Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TO ADDRESS
PAKISTAN’S IMMINENT
SOCIO-ECONOMIC CHALLENGES
Exports
Enterprise(s) &
Employment
Equity
Education-Health E-Pakistan &
Population Empowerment
Empowering Youth,
Women & Others
Energy
Affordable Environment
& Efficient Water & Food
Security
FOREWORD
When present government came into office on 11th April, 2022, it found that Pakistan currently faces several
socioeconomic challenges that required a holistic and coordinated effort for effective resolution. A Turn
Around Pakistan Summit was held on 28th June, 2022, in which more than 1,000 senior leaders from busi-
ness, academia, government and overseas pakistanis participated. After extensive consultations with public
and private stakeholders. During the Turnaround Conference 2022, the Ministry of Planning, Development
and Special Initiatives, under the leadership of Minister Ahsan Iqbal, came up with a 5Es framework to combat
Pakistan’s socioeconomic issues in the short and medium term and provide a strong and stable platform for
achieving long term goals of Vision 2035 and Vision 2047.
The Framework encompasses initiatives and multiple pronged strategies for addressing the overall challeng-
es to Pakistan’s socio-economic spectrum within short to medium timeframe.
Under this framework, key initiatives will be along the lines of the following 5 Es of development: Exports,
Equity, E-Pakistan, Environment, Energy and Equity. The rationale behind each component of the framework is
given below.
1. Exports: Increasing exports will provide Pakistan economic stability and much-needed resources to
execute development projects. Therefore, the first E addresses the issue of exports promotion with different
initiatives in various sectors like; Manufacturing, Mineral, Investment, Commerce and SMEs by building
competitive enterprises and generation employment.
2. E-Pakistan and Empowering Youth and Woman: Inclusive development empowering our populations’
high potential yet marginalized groups such as women and youth will unlock Pakistan’s true potential for
growth and prosperity. Ministry of Planning, Development and Special Initiatives’s initiatives like the
Ba-Ikhtiar Naujawan Internships for graduates will help 60,000 youths gain employment and get one step
closer to playing their much-needed role in Pakistan’s long-term prosperity.
3. Environment: In the wake of modern climate change afflicted world, climate readiness is essential for the
survival of Pakistan, which is among top ten most vulnerable countries in the world. Thus, the framework
focuses on providing institutional, legal and policy objectives for minimizing the impacts of climate
change on Pakistanis’ lives and livelihoods through 4RF strategies and by addressing key areas like water
and food securities.
4. Energy and Infrastructure: Availability of efficient energy and supporting infrastructure is a prerequisite
for modern economic and social development. Under the 5Es framework, increasing Pakistan’s efficient
and green energy production and building infrastructure for affordable energy will be a key priority area.
5. Equity: Equitable access to services such as health and education, and economic opportunities will yield
a just and harmonious society. Hence, the framework puts special emphasis on providing equitable
access to marginalized groups via affirmative action as and where necessary. In particular, efforts are
being made for the socioeconomic uplift of the 20 poorest districts across the country which are in dire
need of such assistance.
This comprehensive, all-encompassing framework will act as the North Star for Pakistan’s socioeconomic
development, leading Pakistan in the direction of long-term prosperity.
MESSAGE BY
THE PRIME MINISTER
Equity
Education-Health E-Pakistan &
Population Empowerment
Empowering Youth,
Women & Others
Energy
Affordable Environment
& Efficient Water & Food
Security
INTRODUCTION
BACKGROUND 07
EXPORTS
ENTERPRISE(s) AND EMPLOYMENT 10
CONTENTS
THE 7 PILLARS
The Conference encompassed seven diverse pillars which are the key drivers and
enablers of growth as envisaged in Vision 2025 under which 35 Sub-Thematic
Working Groups were defined which covered areas like; development of human
and social capital; achieving sustainable and inclusive growth; focused institu-
tional reforms and improving governance; improving national food security etc.
The thematic groups were categorized into 7 pillars, each pillar focusing on sev-
eral key development areas.
Achieving Sustainable, Indigenous and Inclusive Growth: This thematic group focused on
export led growth, resource mobilization, blue economy, maritime sector development, urban devel-
opment, arts and culture, and sports.
Energy, Water and Food Security: This pillar deliberated on key sectors of economy which include
power sector, oil & gas, water resource management, agriculture productivity, competitiveness
enhancement, milk and meat productivity enhancement, and tackling malnutrition and stunting.
Institutional Reform and Democratic Governance: The thematic groups under this pillar high-
lighted challenges being faced by Pakistan in the areas of Civil Service Reforms, Police & Criminal
Justice System Reforms and State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs).
Putting People First: Developing human and social capital, and various other important aspects
of human resource development were discussed and deliberated upon such as health, education,
population, manpower development, gender, social protections and national cohesion.
Private Sector-Led Growth: Thematic groups under this mainly discussed areas such as creation
of business-friendly environment, digital economy/IT, exports, start-ups, role of science technology
and innovations, small and medium enterprises, cluster-based development & value chain gap
improvements to enhance export led growth for investment & growth.
Improving National Competitiveness: This pillar conducted in depth discussion of possible
measures to be taken for improving competitiveness through enhanced productivity, innovation, and
quality, augmenting exports & made in Pakistan by developing global brands and reforming higher
education in the country.
8
Modernization of Transportation Infrastructure and Greater Regional Connectivity: The
thematic groups under this pillar deliberated on regional connectivity via rail, road, CPEC and
telecommunication.
The Conference offered an opportunity to provide a short to medium-term framework to support the
country in formulating a coordinated set of policies to deal with its immediate economic crises and
enable the economy to work at its full potential by untapping the hidden resources so that to ensure
a better living for the people of Pakistan. Based on recommendations given by these thematic working
groups, a framework for addressing Pakistan’s socio-economic challenges has been prepared which
focuses on the key 5-E areas, namely Exports, Empowerment and E-Pakistan, Equity, Environment &
Climate Change, and Energy & Infrastructure. The document ahead will expand on the government’s
vision for development in these key socioeconomic areas.
VISION 2025
(7+5 Framework)
ke
9
EXPORTS
Enterprise(s) and Employment
INTRODUCTION
Pakistan’s previous approach to maintaining current account balance via import substitution has led
to repeated cycles of crashes. To keep the economy growing on a stable path, the country needs to
move towards an export-led turnaround leading to economic growth, like the East Asian Tigers. To
achieve this goal, the government has launched several initiatives along the following objectives –
increasing productivity, product and market diversification and brand development, SME development
and nurturing local endowments, and fostering an enabling business environment.
SITUATION ANALYSIS
Pakistan has historically followed import-based, consumption led economic growth with the result
that its reserves have always found it hard to shore up foreign currency liquidity to pay for imports.
Consequently, Pakistan has had to take on foreign currency, budgetary support loans and deposits to
finance its foreign currency needs. While this approach, over the past few decades or so, has man-
aged to keep the country afloat, foreign loans and deposits themselves have a repayment burden to
address, which exacerbates the predicament upon the commencement of loan debt servicing and
repayment. Exports, Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) and remittances are three key avenues which
cradle the solution to the country’s economic woes, with exports a standout amongst these which can
help address concerns. Pakistan’s turnaround efforts and subsequently growth model must be reori-
ented while ensuring imports are directed toward more productive avenues. Imports of industrial raw
materials and intermediate goods ought to feed into production for export. Locally produced agricul-
tural products can specifically save precious foreign exchange and help earn export revenues. This
overarching policy direction can lead toward export-led growth in order to tackle the chronic
boom-and-bust cycles, provide a stable macro-economic environment which will, in turn, cultivate an
environment amenable for FDI.
11
In the case of Pakistan, absolute exports have been largely range bound in the last 10 years, even
decreased in some years. As depicted in the comparative table below, Pakistan’s absolute exports
have remained largely stagnant in comparison to some of its regional peers, many of whom have
shown growth over the period.
400
300
200
100
-
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
31.8
74.5
1990 2021
68.8
25.3
25.1
24.5
23.7
23.2
22.9
21.4
20.8
20.4
36.0
27.3
21.6
21.4
14.8
10.7
9.1
7.1
5.9
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
Further, Pakistan has by far the lowest Export-to-GDP ratio amongst regional competitors. Not only
does Pakistan fare poorly amongst regional countries, but its own relative performance depicts a
strong declining trend with the ratio losing almost six percentage points over the last 30 years. The
situation clearly suggests that without a sincere attempt at course correction to turnaround the econ-
omy toward export-led growth, boom-bust predicament will continue to prevail with the country
remaining marred in its usual dismal economic performance.
Another area where Pakistan needs to lay more
emphasis in order to augment its exports is
productivity. As per global research results, 60
percent of countries that had Total Factor
Productivity (TFP) growth of more than 3
percent grew at 8 percent or more. On the other
hand, lower TFP growth rates were associated
with lower GDP growth rates. In the case of Paki-
stan as depicted in the figure, average TFP
12
growth has averaged 1.5 percent. To improve production and consequently exports, Pakistan must
improve its productive capacities, productivity and technological capabilities.
As such, growth in the SME sector contributes directly and substantially to the overall economic
growth. In the case of Pakistan as well, majority of the manufacturing and business activity takes
13
place in this sector, which also consti-
tutes nearly 90% of all enterprises and Key Highlights of SMEs
employs around 72% of the non-agri- Total Number of SMEs Over 5.2 million
cultural labor force. The share of SMEs
in GDP is approximately 40% with an Percentage of Non-agricultural 72%
estimated 25% contribution to overall Labour force employed by SMEs
exports. Arguably, the SME sector is a Contribution to GDP 40%
key cog in the country’s economy; with-
out its development and increased Contribution to Exports 25%
contribution to exports, it would be an Source: SMEDA
uphill task to achieve turnaround from import-based economy to export-led orientation and growth.
Strategies for industrial expansion ought to be in sync with export development strategies, however,
such linkages still have substantial room to develop for an optimal outcome.
Augmenting Productivity
1
Product, Market Diversification, Trade
Faciliation and Brand Development 2
PRIORITIES
Enabling and Conducive Business
Environment 3
SME Developemt and Nurturing
Local Endowments 4
1. AUGMENTING PRODUCTIVITY
With global evidence in perspective, it becomes a case of urgency to address productivity issues
across public and private domains to unlock the country’s export potential and transition toward
higher export-oriented GDP growth.
FLAGSHIP INITIATIVES
01 04
National Productivity Pakistan Regulatory
Master Plan Reforms Initiative
02 05
Market Diversification and Doing Business Facilitation:
Chambers Of Commerce and
Regional Connectivity
INITIATIVE(S) Industry, Exporters and Top Brands
03 06
Product Development and SME Development and
Trade Facilitation Nurturing Local Endowments
na
fo
l In
Productivity Master Plan (NPMP). The Plan, which is in its final NATIONAL
u s t r y Tra n s
f ra s t r t u re
nv
i
ig
STRATEGY 2
STRATEGY 3
Physical Fostering Open
Establishing and Secured
Vibrant Innovation Infrastructure
through Government.
Ecosystem.
Private-Public
Reforming Partnership.
Private-Public
Partnership.
16
4. FREE TRADE AGREEMENT WITH GULF COOPERATION COUNCIL
Pakistan is in the process of concluding the Free Trade Agreement with Gulf Cooperation Coun-
cil (GCC), which comprises of six members namely Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emir-
ates, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, and Sultanate of Oman. An important feature of the FTA is a sepa-
rate free trade agreement in the Services Sector.
Based upon the dynamics of the Services Sector in Pakistan, emphasis has been placed on
Commercial Presence (Mode 3) and Movement of Natural Persons (Mode 4) to enhance
employment opportunities for the skilled and semi-skilled human resources in GCC countries
and to promote investment opportunities in Pakistan in the form of joint ventures. All of the 11
sectors of services trade have been included in this on-going FTA.
5. COMPREHENSIVE ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT WITH UAE
The GoP is also working on finalizing terms of reference to negotiate Comprehensive Economic
Partnership Agreement (CEPA) for establishing a Free Trade Area with the government of the
United Arab Emirates.
6. REGIONAL CONNECTIVITY
A vibrant regional trading network is essential for creating the necessary conditions for export
growth. Regional Connectivity, facilitating border markets and trade is, therefore, a target area
of the Ministry of Commerce. The following initiatives have so far been taken, which are expect-
ed to start showing results in the next 12-24 months:
An Agreement between Uzbekistan & Pakistan on transit trade operational in 2022. Paki-
stan’s exports to Uzbekistan have increased from USD 36.56 million in July-March FY
21-22 to USD 73.12 million in the same period of FY 22-23.
Pakistan-Uzbekistan Preferential Trade Agreement (PTA) was signed in 2022, extending
market access for Pakistan in Cement, Mobile Phones, Pharmaceuticals, Chemicals,
Processed food, and Confectionary sectors. Tariff concessions have been given on a total
of 17 tariff lines at HS-6 level by both countries under this PTA and is likely to support
Pakistan’s exports.
Pakistan-Tajikistan Transit Trade Agreement was signed December 2022. The agreement
will become operational after the notification of its rules by custom authorities.
The Ministry of IT will focus on National E-Commerce Council. Given the sector’s
fast-paced growth and the adoption of Pakistan’s first E-Commerce Policy, E-Commerce
exports of Pakistan are expected to increase by 50%. With the support of a dedicated
National E-Commerce Council, the evolution in E-Commerce will be reviewed and
recommendations will be provided.
2. ZERO-TIME-TO-STARTUP POLICY
BOI is working on the development of Zero Time To Startup (ZTTS) Policy for replacing NOCs
with Compliance Verification Process (CVP) through adopting Risk-Based approach. Likewise,
Business Enabling Environment (BEE) initiative is a new benchmarking exercise under devel-
opment. BEE will provide a quantitative assessment of the business environment for private
sector development, published annually and covering most of the economies worldwide.
In the aforesaid context, to institutionalize the reforms process and strengthen the regulatory
guillotine drive, the Board of Investment has drafted Assan Karobar Bill, which is with the Minis-
try of Law & Justice for vetting before submission to the cabinet Committee on Legislative
Cases (CCLC). Regulatory reforms can have a significant impact on investments, exports, and
SMEs (small and medium-sized enterprises) growth. When implemented effectively, these
21
reforms can create a more favorable business environment, reducing the barriers and costs
associated with starting and running businesses.
3. INVEST PAKISTAN
Another key flagship initiative from BOI is “Invest Pakistan” that specializes in investment reali-
zation, sustainability, and bringing the government together to resolve binding constraints in
the investment decision. BoI will register a new public-private partnership company named
‘Invest Pakistan’ with the Securities Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP).
The company will operate as a joint venture between the government and private sector part-
ners and will bring together expertise and resources of both parties to promote investment in
the country. The Cabinet has approved legislation for ‘Invest Pakistan’ initiative on the recom-
mendations of BoI and ensuing legislation will help ensure provisions for investor-friendly
services.
Nine (09) sites for development of Special Economic Zones under CPEC are under execution.
Four SEZs namely Rashakai SEZ, Allama Iqbal Industrial City (AIIC), Bostan SEZ and Dhabeji
22
Dhabeji Industrial Zone are at advanced stages of development. The government will make its
priority to follow through on the high priority CPEC SEZs in order to provide a conducive
eco-system for businesses to relocate and thrive across the country.
Pharmaceuticals Electronics
In the first phase, 5 sectors from the list above will be picked to evolve development plan for
each cluster which will be rolled-out within 6 months of commencement.
2. SME FUND
SME Policy approved by the Federal Cabinet provides that an SME Fund will be established to
ensure that SME development initiatives are implemented and SMEDA is able to play a robust
role supporting interventions across the SME eco-system. The fund, to the tune of PKR 30 billion
will, among other things, undertake the following initiatives:
Technology upgradation of SMEs
23
SME Credit Market Developmen.
Cost sharing for business development services, technology/product improvement, certi-
fication, market access, training, productivity enhancement etc.
Programs / projects, such as common facility centers and small interventions for SME
sector development in partnership with institutional players.
Undertake and promote equity finance, venture capital and other technology based
financial solutions.
Support entrepreneurship eco-system development, including support for digitization,
automation, adoption of new technologies, incubation and start-up accelerator
programs.
Market information, marketing and exhibition support.
Mineral sector is one of the key focus areas and remains a contender to develop with the
objective of product diversification based on local endowments in perspective. However, any
local or foreign investment commences with transparent, credible data to base its investments
upon, without which natural endowments may remain untapped in an organized fashion. To
develop the sector, the GoP is in the process of setting up a National Mineral Data Centre to
facilitate investors, which is expected to be rolled out in the next 12-15 months.
ESTABLISHMENT OF
NATIONAL MINERAL DATA CENTRE
24
THE PROJECT IS BEING EXECUTED KEEPING IN VIEW FOUR KEY COMPONENTS
Integrated GIS based Solutions/Applications for data storage and information processing.
EXPORT ENHANCEMENT: Over the last five years, Pakistan’s main agricultural exports have been
rice ($2.0-$2.5 billion/year), fisheries ($400-$450 million/year), fruits and vegetables
($640-$800 million/year), and meat ($225-$340 million/year). Other than rice, all other com-
modities have much higher potential to increase export. For Pakistan, more tangible agricultur-
al export enhancement opportunities are in China. The Ministry of National Food Security and
Research (MNFSR) has been exploring these opportunities though CPEC initiatives and the
platform of the Joint Working Group on Agriculture (JWG-A). China’s annual agricultural
imports exceed $278 billion which include meat, fisheries, fruits, and vegetables. Annual
imports of each of these commodities exceed $10 billion. Pakistan’s current agricultural export
to China, over the last five years, have ranged $500-$950 million. The higher export last year
was due to increase in rice exports.
For agricultural export enhancement to China, under the (Joint Working Group – Agriculture )
JWG-A, MNFSR is developing the following business models:
Industrial Scale
01 Feedlot Fattening
03 Vegetable Exports
25
01 Industrial Scale Feedlot Fattening: Over three million male buffalo calves are wasted
annually in Pakistan. These claves cannot be saved and raised at the household level.
MNFSR has prepared a pre-facility and now working with private sector companies of
both China and Pakistan to help develop joint ventures. In three years, Pakistan could
start exporting beef worth $500 million to $1.0 billion per annum. The longer-term
potential of meat exports to China could range between $2.0-$3.0 per annum. MNFSR
has assisted one Chinese company to establish donkey slaughterhouse in Gwadar
SEZ as well. The company is expected to start operations this year with annual exports
of expected around $30 million. They are also developing donkey breeding farms to
expand their operations in the medium to long-term.
02 Inland Shrimp Farming: MNFSR has already established the proof of concept that Paki-
stan can expand inland shrimp farming in the saline waterlogged land of Punjab and
Sindh. Like feedlot fattening initiative, MNFSR is working with private companies of
both countries to workout investment models in inland fisheries and shrimp farming,
processing, and export to China. Pakistan could start exporting fisheries worth
$500-$800 million per annum. The potential is much higher in the long run.
03 Vegetable Exports: MNFSR has assisted one Chinese company to expand its Chili
production from 400 acres in 2021-22 to 10,000 acres in 2022-23. They are planning
to set up chili processing plant in south Punjab this year. This proof of concept will lead
this and other Chinese companies to establish production and processing of other
vegetables and export to Gulf countries and China. Pakistan has the potential to
expand its vegetable export $500-$800 million per annum in the next three years.
IMPORT SUBSTITUTION: In the next 2-3 years, by taking policy and development initiatives, Paki-
stan has the potential to become self-sufficient in wheat and cotton and attain 25% to 30%
import substitution in pulses and edible oil.
IMPORT
Policy Initiatives 01 SUBSTITUTION 02 Development
INITIATIVES Initiatives
01 Policy Initiatives: By announcing the profitable support price for wheat and profitable
intervention price for cotton a month before their respective sowing times, as well as
expanding access to formal credit to farmers, Pakistan can achieve self-sufficiency in
wheat and near self-sufficiency in cotton. It will save import expense of about
$2.5-$3.0 billion a year. For cotton, the government has announced profitable inter-
vention price since 2021 but farmers’ access to high-yielding varieties and good qual-
ity certified seed have been major impediments. Both are now becoming available
slowly but can be expedited through policy actions in coordination with the private
sector. MNFSR is actively working with two Chinese companies to field-test their Bt
26
cotton varieties and introduce them in Pakistan. By introducing policy of regulatory
duty on palm oil, Pakistan can attain 25%-35% import substitution worth about $500
million to $1.5 billion (depending on the international prices) in the next 2-3 years.
With similar policy actions, profitable support price and buy-back arrangement, Paki-
stan can attain 25%-30% import substitution in pulses saving about $250-$300
million a year. Further, share of farm credit is less than half of the total formal credit to
the sector. Smallholders, who till about half the farmland and produce over 80% of
the food, lack access to formal credit. MNFSR has developed innovative concept to
provide formal credit to landless farmers and smallholders without collateral. Nurtur-
ing such initiatives will be critical to attain agricultural growth potential.
27
E-PAKISTAN AND
EMPOWERMENT
Empowering Youth, Women and Others
E-PAKISTAN
Enhancing Economic Competitiveness
Using Information and Communication Technology
INTRODUCTION
The Government of Pakistan identifies that the growth of information and communication technology-
(ICT) is a vital factor for the mid-to long-term progress of the country, therefore, government is working
on a Digital Pakistan vision to enhance digital economy that will spur economic prosperity and citizen
empowerment.
The Government of Pakistan strives to improve its citizens’ quality of life and economic well-being by
ensuring availability of accessible, affordable, reliable, universal and high quality ICT services. GOP
strongly believes in mass adoption of emerging digital technologies and innovative applications to
enable cross-sector socio-economic development and transformation of economic activities, govern-
ance models, social interaction, and achievement of sustainable development goals.
SITUATION ANALYSIS
Knowledge is the most strategic asset in the emerging global economy and a key medium of wealth
creation. Rapid adoption of digital information technologies is acting as a change enabler and disrup-
tor of the conventional approach to provide services. Thus, giving birth to entire new sectors of eco-
nomic activity. Telecom and digital connectivity has a significant positive impact on the economy and
contribute to the growth of GDP by increasing productivity, expanding markets, creating jobs, fostering
innovation, and improving access to information.
Despite current economic and inflationary pressures, Telecom sector metrics reflect huge potential for
stable growth. There are over 194 million biometrically verified cellular connections with mobile cov-
erage of over 90% of the population. Broadband subscribers have also crossed the 127 million mark,
reflecting 56% broadband penetration. 3G and 4G mobile signal coverage is available to more than
78% of the population. The annual mobile broadband data usage has seen phenomenal growth
29
reaching more than 8,970 petabytes showing an annual growth of 31%. The under pressure telecom
industry still managed to achieve a revenue of PKR 694 billion during FY 2021-22 and contributed
more than PKR 325 billion in the national exchequer i.e. the sector returned 45% of its revenues to
the national exchequer. The Telecom sector has been a flag-bearer of foreign investments in the coun-
try with almost $ 6 billion investment since 2017-18.
Pakistan’s IT industry has been growing at a rapid pace in the last 10 years. Currently, the IT exports
are estimated to exceed USD 2.5 billion. However, compared to the regional and emerging IT players
it is still significantly very low. The current workforce employed in the IT sector (excluding freelancers)
is around 325,000. Another 300,000 are estimated to work as ‘active’ freelancers out of a million
associated with free-lancing. These freelancers are mostly associated with e-commerce, software
development and creative content services. The universities in the country are producing 25,000
graduates approx. every year. However, a high proportion of them are not ‘industry-ready’ immediately
and thus have either to undergo intensive skills training or adopt non-IT professions. This has created
a supply-demand gap hindering rapid growth of the IT industry and consequently IT/ ITeS exports.
On the IT infrastructure and connectivity side, despite rapid transformation of the telecommunication
land-scape in the country over the last two decades, Pakistan still faces a number of problems such
as unavailability of alternative internet international routes, last mile high speed broadband and few
domestic cloud service providers/data centers and high taxation on telecom services i.e. ~35%
current restrictions on import of ICT and Telecom equipment, high USD exchange and interest rate,
energy prices.
There is a huge potential and opportunity for Pakistan to aggressively gear its economy towards digi-
tal/information technologies with specially emphasis on IT/ITeS exports having telecom digital con-
nectivity, utilizing un-assigned spectrum of almost 250-300 MHz. The envisioned turnaround of Paki-
stan’s economy in the medium to long-term is possible by giving IT and Telecom sectors the top priori-
ty.
For the Vision 2025, The National Information Technology Board (NITB) can contribute in developing
Digital Solution and implementing e-Governance Project which will lead towards the broader Vision
of the Highest office of "Putting People First”. To Promote the National Vision of Putting Every Pakistan-
is First, we can start by developing digital platforms for basic services, promoting gender inclu-
sivity and empowerment, and providing training on digital literacy and entrepreneurship. NITB can
extend its supports in developing a comprehensive digital strategy that outlines the National goals,
objectives, and action plan for achieving a Government Digital Economy, which will includes evaluat-
ing current digital capabilities and identifying areas for improvement. NITB can play a key role in "Insti-
tutional Digital Transformation, Institutional Digitization and e-Governance" by providing technical
expertise and support to civil service and state-owned enterprise reforms, and promoting transparen-
cy, accountability, and citizen participation in governance. We can contribute to “Energy, Water, and
Food Security" by developing digital platforms and tools for efficient resource management and
promoting the use of technology in agriculture productivity. We can also extend our support to "Private
Sector-Led Growth" by creating a business-friendly environment, promoting digital entrepreneurship,
and developing digital platforms for export-led growth. Lastly, we can contribute for "Improving Nation-
al Competitiveness" by promoting productivity, innovation, and quality through technology, enhancing
exports, and developing a skilled workforce through higher education reform.
The National Information Technology Board (NITB) plays a crucial role in the implementation of the
5Esframework of development outlined by the Ministry of Planning, Development & Special Initiatives.
NITB is responsible for driving digital transformation across various sectors of the economy and socie-
ty, which is essential for achieving the objectives of the 5Es framework.
Environment: We can develop, based on stated of the Art technologies, using AI and Big Data
Predictive Solution for Climatic Disaster Management, which can help in developing a proactive
approach towards disaster and risk management. We can also extend our services in developing
smart solutions to address the impacts of climate change, such as developing climate modeling
tools and promoting the use of renewable energy sources. We have always promoted less paper
environment by promoting Go Green and Green Pakistan Vision.
Energy and Infrastructure: NITB can work with the government and private sector to
promote the development of digital infrastructure, such as broadband networks and data
centers, that support efficient energy production and distribution. NITB can also develop digital
solutions to improve the efficiency of energy use in various sectors, such as agriculture and trans-
portation using Big Data and Block chain Decision Making.
Equity: We can help improve access to services by promoting digital inclusion, particularly in
marginalized communities. This includes developing digital literacy programs and providing
access to affordable internet services. We can also help implement e-governance initiatives
that improve access to government services and reduce corruption. For example, working in
close collaboration with USF and Other telecom partners for introducing free applications for edu-
cation and health services in far flung areas.
How can NITB relate to the seven pillars defined in the conference encompassed
seven diverse pillars which are the key drivers and enablers of growth as envisaged
in vision 2025:
Achieving Sustainable, Indigenous, and Inclusive Growth: With the passive growth
towards adoption of the Digital Economy Globally, we can provide assistance and knowledge area
by promoting the digital economy and creating an enabling environment for entrepreneurship,
innovation, and creativity. Been the technology wing of the Government of Islamic Republic of
Pakistan, we can develop policies and programs to promote the use of technology in traditional
industries such as agriculture, arts and culture, and sports. Additionally having a strong team of
professionals in the Digital Development, we can also contribute to resource mobilization by
developing digital platforms for crowd funding, venture capital, and angel investing.
Energy, Water, and Food Security: NITB can contribute to this theme by developing digital
platforms and tools for efficient management of energy, water, and food resources. We can also
promote the use of technology in agriculture productivity, milk and meat productivity enhance-
ment, and tackling malnutrition and stunting using Big Data, Data Analysis and Data Driven Deci-
32
sion Making for increasing the productivity through Technology.
Institutional Reform and Democratic Governance: NITB has been the pioneer in laying
the foundation of the e-Governance through its state-of-the-art developed Solution e-Office. E-Of-
fice is complete Office suite for enterprise management including key enterprise features like Digi-
tal File and Document sharing, Digital Noting along with functions like Human Resource Man-
agement, Financial Management and Procurement. We have successfully roll out e-Office in
40 Ministries and around 192 attached departments. Through e-Office successful implementa-
tion as a Positive Use Case, we had and will continue to play a key role in institutional reform
by providing technical expertise and support to civil service reforms, police and criminal justice
system reforms, and state-owned enterprise reforms. Technology is always used Globally for
the promotion of transparency, accountability, and citizen participation in governance and deci-
sion-making processes, we been the lead player can extend our expertise and support for achiev-
ing the targets as Envisioned by the Government of Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Putting People First: Being the Digital Transformation wing and promoting Digitalization, NITB
can play its part by leveraging information technology to develop and enhance human and social
capital. For example, as in the Past we have been an active player which has contributed in uplift-
ing the Digital Era of the Country where we have successfully developed and deployed digital plat-
forms for online education, healthcare, and social protection programs to provide access to basic
services for people in remote areas.
Private Sector-Led Growth: We have always in the Past, played a role in bringing the Private
Industries and the Public Government Departments together on a single platform where sharing
of the capacity and development for increasing the Capacity of Human Resource, National Project
Targets and Mutual Goal for excelling the Country in the Digital Era has been achieved. NITB can
support this theme by creating a business-friendly environment and promoting digital entrepre-
neurship, start-ups, and small and medium enterprises. NITB can also develop digital platforms
for export-led growth and value chain gap improvements to enhance investment and growth
along with Private Industry Counterparts.
Modernization of transportation infrastructure: NITB can play a key role in the mod-
ernization of transportation infrastructure by promoting the use of technology in transporta-
tion management, logistics, and supply chain management. To achieve the transportation evolu-
tion, we can extend our support towards the development of telecommunication infrastructure to
enhance regional connectivity via rail, road, and the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).
How National Information Technology Board can work on different layers of eco-
nomic uplifting?
33
As part of its ongoing commitment to ensure IT-related policies and regulations aligned with national
strategy and objectives, NITB has delivered over 180 successful projects, including G2B, G2C, and
G2G since 2014. Through supportive policies and regulatory environment, it plays a vital role in the
success of the IT sector in Pakistan. It envisions to create an environment conducive to business
growth, job creation, and innovation in the IT industry. The objective is to help Pakistan's IT sector
become a vibrant and efficient industry capable, of competing in the global IT landscape. By serving
as a hub for implementing digital initiatives, it will propel digitalization in Pakistan and develop
the country's information infrastructure.
1. In terms of Government to Government (G2G) services, the National Information Technology
Board (NITB) is responsible for developing and implementing digital strategies to promote e-
Governance, Digital Transformation and Digitization. This includes working with manufactur-
ing, commerce, and small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) to help them leverage digi-
tal tools and platforms to expand their reach in international markets. Additionally, NITB
collaborates with the private sector to create more job opportunities in the IT sector, promot-
ing empowerment and inclusive development.
2. Regarding Government to Citizen (G2C) services, NITB aims to promote digital inclu-
sion, particularly in marginalized communities, through the development of digital literacy
programs and Digital Solutions compliance with the Government Business Processes.
Furthermore, NITB implements e-governance initiatives to improve access to government
services and reduce corruption. By leveraging digital tools and platforms, NITB can help
citizens interact with the government more easily and transparently in a cost effective &
smart efficient manner.
3. In terms of Government to Employee (G2E) services, NITB creates opportunities for youth and
women through various digital initiatives. For example, NITB develops programs to train
young people in digital skills, such as software development, digital marketing, Data Analytics
etc. We empowers employees to acquire the skills necessary to succeed in the IT industry.
Baytee App
This digital wonder of NITB serves 51% of the population of Pakistan i.e. women. As
suggested by its name, Baytee Mobile App targets to lift up the life quality of Pakistani
women.
DGSE App
DGSE App provides digital assistance for educating students who are faced with
physical, developmental, or neurological delays.
35
Water Billing Portal
This portal is for AJK, manages billings district-wise and region-wise, dynamic bill
generate and via BAR Code reader. Online bill view and payment will be made in the
second phase.
E Portal (NOC)
It is aimed at automating the process of the NOC certificate, i.e. by digitalizing the No
Objection Certificate procedure for employees working under the Establishment Divi-
sion from manual to digital.
Bait-ul-Maal Portal
It aims at serving students the ease of using Bait ul Maal services by using the
student information system of Pakistan bait-ul-Maal, student profile, enrolment in any
course and session, and multiple training centers managed.
Innovation Hub
Developed to empower the general public by welcoming their unique business
proposal to be reviewed by subject matter experts.
NLCC Dashboard
Aimed for synergizing and articulating national efforts against locust for decision
making and effective implementation, Managing and displaying stats of survey and
control areas of the country in terms of maps, charts, and tables, on daily basis.
4. Initiative: e-Office
An indigenous e-government ERP/GRP is developed and being implemented in all the
40 federal ministries/divisions along with underlined 192 departments. E-Office is a com-
plete back-office automation suite.
Injection into Economy: 600 million per annum.
Economic Indicators 2020-22:
• Up to 25 % savings on POL
• Up to 70 % savings on annual stationery cost (approx. 600 million)
• 100 % Transparent, accountable system with executive dashboard for decision making.
• 80 % of time savings in process time.
• Increase government efficiency.
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS
1. DEMAND DRIVEN INDUSTRY QUALITY & CAPACITY ENHANCEMENT PROGRAM
This Project defines the Standards & Policies, Testing & audit, Training, and Product Certification mech-
anism for government departments to conceive, plan, design, procure, develop or deploy and imple-
ment ICT solutions. Provide an adequate level of confidence that government IT/software RFP com-
plies with minimum quality standards. It will also help local Industry increase their level of quality and
competitiveness to international standards.
The current 'project focuses towards achievement of objectives of "Pakistan Digital Policy"
through implementation of Hospital Management Information System in all Federally Administrative
hospitals under the concept of "One Patient One ID". The objective of the project is to improve patient
services through better management and, efficient use of available resources both human and
financial.
39
IGNITE’S NATIONAL INCUBATION CENTERS FOR
TECH ENTREPRENEURSHIP
The establishment of National Incubation Centers (NIC) for Tech Entrepreneurship Program aims to
provide support and resources to startups and entrepreneurs in Pakistan to help them develop innova-
tive ideas and grow their businesses. The program was launched in 2017 and is focused on fostering
a culture of entrepreneurship in the country by providing a platform to startups for business planning,
product development, pitching, networking, and funding.
Under NIC program, Ignite-National Technology Fund has established eight (8) incubation centers at
Islamabad, Lahore, Quetta, Karachi, Peshawar, Hyderabad, Faisalabad (Agritech), and Rawalpindi (Aer-
ospace technologies). Each NIC is providing a range of services to startups that include access to
coaching, mentorship, curriculum and networking opportunities, funding and investment support,
co-working space, opportunities to showcase products & services at local & international events and
other facilities & resources.
The NIC Program for tech entrepreneurship has been instrumental in promoting innovation and entre-
preneurship in Pakistan. All of the eight (8) NICs have been supporting wide range of startups from
different industries. So far, more than 1,317 startups have been hosted by these NICs and more than
660 have been graduated successfully. These startups have collectively committed an investment of
US $ 73.76 million and have generated revenue of PKR 9.14 billion. More than 126,000 jobs have
been created by these startups.
These NICs are also making a significant contribution to the female entrepreneurs of Pakistan and
about 36% of the startups are women led. More than, 2300 women have been empowered through
this program. These NICs have helped to boost economic growth, create new jobs, drive innovation
and promote women led entrepreneurship in the country.
40
IGNITE’S DIGISKILLS.PK FOR CAPACITY BUILDING
OF FREELANCERS
DigiSkills.pk is a flagship project of Ignite being executed nationwide since 2018 through Virtual
University, which is equipping existing and new freelancers with knowledge, skills, tools & techniques
necessary to seize the earning opportunities available internationally through freelancing in online
jobs market places and also locally. The first phase of this project was completed in February 2022 in
which 10 freelancing trainings were provided, whereas the second phase i.e.DigiSKills.pk 2.0 was
launched in Jan 2022 in which 5 new courses were added and with existing 10 courses whose con-
tent was also upgraded.
Overall, there are more that 3.3 million enrollments in 16 batches in 15 most in demand freelancing
courses, till date. Furthermore, there are around 27% female and 73% male enrollments with a
course completion rate of 31%. As per an independent study conducted in June 2022 through a
third-party firm, Digiskills.pk trained freelancers have earned more than USD$ 290 million.
1. Digiskills.pk had 11 batches, which had 2.3 million+ enrollments in which 579,322 were
females.
2. Currently Batch-4 of digiskills.pk 2.0, is in progress and there are 1,136,065 enrollments in
which 325,656 are females.
41
IGNITE’S INNOVATION FUND
With the objective of transforming country’s economy to knowledge-based economy, Ignite, has
funded over multiple ICT-centric technical innovative SEED projects to facilitate and nurture the
Research and innovation ecosystem among academicians, professionals and startups, etc.
These projects were funded to different segments of the society, including academia, IT industry and
Start-ups. The primary focus of these projects was to encourage and promote ICT related research,
development and innovation. After transformation into Ignite, the company is focusing on projects
with commercial orientation, based upon Fourth Industrial Wave technologies – like AI, IoT, Robotics
and AR/VR etc.
In total 149 projects have been funded worth Rs. 2.59 Billion since inception of Ignite. Highlights are
as follows:
Going forward, Ignite is planning new programs for empowerment of women and youth of Pakistan.
Some of them are as follows:
Ignite Startup Portal where both NIC and non-NIC startups can register and market their
products.
A Center of excellence in gaming & animation
An accelerator for seed funding of early stage startups
Bootcamps in programming languages in demand to train programmers
A technology transition fund for commercialization of new products
National Grassroots Initiative for funding of final year projects of ICT graduates
A women-focused incubator for women entrepreneurs
STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES
To create a holistic digital ecosystem with infrastructure and institutional frameworks for
rapid delivery of innovative digital services, application and content.
42
Promote adoption of Telecom/ICT/digital technology in all spheres of the economic and
social activities, including healthcare, education, agriculture, social services, local gov-
ernment, and public sector services
Promote investment friendly telecom policy for increased investment in the sector and
introduction of 5G in Pakistan
Empower youth and women by using ICTs to reduce inequalities amongst the less-privi-
leged segments of the society and persons with disabilities. Thus, encourage policy of
inclusivity.
Promote innovation and entrepreneurship through provision of digital infrastructure
facilities, expanded easy access to funds, up skilling and training workforce competitive
with international standards and increasing the quantity of industry-ready workforce
and enabling investment environment.
THEMATIC INITIATIVE 2: NATION-WIDE INTERNET ACCESS WITH FOCUS ON LAST MILE HIGH
SPEED BROADBAND.
Breakthrough policy interventions like publication of Spectrum Refarming Framework,
Telecom Infrastructure Sharing Guidelines/Regulations, Spectrum Sharing Framework,
44
Balanced Space & Satellite Policy Framework, 5G Readiness Plan.
Telecom reforms for better telecom sector health, increased investment in the sector and
introduction of 5G in Pakistan.
Improve in connectivity infrastructure is necessary to have high quality data speeds. To
achieve this, availability of high-speed broadband up to the last-mile availability is
required. For this investment incentives will be worked out in consultation with the stake-
holders to have an internationally competitive infrastructure. This will further enable
attracting international investors and businesses to provide their services in the country.
The framework provides a regulatory mechanism for the industry, to enable the development of IoT
eco-system in Pakistan. This framework aims to accelerate the growth of IoT services to facilitate digi-
tal transformation creating IoT-enabled systems in different sectors to automate operations and
render electronic services to citizens.
IoT is one of the major technologies of the Fourth Industrial Revolution (Industry 4.0); it is used to run
smart city systems and digital services such as smart homes, smart meters, transportation etc., there-
by, supporting Government’s vision of Digital Pakistan. The regulatory framework is available at
www.pta.gov.pk
With IOT Framework launched almost nine new IOT SME/Enterprise were granted- nationwide license
in the last one year only.
46
Infrastructure sharing concept promotes resource optimization by better utilization of assets, avoiding
duplication of network infrastructure, saves times & cost and accelerate service rollouts. Telecom
network deployment involves heavy CAPEX and OPEX liabilities for operators and is considered as a
major deterrent for network expansions. Furthermore, delays to rolling out network infrastructure,
which are attributed to procuring Right of Ways, operational cost, maintenance cost & Average Reve-
nue Per User are the challenges to licensed operators that shall be addressed.
Infrastructure sharing enables operators to focus on competition in the service layer regardless of the
extent of the sharing. Operators can share whole or strategically passive elements of their network to
share infrastructure costs, while providing acceptable performance. Furthermore, these savings can
facilitate mobile operators’ migration to next generation technologies.
Ministry of IT & Telecommunication and Pakistan Telecommunication Authority has finalized the draft
of first ever Infrastructure Sharing framework after multiple consultations with stakeholders and Indus-
try. The draft was also uploaded on Ministry of IT & Telecom’s website for open consultation with stake-
holders.
The Telecom Infrastructure framework is expected to attract two billion USD foreign direct in the next
two to three years in Pakistan.
Now, the final draft is ready to be presented to Economic Coordination Committee for approval
followed by Federal Government’s approval.
The Readiness plan is available on MOITT website. Once commercially launched with digital inclusion
may add 3 to 5 billion USD contribution in the national economy in the next 5 years.
While spectrum sharing holds potential, it cannot supplant the need for exclusively licensed mobile
spectrum. However, sharing can play a complementary role to traditional spectrum licensing by allow-
ing mobile services to access new bands where there are no other reasonable alternatives.
It is essential to care of frequency bands that suits sharing and select the right sharing framework to
ensure innovative and affordable mobile services. Firstly, the proposed band should provide sufficient
spectrum in areas where mobile operators are seeing growing demand. Secondly, the sharing frame-
47
work should be understandable, usable and tailored to the needs of the users (e.g. certainty of access,
sufficient block sizes etc.).
Pakistan Telecommunication Authority has finalized the draft of first ever Frequency Sharing frame-
work after multiple consultations with stakeholders and Industry. The draft will be forwarded to Ministry
of IT & Telecom’s website once Technical Member/Chairman join.
Satellite-based technologies are widely employed in developed countries to provide high quality com-
munications services to remote areas, cut costs, boost productivity, and promote efficiency, and they
are aiding the development of a global economy.
Developing countries are gravitating to satellite-based solutions because they can connect raw mate-
rial suppliers with agents, shippers, importers, merchants, and ultimately customers in widely separat-
ed geographic areas without being constrained by physical distance. Indeed, the benefits of satel-
lite-based communications are being realized in every sector of activity, both private and public.
The telecom sector of Pakistan is on the verge of entering a new era, especially in the regime of satel-
lite. This will open another avenue of benefiting from the space economy through adaptation of satel-
lite-based communications. Communication satellite systems make it possible for rural areas to have
access to voice and internet, as well as to socially useful e/m-services like e/m-learning and
e/m-health, as well as to efficiently deliver broadcast services over large geographic areas.
Currently, Pakistan is using 2,200MHz of its total satellite capacity, of which Pakistani satellites
account for 21% and foreign satellites for the remainder. The new framework shall open up the space
economy and uplift the revenues to domestic satellite operators licensed by PTA. The issue of frequen-
cy dumping and broadband connectivity through foreign satellite operators without domestic pres-
ence shall be addressed.
Considering all above factors, the new Satellite regime framework shall not only provide opportunities
to new market entrant but also shall scale up the domestic space Programme.
Given the central role of 5G technology in this decade and beyond, it is important for Pakistan to
develop a short, medium & long-term, forward-looking spectrum roadmap that addresses the future
spectrum needs. In this regard, the establishment of a framework for spectrum refarming is an essen-
tial step that will help Government of Pakistan in timely introduction of new technologies and services
48
for the greater benefit of all citizens and stakeholders in Pakistan.
National Cyber Security Policy: Cyber-attacks and cyber breaches pose a serious threat
to the cyber space of Pakistan. To prevent these threats, National Cyber Security Policy
2021 was made to secure and govern the cyber space of Pakistan. This policy will ensure
that the required framework is in place to not only deter the ongoing attacks but also
proactively engage in discouraging future attacks.
Pakistan Cloud First Policy: The policy will result in optimized utilization of resources,
reduction in ICT expenditure and increased coordination between public sector entities for
their ICT related initiatives. The policy is successfully approved by the Cabinet during Feb-
ruary 2022.
Personal Data Protection Bill: The preparation of this bill is a landmark achievement and
will pave way for evolution of digital ecosystem in Pakistan by bringing in investment in the
field of Information and Communication Technologies. The bill has already been approved
in principally by the Cabinet during Year 2022 and in process for further consultations.
EMPOWERMENT
Youth, women and differently abled people
INTRODUCTION
Pakistan has a significant young population, 63% of its citizens under 30. To address the needs of
these young people, the Prime Minister has announced several initiatives, including the National
Youth Internship Program, which will provide 60,000 paid internships to graduates, and the establish-
ment of 250 vocational training centers. Additionally, 250 mini sports complexes, Pakistan Innovation
Fund, a Youth Council and a Youth Unit at MoPD&SI are being established to promote youth empower-
ment.
However, gender inequality remains a significant issue in Pakistan, ranking 153rd out of 156 countries
on the Global Gender Gap Index 2021. The government has outlined strategic objectives for improv-
ing the status of women, including providing access to education and employment opportunities (Na-
tional Gender Policy Framework), improving mobility (Women On Wheels), and increasing
representation in decision-making positions (Gender Unit).
50
SITUATION ANALYSIS
With nearly sixty four percent population below the age of 29, Pakistan is one of the youngest coun-
tries in the world. This large youth bulge offers the country a golden opportunity to benefit from a
potential “demographic dividend” while simultaneously raising the challenge of providing adequate
services, jobs and engagement opportunities. While Pakistan has made considerable progress in
improving the state of socio-economic development of young people over the years, the overall pace
of progress has been slow compared to other developing countries. Indicators of human development
including education levels, access to employment opportunities, political participation, health and
well-being indicate that Pakistani youth face multiple challenges in accessing basic services, secur-
ing gainful employment opportunities and participating in social and political processes.
Despite having the 9th largest workforce in the world, Pakistan’s youth employment is among the
lowest in the South Asian countries. The disconnect between the skills set of young people and the
demands of industry are a major contributor to high youth unemployment. Furthermore, there are
considerable disparities within the youth cohort based on gender, location (urban/rural, provincial),
income status and physical ability. Poor, differently abled, female and rural youth face greater chal-
lenges in accessing socio-economic and political opportunities and services. Sensitivity to the needs
of marginalized youth such as differently abled young people is critical for inclusive and sustainable
development of the nation.
In addition to age, gender is a major dimension of social inequality and exclusion. Although succes-
sive governments have taken a number of progressive steps to promote basic human rights, protect
girls and women against discrimination and violence and address drivers of gender-based discrimi-
nation, the pace of progress on gender equality remains slow compared to other developing nations.
Women constitute 48.7 percent of the total population of the country. Yet they face discrepancies in
accessing health, education, financial, and legal services and participating in social and political
decision-making processes. The result is that Pakistan consistently ranks low on most global indices
measuring the state of gender equality. According to Global Gender Gap Index report 2021, Pakistan
has a huge gender disparity in terms of economic participation . The indicators for political participa-
tion are more promising , yet there is considerable room for development in this sphere as well. Gen-
der-based disparities persist in health , education , income and employment opportunities , social
protection , personal security , control over assets and participation in decision-making processes .
Additionally, women shoulder the burden of unpaid care and domestic work, further reflecting harmful
and restrictive social norms. Violence against women and differently abled girls is also rampant,
which spikes further during natural calamities and disasters.
EDUCATION ENGAGEMENT
4ES
While ensuring quality education, gainful employment, youth entrepreneurship and meaningful
social and political engagement remain the key pillars of the Government’s strategy, inclusion is a
cross-cutting priority, which has been integrated across all pillars. For key initiatives under each pillar,
quotas have been fixed, where possible, for girls, women, trans-genders, differently-abled persons and
youth from least-developed regions and provinces. Moreover, the Government has also launched
several initiatives specifically designed for women, transgenders and differently-abled persons.
Furthermore, the Government is keen to harness the unlimited potential of Information and Communi-
cation Technology (ICT) in empowering youth, women and other marginalized social groups. ICT is a
critical enabler in creating opportunities for employment and entrepreneurship, accessing basic
services, and participation in social and political processes. Equipping young people with digital skills
and providing them access to finance and information is crucial to enable them to navigate and lever-
age the rapidly changing world.
The following short-term and medium-term goals will help turn the afore-mentioned vision into reality:
Facilitate and accelerate school-to-work transition of young people.
Increase the employability, marketability and work-readiness of youth, women, transgender,
and differently abled people by equipping them with high-demand soft and hard skills.
Modernise the public sector technical and vocational training regime and integrate skills
training in general education systems.
Prepare young graduates for taking up leadership positions in the economic and political
spheres.
Break down and address barriers to entry in labour market faced by young people, women
and other marginalized social groups.
End gender-based violence and mainstream gender protection across systems, policies,
processes, and programs.
Integrate and mainstream social inclusion and gender lens across systems, policies and
processes.
Leverage the role of ICT in creating opportunities for socio-economic and political empower-
ment of young people and women.
Provide digital skills and gadgets to young people to help them navigate the digital world and
create self-learning and self-employment opportunities.
52
FLAGSHIP INITIATIVES
THE GOVERNMENT’S INITIATIVES FOR YOUTH FOCUSES ON
4 KEY AREAS
Youth Unit
The MODPSI will launch a Youth Unit that will be dedicated specifically to the cause of youth
empowerment.
Youth Summit
MOPDSI will organize a summit for the youth for university students across Pakistan. The
summit will engage youth in key policy areas to create insights to inform policy and future
plans.
WOMEN ON WHEELS
The Women on Wheels project will facilitate women’s mobility by providing motorbikes
and scooters to women at subsidized rates and training them to drive them.
WOMEN SUMMIT
The government will organize a women centric summit to promote collaboration among
women across various industries and fostering entrepreneurship.
GENDER UNIT
A gender unit will be established at the Ministry of
Planning and Development to review development
project proposals from a gender equity perspective
and integrate gender equity into the design of the
development projects.
56
QUOTAS FOR WOMEN
Various development initiatives will have quota for women to encourage their participa-
tion. For instance, in the Ba-Salahiyat Naujawan Program, a 40% share has been intro-
duced for females to encourage their labor force participation.
MoFEPT’s Distance education initiatives creating inclusiveness for females through acceler-
ated learning pathways, teacher training, skill based learning and foundational learning
programmes.
57
FLAGSHIP E-GOVERNANCE AND TRANSPARENCY
INITIATIVES
PRIME MINISTER’S
LAPTOP SCHEME
The Prime Minister’s Youth Laptop Scheme will provide technological access to young
and talented students studying in public sector higher education institutes across the
country including AJK and GB. Rs. 10,827.28 million have been allocated for this pro-
ject where 100,000 laptops would be distributed among meritorious students in two
years.
SERVICES.GOV.PK
The government’s services portal servic-
es.gov.pk will provide guidelines and tutorials
about government’s services.
58
MOBILE APP
Prime Minister's Youth Programme Mobile App is a plat-
form to discover the world of opportunities. Youth will be
able to find job opportunities, career counselling, and all
the information related to different initiatives of the
Prime Minister's Youth Programme in a single mobile
application.
59
ENVIRONMENT
Water and Food Security
INTRODUCTION
Pakistan faces significant challenges in
ensuring the sustainability of its envi-
ronment, water resources, and food
security. In recent years, the impacts of
climate change have worsened these
challenges, and urgent action is
needed to address them. This chapter
provides a comprehensive overview of
the current situation in Pakistan in
terms of environment, water resources,
and food security. It outlines the gov-
ernment's response to these challeng-
es and the initiatives being taken to
mitigate the effects of climate change,
enhance efficiency of water use, pro-
mote sustainable agriculture, reduce
greenhouse gas emissions, manage
water pollution, land degradation, and
improve water management. Addition-
ally, the chapter outlines initiatives
being taken to enhance resilience,
rehabilitate infrastructure, and ensure
food security.
SITUATION ANALYSIS
Pakistan ranks as the eighth most vulnerable country on the Climate Risk Index 2021.1 Moreover,
Pakistan’s vulnerability to climate change is expected to increase further as Pakistan’s projected rise
in temperature is 5.3 degrees Celsius, higher than the global average of 3.7 degrees Celsius in the
same Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) scenario.
Climate Change is a risk multiplier for developing countries such as Pakistan. It exacerbates
pre-existing threats and other drivers of instability, contributing to security risks including water, food
and energy security. Pakistan has experienced extreme consequences of climate change, including
frequent heatwaves, floods, and droughts. Climatic variability and probability of extreme events is on
the rise as witnessed in the unprecedented floods in 2022. The flood affected approximately 33
million people. The Post-Disaster Needs Assessment (PDNA) of the 2022 floods reported that Pakistan
suffered total damages of more than US$14.9 billion and economic losses of around US$15.2 billion,
amounting to 4.8% of the FY22 gross GDP. 2
Due to rising population and lack of water resource governance, Pakistan is soon to face a water
security crisis. The per capita availability of surface water has declined from 5,260 cubic meters
annually in 1951 to approximately 1,000 cubic meters in 2016. Projections indicate that by 2025, this
figure may decline further to around 860 cubic meters, signifying Pakistan's shift from a "wa-
ter-stressed" to a "water-scarce" nation.
Moreover, the frequency of droughts has increased over the past decade, posing immediate food
security risks. 3 Drought impacts result from declines in crop yield and livestock productivity, threaten-
ing the livelihoods of agriculture-dependent households, thereby increasing the risk of hunger and
poverty for vulnerable populations. Additionally, increased frequency of droughts leads to land degra-
dation and a decline in groundwater reserves, exacerbating water stress-related risks, particularly the
availability of safe drinking water. Climate change, heatwaves, floods, and droughts are threatening
Pakistan's primarily subsistence-based, irrigated agriculture sector. Consequently, in the last two
years, the country has imported $1.77 billion worth of wheat, leading to increased imported inflation
despite its traditional self-sufficiency. The unstable supply chains caused by the Ukraine War under-
score the importance of greater self-sufficiency.
Early identification and an efficient disaster governance architecture is critical for risk mitigation.
Pakistan has implemented that includes the National Disaster Management Authority and Provincial
and District Disaster Management Authorities. The Federal Flood Commission is responsible for flood
control in the country, while the National Disaster Risk Management Framework outlines priorities for
action over five years. Despite these efforts, challenges remain regarding disaster preparedness and
response, particularly at the district level and in terms of community awareness and education which
signifies the need of a comprehensive disaster governance architecture.
62
adaptation targets. Risks associated with extreme climate-related events, air pollution, and environ-
mental degradation are anticipated to reduce Pakistan’s GDP by 18 to 20% by the year 2050. It is esti-
mated that the total investment of USD 348 billion is required for climate response between 2023 and
2030. Additionally, to achieve full implementation of its Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs),
Pakistan would require a total cost of nearly USD 200 billion. 4
4
World Bank Group. (2022). Country and Climate Development Report.
63
increased, with an emphasis on regional and global cooperation among governments, climate
science research organizations, and other stakeholders.
Strengthen Community Based Resilience and Adaptation: The government has prioritized
community-based initiatives that empower local populations to adapt to the changing climate
and build resilience to future shocks. This approach strategizes capacity building, aware-
ness-raising, and the promotion of nature-based solutions and green interventions to promote
integrated flood risk management, disaster risk management and climate readiness.
FLAGSHIP INITIATIVES
Environment, Climate Change, and
Disaster Governance Initiatives
01
INITIATIVE(S)
Food Security
Initiatives
02 03 Water Governance
and Infrastructure Initiatives
5 Catastrophe Modeling for Disaster Risk Finance 13 The Sindh Coastal Resilience Project (SCRP)
64
1. CLEAN GREEN PAKISTAN INITIATIVE
The initiative focuses on promoting sustainable development, reducing pollution, and conserv-
ing natural resources. The Clean Green Pakistan initiative includes several programs, such as
tree planting campaigns, waste management initiatives, and efforts to promote the use of
renewable energy sources. The initiative also aims to raise awareness among the public about
environmental issues and the importance of protecting the environment.
2. NATIONAL CLEAN AIR POLICY (NCAP) 2023
The National Clear Policy was approved by the Federal government with the aim to improve air
quality in the country by reducing pollution. The policy aims to provide a comprehensive frame-
work for improving air quality in Pakistan, with particular focus on implementing national-scale
actions that would lead to measurable improvements. With this policy in place, the government
is poised to make significant progress in the fight against air pollution in Pakistan, with major
objectives being reducing annual deaths and trans-boundary pollution, improving the health
of Pakistani citizens, with a positive impact on the country’s economic activity.
National Clean Air Policy has identified one priority intervention in each of the five major air
polluting sectors: transport, industry, agriculture, waste, and residential. The successful imple-
mentation of these five priority interventions is expected to make a substantial contribution to
improving air quality, reducing emissions by 81 percent in 2040, compared to the baseline
scenario, and by 70 percent compared to 2020 levels.
4. REDD+ INITIATIVE
REDD+ initiative was launched with the aim of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from
deforestation and forest degradation. The initiative aims to promote sustainable forest man-
agement, enhance carbon stocks in forests, and increase the participation of local communi-
ties in forest conservation efforts. The REDD+ initiative also aims to address the drivers of
deforestation, such as illegal logging and land-use change, and promote alternative livelihood
options for communities living in and around forests. Pakistan's REDD+ initiative is aligned with
the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and has received
support from international organizations such as the World Bank and the Food and Agriculture
Organization (FAO). The initiative is expected to play a crucial role in reducing carbon emis-
sions in Pakistan and contributing to global efforts to address climate change.
65
5. CATASTROPHE MODELING FOR DISASTER RISK FINANCE
This flagship program aims to promote olive cultivation on 50,000 acres by developing infra-
structure and capThe development of the Natural Catastrophe (NatCat) Model is a key initiative
undertaken by NDRMF in collaboration with SUPRACO. This model is designed to quantify the
extent of primary natural hazards, such as floods, droughts, tropical cyclones, and earthquakes,
as well as vulnerability and risk assessment, and loss estimation. The NatCat Model combines
historical disaster data with current demographic, infrastructure, scientific, and financial infor-
mation to determine the potential cost of catastrophes for specified geographic areas. By simu-
lating the physical characteristics of thousands of potential catastrophes and projecting their
effects on residential, commercial property, and critical infrastructure, the model informs users
on the likelihood and intensity of future events. acity for mass-scale production of true-to-type,
disease-free olive nursery plants in the public and private sectors.
6. CLIMATE RESPONSIVE PUBLIC INVESTMENT - 4RF STRATEGY
The 4RF Strategy, aimed at addressing the impacts of the 2022 floods, aligns with the strategic
vision and priorities of Pakistan, particularly in areas such as Climate Responsive Public Invest-
ment, Coordinated Disaster Governance Architecture, Systemic Resilience and Adaptation, and
Nature-based Solutions. The 4RF Strategy's focus on the rehabilitation and reconstruction of
community infrastructure, such as irrigation, roads, WASH, primary health, and education, sup-
ports the strategic priority of Climate Responsive Public Investment. By investing in these sec-
tors, the government is working to build a more resilient and sustainable infrastructure system
that can better withstand climate change impacts.
The 4RF Strategy's emphasis on livelihoods support, including livestock restocking, cash com-
pensation, horticulture support for farmers, climate-smart agriculture, youth internships, and
natural resource restoration and reforestation, aligns with the strategic priority of Systemic
Resilience and Adaptation. Lastly, the 4RF Strategy's focus on natural resource restoration and
reforestation connects with the strategic priority of Nature-based Solutions. By investing in the
restoration of ecosystems and the promotion of green infrastructure, the strategy aims to
protect communities from climate extremes like floods and enhance overall climate resilience.
Moreover, in response to the Post Flood 2022 scenario, the Government of Pakistan has initiat-
ed several flagship projects aimed at enhancing resilience, rehabilitating infrastructure, and
ensuring food security for its citizens. Among these initiatives are:
Promotion of Olive Cultivation on Commercial National Peste Des Petits Ruminants (PPR)
5 Scale in Pakistan (Phase-II) 14 Eradication Programme
Microbes for Supplementing Fertilizers and Locust Emergency and Food Security Project
8 Inducing Abiotic Stresses in Crops. 17 (LEAFS)
71
crops in urban environments. In the short term, the project will develop and pilot tunnel farming
and hydroponic systems for fruits and vegetables with micro-irrigation, alongside rooftop and
kitchen gardening for both household and commercial applications. Medium-term actions
include professional training, capacity building, and upscaling strategies, as well as conduct-
ing economic and food security analyses and evaluating vertical farming as a climate change
adaptation and mitigation tool. In the long term, the initiative aims to develop business models
through full life-cycle analysis (LCA), investigate vertical farming derivatives such as multi-story
and multi-crop greenhouses, explore rack-stacked designs for optimal solar exposure, identify
employment opportunities in the sector, and extend the range of crop types while optimizing
response to controlled variables like LED lighting, temperature, humidity, and CO2 levels.
17. NATIONAL PROGRAM FOR ANIMAL DISEASE SURVEILLANCE IN PAKISTAN
The project aims to improve the country's preparedness for future locust and other invasive
pest attacks by enhancing the capacity of the plant protection department and strengthening
the national food security system. The project is comprised of 5 main components: pest surveil-
lance/early warning, preparedness, and control capacity enhancement, strengthening of
national food security management system, project management, monitoring, and evaluation,
contingent emergency response component, and livelihood protection and rehabilitation.
National Water Policy Implementation Framework Water Harvesting, Water Pricing and Ground Water
1 and National Water Conservation Strategy 8 Recharge
Moreover, for a holistic and integrated handling of floods, National Flood Protection Plan-IV is
being updated through Asian Development Bank (ADB) on the directions of the Prime Minister
to incorporate lessons learnt from devastating floods of 2022.
CONCLUSION
The Government of Pakistan is implementing various initiatives and projects to address the challeng-
es of climate change, water scarcity, and food security. These initiatives cover a wide range of areas,
including climate change adaptation and mitigation, decision support systems, efficient use of natu-
ral resources, climate-resilient agriculture, and watershed management. Moreover, the government
has allocated substantial funds for water sector projects and introduced flagship initiatives in
response to emerging climate scenarios. Collectively, these efforts demonstrate the Government of
Pakistan's commitment to sustainable development, environmental protection, and securing the
well-being of its citizens in the face of a changing climate, increasing water scarcity, low water use
efficiency, lack of water conservation and food insecurity. Continued investment and innovation in
these initiatives will be crucial for ensuring long-term resilience and sustainability in the country.
75
ENERGY
Secure, Sustainable and Affordable
INTRODUCTION
Energy is an integral part of the economic order of Pakistan. Infrastructure and networks of roads, rail,
optical fiber, electricity grid, and oil and gas pipelines are the building blocks of the supply chains for
effective and efficient delivery of public and private service delivery. Supply of reliable, secure, efficient
and affordable electricity is one of the primary drivers for sustainable development of Pakistan.
Energy shortfalls have had a significant impact on Pakistan's socio-economic stability over the last
few decades. The supply-demand deficit reached its peak in 2012, with a staggering 66201 MW
shortfall, accounting for 50% of the generation capacity. As a result, policy discussions shifted to
focus primarily on generation and supply-side interventions. Between 2013 and 2018, Pakistan
undertook ambitious capacity additions, adding 12,2302 MW to the energy mix. Notably, the design
and implementation of the RLNG (Regasified Liquefied Natural Gas) supply chain in a short time
period was a remarkable milestone in Pakistan's energy mix. The share of RLNG in the energy mix
experienced tremendous growth, serving the demands of various power plants in addition to meeting
the needs of fertilizer plants and the industrial sector.
In addition to electricity generation projects, flagship project of ±660 KV HVDC Transmission Line
Project from Matiari to Lahore for evacuation of 4000 MW capacity has enhanced the grid infrastruc-
ture. Distribution, however, remains least invested/upgraded with overloading of the power transform-
ers and events of burning/blasting of the distribution transformers in different DISCOs show no res-
pite 3. A flagship project of Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) is in process that will help in curb-
ing AT&C losses and overloading issues at the distribution value chain of electricity.
Transmission and distribution infrastructure for natural gas/ RLNG shows a similar story with empha-
sis and bottlenecks at the generation. For decades, natural gas stood up as the leading energy source
to serve sectoral and power generation needs. Due to the continuous depletion of the local gas
reserves, the supply gap is filled with imported LNG to meet the rising demand. The trend shows that
we are moving towards non-indigenous fuel sources and thus are more exposed to the international
price shocks. Fertilizer sector remain one of the top beneficiary of this fuel source. Rationalizing subsi-
dies and prices are integral for efficient utilization of this resource.
Oil and its associated products including but not limited to motor spirit (MS) and high speed diesel
(HSD) are concentrated with transport sector and have shown continuous growth in demand. Furnace
oil (FO) have been tried to phase out from electricity generation sector. Pakistan only produces small
fraction of the crude oil whereas the requirements/expected demand of the petroleum products (MS
and HSD) may require more refineries in the supply chain. However, with the onset of electric vehicles
this demand may be substituted by electricity. To summarize, this supply resource is highly indigenous
and has dented the import bill.
1
NEPRA State of Industry Report 2015.
2
https://www.finance.gov.pk/survey/chapters_19/Economic_Survey_2018_19.pdf
3
NEPRA State of Industry Report 2021-22
77
SITUATION ANALYSIS
Energy sector is an intricate and interdependent web with stakeholders ranging from regulators (NE-
PRA/OGRA), suppliers/generators to demand centers (industrial, domestic, commercial etc). A
number of institutions are involved in sector level or operation level planning of Energy Sector. The
solution for many problems in energy sector lies in coordination and integration of energy planning
capabilities within the country. Fast changing dynamics of Energy Sector warrants institutionalizing
the Integrated Energy Planning (IEP) capability within the country. IEP supports analysis-based energy
decision making for the best interest of Pakistan as a whole, across energy sub-sectors. For energy
decisions to be prudent across all levels of multiple energy forms, they must align with commonly
accepted goals that are pursued through coordination and consistent policies, plans, processes and
implementations.
Energy shortfalls have largely set the narrative of energy policy in Pakistan. To reiterate energy is cen-
tral to economic growth whereas energy efficiency and conservation (EE&C) is a prerequisite for eco-
nomic development. EE&C is crucial for meeting the challenges of customer affordability and sector
financial viability. Demand/Load control programs also come under this thematic area.
Ensuring both the diversification and indigenization of energy sources continues to be of prime
importance. Coal is the primary indigenous energy source of Pakistan. Thar has the largest coal
reserves in the country which has been actively developed in recent years. The first Thar plant, having
capacity of 660 MW, became operational in the first quarter of FY2020. Currently, the overall electrici-
ty generation from coal has reached to 5280 MW. Thar coal is contributing 1,320 MW, while imported
coal contribution in electricity generation is 3,960 MW which is around 75 percent of the total elec-
tricity generation from coal in the country. Electricity generation configuration is relying heavily on the
imported coal and this trend is likely to change as units based on the Thar field are added to the elec-
tricity generation mix . A snapshot of installed capacity and generation mix .
In order to resolve the energy crisis, the installed capacity of electricity was increased by 30% from
2013-2018. Government of Pakistan (GoP) has announced different policies to ensure the smooth
supply of energy to the general public and to boost economic growth. These polices include “The
National Power Policy 2013”, “The Power Generation Policy 2015” and “Alternative and Renewable
Energy Policy 2019”. The National Power Policy 2013 aimed to develop an efficient and consum-
78
er-centric power generation, transmission and distribution system that could meet the needs of the
people and boost the economy of the country in a sustainable and affordable manner. The main
targets included complete elimination of load shedding, decreasing the aver- age cost of electricity
generation, decrease in the transmission & distribution losses, increase in the revenue collection and
a reduction in the time required for decision making at the ministry level or other related departments.
Alternative and Renewable Energy Policy main objective was to provide supportive environment for
renewable power projects, increase the share of green energy capacity to 20 percent by 2025 and 30
percent by 2030 through attracting private capital in the area of green energy. Consequently, this
nudge has shown positive results. The graphical representation of installed capacity and bifurcation
of Renewables for FY 2020-21 and FY 2021-22 is given below:
NTDC has transmission capacity of 22350 MVA over 500 kV transmission network and 31060 MVA
over 220 kV transmission network. IGCEP 2022-31 targets inclusion of 60% Renewable (39 % Hydro
and 21 % Variable renewables) with almost 70 GW generation capacity. Relying on renewable and
indigenous resources will need revamping of NTDC system as well as Distribution from 132 kV to
11kV to meter.
STRATEGIC VISION
Diversification and Indigenization of Energy Mix: The Government of Pakistan (GoP) is inter-
ested in diversifying its energy mix by investing in renewable energy sources like wind, solar,
and hydro power. Likewise, Thar's indigenous sources will be utilized in an efficient and envi-
ronmentally responsible manner. By doing so, the country can reduce its dependence on
imported fuels and promote sustainable energy development.
Energy Efficiency and Conservation: The GoP is currently working on enhancing energy
efficiency across all sectors, including industry, transportation, and households. This effort
aims to reduce energy consumption, cut costs, and promote environmental sustainability.
Infrastructure development: To improve the efficiency and reliability of the energy sector, the
GoP is exploring various options for infrastructure development. This includes upgrading
supply chain networks for electricity, gas and oil. Smart grid technologies and integrated plan-
ning are essential.
79
Private Sector Investment: In an effort to encourage sustainable energy development, Paki-
stan has incentivized private sector involvement in the energy sector and created an invest-
ment-friendly environment. The involvement of the private sector will bring in capital and
expertise necessary for supporting sustainable energy development.
Regional Cooperation: The Government of Pakistan is committed to strengthening regional
cooperation in the energy sector by exploring opportunities for cross-border energy trade and
collaboration with neighboring countries. By doing so, the country can reduce energy costs,
promote regional stability, and facilitate regional development.
Pakistan Vision 2025 recognizes that sufficient, reliable, clean and cost-effective availability of
energy– for now and the future – is indispensable to ensure sustainable economic growth and devel-
opment.
Short-Term and Medium terms recommendations:
Operationalize CTBCM (Competitive Trading Bilateral Contract Market) to move to a
multi-buyer market.
Swiftly pursue the development of distributed generation and renewable energy
zones/parks with solar and wind generation to reduce generation costs.
Increase of non-hydel renewables share.
Effective management to reduce high T&D losses.
Efective governance to resolve the circular debt.
Accelerated exploration & production activities in oil and gas.
Reduce UFG (Unaccounted For Gas) losses.
Upgradation of transmission capacity to improve Power Evacuation Capacity.
FLAGSHIP INITIATIVES
BUILDING AGRICULTURE
SECTOR SECTOR
80
INDUSTRIAL SECTOR TOTAL FINANCIAL IMPACT
$114 MILLION
MEPS FOR P E R A N N U M
INDUSTRIAL MOTORS
$4.7 BILLION
P E R A N N U M
MEPS for
Energy Conservation
Air- Conditioner 1 4
Building Codes
and Refrigerator
Implementing the MEPS for gas based domestic The implementation of the Energy Conservation
2 appliances offer an annual energy saving of 165 4 Building Codes on new commercial buildings
MMBTU which reflects a financial impact of 6610 alone offer a 40% reduction in the energy
million USD/annum consumption of these buildings.
81
TRANSPORT SECTOR TOTAL FINANCIAL IMPACT
$1.55 BILLION
P E R A N N U M
1 liters per year having annual financial impact of 1.5 billion USD. Tune-up
program of gas based industrial furnaces and HFO based Captive Gensets
offer annual energy saving of 40 billion CFt in gas, 80,000 tons of HFO, and
800,000 tons in coal.
2
Launching a tractor tune up centre programme: Annual energy saving of 135
million liters of diesel with an annual financial impact of 140 million USD on
the economy.on the economy.
3
Development and implementation of fuel economy standards for Cars,
Buses, and Trucks: Annual energy savings of 819 million liters of diesel
with an overall financial saving of 832 million USD to the economy.
30% shift to Electric Vehicles (2, 3, and 4 wheelers) by 2030: Saving of fuel
(diesel & motor spirit combined) is estimated as 1 billion liters per annum by
considering 5% penetration of EVs. This shall result in financial savings of 970
million USD.
4
AGRICULTURE SECTOR
TOTALFINANCIAL
TOTAL FINANCIALIMPACT
IMPACT
$629 MILLION
P E R A N N U M
Diesel Tube-wells Tune up Programme
Annual energy saving of 305 million liters of diesel Solar Water Pumping
with an annual financial saving impact of 315
If the existing water pumping (shal-
million USD on the economy.
low) is shifted to solar water pump-
ing, 2520 million liters of diesel
Electric Tube-wells Efficiency Improvement Programme fuel is saved per annum registering
a financial saving of 260 million
Annual energy saving of 447 million liters of USD.
diesel with an annual financial impact of 54
million USD.
82
POWER SECTOR
NATIONAL ELECTRICITY PLAN
The 5-year NE-Plan provides a strategic framework for implementing the electricity policy recommen-
dations and monitoring their achievements. The implementation of this plan is key to achieving the
stated goals. It provides an overarching framework to the stakeholders to ensure integrated planning,
institutional reforms, adoption of modern technologies, and complementing legal and regulatory
frameworks. Pakistan can reap the multiple benefits of a secure, equitable, and sustainable energy
system.
ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE
TAPI pipeline and North-South Gas pipeline infrastructure are flagship regional cooperation projects.
Pipeline infrastructure to gain access via Gwadar to Europe for LNG exports. ISGS also plans for
underground gas storages using depleted fields.
84
EQUITY
Education, Health, Population and
Development of Least-Developed
Regions
INTRODUCTION
The pandemic's recent health crisis and economic tumults have made it challenging to
achieve equity in health and education. Notwithstanding the intensity of the issues, the
challenges are still salvageable. The framework covers education from ECE to Ph.D. levels
to achieve equity in education. Equity in education allows students to learn what they
want or need to know, ensuring we will leave no one behind due to one’s gender, ethnici-
ty, region, or socioeconomic position. Introducing equity in education aims to ensure that
inclusivity and education are for all. Everyone from any background must be able to read,
write, learn, and possess the skills required in the modern world.
To achieve equity in the health sector, the framework is designed so that everyone can
access a fair and just healthcare system, covering physical, mental, and psychological
healthcare needs. The government will achieve this by overcoming social, economic, and
other impediments.
The 5E Framework can achieve equity by addressing the needs of the poorest regions
and upgrading them up to the mark of modern development. To do so, the MoPD&SI has
started its 20 poorest districts upgrades. The project aims to eliminate the regional dis-
parities that exist in the country and strengthen national unity.
Equity cannot be achieved without access; both of these components ensure social jus-
tice and a way forward toward a socially just society. Persons with disabilities and trans-
gender people are the most excluded segments in our community. To limelight persons
with disabilities, the framework aims to formulate a national policy on PWDs and
upgrade national special education.
86
SITUATION ANALYSIS
Pakistan’s population is projected to increase to over 274 million by 2030 and 367 mil-
lion by 2050 . Although Pakistan’s population growth rate has declined steadily over the
years, the country’s annual population growth rate of 2.4% is still higher than that of
neighboring countries (India, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka) . Over two-thirds of the coun-
try’s population are people below the age of 30, which makes Pakistan one of the
youngest countries in the world, and the second youngest in the South Asian region after
Afghanistan. Over the course of coming three decades, the relatively high fertility rates
will continue to drive the ongoing population growth.
The 18th Constitutional Amendment devolved the function of population planning to the
provinces. While provinces have taken a number of steps to improve population planning,
a coordinated and holistic approach is required to address this serious challenge. The
need for a well-coordinated federal approach is reinforced by the negative “externalities”
of high population growth rate in the form of low real wages, rising poverty, pollution,
insecurity etc. In this regard, a National Taskforce was established but was not made
effectively operational. The current Government plans to reinvigorate the National Task
Force on Population Planning and implement the National Action Plan for Population
Control.
High population growth rate over the years has strained and affected access to afforda-
ble and quality health and education services. Although Pakistan has introduced and
implemented a number of measures to improve access to health and education services
and improve the quality and affordability of these services for all citizens, the pace of pro-
gress remains slow. In this regard, the incorporation of Article 25A in the Constitution
enshrined universal access to education as a fundamental human right.
Despite making progress over the years, Pakistan continues to face several developmen-
tal challenges. People across various regional and social groups have unequal access to
health and education. In 2018-2019, Pakistan’s national poverty rate was 21.5 percent,
but it was 21.6 percent for Sindh, 27 percent for KPK and 40.7 percent for Balochistan.
Pakistan’s progress on development indicators lags behind other developing countries.
UNICEF estimates that Pakistan has 22.8 million out of school children . There are more
boys enrolled than girls at every stage of education, placing women at a great disadvan-
87
tage. In Sindh, 58 percent of girls of school going age are out of school, while the number
is even higher at 78 percent out of school girls in Balochistan. The quality of education
needs critical reforms too, as there is a huge gap between the skills and values needed
and what the country’s education system is currently producing.
Pakistan’s healthcare provision is lagging behind other nations as well. An average Paki-
stani has a life expectancy of only 66 years, ranking 150th in the world. High child mortal-
ity rate is a major contributor to Pakistan's low average life expectancy. Out of every 1000
children born, 65 children die before their fifth birthday. The social taboo surrounding
reproductive healthcare has resulted in soaring maternal mortality rates and lack of
family planning. Mental health issues often go neglected as there are only 0.19 psychia-
trists per 0.1 million people . The need for resilient mental health provision has become
much more pertinent and pronounced in the wake of global pandemic and the recent
floods in the country. A significant overarching challenge is the lack of resources. Paki-
stan has 1.6 medical staff personnel per 1000 people, while the WHO recommended
number is 2.5.
Since the adoption of the 18th Constitutional Amendment, provincial governments have
the primary responsibility for delivering quality and affordable health and education ser-
vices to citizens. The Federal Government provides thought-leadership and fiscal support
to the provinces. Moreover, the Federal Government also provides support to less-devel-
oped regions and provinces in addressing key issues related to access to, and quality of,
schooling and healthcare. Furthermore, the Federal Government is also introducing
holistic reforms in education and health delivery in federally-governed territories and
seeks to set benchmarks and standards and model delivery systems.
The government’s vision is universal education and healthcare provision across Pakistan.
Pakistanis need equal and improved access to services. The strategic objective is to
improve the health and learning and attainment of all Pakistanis, particularly women and
children, by providing universal access to affordable, quality essential health and educa-
tion services, delivered through a resilient and responsive health and education systems.
In the education and health sectors, the government will particularly focus on fulfilling
88
fulfilling the needs of the social groups who have traditionally been discriminated
against due to their age, class, gender, physical ability or region. It will serve the govern-
ment’s goal of will reducing inequality, hence strengthening national unity and bringing
the nation closer to achieving its sustainable development goals.
The following short-term and medium-term goals are critical for achieving this vision:
FLAGSHIP INITIATIVES
LEAST-
EDUCATION HEALTH & DEVELOPED
POPULATION REGIONS
89
1. EDUCATION
Early Childhood Education (ECE)
and Foundational Learning 01 07 Model Teacher Training Institute
INITIATIVE(S)
National Virtual Schooling System 04 10 Deworming of School Children
Financing of Pakistan’s education technology ecosystem will ultimately rely on the consistent
commitment of federal and provincial education budgets. Provisional strategies can be achieved
with the support of development partner funding and alternative financing.
Open our higher education system to tuition paying students from advanced countries like UK,
US, France, Germany, Gulf and Central Asian States.
To kickstart the process, it is proposed that Higher Education may be declared or given the
status of an Industry.
To facilitate the process of internationalization, “Study in Pakistan and HE Internationaliza-
tion” Program may introduce extending scholarship to foreign students for education and
training in Pakistan. This will not only internationalize HE, improve rankings of universities
but also build Pakistan’s soft image and a HE International destination.
For International Undergraduate Students change VISA Regimes, develop user-friendly
admission policies, and participate in Tuition Exchange Programs among universities.
Junior Year abroad programs for undergraduates will enable students to learn about Herit-
age and Pakistani Culture, Gandhara Civilization. Undergraduate students can enroll in
courses of their major also.
Open Online Course/Programs through EdEx/Coursera. HEC is also developing a MOOCs
platform for offering online courses for both domestic and international students.
Collaborative Globally significant Research at Graduate/Post-Graduate level in Climate
Change, Agriculture and Food Security with universities in EU, UK, USA, Central Asian and
Gulf States.
93
2. HEALTH AND POPULATION PLANNING
Universal Health Coverage Reforms Reinvigoration of the National Task
01 (UHC) in Pakistan 09 Force on Population
94
UHC target under SDG3 for 2030 is 80%. Work on prioritization of Inter-sectoral policies has
started to work with other sectors, which have the potential to target half of the burden of
disease. The draft Intersectoral policies action plan prepared. Other UHC reforms include:
Development of Joint LHW Strategic plan.
Training of Provincial Master trainers on revised LHW curriculum and training of facili-
ty-level master trainers on LHW revised curriculum.
Non-Communicable diseases (NCD) Action Plan has been developed in line with UHC
and approved by the Inter-ministerial Health and Population Forum. Beside action plan,
National Tobacco Control Strategy is developed and approved.
UHC Situation Analysis (2022) was completed and UHC index was estimated at national,
provincial/ area and district level. Trend in the UHC index is as below:
Gilgit Baltistan 35.8 39.3 41.0 42.6 43.5 45.2 48.5 +35.5%
Islamabad district has been identified as the first model healthcare district for the implementa-
tion of different UHC related reforms and lesson learning. Following are the key reform initiatives
towards the implementation of UHC reforms in the ICT are as follows:
Geographic mapping of all public and private sector health facilities.
Adaptation of WHO’s Services Access and Readiness Assessment (SARA) tool and survey
in Islamabad to identify gaps.
Testing of digital health information system at community and PHC centre level.
Complete merger of health and population welfare facilities and staff (with training of
FWC workers as Health, Population & Nutrition counsellors).
LHW curriculum in line with UHC / EPHS at community level has been revised and training
of new 850 LHWs to start in 2023.
UHC Monitoring & Evaluation Framework for Islamabad is being developed. Lessons
learnt will be used for developing UHC M&E framework at provincial level initially for 40
districts.
Joint Annual Review & Planning Exercise (District Health Planning) activity held in April
2023.
Beside upgradation of already existing health facilities, a number of new health facilities
are in the construction phase in the area of G-13, Bari Imam and Bara Khau of Islamabad
Capital Territory.
During floods, Mental Health and Psychosocial support (MHPSS) sessions are being started in
Lasbella initially. Sessions for other districts of Balochistan and Sindh have been planned. Mental
health education has been incorporated in revised Lady health Worker’s training curriculum to
promote awareness and early referral at community level. GoP has adopted WHO school mental
health guidelines to conduct online training course for teachers on early identification and man-
agement of mental health problems in school children. In this regard, trainings of teachers from
different districts of Punjab were carried out. There is need to collaborate with Ministry of Federal
Education for Development and inclusion of Life skills syllabus, increase Media campaigns with
separate media messages for Mental health and drug use prevention abnd also establishment
of Telehealth Centers.
08 FAMILY PLANNING
Pakistan is importing all of its contraceptives at a relatively higher cost. Hence, this initiative aims
to locally manufacture contraceptives. For this purpose, after identifying the relevant stakehold-
ers, a RTC will be conducted to develop a policy on the promotion of contraceptive manufactur-
ing.
09 REINVIGORATION OF THE NATIONAL TASK FORCE ON POPULATION
With the President of Pakistan as its chair, the Federal Task Force (FTF) comprises of Provincial
and Regional Chief Ministers, Provincial and Regional Chief Secretaries, and key Federal Minis-
ters in addition to relevant officials. The FTF in pursuance of the CCI Recommendations is respon-
sible for taking the Family Planning /Reproductive Health agenda forward and operates with the
clear terms of reference.
10 IMPLEMENTATION OF NATIONAL ACTION PLAN (NAP) ON POPULATION PLANNING
The NAP spells out the actions required to implement each of the CCI Recommendation with
timelines, budget, output /impact indicators as an evidence to the implementation. The NAP
focuses on the following key areas; governance and accountability; ensure universal access to
FP/RH services; finances; legislation; advocacy and communications, curriculum and training;
contraceptive commodity security and involving Ulema.
Pakistan has made its FP2030 Commitments inline with its national goals agreed under the CCI
Recommendations and the targets set for the National Action Plan to strengthen family planning
focus fully following the eight key CCI recommended areas. Giving due consideration that Popu-
lation is a cross-cutting issue, which has its linkages with most important issues relating to pov-
erty, health, illiteracy, environment, climate change, economic instability, etc, the government of
Pakistan has developed a New National Narrative with its theme to adopt the middle of the
Course “Tawazun” and decide the family size according to the resources, enabling to fulfill the
fundamental rights of all.
98
families and eventually targeting universal families and providing coverage eventually to more
than two hundred thirty (230) million population across Pakistan. Currently, program is providing
services to more than one hundred seventy (170) million population of Punjab, Khyber Pakh-
tunkhwa (KP), Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK), Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), Islamabad Capital Territory
(ICT) and Tharparkar – Sindh.
So far, the program has not been implemented in Balochistan and Sindh (other than District -
Tharparkar). However, Balochistan Government has started working and taking necessary steps
to implement this social health protection initiative in all districts. At current level of maturity, the
program is providing financial protection for indoor health care coverage only.
In Federal Government the program is managed under the administrative control of Ministry of
National health Services, Regulations and Coordination and currently financed through PSDP. In
each participating province (Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa) the program is managed by
health department with different source of financing.
100
3. LEAST-DEVELOPED REGIONS
KP
(MPI-Based)
PUNJAB
1 Districts
BALOCHISTAN
11 Districts
SINDH
5 Districts
102
IMPLEMENTATION AND
M&E FRAME-WORK
FOR 5ES
IMPLEMENTATION FRAME-WORK FOR 5Es
“The true measure/gauge of success for the Planning Commission (PC) is not for whom we
plan/pledge/inculcate resources in the economy, but it is how much resources injects in to those
areas/sectors which actually needs the most.”
Better planning, its implementation followed by robust and integrated monitoring and evaluation
(M&E) framework enhance the contribution of Planning Commission by establishing clear linkages
among all the stakeholders for socio-economic uplift of the country.
Sound Implementation, Monitoring and Evaluation can assist the organization to extract relevant
information from past and ongoing activities that can be used on the basis for programmatic fine-tun-
ing, reorientation and future planning. Without effective planning, monitoring and evaluation, it would
be pretty impossible to adjudge that the progress and success and it can be determined upon the
lenses of M&E. An effective Monitoring & Evaluation (M&E) system is essential to manage the devel-
opment outcome. Such system will help to enable a portfolio of public sector projects to be closely
aligned to the national vision and help in the execution of the projects at the federal and provincial
levels. The M&E Framework, is designed to inculcate a structured approach for monitoring and evalua-
tion of public sector policies, service delivery and development interventions.
To operationalize the Implementation framework, it is important that all the Federal Ministries and
Provincial/Area governments should:
104
TIMELINES
KEY INITIATIVES / RESPON-
5Es KEY AREA
DELIVERABLE
OBJECTIVES
SIBILITY
IMPLEMENTED UNDER IMPLEMENTATION TIME (MONTHS)
Enabling And Tariff Rationalization -------- Tariff Rationalization Study on the Improve textiles product
Study. 12-24 MOC
Conducive value chain of technical textiles. diversification.
Business
Environment.
National To maintain preferential market
-------- Under establishment at the Fed/Prov. 6 access for export oriented
Compliance Centre. MOC
under GSP+ agreement.
SME Cluster
Development
Plans For GSP Scheme To capture European market
Initiated 2024-34 for the upcoming 12
High Potential GSP Scheme with EU. will expire in and to get benefit from MOC
GSP scheme.
Sectors. 12/23. preferential trade terms.
Trade development Initiation of market access activities To capture ASEAN market and
1. EXPORT
conference with -------- in the ASEAN region will be kicked 6 to get benefit from preferential MOC
ASEAN Countries. off in the coming month. trade terms.
Up-skilling/ Reskilling
Strategic HR For Digital -------- Launching of massive open online 12 -------- Educa-
Thrust Area 1: Ecosystem. courses. tion/HEC
Accelerating
Growth of
Empowering Youth, Women and Others
Human
2. E-Pakistan and Empowerment
Implementation of holistic
2. E-Pakistan and Empowerment
National Cyber -------- Improvement and revisit of cyber 6 national cyber security MoIT&T
security Initiative. security policy, rules and regulations. initiative with a persuasive
national digital ecosystem.
Empowerment Of
Strategic More skill oriented and MoIPC &
Youth, Women And -------- Initiation of ICT for girls programme, 6-12
Thrust Area 3: empowered youth and MoITT
Under- Privileged software coding in line with SDGs.
Ease of Doing women.
Segments.
Business and
Access to
Funds. Provision of enabling environment
for companies to setup VC funds
for start-ups and SMEs. More companies will register
Venture Capital -------- Provision of enabling environment and start functioning thus MoIT&T
6-12
for International and domestic boosting the employment
investor. opportunities.
Provision of bank loans and
financing facilities for SMEs.
Reforming and
Implementing Legal
Provisions for Devising of Acts and Laws for More confidence on the
Intellectual Property, -------- Intellectual Property Rights, Data 6 Investor. MoL/MoC
Copyright Protection, Protection ATC.
and Contract
Agreements.
Economic and
development
Green Growth policies with a MoPDSI/
-------- -------- 6 --------
Framework. focus on MoCC
climate impact
technologies.
TIMELINES
KEY INITIATIVES / RESPON-
5Es KEY AREA
DELIVERABLE
OBJECTIVES
SIBILITY
IMPLEMENTED UNDER IMPLEMENTATION TIME (MONTHS)
Plans to
strengthen
pollution
control.
Use climate-
smart services
and NBS.
Resilient Green MoPDSI/
Cities. -------- infrastructure, -------- 12-36 -------- MoCC
engage
communities.
Water and Food Security
Promote green
infrastructure
3. Environment
for flood
control and
ground water
recharge.
Modernizing
irrigation and
Food -------- drainage -------- -------- Ministry
12-36 of Food
Security. Prioritizing
climate-smart
agriculture.
Sustainable groundwater
governance.
Water Rationalized water pricing/agricul- --------
-------- -------- 12-36 M/O WR
Governance. ture incentives.
Green infrastructure for
groundwater recharge.
107
TIMELINES
KEY INITIATIVES / RESPON-
5Es KEY AREA
DELIVERABLE
OBJECTIVES
SIBILITY
IMPLEMENTED UNDER IMPLEMENTATION TIME (MONTHS)
Improve Education
The framework is designed to
access to Mo
-------- -------- 12-36 get access of fair and just
healthcare Health and health care system covering Education/
and Population physical, mental, and MoH
education psychological health care
services. Least-Developed needs.
Regions
Enhance the
quality of
existing
health and
education
services.
Enhance
access to
family
planning
services and
increase
contraceptive
prevalence.
Increase the
Education, Health, Population and Development of Least-Developed Regions
uptake of
education by
girls at the
primary level.
Increase the
provision of
mental health
and
psychological
support.
Support
5. Equity
deworming
and
immunization
initiatives.
Promote
awareness
about sexual
and
reproductive
health and
rights.
Promote
awareness
about
population
planning and
control as a
core
element of all
public
communica-
tion and
development
strategies
Improve
socioeco-
nomic
conditions of
the poorest
regions of the
country
through
targeted
interventions
and
affirmative
action.
108
M&E TYPE KEY CRITERIA POINT(S)
Field based monitoring / At-least 10% of selected PSDP projects, worth Rs. 2 billion to Rs. 10 billion.
Inspection / validation
MONITORING
At-least 20% of selected PSDP projects with 60% completion, worth Rs. 10 billion or more, and with
Third-Party Monitoring (TPM) emphasis on: large-scale infrastructure dev projects; projects which are slow- progressing, either physical
or financial progress; and special initiatives.
Formative, mid-term Ongoing projects, having more than 3 years of tenure / life Projects, worth Rs. 2 billion or more with
evaluation emphasis on: projects having major contribution on national infrastructure, foreign funding projects, and
projects which are of strategic nature and/or of political importance.
Expectedly 10-15% of the projects completing in 2022-23, worth Rs. 2 billion or more, for which PC-IV will
EX-POST EVALUATION
Summative, project end-evalua- be submitted to Projects having perpetual liabilities, and/or related future initiatives. Projects having major
tions using non-experimental contribution on national infrastructure, foreign funding projects, and projects which are of strategic nature
approaches and/or of political importance.
Reviews / Assessments Any project/ programme, meeting above criteria for which quick review/ assessment (mainly qualitative)
is required.
109
Ministry of Planning Development and Special Initiatives
P Block, Pak Secretariat, Islamabad, Pakistan
www.pc.gov.pk