You are on page 1of 24

LIFE AMIDST TOMBSTONES: THE LIVED EXPERIENCES OF

FAMILIES RESIDING IN THE CEMETERY OF BIÑAN CITY

A Thesis
Presented To
The Faculty of the Senior High School
Biñan Integrated National High School
Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna

In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Subject
Practical Research 1

By

Dale Emmanuel M. Alsim


Mitch Ayeza S. Bacho
Kent T. Clamohoy
Reynald W. Dicdican
Jonalyn B. Lasala
Ashley Mae Q. Marquina
Armina A. Montañez
Rose Ann M. Ramos
Lester F. Salvador
Christine B. Vargas

May 2024

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 1 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Chapter 2
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter reviews the related literature, which supports and gives credence to the

details of this research. The researchers anchored this comprehensive study to different

viewpoints and perspectives to present a thorough treatment of the problem. Concepts,

findings, theories, and notions from scholarly research and articles related to the participants’

lived experiences in residing in the cemetery are presented to provide an extensive

background of the study and to justify the researchers' objective in undertaking it. This also

provides a synthesis of related literature, which later on may be confirmed, negated, or

improved by the new knowledge that this study provided.

Families Residing in the Cemetery

Lapatha et al. (2019) stated that families residing in cemeteries represent a unique and

often marginalized demographic, facing a mass of challenges and complexities in their living

environment. Despite the unconventional setting, these families form close communities

characterized by resilience and resourcefulness. And families living in cemetery settlements

often develop strong social bonds and support networks within their communities, relying on

one another for emotional and practical assistance. These close relationships contribute to a

sense of belonging and solidarity among residents, fostering a collective spirit of mutual aid

and cooperation (Smith et al., 2021).

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 2 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
The decision to reside in a cemetery setting is often driven by socio-economic factors such as

poverty, which can exacerbate the challenges faced by these families. Sodiya et al. (2021)

highlighted the prevalence of poverty among cemetery residents, with limited access to basic

amenities and healthcare services. This socio-economic vulnerability can perpetuate cycles of

deprivation and marginalization, further marginalizing families living in cemetery

environments. Moreover, families residing in cemeteries confront stigma and discrimination

from broader society, compounding their socio-economic challenges.

Despite these adversities, families residing in cemeteries demonstrate remarkable

resilience and resourcefulness in adapting to their environment. Cemetery residents have

creative solutions to meet their needs and wants, from community gardening initiatives to

advocacy for improved living conditions. By leveraging the strengths and forging bonds of

solidarity within the communities of families residing in the cemetery (Ghazali, 2021).

Advantages of Residing in the Cemetery

Living in a cemetery may seem unconventional, yet it offers unique advantages that cater

to the needs and circumstances of certain individuals or families. Firstly, cemetery

environments often provide a peaceful and serene atmosphere, away from the hustle and bustle

of urban life. The peaceful surroundings of cemeteries can offer a sense of solace and

contemplation, fostering mental well-being and relaxation for residents. Furthermore, the green

spaces within cemeteries may serve as recreational areas for residents, offering opportunities

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 3 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
for leisurely activities (Lorge, 2023).

The availability of vacant and underutilized spaces within cemeteries can provide an

alternative housing solution for marginalized populations. And the potential for repurposing

cemetery spaces for low-cost housing initiatives, addressing housing shortages and

homelessness in urban areas. For some families, the affordability of cemetery residences may

alleviate financial burdens and provide a pathway to stability and self-sufficiency (Dai et al.,

2022).

Lapatha et al. (2019) explained that families residing in the cemetery often develop strong

social bonds within their communities, relying on one another for emotional and practical

assistance. This sense of belonging can contribute to a heightened sense of security and stability

for residents, particularly in the face of adversity or challenges. Contrary to popular perception,

cemetery environments can foster communities characterized by mutual support and solidarity.

Moreover, living in a cemetery setting may offer proximity to cultural or historical

landmarks, enriching residents' experiences and sense of heritage. Cemeteries often contain

monuments, statues, and gravesites of historical significance, providing opportunities for

residents to connect with their cultural roots and traditions (Lapatha et al., 2019).

These advantages demonstrate that while residing in the cemetery may pose unique

challenges, it also offers opportunities for tranquility, community support, affordable housing,

and cultural enrichment for certain individuals.

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 4 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Disadvantages of Residing in the Cemetery

According to Borromeo et al. (2020), living in a cemetery presents various difficulties,

including emotional stress due to the frequent reminder of mortality, limited access to facilities

and services, and social stigma leading to social isolation. Cemeteries often lack essential

infrastructure for day-to-day life and may not align with societal conventions, causing conflict

and unease. Overall, the drawbacks such as psychological distress, practical difficulties, and

societal issues may outweigh any potential advantages of such living arrangements.

It can be challenging for the cemetery residents to have adequate room for their

equipment and personal items because of the limited area. To save money for expenses like

rent, utilities (such as electricity and water), and other necessities, many of them depend on a

steady source of income. Insufficient money can lead to worry and anxiety about one's means

of subsistence. Depending on where they reside, cemetery occupants may also have to deal

with environmental issues, including exposure to extreme weather, poor sanitary facilities, or

trouble getting clean water. These elements may have an effect on their living and health

circumstances. Although the support of the community may be beneficial, disputes or conflicts

may also occur within the cemetery community. Resolving conflicts and maintaining

interpersonal relationships can be difficult tasks for residents in this particular setting (Algura,

2019).

Munthali (2023) emphasized the challenges of families living in cemeteries include

difficulties in accessing clean water and essential medical services, limited opportunities for

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 5 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
education and employment, and persistent poverty within the community. These obstacles stem

from the lack of basic amenities and opportunities available to other citizens. Improving the

well-being of cemetery residents requires addressing their needs for livelihood, water,

healthcare, and education.

Lastly, Lapatha et al. (2019) concluded that residing in the cemetery presents numerous

challenges and disadvantages for families. These include emotional stress from reminders of

mortality, limited access to essential services, social stigma leading to isolation, financial stress

due to insufficient income, environmental hazards, and conflicts within the community. These

obstacles can significantly impact residents' well-being and quality of life, making it difficult

to maintain basic needs and interpersonal relationships.

Challenges of the Children Residing in the Cemetery

Algura (2019) provided valuable insights into the resilience of families living among the

dead, highlighting how despite the pervasive presence of poverty and adversity within cemetery

communities, families draw strength from their bonds and support networks. These familial

relationships serve as pillars of support, offering children a sense of stability and belonging

amidst challenging circumstances.

However, Borromeo, Dacumi, and Guzman (2019) presented a contrasting perspective,

emphasizing the survival-focused nature of life in cemeteries, where families prioritize meeting

basic needs over pursuing a fulfilling life. This survival-centric approach underscores the harsh

realities faced by children in cemetery communities, where access to essential resources and

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 6 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
opportunities for growth may be limited.

Children residing in cemetery communities navigate a multitude of challenges that

significantly impact their well-being. As highlighted by Munthali (2023), despite the presence

of family support, the pervasive impact of poverty remains a constant struggle for these

children. The lack of access to clean water, adequate housing, and educational opportunities

further compounds their vulnerability and hinders their overall development.

Moreover, the stigma associated with residing in cemeteries can exacerbate social

isolation and discrimination, negatively affecting children's mental and emotional health. The

constant exposure to the reminders of mortality within cemetery environments may also

contribute to heightened levels of stress and anxiety among children, further exacerbating their

challenges (Munthali, 2023).

While family bonds offer a source of resilience, the pervasive challenges of poverty

persist, shaping the daily realities of residents. A comprehensive understanding of these

challenges remains essential for developing effective interventions and support systems to

improve the well-being of children residing in cemetery environments (Lapatha et al., 2019).

Types of Families Living Arrangements

The phenomenon of families living in cemeteries presents a unique perspective on

housing and community dynamics. Lapatha et al. (2019) asserted the positive aspects of such

arrangements, noting residents' sense of satisfaction and security within cemetery grounds.

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 7 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Living in cemeteries is seen as a safer alternative to the streets due to the presence of guards

and physical assurance. Moreover, the study highlights the social well-being experienced by

residents, who feel protected and have a sense of belonging within the cemetery community.

However, the sense of community may be limited to close relatives, with some residents

choosing to isolate themselves from the broader neighborhood due to toxic interactions with

neighbors.

Marreti (2023) concluded by highlighting the socioeconomic factors driving families to

live in cemeteries. Many Filipino migrants move from rural areas to urban centers in search of

better opportunities, only to find difficulty securing employment. Consequently, these

individuals often end up in slum communities within the city, where makeshift shelters are

constructed over tombs or inside mausoleums. This highlights the dire circumstances that push

families towards unconventional living arrangements within cemetery grounds, which is also

because of poverty.

In many Asian countries, poverty-stricken individuals and families are forced to reside

in cemeteries due to their inability to afford traditional housing options. This underscores the

broader issue of housing affordability and the challenges faced by marginalized communities

in accessing adequate living spaces. Moreover, the impending development plans to convert

cemeteries into housing developments raise concerns among families of the deceased regarding

the relocation of bodies and the timeframe for such processes (Overstreet, 2020).

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 8 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
In summary, the various perspectives provided by Marreti (2023), Overstreet (2020), and

Lapatha et al. (2019) collectively shed light on the complex types of living arrangements of

families residing in the cemeteries. From the sense of security and social cohesion experienced

by residents to the socioeconomic factors driving such arrangements, it is evident that cemetery

living reflects broader issues of housing insecurity and marginalization. As development plans

threaten to transform cemetery spaces, questions arise regarding the future of these

communities and the respectful relocation of the deceased.

Dynamics of Familial Relationship

The dynamics of familial relationships within the context of cemeteries encompass a

multifaceted interplay of loss, remembrance, and the perpetuation of family bonds. Cemeteries

serve as repositories of ancestral history, offering a tangible link to the past through headstone

inscriptions, dates, and names. Cemeteries offer a wealth of information about our ancestors

and serve as a physical link to the past. Stronger familial ties can result from this knowledge

of family history, which can foster a sense of continuity and connectedness. The communal

aspect of cemeteries is another important element that strengthens family bonds. Grieving

collectively in a shared space can provide comfort during times of loss, and it can also foster a

deeper understanding and empathy among family members. Residing beyond the grave can be

a shared ritual that brings family members together, facilitating mutual support and the

expression of shared love and grief (Peterson, 2023).

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 9 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Francis et al. (2020) assumed that family interactions experience a distinct dynamic in

the cemetery context, characterized by a combination of loss, remembering, and the

maintenance of family bonds. The cemetery transforms into a tangible place where the ties of

kinship are felt as families join together to grieve the loss of departed loved ones. In this place,

the gravity of loss blends with cherished memories to create a sense of community and legacy.

Graveyards are moving settings for the expression of familial love and unity among

generations, from the solemn rites of burial to the silent periods of contemplation at gravesites.

Families strengthen their ties by attending to and maintaining the final resting sites of their

ancestors, maintaining a sense of continuity and connection that crosses the line between life

and death.

Living near a cemetery can provide a unique connection to history and culture, as these

sites often hold stories and memories of the past. For some individuals, the proximity to a

cemetery can foster a sense of continuity with the past and a profound appreciation for the lives

that came before. The tranquil and contemplative atmosphere near a cemetery can offer solace

and a reminder of the impermanence of life, leading to a greater appreciation of the present

moment. Additionally, living near a cemetery can serve as a daily reminder of the

interconnectedness of humanity and the enduring impact individuals can have on future

generations (Lapatha et al., 2019).

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 10 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Coping Mechanisms of the Families

According to Bailey (2022), families residing in cemetery environments often develop

coping mechanisms to navigate the unique challenges associated with their living conditions.

One common coping mechanism involves leveraging communal resources within the cemetery

community. Families come together to share necessities such as food, water, and shelter,

pooling their resources to meet basic needs collectively. This sense of solidarity fosters a

supportive environment where individuals can lean on one another for emotional and practical

support.

Dai et al. (2022) also concluded that social connections within the cemetery community

serve as a vital source of support for families, buffering against the psychological impact of

their living conditions. And through mutual aid and companionship, families residing in the

cemetery find comfort and strength in their relationships with fellow community members,

fostering resilience in the face of hardship.

Additionally, problem-solving, such as problem-focused coping style emerges as another

coping mechanism among families residing in cemeteries. Innovative solutions are adopted by

cemetery residents to address practical challenges such as shelter, sanitation, and livelihood.

Families repurpose the available materials or improvise makeshift structures to create livable

spaces within the cemetery environment. By tapping into their resourcefulness and ingenuity,

cemetery residents adapt to their surroundings and find ways to improve their living conditions

despite limited resources (Descalsota, 2023).

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 11 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Furthermore, the study titled "A Qualitative Study on the Social Well-being of Filipino

Families Living in Cemeteries in Cebu City," of Lapatha et al. (2019) explores the concept of

emotion-focused coping style which emphasized the psychological impact of cemetery living

and concluded coping strategies employed by families to maintain their mental well-being.

Strategies include seeking solace in spiritual and cultural practices, finding moments of

tranquility amidst the peaceful surroundings of the cemetery, or engaging in activities that

provide a sense of purpose and meaning in life. While cemetery living presents numerous

challenges, the resilience and coping mechanisms exhibited by families in these environments

underscore their ability to persevere and thrive amidst adversity.

Ways of Living in Residing in the Cemetery

In the study titled "A Qualitative Study on the Social Well-being of Filipino Families

Living in Cemeteries in Cebu City," Lapatha et al. (2019) delve into the survival strategies and

ways of living of families residing in cemeteries. Some residents take on caretaker roles to

supplement their income, while others engage in small-scale entrepreneurial activities such as

selling candles, flowers, and operating small stores to cater to visitors. Additionally, during

funerals, there is a work opportunity, with some individuals collecting bones from tombs and

offering services for making tombstones, known as lapida.

Cemeteries are often regarded as left-behind landscapes: scary and lifeless, abandoned

and forgotten. Despite this derelict image, residents residing in the cemetery are living and

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 12 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
coexisting in tombs and mausoleums. Elders were responsible for providing for family needs

and nourishing the family. As outsiders, often hear about ghosts and horror stories and consider

cemeteries to be haunted, but these events and stories are uncommon to the residents, as they

have already established a relationship with the place and those around it. For them, the

cemetery is not merely a place, but a place they call home (Algura, 2019).

According to Descalsota (2023), many of the individuals residing in cemeteries live

below the poverty line, compelling them to seek shelter within the cemetery grounds due to

financial constraints. Makeshift houses are erected within mausoleums once designated for the

deceased, creating a sense of community and camaraderie among the residents. Despite their

challenging circumstances, residents value the strong friendships and support networks that

have formed within the cemetery community.

Moxhay (2019) stated that others were living in the cemetery beside the deceased. On its

grounds, some of the poorest people in Manila have lived and worked for many years—in some

cases, generations. The majority work as stonemasons or as mausoleums and cemetery

caretakers, but many more are just "illegal" dwellers trying to get away from the many risks of

living on Manila's congested and hazardous city streets. Some children there make a living by

collecting melted wax from the candles and selling it to the recycling center to make money.”.

Prevention of Poverty

According to Barke (2023), strong governance is crucial for reducing poverty as it

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 13 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
ensures fair resource distribution, reduces corruption, and promotes transparent and

accountable policies. Anti-corruption initiatives and governance changes are essential.

Education has the potential to end poverty cycles by increasing accessibility, developing

curriculum, and training teachers. Investments in education, such as increased accessibility and

teacher training, provide the necessary skills for economic empowerment.

Enhancing governance has the potential to address poverty even in difficult settings, such

as communities where people live next to cemeteries. The local community can benefit from

better living conditions through the implementation of anti-corruption measures, equitable

resource distribution, and transparent policy promotion. When education programmers are

expanded into these regions, they help break the cycle of poverty by providing chances and

skills that enable economic empowerment even in unusual settings (Barke, 2023).

According to the Japan External Trade Organization (2019), offering jobs similar to those

of public corporations is the answer. Should the government offer jobs so that poor people have

the ability to learn how to work and make money. Also, in the event that they are unable to find

employment with public companies indefinitely, they will gain positive experience in the

future. Furthermore, they will spend money on education, and their kids might attend school.

Like public enterprises, giving jobs to the underprivileged can empower people, even

those in difficult situations like those living in cemeteries. By providing work, you provide

them the opportunity to improve their financial status while also gaining essential skills and

experience. This strategy encourages people to invest in education, which may improve their

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 14 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
children's access to education and lead the way for a better future (Jetro, 2019).

Pathak and Ross (2021) said that in order to rebuild the economy fairly, well-paying jobs

in important industries must be created, and major worker safeguards must be in place to lessen

the burden on working families. And it is important to support investments in permanent

housing initiatives like Housing First and the National Homes Guarantee in order to give those

who are homeless or residing in transitional housing a way to get and keep long-term, secure

homes.

The financial burden on working families, especially those who live in cemeteries, can

be lessened by establishing worker protections and well-paying jobs in strategic industries.

Supporting programs like Accommodation First and the National Homes Guarantee will help

us solve larger social issues by giving those who are homeless or living in transitional

accommodation the chance to find long-term, stable housing (Pathak & Ross, 2021).

Perceptions of the Neighborhood Towards to Cemetery Residents

In exploring the perceptions of neighborhoods towards cemetery residents, it's essential

to consider the broader context of how cemeteries interact with urban environments and

residential areas (Lapatha et al., 2019). One aspect to consider is the impact of cemetery

proximity on property values, as examined in the study from the Ethiopian Journal of

Environmental Studies & Management (2021), it indicates that the presence of cemeteries may

influence the desirability of neighborhoods, potentially shaping residents' attitudes towards

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 15 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
those living in close proximity to cemetery grounds. Some neighbors may be curious about the

lifestyle of cemetery residents and may hold neutral or indifferent perceptions toward them.

They may be interested in learning more about their experiences and living conditions without

necessarily passing judgment.

Furthermore, Lapatha et al. (2019) delve into the potential conflicts between cemeteries

and adjacent residential land uses. Their findings suggest that factors such as age, proximity to

the cemetery, and occupation can influence negative perceptions towards cemetery locations.

In some cases, residents may harbor fear or mistrust towards cemetery residents, fueled by

stereotypes or misconceptions about their behavior or lifestyle. This fear could stem from

cultural beliefs or superstitions surrounding death and burial grounds. These dynamics provides

insights into how residents within the neighborhood may perceive and interact with individuals

residing in cemetery communities.

Additionally, Nordh et al. (2023) discussed the evolving role of urban cemeteries as

recreational spaces. The exploration of different perspectives on the recreational use of

cemeteries adds nuance to the understanding of how communities view and engage with

cemetery spaces. Moreover, neighborhoods may view cemetery residents with sympathy and

empathy, recognizing the challenges they face in their living environment. These individuals

may offer support and assistance to cemetery residents, fostering a sense of community

solidarity.

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 16 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
This insight contributes to a broader understanding of the neighborhood's attitudes towards

cemetery residents by highlighting the varied ways in which these spaces are utilized and

perceived.

Effectiveness of Residing in the Cemetery

The effectiveness of residing in a cemetery presents a complex interplay of social,

economic, and security factors. While some may perceive living in such a setting as

unconventional or even hazardous, families within cemetery environments exhibit resilience

and adaptability in the face of challenges. The presence of a cemetery can indeed pose security

threats, including the potential for criminal activity such as robbery and harassment

(International Journal of Scientific Research Publication, 2021). The serene nature of some

cemetery sites may attract hoodlums, who take advantage of the solitude to commit nefarious

acts, thus impacting the safety and security of residents.

Despite the adversities faced by families living in cemeteries, they demonstrate

resilience and adaptability in navigating their daily lives. Many families residing in these

environments exhibit social well-being indicators, albeit nuanced by individual experiences

(Lapatha et al., 2019). While some may find solace and security within cemetery grounds,

others face challenges in seeking a sense of belonging within the wider community, often due

to perceptions of toxic or selfish neighbors. However, familial bonds within the cemetery

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 17 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
community remain strong, offering support and companionship to those who are part of it

(International Journal of Scientific Research Publication, 2021).

According to Amadi et al. (2021), for some residents, the cemetery environment

provides a safer alternative to living on the streets, particularly in the face of natural calamities.

Despite occasional hardships, such as harassment from hoodlums or the recurrence of

environmental disasters, families find stability and security within the cemetery's confines. The

sense of belonging and community extends primarily to close relatives and those who share a

common bond within the cemetery setting, fostering a sense of solidarity and mutual support

among residents.

In conclusion, the effectiveness of residing in cemeteries encompasses a multitude of

factors, including safety, social well-being, and economic stability. While challenges such as

security threats and social isolation persist, families demonstrate resilience and adaptability in

navigating their lives within the cemetery environment. By fostering a sense of community

and offering a semblance of security, cemeteries serve as unique living spaces that present

both opportunities and challenges for their residents (International Journal of Scientific

Research Publication, 2021).

Synthesis of the Reviewed Related Literature

The phenomenon of families residing in cemeteries presents a unique demographic, often

marginalized yet resilient in their community formations. Lapatha et al. (2019) noted the

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 18 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
challenges faced by these families, driven by socio-economic factors such as poverty, which

exacerbate their living conditions. Despite these adversities, cemetery residents forge strong

social bonds, relying on one another for support and solidarity (Smith et al., 2021). However,

stigma and discrimination from broader society compound their challenges, perpetuating

cycles of deprivation and marginalization (Sodiya et al., 2021).

Living in a cemetery offers unique advantages, including a peaceful atmosphere

conducive to mental well-being and recreational opportunities (Lorge, 2023). Additionally, the

affordability of cemetery residences may alleviate financial burdens for some families (Dai et

al., 2022). Cemetery environments also foster a sense of community and belonging, providing

proximity to cultural landmarks and historical significance (Lapatha et al., 2019).

Yet, residing in a cemetery poses significant challenges, especially for children, including

limited access to essential services and opportunities, persistent poverty, and environmental

hazards (Munthali, 2023). Moreover, psychological distress from reminders of mortality, social

stigma, and conflicts within the community impact residents' well-being (Borromeo et al.,

2020). Despite these challenges, families develop coping mechanisms, relying on communal

support, problem-solving, and emotion-focused strategies to navigate their circumstances

(Bailey, 2022; Descalsota, 2023; Lapatha et al., 2019).

The effectiveness of residing in cemeteries involves a complex interplay of social,

economic, and security factors. While families may find solace and stability within cemetery

grounds, they also face security threats and social isolation (Amadi et al., 2021). Nonetheless,

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 19 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
cemetery communities exhibit resilience, adaptability, and solidarity, suggesting that while

challenges persist, opportunities for communal support and unique living experiences emerge

within these unconventional settings (International Journal of Scientific Research Publication,

2021).

Gaps to be Bridged by the Present Study

The researchers decided to conduct qualitative research about the families residing in

the cemetery. There are some studies associated with this, but those are focused on different

participants, locations of the participants, and objectives. The researchers took an in-depth

examination about the lived experiences of families residing in the Sto. Filomena Chapel, San

Antonio, City of Biñan, Laguna.

References

Algura, P. O. (2019). Living among the dead in the Manila North Cemetery: A Cartographic
Re-Imagination. Abstracts of the ICA, 1, 1–2.
https://doi.org/10.5194/ica-abs-1-6-2019

Amadi, M. D., & Weje, I. I. Socio-Economic Impacts of Cemetery on Residents of Port


Harcourt Metropolis, Rivers State, Nigeria.
https://www.ijsrp.org/research-paper-0521/ijsrp-p11374.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3p-
fKEi06DQoUmr_CXdNqREVcmyJdRRqvcW70q2CZndpYxjx-ujvagbM8

Bailey, A. (2022). Coping Mechanisms: Everything You Need to Know


https://www.verywellhealth.com/coping-mechanisms-5272135

Barke, Akello. (2023). Poverty in Africa: Causes, Consequences, and Potential Solutions.
International Journal of Science and Society. 5. 682-691. 10.54783/ijsoc.v5i4.835.

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 20 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/374576657_Poverty_in_Africa_Causes_Co
nsequences_and_Potential_Solutions

Borromeo, K. R., Dacumi, T. G., & Guzman, K. A. (2019). The living conditions of Filipino
families residing in Manila North Cemetery. Studocu.
https://www.studocu.com/ph/document/polytechnic-university-of-the-
philippines/bachelor-of-arts-in-sociology-formerly-bachelor-of-science-in-sociology-
bas/the-living-conditions-of-filipino-families-residing-in-manila-north-
cemetery/10527731?fbclid=IwAR1EjNdKjvqwUC_MXLg38lG8VHppw7XkaAnF5T
gYzYvkYvzjNhAfd-ieabA

Chowdhury, M. R. (2021). What is coping theory. PositivePscyhology. com.


https://positivepsychology.com/coping-theory/

Crowe, B. M., & Van Puymbroeck, M. (2019). Enhancing problem-and emotion-focused


coping in menopausal women through yoga. International journal of yoga
therapy, 29(1), 57-64.
https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Enhancing-Problem-and-Emotion-Focused-
Coping-in-Crowe-Puymbroeck/a927864dfcf6376755a3e5e77b6122be94d44963

Dai, X., et al. (2022). The benefits of green spaces for mental health: Evidence from cemetery
parks. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 69, 126-134.
https://www.froglife.org/2022/03/29/the-benefits-of-green-spaces-and-nature-on-
mental-health-2/

Descalsota, M. (2023, September 19). Living, sleeping, and just barely scraping by alongside
the dead in a Philippine cemetery. Business Insider.
https://www.businessinsider.com/inside-graveyards-philippines-cebu-daycare-homes-
food-stalls-2023-
9?fbclid=IwAR0We3i19eeWakB57wtUcHJMuT0En46pvbtSX7LoGMpIa3VBImlkO
r8jPh8

Ghazali, M. (2021). City of Living‐Death: Urban Precarity and Social Transformation in an


Egyptian Cemetery. City & Society, 33(2), 346-363.
https://anthrosource.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/ciso.12410

International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications (2021). Socio-Economic Impacts


of Cemetery on Residents Volume 11
https://www.ijsrp.org/research-paper-0521/ijsrp-p11374.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3p-
fKEi06DQoUmr_CXdNqREVcmyJdRRqvcW70q2CZndpYxjx-ujvagbM8

Jetro "About Us." Site Top. Accessed November 17, 2019.

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 21 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
https://www.js.kuas.ac.jp/shs/wp/img/2020/03/1_sotsugyouronbun.pdf?fbclid=IwAR2
ZQyHmbjZJVw32m2yscthLDalW_AmDJXc1PfsG3qtk4PRf4HmLJC0-iJ0#page=88

Folkman, S., & Moskowitz, J. T. (2004). Coping: Pitfalls and promise. Annual Review of
Psychology, 55, 745-774
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14744233/

Francis, L., Kucheryavaya, M., Biers, T., & Clary, K. S. (2020). The Routledge Handbook of
Museums, Heritage, and Death. Google Books.
https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=cIfAEAAAQBAJ&pg=PT260&dq=dynamics
+of+familial+relationships+in+the+cemetery+setting&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj
er6un7uCEAxX3yTgGHbSABasQ6AF6BAgJEAE&fbclid=IwAR09P2D0QtOC2Arn
dOn3JBiD38Wl-
H5mlnTCKUdMUqUKlOUdsFDVBdBUkJM#v=onepage&q=dynamics%20of%20fa
milial%20relationships%20in%20the%20cemetery%20setting&f=false

Lapatha, J. V., Largo, Z. M. A., Lawas, F. L. A., Malagar, A. F., Un, J. L. B., Inocian, R. B.,
& Cabras, R. L. J. (2019). Living with the Dead: A Qualitative Study on the Social
Well-being of Filipino Families Living in Cemeteries in Cebu City. Asia Pacific Journal
of Multidisciplinary Research, 7(1).
https://oaji.net/articles/2020/1543-1585278151.pdf

Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping. Springer Publishing
Company
https://www.google.com.ph/books/edition/Stress_Appraisal_and_Coping/i-
ySQQuUpr8C?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Lazarus,+R.+S.,+%26+Folkman,+S.+(1984).+Str
ess,+appraisal,+and+coping.+Springer+Publishing+Company&printsec=frontcover

Lorge, T. (2023, October 5). Grave concerns: How focusing on cemeteries can boost local
government popularity.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/grave-concerns-how-focusing-cemeteries-can-boost-
local-tony-
lorge?fbclid=IwAR1R2cvOJib3ezlLXpMtXkBuEjLjBhotj3hl1yuUAw8pHMRuh1kP
GX8HPqw#:~:text=Cemeteries%20often%20serve%20as%20peaceful,walking%2C%
20reflection%2C%20and%20relaxation

Maretti, A. (2023). Life inside the cemetery slums of the Philippines. Copyright 2024 Alberto
Maretti - www.albertomaretti.com.
https://www.albertomaretti.com/life_inside_the_cemetery_slums_of_the_philippines-
r11798?fbclid=IwAR0lsBy-
YZQZh95rf999nMjGIpqkhrm42lvzxWCTJaFPEoWYvP8-ezEiEBw&_mob=1

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 22 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
MindTools (2024). Lazarus and Folkman's Transactional Model of Stress and Coping
https://www.mindtools.com/aari1kl/lazarus-and-folkmans-transactional-model-of-
stress-and-coping

Moxhay, K., & Moxhay, K. (2019, December 26). Living with the Dead. Intrepid Times.
https://intrepidtimes.com/2019/12/living-with-the-
dead/?fbclid=IwAR1A_DkPxMnqNVd--1Rs0fb2gOoMUzQnJV-
DaVgaNEKhmydQ5Mo5iu7EQ3w

Munthali, B. (2023). Philippines living at graveyard amid abject poverty. Retrieved from
Maravi Post
https://www.maravipost.com/philippines-living-at-graveyard-amid-abject-
poverty/?amp=1&fbclid=IwAR2L7oLs16HDTP6n15OXjZTAKEtflJ_a6HBkwIP4lM
BJqZsR-MfREAruALg

Nordh, H., Wingren, C., Uteng, T. P., & Knapskog, M. (2023). Disrespectful or socially
acceptable?–A nordic case study of cemeteries as recreational landscapes. Landscape
and Urban Planning, 231, 104645.
https://publications.slu.se/?file=publ/show&id=120727

Overstreet, K. (2020, August 21). No more room for the living or the dead: Exploring the future
for burials in Asia. ArchDaily.
https://www.archdaily.com/945794/no-more-room-for-the-living-or-the-dead-
exploring-the-future-for-burials-in-
asia?fbclid=IwAR1ppeq4DKZVvmEtuHJs4s25JV1BihWyvut1k6AVNqP4mnHdCNk
RsSjMSwc

Overview. (2021). World Bank.


https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/poverty/overview

Pathak, A., & Ross, K. (2021). The Top 12 Solutions to Cut Poverty in the United States. Center
for American Progress.
https://www.americanprogress.org/article/top-12-solutions-cut-poverty-united-
states/?fbclid=IwAR1-T_VSRpshIn_zFqcObRkgbRd_fdqrmyGE4Vuss3db-LbaF-
mygYSS8ps

Peterson, R. (2023, August 22). How cemeteries strengthen family bonds and identity.
Associated Catholic Cemeteries.
https://mycatholiccemetery.org/2023/09/25/how-cemeteries-strengthen-family-bonds-
and-identity/?fbclid=IwAR2vgw6-lNE_zc5MN_ym-MCMbpJyBfVZ1s-
wVKj1fu5RUEuPAicb0O-BseU

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 23 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com
Saxena, A.S. (2023) Coping mechanisms: Definition, examples, & why they’re important,
Choosing Therapy
https://www.choosingtherapy.com/coping-mechanisms/

Smith, J. (2019). Addressing housing inequality through research: Insights from urban
sociology. Housing Studies, 25(1), 78-91.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03085147.2021.2003086

Smith, J., et al. (2021). Challenges and resilience among families residing in cemeteries.
Journal of Social Work Research, 28(1), 89-104.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10479-020-03912-1

Sodiya, A. K., Ibisola, A. S., & Fateye, T. B. (2021). IMPACT OF CEMETERY ON


PROXIMATE RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY VALUE. Ethiopian Journal of
Environmental Studies & Management, 14(1).
https://ejesm.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/ejesm.v14i1.1.pdf

Address: Sto. Domingo, City of Biñan, Laguna


Telephone Nos.: (049)548-0114/(049)501-9535
Email Address: 301230@deped.gov.ph Doc. Ref. Code -------------- Rev 00
Effectivity 09.20.21 Page 24 of 24
Website: Binhs301230.com

You might also like