Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/339100892
CITATIONS READS
6 365
2 authors, including:
Anastasiia V. Tumskaia
Saratov State University
13 PUBLICATIONS 49 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Anastasiia V. Tumskaia on 02 May 2022.
ORIGINAL PAPER
Abstract
Falsified drugs are a serious problem of modern society. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a fast and simple method of
drug screening for checking of their falsification. In this article, we present paper-based test methods that can be used to
identify amoxicillin, a β-lactam series antibiotic agent, used the mobile phone camera. The detection time is 10 min. Ninhy-
drin, p-dimethylaminobenzaldehyde, and Fehling’s reagent are used as reagents for the test. We have found out the optimal
conditions of express analysis, including temperature and duration of heating. We have obtained the color scales for visual
and colorimetric detection of the antibiotic agent. Optimal color parameters for RGB, CMYK, and HSV color models have
been analyzed. We have demonstrated linear correlations between optimal colorimetric parameters and antibiotic agent
concentration. Profiles of radar diagrams using color parameters as coordinates are obtained. Linear correlation between
area and perimeter of radar diagrams and amoxicillin concentration was found.
Keywords Express analysis · Indicator papers · Antibiotic agents · Amoxicillin · Phone camera-based detection ·
Colorimetry
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Chemical Papers
Mohamed (2001) Spectrophotometry Molybdenum and thiocyanate 7.5–75 μg/mL 0.75 μg/mL Simple, rapid, accurate sensitive
Aly and Amin (2007) Spectrophotometry Sudan III 0.2–22 μg/mL 0.06 μg/mL Simple, rapid, accurate sensitive
Shirole et al. (2018) HPLC Potassium dihydrogen phos- 0–60 µg/mL 0.28 μg/mL Expensive instrumentation
phate, methanol
Pawar et al. (2017) Fluorimetry Quantum dots 5–30 μg/mL 5.19 μg/mL Expensive instrumentation
Bergamini et al. (2006) Voltammetry [N,N-ethylenebis(salicylidenea 28.5–82.6 μM 24.8 μM Time consuming synthesis,
minato)]oxovanadium(IV) expensive instrumentations for
Hatamie et al. (2015) Voltammetry ZnO NRs/gold/glass electrode 19 μM 50–250 μM characterization and detection
13
Chemical Papers
We isolated a part of the photo and averaged it using the to the control. Further express analysis using colorimetric
“Average” filter, and then, we determined the values of the tests 1, 2, and 3 was carried out after 10 min.
color channels provided by RGB, CMYK, and HSV color
models. Next, we determined the intensity values of the Development of color scales for visual
color parameters, and found linear correlations between and colorimetric identification of amoxicillin
the intensities of the color parameters and the concentra-
tion of amoxicillin. Standard amoxicillin solutions with concentrations of 0, 1,
2, 4, 8, 16, and 32 mg/mL were used to obtain color scales.
A drop of the solution was applied to colorimetric test 1, 2,
or 3; the test paper was then heated, placed in a box, photo-
Results and discussion graphed, and processed via colorimetric technique. Figure 2
shows the resulting color scales after 10 min of heating indi-
Selection of optimal conditions for express analysis cator papers at 95–100 °C.
To optimize the conditions of express analysis, we per- Linear correlations for colorimetric identification
formed some preliminary tests. As a result, the follow- of amoxicillin
ing concentrations of reagents were selected as optimal:
ninhydrin (0.1 M), DMAB (0.1 M), and Fehling’s reagent Photos of color scales were processed using Adobe
as prepared according to the technique described in (Feigl Photoshop® software; the intensity of the color parameters
1960). was determined via RGB model. We selected the best chan-
We have found that the strongly acidic medium (pH nels by comparing their sensitivity (tg α) and regression
2–3) provides the best results for the amoxicillin reaction coefficient values. For test papers with ninhydrin, the best
with ninhydrin and DMAB on indicator papers; therefore, color channel is Blue (B) (47.6) with a regression coefficient
standard antibiotic solutions were prepared in 0.01 M HCl. of 0.986 (Fig. 3a). The concentration curves of test papers
We used the aqueous solution of amoxicillin in the case of covered with DMAB showed that the largest tilt angle was
its reaction with Fehling’s reagent having basic pH. selected for a Blue color channel (B) (24.6) with regres-
We have determined the optimal heating time for sion coefficient equal to 0.987 (Fig. 3b). Similarly, for test
the indicator paper. To do this, a solution of amoxicil- papers covered with Fehling’s reagent, we selected a Blue
lin was applied to indicator papers covered with ninhy- (B) (− 59.2) channel with a regression coefficient of 0,989
drin, DMAB and Fehling’s reagent; the paper was then (Fig. 3c). Limit of detection (LOD) is 1.5 mg/mL (colori-
heated at 95–100 °C for 1–15 min, placed in a box, and metric test 1); 2,2 mg/mL (colorimetric test 2); 1,9 mg/mL
photographed. (colorimetric test 3).
One of the advantages of express methods of analysis
is their rapidness. As we can see from Fig. 1, the optimal Color stability of the developed colorimetric tests
heating time is 10–15 min for colorimetric test 1, 2, and 3, over time
because we have the maximum color change as compared
After express identification was performed, the indicator
papers were stored at room temperature in a dark place. For
13
Chemical Papers
Fig. 3 Correlation between the intensity of color channels and concentration of amoxicillin: a—colorimetric test 1, b—colorimetric test 2, and
c—colorimetric test 3 (n = 3)
13
Chemical Papers
Fig. 5 Radar chart profiles: a—colorimetric test 1, b—colorimetric test 2, c—colorimetric test 3; Amoxicillin concentration, mg/mL
Fig. 6 Profiles radar charts (A for RGBCMYK coordinates; B for RGBHSV coordinates) obtained for colorimetric tests 1, 2, and 3 interacting
with 4 mg/mL amoxicillin solution
Table 2 Linear correlations between the square (perimeter) of radar chart and the concentration of amoxicillin
Type Coordinate system Regression equation for correlation r2 Regression equation for correlation r2
between area and logC/C (mg/mL) between perimeter and logC/C (mg/mL)
13
Chemical Papers
Validation of express identification method of auxiliary components of the drug and their mixture. The
concentrations of the components indicated on the package
The validity of express identification method based on the of the drug were selected: talc 3.7 mg; magnesium stearate
developed colorimetric tests was tested (Table 3). 3.7 mg; potato starch 75.6 mg per 1 tablet (tablet weight
The values of relative errors of identification do not 370 mg). The intensity value of the Blue channel does not
exceed 9% for colorimetric test 1, 11% for colorimetric test change in the presence of auxiliary components, as well as
2, and 7% for colorimetric test 3. their mixture in all three studied systems (Fig. 7a–c). The
intensity of the Blue channel was constant in all cases. For
Analysis of commercial amoxicillin drugs this reason, we concluded that talc, magnesium stearate,
and potato starch do not interfere with the detection of
We checked our tests to identify amoxicillin in commercial amoxicillin.
medical drugs produced in the form of 250 mg pills and The express identification was performed by dissolving a
500 mg capsules. The analyzed drugs contain amoxicil- sample of drug, filtering the resulting solution, and adding
lin trihydrate as the active substance, and talc, magnesium a drop of the analyzed solution to the surface of paper of
stearate, and potato starch as additives. Figure 7 shows the colorimetric tests 1, 2 and 3. The results of the quantitative
intensity values of the Blue color channel in the presence identification of the antibiotic are presented in Table 4.
Fig. 7 Intensity of the Blue color channel in the presence of talc (1% solution), magnesium stearate (1%), starch (20%), and their mixture with
concentration of amoxicillin 10 mg/mL: a—colorimetric tests 1, b—colorimetric tests 2, and c—colorimetric tests 3
Table 4 Results of amoxicillin identification in drug samples via spectrophotometric and express testing methods (n = 3, P = 0.95)
“AVVA RUS” pills, 250 250 ± 4 0.01 253 ± 23 0.09 260 ± 28 0.11 234 ± 14 0.02
Russia
“Hemofarm” capsules, 500 495 ± 10 0.02 489 ± 36 0.07 540 ± 38 0.07 503 ± 25 0.03
Serbia
13
Chemical Papers
13
Chemical Papers
dots for the simultaneous detection of several antibiotics in milk. Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
Biosens Bioelectron 63:255–261. https: //doi.org/10.1016/j. jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
bios.2014.07.049
World Health Organization. WHO model list of essential medicines.
20th list, March 2017. www.who.int/medicines. Accessed 19 Feb
2019
13