You are on page 1of 7

Writing a literature review on discrimination can be a daunting task.

It requires extensive research,


critical analysis, and synthesis of various scholarly sources to provide a comprehensive overview of
the topic. Discrimination is a complex issue with multifaceted dimensions, encompassing race,
gender, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, disability, and more. Thus, reviewing the existing
literature involves navigating through a vast array of academic articles, books, reports, and other
sources across different disciplines such as sociology, psychology, law, and political science.

One of the challenges in writing a literature review on discrimination is ensuring the inclusion of
diverse perspectives and voices. Discrimination affects individuals and communities differently
based on their socio-cultural context and intersecting identities. Therefore, it is essential to consider a
wide range of literature that reflects this diversity and provides a nuanced understanding of
discrimination and its impacts.

Moreover, synthesizing the findings from various sources while maintaining coherence and clarity
can be demanding. Writers must carefully analyze the methodologies, theories, and empirical
evidence presented in the literature to identify common themes, trends, and gaps in knowledge. This
process requires critical thinking and the ability to discern the relevance and reliability of different
sources.

Furthermore, organizing the literature review in a logical and structured manner is essential to
effectively communicate the key insights and arguments. Writers must create a coherent narrative
that guides readers through the existing literature, highlighting the key debates, theoretical
frameworks, and empirical findings.

Given the challenges involved in writing a literature review on discrimination, many individuals
may find it beneficial to seek assistance from professional writing services. ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔
offers expert assistance in crafting literature reviews that are comprehensive, well-researched, and
tailored to specific requirements. Our team of experienced writers can help you navigate the
complexities of the topic and produce a high-quality literature review that meets your academic
goals. Save time and effort by ordering your literature review from ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔ today.
Starting point for RCTs is “Low Risk” with 0 points. The law applies to employers and providers of
education or training. They suggest; examining one’s own speech practices, listening and
acknowledging talks about experiences of discrimination, and countering and not reproducing
discrimination as practices that protect affected children. Ein Literatur Review zum aktuellen
Forschungsstand. Third, actual home or job seekers do not randomly assign themselves to housing
agents or employers but select them for various reasons. Chapter Chapter Discrimination in Mortgage
Lending: A Literature Review DOI link for Discrimination in Mortgage Lending: A Literature
Review Discrimination in Mortgage Lending: A Literature Review By John Yinger Book Mortgage
Lending, Racial Discrimination and Federal Policy Click here to navigate to parent product. In a
parallel experiment, subliminal exposure to photographs of unfamiliar black male faces, as compared
with white ones, was followed by more rude, hostile behavior when the white experimenter
subsequently made an annoying request. Our definition includes two components that are related to
(but broader than) a large body of case law: differential treatment on the basis of race that
disadvantages a racial group and treatment on the basis of inadequately justified factors other than
race that disadvantages a racial group (differential effect). In both approaches, an attempt is made to
manipulate apparent race, while holding all other variables constant, and to elicit a response from the
participants. Nonetheless, the courts have held that the burden of persuading the court that the
employment decision was discriminatory remains with the plaintiff. They argue that an estimate of
discrimination at a randomly selected firm (or in an advertisement) does not measure the impact of
discrimination in a market. Thus, the results of real-world-oriented laboratory studies could provide
more fully fleshed-out theories of discriminatory mechanisms to guide the modeling work. We use
cookies to create the best experience for you. The study covered both housing rentals and sales, and
the auditors were assigned incomes and family characteristics appropriate to the housing unit
advertised (Turner et al., 1991a). Members of each pair are typically trained to act in a similar
fashion and are equipped with identical supporting documents. Accurately determining what
constitutes the effect of discrimination, personal choice, and other related and unrelated factors
requires the ability to draw clear causal inferences. Auditors or testers are randomly assigned to pairs
(one of each race) and matched on equivalent characteristics (e.g., socioeconomic status), credentials
(e.g., education), tastes, and market needs. Both of these proposed approaches to measuring
discrimination are valid, but each has limitations. Murphy formally delineates the circumstances
under which an estimate of discrimination will be erroneous if the researcher fails to account for
individual auditor characteristics that do not vary in distribution by race and therefore were not used
in the matching process. Unbeknownst to the interviewer participants, the applicants were
confederates of the experimenters, trained to respond in a standard way. For example, researchers
randomly assigned participants to see, at subliminal speeds, words related to rudeness or neutral
topics and showed that those participants exposed to rude words responded more rudely to an
experimenter. Two coders used the same scales to rate, separately, participants’ verbal and nonverbal
behavior, respectively, from audiotapes and from videotapes on which only the participant was
visible. With the exception of a study we describe later (in Box 6-5 ), we do not review other types
of field experiments in the domain of racial discrimination. This definition of discrimination is used
in many social science fields (e.g., economics, psychology, sociology) to refer to unequal treatment
because of race. Murphy formally delineates the circumstances under which an estimate of
discrimination will be erroneous if the researcher fails to account for individual auditor characteristics
that do not vary in distribution by race and therefore were not used in the matching process. This is
achieved by reviewing a variety of academic books and renowned journal articles, getting a sound
know-how of the theories pertaining to discrimination, its role in different diverse workplaces,
focusing on South Asia, especially Pakistan, and then studying them thoroughly by comparing and
contrasting different case studies of countries globally. Any product that may be evaluated in this
article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the
publisher. Despite the extensive search, only very few studies on the relationship between experiences
of discrimination and developmental outcomes among very young and refugee children could be
identified in the present systematic review. Also, although African Americans are overrepresented in
federal and state prisons relative to their proportion in the population (Walker et al., 1996), American
Indians actually have the highest incarceration rate for any race: In 1997, 1,083 of every 100,000
American Indians in the United States were incarcerated (Smelser and Baltes, 2001).
The effects of these variables must be accounted for in the study design and analysis. The race of
actors and targets was not specified verbally, but each incident was accompanied by one of four
drawings of the event, identical except for the depicted race of the actor and target. Findings on
(intersectional) discrimination experiences of immigrated minors can contribute to a critical view of
discrimination in psychotherapeutic and pedagogical work. In the sales market, whites discussed 35
percent more houses and were invited to inspect 34 percent more houses; moreover, the difference in
treatment was larger for low-income families and families with children. This time period includes
the transit time for us to receive your return from the shipper (5 to 10 business days), the time it
takes us to process your return once we receive it (3 to 5 business days), and the time it takes your
bank to process our refund request (5 to 10 business days). The gross measure may provide useful
supplemental information to the net measure if the balancing disparities are large. Therefore, it is
unable to estimate what proportion of observed disparities is actually a function of discrimination.
All great insights into the issues of the variables under scrutiny are connected and related with the
overall theme of this study and thrown light upon elaborately. This review sparked the realization,
discussed in earlier chapters, that modern forms of discrimination can be subtle, covert, and possibly
unconscious, representing a new challenge to careful measurement, both inside and outside the
laboratory (survey measures for these forms of discrimination are discussed in Chapter 8 ). The
typical field experiment uses a two-group, post-test-only control group design (Campbell and
Stanley, 1963). This study covered 40 metropolitan areas chosen to represent areas with central cities
that were at least 11 percent black. Research indicates that gender, race, and age are the most salient,
immediately encoded social categories (Fiske, 1998). Only original studies published as peer-
reviewed journal articles with abstract, title and full-text in German or English were included (IC 4)
with no date restrictions. Because race cannot be experimentally manipulated, an explicit
specification of the behavioral process is needed that allows the translation of results from such
experiments into causal statements about the actual discrimination mechanism measured in the
experiment (i.e., the extent to which the experimenter can manipulate some other factor related to
race, such as perception). Thus, the studies included in this review and their data bodies need to be
contextualized in constituting power and inequality relations. One use of such methods is to assist in
policy formulation and evaluation, but discussion of policies as such goes beyond our charge. To this
strategic and timely intervention in a national. Participants rated how mean, threatening, friendly,
and playful each incident was. Propensity score matching is sometimes used when there are too
many relevant characteristics on which to match on every one. As a point of comparison, in this
section we look at the legal definitions of discrimination and identify the circumstances under which
a legal finding of discriminatory behavior can be made. Furthermore, for measuring discrimination,
they appear to reflect the broader public vision of what discrimination means—the treatment of two
(nearly) identical people differently. Nonetheless, we chose to use the MMAT despite this limitation
due to the potential to assess the methodological quality of different study types within one review.
The constitutional prohibition against violations of equal protection (directly applied to the states
under the Fourteenth Amendment and indirectly applied to the federal government under the due
process clause of the Fifth Amendment) prohibits racial classifications unless justified by a
“compelling interest” and unless the policy is “narrowly tailored” to serve that interest. In defining
discrimination for this report, we focus primarily on discrimination that has harmful consequences
for disadvantaged racial minorities. Neither requirement was intended to measure an employee’s
ability or performance in a particular job or job category within the company. Other more direct
forms of discrimination are also possible to measure in such experiments, such as making negative
comments in a job interview. If a rental office has more than one agent who shows apartments,
different experiences of the members of the pair may be traceable to differences in the behavior of
the agent with whom they dealt. If laboratory studies were to be more focused on real-world-type
behaviors, they could help analysts who use statistical models for developing causal inferences from
observational data (see Chapter 7 ). In this chapter, we review two experimental approaches that have
been used by researchers to reach causal conclusions about racial discrimination: laboratory
experiments and field experiments (particularly audit studies). This will facilitate perceiving and
reducing individual and structural disadvantages in therapeutic care and different life outcomes.
Assunta, Italy Daeem Ghassan, Sigmund Freud Institute, Germany. This means that practicing
Muslims cannot work there since they cannot pray at the appointed times.(Ibid, 1995). This covers
aggravation based on any of the above. (Alf, 1958). If all unmatched characteristics have the same
distribution across racial groups, and if the auditors were selected to be representative of the
distribution of these characteristics, we will have managed to balance the covariates across racial
groups and can estimate an unbiased effect of race. Alternatively, the advertisements themselves can
be included in the model, which makes the error terms independent. Other more direct forms of
discrimination are also possible to measure in such experiments, such as making negative comments
in a job interview. This period excludes delivery times, which depend on your geographic location.
As the court has emphasized, a government is not prohibited from acting in spite of harm to
members of disadvantaged racial groups; it is banned only from causing harm because of race. In
another example, Yinger (1986) studied the Boston housing rental and sales markets in 1981. A need
for more empirical research focusing on the path and (possibly) indirect link between discrimination
and children and adolescents’ school-related outcomes as well as resulting school recommendations
and the chosen career path was derived. It is valuable to determine how much discrimination exists
before such behavioral responses take place—which is the amount estimated using paired
testing—and whether discrimination arises under certain circumstances. This problem can often be
addressed using double-blind methods, in which experimenters as well as participants are not aware
of the treatment assigned to them. Indirect discrimination can also occurs when a rule or condition,
which is applied equally to everyone, can be met by a considerably smaller proportion of people
from a particular group, the rule is to their disadvantage, and it cannot be justified on other grounds.
(Alf, 1958). Participants rated how mean, threatening, friendly, and playful each incident was. The
review highlights the consequences of discrimination and confirms that the different manifestations
of discrimination, such as modernized racism and microaggression, must be considered alongside
deeper explorations of how they affect developmental outcomes. If laboratory studies were to be
more focused on real-world-type behaviors, they could help analysts who use statistical models for
developing causal inferences from observational data (see Chapter 7 ). Murphy recommends
ascertaining “discrimination in situations in which Blacks are qualified buyers” (2002:72). Also, you
can type in a page number and press Enter to go directly to that page in the book. It found that the
experience of discrimination mainly affects (mental) health and social relationships. However, many
other effects tested both in the laboratory and in the field have been consistent, some showing even
stronger effects in the field (Brewer and Brown, 1998; Crosby et al., 1980; Johnson and Stafford,
1998). Although legal segregation and exclusion ended in 1968 with the Fair Housing Act, racial
disparities in certain neighborhoods and housing markets continue. They argue that an estimate of
discrimination at a randomly selected firm (or in an advertisement) does not measure the impact of
discrimination in a market. Moreover, researchers can mimic the employment interview context to
examine the potentially large effects that nonverbal forms of discrimination are hypothesized to have
on people’s ability to obtain a job. The study confirmed the results of earlier local housing audits and
demonstrated that discrimination was not confined to a few isolated cases (Wienk et al., 1979).
Other participants saw the initial 6-minute videotape depicting socioeconomic status but also saw an
additional 12-minute videotape that depicted the child taking an oral test on which her performance
was mixed. For example, if there are theoretically or practically compelling reasons for suspecting
that an effect is limited to college sophomores, one might also replicate the study with business
executives on campus for a seminar or retirees passing through for an Airstream conference. Direct
contact is the best approach to changing attitudes. Although experiences of racism are part of the
everyday life of many minors affected by the process of “Othering” (e.g., those with an immigrant
background), an overview of empirical findings is missing for this age group worldwide. Yet no
doctrine of law would permit either of these ostensibly neutral governmental programs to be
challenged as racially discriminatory. The order of arrival at the location is randomly assigned.
Comparably similar legal definitions of indirect discrimination and harassment apply in respect of
sexual orientation, religion, age, gender and disability. It is assumed that nursing is a natural
extension of the woman’s caring nature. In another example, Yinger (1986) studied the Boston
housing rental and sales markets in 1981. Unaccompanied Migrant Children and Adolescents and
Human Rights. We know that discrimination is a significant issue. They followed two different
bargaining strategies: one that depended on the behavior of the seller and another that was
independent of seller behavior. Public Perceptions of Older People and Ageing: A literature? pdf.
Because race cannot be experimentally manipulated, an explicit specification of the behavioral
process is needed that allows the translation of results from such experiments into causal statements
about the actual discrimination mechanism measured in the experiment (i.e., the extent to which the
experimenter can manipulate some other factor related to race, such as perception). Direct
discrimination is when a person is treated less favorably by another in a comparable situation. In the
rental market, whites discussed 17 percent more units with a rental agent and were invited to inspect
57 percent more units than blacks. In addition, the current findings support that for training or
treatment practice among immigrant children and adolescents, teachers, social workers, and other
stakeholders should be oriented toward a discrimination-critical approach. While many factors may
contribute to such differences, their size and extent suggest that various forms of discriminatory
treatment persist in U.S. society and serve to undercut the achievement of equal opportunity.
Similarly, the war on drugs is designed to identify and punish the tens or even hundreds of thousands
of workers in the illegal drug trade, a disproportionate number of whom will inevitably be drawn
from disadvantaged groups having less abundant opportunities in the legitimate economy. They
cannot, by their nature, say how often or how much a particular phenomenon occurs, such as what
proportion of a racial disparity is a function of discriminatory behavior. Other more direct forms of
discrimination are also possible to measure in such experiments, such as making negative comments
in a job interview. Three scientific databases were systematically searched up to June 11, 2021. Field
audit studies randomly assign experimental and control treatments (e.g., black and white apartment
hunters) to units (e.g., a rental agency) and measure outcomes (e.g., number of apartments shown).
Third, most of the articles included in this review had cross-sectional study designs. The high
number of medium and low ratings mainly resulted from included studies not reporting enough
information on their sample (e.g., sampling process, inclusion and exclusion criteria, non-responders)
to make a clear judgment. Review of Research on Age Discrimination in the? pdf. Literature review
of issues related to work-life? pdf. Later in the semester, 40 students (15 male and 25 female)
participated in what they believed to be two separate studies. Although discriminating real estate
agents can be found liable for housing market discrimination, there is. Another famous experiment
showed that researchers can study social perception processes hypothesized to underlie
discrimination, in which people see what they want to see by interpreting ambiguous evidence to fit
their stereotypical biases (Darley and Gross, 1983; see Box 6-2 ). This shift occurred precisely
because of the discrepancy between some people’s overtly egalitarian responses on surveys and their
discriminatory responses when they think no one is looking, or at least when they have a
nonprejudiced excuse for their discriminatory behavior. For instance, African Americans and
Hispanics compared with non-Hispanic whites are less likely to receive kidney dialysis or transplants
(Epstein et al., 2000), are less likely to receive appropriate cancer diagnostic tests or treat-. If you
receive a refund, the cost of return shipping will be deducted from your refund. Nonreactive,
unobtrusive, disguised measurement can avert this problem. Barbie - Brand Strategy Presentation
Barbie - Brand Strategy Presentation Good Stuff Happens in 1:1 Meetings: Why you need them and
how to do them well Good Stuff Happens in 1:1 Meetings: Why you need them and how to do them
well Introduction to C Programming Language Introduction to C Programming Language From
Discrimination to Social Inclusion: A review of the literature on anti-stigma initiatives in mental
healthy final 1. FROM. It is likely that audit studies of racial discrimination in other domains (e.g.,
schooling and health care) could produce useful results as well, even though their use will
undoubtedly present methodological challenges specific to each domain.

You might also like