You are on page 1of 15

Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.

9, 2679-2693 ISSN 1229-9197 (print version)


DOI 10.1007/s12221-022-0014-9 ISSN 1875-0052 (electronic version)

Performance of Wood-plastic Composites Manufactured from Post-consumer


Plastics and Wood Waste under Coastal Weathering in Thailand
Chatree Homkhiew1,2*, Chainarong Srivabut2, Surasit Rawangwong1,2, and Worapong Boonchouytan1,2
1
Materials Processing Technology Research Unit, Faculty of Engineering,
Rajamangala University of Technology Srivijaya, Muang District, Songkhla 90000, Thailand
2
Department of Industrial Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Rajamangala University of Technology Srivijaya,
Muang District, Songkhla 90000, Thailand
(Received January 4, 2022; Revised February 21, 2022; Accepted March 21, 2022)

Abstract: The performance of wood-plastic composites (WPCs) under natural weathering needs to be further evaluated, in
particular their resistance to coastal weathering in tropical counties. Because the coastal weathering is sensitive to the rising
acidity of the sea and changes in the frequency of storms. Thus, the effects of coastal weathering, post-consumer plastic types
(plastic bags, straws, and cups), and wood waste (twigs) contents in the range of 40-60 wt% on the durability of WPCs were
investigated. The samples were prepared by a twin-screw extruder and a compression molding machine. The results revealed
that the increase of wood flour from 40 to 60 wt% into the plastic bag composites insignificantly rose (about 0.12 %) the
melting temperature, but significantly decreased (about 23.8 %) the melting enthalpy of the un-weathered WPCs. Post-
consumer plastic from straws exhibits higher lightness and discoloration than that from a bag and cup, the plastic bag shows
the lowest these values. All the mechanical properties of the post-consumer plastics and WPCs significantly (α=0.05) reduced
in all cases after coastal weathering for 6 months. Overall, the post-consumer plastics from both the straw and cup presented
higher mechanical properties than the virgin high-density polyethylene; however, the WPCs based on the plastic bag showed
the lowest loss in modulus of rupture, modulus of elasticity, and shear strength after coastal weathering for 6 months.
Keywords: Wood-plastic composites, Municipal solid waste, Weathering, Construction material, Wood twigs

Introduction impressive consumption in the past few decades. Some


properties of plastic waste are similar to those manufactured
Plastic waste has become a matter of great concern in from virgin materials [10,11]. Homkhiew et al. [12] and Yu
several countries and makes up a substantial volume of et al. [13] reported that recycled plastic exhibited some
global municipal solid waste [1,2]. These wastes have large similar mechanical properties with virgin materials. Many
quantities in which most plastic waste comes from products produced from plastic wastes are plastic lumber,
residential, commercial, industrial, and institutional sources, decking, terrace, floor carpets, flower vases, park benches,
etc [3-5]. The researcher and government have focused their and picnic tables including composite materials [14,15].
efforts on recycling these waste plastics to reduce the Wood-plastic composites (WPCs) have attracted significant
quantity of materials going into landfills. Thailand is one of interest in residential markets and construction industries.
those countries where post-consumer plastics such as plastic The WPC production has been focused on the use of
bags, plastic cups, and plastic straws are widely generated. recycled plastic and wood waste. The WPCs manufactured
In the year 2019, the Pollution Control Department (PCD) of from plastic wastes reinforced with wood fibers or other
Thailand reported the waste statistics data that Thailand natural fibers are principally produced from commodity
generated 28.71 million tons of plastic waste, and 6.38 recycled thermoplastics such as polypropylene (PP),
million tons of these were disposed of with inappropriate polyethylene (PE), polystyrene (PS), and polyvinyl chloride
methods [6]. Plastic waste management in Thailand has (PVC) [16,17]. The influence of plastic types on the melt
become more complex in the last decade owing to the index, deflection, flame retardant, and other thermal
developing countries. Although, it aims to have plastic waste properties of WPC materials has been reported. In addition,
in Thailand recycled 100 % in the year 2027, that is an Ratanawilai et al. [18] reported that the wood types and
ambitious plan given the country's current recycling capacity contents affected water absorption, strength, stiffness,
is only 25 % at most [7]. biodegradation, and microstructure of wood fiber adhesion
There are many applications of plastics displayed in to the recycled plastic matrix, as well as color changes
everyday life. Most plastic wastes made from thermoplastics following exterior exposure. Moreover, most of the research
are relatively easy to recycle [8,9]. Both virgin and recycled investigated the reinforcement of plastics using different
materials of thermoplastics are apparently the major types of wood fibers to achieve improvement in the
polymer construction materials of the future because of their mechanical, physical, and thermal properties [19,20]. These
wood fibers are now well recognized to impart good
*Corresponding author: chatree.h@rmutsv.ac.th reinforcing capability to WPC materials. Also, the wood

2679
2680 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

fibers or natural fibers come from renewable resources, local simulated plastic waste fraction to produce the composites
factories, and municipal waste are relatively inexpensive reinforced with wood fibers. There have been few reports on
[16,18]. the effects of plastic types and wood contents on the
Natural weathering is one of the important conditions durability of the WPCs under real natural weathering, and no
needed to evaluate the performance of the WPCs [21,22]. reports exist on the effect of different post-consumer plastic
Significant interest has also arisen about the outdoor types and WF contents on the properties of the WPCs under
performance of WPCs, in particular their resistance to real coastal weathering that exposed to ultraviolet, high heat,
coastal weathering for tropical countries. Coastal weathering gusty wind, and acid rain. These factors are an accelerator in
can affect the properties of the WPCs because the coast is the deterioration of the WPCs.
sensitive to rising sea levels, rising acidity of the sea, The waste plastics in the landfills consisted of extensive
changes in the intensity and frequency of storms, warmer post-consumer plastics such as plastic bag, cup, and straw as
ocean temperatures, and increases in precipitation. Homkhiew well as wood waste. The post-consumer plastic types are an
et al. [21] investigated the effects of the different grades of important factor affecting the photodegradation and mechanical
PP (virgin and recycled) of the PP/rubberwood flour properties of the WPCs because different plastic products
composites under natural weathering and found that the were produced from different plastic types and grades.
virgin PP composites gave a smaller loss of MOR, MOE, Hence, the effect of the post-consumer plastic types and
and hardness than that recycled PP. Hung et al. [23] also wood waste contents on the properties of the composites
studied the properties of the high-density polyethylene under real coastal weathering are needed to be further
(HDPE)/bamboo composites after exposure to natural investigated. The current research aims to determine the
weathering, after exposure for 120-240 days the crystallinity effects of post-consumer plastic types, such as plastic bags,
of the composites increased. Further, Taib et al. [24] revealed plastic cups, and plastic straw as well as wood waste
that the HDPE/wood flour composites’ deterioration was contents on the durability of the WPCs under real coastal
delayed after adding the hindered amine light stabilizer weathering resistance. The new information from this study
(HALS) and ultraviolet absorber (UVA), meanwhile after will facilitate in making decisions regarding the selection of
exposing to natural weathering the bamboo powder/PP post-consumer plastic for manufacturing the WPC products,
foamed composites with the antioxidant and HALS had such as railing, fencing, flooring, and decking, applied under
higher creep resistance and greater retentions of flexural coastal weathering. The use of post-consumer plastics and
modulus, tensile and notched impact strengths than the wood waste for producing a new composite material would
reference composites [25]. Silva et al. [26] also reported that become a promising way to reduce the waste in landfills.
the recycled polypropylene/ethylene vinyl acetate/wood
flour composites needed to add the antioxidant additives for Experimental
reducing the discoloration and loss of the mechanical
properties. In addition, the properties of WPCs depend on Materials
wood fiber as reinforcement because the internal structures The post-consumer plastics, namely plastic bags, plastic
of the wood fiber consist of lignin and cellulose. Lignin was cups, and plastic straws, were collected from the Songkhla
greatly impacted by natural weathering, and these might municipal solid waste landfill site (Songkhla, Thailand).
have contributed significantly to changing the surface and Their mechanical and physical properties were shown in
color [16,21]. Moreover, the lignin is a chromophore in the Table 1. All of the plastics used in this research were waste
ultraviolet (UV) region, and energy is transferred and initiates materials from the community. Initially, the plastic wastes
degradation processes, resulting in the lignin displaying were washed with a liquid detergent solution and three
early effects of degradation caused by natural weathering rinsed in water before recycling. Subsequently, these plastics
[27]. Several researchers in this field have concentrated on were milled using a cutting mill with scrap sizes of 0.5-
the use of either a single plastic from the waste stream or a 1.5 cm and melted into pellets employing a co-rotating twin-

Table 1. Mechanical and physical properties of post-consumer plastics


Types of plastic Mechanical properties (MPa) Hardness Density MFI
wastes MOR MOE SS (Shore D) (g/cm3) (g/10 min)
Plastic bag 19.9 524 11.4 61.9 0.962 15.6
Plastic straw 54.1 1836 24.1 73.9 0.915 12.1
Plastic cup 57.4 1768 25.7 76.0 0.913 11.8
Note; MOR: modulus of rupture; MOE: modulus of elasticity; SS: shear strength; MFI: melt flow index. The melt flow index of the plastic
bag, straw and cup was carried out using an ASTM D 1238 standard.
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2681

Figure 1. Raw materials from (a) plastic bags, (b) plastic straws, (c) plastic cups, and (d) wood twigs.

screw extruder, Model CTE-D25L40 from Chareon Tut Co., Table 2. Formulation of wood-plastic composites in the experiment
Ltd. (Samutprakarn, Thailand). The temperatures from
Plastic Plastic Plastic Twigs
feeding to die zone were controlled in the range from 145 to Composite HDPE
bag straw cup flour
165 oC, while the screw rotation speed was fixed at 40 rpm. sample code (wt%)
(wt%) (wt%) (wt%) (wt%)
The wood twigs used as reinforcement in WPCs were
H100 96 - - - -
collected from the Songkhla landfill site. Prior to mixing, the
twigs were cut and hammer-milled into wood flour (WF), as B100 - 96 - - -
displayed in Figure 1. The WF was then sieved through a S100 - - 96 - -
mesh size of 40 (passing particles smaller than 400 µm) and C100 - - - 96 -
dried in an oven at a temperature of 110 °C for 12 h to ensure B6W4 - 56 - - 40
that the moisture content was less than 2 %. The chemical B5W5 - 46 - - 50
composition of wood twigs was cellulose 41.5 %, hemicellulose B4W6 - 36 - - 60
29.1 %, lignin 26.8 %, and ash 2.6 %. Besides, the ultraviolet
S6W4 - - 56 - 40
(UV) stabilizer, used as an additive in composite materials
with the trade name MEUV008, was purchased from TH S5W5 - - 46 - 50
Color Co., Ltd. (Samutprakarn, Thailand). Color masterbatch S4W6 - - 36 - 60
used for any plastic and all kinds of products was supplied C6W4 - - - 56 40
from HV PLAS Co., Ltd. (Samutsakhon, Thailand). C5W5 - - - 46 50
C4W6 - - - 36 60
Composites Processing
Note; HDPE: high-density polyethylene; wt%: percent by weight;
In experimental design, the WPC compositions consist of All formulations were filled pigment 3 wt% and ultraviolet stabi-
recycled plastic pellets in the range of 36-56 wt%, wood lizer 1 wt%. The H100 means 96 wt% of HDPE, and B6W4 means
twig flour in the range of 40-60 wt%, pigment fixed at 56 wt% of plastic bag and 40 wt% of twigs flour.
3 wt%, and UV stabilizer fixed at 1 wt%, as shown the
formulations in Table 2. The recycled plastic pellets, wood
twig flour, pigment, and UV stabilizer were then compounded Subsequently, the compression molding machine was applied
into WPC pellets employing the co-rotating twin-screw to produce the WPC panels with a temperature profile of
extruder. The melt temperature zones were set in the range 200 °C under the maximum pressure of 1000 psi for 25 min
of 165-185 °C from feed to die and the screw rotation rate with pre-heating (5 min), compressing (10 min), and cooling
was fixed at 60 rpm. The extruded strands would then be (10 min). The pellets were compressed in a rectangular mold
blown in air through a cutting machine into WPC pellets and with approximate dimensions of 20 cm (width)×25 cm
dried in an oven at a temperature of 50 °C for 24 h. (length)×0.48 cm (thickness). Finally, all of the specimens
2682 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

were machined from the WPC panels according to the temperature was in the range from 22.8 to 34.8 °C, as shown
American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard, in Table 3. The weather data during the experiment was
related to the testing of mechanical and physical properties, supported by the Southern-East Coast Meteorological Center,
such as ASTM D790, ASTM D5379, and ASTM D2240. Ministry of Digital Economy and Society, Thailand.

Natural Weathering Test Analytical Methods


Natural weathering tests under coastal climate in the South Thermal Analysis
of Thailand were carried out in accordance with ASTM Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of the raw materials
D1435. The dimensions of WPC specimens depend on the for manufacturing the composite materials was conducted
type of properties being measured. The composite samples employing a Perkin Elmer, Model TGA-7 (Massachusetts,
were fixed on racks facing south and inclined at a 45 o angle USA). The temperature range of testing was from 50 to
on the roof of the ten-floor of the Engineering Building at 600 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C/min under pure nitrogen
Rajamangala University of Technology Srivijaya, Muang, with approximately 6-7 mg samples in weight. In addition,
Songkhla (latitude 7° 12' 3.1"N and longitude 100° 36' 4.7"E), the effects of waste material concentration on melting
which is far from the coast, about 50 meters, as shown in temperature (Tm) and melting enthalpy (ΔHm) of the WPC
Figure 2. The WPC samples were then weathered by a total samples were performed using differential scanning calorimetry
exposure time of 6 months from July 2020 to December (DSC), Model DSC-7, Perkin Elmer (Massachusetts, USA)
2020, which covered the period of the rainy season at at a heating temperature ranging from 20 to 500 °C with a
Songkhla in the South of Thailand. Such period has a severe heating rate of 10 °C/min. The percentage of crystallinity
change in weather conditions both gusty wind from storms, (χc) from compounding between recycled plastics and wood
acidic water from rainfall, high heat, and ultraviolet rays waste was calculated in the following equation (1).
from the sunlight, are accelerators in deterioration of the
H 100
WPCs. The WPC samples were measured after exposure for c = ----------m0-  --------- (1)
2, 4, and 6 months, respectively. The average relative Hm W
humidity in the range of this experiment was 82.03 %RH, where ∆Hm is the enthalpy of fusion determined from DSC,
the total rainfall was 2,366.8 mm from 117 days, and the ΔHm0 is the theoretical enthalpy of fusion of 100 %

Figure 2. Experimental set-up for wood-plastic composites in natural weathering test on (a) July 2, 2020 and (b) September 2, 2020.

Table 3. Characteristics of weather conditions during the natural weathering testing


Number of rainy Rainfall value Average relative humidity Temperature (oC)
Month
(day) (mm) (%RH) Max. Min. Avg.
July 16 138.6 79.82 34.8 23.7 28.1
August 14 245.1 78.60 25.4 22.8 28.3
September 18 146.8 79.91 34.7 23.0 27.9
October 18 285.6 82.96 33.5 23.5 27.2
November 28 925.8 86.02 31.8 22.8 27.0
December 23 624.9 84.86 31.2 23.1 26.6
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2683

crystalline plastic melting (293 J/g for HDPE [28,29] and Three-point Bending Test
148 J/g for PP [30,31]), and W is the weight fraction of Flexural properties of WPC samples were measured using
plastic in the WPCs. a Mechanical Universal Testing Machine, Model NRI-
Visual Surface and Morphological Analysis TS500-50 from Narin Instruments Co. Ltd. (Samutprakarn,
The optical microscopy, Model Zeiss Axioskop (Oberkochen, Thailand), in accordance with ASTM D790. The specimens
Germany), was used to evaluate the changes of the WPC with dimensions of 100 mm (length)×13 mm (width)×4.8 mm
surfaces after exposure for 2, 4, and 6 months. The interfacial (thickness) were tested before and after outdoor exposure for
morphology of WPCs was observed both before and after 2, 4, and 6 months. The condition for the experiment was
outdoor exposure. Also, the voids and interfacial bonding controlled at a crosshead speed of 2 mm/min with a span of
including dispersion of the wood flour in recycled plastics 80 mm. Data were collected and used to calculate the
were investigated by a cross-section area using a Field modulus of rupture (MOR) and modulus of elasticity (MOE)
Emission Scanning Electron Microscope (FE-SEM), Model of each formulation and condition.
FEI Apreo microscope from FEI Company (Oregon, USA). Single Shear Test
Prior to the SEM observation, the surfaces of the samples A single shear test of WPC materials was carried out on
were gold-coated using a sputter coater to prevent electron the Mechanical Universal Testing Machine with a dimension
charging during the imaging analysis. The micrographs were specimen of 76 mm (length)×20 mm (width)×4.8 mm
taken at a magnification level of 500× and an accelerating (thickness) following the standard ASTM D5379. Each
voltage of 5 kV. specimen for the single shear test was controlled at a
Colorimetric Analysis crosshead speed of 2 mm/min. The experimental results
The color measurement of the composite surfaces was were measured before and after weathering for 2, 4, and 6
carried out in accordance with the CIE L*a*b* color system. months. The data obtained from the experiment and their
The WPC samples were measured before and after exposure average values were reported.
time for a total of 6 months using a CHECK 3 portable Hardness Test
spectrophotometer (Datacolor, USA). Generally, the L* The hardness tests of WPC samples un-weathered and
displays the lightness of samples in which the minimum weathered for 2, 4, and 6 months were evaluated in
value of L* represents the black color and a larger L* value accordance with the ASTM D2240 specification. All of the
denotes a perfect reflecting diffuser or white color. The a* specimens with approximate dimensions of 30 mm (length)
and b* values are the chromaticity coordinates representing ×30 mm (width)×4.8 mm (thickness) were investigated
red-green and yellow-blue, respectively. Five specimens of employing a mechanical Shore D Durometer, Model GS-
each condition were measured at three locations on the 702G from Teclock Corporation (Nagano, Japan). Reported
surfaces of each WPC sample. Additionally, the total change values were the average data of hardness measurements.
in color (ΔE) of the composite samples was calculated using
the following equation (2): Results and Discussion
2 2 2
E = L + a + b (2) Characteristics of Raw Materials
Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) is generally applied to
where ΔL, Δa, and Δb represent the differences between measure the thermal stability of polymer; however, it could
before and after the exposure time of L*, a*, and b*, be used to assess thermoplastic types. Due to many post-
respectively. consumer plastics (waste plastic from bags, straws, and
Statistical Analysis cups) used in current work, it is necessary to evaluate their
Experimental results from five samples of each formulation, thermal stability for identifying thermoplastic types by
condition, and characterization were employed to analyze comparing them with virgin plastics (plastic reference). The
statistics. The effects of exposure to the natural weathering TGA and derivative thermogravimetric (DTG) curves of
for 6 months on the WPCs’ properties were evaluated using polypropylene (PP), high-density polyethylene (HDPE),
a two-sample t test. A 5 % significance level (α=0.05) was post-consumer plastics, and wood flour are shown in Figures
used for statistical analysis. 3(a) and 3(b), respectively. As expected, decomposition
profiles of the virgin plastics and the post-consumer plastics
Characterizations are characterized by only one peak. The peak of PP, plastic
Before mechanical testing, all of the specimens were dried straw, and plastic cup started at about 407, 380, and 376 °C
in an oven at a temperature of 50 °C for 24 h to reduce the with maximum derivative weight at 454, 453, and 452 °C,
moisture content in the WPC specimens. All the mechanical respectively, while the HDPE and plastic bag initially
tests were conducted at a room temperature of 25 °C with occurred at approximate 428 and 426 °C with maximum
five replications for each WPC formulation at each exposing weight loss rates at 478 and 476 °C, respectively. It was
time. found that the HDPE and the plastic bag had a higher
2684 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

thermal stability than those PP, straws, and cups. Further, it slightly higher modulus of rupture (MOR), shear strength
could be seen that the thermal stability of the bag is (SS), and hardness than that the straw and the plastic bag
insignificantly different from the HDPE, meanwhile, the gave the lowest mechanical properties. As the above result,
straw and cup have little difference of the thermal stability the straw and cup were proved that they were produced from
with the PP. Meaning that the bag used in the current study the PP, while the bag was manufactured from the HDPE. In
was produced from the HDPE thermoplastic, while the straw fact, the PP plastic has more mechanical properties than the
and cup were generated from the PP. HDPE. Because, the HDPE has ethyl groups attached to
Figure 3 also shows the thermal stability of wood waste. alternate carbon atoms on the chain backbone, while the PP
The first 7 % weight loss of the wood in the range 50-120 °C has methyl groups on the chain backbone, which these
was due to moisture release. The first peak in Figure 3(b) methyl groups contribute to the mechanical properties that
started at about 289 °C and the second peak occurred at are superior to the HDPE [15].
approximately 357 °C for the wood waste. In general, the
thermal decomposition of natural fiber approximately occurs Differential Scanning Calorimetry Analysis
at 250, 358, and 476 °C for hemicelluloses, cellulose, and Effects of the natural weathering on changes in the
their lignin and ash, respectively [27,32], which is consistent thermal properties of the wood-plastic composites at the
with this research. Further, it was found that waste wood’s surface layer were determined from the DSC analysis. Table
chemical composition (by weight) included cellulose 4 presents that the melting temperature (Tm) and melting
41.5 %, hemicellulose 29.1 %, lignin 26.8 %, and ash 2.6 %. enthalpy (ΔHm) of the WPCs reduced after exposure to coast
Mechanical properties of the post-consumer plastics are climate for a total of 6 months. The reduction in the melting
indicated in Table 1. It was found that the plastic cup had a temperature of the weathered WPCs can reflect the
degradation of molecules on the crystalline phase formation
[33]. The increasing addition of WF into the plastic bag
composites slightly affected the melting temperature but
significantly decreased the melting enthalpy of the un-
weathered WPCs. It was further reported that the WPCs
based on a plastic cup and plastic straw have significantly
higher melting temperatures than those WPCs based on
plastic bags.
DSC was often used to determine the crystallinity degree
of the un-weathered and weathered WPCs. Table 4 shows
that the crystallinity of the WPCs based on a bag before
weathering is 67 % and that of the WPCs after weathering
for 6 months is 30.40 %, which indicates that the crystallinity
of the WPCs decreased about 54.63 % after exposing to the
coastal weathering. This is due to the higher concentration of
formed polymer radicals with different functional groups
(carboxyl, carbonyl, vinyl, hydroxyl), which these groups
disable the fine order of polymer chains, resulting in the
reduction of crystallinity degree [34,35]. The increasing
incorporation of WF from 40 to 60 wt% into the plastic bag
composites significantly increased the crystallinity degree

Table 4. Melting temperature, melting enthalpy, and crystallinity


degree of the WPCs in the experiment
Sample Tm (oC) ΔHm (J/g) Crystallinity (%)
B6W4 125.67 117.789 67.00
B6W4* 124.67 53.439 30.40
B4W6 125.83 95.114 81.16
C6W4 149.83 66.923 75.36
S6W4 150.17 59.134 66.59
Note; *WPC sample after weathering for 6 months; Tm is the melt-
Figure 3. Curves of (a) TGA and (b) DTG for raw materials. ing temperature; ΔHm is the heat quantity obtained by DSC.
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2685

by about 21.13 %. This is because of an increment in larger post-consumer plastic and WPCs. For virgin HDPE and
crystals residing closer to the wood fibers. In fact, the post-consumer plastics (bag, straw, and cup), the lightness
crystallization behavior of the blending plastics is influenced and discoloration steadily rose with exposure time, due to
by many factors, such as thermal history, composition, size photobleaching of pigment added into the plastics. The post-
of dispersed particles, and interfacial interactions [36]. consumer plastic from a straw exhibits higher lightness and
Besides, it was also found that the WPCs based on a plastic discoloration than that from bag and cup, and the plastic bag
cup gave the highest crystallinity degree as compared with shows the lowest these values. Further, the virgin HDPE
those based on a plastic bag and plastic straw. The changes shows lower lightness and discoloration than all the post-
in WPC structure will result in changes in all properties. consumer plastic, for the same exposure times. This may be
due to the stronger structure (chains) of the virgin plastic.
Color Changes and Cracked Surface Analysis The WPCs based on a plastic bag illustrate an increase of
Physical appearances of the post-consumer plastic and the lightness and discoloration with exposure time, but for the
recycled plastic composites with different WF contents, after WPCs based on a straw and cup the lightness and discoloration
exposure to the coastal weathering for a total of 6 months, quickly increased up to 4 months of weathering and then
were assessed from lightness, discoloration, and fractured slightly reduced after 6 months. This bleaching could be
surface. Figures 4(a) and 4(b) display lightness (L*) and total attributed to the photo-oxidation of the wood component,
color changes or discolorations (∆E), respectively, of the particularly lignin, while darkening has been caused by

Figure 4. Effects of natural weathering on (a) lightness and (b) total color change of the composites with different plastic types and WF
contents.
2686 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

Table 5. Effects of natural weathering on physical and mechanical properties of the composites with different plastic types and WF contents
Lightness (L*) MOR (MPa) MOE (GPa) SS (MPa) Hardness (Shore D)
Formulation
0M 6 M % change 0 M 6 M % loss 0 M 6 M % loss 0 M 6 M % loss 0 M 6 M % loss
H100 34.7 a 37.4 b 7.8 23.1 a 18.4 b 20.3 0.88 a 0.65 b 26.1 13.3 a 12.9 a 3.01 66.3 a 62.2 b 6.18
a b a b
B100 37.1 44.1 18.8 19.9 16.3 18.1 0.52 a 0.45 b 13.5 11.4 a 10.2 b 10.5 61.9 a 59.9 b 3.23
S100 35.4 a 66.8 b 88.7 54.1 a 41.3 b 23.7 1.84 a 1.57 b 14.7 24.1 a 23.0 b 4.56 73.9 a 71.6 b 3.11
a b a b
C100 38.6 56.7 46.7 57.4 44.3 22.8 1.77 a 1.38 b 22.0 25.7 a 23.7 b 7.78 76.0 a 72.8 b 4.21
B6W4 28.3 a 67.2 b 137.7 17.6 a 15.7 b 10.8 1.07 a 1.05 a 1.90 10.3 a 9.90 a 3.88 65.2 a 64.1 b 1.69
a b a b
B5W5 28.1 69.9 148.5 15.5 12.9 16.8 1.27 a 1.08 b 15.0 10.1 a 9.30 b 7.92 66.2 a 64.9 b 1.96
a b a b
B4W6 27.9 69.0 147.6 13.6 10.3 24.3 1.40 a 1.15 b 17.9 9.90 a 8.80 b 11.1 66.6 a 65.1 b 2.25
S6W4 27.7 a 76.8 b 176.7 31.3 a 27.0 b 13.7 2.31 a 2.09 b 9.50 19.9 a 18.4 b 7.54 76.0 a 74.5 b 1.97
a b a b
S5W5 27.6 76.9 178.3 27.3 22.3 18.3 2.47 a 2.07 b 16.2 18.4 a 16.2 b 12.0 76.8 a 75.2 b 2.08
S4W6 27.5 a 77.2 b 180.1 19.5 a 15.8 b 19.0 2.57 a 1.89 b 26.5 16.0 a 13.8 b 13.8 76.9 a 74.8 b 2.73
a b a b
C6W4 27.7 76.8 177.2 33.5 27.4 18.2 2.40 a 2.08 b 13.3 21.0 a 18.1 b 13.8 77.1 a 76.0 b 1.43
C5W5 28.8 a 76.7 b 166.4 26.8 a 20.9 b 22.0 2.46 a 2.04 b 17.1 18.7 a 16.2 b 13.4 77.4 a 76.2 b 1.55
a b a b
C4W6 27.4 76.1 178.0 20.9 15.5 25.8 2.52 a 1.61 b 36.1 15.2 a 12.5 b 17.8 78.0 a 76.3 b 2.18
Note: M: month; Different superscripts a-b of each property and formulation indicate significant difference (α=0.05) between properties of
un-weathered and weathered specimens for 6 months.

oxidation (black mold) on the surface of the composites correlated to polymer chain scission, which was affected by
[21]. Likewise, the WPCs based on the bag provided the wetting and drying cycles [21,38,39]. When the cracks
lowest lightness and discoloration whereas based on straw occurred and accumulated, the penetration of easier light and
and cup they gave insignificantly different values, for the water into the deep composite structure, facilitated further
same wood contents. Moreover, the WPCs based on a plastic degradation [39]. In addition, the WPCs based on the plastic
bag, straw, and cup steadily show higher lightness and cup clearly illustrate rather and larger surface cracks than
discoloration than those neat post-consumer plastics, for the those based on the plastic bag and straw, for the same wood
same plastic types and exposure times. This result indicates contents. The WPCs with 60 wt% WF obviously display
that the wood flour mainly affected the physical appearances more cracks on the surfaces than that with 40 wt% WF. This
of the WPCs under aging conditions. The photobleaching is indicates that the increasing presence of the wood fiber in
because of the photo-degradation of lignin whose chromophoric the plastic composites accelerated the photodegradation of
groups will absorb ultraviolet radiation and create free the plastics [39,40], and the composites added higher wood
radical groups, meanwhile, it leads to the creation of water- flour had a larger swelling ratio when contacted with water
soluble substances which can dissolve by rainfalls [37]. or moisture [21]. Finally, the changes on these surfaces lead
Further, the two-sample t test in Table 5 also indicates that to degradation in the mechanical properties of the WPCs.
the exposure to the coastal weathering for 6 months
significantly (α=0.05) affected the lightness of the neat Flexural Property Analysis
plastics and the WPCs. The neat plastics and the composites Owing to the widespread outdoor application of the
un-weathered (suffix a) display significantly lower lightness WPCs, the characteristic of the flexural properties of both
than those weathered (suffix b) for 6 months, at the same modulus of rupture (MOR) and modulus of elasticity (MOE)
WF contents and plastic types. is very important. The flexural property loss of the post-
Microscopy images of the composite surfaces before and consumer plastic and the recycled plastic composites
after weathering for 2, 4, and 6 months were shown in Table reinforced by the different WF contents are displayed in
6. Prior to exposure (un-weathered), the WPC surfaces were Figure 5. Both MOR and MOE of the post-consumer plastic
smooth with no significant defects, meaning it could be and WPCs were reduced with exposure times. When the
concluded that encapsulation of wood fiber into a plastic WPCs are exposed to ultraviolet rays, chain scissions of the
matrix is successful. However, with higher WF loading the plastics occurred continually with the exposure times. It
surfaces became rougher. This could well explain that a affects the crystalline regions and decreases the crystallinity
larger WF content would be exposed on the composites’ of the plastics, as the results shown earlier in DSC analysis.
surface. After natural exposure, the WPC surfaces became Likewise, the two-sample t test in Table 5 also displays that
more cracks appeared in the plastic matrix with increasing the exposure to coastal weathering for 6 months significantly
exposure time. The cracks on the WPC surfaces are directly (α=0.05) decreased the MOR and MOE of the neat plastics
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2687

Table 6. Optical microscopy images of the WPC surfaces at different weathering stages
Un-weathered Weathered for 2 months Weathered for 4 months Weathered for 6 months

B6W4

B4W6

S6W4

S4W6

C6W4

C4W6

and the WPCs, except the MOE of the plastic bag outdoor weathering for 360 days. The WPCs with higher
composites reinforced with 40 wt% WF (loss about 1.90 %). plastic contents had better encapsulation of the wood fiber,
Moreover, the recycled plastic composites with higher WF which helps superior protection from ultraviolet radiation
contents sharply lost MOR and MOE after weathering for 6 and humidity [15,41]. Further, the swelling of WPCs
months; for example, the composites between the plastic cup absorbed humidity increased with WF content, which causes
and wood flour of 40, 50, and 60 wt% showed a reduction of microcracks in the plastic matrix, resulting in a decrement of
MOR about 18.2 %, 22.0 %, and 25.8 %, respectively, for efficiency in stress transfer from plastic matrix to wood fiber
MOE about 13.3 %, 17.1 %, and 36.1 %, respectively, as [21,42]. Besides, the composites from plastic cup lost the
shown in Table 5. These findings agree with Te-Hsin et al. largest MOR and MOE and the plastic bag showed the
[41] reporting that the WPCs with 60 wt% wood sawdust lowest loss. This result could be substantiated with the
gave the highest losses of mechanical properties after microscopy images (as illustrated in Table 6), that the WPCs
2688 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

Figure 5. Effects of natural weathering on (a) MOR and (b) MOE of the composites with different plastic types and WF contents.

based on a plastic cup showed the largest surface cracks, the MOE. Since wood has more modulus or stiffness as
while the composites based on plastic bags exhibited the compared with plastic matrix, and thus the increasing
fewer cracks on surfaces, resulting in the lowest loss of incorporation of WF rises the stiffness of the WPCs. However,
flexural properties. after weathering for 4 and 6 months the composites based on
The effects of WF contents and post-consumer plastic a plastic straw and cup illustrated trends of a decrease in
types on the MOR and MOE of WPCs are also shown in MOE with the increasing additions of WF content.
Figure 5. As expected, the MOR of all the WPCs revealed Furthermore, the virgin HDPE presented the lower MOR
that the strength reduced continuously with WF content. and MOE than those post-consumer plastics, i.e., straw and
This is because the WF suppresses the orientation strengthening cup. The above result, the plastic straw and cup were
of the plastic at high deformation, leading to a reduction of produced from the PP that has methyl groups on the chain
the deformation, which causes the WPC specimens to break backbone, which leads to superior mechanical properties
close to the yield point [43]. Homkhiew et al. [44] also than the HDPE [15]. It was further found that the MOR and
explained that a reduction in the strength of the WPCs can MOE of WPCs based on a plastic straw are slightly different
be caused by entanglement and agglomeration of WF in the than based on a plastic cup, but they have significantly
plastic matrix as well as the poor interfacial bonding higher MOR and MOE than WPCs based on a plastic bag.
between wood fiber and plastic matrix, which can be proved These results can be substantiated in SEM micrographs
from the morphological analysis. In contrast, an increase of (Figure 6) which illustrate that the composites based on
WF contents in the un-weathered plastic composites rises plastic straw (Figures 6(c) and 6(d)) and plastic cup (Figures
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2689

Figure 6. SEM micrographs (magnification of 500×) of WPCs made from (a), (b) plastic bag, (c), (d) plastic straw, and (e), (f) plastic cup.

6(e) and 6(f)) had less voids, fewer porosities, and better and WPCs reduced slightly in all cases with the increasing
interfacial bonding between the plastic matrix and WF than exposure time. Variation in decrement of the shear strength
those based on a plastic bag (Figures 6(a) and 6(b)). was partly correlated to the climate. This is due to the
Therefore, the plastic composites based on a straw and cup moisture and ultraviolet rays. When plastics were exposed to
had stronger efficiency in transferring force from matrix to ultraviolet rays, a chain scission mechanism of the plastics
WF, which led to higher bearing capacity. occurs, resulting in the generation of the free radicals and
reduction of the molecular weight [45,46]. Likewise, the
Shear Strength Analysis moisture absorption of the WPCs enhanced the degradation
The effects of the coastal weathering on the shear strength of interfacial adhesion [47] because the swelling of wood
of the post-consumer plastic and the recycled plastic fiber destroys the bonding with the plastic matrix [48]. Both
composites with different WF contents are illustrated in of these lead to reduce the mechanical properties of the
Figure 7. The shear strength of the post-consumer plastic WPCs, due to a decrease in the efficiency of loading transfer
2690 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

from the plastic matrix to the wood fiber. Further, the two- was manufactured from the HDPE. Thus, the WPCs with a
sample t test in Table 5 also demonstrates that the effects of plastic bag displayed the lowest shear strength. Further, the
exposure to the natural weathering for 6 months were shear strength of the WPCs exhibited a continuous decrease
statistically significant the shear strength of all WPCs, with WF content. This result can be proved by considering
except the plastic bag composites reinforced with 40 wt% the SEM images in Figure 6. The recycled plastic composites
WF (loss about 3.88 %). The composites un-weathered reinforced with higher WF content (Figures 6(b), (d), and
(suffix a) show significantly higher shear strength than those (f)) display rougher surfaces, larger agglomeration of WF,
weathered (suffix b) for 6 months, at the same WF contents and more gaps between WF and cavities between WF and
and plastic types. plastic matrix. Thus, it led to having a worse stress transfer
The shear strength of neat plastics reduced by 3.01 %, between the plastic matrix and WF, which results in a
10.5 %, 4.56, and 7.78 % for virgin HDPE, bag, straw, and decrease in the load resistance performance [50].
cup, respectively, while the strengths decreased in ranges of
3.88-11.1 %, 7.54-13.8 %, and 13.41-17.8 % for WPCs Hardness Analysis
based on the bag, straw, and cup, respectively, after 6 months The hardness of each post-consumer plastic and recycled
of weathering, as shown in Table 5. The WPCs with a lower plastic composites with different WF contents is shown in
WF content had lesser losses in the mechanical properties. Figure 8. As expected, the hardness of all the post-consumer
Since the addition of lower WF increases the ductility of the plastic revealed a similar trend to the MOR and the shear
WPCs [49]. Also, the WPCs with lesser WF proportion strength: the post-consumer plastic from the cup reached the
absorb lower moisture which results in the damage from highest hardness whereas from the bag it attained the lowest
smaller swelling. Further, the WPCs based on a straw and value, due to the plastic bag produced from the HDPE.
cup exhibit more shear strength loss after 6 months of Further, the post-consumer plastics from both a straw and
weathering than all the neat plastics. Ratanawilai and cup present a higher hardness value than the virgin HDPE.
Taneerat [15] discussed that the humidity absorbed by the This is because both the straw and the cup were manufactured
WPCs penetrates into voids and gaps between the phases, from the PP which has larger hardness than the pure HDPE.
which can damage the compatibility between the phases of The choice of post-consumer plastic significantly influenced
plastic matrix and wood filler. the hardness value of WPCs. The composites from a plastic
Figure 7 also shows the effects of post-consumer plastic cup gave the largest hardness value while the plastic bag
types and WF contents on the shear strength of WPCs. As obtained the lowest value, which is consistent with the
can be seen, the WPCs based on a plastic bag showed the hardness of neat post-consumer plastic. It is also revealed
lowest shear strength as compared to the composites that the average hardness of WPCs generally rose with the
containing other post-consumer plastic, and the composites reinforcing WF content. This is caused by the fact that the
based on a plastic cup displayed the highest strength, which wood fiber has a significantly greater hardness than those
is agreeable with the shear strength of neat post-consumer weak plastic matrices [32,44], and the increasing incorporation
plastic. Normally, the strengths of the WPCs depend on the of the wood fiber into the plastic composites reduced the
mechanical properties of neat plastics. In current work, the elasticity of polymer chains, leading to stiffer composites
plastic cup was produced from the PP, but the plastic bag [51].

Figure 7. Effects of natural weathering on shear strength of the composites with different plastic types and WF contents.
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2691

Figure 8. Effects of natural weathering on the hardness of the composites with different plastic types and WF contents.

Figure 8 also displays the degradation in hardness values higher thermal stability than those PP, straw, and cup. For
of the post-consumer plastics and the recycled plastic the physical appearances, the virgin HDPE, the neat post-
composites with different amounts of WF. The average consumer plastics, and the composites based on plastic bags
hardness of the virgin HDPE, the post-consumer plastics, exhibited that the lightness and discoloration steadily rose
and the WPCs decreased with exposure time. This was with the exposure time. Both neat plastic and composites
caused by the increasing number of polymer chain scissions from straws showed higher lightness and discoloration than
with the exposure time [52], resulting in embrittlement and those from bag and cup, and the plastic bag showed the
surface cracks, as shown in Table 6. The shorter polymer lowest these values. In addition, the characteristics of the
chains lead to lowers molecular weight of the polyolefin mechanical properties need to evaluate for deciding the
which results in the degradation of all mechanical properties outdoor applications of the WPCs. All the mechanical
[38]. The virgin HDPE and all neat post-consumer plastics properties of the post-consumer plastics and the WPCs
lose more hardness after 6-month exposure than all the significantly (α=0.05) decreased in all cases after coastal
WPCs, as shown in Table 5. The neat post-consumer plastics weathering for 6 months. Meaning that the lifetimes of the
exhibited the hardness loss in the range of 3.11-4.21 % and WPCs are shortened after exposure to coastal weathering.
the WPCs lost the hardness in a range of 1.43-2.73 %, but, The virgin HDPE presented lower MOR, MOE, SS, and
interestingly, the virgin HDPE loses its hardness up to hardness than those of a plastic straw and cup. The WPCs
6.18 %. This is probably because of the presence of chemical based on a plastic bag showed the lowest mechanical
impurities in plastic products (cups, straws, and bags), which properties as compared to the composites containing other
might enhance the resistance to ultraviolet rays. Further, it post-consumer plastics because the straw and cup were
was also found that the hardness loss of the recycled plastic generated from the PP plastic. Further, the MOR and SS of
composites clearly rose with an increment of the reinforcing all the WPCs also revealed that the strength reduced
WF content. Since the number of plastic chain scissions on continuously when the WF additions rose, due to larger
the WPCs’ surfaces increases. These results could be also agglomeration of WF and more gaps between WF and
substantiated with microscopy images in the Table 6, in plastic matrix. Moreover, the composites with higher WF
which the WPCs with higher WF contents illustrate more contents sharply lost MOR, MOE, SS, and hardness after
and larger cracks on the surfaces. A two-sample t test (in coastal weathering for 6 months. This is because the WPCs
Table 5) indicates that the exposure to the coastal weathering with higher WF contents are poorer protection from
for 6 months significantly (α=0.05) reduced the hardness of ultraviolet radiation and humidity. Based on the findings of
the neat plastics and the WPCs. these results, the composites with a small amount of WF are
suggested for manufacturing the WPC products in applications
Conclusion under coastal weathering. The research of WPCs exposure to
coastal weathering should be further performed and tested
The experimental results showed that the coastal exposure over a year in order to cover year-round weather conditions
time, different post-consumer plastic types and WF contents and reveal the lifetime of WPC products. Finally, it could be
significantly affected all of the properties of the WPCs. The concluded that post-consumer plastics and wood waste are
TGA results revealed that the HDPE and plastic bag had a possible as raw materials for manufacturing the WPCs, and
2692 Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 Chatree Homkhiew et al.

it is the promising solution for recycling these wastes to 17. X. L. Hao, X. Yi, L. C. Sun, D. Y. Tu, Q. W. Wang, and R.
reduce the abundance of wastes in landfills and environmental X. Ou, Constr. Build. Mater., 226, 879 (2020).
conservation. 18. T. Ratanawilai, K. Nakawirot, A. Deachsrijan, and C.
Homkhiew, Fiber. Polym., 15, 2160 (2014).
Acknowledgements 19. A. N. Shebani, A. J. Van Reenen, and M. Meincken, J.
Compos. Mater., 43, 1305 (2009).
The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support 20. E. Kuka, D. Cirule, J. Kajaks, I. Andersone, and B.
from the Thailand Science Research and Innovation Andersons, Int. Wood Prod. J., 9, 90 (2018).
(Research Grant Code: 324) and the Rajamangala University 21. C. Homkhiew, T. Ratanawilai, and W. Thongruang, Ind.
of Technology Srivijaya (RMUTSV), Thailand. We would Crop Prod., 56, 52 (2014).
also like to thank Mr. Suppawit Hongsopa and Mr. Ammarin 22. D. Friedrich and A. Luible, Constr. Build. Mater., 124,
Intarasanee for supporting this work and to convey my 1142 (2016).
thanks to Ms. Iris Leonard from University of North 23. K. C. Hung, Y. L. Chen, and J. H. Wu, Polym. Degrad.
Carolina at Chapel Hill for editing this article. Stabil., 97, 1680 (2012).
24. R. M. Taib, N. S. A. Zauzi, Z. A. M. Ishak, and H. D.
Conflicts of Interest Rozman, Malay. Polym. J., 5, 193 (2010).
25. X. Zhou, S. Huang, and L. Chen, J. Vinyl. Addit. Technol.,
The authors declare no conflict of interest. 22, 311 (2016).
26. C. B. Silva, A. B. Martins, A. L. Catto, and R. M. C. Santana,
References Revis. Matéria, doi.org/10.1590/S1517-707620170002.
0168 (2017).
1. W. Markphan, C. Mamimin, W. Suksong, P. Prasertsan, 27. H. Essabir, R. Boujmal, M. O. Bensalah, D. Rodrigue, R.
and S. O-Thong, Peer J., doi.org/10.7717/peerj.9693 (2020). Bouhfid, and A. Qaiss, Mech. Mater., 98, 36 (2016).
2. I. Kamdar, S. Ali, A. Bennui, K. Techato, and W. 28. P. Zou, H. Xiong, and S. Tang, Carbohydr. Polym., 73, 378
Jutidamrongphan, Resour. Conserv. Recyc., 149, 220 (2019). (2008).
3. A. Ashori, Polym. Plast. Technol. Eng., 47, 741 (2008). 29. G. Liang, J. Xu, S. Bao, and W. Xu, J. Appl. Polym. Sci.,
4. P. T. Nguyen, M. Yasuhiro, and F. Takeshi, Environ. Monit. 91, 3974 (2004).
Assess., 175, 23 (2011). 30. T. Ratanawilai and C. Srivabut, Case Stud. Constr. Mater.,
5. A. R. Putri, T. Fujimori, and M. Takaoka, J. Mater. Cycles 16, e00791 (2022).
Waste Manag., 20, 2140 (2018). 31. M. D. H. Beg and K. L. Pickering, Polym. Degrad. Stabil.,
6. PCD, Thailand State of Pollution Control Report, https:// 93, 1939 (2008).
infofile.pcd.go.th/Waste/Wst2019.pdf (Accessed April 15, 32. C. Homkhiew, W. Boonchouytan, W. Cheewawuttipong,
2021). and T. Ratanawilai, J. Mater. Cycles Waste Manag., 20,
7. Greenpeace Thailand, Greenpeace is Powered by People 1792 (2018).
Like You. https://www.greenpeace.org/thailand (Accessed 33. S. Butylina, M. Hyvärinen, and T. Kärki, Polym. Degrad.
July 23, 2021). Stabil., 97, 337 (2012).
8. Y. L. Jiun, C. T. Tze, U. Moosa, and M. A. Tawawneh, 34. M. Pracella, L. Rolla, D. Chionna, and A. Galeski,
Polym. Polym. Compos., 24, 735 (2016). Macromol. Chem. Phys., 203, 1473 (2002).
9. T. A. Lin, J. H. Lin, and L. M. Bao, Appl. Sci., 10, 5810 35. L. K. Krehula, Z. Katančić, A. P. Siročić, and Z. Hrnjak-
(2020). Murgić, J. Wood Chem. Technol., 34, 39 (2014).
10. B. Liu, P. Zhu, A. C. Xu, and L. M. Bao, J. Thermoplast. 36. I. Spiridon, O. M. Paduraru, M. Rudowski, M. Kozlowski,
Compos. Mater., 32, 342 (2019). and R. N. Darie, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 51, 7279 (2012).
11. S. P. Cestari, P. J. Martin, P. R. Hanna, M. P. Kearns, L. C. 37. C. Badji, L. Soccalingame, H. Garay, A. Bergeret, and J. C.
Mendes, and B. Millar, J. Polym. Eng., 41, 509 (2021). Bénézet, Polym. Degrad. Stabil., 137, 162 (2017).
12. C. Homkhiew, T. Ratanawilai, and W. Thongruang, J. 38. S. Khamtree, T. Ratanawilaia, and S. Ratanawilaib, Mater.
Thermoplast. Compos. Mater., 28, 179 (2015). Today Commun., 24, 100971 (2020).
13. L. C. Yu, D. F. Zhao, and W. Wang, Waste Manag., 84, 402 39. Y. Peng, R. Liu, J. Cao, and Y. Chen, Appl. Surf. Sci., 317,
(2019). 385 (2014).
14. C. Srivabut, T. Ratanawilai, and S. Hiziroglu, Constr. 40. R. N. Darie, R. Bodirlau, C. A. Teaca, J. Macyszyn, M.
Build. Mater., 162, 450 (2018). Kozlowski, and I. Sporodpn, Int. J. Polym. Anal. Charact.,
15. T. Ratanawilai and K. Taneerat, Constr. Build. Mater., 172, 18, 315 (2013).
349 (2018). 41. Y. Te-Hsin, Y. Tsu-Hsien, C. Wei-Cheng, and L. Shao-
16. C. Srivabut, T. Ratanawilai, and S. Hiziroglu, J. Mater. Yuan, Constr. Build. Mater., 88, 159 (2015).
Cycles Waste Manag., 23, 1503 (2021). 42. S. Sair, A. Oushabi, A. Kammouni, O. Tanane, Y. Abboud,
Performance of WPCs from Post-consumer Plastics Fibers and Polymers 2022, Vol.23, No.9 2693

and A. El Bouari, Case Stud. Constr. Mater., 8, 203 (2018). 48. V. D. Nguyen, T. T. Nguyen, A. Zhang, J. Hao, and W.
43. S. P. Appu, O. Ashwaq, M. Al-Harthi, and Y. Umar, J. Wang, J. For. Res., 31, 1071 (2020).
Thermoplas. Compos. Mater., 34, 316 (2021). 49. A. Vedrtnam, S. Kumar, and S. Chaturvedi, Compos. B
44. C. Homkhiew, S. Rawangwong, W. Boonchouytan, W. Eng., 176, 107282 (2019).
Thongruang, and T. Ratanawilai, Int. J. Polym. Sci., doi.org/ 50. C. Lazrak, B. Kabouchi, M. Hammi, A. Famiri, and M.
10.1155/2018/7179527 (2018). Ziani, Case Stud. Constr. Mater., 10, e00227 (2019).
45. E. Yousif and R. Haddad, SpringerPlus., 2, 398 (2013). 51. M. S. Jamil, I. Ahmad, and I. Abdullah, J. Polym. Res.,
46. S. B. Torun, E. D. Tomak, A. D. Cavdar, and F. Mengeloglu, 13, 315 (2006).
Polym. Test., 101, 107290 (2021). 52. H. Du, W. Wang, Q. Wang, Z. Zhang, S. Sui, and Y. Zhan,
47. B. Chen, Z. Luo, H. Chen, C. Chen, D. Cai, P. Qin, H. Cao, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 118, 1068 (2010).
and T. Tan, Waste Biomass Valori., 11, 1701 (2020).

You might also like