Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Supermarkets, Inc.
Submitted to
Tom Cavanagh
Knights Investment Group
Orlando, Florida
by
José E. Romero Martínez
This report analyzes the potential advantages and disadvantages of acquiring Publix Supermar-
kets, Inc. as part of the future investment profile for Knights Investment Group (KIG). The docu-
ment briefly examines the company’s history and current brand offerings and divestments. Using
the 2021 Annual Report to stakeholders and additional qualitative sources, the report suggests
that acquiring Publix will be significantly beneficial to the company’s future. Additional recom-
mendations are also provided regarding a smoother transition before and after corporate acquisi-
tion.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Publix Supermarkets, Inc. is a Lakeland, Florida-based grocery and supermarket chain dedi-
cated to providing quality produce, excellent customer service, and a stake in employee growth
through its employee-owned stock program. The study intends to analyze the company profile
for Publix and determine its suitability for acquisition by Knights Investment Group (KIG). Busi-
ness managers, financial stakeholders, market researchers, and Publix employees and manage-
ment will benefit from reading this report as they will engage in new opportunities to seek
growth and expand in careers in the retain and grocery industries.
Publix exhibits major advantages that make the company a suitable candidate for acquisition, in-
cluding:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.......................................................................................................................2
LIST OF TABLES.....................................................................................................................................3
LIST OF FIGURES...................................................................................................................................3
INTRODUCTION.....................................................................................................................................4
PURPOSE..................................................................................................................................................4
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY.........................................................................................................4
SCOPE AND METHODOLOGY............................................................................................................4
COMPANY PROFILE..............................................................................................................................5
COMPANY BRANDS AND VENTURES...............................................................................................5
ADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION OF PUBLIX SUPERMARKETS, INC......................................6
Publix has a growing store operations and consumer base...................................................................6
The company’s sales, gross profit, investment income and net earnings have increased in the past
three years...............................................................................................................................................6
Publix is nationally recognized as a leader in customer service satisfaction........................................7
Publix is committed to sustainability and social responsibility..............................................................7
Publix faces little competition in Florida...............................................................................................8
DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION OF PUBLIX SUPERMARKETS, INC...............................8
Will the employee stock ownership plan be reformed?..........................................................................8
How ready is Publix for publicly embracing LGBT+ rights?................................................................9
Can Publix reconcile with the Fair Food Program?...........................................................................10
CONCLUSION........................................................................................................................................10
RECOMMENDATIONS........................................................................................................................10
REFERENCES........................................................................................................................................12
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Summary of sales, gross profit, investment income, and net earnings for Publix Supermarkets
between 2019, 2020, and 2021. Source: Publix Supermarkets 10, 11..........................................................7
Table 2: Summarized depiction of donations and recipients provided by Publix in 2021. Source: Publix
Supermarkets, 4...........................................................................................................................................8
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Graphic chart of active Publix store locations by state in 2021. Source: Publix Supermarkets, 1
.................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Figure 2: Select Share Price for Publix Staff and Employees between 2021 and 2022. Source: Publix As-
set Management Company, 2022.................................................................................................................9
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 4
INTRODUCTION
Publix Supermarkets, Inc. is a Lakeland, Florida-based supermarket chain dedicated to provid-
ing quality produce, excellent customer service, and a stake in employee growth through its em-
ployee-owned stock program. Having never experienced a layoff from since the business was
founded in 1930, even during the great Recession (Anderson, 2009), the company boasts a vital
cultural profile, appreciation, and stability for both Florida residents and visitors. Thus, acquiring
Publix Supermarkets as the holding company for knights Investment Group (KIG), which is also
based in Central Florida, serves to be an attractive opportunity for expansion into the retail trade
business. With an estimated private valuation of $45 billion as of November 2021, the company
has secured its market brand and both employee and customer loyalty a part of its culture (Bary,
2022).
PURPOSE
The purpose of the study is to analyze the company profile for Publix Supermarkets and deter-
mine its suitability and/or feasibility for acquisition by Knights Investment Group (KIG).
We have used the 2021 Annual Report to Stakeholders as the main basis for financial figures re-
garding the company’s fiscal health. (The 2021 fiscal year for Publix ended on December 25,
2021.) We also reviewed news articles, business trade publications, and market reviews to ad-
dress the company’s public reception and national recognition.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 5
COMPANY PROFILE
In 1930, George W. Johnson resigned from a four-year career as a manager of a Piggly Wiggly
in Winter Haven, Florida, and decided to open a store called Publix Food Store. He named the
store “Publix” due to a chain of movie theaters of the same name. Five years later, Jenkins
opened a second store in Winter Haven. Eventually, he established the first Publix Super Market
and thus began the supermarket’s expansion. From acquiring a warehouse to replacing stores in
larger supermarkets, Publix expanded to dominate its competition in Central Florida and moving
into South Florida in the sixties; acquiring Albertson stores and opening new retail opportunities
in the Pensacola area; and expanding to the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic (Miller, 2022). Outside
of Florida, Publix stores are also located in Georgia (1991), South Carolina (1993), Alabama
(1996), Tennessee (2002), North Carolina (2014) and Virginia (2017), with an announced expan-
sion into the Louisville, Kentucky area in late 2013.
Publix Aprons provides cooking classes in both in-person and online settings where
chefs teach and prepare meals for students, as well as virtual cooking classes through
YouTube (“Publix Aprons”). Customers can sign up for different cooking events at
twelve (12) cooking school locations throughout the Southeast—nine in Florida, and one
location each in Alabama, Georgia, and Virginia (“Publix Aprons® Cooking School”
2022).
Publix GreenWise Market is a retail concept that emerges from the health food trends
established by upscale groceries like Whole Foods Market and capitalizes on the com-
pany’s GreenWise® organic brand. President Kevin Murphy stated about the concept
upon the opening of a Tampa, Florida store, “Our curated mix of high-quality specialty
make-at-home and grab-and-go items will add a level of convenience for residents and
visitors looking for easy meal solutions” (Bendychowski 2021). Publix GreenWise Mar-
ket has eight (8) locations in the Southeast—seven in Florida (Boca Raton, Fort Laud-
erdale, Lakeland, Nocatee, Odessa, Tallahassee, and Tampa) and one in Mountain beach,
Alabama.
Publix Sabor was created in 2005 as an extension of the Publix brand by providing His-
panic and Caribbean products towards the fast-growing Hispanic population in Central
and South Florida. While the stores have a smaller square feet footprint than the typical
Publix store, they also provide a welcoming environment for Hispanic customers whilst
not alienating the rest of the consumer base. As director of media and communications
Mara Brown mentioned in 2005, “You don’t have to be a Hispanic customer to love this
store. You just have a greater variety [of ethnic products] here” (Blank 2005). Publix Sa-
bor also has competition with other regional ethnic supermarkets such as Presidente Su-
permarkets, Key Foods/Bravo Supermarkets, and Sedano’s.
Publix Pharmacy was created in 1986 in Altamonte Springs, Florida, and the venture
has expanded to where over 90% of stores have a pharmacy by providing health services,
medications, and consultations to customers. Publix Pharmacy has been reported by J.D.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 6
Power as having the highest Overall customer satisfaction among brick-and-mortar super-
markets as of 2016, third in 2018, and second in 2019 (Effler 2016, 2018, 2019). Publix
pharmacy also had a free antibiotics and medication program between 2007 and 2022; as
of June 1, 2022, however, “maintenance medications like lisinopril and amlodipine will
be accessible at a reduced price” (Hendren 2022).
Figure 1: Graphic chart of active Publix store locations by state in 2021. Source: Publix Super-
markets, 1
The company’s sales, gross profit, investment income and net earnings have increased in the
past three years.
Per the company’s fiscal year and comparisons with 2019 and 2020, the company’s sales earning
amounted to $48.0 billion dollars in 2021, compared to $44.9 billion in 2020 and $38.1 billion in
2019. The company attributes this growth in sales to the pandemic and the increase in product
costs (Publix Supermarkets, 10). Gross profit has remained stable in the same three-year period,
from 29.2% in 2019 to 27.4% in 2021, attributed to “increased production costs” and the pan-
demic to a minor degree (Publix Supermarkets, 10). Regarding investment income, Publix
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 7
earned $1.3 billion in 2021 compared to $975 million in 2020 and $814 million in 2019. Net
earnings also reflect an increase among the last three comparison years, to $4.41 billion in 2021
against $3.97 billion in 2020 and $3 billion in 2019. A summary can be found below on Table 1:
Table 1: Summary of sales, gross profit, investment income, and net earnings for Publix Super-
markets between 2019, 2020, and 2021. Source: Publix Supermarkets 10, 11
participates in the program, as well as purchase additional shares if desired (Bary 2012). Stock
prices are set quarterly by the company for employees to purchase and must be sold back to the
company at a five-for-one split (set in April 2022) for liquidity. Company dividends are also paid
out quarterly using the program (please see Publix Asset Management Company; see Graph 2).
May 2021 August 2021 November 2021 March 2022 April 2022 May 2022
Quarter
Rosen and Coney argue that companies with an ESOP program have grown faster than their con-
temporaries in part to the “synergy” between ownership and worker participation—where em-
ployees are incentivized to become productive owners committed to company growth, and their
innovative ideas allow the company to thrive (1987).
In Publix’s case, the acquisition may be immediately considered a threat to the company’s ESOP
structure. We strongly suggest that this structure be maintained—or at the very least modified to
satisfy shareholder requirements with equal benefits to the previous ESOP program—to retain
talent and prime its position to continuous growth. (It is important to note that Publix is currently
not unionized.)
that Publix would refuse to cover a prescription for PrEP or pre-exposure prophylaxis, a medica-
tion used to help prevent the spread of HIV to users. After a meeting with Florida Rep. Carlos G.
Smith (D-Orlando), the company agreed to provide services for PrEP in 2018 (Lynch 2018).
However, the company was embroiled in scandal earlier this year over the alleged donation of
$200,000 dollars to lobbying sponsors of the Parental Rights in Education bill (also known as the
“Don’t Say Gay” bill in Florida), earning the hashtag #BoycottPublix on Twitter and receiving
criticism from both employees and consumers (Kika 2022).
At the same time, the company has allowed employees with same-sex spouses to enroll in health-
care and dental plans since 2014, even before same-sex marriage became legal in Florida and
other Southern states (Lobesco 2014). Given the controversies, it is important that the company
take strides in visibly improving relations between the LGBT+ community, staff, employees, and
allies in encouraging trust and confident in the company’s commitment to equality and diversity.
For companies joining the Fair Food Program, there has been a significant decrease in reports of
labor exploitation and sexual misconduct in participating farms. However, the Fair Food Pro-
gram has continuously lobbied for Publix’s including in the program to no avail. Fort Myers,
Florida resident and collaborator Patricia Krause has written on this matter: “It is a disservice to
[Publix’s] customers who, if educated on this issue, would hesitate to buy food that is tainted by
blood, sweat, and tears” (2018). Thus, a priority for acquisition must include having Publix join
the Fair Food Program and become a collaborator in the organization’s commitment to fair and
ethical food products.
CONCLUSION
Through this report, the feasibility for acquiring Publix Supermarkets by Knights Investment
Group (KIG) can be determined not only quantitatively through its earnings and investment pro-
file, but also gauging the company’s commitment (and potential improvement) through qualita-
tive standards. A smoother transition can be guaranteed by committing to maintain Publix as an
employee-owned company but allowing for changes in certain corporate practices through acqui-
sition, as well as commit towards great inclusivity and appreciation to the changes consumers are
looking towards values-based marketing. Thus, acquiring Publix provides an important path to-
wards greater financial solvency for KIG, as well as credit trustworthiness and a commitment to-
wards personal and professional growth.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Continue with the company’s regional growth development and outreach in the South-
east.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 11
Leave the ESOP intact, or alternatively provide a new financial incentives scheme that
encourages participation and empowers employees to keep working with Publix.
Stop funding organizations that promote policies against the LGBT+ community.
Have Publix join the Fair Food Program and guarantee that the products created and con-
sumed in its stores have been sourced through ethical means.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 12
REFERENCES
Anderson, G. (2009, February 10). Publix just says ‘no’ to layoffs – RetailWire. RetailWire.
https://retailwire.com/discussion/publix-just-says-no-to-layoffs/
Bary, A. (n.d.). Employee-Owned Publix Offers a Lesson for Other Supermarket Chains. Re-
trieved July 13, 2022, from https://www.barrons.com/articles/employee-owned-publix-
lesson-supermarket-chains-51642717801
Bary, A. (2021, Jauary). Employee-owned Publix offers a lesson for other supermarket chains.
Barron’s. https://www.barrons.com/articles/employee-owned-publix-lesson-supermarket-
chains-51642717801
Berdychowski, B. (n.d.). In the new Tampa Publix GreenWise Market, lots of organic food and
kombucha. Tampa Bay Times. Retrieved July 11, 2022, from
https://www.tampabay.com/news/business/2021/08/19/in-the-new-tampa-publix-greenwise-
market-lots-of-organic-food-and-kombucha/
Blank, C. (2005, May 2). Publix’s “Sabor” include snew look. Supermarket News.
https://www.supermarketnews.com/archive/publixs-sabor-includes-new-look
Brady, D., Debter, L., Council, J., McGregor, J., & Swant, M. (n.d.). The Forbes Halo 100 2022.
Forbes. Retrieved July 17, 2022, from https://www.forbes.com/halo-100/
Corporate Equality Index 2022. (n.d.). HRC Digital Reports. Retrieved July 20, 2022, from
https://reports.hrc.org/corporate-equality-index-2022?
_ga=2.32318902.94432203.1658345966-803290871.1658345966
Effler, G. (2018, August 28). 2018 U.S. Pharmacy Study. J.D. Power.
https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2018-us-pharmacy-study
Effler, G. (2019, August 20). 2019 U.S. Pharmacy Study. J.D. Power.
https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/2019-us-pharmacy-study
Farkas, S. O. (n.d.). Gabriela Golder – Kadist [KADIST]. KADIST. Retrieved July 12, 2022,
from https://kadist.org/program/gabriela-golder/
Harrison, J., Owdom, M., Pitchford, D., Stratton, A., & Warren, B. (2018). Publix Supermarkets,
Inc. Robins Case Network; Robins Case Number. https://scholarship.richmond.edu/robins-
case-network/19
Hendren, L. (2022, April 4). Publix is ending its free prescription program. So here are other
options for cheap drugs. Wtsp.Com. https://www.wtsp.com/article/news/health/publix-end-
free-prescription-program/67-867393da-b92e-414b-aaf1-44e301465306
History | Publix Culture | About Publix. (n.d.). Publix Super Markets. Retrieved July 11, 2022,
from http://corporate.publix.com/about-publix/culture/history
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 13
Iannelli, J. (n.d.). Florida farmworkers say Publix won’t protect workers from sexual violence.
Miami New Times. Retrieved July 20, 2022, from
https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/publix-wont-protect-workers-from-rape-
farmworkers-say-9821058
Kika, T. (2022, April 25). How Publix got caught up in “Don’t Say Gay” aftermath. Newsweek.
https://www.newsweek.com/how-publix-got-caught-dont-say-gay-aftermath-1700661
Krause, P. (n.d.). I encourage Publix to join Fair Food Program. The News-Press. Retrieved
July 20, 2022, from
https://www.news-press.com/story/opinion/contributors/2018/01/31/encourage-publix-join-
fair-food-program/1080597001/
Lilly, C. (2021, May 20). Publix’s history of discrimination against LGBT workers. South Flor-
ida Gay News. https://southfloridagaynews.com/National/publix-s-history-of-
discrimination-against-lgbt-workers.html
Lobosco, K. (2014, December 30). Publix grocery, a southern grocery chain, is giving health
benefits to same-sex couples. CNNMoney. https://money.cnn.com/2014/12/30/pf/publix-
same-sex-benefits/index.html
Lynch, R. (2018, February 6). Publix to now give PrEP insurance coverage.
https://southfloridagaynews.com/Local/publix-to-now-give-prep-insurance-coverage.html
Miller, M. (2022, March 24). Publix Supermarket: Part of Florida history since 1930. Florida
Back Roads Travel. https://www.florida-backroads-travel.com/publix-supermarket.html
Myers, A., & Tedone. (2016, April 7). Publix’ marketing success: Driven by customer-centric
culture. AMA Tampa Bay. https://amatampabay.org/publix-marketing-success-customer-
centric-culture/
Nutcher, P. (2022, February 2). Publix is the top grocer on a new Forbes survey of customer ser-
vice and social responsibility. The Ledger.
https://www.theledger.com/story/business/2022/02/02/publix-ranks-no-1-among-grocers-
customer-service-and-charity/9314040002/
Pacific Oaks College, P. O. C. 2 min. (2021, 13). Breaking down the 4 types of corporate social
responsibility | Pacific Oaks College. Pacific Oaks College.
https://www.pacificoaks.edu/voices/business/breaking-down-the-4-types-of-corporate-
social-responsibility/
Publix Aprons® Cooking School. (n.d.). Publix Super Markets. Retrieved July 11, 2022, from
https://www.publix.com/aprons-cooking-school
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ACQUISITION 14
Publix Asset Management Company. (n.d.). Publix Stock Price | Historical Chart and Dividends
| Publix. Publix Super Markets. Retrieved July 21, 2022, from
http://www.publixstockholder.com/stock-and-dividend-information
Repko, M. (2021, November 4). Kroger is taking on Publix in Florida without opening a single
grocery store—And building a blueprint for its future. CNBC.
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/04/kroger-is-taking-on-publix-in-florida-without-opening-a-
single-grocery-store.html
Rosen, C., & Quarrey, M. (1987, September 1). How well is employee ownership working? Har-
vard Business Review. https://hbr.org/1987/09/how-well-is-employee-ownership-working
Silverstein, S. (n.d.). Aldi is the fastest-growing US grocery chain, report says. Grocery Dive.
Retrieved July 20, 2022, from https://www.grocerydive.com/news/aldi-is-the-fastest-
growing-us-grocery-chain-report-says/621501/
Spears, S. (2019, January 17). Why Florida loves Publix: An illustrated history. Florida Travel +
Life. https://www.floridatravellife.com/why-florida-loves-publix/
Tews, J., & Effler, G. (2016, August 29). J.D. Power 2016 U.S. Pharmacy Study. J.D. Power.
https://www.jdpower.com/business/press-releases/jd-power-2016-us-pharmacy-study
What Is Employee Ownership? | NCEO. (n.d.). Retrieved July 20, 2022, from
https://www.nceo.org/what-is-employee-ownership
Wright, E. (2015, July 15). Fair Food Program scandal at Publix. BORGEN.
https://www.borgenmagazine.com/fair-food-program-scandal-publix/