Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alejandro Christie
Cranfield University, Cranfield, Bedfordshire MK43 0AL, United Kingdom, a.d.christie@cranfield.ac.uk
Abstract
Internal air systems [also referred to as secondary air systems - SAS] are an essential part of modern gas turbines. These
systems are a subset of a larger group of engine air systems. SAS functions are restricted to the provision of cooling flows,
sealing of bearing chambers/flow paths and control of bearing axial loads. These systems are integral to engine performance
and also heavily impact upon it as up to 25% of core mass flow may be utilized. It is therefore essential that gas turbine
engineers have an understanding of how these systems operate. The objectives of this paper are to review the working
principles, extraction/delivery methods, configurations and general parameters affecting system performance and sizing. Each
function is initially discussed in isolation. The JT8D engine is then used to illustrate how airflows are integrated to fulfil
multiple functions simultaneously. A brief discussion is given as to how SAS seals impact upon performance during speed
transients. Concepts such as preswirl, deswirl and hot gas ingestion are reviewed. Consideration is also given to penalties
associated with the use of SAS.
Keywords: internal air system, secondary air system, bleed flow, turbine cooling
1. Introduction
1.1. Overview
1
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
This has resulted in engines which have allowed for minimize frictional losses so that airflows maintain a
extended aircraft flight range and payload capacity. reasonable static pressure at the point of egress into the
Blade cooling has been the principle factor which has led main flow path.
to this achievement [4]. Blade cooling technology is a Bleeds are taken from the earliest possible extraction
principal component of internal air systems. point in order to minimize performance losses [10].
Figure 1 gives a concise overview of the However, the pressure drop across the channel must be
development of Blade Cooling technology. Rolls-Royce sufficient to facilitate the required mass flow, after taking
embarked upon work in this area as early as 1947. The into account frictional losses [11].
1950's saw the first engine runs utilizing cooled blades Convection is the dominant heat transfer mechanism
and these systems were finally put into service in the employed in the cooling air system. Heat energy is
early 1960's. Improvements in cooling technologies have removed as air moves along turbine disc surfaces.
since been largely geared towards increasing turbine At the blade, various cooling methods or
entry temperatures whilst reducing the percentage of core combinations thereof are employed. These methods
air required for cooling [5]. include jet impingement, film cooling and use of
multipass channels. Complex internal geometries are also
2. Cooling System utilized to enhance heat transfer by restarting boundary
layers, increasing internal surface areas and enhancing
2.1. Overview turbulent mixing. Finally, air is ejected into the main gas
path through orifices in the blade and platform [Refer to
The key function of the cooling system is to limit Figure 3].
component temperatures by cooling or heating them.
Over the last thirty years, TET's have doubled to
temperatures of around 1800°C, whilst HPT component
life has either remained the same or otherwise increased
[6]. This technology allows turbine blades, discs and
NGV's to operate within temperature envelopes above
that of the incipient melting point of the materials from
which they are made.
Cooling air is bled from the compressor and directed
into turbine blades via cavities or piping. Air is then
routed through channels within the blades/NGV's to
facilitate heat transfer. The blade metal temperature is
correspondingly kept within safe limits and finally the air
is ejected back into the main gas path. Blades are thus
able to operate at high turbine entry temperatures with an
acceptable creep life [7].
Temperature affects turbine discs in three principal
ways; diminished load bearing capacity at high Figure 2: Deswirler tubes in the HPC IAE V2500 two
temperature, stress arising due to thermal expansion and shaft engine [2]
stress arising due to thermal gradients [8]. Whilst air
cools the rim of the disc to mitigate against temperature As air is bled through internal compressor cavities, it
and expansion effects, it is used to heat the bore in order is subjected to increased whirl. Increased whirl velocity
to reduce the thermal gradient [6] and resulting decreases the static pressure. One way of recovering this
component stresses. pressure is to use de-swirler tubes as shown in Figure 2.
This allows for controlled radial inflow of cooling air
2.2. Governing Principles from the compressor.
The whirl velocity of the air is forced to the speed of
The interrelated parameters of static temperature, the tubes and thus the disc. As the air moves toward the
static pressure and whirl velocity govern the supply and inner radius, the whirl component is reduced. Thus the
effectiveness of the SAS for component cooling. Static static pressure is maintained. This relationship is further
temperature and pressure are used as they represent the expressed by equation (1) which assumes a negligible
actual conditions which the components experience. The change in density at a constant total pressure.
1
whirl velocity refers to the tangential velocity component 𝑝∝ ... (1)
𝑉2
of the air as it passes through the engine. Conversely, on the turbine side of the engine, a
Airflow through SAS cavities is as a result of the penalty on static pressure may be considered acceptable
pressure drop across the compressor and turbine. A pre- when a corresponding reduction in static temperature is
defined mass flow is requisite to fulfil cooling achievable. This is seen as an acceptable trade-off as the
requirements and is a function of the pressure drop, creep life of a high temperature component is highly
pressure loss [9] and orifice geometry. Designers aim to
2
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
sensitive to minute changes in temperature [of the order void [13]. This HGI diminishes the service life of
of a 2X reduction in creep life for a temperature increase rotating components such as discs and seals [14]. Sealing
of roughly 15K]. To this end pre-swirl nozzles are used. of flow paths is therefore necessary to prevent ingress
Pre-swirl devices are used primarily on the 1st stage into rotor drum cavities. "Platforms of rotor blades and
HP rotor, where SAS demands are met by air which has inner bands of nozzle guide vanes are designed to form a
been bled directly from the diffuser. Since this air has no radial or axial clearance seal at rim portion of the
swirl component, work is done by the 1st stage HP rotor cavities" [14]. The SAS also cools the disc hence seals
disc to increase its velocity to that of the disc. are fitted close to the rim of the disc to minimize the
Correspondingly, its temperature is increased as it is cooling air requirement [15]. The optimum amount of air
pumped out radially into the root of the blade. Total must be determined as too much cooling air can have a
temperature increases along with both the static and detrimental effect on turbine efficiency whereas too little
dynamic temperature. will be insufficient to prevent HGI [12].
3
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
Figure 7: Pratt and Whitney PT6 Compressor Rear Bearing Sump Arrangement [16]
Figure 4 shows a typical rim sealing arrangement. dominant means of flow control [17]. To this end,
However, even with a sealing system, local pressure labyrinth seals are extensively used. Figure 8 illustrates
differences can cause localized HGI as depicted in Figure the basic design and function of a two toothed labyrinth
5. Hence, "the designer of internal air systems wants to seal. D. Eser and J.Y. Kazakia [18] highlight the
know the following: the most effective seal geometry; parameters which govern metering of the flow across
how much sealing air is required to prevent ingress; these types of seals. Other types of seals employed in
when ingress occurs, how much hot gas enters the wheel- SAS include brush seals, carbon seals, fluid and
space; and how does this hot gas affect the temperatures abradable lined seals, hydraulic seals, ring type oil seals,
on the rotating and stationary components" [12]. thread type labyrinth oil seals and continuous groove
Figure 6 shows a typical arrangement utilized in flow labyrinth air seal [1].
path sealing. The flowrate is metered using interstage
seals. Continuous groove interstage labyrinth air seals 4. Sealing of Bearing Chambers
and honeycomb seals are generally used in this type of
application. Empirical correlations and CFD are 4.1. Overview
extensively used to develop seal geometries which give
the required flow rate. Bearing chamber oil leakage may lead to excessive
loss of oil, engine fire, cabin odour or smoke [2]. To
3.1. Seals prevent this from occurring, pressurized air is bled from
the compressor and directed into cavities surrounding the
While it is not the intention of this paper to hold an in- sumps [bearing chambers]. "The sumps are encased in
depth discourse on gas turbine seals, a brief overview is protective air jackets that prevent excessive heat fluxes
useful. SAS flow control is indispensably linked to the from reaching the oil wetted walls, thereby preventing
efficiency of the engine core and seals provide the coking and thermal deterioration of the oil" [19]. SAS air
4
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
maintains a specified differential pressure across bearing compartment via the scavenge oil system rather
labyrinth seal faces such that air is leaked into the than through a center vent tube [16].
bearing chamber thus preventing the escape of lube oil.
Finally, the air is vented [16].
5
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
Figure 14: Industrial Turbine Thrust Balance [24] Figure 16: Rolls Royce AE3007 cooling circuit [2]
6
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
Figure 17: Pratt and Whitney JT8D turbofan engine layout (front end) [19]
Figure 18: Pratt and Whitney JT8D turbofan engine layout (back end) [19]
7
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
5.2. Delivery Methods no.3 bearing. This air provides a sealing flow to the rear
seal of this bearing. Airflow is also routed to the front face
Compressor air is generally extracted through orifices or of the seventh stage disc. In this way, ninth stage discharge
labyrinth seals to internal cavities. Alternatively, air can be pressure is maintained on the seventh stage seal diameter
extracted to external manifolds and routed for re-entry to thus achieving a partial thrust balance. Hence it is seen that
the engine. this bleed performs bearing sealing as well as partial thrust
Figure 15 illustrates two ways which have been utilized balance.
for air extraction to external cavities. It is seen that hollow Thirteenth stage air is bled through a multi-edged seal.
vanes are employed to channel air from the inner diameter Initially, this flow occupies a cavity formed between the
to an external manifold. Alternatively, round holes have compressor hub and diffuser inner duct [refer to Figure 18].
been used along the outer annulus wall at a later stage. Due It then moves through a cavity created by the combustor
to the variation in pressure, each flow is channelled through inner case and the turbine shaft heat shield. This air is used
separate manifolds. to provide pressure to the rear of the no.5 bearing. It also
Figure 16 serves to illustrate the intricacy of modern supplies a cooling flow to the front and rear faces of the HP
internal air systems at the turbine end of the machine. It is turbine disc. Air is ejected through the blade to provide
characteristic for first stage NGV's to utilize combustor cooling whist also being ejected through the rear interstage
liner cooling flows. Cooling flows are delivered to turbine seal to prevent HGI. As such, it is seen that this flow
blades solely through internal cavities whereas NGV's can carries out both bearing chamber sealing as well as turbine
be fed through either internal or external flows. blade and disc cooling.
Internal air systems are highly integrated. Bleed flows Engine design is a highly iterative process. First order
from a single extraction point may be used to fulfil single calculations rely upon assumptions about the SAS. Higher
or multiple SAS functions. The two spool Pratt and accuracy assumptions result in less iterations to achieve a
Whitney JT8D engine exemplifies this concept. final design. Assumptions must therefore be based upon
Air is bled from the sixth stage [last stage] of the LP actual values utilized in similar engines. However, in the
compressor [refer to Figure 17]. This air is extracted absence of this data, Walsh and Fletcher [11] have
through a gap between the bearing support and rear of the provided typical magnitudes for first order calculations.
sixth stage disc. This bleed is utilized to maintain pressure Percentages stated in this section are relative to the inlet
at the seal of the no.1 bearing and at the front face of the core mass flow.
no.2 bearing chambers [refer to Figure 19]. A portion of the
air is directed through the LPC driveshaft. As seen in Cooling Requirements and Rim Sealing:
Figure 18, this air is circulated around the turbine disc 0.5% per disc face for HPT.
before passing out to the main flow through the rear hub. 0.25% per disc face per LPT and free power turbine.
Thus this bleed performs bearing chamber sealing as well This figure may increase to 0.5% if a low technology
as disc cooling. rim is used.
Ninth stage air enters the inner cavity of the HP
compressor through holes in the interstage spacer. Holes in Bearing Chamber Sealing:
the front hub of the rotor permits the passage of air to the 0.02 kgs-1 per bearing chamber.
8
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
8. Penalties Associated with the SAS During acceleration transients, seal boundary conditions
change due to increased flow area. This results in a loss of
available turbine work due to drop in turbine mass flow.
Enthalpy of the flow is reduced due to mixing with the
cooling flow. Work is lost to facilitate pumping additional
cooling air radially [27].
8.4. Degradation
Whilst performance benefits have been derived from This paper provided a broad literary review of SAS
employing cooling systems, performance penalties have functions pertaining to component air cooling flows,
been simultaneously incurred. sealing of bearing chambers and flow paths as well as
At a given TET, an uncooled blade will render a higher control of bearing axial loads. Operational principles were
thrust than a cooled blade. Thus, as the percentage of discussed along with transient performance, delivery
cooling air increases for a given TET, the thrust output methods and penalties. The JT8D engine was used to
correspondingly decreases. This is implicit in Figure 20. It exemplify the multifunctional use of bleed flows. First
is therefore essential for designers to use the least possible order values for flow requirements was addressed at a
percentage of core mass flow to meet cooling demands. cursory level.
Deswirlers add additional weight, cost and disc features
[2]. Preswirl nozzles reduce static pressure at egress points Acknowledgements
to the main gas path hence reducing mass flow. However,
this must weighed against the benefit of the lower entry I would like to thank Sharad Kapil for his time spent in
temperature cooling flow. helping me to conceptualize this highly intricate engine
system.
8.2. Generic Penalties
References
Losses arise from complex fluid dynamic interactions
within internal passages. One such loss is the excess shaft [1] ROYCE-ROLLS. (1996) The Jet Engine. 5th Edition.
power required to drive the disc in order to overcome ed. Derby: Rolls-Royce plc.
frictional drag. This drag arises from shear stresses [2] ROLLS-ROYCE. (2005) The Jet Engine. 6th Edition.
between the disc and internal airflow which it is rotating ed. Derby: Rolls-Royce plc.
[25]. This power loss is referred to as windage and is [3] HALLS, G. A. (1967) Air Cooling of Turbine Blades
sometimes accounted for as a decrease in the overall and Vanes: An account of the history and development
compressor efficiency [11]. of gas turbine cooling. Aircraft Engineering and
Other losses include leakage, increased manufacturing Aerospace Technology, 39(8), p. 4-14.
cost and additional compressor work required to generate
[4] RUBINI, P. A. (2012) Turbine Blade Cooling Lecture
bleed flows [4].
Notes. Cranfield: Cranfield Press.
"Direct performance gains arise from more effective use
of the air consumed by the secondary system – thereby [5] MEETHAM, G. W. (1988) High Temprature Materials
reducing parasitic losses. Indirect performance gains also
9
38th Engine Systems Symposium – March 2013 ESS-38-47
A. Christie / Gas Turbine Internal Air Systems
in Gas Turbine Engines. Materials & Design, 9(4), p. Commercial Turbofan Engines: An Introduction to
213-219. Systems Functions. Berlin: Springer.
[6] BALLAND, M.; COULON, S.; MONCHOIS, F. (2003) [22] PILIDIS, P.; PALMER, J. R. (2012) Gas Turbine
Use of NS3D Code in the Design of HPT Blade Cooling Theory and Performance. Cranfield: Cranfield
Air Supply Systems. SNECMA. MOISSY- University Press.
CRAMAYEL. (ADA419459). [23] BHADESHIA, H. K. D. H. (2012) Steels for bearings.
[7] CARTER, T. J. (2005) Common failures in gas turbine Progress in Materials Science, 57(2), p. 268-435.
blades. Engineering Failure Analysis, 12(2) , p. 237- [24] ROFKA, S. et al. (2008) GAS TURBINE WITH AXIAL
247. ISSN 1350-6307. THRUST BALANCE. US8092150.
[8] COOKSON, R. A.; HASLAM, A. S. (2011) [25] CHILDS, P. R. N. (2011) Rotating Flow. Oxford:
Mechancial Design of Turbomachinery. Cranfield: Butterworth-Heinemann.
Cranfield University Press.
[26] C. YOUNG, P. D. S. (2006) RECENT ADVANCES IN
[9] CARCASCI, C.; FACCHINI, B. (1996) A numerical THE SIMULATION OF GAS TURBINE SECONDARY
procedure to design internal cooling of gas turbine AIR SYSTEMS. 25th Congress of International Council
stator blades. Revue Générale de Thermique, 35(412), of the Aeronautical Sciences. Hamburg, Germany.
p. 257-268, ISSN 0035-3159. (ICAS 2006-5.4.4).
[10] BIRD, V. J. [Rolls Royce Plc]. (2003) Gas turbine [27] NIELSEN, A. E.; MOLL, C. W.; STAUDACHER, S.
internal air system. EP1013882B1. (2004) Modeling and Validation of the Thermal Effects
[11] WALSH, P. P. . F. P. (2004) Gas Turbine Performance. on Gas Turbine Transients. ASME Conf. Proc.
2nd Edition. ed. Oxford: Blackwell Science. (GT2004-53344).
[12] OWEN, J. M. Theoretical modelling of hot gas [28] MEHER-HOMJI, C. B.; CHAKER, M.;
ingestion through turbine rim seals. (2012) Propulsion MOTIWALLA, H. (2001) Gas turbine performance
and Power Research, 1(1), p. 1-11, ISSN 2212-540X. deterioration. Proceedings of the 30th Turbomachinery
[13] SOARES, C. (2008) Gas Turbines. Burlington: Symposium. p. 17-20.
Butterworth-Heinemann. [29] KURZ, R.; BRUN, K. DEGRADATION IN GAS
[14] TERAMACHI, K. et al. (2002) Effect of Geometry and TURBINE SYSTEMS. (2001) ASME Journal of
Fin Overlap on Sealing Performance of Rim Seals. 38th engineering for gas turbines and power, 123, p. 70-77.
AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference
& Exhibit. Indianapolis, Indiana: AIAA.
[15] OWEN, J. M.; PHADKE, U. P. (1988) Aerodynamic
aspects of the sealing of gas-turbine rotor-stator
systems: Part 1: The behavior of simple shrouded
rotating-disk systems in a quiescent environment.
International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 9(2) p.
98-105, ISSN 0142-727X.
[16] OTIS, C. E.; VOSBURY, P. A. (2010) Aircraft Gas
Turbine Powerplants. Frankfurt: Jeppesen & Co.
Gmbh.
[17] STEINETZ, B. M.; HENDRIX, R. C.; MUNSON,
J.(1998) Advanced seal technology role in meeting next
generation turbine engine goals. National Aeronautics
and Space Administration. Lewis Research Center.
(NASA/TM/1998/206961).
[18] ESER, D.; KAZAKIA, J. Y. (1995) Air flow in cavities
of labyrinth seals. International Journal of Engineering
Science, 33(15), p. 2309-2326, ISSN 0020-7225.
[19] TREAGER, I. E. (2001) Aircraft Gas Turbine Engine
Technology. 3rd Edition. ed. [S.l.]: McGraw-Hill.
[20] COLLINS, D. (2007) The Effects of Wear on Abradable
Honeycomb Labyrinth Seals [Thesis]. Cranfield:
Cranfield University Press.
[21] LINKE-DIESINGER, A. (2008) Systems of
10