Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Microsoft Word - 3 corrosionFINAL 13-09
Microsoft Word - 3 corrosionFINAL 13-09
Table of content
3.2 Why do some materials corrode faster than other ones? 3.4
Corrosion is the breakdown of a material through a chemical reaction with the surrounding
environment.
For initiation and propagation of a corrosion attack a so called “corrosion cell” must be
established. A corrosion cell is an electrical circuit, with transport of electrons and ions
between two differently charged electrodes. A typical corrosion cell will consist of:
Figure 3.1
A corrosion cell
Cathode:
Steel 2+ - Anode:
Zn = Zn + 2 e
Zinc
O2
½ O2 + H2 O + 2e - =
- 2OH -
When metals are immersed in a liquid (like seawater) the liquid itself will be the electrolyte.
An electrochemical reaction may also take place above the waterline as an electrolyte can
be formed by moisture in the atmosphere (high humidity, condensation or dew). Moisture
or water can easily collect impurities or salt from the steel surface or from the atmosphere,
and together they form a conductive electrolyte.
Figure 3.2
The corrosion process on steel.
W ater
Steel
F e (O H ) 2
OH ¯ Fe 2+
C athode A node
e¯
C athode: A node:
O 2 + 2 H 2O + e ¯ → 4 OH ¯ Fe → Fe 2+ +e¯
As seen from the figure above the material dissolves when corrosion occurs. A large portion
or the resulting corrosion products will remain on the metal surface even though some of it
may be transported away by electrolytes with high flow velocities. Thus, in most cases we
The explanation is found by looking at the energy levels of the various materials. All
materials have a desire to be at a lowest possible energy level. For most metallic materials
this is as a mineral, oxide or similar and not in the form of the metal or alloy we use for
construction purposes. In nature only a few pure metals are found. These metals are called
“Noble metals” and do not need to go through energy consuming purification or a refining
process before taken into use. Thus, the energy level of the Noble metals is almost the
same as the level in their most stable form found in nature.
For Magnesium, Zinc, Aluminium, iron and steel the situation is quite different. These
metals (or their alloys) are not found free in nature. For example iron and steel are
extracted from iron ore in a blast furnace or electro oven where the iron ore together with
coal or coke is heated up to a very high temperature. To produce iron or steel large
amounts of energy is introduced. Thus, the energy levels of the materials we actually take
into use are much higher than the natural energy level of the metals found in nature.
Nature does not look upon the new energy level as very favourable and starts a process of
bringing the metals back to its’ origin. The metals will decompose (corrode) and energy will
be released; a corrosion process has started.
In a very simplified model you may say that the more energy required to produce a metal or
alloy the higher is the driving force to start a corrosion process. As seen later alloys can be
ranked to find out which one of them are stable and which ones are likely to corrode.
Figure 3.3
Energy levels of materials through a manufacturing process.
R e a c tio n b e tw e e n th e m a te r ia l a n d
th e s u r r o u n d in g e n v ir o n m e n t ta k e s p la c e
P la te s , p ip e s ,
p r o f ile s , e tc .
g W
g y r in at
e r c tu e
n
E u fa O r /h
xy u
an ge m i
M n d it
y
R a w m a t e r ia l
Iron ore R u st
T h e p r e s e n c e o f w a t e r / h u m id it y a n d O x y g e n
is a p r e - r e q u is it e f o r c o r r o s io n o f s t e e l
As mentioned above, the energy model is a simplification. Some materials can be much
more stable than one should expect. The main reason for this is usually one of the two
listed below (or a combination):
Also the opposite effect is frequently experienced: A material suffers corrosion where
inertness is expected. There are many reasons for these negative surprises. The most
occurring ones are:
To predict the corrosion rate of a material is very difficult. The reason being that the
amount of influencing parameters and variables are enormous. Also, the rate of corrosion
may increase or diminish, depending on build up of corrosion products and how the
environment and operating conditions change with time.
It should also be noted that variable corrosiveness could be experienced for one type of
electrolyte. For example the corrosiveness of seawater varies to some degree from place to
place in the oceans. Important factors like salinity, temperature and microbiological
activity/growth will vary both with geographical location and season.
Acidity/pH: The pH scale (0-14) is used as a measure of acidity. The scale is based on the
concentration of hydrogen ions in a solution. A value of 1 refers to the highest acidity, while
14 is the most basic (alkaline) and 7 is neutral. In general corrosion will increase with
increasing acidity (low pH values), but high degree of alkalinity may also promote corrosion.
For example Aluminium is only passive in close to neutral solutions (pH 5-8).
• Humidity
• Temperature
• Content of salts
• Content of air pollution, including soot and dust particles
Figure 3.4
The corrosion rate will increase with increasing humidity
C o r ro sio n ra te
0 20 40 60 80 100
R ela tiv e H u m id ity , %
Finally, the exposure conditions are of great importance to the corrosion velocity. The
effect of rapid corrosion is often due to:
• Conditions that prevent wet metal surfaces from drying (poor ventilation, salts
that attract humidity, etc.)
• The increased conductivity of damp films on metal surfaces (from salts and acid
contaminants)
• Severe environmental stresses, like high pressure and temperature.
• Rapid changes in environmental conditions (e. g. Temperature: High/low
temperature giving thermal stresses of base material and protective systems and
condensation on surfaces)
Selection of a corrosion protection system must be seen in the context of the measures that
the authorities prescribe. These are in most cases of legislative character, requirements
from classification societies or national pollution authorities. Their objectives within
corrosion protection are:
Safety:
DNV Rules for Classification of Ships.
The introduction of double hulls
Requirements for better access and more stringent inspection routines
Restrictions regarding Soft coats in ballast tanks.
The use of light coloured coatings in ballast tanks
Environment:
Oil Pollution Act of 1990, IMO Regulations
Restrictions on the use of Tar containing products and use of soft coats.
General requirements for protecting operators dealing with paint
Precautions regarding use of epoxies
The owner of a structure always has a certain philosophy regarding corrosion protection.
Very often, the philosophy is separated in two phases: Construction stage and operation.
Actually it is important to think about the operation of the unit from the very beginning.
During the design phase of a newbuilding, attention should be paid to the corrosion
protection system that will be employed, in addition to inspection and maintenance
facilities. Regarded in relation to the high costs of subsequent maintenance, particularly if
steel has to be replaced, the correct strategy is to invest in optimal design and corrosion
protection at the newbuilding stage. The significance or criticality of a structure must be
evaluated along with its accessibility, operation and safety.
In many cases the corrosion protection philosophy is a mirror of the operation strategy of
the owner. For example: During production of oil there will be only one owner of the
platform. The design life of an offshore platform can be 25 years. The owner will seek to
reduce the total life time costs to a minimum, meaning that it can be a good investment to
spend money on an “expensive” protection system at the newbuilding stage instead of
carrying out extensive annual maintenance, starting only after a few years of operation. A
shipowner following a ship from “Cradle to grave” is more or less in the same situation,
while other ship owners and management companies who typically hold the ship for a short
period of time. Their prime interest is to keep all costs at a minimum for a given period of
time. The costs for necessary maintenance after the ship has been sold are considered as
irrelevant (but the second hand value is not). Thus, based on the over all operational
philosophy the corrosion protection philosophy is put up. Here are some of the factors to
consider:
C) Costs
As seen from above, the owner’s philosophy will be very closely connected to costs. In
addition it is worth while mentioning a general trend in the market: Owners are more and
more willing to base their cost estimates for a structure on a life time cost evaluation, LCC
(Life Cycle Cost). This is in contrast to what could be seen only a few years ago. Here, the
It is extremely important to closely evaluate the specifications for corrosion protection and
the acceptance criteria for cost, time involved, products used, standard of work performed,
safety, etc.
What is required to prevent iron and steel from rusting? We have seen that air (oxygen)
and an electrolyte / moisture is needed to initiate the corrosion process. If we can prevent
one of these factors from coming into contact with steel, or for that matter, both, we will
prevent rusting as we cut the electrical circuit in the “corrosion cell”. Experience has shown
that the most effective way of doing this is by applying an Organic coating (paint) to the
object. This is the most important and frequently used method of protecting against
corrosion.
Another frequently used method is the cathodic protection. This method actually reverses
the electrical current in the corrosion cell. Thus the dissolution of the metal is stopped,
while another metal introduced in the electrical circuit “sacrifices” itself. This metal (Zinc,
Aluminium or Magnesium) is called a sacrificial anode.
In spite of the fact that both paint and cathodic protection is described in separate sections
of this book a short introduction is given here.
Paints and coatings are the most important method of protecting tanks and holds. Coatings
prevent the steel from coming into contact with the corrosive environment. The quality,
and thus the useful life, of coatings depends primarily on the cleanness and pre-treatment
of steel surfaces, and on prevailing conditions while they are being applied. Other
important requirements concern coating quality, coating thickness and number of coats.
• The barrier effect, which prevents seawater or other corrosive agents from
coming into contact with the surfaces that are to be protected. Example: epoxy
paints.
• The cathode effect: whereby the paint itself acts as a sacrificial anode. Example:
zinc-rich paints.
• Inhibiting / passivating, whereby the paint passivates the surface of the steel
(anodic effect). Example: Paints incorporate rust preventing pigments.
Sacrificial anodes or an impressed current system are used for cathodic protection of
various objects. Cathodic protection only works when both the anodes and the structures
they are to protect are immersed in water.
In addition to the methods mentioned above, corrosion can be reduced by the following
methods:
Inhibitors
The addition of inhibitors (various types of chemicals) to closed pipe systems, ballast water
or cargo can reduce corrosion. The type of inhibitor to use depends on the fluid in the
system and on the type of materials to protect. An inhibitor will either passivate the surface
Inert gas
The primary function of inert gas is to prevent gas explosions, but it can also act as
corrosion protection. Nitrogen, carbon dioxide and ships’ exhaust gases are used as inert
gases. Exhaust gases include both combustion products from a ship’s engines and
hydrocarbon gases from its cargo. “Boil off” can be combusted to carbon dioxide. Exhaust
gases often contain a great deal of oxygen, water vapour, sulphur dioxide or similar and
may in fact increase corrosion. The composition of the exhaust gases must therefore be
checked before being used to reduce corrosion.
Table 3.1
Common forms of corrosion on some materials
Carbon steel
- Uniform corrosion In most corrosive environments where electrolyte is stagnant.
- Uneven corrosion (deep pits) In most corrosive environments at high flow velocities.
- Galvanic corrosion In corrosive environments when coupled to a more noble
material.
- Stress corrosion cracking For high tensile steels. Combination of mechanical impact and
a corrosive environment.
Stainless steels
- Crevice corrosion Particularly in aqueous environments containing aggressive
ions like chlorides. Typical example: Seawater
- Pitting corrosion Particularly in aqueous environments containing aggressive
ions like chlorides. Typical example: Seawater
- Stress corrosion cracking Combination of mechanical impact and a corrosive
environment.
Aluminium
- Pitting corrosion Particularly in aqueous environments containing aggressive
The most common type of corrosion is the uniform or general corrosion. It is normally
characterised by a chemical or electrochemical reaction proceeding uniformly over the
entire surface or over a large area.
A piece of steel, greatly magnified, is found to be full of irregularities and pores. If we look
at steel through a microscope we can also see that the steel consists of different particles or
crystals. A steel plate will consist of a large number of microscopic electrical elements.
When a general type of corrosion attack takes place on a surface, both the anodic and the
cathodic processes are evenly distributed over the metal surface. The energy, which was
originally supplied to the steel during its extraction, is easily released. The steel reacts with
oxygen and moisture and forms rust. The cycle is complete and we are back to the original
lowest energy level in which iron and steel can exist.
A general corrosion attack leads to a reduction of the materials thickness linear with time.
The rate of corrosion can be calculated from corrosion data. For example a corrosion rate of
0.13 mm/year would result in a metal loss of 1.52 mm in a twelve-year period. A corrosion
allowance of 1.59 mm is often adequate to provide 12 years of service in process
exposures, perhaps 25 years in storage tanks. However, the world is rarely ideal and in most
cases an uneven corrosion must be expected. Hence, the corrosion attack can locally be up
to 10 times faster than the theoretical calculated average value.
Figure 3.5
General or uniform corrosion on a steel plate.
• A steel surface consists of noble and less noble areas Uniform corrosion is a corrosion attack
• This can be looked upon as small galvanic cells uniformly distributed over the entire surface
• The anodic parts will corrode
Corroded area
Rust
+
-
-
+ -
+ Steel
+ -
+ - +
+ + -
+ + Thickness after corrosion Original thickness
-
When two materials are electrically coupled in seawater the more negative (active) material
in the couple will act as the anode, and will show an increased corrosion rate compared to
the unexposed state. The more positive (noble) component, the cathode, will have a
reduced corrosion rate.
Figure 3.6
Galvanic corrosion. The cathode is protected
while accelerated corrosion of the anode takes place.
The severity of the attack depends on:
• Conductivity of the electrolyte
• A node - Cathode area ratio
The degree of increased corrosion rate due to the galvanic coupling will vary from case to
case. Generally, the following factors will influence the galvanic corrosion process:
• The difference between the corrosion potentials of the uncoupled metals or alloys.
(See galvanic series below).
• The surface areas of the cathodic and anodic zones. When the surface area of the noble
metal (the cathode) is large compared to the more active member (the anode), an
unfavourable ratio exists. This will result in an accelerated corrosion of the anode. The
opposite area ratio (large anode and a smaller noble metal surface) produces only
slightly accelerated galvanic effects.
• The distance between the cathode and the anode. The shorter the distance the more
severe is the attack. This is shown in figure 10.5. The corrosion of the anode decreases
with increasing distance from the cathode, due to increased ohmic resistance.
• The electrical resistance of the galvanic circuit. A corrosion cell can be compared with
an electrical circuit. An increased resistance will reduce the electrical current and
The galvanic corrosion can of course be measured by immersion testing of the metals in the
environment of interest. In most cases, however, the galvanic corrosion is predicted by the
use of a galvanic series. In the galvanic series metals and alloys are ranked according to
their free corrosion potentials, measured as a volt signal in the electrolyte, e.g. seawater.
The potential difference between the materials is of decisive importance to the corrosion
velocities. If the potential difference is greater than 50 - 100 mV, the least noble material
may suffer accelerated corrosion.
It should be noted that the potential and range of potentials might differ considerably with
exposure condition, i.e. time, temperature, and still seawater versus high velocity
conditions.
Table 3.2
Galvanic series of metals and alloys in seawater at ambient temperatures relative to
different reference electrodes.
Reference electrodes
Material Ag/AgC1 Zn Cu/CuSO4
Graphite +0.25 +1.28 +0.17
Titanium 0 +1.03 -0.08
St. S (316) -0.05 +0.98 -0.13
Monel (400) -0.08 +0.95 -0.16
St. S 304) -0.08 +0.95 -0.16
Inconel (600) -0.15 +0.88 -0.23
Copper-nickel (90:10) -0.23 +0.80 -0.31
St. S (416) -0.28 +0.75 -0.36
Pits are sometimes isolated or they can be so close together that they seem to form a rough
surface. Generally, a pit may be described as a cavity or hole with a surface diameter about
the same as, or less than, the depth.
Figure 3.7
Pitting corrosion seen from above (left) and from the side (right).
Stainless steel
Crevice corrosion is a type of intense localised corrosion frequently occurring within narrow
gaps, crevices and under different types of deposits on metal surfaces exposed to corrosive
liquids. Particular attention must be paid to stainless steel under such conditions. The type
of attack is usually associated with small volumes of stagnant solution between overlapping
plates, under washers, gaskets, deposits and crevices under bolts where little oxygen is
available. However, it is not always necessary to have crevices to initiate such attacks. This
type of corrosion attack may also occur on a metal surface covered with spillage of paint,
The mechanism of crevice corrosion is complicated - but can be illustrated by low level
access of oxygen, needed in order to maintain the oxide film on passive materials. (See
“Pitting corrosion”). For crevice corrosion to occur the crevice must be wide enough to
permit entry of the corrosive liquid, but sufficiently narrow to maintain a stagnant zone of
solution within the crevice, limiting the transport of ions in and out of the crevice. Due to
this the environment inside the crevice will be different from the environment outside.
Corrosion will be initiated inside the crevice, as a more acidic environment compared with
the freely exposed surface will develop here. Solutions containing chloride ions are the
most aggressive environments with respect to causing crevice corrosion.
Figure 3.8
Crevice corrosion initiated on steel under panel and drop of paint.
Seaw ater
Ingress of seaw ater
Plate Paint
Stainless Steel
C orroded areas
Cracks may be formed in many construction materials. The main reason for initiation of a
crack is remaining internal stresses from manufacturing. Often a mechanical tensile stress is
also present, external deformations like bending, forming and welding, but at a level that in
itself is not harmful. However, this situation can change if the construction is exposed to a
corrosive environment. Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is a combination of tensile forces
and a corrosion attack with a very rapid material failure as a result. The cracks formed by
this combined action are often difficult to detect and when allowed to grow they may lead
to sudden and catastrophic failures.
Well known materials that may show susceptibility to SCC in chloride environments are
austenitic stainless steels containing chromium and nickel and a number of aluminium
alloys. Generally the susceptibility to SCC increases with increasing temperature. For a
In the offshore industry a lot of the hot stainless steels tubes are blast-cleaned with a fine
non-metallic abrasive and then an epoxy coating is applied. This is done to minimise the
tendency of SCC, especially on insulated stainless steels with an operating temperature of
60 o C or higher.
As for SCC (see above), Corrosion fatigue is also a type of failure occurring as a consequence
of a combined effect of a corrosive environment and physical stresses. Here, the physical
stresses are in the form of cyclical variations. Corrosion fatigue is frequently found in
connection with deformations and vibrations caused when reduced material dimensions
with high-strength steel are used.
As shown by the figure below the safe area is above the dotted line. In this case the
material in question is capable of withstanding all combinations of loads and dynamic cycles
in a non-corrosive environment. However, when exposed to a corrosive environment the
same material will break after a certain number of dynamic cycles. This is indicated by the
curve entering the dangerous zone below the dotted line in the figure.
Figure 3.9
Corrosion fatigue may occur at a combination of dynamic loads and a corrosive
environment.
Load
Corrosion fatigue
In the sea, mud and soil different types of bacteria will always exist. Under certain
conditions they can take part in a corrosion process. The mechanisms behind this are
complicated and will not be dealt with here. Bacterial corrosion (microbiological, anaerobic,
etc.) is found in oil tanks, ballast tanks, and on structures/objects buried in marine muds
(for example a pipeline). Conditions that encourage bacterial corrosion are:
Again, a result of two different factors combining to give a very common type of failure:
Erosion corrosion. A too high flow velocity of the flowing media causes the part of the
failure arising from erosion. This creates a turbulence that removes the protective layers or
the corrosion products from the metal surface. Then the bare base material will be
continuously exposed to the corrosive environment giving a very high, localised corrosion
velocity. Soft metals are particularly vulnerable to his form of attack, for example, copper,
brass, pure aluminium and lead, but most metals are susceptible to erosion corrosion in
particular flow situations.
Figure 3.10
Erosion corrosion. Appearance by grooves, gullies, waves, rounded holes. Often the
pattern created is called horse-shoe attack.
Figure 3.11
Construction / design is decisive for the degree of erosion corrosion.
Design to the right is better than to the left.
Perhaps the most well known example of de-alloying is de-Zincification of brass. This is
readily recognised as the alloy assumes a red copper colour, i.e. in contrast to the original
yellow. De-Zincificated zones are porous and mechanically weak and may result in a sudden
break when the alloy is exposed to physical impacts.