioning values of
NAP in sunflower oil-water systems in the presence and absence of different surfac-
tants at 25 °C and ionic strength of 150 mM NaCl.
2.2.2. Oil-water partition coefficient assay
The partition coefficients of NAP between edible oils and water were log Koil/w DGBw ! oil (kJ mol1)
derived by modifying the method suggested by Freiría-Ga ndara et al. surfactant free 1.719 9.812
[5], which employs the shake-flask method to measure the partition
[surfactant] (mM) SDS Brij 35 DTAB SDS Brij 35 DTAB
coefficients in binary oil-water systems for a number of bioantioxidants.
The oil-water partition coefficient of the drug NAP is measured in vari- 0.10 1.020 0.864 0.531 5.821 4.933 3.031
0.08 1.145 1.091 0.809 6.536 6.227 4.616
ous concentrations of the surfactants SDS, DTAB and Brij 35 in range
0.06 1.211 1.151 0.852 6.911 6.568 4.862
0.020.1 mM in ionic strength of 150 mM NaCl. All surfactants in this 0.04 1.238 1.200 0.996 7.069 6.848 5.686
work are used in a concentration below their CMC due to the turbidity 0.02 1.269 1.237 1.104 7.246 7.062 6.301
that occurs in the concentrations above CMC in the biphasic oil-water
systems. The hydrophobic drug NAP is dissolved directly in turn in ses-
ame oil or olive and sunflower oils to obtain concentration of 3.3 mM or Table 3
The sesame oil-water partition coefficient and standard Gibbs free energy of parti-
4.9 mM respectively. A 1.0 mL of the solution is diluted by adding aque-
tioning values of NAP in the presence and absence of different surfactants at 25 °C
ous surfactants solutions (to reach to desired concentration of surfac- and ionic strength of 150 mM NaCl.
tant) and NaCl solution (to adjust ionic strength) to 10 mL for preparing
1:9 (oil:water, v/v) mixtures. After several minutes of stirring by means log Koil/w DGBw ! oil (kJ mol1)
of a high-speed rotor, the mixtures allowed stand for at least 48 h to surfactant free 1.534 8.758
reach equilibrium between the phases. After this time, the oil and aque-
[surfactant] (mM) SDS Brij 35 DTAB SDS Brij 35 DTAB
ous phases were separated by centrifugation to determine the NAP con-
centration in these two phases by using UVvis spectrophotometry via 0.10 1.405 1.378 1.004 8.023 7.868 5.729
0.08 1.467 1.461 1.119 8.376 8.343 6.389
previously obtained calibration curves. Each of the experiments is
0.06 1.504 1.480 1.239 8.587 8.451 7.074
repeated at least three times. 0.04 1.511 1.500 1.329 8.627 8.566 7.587
0.02 1.526 1.511 1.374 8.714 8.626 7.847
3. Results and discussion
3.1. Data of partition coefficients 3.2. Standard Gibbs free energy of partitioning
In biphasic oil-water system, NAP molecules distribute between Different factors that contribute to partition coefficients include
water and the oil phase. The oil-water partition coefficient (Koil/w) for hydrophobic and dispersion forces, the solute’s hydrogen bond
drug NAP is the ratio of the NAP concentration in oil phase to its con- acceptor (basicity), hydrogen bond donor (acidity), and polarizability
centration in aqueous phase after an equilibrium is reached. The Koil/ which shows the induction forces and orientation. Therefore, analyz-
w value in logarithmic form is calculated as [5,17]
ing the partitioning behavior of a solute in the nonpolar solvent/
water biphasic system is useful for estimating the needed energy of
log Koil=w ¼ log ½NAPoil =½NAPw ð1Þ nonpolar molecules that have hydrophobic contacts with water [18-
where [NAP]oil and [NAP]w represent equilibrium concentrations of 20]. One of the thermodynamic functions which describes this energy
the partitioned drug NAP in the oil phase and aqueous phase, respec- cost is the standard Gibbs free energy of transfer (DGBw ! oil ) of a solute
tively. These concentrations are assayed by the calibration curve from water medium (w) to an organic (oil) phase which both are in
obtained for the drug in each of phases. The values of oil-water partition an equilibrium. It also provides a quantitative measurement of the
coefficient of NAP in the surfactant media used at the temperature 25 °C relative hydrophobicity of the solute as well as the phases [21]. The
are reported in Tables 1, 2 and 3 respectively for binary olive-, sun- relationship between Gibbs free energy of transfer of a component
flower- and sesame-water systems. Unfortunately, to date, no data for from one phase to another and its partition coefficient at a constant
the partitioning of the drug NAP in edible oil-water systems in the pres- temperature can be predicted as follows [4]:
ence of surfactants have been reported in the literature for comparison. DGBw ! oil ¼ 2:303RT logKoil=w ð2Þ
According to the data shown in Tables 1, 2 and 3, by rising the
concentration of each surfactant the log Koil/w values of drug where T is the absolute temperature, R stands the constant of the gas-
decrease. Moreover, within the surfactant concentrations tested, the ses (8.3145 J K 1 mol1) and Koil/w represents the partition coeffi-
magnitude of NAP partition coefficient is in the order of SDS > Brij 35 cient. The DGBw ! oil values for all binary oil-water systems are
> DTAB. calculated and the results obtained are listed in Tables 1, 2 and 3.
According to these Tables, DGBw ! oil is negative in sign that indicates
the preference of this drug for oil phase and thus spontaneous trans-
Table 1 fer process. The highest DGBw ! oil values corresponded to the SDS sys-
The partition coefficient and standard Gibbs free energy of the partitioning values of
tem, confirming the transfer process of negatively-charged drug NAP
NAP in binary olive oil-water systems in the presence and absence of different sur-
factants at 25 °C and ionic strength of 150 mM NaCl.
from aqueous phase containing SDS surfactant to oil phase is energet-
ically more favorable, due to repulsive forces between the negatively-
log Koil/w DGBw ! oil (kJ mol1) charged head groups of SDS and the drug. While the lower values
surfactant free 1.729 9.870 DGBw ! oil are observed for Brij 35 and DTAB surfactant systems,
respectively.
[surfactant] (mM) SDS Brij 35 DTAB SDS Brij 35 DTAB
Fig. 3. Influence of the surfactant concentration on the partition coefficient of NAP in biphasic (a) olive oil- (b) sunflower oil- (c) sesame oil-water systems at 25 °C and ionic
strength of 150 mM NaCl; the lines are drawn to guide the eye.
NAP partition coefficients in all surfactant solutions. The surfactants solutions at the identical concentration of the surfactants. Moreover,
can potentially transfer from aqueous phase to the oil phase and irrespective of the edible oil type, the drugs` partition coefficients in
even locate themselves at the oil-water interface [17]. This can the surfactant media are lower than those in the surfactant free
explain the highly non-linear behaviors in Fig. 3 especially those of medium. These results all reflect the surfactant-dependent property
the neutral surfactant. Moreover, an increase in the surfactant con- of the NAP partitioning.
centration at high concentration will not have a strong effect in The drug NAP is a compound with low solubility in water (25 mg
reducing partition coefficient of the drug due to surfactant transfer- L 1 at room temperature [3]). In addition, this drug has been known
ring in the oil phase. as a weak acidic drug (pKa=4.40 [22]), thus in the neutral aqueous
According to Tables 1-3, among the surfactants tested, NAP parti- medium (pH ~ 6.8), its carboxylic OH group can dissociate and form a
tion coefficient is the highest in SDS solutions and the lowest in DTAB mixture of neutral and anionic species of the drug. Therefore, there
Fig. 4. A schematic diagram of possible interactions and orientation of the drug NAP in the presence of anionic SDS, cationic DTAB and non-ionic Brij 35 surfactants.
Y. Nachari and M. Jabbari / Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers 119 (2021) 15 5
are probably interactions between the ionized drug NAP with surfac- Acknowledgments
tant systems which may be of type hydrogen bonding, hydrophobic
and electrostatic forces [23-25]. On the other hand, according to the The authors appreciate Damavand Darou Pharmaceutical Chemi-
literature reports, the dissociation constant (Ka) of a weak acid in the cals Co. (Damghan, Iran) for providing the drug naproxen, and also
oil solutions is typically 56 times smaller than those in the aqueous the Research Council of Damghan University for facilitating the
solution [26]. Thus, we ignore the ionization of weak acids in the oil equipment and laboratory facilities.
phase and represent the possible orientations between the drug NAP
and surfactant system in aqueous phase schematically in Fig. 4. In
aqueous phase, the surfactant molecules stay close to surface due to
having non-polar hydrocarbon chain. The possible orientation and References
interactions of NAP molecule in aqueous phase in the presence of sur-
factants SDS, DTAB and Brij 35 is such that its negatively-charged car- [1] Mohammadzade M, Barzegar-Jalali M, Jouyban A. Solubility of naproxen in 2-
boxylic group binds to the outer section (hydrophilic) of surfactants propanol + water mixtures at various temperatures. J Mol Liq 2015;206:110–3.
surface by electrostatic or hydrogen-bonding interactions, while the [2] Mora CP, Martínez F. Thermodynamic study of partitioning and solvation of
(+)-naproxen in some organic solvent/buffer and liposome systems. J Chem Eng
non-polar part of drug drawn into the inner layer (hydrophobic) with Data 2007;52:1933–40.
the aid of the hydrophobic interactions. [3] Bhat PA, Rather GM, Dar AA. Effect of surfactant mixing on partitioning of model
As described before, comparison between cationic, anionic and hydrophobic drug, naproxen, between aqueous and micellar phases. J Phys Chem
B 2009;113:997–1006.
non-ionic surfactant media shows that the log Koil/w values of NAP [4] Lozano HR, Martínez F. Thermodynamics of partitioning and solvation of ketopro-
has the order SDS > Brij 35 > DTAB in binary edible oil-water sys- fen in some organic solvent/buffer and liposome systems. Braz J Pharm Sci
tems. The drug NAP interacts attractively with the surface of surfac- 2006;42:601–13.
[5] Freiria-Gandara J, Losada-Barreiro S, Paiva-Martins F, Bravo-Diaz C. Differential
tant DTAB via negatively-charged carboxylic group present in its partitioning of bioantioxidants in edible oilwater and octanolwater systems:
structure, while in the presence of SDS, electrostatic repulsions exist linear free energy relationships. J Chem Eng Data 2018;63:2999–3007.
between negatively-charged head groups of SDS and the carboxylic [6] Congliang Z, Yan W, Fuan W. Determination and temperature dependence of n-
octanol/water partition coefficients for seven sulfonamides from (298.15 to
group of NAP. This transfers more NAP from oil to aqueous phase in 333.15) K. Bull Korean Chem Soc 2007;28:1183–6.
the presence of DTAB and therefore the concentration of drug in [7] Sangster J. Octanol-water partition coefficients, fundamentals and physcial chem-
aqueous phase increases. The partition coefficients in DTAB medium istry. J. Wiley Sons: Chichester 1997.
[8] Chamberlin AC, Levitt DG, Cramer CJ, Truhlar DG. Modeling free energies of solva-
are lower than those in Brij 35 system because of stronger electro-
tion in olive oil. Mol Pharm 2008;5:1064–79.
static interactions between NAP and DTAB in aqueous phase. Accord- [9] Bao Q-Y, Liua A-Y, Maa Y, Chenc H, Honga J, Shenb W-B, Zhang C, Ding Y. The
ingly, our data reveals that at higher DTAB content, the partition effect of oil-water partition coefficient on the distribution and cellular uptake of
coefficients decrease gradually, which can be attributed to stronger liposome-encapsulated gold nanoparticles. Colloids Surf B 2016;146:475–81.
[10] Vinarov Z, Katev V, Radeva D, Tcholakova S, Denkov ND. Micellar solubilization of
electrostatic interactions. poorly water-soluble drugs: effect of surfactant and solubilizate molecular struc-
Moreover, the order of increasing log Koil/w values in binary oil/ ture. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2018;44:677–86.
water media are as follows: olive oil/water > sesame oil/water > sun- [11] Kohantorabi M, Salari H, Fakhraee M, Gholami MR. Surfactant binary systems: ab
initio calculations, preferential solvation, and investigation of solvatochromic
flower oil/water. This is probably due to difference in the solubility of parameters. J Chem Eng Data 2016;61:255–63.
NAP in the edible oils used. Based on the results obtained, among the [12] Attwood D, Florence AT. FASTtrack: physical pharmacy. 2nd ed. London: Pharma-
edible oils under study, the drug NAP has the most solubility in olive ceutical Press; 2012.
[13] Liu J, Lu GW, Sandoval M, Ciringh Y, Xue G, Jaeger D, Kompanik K, Jiao J, Gelotte
oil and the lowest solubility in sunflower oil. KM. Determination of benzalkonium chloride partition in micelle solutions using
ultrafiltration method. AAPS Pharm Sci Tech 2009;10:1216–23.
Conclusions [14] Mehling T, Kloss L, Ingram T, Smirnova I. Partition coefficients of ionizable solutes
in mixed nonionic/ionic micellar systems. Langmuir 2013;29:1035–44.
[15] Zhang H, Annunziata O. Modulation of drug transport properties by multicompo-
Poor aqueous solubility and lipophilicity of drugs/bioactives limit nent diffusion in surfactant aqueous solutions. Langmuir 2008;24:10680–7.
their application in drug formulation and delivery development. In [16] Zhang H, Annunziata O. Diffusion of an ionic drug in micellar aqueous solutions.
Langmuir 2009;25:3425–34.
this study, the lipophilicity of the minimally soluble drug compound ndez-Rodríguez EA, Losada-Barreiro S, Bravo-Díaz C. Enhancing the frac-
[17] Raimu
naproxen in terms of partition coefficients has been determined in tion of antioxidants at the interfaces of oil-in-water emulsions: a kinetic and ther-
binary edible oil-water systems in the presence of anionic (SDS), cat- modynamic analysis of their partitioning. J Colloid Interface Sci 2019;555:224–33.
ionic (DTAB) and non-ionic (Brij 35) surfactants. The findings [18] Schwarzenbach RP, Gschwend PM, Imboden DM. Organic liquid-water partition-
ing. Environmental organic chemistry. 2nd editor J. Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 2003.
obtained in the amphiphilic systems reveal that the log Koil/w values [19] Leo AJ. Octanol/water partition coefficients. Encyclopedia of computational chem-
of drug in the surfactant media are lower in comparison with surfac- istry. Ltd: John Wiley & Sons; 2002.
tant free medium, irrespective of the edible oil type. Moreover, the [20] Molyneux P. Octanol/water partition coefficients Kow: a critical examination of
the value of the methylene group contribution to log Kow for homologous series
anionic SDS surfactant shows the highest log Koil/w value for NAP as a of organic compounds. Fluid Phase Equilib 2014;368:120–41.
result of electrostatic repulsions between the drug and the negative [21] Leo A, Hansch C, Elkins D. Partition coefficients and their uses. Chem Rev
charge of surfactant head group, whereas the cationic DTAB and non- 1971;71:525–616.
[22] Babic S, Horvat AJM, Pavlovic DM, Kastelan-Macan M. Determination of pKa val-
ionic Brij 35 surfactant provided lower log Koil/w values, respectively. ues of active pharmaceutical ingredients. Trends Anal Chem 2007;26:1043–61.
The findings of present study indicate that NAP partition coefficient [23] Jabbari M, Teymoori F. An insight into effect of micelle-forming surfactants on
is function of a series factors such as surfactant type, surfactant con- aqueous solubilization and octanol/water partition coefficient of the drugs gemfi-
brozil and ibuprofen. J Mol Liq 2018;262:1–7.
centration, and vegetable oil type used.
[24] Jabbari M, Jabbari A. Antioxidant potential and DPPH radical scavenging kinetics
of water-insoluble flavonoid naringenin in aqueous solution of micelles. Colloids
Declaration of Competing Interest Surf. A 2016;489:392–9.
[25] Jabbari M, Jabbari A. DPPH radical-scavenging activity and kinetics of antioxidant
agent hesperidin in pure aqueous micellar solutions. Bull Chem Soc Jpn
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial 2016;89:869–75.
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influ- [26] Dean JA. Lange s handbook of chemistry. New York: McGraw-Hill, Inc.; 1992.
ence the work reported in this paper.