Criteria Excellent (15) Fair (10) Need improvement

(5)
Correctness of Speaking voice is Speaking voice is Speaking voice is
response clear and at a good clear for some of unclear or muffled,
pace, and their presentation and too fast or too
understand the but may be too slow, and doesn’t
presentation/activity slow or too fast at understand the
. times presentation.

Students Students
Students responded responded to responded to
to “WH” questions “WH” questions “WH” questions
using complete using complete using complete
sentences sentences gives 3-5 sentences gives 5
independently verbal and/or verbal and/or
visual prompts visual prompts
from the teacher from the teacher

Relevance of the Supporting ideas Ideas are generally Ideas are not
presentation can be recognized supported in the express well. There
easily; Excessively text itself; are no examples to
relevant examples. commonly relevant justify; irrelevant
that is enough to
make the content
clear and
sufficient.
Cooperatioin Members are on Members have Members do not
tasks and have defined know their tasks
defined responsibilities and have no
responsibilities at all most of the time; defined
times. group conflicts responsibilities.
Group conflict;
settle by their
teacher.