Professional Documents
Culture Documents
different
kinds of
ways to be
all over the place
Hannah Todt
1
To all
leuze and Félix Guattari horizontally along or just below the soil surface. It can be
quite long and branch in many directions. Unlike roots,
rhizomes are divided into nodes, and roots and new plants
can grow from these nodes. Tracing the origin of a rhizome
is a difficult undertaking.
6 7
INTRODUCTION RETHINKING
INTRODUCTION
PRIORITIES
8 9
FISH OR FOWL Jane Rendell, Critical
4
In the context of art making, the prefixes „multi“ and
Spatial Practices. Setting
Out a Feminist Approach
„inter“ have been described by Jane Rendell as distinct ways
to some Modes and what of integrating various media. For Rendell, multidisciplinary
Matters in Architecture, art involves the juxtaposition of a multitude of techniques
in: BROWN, Lori (Ed.), and materials within one project. Each medium retains its
Feminist Practices: Inter-
disciplinary Approaches
distinctiveness and autonomy. Interdisciplinary art on the
to Women in Architecture, other hand focuses on transitions between disciplines, in
Routledge, 2011 order to understand the relationships between them.4
Given the terminology defined by Rendell I wonder if dis-
5
I like to think of it as
tinguishing between the two terms does not run counter to
“I am sure that no two people have the same 3
Deborah Hay, My Body,
internal or invisible the desire for versatility. Artists might find themselves in a
the Buddhist, Wesleyan
definitions of „body“. For some of us, the way we University Press, 2000 processes like learning, state of ambiguity, where they must balance the desire for
digesting, changing opi- personal expression and autonomy with the practical need
write the body can fluctuate even in the course of nions or growing a baby
to react to market demands with flexibility and adaptabil-
a day. I have come to understand that the body in the uterus.
ity. I am interested in the relationship between need and
as form and content is not what it seems to be, necessity, between freedom and free will, or basically any
and that my dances are not about specific transition between two modes that is intangible.5
The tricky part is to position yourself in the face of a mul-
subjects.” 3 titude of possibilities, and to create your own vocabulary
given the many different languages you can speak.
12 13
FISH OR FOWL FISH OR FOWL
14 15
VESSEL INSTRUMENTS A flute is what I like to refer to as a vessel instrument. The
basic requirement for a vessel instrument is a resonating
body that you can blow into with mouth air. That means
that an empty beer bottle is also a flute. Or an oil lamp.
The difference between the flute and its little sister, the
whistle, is blurry. A whistle, according to Western musical
notation, may produce a less distinct tonality. Nevertheless,
with a little practice, you can change the pitch by changing
the angle of attack, and thus transform the whistle into a
flute. Such a whistle would be, for example, the acorn hat,
which is used in Austria as an emergency whistle if you
ever get lost in the mountains. By clamping the acorn hat
between the fingers and blowing hard, a very, very, very
loud whistling sound is produced. The same can be repeated
with shells, plastic lids, bells, walnut shells, generally all
sorts of vessel-like objects small enough to fit between your
fingers. You see, flutes and whistles speak many languages:
they are warning signals, musical instruments or imitate
animal sounds. To me, they are containers in which I collect
processes and experiences and redistribute them as stories.
16 17
VESSEL INSTRUMENTS VESSEL INSTRUMENTS
18 19
VESSEL INSTRUMENTS VESSEL INSTRUMENTS
If, for example, you take a shell found on the beach and 8
Jordan Flaherty, No More 10
Angela Mesiti, The If you have a hat, you can turn it upside down, and then
use it as a whistle, the question arises as to what a shell Heroes, AK Press, 2016 Calling, 3 channel video you have your own carrier bag. An acorn hat is a miniature
installation, digital video,
is, as well as what a whistle is, or, to go further, how value 9
Ursula K. Le Guin, The sound, 35:36 min., 2013-14 carrier bag. Last summer I learned to use it as a whistle. I
is attributed according to symbolism, function, form, and Carrier Bag Theory of Ficti- have found that animals respond to this whistle in differ-
language. It is also linked to the question of how stories are on, Ignota Books, 2020 ent ways. Birds answer by chirping back, sheep startle, and
told and how we decide which part of the story to make the cats run away. If I had whistled in the Turkish village of
protagonist, if we do that at all. Kuskoy, on the Greek island of Evia or the Canary Island of
Maybe we decide for protagonists, but perhaps temporary La Gomera, I might have received a response in whistling
ones who take turns or complement each other, instead of language. The video installation „The Calling“ by Angela
heroic leaders who dominate the story. Jordan Flaherty’s Mesiti explores human whistling languages and the people
book „No more Heroes“ comes to mind.8 He talks about her- who still use them.10 The work shows how the languages
oism as a privilege, a person that is, as savior, more skilled have transformed from their traditional use as means of
and powerful than the rest of us, implying that others need communication across great distances into tourist at-
to be rescued. In a certain way, acts of heroism reinforce tractions and cultural artifacts, while still being taught to
that privilege, which is why heroism in itself follows a school children.
dividing rather than a uniting cause. Furthermore, Flaherty
talks especially about cis, white heroism, people who want
to help and “just mean well”, without being especially suited
to provide a certain kind of help. The problematic nature
of this approach is further amplified when the people who
are the „victims“, or in other words, the people who receive
help, have either not asked for it or are not actively involved
in the process of change.
Ursula K. Le Guin offers another take on heroism and sto-
rytelling. Her essay „The Carrier-Bag Theory of Fiction” chal-
lenges the traditional, hero-centered narrative structure
that, in her opinion, dominates much of Western literature
and privileges individualism, competition, and conquest
over collaboration and mutual support.9 Le Guin proposes
a “carrier-bag theory” of storytelling, which is based on the
idea that the earliest human tool was not a weapon, but a
container for carrying food, water, and other necessities.
The carrier bag represents a more communal mode of A few months after I had acorn-whistled from hand to
storytelling, by valuing the collection and preservation of mouth for the first time, I decided to cast some hats in
diverse perspectives, experiences and voices. Rather than bronze. I wanted to know if the timbre would change with
focusing on the journey of a single hero, the carrier-bag the material and what bronze would sound like, and I want-
collects multiple narratives that come together and cherish ed to make whistles that were sturdy and durable. Whistles
the complexity of human experience. that could provide some sort of support.
20 21
VESSEL INSTRUMENTS
22
DEPENDENCE IS Céline Condorelli, ibid. Acorn hats, just like bowls, shells, bags or vessels, are
12
tion and Exuberance, in: you are holding in your hands, as they carry ink and the
LAUWAERT, Maaike, VAN words you are reading.
WESTRENEN, Francien When talking about objects that are also containers, I think
(Ed.), Facing Value. Radical of the artist Céline Condorelli, who uses display or support
perspectives from the arts,
Valiz, Amsterdam, 2017 as a means to address both the discourse on objects and the
discourse on containers. She believes that this approach can
Maggie Nelson, On Free-
14
help ease the tension between art and ideological critique
dom: Four songs of care and allow for a practice that reconnects form and the social,
and constraint, Penguin
“I would like to claim nothing of disciplines and Céline Condorelli,
11
http://www.celinecondo- Random House, 2021 two things that are often seen as separate.12
their complicated boundaries, but I am interested relli.eu/files/curacondo- For me, visualizing structures is also about ascribing value
relliwadedisplay-min. to connections and relating to one another. Being inspired
in the relationship between things, ideas, pdf, 2015 is often thought of as an internal ability born out of one.
people, and how that takes place in space – and This assumption is based on the illusion of the „infinite
in taking up a position that therefore still has potency of the self“13, as Jan Verwoert calls it, and overshad-
ows the approach that most of our ideas arise from latent
some room for manoeuvre.” 11
memories. According to Verwoert, acknowledging our
indebtedness to others as a necessary condition for our own
agency means that we must also recognize the significance
of care. For me, it is also about positively connoting the idea
of dependency: relating to each other, supporting each oth-
er, needing each other; in short, dependence is not a drug.
Connectedness, however, should not eliminate the possibil-
ity of growing or changing one’s mind. Because, as Maggie
Nelson has it, „very rarely does one story ‘stick’ throughout a
life“14.
24 25
DEPENDENCE IS NOT A DRUG DEPENDENCE IS NOT A DRUG
26 27
INSIDE THE OUTSIDE The car as a place of transit offers a protected intimacy that
four straight sheetrock walls do not. Maybe it’s because
a car doesn’t have four walls, but usually more or less,
depending on where you’re looking at it from. There’s the
trunk, for example, which is again a room within a room,
so it’s hard to say how many exterior walls there are. In
many cars, for example, the space where I don’t know what
it’s called, where the engine and all the organs are, is open
at the bottom. As if the abdominal cavity could be opened
with a front lid, and you can see into the magic of life, and
“I think the question is whether the mouth skin 15
Daniel Fonatti
the back simply doesn’t exist, everything hangs and holds
is now actually inside walls or part of the facade, on somewhere, to the inner walls, or to each other. The
poor car organs, are totally exposed to many circumstances,
because if they are actually one with the skin noise and dust from below, hot asphalt roads in summer,
outside via the lips, are we then tubes or pipes.” 15 or snow storms. Floor plates exist only for the people who
drive this system. Compared to normal rooms, the car
offers faster escape, because unless you sit in the back in
the middle, you can actually always lean on the door. That
means that your own of the „four“ walls is actually also a
door, which makes it easier to stay mobile and leave the
„room“ in an emergency. Everything is so flexible.
The steering wheel moves the conversation in different
directions, and you find yourself in familiar places, no
longer on the sidewalk, but in the middle of the street, in
the middle of it all, here we go! No matter where you drive,
the conversation always stays connected and doesn’t jump
around randomly. The hare hops differently here. No one on
the outside can hear you, and yet somehow you’re in public
space. You can be onlookers. This gives the car such a spe-
cial status when you’re trying to feel comfortable in spaces.
28 29
BERRIES IN A BASKET Imagine you are taking a very long walk along a path called
„Thesis Research“. There are berry bushes growing along
each side of the path. You may have been walking for a long
time when you see that the once green berries have become
juicy and ripe. Those that catch your eye are the ones that
are waiting for you to pick them. You collect them in your
basket, where they gather, share experiences, and possibly
breed new ideas by learning from each other.
30 31
THERE ARE NO ACCIDENTS I vividly remember a The other day I broke two vertebrae when I fell down the
17
32 33
THERE ARE NO ACCIDENTS THERE ARE NO ACCIDENTS
36 37
ONE THING LEADS TO ANOTHER ONE THING LEADS TO ANOTHER
A few days later, I noticed something strange. I could not A pair of stonewashed jeans
get that puzzle piece out of my head. I began to imagine
all the things it could have been a part of and wrote them
The contrail of an airplane
down in a list. Zoomed in
Into the end of a 35mm film
A forget-me-not
A galaxy
Sea spray generated by breaking waves
A prototype
A gradient
A transition
A transient
A 20 Euro bill
A credit card
A shoelace
A neon light
An iceberg
A Bob Ross painting
The packaging of a milky way candy bar
It could be hair
Eyes
Nails
Veins
Liquid
Solid
A break
A fade
A phase
38 39
ONE THING LEADS TO ANOTHER ONE THING LEADS TO ANOTHER
40 41
ONE THING LEADS TO ANOTHER ONE THING LEADS TO ANOTHER
Around the same time that I stumbled upon the puzzle ming with Laure Prouvost,
Manuella éditions, 2022
piece, I was invited to give a five-minute performance at
Oscillation Festival 2022 in Brussels. I decided to turn the
list of words into a song that I would share with the audience.
Later, I recorded that song and turned the photos that I
had collected into a video clip, which then became the video
work „Could be“.
42 43
DIFFERENT KINDS OF Since last fall, I’ve noticed that I increasingly feel the desire
to work in collaborations. For this reason, together with
WAYS TO BE ALL OVER Anna Lugmeier, Francesca Hawker and Johanne Shan, we
THE PLACE
decided to initiate the event “RESTWäRME” (German = re-
sidual heat). “RESTWäRME” was our first attempt to create a
format dedicated to sharing artistic processes. Rather than
presenting finished works or performances, the evening
was intended to bridge academic, institutional, and festive
events. We sent out an email among our circle of friends
encouraging participation and sharing. In that email, we
described the goals of the evening as follows:
44 45
DIFFERENT KINDS OF WAYS TO BE ALL OVER THE PLACE DIFFERENT KINDS OF WAYS TO BE ALL OVER THE PLACE
We also established a few ground rules for the evening’s The first initiation of “RESTWäRME” met with great inter-
proceedings that would be applied to future events: est. About one hundred people came to see six contribu-
tions. Since we had not expected such a crowd, the desire to
– Host: The event will be opened by a different host each time, create a safe space for sharing turned into something else,
who will guide the participants through the evening. much bigger and more elusive. We received mostly positive
– Contributions do not have to stick to any particular artistic feedback, and soon people who had attended the event were
practice, but should last a maximum of 15 minutes. asking about the next edition of “RESTWäRME”. It was a
– Closing Song: The end of the evening is introduced with a beautiful and overwhelming evening. As organizers, I think
closing song performed by a different person (or duo) each time. we all agreed that we needed to digest for a moment before
– There is a guestbook where you can sign up for future events we could start thinking about a sequel. Especially since, in
and express your interest to participate next time as host or retrospect, we realized that each of us might have imagined
performer. Furthermore there is the possibility to take care of this evening differently.
the decoration, drinks or snacks.
46
DIFFERENT KINDS OF WAYS TO BE ALL OVER THE PLACE
Glander
Another attempt I made to create a collaboration around A performance score
a performative gesture was the performance “Glander” Hannah Todt, 2023
(French = to waste one’s time doing nothing), which took
Glander (french) = Wasting time doing nothing; lazing around or doing useless things
place in December 2022 in a largely abandoned shopping
mall in Brussels, on the occasion of the opening of the What? A guided sound improvisation
exhibition La Bassine, curated by Lola Meotti. I taught some Who? At least 5 performers
Clothes? Everyday clothes
friends in advance how to whistle with acorn hats. During Length? Variable
a five to ten minute long performance following a score, Location? Variable – public spaces, open fields, exhibition spaces, …
Props? One acorn hat per person plus the five bronze acorns for one of the performers
we used acorn hats as whistles to communicate with each
other in different rhythms, volumes and tonalities. I. Tuning / In the beginning the performers gather to tune in with each other. It is important in order
to set the tone for the following interaction and to feel connected to the group. To tune, each
performer places an acorn hat between their fingers and begins to blow air into their fist, until they
Although both the first edition of “RESTWäRME” and find the right placement of the acorn and thus the whistle. One person starts, followed by the others.
“Glander” received a positive response, there were no fol- At this moment, there is no rush. The performers take their time to tune.
low-up events. In the future, instead of moving from one
II. Introduction / The performers will spread out in the space. They move around until they find a spot
project to the next, I would like to give first attempts more that they like and remain standing in silence for a while. The person in possession of the bronze
space to develop. It would have been important for both acorns initiates the performance by rubbing them between their hands. They rub and shake them to
make sound, and they may walk around.
“RESTWäRME” and “Glander” to come together as a group
afterwards, and share our personal impressions in order to III. Dialogue / After a few minutes, the first performer begins to whistle. At this moment, the whistlers
understand how a collective process can grow. A sense of should take it slow, which means that one person's whistle is followed by silence. Imagine a dialogue
between the performers where one person says something and the others answer a few seconds later.
community can be short-lived if we don’t enter and exit the A conversation that goes back and forth between the group members.
experience in an adequate way. I realized that developing
a collaboration (especially in the early phase) requires a lot IV. Chaos / In this phase the whistles get more and more intense, thus more frequent and louder. They
might overlap and interrupt each other. If desired, one whistler can approach another and try to
of time and dedication. Regarding my upcoming diploma, it synchronize with them, finding a common whistling rhythm, and then separating again by moving
didn’t seem doable to let these collective projects manifest on. During this chaotic part, the person holding the bronze acorns passes them to another performer.
in such a short period of time or to integrate them into my V. Wind down / To end part IV., the group members will wind down, find a slower pace and whistle less
diploma project. However, it remains my intention to pur- frequently (but this does not mean they become quieter). The person who received the bronze acorns
sue collaborative projects more profoundly in the future. assesses when the performers are "out of breath" and begins rubbing or shaking the bronze acorns
between their hands to make noise. The use of the bronze acorns signals to the group that their
whistling should slowly fade out. The metallic rubbing sound of the bronze acorns should end up
being the only sound audible after everyone has stopped whistling.
General guidelines
• Slow down: Take your time, don’t rush. Create an atmosphere, tune in, and have a dialogue with each other. It is
good to take things slowly.
• Position: Throughout, the whistlers can stand still, sit, lie down or walk around if they feel like it.
• Connect: Try to maintain regular eye contact with the other performers. It makes a difference to feel connected
and to not wonder what the fuck you are doing here. When you look into the eyes of someone who is making the
same gesture as you, you are reminded that something is happening, that there is a connection, and things start to
make more sense.
• Volume: Be loud! It may feel like you are taking up all the acoustic space, but you are not. Remember that you may
always sound very different to others than to yourself.
• Humidity: If you can’t whistle anymore because your fingers and acorn are too wet from your spit,
take the time to dry them a bit with your sweater.
48
FROM HAND When you are a baby, you instinctively bring your hands to
your mouth. You chew on them until they’re soft and wrin-
TO MOUTH kly from the spit, without knowing that they will one day be
the hands that feed you.
During the pandemic, we were asked to keep our hands
away from our mouths, and even more so the hands of
others. The mask was the tool that reminded us of this.
Instead, the hands were used for other movements; an
itchy nose, for example, was quieted by rubbing the mask in
circular motions. The hands should avoid touching bodies
while continuing to perform work-related activities.
When using your hands for work, there are different ways
to do so. For example, so-called handcrafts, like knitting or
kneading dough, require dexterity and coordinated muscle
strength. Often, it’s more about the upper ends of the hand,
the fingertips, which are then used, for example, to type on
a computer keyboard. Some people can be surgeons, if they
have a steady hand.
Many professions require a person to move their hands in
a repetitive motion. The gesture is part of a larger whole
of gestures performed by other hands, which can lead to
individuals wondering what purpose their gesture serves,
ultimately leading to alienation.
50 51
FROM HAND TO MOUTH FROM HAND TO MOUTH
52 53
55
CONCLUSION Dear A,
56 57
CONCLUSION CONCLUSION
58 59
REFERENCES Bibliography
BERARDI, Franco, The Age of Impotence and the Horizon of Possibility, London, Verso, 2020
BOLTANSKI, Luc & CHIAPELLO, Eve, The New Spirit of Capitalism, London, Verso, 2005
CAGE, John, Empty Mind, Berlin, Suhrkamp, 2013
CAIRO, Aminata, Holding Space: A Storytelling Approach to Trampling Diversity and Inclusion,
Figures Aminata Cairo Consultancy, 2021
DEWEY, John, Art As Experience, New York, Perigee Trade, 1980
All drawings, photos and video stills: Hannah Todt DUSAPIN, Alice, Wolfgang Stoerchle: Success in Failure, Paris, Daisy Editions/Daviet-Thery,
Photo p. 42: Camille Poitevin 2022
RESTWäRME photos: Johanne Shan, Hannah Todt FISHER, Mark, Kapitalistischer Realismus ohne Alternative ?, Hamburg, VSA Verlag, 2020
FISCHLI, Peter, WEISS, David, Plötzlich diese Übersicht, Zurich, Stähli, 2001
Fonts FLAHERTY, Jordan, No More Heroes, Chico, AK Press, 2016
Via LIBRE FRONTS BY WOMXN GOLDBERG, RoseLee (Ed.), Laurie Anderson, New York, Harry N. Abrams, 2000
Combine by Julie Patard GRAEBER, David, Bullshit Jobs, Paris, Les Liens Qui Libèrent, 2019
Rasa by Anna Giedryś and David Březina GRAEBER, David, Pour une anthropologie anarchiste, Paris, Éditions Lux, 2006
HAY, Deborah, My Body, the Buddhist, Middletown, Wesleyan University Press, 2000
Articles LAUWAERT, Maaike, VAN WESTRENEN, Francien (Ed.), Facing Value. Radical perspectives
from the arts, Amsterdam, Valiz, 2017
MOUFFE, Chantal, Artistic Activism and Agonistic Spaces, in: ART & RESEARCH. A Journal of LE GUIN, Ursula K., The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction, London, Ignota Books, 2020
Ideas, Contexts and Methods, Volume 1, n° 2, summer 2007, https://chisineu.files.wordpress. NELSON, Maggie, On Freedom: Four songs of care and constraint, Dublin, Penguin Random
com/2012/07/biblioteca_mouffe_artistic-activism.pdfm.pdf House, 2021
CONDORELLI, Céline, WADE, Gavin, You Display, I Display, We Display, http://www.celine- PROUVOST, Laure, LEGSICON, London/Antwerp, Book Works/M HKA, 2019
condorelli.eu/files/curacondorelliwadedisplay-min.pdf, 2015 ROMAN, Mathilde, Swimming with Laure Prouvost, Paris, Manuella éditions, 2022.
MILLET, Catherine, The Wealth in Art. Luc Boltanski and Arnaud Esquerre talking to Cath- RAINER, Cosima, ROLLIG, Stella, DANIELS, Dieter, e.a., See This Sound, Promises in Sound
erine Millet, Artpress No.441, February 2017, p. 32-40 and Vision, Cologne, Verlag der Buchhandlung Walther König, 2009
RENDELL, Jane, Critical Spatial Practices. Setting Out a Feminist Approach to some Modes
Audiovisual sources and what Matters in Architecture, in: BROWN, Lori (Ed.), Feminist Practices: Interdisciplinary
CURTIS, Adam (Dir.), Can‘t Get You Out of My Head : An Emotional History of the Modern Approaches to Women in Architecture, Abingdon-on-Thames, Routledge, 2011
World, UK, BBC Film, 2021 SONTAG, Susan, Notes on „Camp“, London, Penguin Classics, 2018
LYNCH, David (Dir.), Lamp, US, David Lynch, 2003 STEYERL, Hito, Duty Free Art. Art in the Age of Planetary Civil War, London, Verso, 2019
MESITI, Angela, The Calling, 3 channel video installation, digital video, sound, 35:36 min.,
2013-14
60 61
GRATITUDE Gratitude from very deep inside to
62 63
„If meaning can be created through everyday experiences and encounters, we
can begin to imagine a shift in the attribution of value, and with it a separation
of creation from commodity, process from progress, and worth from monetary
different
kinds of
ways to be
all over the place is a rhizomic arrangement of drawings,
photographs and various literary forms such as essays, song lyrics and au-
tomatic writing that aims to interpret versatility as feminist practice. The
anthology focuses on the exploration of storytelling and how the mean-
ing of (hi)stories may change through a shift in perspective. Immaterial
values that are crucial to creative processes, such as learning, unlearning,
sharing, supporting, engaging, collaborating, or showing vulnerability are
playfully reappropriated and put in relation to one another.