Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2. If price fell and quantity remained constant, a possible cause would be a shift out
to the right of the supply curve and a shift of the demand curve in to the left.
Another possibility would be a shift of the demand curve in to the left with a
vertical supply curve. Note that when both curves shift, the effect on either price
or quantity depends on the relative size of the shifts.
3. Computer pricing of roads could end bottlenecks and rush hour congestion by price
rationing. Currently at zero price, at certain times, the quantity demanded greatly
exceeds the quantity supplied, resulting in congestion. Raising prices, during those
times, could eliminate excess demand and reduce the congestion. This
technological change will spread out congestions over wider geographic areas and
over the day, as individuals with more flexibility with respect to route and timing
will choose to demand less of the current high demand route at rush hour.
1
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
4. a. This would represent a shift in demand to the left
assuming the decline in Cookie Monster’s popularity
represents a decline in the popularity of cookies. The
price and quantity of cookies would likely fall as
shown in the accompanying graph.
b. This is represented by a shift in demand for bread
(high in carbohydrates) to the left. Equilibrium price
and quantity falls as the graph shows. (Note: this is
the same graph as for part a.)
5. a. Both the shift in demand to the right and the shift of supply to the left lead to a
higher equilibrium price of oil. The effect on equilibrium is indeterminate. While
the shift in demand to the right would lead to a rise in equilibrium quantity, the
shift in supply to the left would reduce it. Whether equilibrium quantity rises or
falls depends on the relative size of the shifts. The accompanying graph shows a
slight decline in equilibrium quantity and a significant increase in equilibrium
price.
b. With an in production (supply shifts to the right), equilibrium price will decline
and equilibrium quantity will decline as shown in the graph below. Because
demand has increased in the meantime, the equilibrium price and quantity will be
higher than before the original supply disruption.
2
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
6. a. This represents a shift of the supply curve to the left because the offended decide
not to supply organs, increasing the legal price significantly and perhaps reducing
the equilibrium quantity to a quantity that is below the amount currently provided
at zero cost. This is shown in graph (a) below.
b. How responsive quantity supplied is to price affects the slope of the supply curve.
If quantity supplied is very responsive to price, the equilibrium price might be
quite low and legalizing organ sales would have significant benefits to society. In
fact, the authors of the study estimate the equilibrium price of kidneys to be less
than $1000. In graph (b) below, S1 is much more responsive to price than S0.
(a) (b)
7. The drought in Australia caused a decrease in supply, which shifted the supply
curve for rice to the left. Equilibrium price rose from 12 to 24 cents a pound and
quantity fell as the accompanying graph shows.
3
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
8. See the accompanying graph. A price ceiling of PC below equilibrium price will
cause a shortage shown by the difference between QD and QS
4
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
10. See the accompanying graph. A price floor of PF
above equilibrium price will cause a surplus shown
by the difference between QS and QD.
12. a. A $4 per unit tax on suppliers shifts the supply curve up by $4 shown as a shift in
the supply curve from S0 to S1. Equilibrium price will rise by $4 only if the demand
curve is perfectly vertical. In the case of a vertical demand curve, quantity would
not change. Otherwise, equilibrium price rises by less than $4 and equilibrium
quantity falls as shown in the accompanying graph. In this example, the price
increases by less than $4 to P1 and quantity declines to Q1. The price that suppliers
receive falls to P2.
b. A $4 per unit tax on consumers shifts the demand curve down by $4 shown as a
shift down in the demand curve from D0 to D1. Equilibrium price will fall by $4
only if the supply curve is perfectly vertical. In the case of a vertical supply curve,
quantity would not change. Otherwise, equilibrium price fall by less than $4 to P1
5
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
and equilibrium quantity falls Q1 as shown in the accompanying graph. The price
paid by consumers, including the tax is P2.
c. The unit tax on the consumers and suppliers has the same effect on the both
equilibrium quantity and price. It doesn't matter who pays the tax. Because
consumers demand less at every price, substituting other goods whose prices have
not risen, the demand curve shifts up by the amount of the tax. The price of the
good that suppliers receive rises until quantity supplied equals quantity demanded.
13. a. The quantity supplied and demanded equal each other when the price is $1.00. The
equilibrium price is $1.00 and the equilibrium quantity is 150 units.
b. The tax shifts the supply curve up by $0.75 from S0 to S1. Equilibrium price (the
price consumers pay) is $1.50 and equilibrium quantity is 125. Suppliers receive
the equilibrium price less the tax, or $0.75.
c. The tax shifts the demand curve down by $0.75 from D0 to D1. The equilibrium
price (the price suppliers receive) is $0.75 and equilibrium quantity is 125.
Consumers pay ($0.75 + $0.75), or $1.50.
6
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
d. It doesn't matter upon whom the tax is levied. The result is the same. We can see
this by considering what happens to demand when customers pay the tax. Because
consumers demand less at every price, substituting other goods whose prices have
not risen, the demand curve shifts down by the amount of the tax. The price of the
good that suppliers receive falls until quantity supplied equals quantity demanded.
14. A quota places a quantity restriction on imports. Consumers are willing to pay a
higher price for the lower quantity (QQ) than the equilibrium price without a quota.
Therefore, quotas lead to higher import prices as shown in the accompanying graph.
7
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
16. Public postsecondary education is an example of a third-party payer market
because it is heavily subsidized by state government and in most cases, a student’s
parents. Those consuming the good, students, do not pay the entire cost of the
education they receive. This likely leads to greater expenditures on postsecondary
education than if students had to pay the entire cost of their education.
b. In third-party-payer markets, the person who demands the good differs from the
person paying for the good. Here, with a co-payment of $2 quantity demanded
will be 900 units. Sellers require payment of $14 per unit to supply that quantity.
c. Total spending in part a is $1,800 ($6 × 300). Total spending in part b is $12,600
($14 × 900).
I might decide to hire my friends, or to hire those with whom I like to work—such as
those from a preferred ethnic group or gender. Is doing so fair? Fairness is a judgment
question and judgments differ. From most people’s perspective, such methods are not
fair. The problem is that wage controls set an equal base wage level, but leave open
possibilities for other inequalities. Rather than helping the least skilled end of the
labor pool it prices them out of the market, increasing their unemployment, and
promoting other forms of discrimination. Austrians believe that these market
distortions are not good for society and prefer little or no government intervention.
2. Religious
This is a judgment question and judgments differ. Christians believe that people
should care about society, not just about themselves. So, since spending $20 of your
own would likely free up $100,000 of Medicare resource for someone else, Christian
values would suggest choosing to spend the $20. A primary Christian value is
stewardship.
3. Feminist
There are likely a number of reasons why women are paid less than men. Part of the
pay gap may be explained by differences in work experience, education, on-the-job
training, and work interruptions for women. Economists typically measure
discrimination as a residual – that part of the pay gap that remains “unexplained” after
accounting for these factors. The second part of the question is a judgment question
and judgments differ. A law that requires firms to pay equal wages to those with
comparable skills may be difficult to implement. How would the skills be assessed?
8
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Others argue that assessment itself would add costs to a firm’s production and
increase product prices. However, if the reason for the pay gap is discrimination, the
law can change values and make it more costly to discriminate. Since discrimination
necessarily implies that hiring is on the basis of something other than productivity,
reducing discrimination may promote efficiency. Feminists generally support such
laws.
4. Institutionalist
a. We can see cultural evolution through history; the appendix to Chapter 3 can be used
to trace the cultural evolution of the market system. Here it is important to stress that
religious values and social relationships had to evolve to accommodate the needs of
the new forms of economic organization that emerged. Markets change overnight and
increasingly require rapid adaptation by individuals, which can cause shocks to social
relationships. One might question the long-term (in)stability caused by market
evolution. The outcomes of biological evolution are driven by natural selection: those
organisms with traits giving them a competitive edge in the competition for limited
energy propagate; others disappear. In this context, the only purpose is to successfully
reproduce. Some economists believe that the purpose of cultural evolution is
betterment of the human condition for all.
b. In the U.S. market, evolution has elevated living standards for everyone relative to
those of say 1775. We see access to fresh fruits and vegetables year round; many
diseases have been eliminated; life spans have increased greatly. Yet, we are social
beings who are aware of our social position. One may be well fed, but one may still
feel socially destitute because one’s level of welfare is low relative to one’s
contemporaries. In this sense, market evolution has failed to contribute to betterment.
5. Religious
6. Radical
9
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
a. Today’s rent controls are designed to be less invasive than the ones described in the
book, and thus they do not have the strong effects described there. They still have
some effects, and the policy question is whether the income redistribution effects they
have are sufficiently desirable to warrant the costs of the policies.
b. This is a judgment question; economics can tell one about what the costs and benefits
of a mechanism are; not about what is an appropriate mechanism.
c. This again is a judgment question that requires an integration of normative issues into
the analysis. Most mainstream economists would argue that it is better to deal with
the underlying income distribution issues, rather than specific ones, and that one must
consider the problems of government intervention. Radical economists would argue
that, while mainstream economists talk about "underlying issues", they seldom do
deal with those problems. If one is going to direct spending toward housing,
mainstream economists would prefer using generalized housing vouchers than using
administrative means of allocation apartments, since housing vouchers offer
individuals more flexibility.
Issues to Ponder
1. a. Airways have value because they produce revenue and there are only a limited
number of airways in the industry.
2. a. The graph on the left shows the primary market for tickets, assuming that all
tickets that will be available for the game are offered by lottery. We know that
there is excess demand because at $130 a seat, 110,000 tickets are demanded and
only 10,000 are supplied resulting in an excess demand of 100,000.
b. The graph on the right represents the scalped ticket market, assuming that only
5,000 of the 10,000 ticket holders and only 50,000 of the 100,000 of those who
didn't get tickets are willing to break the law and enter the scalped ticket market.
Assume that sellers will not accept any prices under $2000 and that they will sell
for the best they price they can get over $200. Given this assumption, no tickets
are for sale at $130. At $130 a ticket, excess supply is now 50,000. Assuming
buyers and sellers do not distinguish among the quality of seats, the market-
clearing price is $2,000 per ticket.
c. If scalping becomes legalized, more people would be willing to sell their tickets
because there is no risk of being arrested and fined. Assuming all ticket holders
10
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
are willing to sell their tickets, the supply of tickets shifts to the right to 10,000,
reducing the scalped ticket price of Final-Four tickets to $1,000 a ticket.
Price
Price S0 S1
$2,000
$1,000
$130
$200
$130
Demand
Demand
b. A strongly enforced anti-scalping law (against suppliers) would push up prices far
more as the cost of supply rose and the supply curve shifted to the left. If
enforcement were sufficiently strong, a two-tier price system would emerge with
a low legal price at P0 and another very high price, P2.
4. a. Boards often exist not only to benefit the consumer, but also to benefit existing
producers. Often those who are currently certified attempt to limit the number of
new certifications so as to limit the supply and raise prices.
11
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
quo. Those currently certified may have more “clout” with the board if the board
is comprised of certified hairdressers. The benefits of the changes are also large,
but they are spread out over large groups of consumers, with each consumer
benefiting very little. Therefore, it will be easier for the small group, whose
benefit per individual is large, to organize.
5. a. The Oregon Health Plan includes a prioritized list of medical services that
determine whether a service is covered. The list is based on comparative benefit
to those covered as determined by the Health Care Board. Those services that this
Board believed had the highest net benefit were ranked highest. Those they
believed had a lower net benefit were not covered. The Health Care Board was
made up of heath professionals whose goal was hoped to be the “greatest good for
the greatest number.”
b. Economists should not oppose the Oregon Plan because it involves rationing. The
market involves rationing through the price mechanism. Economists might oppose
the Oregon Plan because in general they support the market as the least-cost
method of providing goods and services to those who actually need it, and
because they believe the board’s rationing is less fair than market rationing.
Economists are open to the argument that the market may not distribute goods and
services in the way that society wants, which may require government
intervention.
c. In the market, the interaction of demand and supply determines the equilibrium
price and quantity that is bought and sold. Those who are able to pay the
equilibrium price are the ones who receive the specified types of health care. The
Oregon Plan uses its benefit-ranking system determined by their Board of
Professionals, rather than price as the rationing mechanism.
b. Other examples include points that hotels give to travelers, loyalty cards, and
bonus checks based on charges that Discover gives those who use its credit card.
c. Firms likely do not monitor these programs because it would be too costly to do
so, and because the benefits of the program are not taxed, which makes them a
type of tax-free income for their employees.
12
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
7. a. An import quota will increase the price of
imported sugar. The accompanying graph
shows how a higher imported sugar price
increases the price that domestic producers can
charge and increase the quantity they can
supply to the market. For example, at world
price P0, domestic consumers demand the
quantity E-B from importers and quantity B
from domestic producers. After a quota
represented by quantity D minus C is imposed,
the import price is P1. Domestic consumers
demand the quantity D-C from importers and
quantity C from domestic producers.
b. The government could have imposed a tariff on imported sugar. This would also
have raised the price of imported sugar.
c. A minimum required import level of 1.25 million will limit the ability of the
United States to support domestic sugar prices. The increase in quantity supplied
will put downward pressure on sugar prices.
c. Eliminating rent controls would most likely allow the market price of apartments
to increase and eliminate side payments. The quantity supplied will rise until it
equals the quantity demanded at the market price. The price, quantity combination
is (Pe, Qe) in the graph. However, if there are few additional apartments available
to be rented (the supply curve is almost vertical), then price will increase
dramatically and quantity supplied will only rise slightly.
d. The political appeal of rent control is that it benefits those who currently rent
apartments. Apartment renters who live in rent-controlled apartments are more
13
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
likely to vote, and this is why it is maintained. There are other possible reasons as
well.
9. a. The government subsidy of mohair provided an enormous incentive for those who
were allowed to sell mohair to sell large quantities at lower price than otherwise.
The elimination of this subsidy shifted the supply curve to the left (shown below
as a shift from Ssubsidy to S no subsidy, increasing the market price for mohair from P0
to P1 and decreasing the quantity demanded and supplied from Q0 to Q1.
b. This program was likely kept in existence because not many people knew about it
(mohair is a relatively small market), and ranchers had no incentive to broadcast
the subsidy.
c. A law that requires that suppliers receive $3.60 more than the market price is the
same as a tax, but the revenue goes to the supplier. The demand curve would shift
to the left (down) to include this tax. The quantity demanded would fall
dramatically. Consumers would not support this law because they would have to
pay an enormously high price. Suppliers would support this law only if they were
guaranteed that they could sell at that high price.
10. Excess supply in U.S. agricultural markets is caused by the government’s policy
of agricultural price supports, or price floors on agricultural products. Political
forces prevent the invisible hand from working.
11. It would likely increase the number since it reduces the cost of having a car that
you drive very little.
12. The demand for rolling machines went up enormously because loose tobacco
became a cheaper substitute for the taxed cigarettes and rolling machines are a
14
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
complement of loose tobacco; some companies more than quadrupled their sales
of loose tobacco and rolling machines.
13. a. Japan prescribes many more drugs than the U.S. because Japanese doctors have a
financial incentive to do so.
b. It would lead to many more drugs being produced, even if they were not really
innovative, as happened when Japan tried this.
c. Drug reps would likely provide free samples and other gifts to doctors and have
lunches for them where they tout the advantages of their drugs.
c. The graphs below show the effect of increasing co-payments. The graph on the
left has a co-payment of $15. Consumers demand Q1 and the shaded region
shows the medical claim costs. In the accompanying graph on the right,
consumers must pay the first $1,500 of medical costs, demonstrated by the lower-
shaded region. (For simplicity, we assume that consumers end up purchasing 50
units at a cost of $30 per unit.) As you can see, however, the medical cost to the
firm (upper shaded area) is much smaller. In addition, the units of medical
services demanded are lower, illustrating the answer to the second question –
hospital admissions declined.
15
© 2017 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in
any manner. This document may not be copied, scanned, duplicated, forwarded, distributed, or posted on a website, in whole or part.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
mm. × 48 mm., the ordinary size on the adjoining banks being only
about 50 to 60 × 30 mm.
Some observations have already been recorded (p. 40) on the
growth of Helix aspersa. In the summer of 1858, which was very dry,
especially in the south of France, the young Helices born that year
were still very small in August. About the end of that month abundant
rain came on, and in four or five days young H. variabilis, H. pisana,
and H. aspersa, eating without cessation, as if to make up for lost
time, grew more than a centimetre of shell. The lip of a young H.
arbustorum has been observed to have grown, at the end of the first
week in the season’s growth, 3 mm., at the end of the second week,
6·25 mm., the third, 11·5 mm., and the fourth 12·5 mm., with a
finished lip.[342]
Careful observation has shown that in the growth of the shell of
Helix aspersa the periostracum is first produced; it is covered with
hyaline globules, 10–12 mm. in diameter, which persist even in the
oldest shells. Calcareous matter is deposited on the internal face of
the new periostracum, at some distance from the margin. It is
secreted by a white zone or band of cells bounding the entire
breadth of the mantle as applied to the peristome. Immediately
behind the white zone are a series of pigment cells which not only
give the shell its colour but complete the calcification of the shelly
matter laid down by the white zone. When the animal has attained its
full growth and the lip is finished off, the white band and the
periostracum cells completely disappear, and only such cells persist
as contribute to the internal thickening of the shell. Shell growth, in
this species, is very rapid. If a portion of the pulmonary sac is laid
bare, by removing a fragment of shell, at the end of 1½ or 2 hours
there may be detected a delicate organic membrane covering the
hole, and strewn with crystals of carbonate of lime. This thickens
with great rapidity, and soon fills up the hole with solid matter. For
two consecutive months an animal, deprived of food, has been
known to reproduce this membrane daily after its removal every
morning.[343] Prof. Schiedt has found that oysters, if deprived of the
right valve and exposed to the light, not only develop brown pigment
over the whole exposed surface of mantle and branchiae, but
actually succeed in part in reproducing the valve and hinge.[344]
Deposit of Additional Layers of Shell.—Mollusca possess the
power of thickening the interior of the shell, by the deposit of
successive layers. This is frequently done in self-defence against the
attacks of boring Mollusca, sponges, and worms. Cases may often
be noticed of Ostrea, Spondylus, and other sedentary molluscs,
which, unable to escape the gradual assaults of their foes, have
provided against them by the deposit of fresh shelly matter. A
somewhat similar plan is adopted to provide against intrusion by way
of the aperture. Pearls are, in many cases, the result of shell
deposition upon the eggs or even the body of some intrusive
parasite (Distoma, Filaria, etc.), and are, in some countries,
artificially produced by the introduction of fragments of sand, metal,
etc., into living Unio and Anodonta. Little joss images are made in
India and China, the nacre on which is produced by thrusting them
inside living Unionidae.
A specimen of Helix rosacea, in the British Museum, into whose
shell a piece of grass somehow became introduced, has partitioned
it off by the formation of a sort of shelly tunnel extending throughout
its entire length (Fig. 167).
Fig. 167.—A specimen of Helix
rosacea Müll., Cape of Good
Hope, into which a piece of
grass has by some means
become introduced. The
animal has protected itself by
covering the grass with a
shelly layer. (From a
specimen in the British
Museum.)
Absorption of Internal Portions.—Certain genera have the
remarkable property of absorbing, when they become adult, the
internal portions of the whorls and the greater part of the columellar
axis. The effect of this is to make the shell, when the process is
complete, no longer a spiral but a more or less produced cone, and it
is found that in such cases the viscera of the spire lose their spiral
form, and take the shape of the cavity in which they lie. Amongst the
genera in which this singular process takes place are Nerita,[345]
Olivella, and Cypraea amongst marine forms, and nearly the whole
of the Auriculidae[346] (Fig. 168). Conus reduces the internal
subdivisions of the spire to extreme thinness. It is noticeable that
these genera are all of considerable thickness of shell, and it is
perhaps the result of the whole energy of the animal being directed
to the formation of its external protection that the internal walls of the
spire become atrophied and eventually disappear.
Fig. 168.—Auricula Judae Lam.,
showing the disappearance
of the partitions of the
whorls, which are
represented by dotted lines.
(After Fischer.)
The Slit.—Many shells are furnished with a slit in the last whorl,
which opens, in most cases, on the outer lip, and is sometimes of
considerable depth, at others a mere notch. In the patelliform shells
it is always in front of the apex. The function of the slit appears to be
mainly anal, the excretory products being thus allowed to escape by
a passage of their own, without soiling the clean water taken in by
the branchiae. The posterior canal of some Gasteropoda probably
performs a similar function. In the adult Fissurella the slit becomes
an apical hole (see Fig. 178 F), in the allied genera it is either
immediately in front of the spire (Puncturella), or half-way between
the spire and the anterior margin (Rimula), or on the margin and well
marked (Emarginula), or a mere indentation of the margin
(Hemitoma). In Pleurotomaria it is exceptionally long, and is well
marked in Bellerophon, Schismope, Scissurella, Murchisonia, and
Pleurotoma (where it is sutural). In Haliotis and Polytremaria it is
replaced by a series of holes, which are closed up as the animal
grows past them. Some of these holes (at least in Haliotis) certainly
serve the purpose of admitting water to the branchiae, while others
are anal. In Trochotoma there are only two holes, united by a narrow
fissure.
The Tubed Land Operculates.—A group of the Cyclophoridae,
which is restricted to Further India and the great Malay Islands, has
developed a remarkable sutural tube on the exterior of the last whorl,
near the aperture, A similar tube, but more obscure, exists in
Alycaeus. Several stages in the development of this tube may be
noticed, beginning with the elevation of part of the peristome into a
simple irregular shelly plate, which is continued, first into a short, and
then into a long tube, which becomes soldered to the shell; finally,
the tube becomes free, and the anterior part of the last whorl is
disconnected from the spire (Fig. 180 A-D).