Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ed - eBook PDF
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://ebooksecure.com/download/harpers-illustrated-biochemistry-32th-ed-ebook-pd
f-2/
a LANGE medical book
Harper’s
Illustrated
Biochemistry THIRTY-SECOND EDITION
New York Chicago San Francisco Athens London Madrid Mexico City
Milan New Delhi Singapore Sydney Toronto
Copyright © 2023 by McGraw Hill, LLC. All rights reserved. Except as permitted under the United States Copyright Act of 1976, no part of this pub-
lication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior written permission
of the publisher.
ISBN: 978-1-26-046995-0
MHID: 1-26-046995-6
The material in this eBook also appears in the print version of this title: ISBN: 978-1-26-046994-3,
MHID: 1-26-046994-8.
All trademarks are trademarks of their respective owners. Rather than put a trademark symbol after every occurrence of a trademarked name, we use
names in an editorial fashion only, and to the benet of the trademark owner, with no intention of infringement of the trademark. Where such designa-
tions appear in this book, they have been printed with initial caps.
McGraw-Hill Education eBooks are available at special quantity discounts to use as premiums and sales promotions or for use in corporate training
programs. To contact a representative, please visit the Contact Us page at www.mhprofessional.com.
Notice
Medicine is an ever-changing science. As new research and clinical experience broaden our knowledge, changes in treatment and drug therapy are
required. The authors and the publisher of this work have checked with sources believed to be reliable in their efforts to provide information that is
complete and generally in accord with the standards accepted at the time of publication. However, in view of the possibility of human error or changes
in medical sciences, neither the authors nor the publisher nor any other party who has been involved in the preparation or publication of this work war-
rants that the information contained herein is in every respect accurate or complete, and they disclaim all responsibility for any errors or omissions or
for the results obtained from use of the information contained in this work. Readers are encouraged to conrm the information contained herein with
other sources. For example and in particular, readers are advised to check the product information sheet included in the package of each drug they plan
to administer to be certain that the information contained in this work is accurate and that changes have not been made in the recommended dose or in
the contraindications for administration. This recommendation is of particular importance in connection with new or infrequently used drugs.
TERMS OF USE
This is a copyrighted work and McGraw-Hill Education and its licensors reserve all rights in and to the work. Use of this work is subject to these terms.
Except as permitted under the Copyright Act of 1976 and the right to store and retrieve one copy of the work, you may not decompile, disassemble,
reverse engineer, reproduce, modify, create derivative works based upon, transmit, distribute, disseminate, sell, publish or sublicense the work or any
part of it without McGraw-Hill Education’s prior consent. You may use the work for your own noncommercial and personal use; any other use of the
work is strictly prohibited. Your right to use the work may be terminated if you fail to comply with these terms.
THE WORK IS PROVIDED “AS IS.” McGRAW-HILL EDUCATION AND ITS LICENSORS MAKE NO GUARANTEES OR WARRANTIES
AS TO THE ACCURACY, ADEQUACY OR COMPLETENESS OF OR RESULTS TO BE OBTAINED FROM USING THE WORK, INCLUD-
ING ANY INFORMATION THAT CAN BE ACCESSED THROUGH THE WORK VIA HYPERLINK OR OTHERWISE, AND EXPRESSLY
DISCLAIM ANY WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANT-
ABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. McGraw-Hill Education and its licensors do not warrant or guarantee that the functions
contained in the work will meet your requirements or that its operation will be uninterrupted or error free. Neither McGraw-Hill Education nor its
licensors shall be liable to you or anyone else for any inaccuracy, error or omission, regardless of cause, in the work or for any damages resulting
therefrom. McGraw-Hill Education has no responsibility for the content of any information accessed through the work. Under no circumstances shall
McGraw-Hill Education and/or its licensors be liable for any indirect, incidental, special, punitive, consequential or similar damages that result from
the use of or inability to use the work, even if any of them has been advised of the possibility of such damages. This limitation of liability shall apply
to any claim or cause whatsoever whether such claim or cause arises in contract, tort or otherwise.
CoAuthors
David A. Bender, PhD Robert K. Murray, MD, PhD
Proessor (Emeritus) o Nutritional Biochemistry Emeritus Proessor o Biochemistry
University College London University o oronto
London, United Kingdom oronto, Ontario, Canada
iii
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Preace ix
S E C T I O N
10 The Biochemical Roles o Transition
Structures & Functions of Metals 96
S E C T I O N
S E C T I O N Metabolism of
Enzymes: Kinetics,
v
vi CONTENTS
17 Glycolysis & the Oxidation o Pyruvate 163 28 Catabolism o Proteins & o Amino Acid
Owen P. McGuinness, PhD Nitrogen 279
Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
18 Metabolism o Glycogen 171
Owen P. McGuinness, PhD 29 Catabolism o the Carbon Skeletons o
Amino Acids 290
19 Gluconeogenesis & the Control o Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
Blood Glucose 180
Owen P. McGuinness, PhD 30 Conversion o Amino Acids to Specialized
Products 306
20 The Pentose Phosphate Pathway & Other Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
Pathways o Hexose Metabolism 191
Owen P. McGuinness, PhD 31 Porphyrins & Bile Pigments 315
Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
S E C T I O N
32 Nucleotides 329
22 Oxidation o Fatty Acids: Ketogenesis 217 Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Peter A. Mayes, PhD, DSc
33 Metabolism o Purine & Pyrimidine
23 Biosynthesis o Fatty Acids & Nucleotides 337
Eicosanoids 226 Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Peter A. Mayes, PhD, DSc
34 Nucleic Acid Structure & Function 348
24 Metabolism o Acylglycerols & P. Anthony Weil, PhD
Sphingolipids 239
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Peter A. Mayes, PhD, DSc 35 DNA Organization, Replication, &
Repair 360
25 Lipid Transport & Storage 247 P. Anthony Weil, PhD
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Peter A. Mayes, PhD, DSc
36 RNA Synthesis, Processing, &
26 Cholesterol Synthesis, Transport, & Modication 384
Excretion 259 P. Anthony Weil, PhD
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Peter A. Mayes, PhD, DSc
37 Protein Synthesis & the Genetic Code 404
P. Anthony Weil, PhD
S E C T I O N
Metabolism of Proteins &
VI Amino Acids 273 38 Regulation o Gene Expression 420
P. Anthony Weil, PhD
S E C T I O N S E C T I O N
Biochemistry of
Extracellular & Intracellular Special Topics (B) 581
VIII Communication 467 X
49 Intracellular Trafc & Sorting o Proteins 581
40 Membranes: Structure &
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Robert K. Murray, MD, PhD
Function 467
P. Anthony Weil, PhD
50 The Extracellular Matrix 599
Kathleen M. Botham, PhD, DSc, & Robert K. Murray, MD, PhD
41 The Diversity o the Endocrine
System 488
P. Anthony Weil, PhD
51 Muscle & the Cytoskeleton 618
January D. Haile, PhD, & Peter J. Kennelly, PhD
S E C T I O N
54 White Blood Cells 664
Special Topics (A) 527
IX Peter J. Kennelly, PhD
ix
x PREFACE
C H A P T E R
1
2 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
and dramatically demonstrated that ermentation can proceed the interrelationship o biochemistry and medicine is a wide,
in the absence o an intact cell. his discovery unleashed an two-way street. Biochemical studies have illuminated many
avalanche o research that initiated the science o biochemis- aspects o health and disease, and conversely, the study o vari-
try. Investigations revealed the vital roles o inorganic phos- ous aspects o health and disease has opened up new areas o
phate, ADP, AP, and NAD(H), and ultimately identiied biochemistry (Figure 1–1). An early example o how investiga-
the phosphorylated sugars and the chemical reactions and tion o protein structure and unction revealed the single di-
enzymes that convert glucose to pyruvate (glycolysis) or to erence in amino acid sequence between normal hemoglobin
ethanol and CO2 (ermentation). Research beginning in the and sickle cell hemoglobin. Subsequent analysis o numerous
1930s identiied the intermediates o the citric acid cycle and variant sickle cell and other hemoglobins has contributed sig-
o urea biosynthesis, and revealed the essential roles o certain niicantly to our understanding o the structure and unction
vitamin-derived coactors or “coenzymes” such as thiamin both o hemoglobin and o other proteins. During the early
pyrophosphate, ribolavin, and ultimately coenzyme A, coen- 1900s, the English physician Archibald Garrod studied patients
zyme Q, and cobamide coenzyme. he 1950s revealed how with the relatively rare disorders o alkaptonuria, albinism, cys-
complex carbohydrates are synthesized rom, and broken tinuria, and pentosuria, and established that these conditions
down into simple sugars, and the pathways or biosynthesis were genetically determined. Garrod designated these condi-
o pentoses, and the catabolism o amino acids and atty acids. tions as inborn errors of metabolism. His insights provided
Investigators employed animal models, perused intact a oundation or the development o the ield o human bio-
organs, tissue slices, cell homogenates and their subractions, chemical genetics. A more recent example was investigation
and subsequently puriied enzymes. Advances were enhanced o the genetic and molecular basis o amilial hypercholester-
by the development o analytical ultracentriugation, paper olemia, a disease that results in early-onset atherosclerosis. In
and other orms o chromatography, and the post-World addition to clariying dierent genetic mutations responsible
War II availability o radioisotopes, principally 14C, 3H, and 32P, or this disease, this provided a deeper understanding o cell
as “tracers” to identiy the intermediates in complex pathways receptors and mechanisms o uptake, not only o cholesterol
such as that o cholesterol biosynthesis. X-ray crystallogra- but also o how other molecules cross cell membranes. Stud-
phy was then used to solve the three-dimensional structures ies o oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes in cancer cells
o numerous proteins, polynucleotides, enzymes, and viruses. have directed attention to the molecular mechanisms involved
Genetic advances that ollowed the realization that DNA was a in the control o normal cell growth. hese examples illustrate
double helix include the polymerase chain reaction, and trans- how the study o disease can open up areas o basic biochemi-
genic animals or those with gene knockouts. he methods used cal research. Science provides physicians and other workers
to prepare, analyze, puriy, and identiy metabolites and the in health care and biology with a oundation that impacts
activities o natural and recombinant enzymes and their three- practice, stimulates curiosity, and promotes the adoption o
dimensional structures are discussed in the ollowing chapters. scientiic approaches or continued learning.
BIOCHEMICAL PROCESSES
BIOCHEMISTRY & MEDICINE UNDERLIE HUMAN HEALTH
HAVE PROVIDED MUTUAL
ADVANCES Biochemical Research Impacts
he two major concerns or workers in the health sciences— Nutrition & Preventive Medicine
and particularly physicians—are the understanding and he World Health Organization (WHO) deines health as a state
maintenance o health and eective treatment o disease. Bio- o “complete physical, mental, and social well-being and not
chemistry impacts both o these undamental concerns, and merely the absence o disease and inirmity.” From a biochemical
Biochemistry
Nucleic
acids Proteins Lipids Carbohydrates
Medicine
FIGURE 1–1 A two-way street connects biochemistry and medicine. Knowledge of the biochemical topics listed above the green
line of the diagram has clarified our understanding of the diseases shown below the green line. Conversely, analyses of the diseases have cast
light on many areas of biochemistry. Note that sickle cell anemia is a genetic disease, and that both atherosclerosis and diabetes mellitus have
genetic components.
CHAPTER 1 Biochemistry & Medicine 3
viewpoint, health may be considered that situation in which all announcement that over 90% o the genome had been sequenced.
o the many thousands o intra- and extracellular reactions that his eort was headed by the International Human Genome
occur in the body are proceeding at rates commensurate with Sequencing Consortium and by Celera Genomics. Except or
the organism’s survival under pressure rom both internal and a ew gaps, the sequence o the entire human genome was
external challenges. he maintenance o health requires optimal completed in 2003, just 50 years ater the description o the
dietary intake o vitamins, certain amino acids and fatty acids, double-helical nature o DNA by Watson and Crick. he
various minerals, and water. Understanding nutrition depends implications or biochemistry, medicine, and indeed or all
to a great extent on knowledge o biochemistry, and the sciences o biology, are virtually unlimited. For example, the ability
o biochemistry and nutrition share a ocus on these chemicals. to isolate and sequence a gene and to investigate its structure
Recent increasing emphasis on systematic attempts to maintain and unction by sequencing and “gene knockout” experi-
health and orestall disease, or preventive medicine, includes ments have revealed previously unknown genes and their
nutritional approaches to the prevention o diseases such as products, and new insights have been gained concerning
atherosclerosis and cancer. human evolution and procedures or identiying disease-
related genes.
Most Diseases Have a Biochemical Basis Major advances in biochemistry and understanding
Apart rom inectious organisms and environmental pollut- human health and disease continue to be made by mutation
ants, many diseases are maniestations o abnormalities in genes, o the genomes o model organisms such as yeast, the ruit
proteins, chemical reactions, or biochemical processes, each ly Drosophila melanogaster, the roundworm Caenorhabditis
o which can adversely aect one or more critical biochemical elegans, and the zebra ish; all organisms that can be geneti-
unctions. Examples o disturbances in human biochemistry cally manipulated to provide insight into the unctions o
responsible or diseases or other debilitating conditions include individual genes. hese advances can potentially provide
electrolyte imbalance, deective nutrient ingestion or absorp- clues to curing human diseases such as cancer and Alzheimer
tion, hormonal imbalances, toxic chemicals or biologic agents, disease. Figure 1–2 highlights areas that have developed or
and DNA-based genetic disorders. o address these challenges, accelerated as a direct result o progress made in the Human
biochemical research continues to be interwoven with studies in Genome Project (HGP). New “-omics” ields ocus on com-
disciplines such as genetics, cell biology, immunology, nutrition, prehensive study o the structures and unctions o the mol-
pathology, and pharmacology. In addition, many biochemists are ecules with which each is concerned. he products o genes
vitally interested in contributing to solutions to key issues such (RNA molecules and proteins) are being studied using the
as the ultimate survival o mankind, and educating the public to techniques o transcriptomics and proteomics. A spectacu-
support use o the scientiic method in solving environmental lar example o the speed o progress in transcriptomics is the
and other major problems that conront our civilization. explosion o knowledge about small RNA molecules as regu-
lators o gene activity. Other -omics ields include glycomics,
lipidomics, metabolomics, nutrigenomics, and pharma-
Impact of the Human Genome Project cogenomics. o keep pace with the inormation generated,
on Biochemistry, Biology, & Medicine bioinformatics has received much attention. Other related
Initially unanticipated rapid progress in the late 1990s in ields to which the impetus rom the HGP has carried over are
sequencing the human genome led in the mid-2000s to the biotechnology, bioengineering, biophysics, and bioethics.
Metabolomics Nutrigenomics
Pharmacogenomics Bioinformatics
HGP
(Genomics)
Bioengineering Biotechnology
Biophysics
Bioethics
FIGURE 1–2 The Human Genome Project (HGP) has influenced many disciplines and areas of research. Biochemistry is not listed
since it predates commencement of the HGP, but disciplines such as bioinformatics, genomics, glycomics, lipidomics, metabolomics, molecular
diagnostics, proteomics, and transcriptomics are nevertheless active areas of biochemical research.
4 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
Deinitions o these -omics ields and other terms appear in Bioinformatics: Te discipline concerned with the collection,
the Glossary o this chapter. Nanotechnology is an active area, storage, and analysis o biologic data, or example, DNA, RNA,
which, or example, may provide novel methods o diagnosis and protein sequences.
and treatment or cancer and other disorders. Stem cell biol- Biophysics: Te application o physics and its techniques to biology
and medicine.
ogy is at the center o much current research. Gene therapy
Biotechnology: Te eld in which biochemical, engineering, and
has yet to deliver the promise that it appears to oer, but it
other approaches are combined to develop biologic products o
seems probable that ultimately will occur. Many new molecu- use in medicine and industry.
lar diagnostic tests have developed in areas such as genetic, Gene Terapy: Applies to the use o genetically engineered genes to
microbiologic, and immunologic testing and diagnosis. treat various diseases.
Systems biology is also burgeoning. he outcomes o research Genomics: Te genome is the complete set o genes o an organism,
in the various areas mentioned above will impact tremen- and genomics is the in-depth study o the structures and
dously the uture o biology, medicine, and the health sciences. unctions o genomes.
Synthetic biology oers the potential or creating living organ- Glycomics: Te glycome is the total complement o simple and
isms, initially small bacteria, rom genetic material in vitro complex carbohydrates in an organism. Glycomics is the
that might carry out speciic tasks such as cleansing petroleum systematic study o the structures and unctions o glycomes
such as the human glycome.
spills. All o the above make the 21st century an exhilarating
Lipidomics: Te lipidome is the complete complement o lipids
time to be directly involved in biology and medicine.
ound in an organism. Lipidomics is the in-depth study o the
structures and unctions o all members o the lipidome and
their interactions, in both health and disease.
SUMMARY Metabolomics: Te metabolome is the complete complement o
■ Biochemistry is the science concerned with the molecules metabolites (small molecules involved in metabolism) present
present in living organisms, individual chemical reactions and in an organism. Metabolomics is the in-depth study o their
their enzyme catalysts, and the expression and regulation o structures, unctions, and changes in various metabolic states.
each metabolic process. Biochemistry has become the basic Molecular Diagnostics: Reers to the use o molecular approaches such
language o all biologic sciences. as DNA probes to assist in the diagnosis o various biochemical,
■ Despite the ocus on human biochemistry in this text, genetic, immunologic, microbiologic, and other medical conditions.
biochemistry concerns the entire spectrum o lie orms, rom Nanotechnology: Te development and application to medicine
viruses, bacteria, and plants to complex eukaryotes such as and to other areas o devices such as nanoshells, which are only a
human beings. ew nanometers in size (10–9 m = 1 nm).
Nutrigenomics: Te systematic study o the eects o nutrients on
■ Biochemistry, medicine, and other health care disciplines
genetic expression and o the eects o genetic variations on the
are intimately related. Health in all species depends on a
metabolism o nutrients.
harmonious balance o the biochemical reactions occurring in
Pharmacogenomics: Te use o genomic inormation and
the body, while disease reects abnormalities in biomolecules,
technologies to optimize the discovery and development o new
biochemical reactions, or biochemical processes.
drugs and drug targets.
■ Advances in biochemical knowledge have illuminated many Proteomics: Te proteome is the complete complement o proteins
areas o medicine, and the study o diseases has ofen revealed o an organism. Proteomics is the systematic study o the
previously unsuspected aspects o biochemistry. structures and unctions o proteomes and their variations in
■ Biochemical approaches are ofen undamental in illuminating health and disease.
the causes o diseases and in designing appropriate therapy. Stem Cell Biology: Stem cells are undierentiated cells that have the
Biochemical laboratory tests also represent an integral potential to sel-renew and to dierentiate into any o the adult
component o diagnosis and monitoring o treatment. cells o an organism. Stem cell biology concerns the biology o
■ A sound knowledge o biochemistry and o other related basic stem cells and their potential or treating various diseases.
disciplines is essential or the rational practice o medicine and Synthetic Biology: Te eld that combines biomolecular techniques
related health sciences. with engineering approaches to build new biologic unctions and
systems.
■ Results o the HGP and o research in related areas will have
Systems Biology: Te eld concerns complex biologic systems
a proound inuence on the uture o biology, medicine, and
studied as integrated entities.
other health sciences.
ranscriptomics: Te comprehensive study o the transcriptome,
■ Genomic research on model organisms such as yeast, the ruit the complete set o RNA transcripts produced by the genome
y D. melanogaster, the roundworm C. elegans, and the zebra during a xed period o time.
sh provides insight into understanding human diseases.
APPENDIX
GLOSSARY Shown are selected examples o databases that assemble, annotate,
Bioengineering: Te application o engineering to biology and and analyze data o biomedical importance.
medicine. ENCODE: ENCyclopedia Of DNA Elements. A collaborative eort
Bioethics: Te area o ethics that is concerned with the application that combines laboratory and computational approaches to
o moral and ethical principles to biology and medicine. identiy every unctional element in the human genome.
CHAPTER 1 Biochemistry & Medicine 5
GenBank: Protein sequence database o the National Institutes o ISDB: International Sequence DataBase that incorporates DNA
Health (NIH) stores all known biologic nucleotide sequences and databases o Japan and o the European Molecular Biology
their translations in a searchable orm. Laboratory (EMBL).
HapMap: Haplotype Map, an international eort to identiy single PDB: Protein DataBase. Tree-dimensional structures o proteins,
nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with common polynucleotides, and other macromolecules, including proteins
human diseases and dierential responses to pharmaceuticals. bound to substrates, inhibitors, or other proteins.
C H A P T E R
Water & pH
Peter J. Kennelly, PhD, & Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
2
OBJ E C TI VE S ■ Describe the properties of water that account for its surface tension, viscosity,
liquid state at ambient temperature, and solvent power.
After studying this chapter, ■ Represent the structures of organic compounds that can serve as hydrogen
you should be able to: bond donors or acceptors.
■ Explain the role played by entropy in the association and orientation, in an
aqueous environment, of hydrophobic and amphipathic molecules.
■ Indicate the quantitative contributions of salt bridges, hydrophobic
interactions, and van der Waals forces to stabilizing the 3-D conformation of
macromolecules.
■ Explain the relationship of pH to acidity, alkalinity, and the quantitative
determinants that characterize weak and strong acids.
■ Calculate the shift in pH that accompanies the addition of a given quantity of
acid or base to a buffered solution.
■ Describe what buffers do, how they do it, and the conditions under which
a buffer is most effective under physiologic or other conditions.
■ Use the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation to calculate the net charge on
a polyelectrolyte at a given pH.
BIOMEDICAL IMPORTANCE the pH of extracellular fluid between 7.35 and 7.45. Suspected
disturbances of acid-base balance are verified by measuring
Water is the predominant chemical component of living the pH of arterial blood and the CO2 content of venous blood.
organisms. Its unique physical properties, which include Causes of acidosis (blood pH <7.35) include diabetic ketosis
the ability to solvate a wide range of organic and inorganic and lactic acidosis. Alkalosis (pH >7.45) may follow vomiting
molecules, derive from water’s dipolar structure and excep- of acidic gastric contents.
tional capacity for forming hydrogen bonds. The manner in
which water interacts with a solvated biomolecule influences
the structure both of the biomolecule and of water itself. An WATER IS AN IDEAL BIOLOGIC
excellent nucleophile, water is a reactant or product in many
metabolic reactions. Regulation of water balance depends on SOLVENT
hypothalamic mechanisms that control thirst, on antidiuretic
hormone (ADH), on retention or excretion of water by the
Water Molecules Form Dipoles
kidneys, and on evaporative loss. Nephrogenic diabetes insipi- A water molecule is an irregular, slightly skewed tetrahe-
dus, which involves the inability to concentrate urine or adjust dron with oxygen at its center (Figure 2–1). The corners are
to subtle changes in extracellular fluid osmolarity, results from occupied by the two hydrogens and the unshared electrons
the unresponsiveness of renal tubular osmoreceptors to ADH. of the remaining two sp3-hybridized orbitals of oxygen. The
Water has a slight propensity to dissociate into hydroxide 105° angle between the two hydrogen atoms differs slightly
ions and protons. The concentration of protons, or acidity, of from the ideal tetrahedral angle, 109.5°. The strongly electro-
aqueous solutions is generally reported using the logarithmic negative oxygen atom in a water molecule attracts electrons
pH scale. Bicarbonate and other buffers normally maintain away from the hydrogen nuclei, leaving them with a partial
6
CHAPTER 2 Water & pH 7
H
CH3 CH2 O H O
2e H
2e
H
H
CH3 CH2 O H O
105°
CH2 CH3
H
positive charge, while its two unshared electron pairs consti- RI R III
tute a region of local negative charge. This asymmetric charge
distribution is referred to as a dipole. FIGURE 2–3 Additional polar groups participate in hydrogen
bonding. Shown are hydrogen bonds formed between alcohol and
Water’s strong dipole is responsible for its high dielectric water, between two molecules of ethanol, and between the peptide
constant. As described quantitatively by Coulomb’s law, the carbonyl oxygen and the peptide nitrogen hydrogen of an adjacent
strength of interaction F between oppositely charged particles amino acid.
is inversely proportionate to the dielectric constant ε of the
surrounding medium. The dielectric constant for a vacuum can participate in hydrogen bonding. The oxygen atoms of
is essentially unity; for hexane it is 1.9; for ethanol, 24.3; and aldehydes, ketones, and amides, for example, provide lone
for water at 25°C, 78.5. When dissolved in water, the force pairs of electrons that can serve as hydrogen acceptors. Alco-
of attraction between charged and polar species is greatly hols, carboxylic acids, and amines can serve both as hydrogen
decreased relative to solvents with lower dielectric constants. acceptors and as donors of unshielded hydrogen atoms for
Its strong dipole and high dielectric constant enable water to formation of hydrogen bonds (Figure 2–3).
dissolve large quantities of charged compounds such as salts.
H H H H Energy Energy
O O Bond Type (kcal/mol) Bond Type (kcal/mol)
H
H H H O O—O 34 —O
O— 96
O H O
H O H H S—S 51 C—H 99
H O C—N 70 —S
C— 108
H
S—H 81 O—H 110
FIGURE 2–2 Water molecules self-associate via hydrogen
C—C 82 —C
C— 147
bonds. Shown are the association of two water molecules (left) and a
hydrogen-bonded cluster of four water molecules (right). Notice that C—O 84 —N
C— 147
water can serve simultaneously both as a hydrogen donor and as a
N—H 94 —O
C— 164
hydrogen acceptor.
8 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
Since hydronium and hydroxide ions continuously recom- Kw is numerically equal to the product of the molar concentra-
bine to form water molecules, an individual hydrogen or oxy- tions of H+ and OH−:
gen cannot be stated to be present as an ion or as part of a water
molecule. At one instant it is an ion; an instant later it is part K w = [H+ ][OH− ]
of a water molecule. Individual ions or molecules are therefore
not considered. We refer instead to the probability that at any At 25°C, Kw = (10−7)2, or 10−14 (mol/L)2. At temperatures below
instant in time, a given hydrogen will be present as an ion or 25°C, Kw is somewhat less than 10−14, and at temperatures above
as part of a water molecule. Since 1 g of water contains 3.35 × 25°C it is somewhat greater than 10−14. Within the stated limi-
1022 molecules, the ionization of water can be described statis- tations of temperature, Kw equals 10−14 (mol/L)2 for all aqueous
tically. To state that the probability that a hydrogen exists as an solutions, even solutions containing acids or bases. We can
ion is 0.01 means that at any given moment in time, a hydro- therefore use Kw to calculate the pH of any aqueous solution.
gen atom has 1 chance in 100 of being an ion and 99 chances
out of 100 of being part of a water molecule. The actual prob-
ability of a hydrogen atom in pure water existing as a hydrogen pH IS THE NEGATIVE LOG OF THE
ion is approximately 1.8 × 10−9. The probability of its being HYDROGEN ION CONCENTRATION
part of a water molecule thus is almost unity. Stated another
way, for every hydrogen ion or hydroxide ion in pure water, The term pH was introduced in 1909 by Sörensen, who defined
there are 0.56 billion or 0.56 × 109 water molecules. Hydrogen it as the negative log of the hydrogen ion concentration:
ions and hydroxide ions nevertheless contribute significantly pH = − log[H+ ]
to the properties of water.
For dissociation of water, This definition, while not rigorous, suffices for most biochem-
+
[H ][OH ] − ical purposes. To calculate the pH of a solution:
K=
[H2 O] 1. Calculate the hydrogen ion concentration [H+].
where the brackets represent molar concentrations (strictly 2. Calculate the base 10 logarithm of [H+].
speaking, molar activities) and K is the dissociation constant.
Since 1 mole (mol) of water weighs 18 g, 1 liter (L) (1000 g) 3. pH is the negative of the value found in step 2.
of water contains 1000 ÷ 18 = 55.56 mol. Pure water thus is For example, for pure water at 25°C,
55.56 molar. Since the probability that a hydrogen in pure
water will exist as a hydrogen ion is 1.8 × 10−9, the molar con- pH = − log[H+ ] = − log10−7 = −(−7) = 7.0
centration of H+ ions (or of OH− ions) in pure water is the
product of the probability, 1.8 × 10−9, times the molar concen- This value is also known as the power (English), puissant
tration of water, 55.56 mol/L. The result is 1.0 × 10−7 mol/L. (French), or potennz (German) of the exponent, hence the use
We can now calculate the dissociation constant K for pure of the term “p.”
water: Low pH values correspond to high concentrations of H+
and high pH values correspond to low concentrations of H+.
[H+ ][OH− ] [10−7 ][10−7 ] Acids are proton donors and bases are proton acceptors.
K= =
[H2 O] [55.56] Strong acids (eg, HCl, H2SO4) completely dissociate into anions
and protons even in strongly acidic solutions (low pH). Weak
= 0.018 × 10−14 = 1.8 ×10−16 mol/L
acids dissociate only partially in acidic solutions. Similarly, strong
The molar concentration of water, 55.56 mol/L, is too great bases (eg, KOH, NaOH), but not weak bases like Ca(OH)2, are
to be significantly affected by dissociation. It is therefore con- completely dissociated even at high pH. Many biochemicals are
sidered to be essentially constant. The concentration of pure weak acids. Exceptions include phosphorylated intermediates,
water may therefore be incorporated into the dissociation con- whose phosphoryl group contains two dissociable protons, the
stant K to provide a useful new constant Kw termed the ion first of which is strongly acidic.
product for water: The following examples illustrate how to calculate the pH
of acidic and basic solutions.
[H+ ][OH− ] Example 1: What is the pH of a solution whose hydrogen
K= = 1.8 × 10−16 mol/L
[H2O] ion concentration is 3.2 × 10−4 mol/L?
K w = ( K )[H2O] = [H+ ][OH− ] pH = − log[H+ ]
−16
= (1.8 × 10 mol/L)(55.56mol/L) = − log(3.2 × 10−4 )
−14 2
= 1.00 × 10 (mol/L) = − log(3.2) − log(10−4 )
Note that the dimensions of K are moles per liter and those of = − 0.5 + 4.0
Kw are moles2 per liter2. As its name suggests, the ion product = 3.5
CHAPTER 2 Water & pH 11
Example 2: What is the pH of a solution whose hydroxide that present initially in the water. This assumption is valid
ion concentration is 4.0 × 10−4 mol/L? We first define a quan- for dilute solutions of strong bases or acids, but not for weak
tity pOH that is equal to −log[OH−] and that may be derived bases or acids. Since weak electrolytes dissociate only slightly
from the definition of Kw: in solution, we must use the dissociation constant to calcu-
late the concentration of [H+] (or [OH−]) produced by a given
K w = [H+ ][OH− ] = 10−14 molarity of a weak acid (or base) before calculating total [H+]
(or total [OH−]) and subsequently pH.
Therefore,
log[H+ ] + log[OH− ] = log10−14 Functional Groups That Are Weak Acids
Have Great Physiologic Significance
or
Many biomolecules contain functional groups that are weak
pH + pOH = 14
acids or bases. Carboxyl groups, amino groups, and phosphate
To solve the problem by this approach: esters, whose second dissociation falls within the physiologic
range, are present in proteins and nucleic acids, most coen-
[OH− ] = 4.0 × 10−4 zymes, and most intermediary metabolites. Knowledge of the
dissociation of weak acids and bases thus is basic to under-
pOH = − log[OH− ]
standing the influence of intracellular pH on structure and bio-
= − log(4.0 × 10−4 ) logic activity. Charge-based separations such as electrophoresis
= − log(4.0) − log(10−4 ) and ion exchange chromatography are also best understood in
terms of the dissociation behavior of functional groups.
= −0.60 + 4.0
When discussing weak acids, we often refer to the proton-
= 3.4 ated species (HA or R—SH) as the acid and the unprotonated
species (A− or R—S−) as its conjugate base. Similarly, we may
Now
refer to the deprotonated form as the base (A− or R—COO−) and
pH = 14 − pOH = 14 − 3.4 the protonated form as its conjugate acid (HA or R—COOH).
= 10.6 We express the relative strengths of weak acids in terms
of the dissociation constants of the protonated form. Follow-
Examples 1 and 2 illustrate how the logarithmic pH scale facili- ing are the expressions for the dissociation constant (Ka) for a
tates recording and comparing hydrogen ion concentrations representative weak acid, R—COOH, as well as the conjugate
that differ by orders of magnitude from one another, 0.00032 M acid, R—NH3+, of the weak base R—NH2.
(pH 3.5) and 0.000000000025 M (pH 10.6).
Example 3: What are the pH values of (a) 2.0 × 10−2 mol/L R—COOH R—COO− + H+
KOH and of (b) 2.0 × 10−6 mol/L KOH? The OH− arises from [R —COO− ][H+ ]
two sources, KOH and water. Since pH is determined by the Ka =
[R—COOH]
total [H+] (and pOH by the total [OH−]), both sources must be
considered. In the first case (a), the contribution of water to R—NH3+ R—NH2 + H+
the total [OH−] is negligible. The same cannot be said for the [R—NH2 ][H+ ]
second case (b): Ka =
[R—NH3+ ]
Concentration (mol/L)
Since the numeric values of Ka for weak acids are negative
(a) (b) exponential numbers, we express Ka as pKa, where
Molarity of KOH 2.0 × 10−2 2.0 × 10−6 pK a = − log K a
− −2 −6
[OH ] from KOH 2.0 × 10 2.0 × 10
Note that pKa is related to Ka as pH is to [H+]. The stronger the
− −7
[OH ] from water 1.0 × 10 1.0 × 10−7 acid, the lower is its pKa value.
Total [OH−] 2.00001 × 10−2 2.1 × 10−6 Representative weak acids (left), their conjugate bases
(center), and pKa values (right) include the following:
Once a decision has been reached about the significance of R—CH2 —COOH R—CH2 COO− pK a = 4 − 5
the contribution of water, pH may be calculated as shown in
Example 3. R—CH2 —NH3+ R—CH2 —NH2 pK a = 9 − 10
The above examples assume that the strong base KOH H2 CO3 HCO3 −
pK a = 6.4
is completely dissociated in solution and that the concentra- − −2
tion of OH− ions was thus equal to that due to the KOH plus H2 PO4 HPO4 pK a = 7.2
12 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
pKa is used to express the relative strengths of both weak Cross-multiplication gives
acids and weak bases using a single, unified scale. Under this
convention, the relative strengths of bases are expressed [H+ ][A− ] = K a [HA]
in terms of the pKa of their conjugate acids. For polyprotic
Divide both sides by [A−]:
compounds containing more than one dissociable proton, a
numerical subscript is assigned to each dissociation, numbered [HA]
starting from unity in decreasing order of relative acidity. For a [H+ ] = K a
[A − ]
dissociation of the type
R—NH3+ → R—NH 2 + H + Take the log of both sides:
then Substitute pH and pKa for −log [H+] and −log Ka, respectively;
K a = [H ]+ then
[HA]
Thus, when the associated (protonated) and dissociated pH = pK a − log
[A− ]
(conjugate base) species are present at equal concentrations,
the prevailing hydrogen ion concentration [H+] is numerically Inversion of the last term removes the minus sign and gives
equal to the dissociation constant, Ka. If the logarithms of both the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation
sides of the above equation are taken and both sides are multi-
plied by −1, the expressions would be as follows: [A − ]
pH = pK a + log
K a = [H+ ] [HA]
[A − ]
The Henderson-Hasselbalch Equation pH = pK a + log
[HA]
Describes the Behavior of Weak Acids & pH = pK a + log(100/1) = pK a + 2
Buffers
The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation is derived below.
3. When the ratio [A−]/[HA] = 1:10,
A weak acid, HA, ionizes as follows:
pH = pK a + log(1/10) = pK a + (−1)
HA H+ + A−
The equilibrium constant for this dissociation is If the equation is evaluated at ratios of [A−]/[HA] ranging
from 103 to 10−3 and the calculated pH values are plotted, the
[H+ ][A− ] resulting graph describes the titration curve for a weak acid
Ka =
[HA] (Figure 2–6).
CHAPTER 2 Water & pH 13
Net charge
0.6 –0.6
fers, resist change most effectively when the desired pH falls
0.4 –0.4 within, ± 1.0 unit or less of their pKa.
Figure 2–6 also illustrates how the net charge on one
0.2 –0.2 molecule of a weak acid varies with pH. A fractional charge
of −0.5 does not mean that an individual molecule bears a
0 0
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
fractional charge but that the probability is 0.5 that a given
pH
molecule has a unit negative charge at any given moment in
time. Consideration of the net charge on macromolecules as
FIGURE 2–6 Titration curve for an acid of the type HA. The a function of pH provides the basis for separatory techniques
heavy dot in the center of the curve indicates the pKa, 5.0. such as ion exchange chromatography and electrophoresis
(see Chapter 4).
Weak Acids Can Be Used to Establish &
Maintain the pH of an Aqueous Solution The Propensity of a Proton to
Solutions of weak acids or bases and their conjugates exhibit Dissociate Depends on Molecular
buffering, the ability to resist a change in pH following addi- Structure
tion of strong acid or base. Many metabolic reactions are Many acids of biologic interest possess more than one dissoci-
accompanied by the release or uptake of protons. Oxidative ating group. The presence of local negative charge hinders pro-
metabolism produces CO2, the anhydride of carbonic acid, ton release from nearby acidic groups, raising their pKa. This
which if not buffered would produce severe acidosis. Bio- is illustrated by the pKa values of the three dissociating groups
logic maintenance of a constant pH involves buffering by of phosphoric acid and citric acid (Table 2–2). The effect of
phosphate, bicarbonate, and proteins, which accept or release adjacent charge decreases with distance. The second pKa for
protons to resist a change in pH. For laboratory experiments succinic acid, which has two methylene groups between its
using tissue extracts or enzymes, constant pH is maintained carboxyl groups, is 5.6, whereas the second pKa for glutaric
by the addition of buffers such as MES ([2-N-morpholino]- acid, which has one additional methylene group, is 5.4.
ethanesulfonic acid, pKa 6.1), inorganic orthophosphate (pKa2 7.2),
HEPES (N-hydroxyethylpiperazine-N′-2-ethanesulfonic acid,
pKa 6.8), or Tris (tris[hydroxymethyl]aminomethane, pKa 8.3). pKa Values Depend on the
The value of pKa relative to the desired pH is the major deter- Properties of the Medium
minant of which buffer is selected. The pKa of a functional group is also profoundly influenced
Buffering can be observed by using a pH meter while titrat- by the surrounding medium. The medium may either raise
ing a weak acid or base (see Figure 2–6). We can also calculate or lower the pKa relative to its value in water, depending on
the pH shift that accompanies addition of acid or base to a buff- whether the undissociated acid or its conjugate base is the
ered solution. In the following example, the buffered solution charged species. The effect of dielectric constant on pKa may
(a weak acid, pKa = 5.0, and its conjugate base) is initially at one be observed by adding ethanol to water. The pKa of a carbox-
of four pH values. We will calculate the pH shift that results ylic acid increases, whereas that of an amine decreases on addi-
when 0.1 meq of KOH is added to 1 meq of each solution: tion of ethanol because ethanol decreases the ability of water
to solvate a charged species. The pKa values of dissociating
Initial pH 5.00 5.37 5.60 5.86
−
TABLE 2−2 Relative Strengths of Monoprotic, Diprotic,
[A ]initial 0.50 0.70 0.80 0.88
and Triprotic Acids
[HA]initial 0.50 0.30 0.20 0.12
Lactic acid pK = 3.86
−
([A ]/[HA])initial 1.00 2.33 4.00 7.33
Acetic acid pK = 4.76
Addition of 0.1 meq of KOH Produces
Ammonium ion pK = 9.25
[A−]final 0.60 0.80 0.90 0.98
Carbonic acid pK1 = 6.37; pK2 = 10.25
[HA]final 0.40 0.20 0.10 0.02
Succinic acid pK1 = 4.21; pK2 = 5.64
([A−]/[HA])final 1.50 4.00 9.00 49.0
Glutaric acid pK1 = 4.34; pK2 = 5.41
log ([A−]/[HA])final 0.18 0.60 0.95 1.69
Phosphoric acid pK1 = 2.15; pK2 = 6.82; pK3 = 12.38
Final pH 5.18 5.60 5.95 6.69
Citric acid pK1 = 3.08; pK2 = 4.74; pK3 = 5.40
ΔpH 0.18 0.60 0.95 1.69
Note: Tabulated values are the pKa values (-log of the dissociation constant).
14 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
groups in the interiors of proteins thus are profoundly affected ■ The strength of weak acids is expressed by pKa, the negative
by their local environment, including the presence or absence log of the acid dissociation constant. Strong acids have low pKa
of water. values and weak acids have high pKa values.
■ Buffers resist a change in pH when protons are produced
or consumed. Maximum buffering capacity occurs within
SUMMARY 1 pH unit on either side of pKa. Physiologic buffers include
■ Water forms hydrogen-bonded clusters with itself and with bicarbonate, orthophosphate, and proteins.
other proton donors or acceptors. These extensive networks
of hydrogen bonds account for the surface tension, viscosity,
liquid state at room temperature, and solvent power of water. REFERENCES
■ Compounds that contain O or N can serve as hydrogen bond Reese KM: Whence came the symbol pH. Chem & Eng News
donors and/or acceptors. 2004;82:64.
Segel IM: Biochemical Calculations. Wiley, 1968.
■ Entropic forces dictate that amphipathic macromolecules bury
Skinner JL: Following the motions of water molecules in aqueous
nonpolar regions away from water.
solutions. Science 2010;328:985.
■ Salt bridges, hydrophobic interactions, and van der Waals Stillinger FH: Water revisited. Science 1980;209:451.
forces participate in the formation of biomolecular complexes Suresh SJ, Naik VM: Hydrogen bond thermodynamic properties of
and maintenance of molecular conformation. water from dielectric constant data. J Chem Phys 2000;113:9727.
■ pH is the negative log of [H+]. A low pH characterizes an acidic Wiggins PM: Role of water in some biological processes. Microbiol
solution, and a high pH denotes a basic solution. Rev 1990;54:432.
C H A P T E R
BIOMEDICAL IMPORTANCE acis normay appear in the urine because amino acis are
amost totay reabsorbe in the proxima tubue, conserving
l-α-Amino acis provie the monomer units of the ong poy- them for protein synthesis an other vita functions.
peptie chains of proteins. In aition, these amino acis an Certain microorganisms secrete free d-amino acis, or
their erivatives participate in such iverse ceuar functions pepties that may contain both d- an l-α-amino acis. Severa
as nerve transmission an the biosynthesis of porphyrins, of these bacteria pepties are of therapeutic vaue, incuing
purines, pyrimiines, an urea. The neuroenocrine system the antibiotics bacitracin an gramiciin A, an the antitu-
empoys short poymers of amino acis cae peptides as mor agent beomycin. Certain other microbia pepties are,
hormones, hormone-reeasing factors, neuromouators, an however, toxic. The cyanobacteria pepties microcystin an
neurotransmitters. Humans an other higher animas can- nouarin are etha in arge oses, whie sma quantities pro-
not synthesize 10 of the l-α-amino acis present in proteins mote the formation of hepatic tumors. The ingestion of cer-
in amounts aequate to support infant growth or to maintain tain amino acis present in the sees of egumes of the genus
aut heath. Consequenty, the human iet must contain ae- Lathyrus can resut in athyrism, a tragic irreversibe isease
quate quantities of these nutritionally essential amino acis. in which iniviuas ose contro of their imbs. Certain other
Each ay the kineys fiter over 50 g of free amino acis from pant see amino acis have aso been impicate in a neuro-
the arteria rena boo. However, ony traces of free amino egenerative isease afficting natives of Guam.
15
16 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
PROPERTIES OF AMINO ACIDS amino aci (Table 3–1). The R groups of amino acis may be
either hyrophiic or hyrophobic (Table 3–2); properties that
affect their ocation in a protein’s mature foe conformation
The Genetic Code Specifies (see Chapter 5). Some proteins contain aitiona amino acis
20 l-α-Amino Acids that arise by the posttranslational moification of an amino
Athough more than 300 amino acis occur in nature, pro- aci areay present in a peptie. Exampes incue the conver-
teins are synthesize amost excusivey from the set of 20 l-α- sion of peptiy proine an peptiy ysine to 4-hyroxyproine
amino acis encoe by nuceotie tripets cae codons (see an 5-hyroxyysine; the conversion of peptiy gutamate to
Tabe 37–1). Whie the three-etter genetic coe cou poten- γ-carboxygutamate; an the methyation, formyation, acety-
tiay accommoate more than 20 amino acis, the genetic coe ation, prenyation, an phosphoryation of certain aminoacy
is redundant since severa amino acis are specifie by mutipe resiues. These moifications significanty exten the func-
coons. Scientists frequenty represent the sequences of pepties tiona iversity of proteins by atering their soubiity, stabiity,
an proteins using one- an three-etter abbreviations for each cataytic activity, an interaction with other proteins.
(Continued)
CHAPTER 3 Amino Acids & Peptides 17
Imino Acid
Proline Pro[P] 2.0 10.6
18 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
The distinction is based on the tendency of their R groups to associate with, or Posttranslational Modifications
to minimize contact with, an aqueous environment.
Confer Additional Properties
Selenocysteine, the 21st Whie some prokaryotes incorporate pyrroysine into pro-
Protein l-α-Amino Acid teins, an pants can incorporate azetiine-2-carboxyic aci,
an anaog of proine, a set of just 21 l-α-amino acis ceary
Seenocysteine (Figure 3–1) is an l-α-amino aci present in pro- suffices for the formation of most proteins. Posttransationa
teins from every omain of ife. Humans contain approximatey moifications can, however, generate nove R groups that
two ozen seenoproteins that incue certain peroxiases an impart further properties. In coagen, protein-boun pro-
reuctases, seenoprotein P, which circuates in the pasma, ine an ysine resiues are converte to 4-hyroxyproine
an the ioothyronine eioinases responsibe for converting an 5-hyroxyysine (Figure 3–2). The carboxyation of gu-
the prohormone thyroxine (T4) to the thyroi hormone 3,3′, tamy resiues of proteins of the boo coaguation cascae to
5-triioothyronine (T3) (see Chapter 41). Since peptiy seeno- γ-carboxygutamy resiues (Figure 3–3) competes a site for
cysteine is inserte irecty into a growing poypeptie uring cheating the cacium ion essentia for boo coaguation. The
translation, it is commony terme the “21st amino aci.” How- amino aci sie chains of histones are subject to numerous
ever, unike the other 20 protein amino acis, incorporation of moifications, incuing acetyation an methyation of ysine
seenocysteine is specifie by a arge an compex genetic eement an methyation an eimination of arginine (see Chapters 35
for the unusua tRNA cae tRNASec which utiizes the UGA anti- an 38). It is aso now possibe in the aboratory to geneticay
coon that normay signas STOP rather than a simpe tripet introuce many ifferent unnatura amino acis into proteins,
coon. Rather, the protein synthetic apparatus recognizes a UGA generating proteins via recombinant gene expression with new
coon as coing for seenocysteine when it is accompanie by a or enhance properties an proviing a new way to expore
stem-oop structure, the seenocysteine insertion eement, in the protein structure–function reationships.
untransate region of the mRNA (see Chapter 27).
O O
HOOC
FIGURE 3–1 Cysteine (left) and selenocysteine (right). pK3,
for the selenyl proton of selenocysteine is 5.2. Since this is 3 pH H2N COOH
units lower than that of cysteine, selenocysteine represents a better
nucleophile at or below pH 7.4. FIGURE 3–3 γ-Carboxyglutamic acid.
CHAPTER 3 Amino Acids & Peptides 19
contain racemic mixtures of d- an l-isomers of mutipe TABLE 3−3 Potentially Toxic l-α-Amino Acids
protein amino acis as we as bioogicay important nonpro-
Nonprotein l-α-Amino Acid Medical Relevance
tein α-amino acis such as N-methygycine (sarcosine) an
β-aanine. Severa nove amino acis that ack terrestria coun- NH NH2 Cleaved by arginase
terparts of biotic origin were aso iscovere. Nuceobases, acti- to l-lysine and urea.
OH
H2N N Implicated in human
vate phosphates, an moecues reate to sugars have aso been H neurolathyrism.
O
etecte in meteorites. These finings offer potentia insights Homoarginine
into the prebiotic chemistry of earth, an impact the search for
extraterrestria ife. Some specuate that meteorites may have O NH2 A neurotoxin.
H
N Implicated in human
contribute to the origin of ife on our panet, a conjecture OH
neurolathyrism.
HO
entite Panspermia, by eivering extraterrestriay generate
O O
organic moecues or even intact microorganisms to our earth. -N-Oxalyl
diaminopropionic acid ( -ODAP)
l-α-Amino Acids Serve Additional An osteolathyrogen.
O NH2
Metabolic Roles OH
H2N
l-α-Amino acis fufi vita metaboic roes in aition to
NH O
serving as the “buiing bocks” of proteins. For exampe, orni-
N
thine an citruine are key intermeiates in the urea cyce H3C C
(see Figure 28–16), whie S-aenosy-methionine serves as a -N-Glutamylamino-propiononitrile
methy-group onor for many enzyme-catayze reactions. (BAPN)
Tyrosine is a precursor of thyroi hormone, whie both tyro- Inhibits ornithine
NH2 NH2
sine an phenyaanine are metaboize to prouce epineph- transcarbamylase,
OH
rine, norepinephrine, an ihyroxyphenyaanine (DOPA). resulting in ammonia
Gutamate is both a neurotransmitter as we as a precursor of a O toxicity.
secon neurotransmitter, γ-aminobutyric aci (GABA). 2,4-Diaminobutyric acid
O H+ O H+ O H+ O
OH OH O– O–
A B C D
In strong acid Around pH 3; Around pH 6–8; In strong alkali
(below pH 1); net charge = 0 net charge = –1 (above pH 11);
net charge = +1 net charge = –2
α-Carboxyl 3.5-4.0 4
Tryptophan
0.123 nm
urea, heme, nuceic acis, hormones such as epinephrine an
neurotransmitters such as DOPA.
121° 122° 0.
13
C C N C 2
nm ■ The presence in meteorites of trace quantities of many of the
120°
0.
117°
110°
14
7 3
nm protein amino acis ens creence to the hypothesis that
N C nm C 15 N
120° 120° 0. asteroi strikes might have contribute to the eveopment of
0.1 nm
ife on earth.
■ Certain of the l-α-amino acis present in pants an pant
H O H R H
sees can have eeterious effects on human heath, for
0.36 nm exampe, in athyrism.
■ The R groups of amino acis etermine their particuar
FIGURE 3–8 Dimensions of a fully extended polypeptide biochemica functions. Amino acis are cassifie as basic,
chain. The four atoms of the peptide bond are coplanar. Free rota-
aciic, aromatic, aiphatic, or sufur-containing base on the
tion can occur about the bonds that connect the α-carbon with the
α-nitrogen and with the α-carbonyl carbon (brown arrows). The
composition an properties of their R groups.
extended polypeptide chain is thus a semirigid structure with two- ■ The partia oube-bon character of the bon that inks the
thirds of the atoms of the backbone held in a fixed planar relationship carbony carbon an the nitrogen of a peptie rener the four
to one another. The distance between adjacent α-carbon atoms is atoms of the peptie bon coplanar, an hence restrict the
0.36 nm (3.6 Å). The interatomic distances and bond angles, which number of possibe peptie conformations.
are not equivalent, are also shown. (Reproduced with permission
from Pauling L, Corey LP, Branson HR: The structure of proteins: two ■ Pepties are often cassifie base on the number of amino aci
hydrogen-bonded helical configurations of the polypeptide chain. resiues present, an are name as erivatives of the carboxy
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1951;37(4):205-211.) termina resiue. The primary structure of a peptie is its amino
aci sequence, starting from the amino-termina resiue, a
irection in which pepties actuay are synthesize in vivo.
Noncovalent Forces Constrain Peptide ■ A amino acis possess at east two weaky aciic functiona
Conformations groups, R—NH3+ an R—COOH. Many aso possess aitiona
weaky aciic functiona groups such as the phenoic —OH
Foing of a peptie probaby begins coincient with its bio- of tyrosine or the —SH, guaniino, or imiazoe moieties of
synthesis (see Chapter 37). The mature, physioogicay active cysteine, histiine, an arginine, respectivey.
conformation refects the coective contributions of the amino ■ The pKa vaues of a functiona groups of an amino aci or of
aci sequence, noncovaent interactions (eg, hyrogen bon- a peptie ictate its net charge at a given pH. pI, the isoeectric
ing, hyrophobic interactions), an the minimization of steric pH, is the pH at which a moecue bears no net charge an thus
hinrance between resiues. Common repeating conforma- oes not move in a irect current eectrica fie.
tions incue α-heices an β-peate sheets (see Chapter 5). ■ The pKa vaues of free amino acis at best ony approximate
their pKa vaues when present in a protein, an can iffer
Peptides Are Polyelectrolytes wiey ue to the infuence of their surrounings in a protein.
The peptie bon is uncharge at any pH of physioogic
interest. Formation of pepties from amino acis is therefore REFERENCES
accompanie by a net oss of one positive an one negative
Bener DA: Amino Acid Metabolism, 3r e. Wiey, 2012.
charge per peptie bon forme at physioogic pH. Pepties Diaz-Parga P, Goto JJ, Krishnan VV: Chemistry an chemica
nevertheess are charge owing to their termina carboxy equiibrium ynamics of BMAA an its carbamate aucts.
an amino groups an, where present, their aciic or basic Neurotox Res 2018;33:76.
R groups. As for amino acis, the net charge on a peptie Koga T, Naraoka H: A new famiy of extraterrestria amino acis
epens on the pH of its environment an on the pKa vaues in the Murchison meteorite. Sci Rep 2017;7:636. https://oi.
of its issociating groups. org/10.1038/s41598-017-00693-9.
Osinski GR, Cocke CS, Pontefract A, et a.: The roe of meteorite
impacts in the origin of ife. Astrobioogy 2020;20:1121.
SUMMARY Secker JM, Lewis SJ: Avances in D-amino acis in neuroogica
■ Both d-amino acis an non–α-amino acis occur in nature, research. Int J Mo Sci 2020;21:7325.
but proteins are synthesize using ony l-α-amino acis. Wu G e.: Amino Acids in Nutrition and Health. Springer, 2020.
d-Amino acis o, however, serve metaboic roes, not ony in Yoshimura T, Nishikawa T, Homma H es.: D-Amino Acids:
bacteria, but aso in humans. Physiology, Metabolism, and Application. Springer, 2016.
C H A P T E R
Proteins: Determination
of Primary Structure
Peter J. Kennelly, PhD, & Victor W. Rodwell, PhD
4
OBJ E C TI VE S ■ Cite three examples of posttranslational modifications that commonly occur
during the maturation of a newly synthesized polypeptide.
After studying this chapter, ■ Name four chromatographic methods commonly employed for the isolation of
you should be able to: proteins from biologic materials.
■ Describe how electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gels can be used to determine
the purity, subunit composition, relative mass, and isoelectric point of a protein.
■ Describe the basis on which quadrupole and time-of-flight (TOF) spectrometers
determine molecular mass.
■ Describe how the availability of genome sequences has facilitated the
determination of protein primary structure.
■ Explain what is meant by “the proteome” and cite examples of its potential
significance.
■ Describe the advantages and limitations of gene chips as a tool for monitoring
protein expression.
■ Outline three strategies for resolving individual proteins and peptides from complex
biologic samples to facilitate their identification by mass spectrometry (MS).
■ Comment on the contributions of genomics, computer algorithms, and
databases to the identification of the open reading frames (ORFs) that encode
a given protein.
24
CHAPTER 4 Proteins: Determination of Primary Structure 25
Membrane
FIGURE 4–1 Diagrammatic representation of the life cycle of a hypothetical protein. (1) The life cycle begins with the synthesis on
a ribosome of a polypeptide chain, whose primary structure is dictated by an mRNA. (2) As synthesis proceeds, the polypeptide begins to fold
into its native conformation (blue). (3) Folding may be accompanied by processing events such as proteolytic cleavage of an N-terminal leader
sequence (Met-Asp-Phe-Gln-Val) or the formation of disulfide bonds (S—S). (4) Subsequent covalent modifications may, for example, attach a
fatty acid molecule (yellow) for (5) translocation of the modified protein to a membrane. (6) Binding an allosteric effector (red) may trigger the
adoption of a catalytically active conformation. (7) Over time, proteins get damaged by chemical attack, deamidation, or denaturation, and
(8) may be “labeled” by the covalent attachment of several ubiquitin molecules (Ub). (9) The ubiquitinated protein is subsequently degraded to
its component amino acids, which become available for the synthesis of new proteins.
a specific protein from a natural source in quantities sufficient from the column, it is automatically collected as a series of
for analysis presents a formidable challenge as living organisms small portions called fractions. Figure 4–2 depicts the basic
contain thousands of different proteins, each in widely varying arrangement of a simple bench-top chromatography system.
amounts. Thus, obtaining pure protein may require successive
application of multiple separation techniques. Selective pre- HPLC—High-Pressure
cipitation exploits differences in relative solubility of individual
proteins as a function of pH (isoelectric precipitation), polarity
Liquid Chromatography
(precipitation with ethanol or acetone), or salt concentration First-generation column chromatography matrices consisted
(salting out with ammonium sulfate). Chromatographic tech- of long, intertwined oligosaccharide polymers shaped into
niques separate one protein from another based on the differ- spherical beads roughly a tenth of a millimeter in diameter.
ence in their size and shape (size-exclusion chromatography), Unfortunately, their relatively large size perturbed mobile-
net charge (ion-exchange chromatography), hydrophobicity phase flow. In theory, resolution could be increased by reduc-
(hydrophobic interaction chromatography), or ability to bind ing particle size. However, the greater pressures required to
a specific ligand (affinity chromatography). overcome the increased resistance of a more tightly packed
matrix crushed the soft and spongy polysaccharide or, later,
polyacrylamide beads. Eventually, small spherical silicon
Column Chromatography particles became available that were physically strong and
In column chromatography, the stationary phase matrix con- porous, with a high surface area for attaching various chemical
sists of small beads loaded into a cylindrical container of glass, groups. These particles were then packed into stainless steel
plastic, or steel called a column. Liquid-permeable frits con- columns capable of withstanding high pressures necessary to
fine the beads within the column while allowing the mobile- force liquid through the more constricted passages formed by
phase liquid to flow or percolate through. The stationary the smaller, tightly packed beads. The high surface area and
phase matrix can be chemically derivatized to coat each bead’s greater uniformity of these silica beads imbue high pressure
surface with the acidic, basic, hydrophobic, or ligand-like liquid chromatography, or HPLC, systems with a resolving
groups required for ion exchange, hydrophobic interaction, or power that is orders of magnitude higher than that of the once
affinity chromatography. As the mobile-phase liquid emerges familiar glass columns and their polysaccharide matrices.
26 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
D E
A A
B B
A B
Affinity Chromatography S E C H D
Affinity chromatography exploits the high selectivity displayed 111
by enzymes and other proteins for ligands such as substrates,
73
products, cofactors, inhibitors, or analogues thereof. In theory,
when a protein mixture is applied to a matrix derivatized with
a particular ligand, only those proteins that bind that ligand
will adhere. Bound proteins are then eluted either by competi- 48
tion with free, soluble ligand or, less selectively, by disrupt-
ing protein-ligand interactions using high salt concentrations or
other agents. Recombinantly expressed proteins are usually puri-
fied by fusing to their gene an additional segment of DNA that
encodes a convenient ligand-binding domain (see Chapter 7). 34
pH = 3 pH = 10
IEF
N C S
O
+ NH2
H
N
N R
H O
R
SDS
PAGE Phenylisothiocyanate (Edman reagent)
and a peptide
N NH
H
O
H
FIGURE 4–6 Two-dimensional IEF-SDS-PAGE. The gel was N
stained with Coomassie Blue. A crude bacterial extract was first N R
H O
subjected to isoelectric focusing (IEF) in a pH 3–10 gradient. The IEF R
gel was then placed horizontally on the top of an SDS-PAGE gel, and A phenylthiohydantoic acid
the proteins then further resolved by SDS-PAGE. Notice the greatly
improved resolution of distinct polypeptides relative to ordinary SDS-
H+, nitro- H2O
PAGE gel (see Figure 4–5). methane
S O
protein to have its sequence determined was the peptide hor-
NH2
mone insulin, an achievement that earned Frederick Sanger a
Nobel Prize in 1958. Mature insulin consists of the 21-residue
N NH + N
H R
A chain and the 30-residue B chain linked by disulfide bonds.
O R
Sanger reduced the disulfide bonds (see Figure 4–4), separated
the A and B chains, and cleaved each chain into smaller and A phenylthiohydantoin and a peptide
shorter by one residue
smaller peptides using the proteolytic enzymes trypsin, chy-
motrypsin, and pepsin followed by incubation with hydro- FIGURE 4–7 The Edman reaction. Phenyl isothiocyanate
chloric acid. Each peptide in the mixture was isolated, treated derivatizes the amino-terminal residue of a peptide as a phenyl-
with 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (Sanger reagent), and their thiohydantoic acid. Treatment with acid in a nonhydroxylic solvent
releases a phenylthiohydantoin, which is subsequently identified by
amino acid composition determined. Sanger reagent reacts
its chromatographic mobility, and a peptide one residue shorter. The
with the exposed α-amino groups of the amino-terminal resi- process is then repeated.
dues, allowing the amino-terminal amino acid of each peptide
to be identified. The ε-amino group of lysine also reacts with
Sanger reagent; but since an amino-terminal lysine reacts with
2 molecules of Sanger reagent, it is readily distinguished from that not only could selectively label the amino-terminal resi-
a lysine from the interior of a peptide. Working from di- and due of a peptide as its phenylthiohydantoin (PTH) deriva-
tripeptides up through progressively larger fragments, Sanger tive but, in contrast to Sanger reagent, permitted the PTH
was able to reconstruct the complete sequence of insulin. derivative to be removed under mild conditions (Figure 4–7).
Sanger would later develop the dideoxy method for sequencing The new amino terminal residue could then be treated with
DNA, an accomplishment for which he was awarded a second Edman reagent and the process repeated to permit each suc-
Nobel Prize in 1980. cessive residue in a peptide to be derivatized.
While, in theory, one could determine the entire sequence
of a polypeptide using Edman reagent, the heterogeneous
EDMAN DEVISED THE FIRST chemical properties of the amino acids meant that every step
PRACTICAL METHOD FOR in the procedure represented a compromise between effi-
ciency for any particular amino acid or set of amino acids and
PEPTIDE SEQUENCING the flexibility needed to accommodate all 20. Consequently,
Sanger’s labor-intensive approach rendered it prohibitively dif- each step in the process operates at less than 100% efficiency,
ficult to apply to any but the smallest polypeptides. Pehr Edman which leads to the accumulation of polypeptide fragments
discovered a reagent, phenyl isothiocyanate (Edman reagent), with varying N-termini that eventually renders it impossible
CHAPTER 4 Proteins: Determination of Primary Structure 29
to distinguish the correct PTH amino acid for that position in GENOMICS ENABLES PROTEINS
the peptide from the out-of-phase contaminants. As a result,
the read length for Edman sequencing varies from 5 to 30 TO BE IDENTIFIED FROM SMALL
amino acid residues depending on the quantity and purity AMOUNTS OF SEQUENCE DATA
of the peptide, hardly enough to determine the sequence of a Today the number of organisms for which the complete DNA
typical protein. sequence of their genomes has been determined numbers in
To determine the complete sequence of a polypep- the hundreds of thousands. Thus, for most research scien-
tide several hundred residues in length, a protein must be tists the genetically encoded sequence of the protein(s) with
cleaved into smaller peptides. These were then purified which they are working has already been determined and
and analyzed by Edman sequencing. This yielded multiple can be accessed in a database such as GenBank. To make an
segments of sequence whose location within the protein, unambiguous identification of the amino acid sequence for
with the exception of the amino terminus, was unknown. a protein, sometimes all that is required is the identities of
In order to assemble these short peptide sequences into the as few as five or six consecutive residues. Today mass spec-
complete sequence of the intact polypeptide, it was neces- trometry (MS) has largely replaced the Edman technique as
sary to generate and analyze additional peptides in search the method of choice for protein identification.
of some whose sequences overlapped with one another,
thereby allowing larger segments of sequence to be pieced
together. While the development of automated Edman MASS SPECTROMETRY
sequencers and sophisticated HPLC systems for purifying
peptides often rendered initial acquisition of a fragmen-
CAN DETECT COVALENT
tary, or partial, sequence relatively quick, finding enough MODIFICATIONS
“overlap” peptides to reconstruct the complete sequence of a The development of mass spectrometric (MS) methods that
typical protein via the Edman technique generally required offer superior sensitivity, speed, and capacity to detect post-
large quantities of purified protein and, more importantly, translational modifications (Table 4–1) has led to its replace-
several months or years of additional work. Consequently, ment of the Edman technique as the method of choice for
the determination of a complete amino acid sequence via protein identification.
the Edman method generally was restricted to highly abun-
dant, readily purified proteins.
MASS SPECTROMETERS COME
IN VARIOUS CONFIGURATIONS
MOLECULAR BIOLOGY In a simple, single quadrupole mass spectrometer, a sample
REVOLUTIONIZED is placed under vacuum and allowed to vaporize in the pres-
THE DETERMINATION OF ence of a proton donor to impart a positive charge. An electri-
cal field then propels the cations toward a curved flight tube
PRIMARY STRUCTURE where they encounter a magnetic field, which deflects them at
The sequence for each and every protein in an organism a right angle to their original direction of flight (Figure 4–8).
is encoded in the latter’s genome. By enabling scientists to The current powering the electromagnet is gradually increased
decode the sequences of proteins directly from their structural until the path of each ion is bent sufficiently to strike a detec-
genes, molecular biology revolutionized amino acid sequence tor mounted at the end of the flight tube. For ions of identical
analysis. The reasons for this were twofold. First, recombinant
techniques permit researchers to manufacture a virtually infi-
nite supply of DNA from even minute quantities of template
TABLE 4−1 Mass Increases Resulting From Common
present in the original sample (see Chapter 39), regardless of
Posttranslational Modifications
the encoded protein product’s natural abundance or ease of
isolation. Second, DNA sequencing is far more efficient than Modification Mass Increase (Da)
the Edman technique. Today, automated sequenators routinely Phosphorylation 80
“read” DNA sequences several thousand deoxyribonucleotides
in length. Consequently, if one could determine just a portion Hydroxylation 16
of the sequence of a polypeptide of interest by Edman analysis, Methylation 14
one could synthesize a complementary oligonucleotide probe Acetylation 42
with which to identify the DNA clone containing the gene of
interest. The result was a hybrid approach in which Edman Myristylation 210
chemistry was employed to obtain a partial sequence that was Palmitoylation 238
subsequently exploited to determine the complete amino acid Glycosylation 162
sequence by DNA cloning and sequencing.
30 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
Accelerator plates
Sample
probe
Flight tube
Sample Chamber
Electromagnet
Variable
power
source
Detector
Vacuum pump
Detector
output
Voltage
FIGURE 4–8 Basic components of a simple mass spectrometer. A mixture of molecules, represented by a red circle, green triangle, and
blue diamond, is vaporized in an ionized state in the sample chamber. These molecules are then accelerated down the flight tube by an electri-
cal potential applied to the accelerator grid (yellow). An adjustable field strength electromagnet applies a magnetic field that deflects the flight
of the individual ions until they strike the detector. The greater the mass of the ion, the higher the magnetic field required to focus it onto the
detector.
net charge, the force required to bend their path to the same Peptides Can Be Volatilized for
extent is proportionate to their mass.
Time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometers employ a
Analysis by Electrospray Ionization or
linear flight tube. Following vaporization of the sample in Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption
the presence of a proton donor, an electric field is briefly For many years, the analysis of peptides and proteins by MS
applied to accelerate the ions toward a detector at the end initially was hindered by difficulties in volatilizing these large
of the flight tube. For molecules of identical charge, the organic molecules. While small organic molecules could be
velocity to which they are accelerated, and hence the time readily vaporized by heating in a vacuum (Figure 4–9), pro-
required to reach the detector, is inversely proportional teins, oligonucleotides, etc. decomposed on heating. Only
to their mass. when reliable techniques were devised for dispersing peptides,
Quadrupole mass spectrometers are generally used to proteins, and other large biomolecules into the vapor phase
determine the masses of molecules of 4000 Da or less, whereas was it possible to apply MS for their structural analysis and
TOF mass spectrometers are used to determine the large sequence determination. Three commonly used methods for
masses of complete proteins. Various combinations of mul- dispersion into the vapor phase are electrospray ionization,
tiple quadrupoles, or reflection of ions back down the linear matrix-assisted laser desorption and ionization (MALDI),
flight tube of a TOF mass spectrometer, are used to create and fast atom bombardment (FAB). In electrospray ioniza-
more sophisticated instruments. tion, the molecules to be analyzed are dissolved in a volatile
CHAPTER 4 Proteins: Determination of Primary Structure 31
Laser
FIGURE 4–9 Three common methods for vaporizing molecules in the sample chamber of a mass spectrometer.
solvent and introduced into the sample chamber in a minute MS2. The first mass spectrometer separates individual pep-
stream through a charged capillary probe (see Figure 4–9). As the tides based on their differences in mass. By adjusting the field
droplet of liquid emerges into the sample chamber, the charged strength of the first magnet, a single peptide can be directed
probe ionizes the sample while the solvent rapidly disperses, into the second mass spectrometer, where fragments are gen-
leaving the macromolecule suspended in the gaseous phase. erated and their masses are determined. Alternatively, they
Electrospray ionization is frequently used to analyze peptides and can be held in an electromagnetic ion trap located between
proteins as they elute from an HPLC or other chromatography the two quadrupoles and selectively delivered to the second
column, already dissolved in a volatile solvent. In MALDI, the quadrupole instead of being lost when the first quadrupole is
sample is mixed with a liquid matrix containing a light-absorbing set to select ions of a different mass.
dye and a source of protons. In the sample chamber, the mixture Tandem MS can be used to screen blood samples from new-
is excited using a laser, causing the surrounding matrix to disperse borns for the presence and concentrations of amino acids, fatty
into the vapor phase so rapidly as to avoid heating embedded acids, and other metabolites. Abnormalities in metabolite levels
peptides or proteins (see Figure 4–9). In FAB, large macromol- can serve as diagnostic indicators for a variety of genetic dis-
ecules dispersed in glycerol or another protonic matrix are bom- orders, such as phenylketonuria, ethylmalonic encephalopathy,
barded by a stream of neutral atoms, for example, xenon, that and glutaric acidemia type 1. In recent years a new generation
have been accelerated to a high velocity. “Soft” ionization by FAB of tandem mass spectrometers has appeared, called Q-TOF-MS,
is frequently applied to volatilize large macromolecules intact. that couple quadrupole (Q) and time-of-flight (TOF) technolo-
Peptides inside the mass spectrometer can be broken gies together in order to harness the best aspects of each.
down into smaller units by collisions with neutral helium or
argon atoms (collision-induced dissociation) and the masses
of the individual fragments determined. Fortunately, since
peptide bonds are more vulnerable to rupture than carbon-
PROTEOMICS & THE PROTEOME
carbon bonds, the most abundant fragments will differ from The Goal of Proteomics Is to Identify
one another by increments of one or two amino acids. Since—
with the exceptions of (1) leucine and isoleucine and (2) glu- the Entire Complement of Proteins
tamine and lysine—the molecular mass of each amino acid is Elaborated by a Cell Under Diverse
unique, the sequence of the peptide can be reconstructed from Conditions
the masses of its fragments.
While the sequence of the human genome is known, the pic-
ture it provides is both static and incomplete. As genes are
Tandem Mass Spectrometry switched on and off and mRNA molecules customized via
Complex peptide mixtures can be analyzed, without prior alternative splicing (see Chapter 36), the spectrum of proteins
purification, by tandem MS, which employs the equivalent of synthesized varies by particular cell type, stages of growth or
two mass spectrometers linked in series. For this reason, anal- differentiation, and in response to external stimuli. Muscle cells
ysis by tandem instruments is often referred to as MS–MS, or express proteins not expressed by neural cells, and the type of
32 SECTION I Structures & Functions of Proteins & Enzymes
subunits present in the hemoglobin tetramer undergo change hydrolyze them into smaller peptides that are then subject to
pre- and postpartum. Many proteins undergo posttranslational reversed-phase, ion-exchange, or size-exclusion chromatogra-
modifications during maturation into functionally competent phy to apportion the vast number of peptides into smaller sub-
forms or as a means of regulating their properties. In order to sets more amenable to analysis. These subsets are analyzed by
obtain a more complete and dynamic molecular description of injecting the column eluent directly into a double quadrupole
living organisms, scientists are working to determine the pro- or TOF mass spectrometer. Multidimensional protein iden-
teome, a term that refers to the identity, abundance, and state tification technology (MudPIT) employs successive rounds
of modification of the entire suite of proteins expressed by an of chromatography to resolve the peptides produced from the
individual cell at a particular time. Since the proteome for each digestion of a complex biologic sample into several simpler
component cell of an organism is distinct and changes with fractions that can be analyzed separately by MS.
time and circumstances, the ultimate, comprehensive human Today, advances in the capability and sensitivity of tandem
proteome constitutes a target of formidable size and complexity. mass spectrometers allow them to directly analyze complex
samples. The elimination of prior proteolytic or chromato-
graphic preparation will soon render it feasible to analyze the
Simultaneous Determination of proteome of an individual cell.
Hundreds of Proteins Is Technically
Challenging Bioinformatics Assists Identification
A key goal of proteomics is the identification of proteins whose of Protein Functions
levels of expression or modification correlate with medically The functions of a large proportion of the proteins encoded by
significant events. In addition to their potential as diagnostic the human genome are presently unknown. Efforts continue to
indicators, these protein biomarkers may provide important develop protein arrays or chips for directly testing the poten-
clues concerning the root causes and mechanisms of a specific tial functions of proteins on a mass scale. However, while some
physiologic condition or disease. First-generation proteomics protein functions are relatively easy to assay, such as protease
employed SDS-PAGE or two-dimensional electrophoresis to or esterase activity, others are much less tractable. Data mining
resolve the proteins in a biologic sample one from another, fol- via bioinformatics permits researchers to compare amino acid
lowed by determination of the amino acid sequence of their sequences of unknown proteins with those whose functions
amino terminus by the Edman method. Identities were deter- have been determined. This provides a means to uncover clues
mined by searching available polypeptide sequences for pro- to their potential properties, physiologic roles, and mechanisms
teins that contained a matching N-terminal sequence as well as of action. Algorithms exploit the tendency of nature to employ
a similar Mr and, for 2D gels, pI. variations of a structural theme to perform similar functions in
These early efforts were constrained by the limited num- several proteins (eg, the Rossmann nucleotide binding fold to
ber of polypeptide sequences available and the difficulties in bind NAD(P)H, nuclear targeting sequences, and EF hands to
isolating polypeptides from the gels in sufficient quantities bind Ca2+). These domains generally are detected in the primary
for Edman analysis. Attempts to increase resolving power and structure by conservation of particular amino acids at key posi-
sample yield by increasing the size of the gels were only mar- tions. Insights into the properties and physiologic role of a newly
ginally successful. Eventually, the development of mass spec- discovered protein thus may be inferred by comparing its pri-
trometric techniques provided a means for protein sequence mary structure with that of known proteins.
determination whose sensitivity was compatible with electro-
phoretic separation approaches.
Knowledge of the genome sequence of the organism in SUMMARY
question greatly facilitated identification by providing a com- ■ Long amino acid polymers or polypeptides constitute the
prehensive set of DNA-encoded polypeptide sequences. It also basic structural unit of proteins, and the structure of a protein
provided the nucleotide sequence data from which to con- provides insights into how it fulfills its functions.
struct gene arrays, sometimes called DNA chips, containing ■ Proteins undergo posttranslational alterations during their
hundreds of distinct oligonucleotide probes. These chips could lifetime that influence their function and determine their fate.
then be used to detect the presence of mRNAs containing ■ By generating a new amino terminus, Edman reagent permitted
complementary nucleotide sequences. While changes in the the determination of lengthy segments of amino acid sequence.
expression of the mRNA encoding a protein do not necessarily However, physical and chemical factors generally limited the
reflect comparable changes in the level of the corresponding number of amino acids that could be reliably identified to 30 or
protein, gene arrays were both less technically demanding and less, which rendered the complete determination of a protein’s
more sensitive than first-generation proteomic approaches, sequence via the Edman technique a time- and effort- intensive
particularly with respect to low abundance proteins. process.
Second-generation proteomics coupled newly developed ■ Polyacrylamide gels provide a porous matrix for separating
nanoscale chromatographic techniques with MS. The pro- proteins on the basis of their mobility in an applied direct
teins in a biologic sample are first treated with a protease to current electrical field.
CHAPTER 4 Proteins: Determination of Primary Structure 33
34
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
CHAPTER IV
§ 1. The problems which arise for the metaphysician from the fact
that the physical order, as it is presented to our senses, consists of
elements having position in space and time, are among the oldest
and most perplexing of all the riddles suggested by the course of our
experience. Adequate discussion of them would demand not only far
more space than we are at liberty to bestow on the topic, but such a
familiarity with the mathematical theory of order and series as is
scarcely possible to any one but an original mathematician. All that
we can do in the present chapter is to deal very superficially with one
or two of the leading problems, more with a view to indicating the
nature of the questions which Metaphysics has to face, than of
providing definite answers to them.
The fundamental problem for Metaphysics is, of course, whether
space and time are ultimate Realities or only appearances; that is,
would the whole system of Reality, as directly apprehended by an
absolute all-containing experience, wear the forms of extension and
succession in time, or is it merely a consequence of the limitations of
our own finite experience that things come to us in this guise? It may
indeed be urged that the contents of the universe must form an order
of some sort for the absolute experience, in virtue of their systematic
unity, but even so it is not clear that order as such is necessarily
spatial or temporal. Indeed, most of the forms of order with which we
are acquainted, both in everyday life and in our mathematical
studies, appear to be, properly speaking, both non-spatial and non-
temporal. Thus, e.g., it is seemingly by a mere metaphor that we
speak of the “successive” integers of the natural number-series, the
“successive” powers of an algebraical symbol, the “successive”
approximations to the value of a continued fraction, in language
borrowed from the temporal flow of events, the true relation involved
being in the first two cases the non-temporal one of logical
derivation, and in the third the equally non-temporal one of
resemblance to an ideal standard. The full solution of the
metaphysical problem of space and time would thus involve (1) the
discrimination of spatial and temporal order from other allied forms of
order, and (2) a decision as to the claim of this special form of order
to be ultimately coherent and intelligible.
The problem thus presented for solution is often, and usually with
special reference to the Kantian treatment of space and time in the
Transcendental Æsthetic, put in the form of the question whether
space and time are subjective or objective. This is, however, at best
a misleading and unfortunate mode of expression which we shall do
well to avoid. The whole distinction between a subjective and an
objective factor in experience loses most of its significance with the
abolition, now effected by Psychology, of the vicious Kantian
distinction between the “given” in perception and the “work of the
mind.” When once we have recognised that the “given” itself is
constituted by the movement of selective attention, it becomes
impossible any longer to distinguish it as an objective factor in
knowledge from the subjective structure subsequently raised upon it.
Kant’s adherence to this false psychological antithesis so completely
distorts his whole treatment of the “forms of intuition,” that it will be
absolutely necessary in a brief discussion like our own to deal with
the subject in entire independence of the doctrines of the Æsthetic,
which unfortunately continue to exercise a disproportionate influence
on the current metaphysical presentment of the problem.[141] It should
scarcely be necessary to point out that the metaphysical questions
have still less to do with the psychological problems, so prominent in
recent science, of the precise way in which we come by our
perception of extension and succession. For Metaphysics the sole
question is one not of the origin but of the logical value of these
ideas.
It is of fundamental importance for the whole metaphysical
treatment of the subject, to begin by distinguishing clearly between
space and time as forms of perception, and space and time as
conceptual forms in which we construct our scientific notion of the
physical order. One chief source of the confusions which beset the
Kantian view is the neglect of Kant and most of his followers to make
this distinction with sufficient clearness. We cannot insist too strongly
upon the point that the space and the time of which we think in our
science as containing the entire physical order, are not space and
time as directly known to us in sense-perception, but are concepts
elaborated out of the space and time of direct perception by a
complicated process of synthesis and analysis, and involving
abstraction from some of the most essential features of the space
and time of actual experience. The following brief discussion may
serve to illustrate the general nature of the relation between the two
forms of space and time, and to exhibit the leading differences
between them.
§ 2. Perceptual Space and Time. Both space and time, as we are
aware of them in immediate perception, are (1) limited. The space
we actually behold as we look out before us with a resting eye is
always terminated by a horizon which has a more or less well-
defined outline; the “specious present,” or portion of duration of
which we can be at any time aware at once as an immediately
presented content, has been shown by elaborate psychological
experimentation to have a fairly well-defined span. Whatever lies
outside this “span of attention” belongs either to the no longer
presented past or to the not yet presented future, and stands to the
sensible present much as the space behind my back to the actually
beheld space before my eyes. Of course, in either case the limits of
the actually presented space or time are not absolutely defined. To
right and left of the line of vision the visible horizon gradually fades
off into the indistinctly presented “margin of consciousness”; the
“sensible present” shades away gradually at either end into the past
and the future. Yet, though thus not absolutely defined, sensible
space and time are never boundless.
(2) Perceptual space and time are both internally sensibly
continuous or unbroken. Concentrate your attention on any lesser
part of the actually seen expanse, and you at once find that it is itself
an expanse with all the characteristics of the wider expanse in which
it forms a part. Space as actually seen is not an aggregate of minima
visibilia or perceptual points in which no lesser parts can be
discriminated; so long as space is visually or tactually perceived at
all, it is perceived as containing lesser parts which, on attending to
them, are found to repeat the characteristics of the larger space. So
any part of the “specious present” to which special attention can be
directed, turns out itself to be a sensible duration. Perceived space is
made of lesser spaces, perceived time of lesser times; the “parts”
not being, of course, actually distinguished from each other in the
original percept, but being capable of being so distinguished in
consequence of varying movements of attention.
(3) On investigating the character of our actual perception of
space and time, it appears to contain two aspects, which we may call
the quantitative and the qualitative. On the one hand, whenever we
perceive space we perceive a certain magnitude of extension,
whenever we perceive time we perceive a longer or shorter lapse of
duration. Different spaces and different times can be quantitatively
compared in respect of the bigness of the extension or the duration
comprised in them. On the other hand, the percept of space or time
is not one of mere extension or duration. It has a very different
qualitative aspect. We perceive along with the magnitude of the
extension the form of its outline. This perception of spatial form
depends in the last resort upon perception of the direction assumed
by the bounding line or lines. Similarly, in dealing with only one
dimension of perceived space, we never perceive length (a spatial
magnitude) apart from the perception of direction (a spatial quality).
The same is true of the perception of time. The lapses of duration we
immediately perceive have all their special direction-quality; the
“specious present” is essentially a simultaneously presented
succession, i.e. a transition from before to after. It must be added
that, in perceptual space and time, the directions thus perceived
have a unique relation to the perceiving subject, and are thus all
qualitatively distinct and irreversible. Direction in space is estimated
as right, left, up, down, etc., by reference to axes through the centre
of the percipient’s body at right angles to each other, and is thus for
any given moment of experience uniquely and unambiguously
determined. Direction in time is similarly estimated with reference to
the actual content of the “focus of consciousness.” What is actually
focal is “now,” what is ceasing to be focal is “past,” what is just
coming to be focal is “future” in its direction.[142]
This is perhaps the most fundamental and important peculiarity of
the space and time of actual perception. All directions in them are
unambiguously determined by reference to the here and now of the
immediate experience of an individual subject. As a consequence,
every individual subject has his own special perceptual space and
time; Geometry and Mechanics depend, to be sure, on the possibility
of the establishment of correspondences between these spatial and
temporal systems, but it is essential to remember that, properly
speaking, the space and time system of each individual’s perception
is composed of directions radiating out from his unique here and
now, and is therefore individual to himself.[143]
§ 3. The Construction of the Conceptual Space and Time Order of
Science. For the purposes of practical life, no less than for the
subsequent object of scientific description of the physical order, it is
indispensably necessary to establish equations or correspondences
between the individual space and time systems of different
percipients. Apart from such correspondences, it would be
impossible for one subject to translate the spatial and temporal
system of any other into terms of his own experience, and thus all
practical intercourse for the purpose of communicating directions for
action would come to an end. For the communication of such
practical directions it is imperative that we should be able mentally to
reconstruct the spatial and temporal aspects of our experience in a
form independent of reference to the special here and now of this or
that individual moment of experience. Thus, like the rest of our
scientific constructions, the establishment of a single conceptual
space and time system for the whole of the physical order is
ultimately a postulate required by our practical needs, and we must
therefore be prepared to face the possibility that, like other
postulates of the same kind, it involves assumptions which are not
logically defensible. The construction is valuable, so far as it does its
work of rendering intercommunication between individuals possible;
that it should correspond to the ultimate structure of Reality any
further than the requirements of practical life demand is superfluous.
The main processes involved in the construction of the conceptual
space and time of descriptive science are three,—synthesis,
analysis, abstraction. (a) Synthesis. Psychologically speaking, it is
ultimately by the active movements of individual percipients that the
synthesis of the individual’s various perceptual spaces into one is
effected. As attention is successively directed, even while the body
as a whole remains stationary, to different parts of the whole
expanse before the eye, the visual space which was originally “focal”
in presentation becomes “marginal,” and the “marginal” focal by a
sensibly gradual transition. When to the movements of head and
eyes which accompany such changes in attention there are added
movements of locomotion of the whole body, this process is carried
further, and we have the gradual disappearance of originally
presented spaces from presentation, accompanied by the gradual
emergence of spaces previously not presented at all. This leads to
the mental construction of a wider space containing all the
individual’s different presentation-spaces, the order in which it
contains them being determined by the felt direction of the
movements required for the transition from one to another.
As we learn, through intercommunication with our fellows, of the
existence for their perception of perceptual extension never directly
presented to our own senses, the process of synthesis is extended
further, so as to comprise in a single spatial system all the
presentation-spaces of all the individual percipients in an order once
again determined by the direction of the movements of transition
from each to the others. Finally, as there is nothing in the principle of
such a synthesis to impose limits upon its repetition, we think of the
process as capable of indefinite continuance, and thus arrive at the
concept of a space stretching out in all directions without definite
bounds. This unending repetition of the synthesis of perceived
spaces seems to be the foundation of what appears in theory as the
Infinity of Space.
Precisely similar is the synthesis by which we mentally construct a
single time system for the events of the physical order. Now means
for me the content which occupies the centre of attentive interest. As
attention is concentrated on the different stages in the realisation of
an interest, this centre shifts; what was central becomes first
marginal and then evanescent, what was marginal becomes central.
Hence arises the conception of the events of my own inner life as
forming a succession of moments, with a determinate order, each of
which has been a now, or point of departure for directions in
perceptual time, in its turn. As with space so with time, the
intrasubjective intercourse of man with man makes it possible for me
mentally to extend this conceptual synthesis of moments of time so
as to include nows belonging to the experience of others which were
already past before the first now of their experiences which I can
synchronise with a now of my own, and again nows of their
experiences relatively to which the last now which synchronises with
one of my own is past. The indefinite repetition of such a synthesis
leads, as before with space, to the thought of a duration reaching out
endlessly into past and future, and thus gives us the familiar concept
of the Infinity of Time.[144]
(b) Analysis. Equally important is the part played by mental
analysis in the formation of the conceptual space and time system.
As we have already seen, successive attention to lesser parts of a
presented extension, or a presented lapse, reveals within each
lesser part the same structure which belongs to the whole, and thus
establishes the sensible continuity of space and time. In actual fact,
the process of attending successively to smaller and yet smaller
portions of space and time cannot, of course, be carried on
indefinitely, but we can conceptually frame to ourselves the thought
of the indefinite repetition of the process beyond the limits arbitrarily
imposed on it by the span of our own attention. Thus, by an act of
mental analysis, we arrive at the concept of space and time as
indefinitely divisible, or possessed of no ultimately unanalysable last
parts, which is an indispensable pre-requisite of Geometry and
Dynamics.
This indefinite divisibility of conceptual space and time is not of
itself enough, as is often supposed, to establish their continuity in the
strict mathematical sense of the word; their continuity depends upon
the further assumption that whatever divides a series of positions in
space or events in time unambiguously into two mutually exclusive
classes, is itself a position in the space or event in the time series.
This assumption does not seem to be absolutely requisite for all
scientific treatment of the problems of space and time,[145] but is
demanded for the systematic establishment of the correspondence
between the spatial and temporal series and the continuous series of
the real numbers. Moreover, it seems impossible to assign any
positive content to the notion of a something which should bisect the
spatial or temporal order without occupying a position in that order.
Hence we seem inevitably led by the same analytical process which
conducts us to the conception of the spatial and temporal orders as
infinite series to think of them also as continuous series in the strict
sense of the term. The alternative conception of them as
discontinuous, if not absolutely excluded, does not seem to be called
for by any positive motive, and is incompatible with the complete
execution of the purposes which demand application of the number-
series to a spatial or temporal content.
(c) Abstraction. The part played by abstraction in the formation of
the conceptual space and time order out of the data of perception is
often overlooked by theorists, but is of fundamental importance, as
we shall see immediately. We have already learned that the most
significant fact about the time and space order of individual
experience is that its directions are unique, because they radiate out
from the unique here and now of immediate feeling. In the
construction of the conceptual space and time order we make entire
abstraction from this dependence on the immediate feeling of a
subject. Conceptual space contains an infinity of positions, but none
of them is a here; conceptual time an infinity of moments, but none
of them is a now. As the time and space of the conceptual order are
taken in abstraction from the differences between individual points of
view, no one point in either can be regarded as having more claim
than any other to be the natural “origin of co-ordinates” with
reference to which directions are estimated. We shall have repeated
opportunity in the remainder of this chapter to observe how important
are the consequences of this abstraction.
Abstraction also enters in another way into the construction by
which conceptual space and time are created. Actual perceived
space and time are indeed never empty, but always filled with a
content of “secondary” qualities. In other words, they are always one
aspect of a larger whole of fact. Extension is never perceived apart
from some further visual or tactual quality of the extended, temporal
lapse never perceived without some change in presented content,
however slight. But in constructing the conceptual space and time
system, we abstract altogether from this qualitative aspect; we think
solely of the variety of positions and directions in time and space
without taking any account of the further qualitative differences with
which they are accompanied in concrete experience. Thus we come
by the notion of an empty space and an empty time as mere systems
of positions into which various contents may subsequently be put.
Strictly speaking, the notion of an empty space or an empty time is
unmeaning, as the simple experiment of thinking of their existence is
sufficient to show. We cannot in thought successfully separate the
spatial and temporal aspects of experience from the rest of the
whole to which they belong and take them as subsisting by
themselves, any more than we can take timbre as subsisting apart
from musical pitch or colour-tone from saturation. We can, however,
confine our attention to the spatial-temporal system of positions
without taking into account the special secondary properties of the
extended and successive. It is from this logical abstraction that the
illusion arises when we imagine an empty set of spatial and temporal
positions as having first to exist in order that they may be
subsequently “filled” with a variety of contents.[146]
§ 4. Characteristics of the Conceptual Time and Space Order. The
following characteristics of the conceptual space and time created by
the construction we have just examined, call for special notice.
Conceptual space and time are necessarily taken, for reasons
already explained, to be unlimited, and indefinitely divisible. Though
it does not seem inevitable that they should be continuous, we
appear to be unable to attach any positive meaning to the notion of
their discontinuity, and, in the practical need for the application to
them of the complete number-series, we have a valid positive ground
for taking them as continuous. But space and time are thus resolved,
in the process of their conceptual construction, into continuous
infinite series of which the terms are spatial and temporal positions
or points. Unlike the parts of perceptual space and time, these
conceptual terms are not themselves spaces or times, as they
contain no internal multiplicity of structure. Conceptual space and
time are thus not wholes or aggregates of parts, but systems of
relations between terms which possess no quantitative character.
Between any two terms of the spatial, or again of the temporal,
series there is one unique relation, which is completely determined
by the assignment of the terms, their distance. In the temporal
series, which has only one dimension, you can only pass from any
one given term to any other through a series of intermediate terms
which is once and for all determined when the initial and final terms
are given, hence nothing is required beyond the terms themselves to
fix their distance. The spatial series is multi-dimensional, i.e. you can
pass from any one term in it to any second by an indefinite variety of
routes through intermediate terms, but it is still true that there is one
and only one such route which is completely determined when the
terms in question are known, namely, the straight line passing
through both. This straight line constitutes the unique distance of the
two points from each other.[147] Thus the genuine concept of which
those of space and time are species is not that of magnitude or
quantity, but of serial order.
Further, and this is a point of fundamental difference between
conceptual space and time, and the spaces and times of immediate
perception, any one position in either order, taken by itself, is
qualitatively indistinguishable from any other. All points of space, all
moments of time, are alike, or, as it is also phrased, conceptual
space and time are homogeneous throughout. It is not until you take
at least two terms of the spatial or temporal series and consider the
relation they determine, that distinction becomes possible. This
homogeneity of conceptual space and time is an inevitable
consequence of the abstraction from the immediate feelings of the
individual subject of experience involved, as we saw, in the process
of their construction. In our actual perception of spatial and temporal
extension, that part of perceived space and time which stands in
direct unity with immediate feeling is qualitatively distinguished as
the here and now from all the rest, and thus does not depend upon
the specification of a second spatial or temporal position for its
recognisability. Here is where I am, now is this felt present. And
similarly, every other part of the actually presented space and time
gets a unique qualitative character from its special relation to this
here and now; it is right or left, behind or in front, before or after.
When we abstract altogether from the unique relation with individual
experience which thus makes the here and now of perception, as we
do in constructing our conceptual space and time order, every
position alike becomes the mere possibility of a here or a now, and
as such mere possibilities the various positions are indistinguishable.
Practically, this homogeneity is important as the indispensable
condition for the quantitative comparison of different portions of
extension or duration.
An apparently inevitable consequence of the homogeneity of
conceptual space and time is the relativity of spatial and temporal
position. As we have seen, positions in conceptual space and time
are not distinguishable until you take them in pairs. In other words, to
fix one position in space or one date you have to give its relation to
another position or date, and similarly to fix this you must specify a
third, and so on indefinitely. To say where A is means to say how you
get to it from B, and B again is only known by the way it is reached
from C, and so on without end. Logically, this is a simple
consequence of the nature of space and time as conceptually
analysed into endless series. To specify any term in the series you
must give the unique relation it bears to some other term, its logical
distance. And, in a series which has neither first nor last term, this
second term cannot be defined except by its logical distance from a
third. In actual perception this difficulty is avoided, owing to the fact
that immediate feeling gives us the here and now from which all our
directions are measured. But in conceptual space or time there is
nothing to distinguish any one here which we may take as our “origin
of co-ordinates,” or any one now which we take as our present from
any other, and hence the endless regress seems inevitable.
It follows, of course, that in conceptual space and time there is no
principle by which to distinguish different directions. In perception
they can be distinguished as right and left, up and down, and so
forth. But since what is right to one percipient is left to another, in
conceptual space, where complete abstraction is made from the
presence of an individual percipient, there is neither right nor left, up
nor down, nor any other qualitative difference between one direction
and another, all such differences being relative to the individual
percipient. When we wish to introduce into conceptual space
distinctions between directions, we always have to begin by
arbitrarily assigning some standard direction as our point of
departure. Thus we take, e.g., an arbitrarily selected line ——— as
A B
such a standard for a given plane, and proceed to distinguish all
other directions by the angle they make with A B and the sense in
which they are estimated (whether as from B to A or from A to B).
But both the line A B and the difference of sense between A B and B
A can only be defined by similar reference to some other standard
direction, and so on through the endless regress.
Similarly with conceptual time. Here, as there is only one
dimension, the difficulty is less obvious, but it is no less real. In
conceptual time there is absolutely no means of distinguishing
before from after, past from future. For the past means the direction
of our memories, the direction qualified by the feeling of “no longer”;
the future is the direction of anticipation and purposive adaptation,
the direction of “not yet.” And, apart from the reference given by
immediate feeling to the purposive life of an individual subject, these
directions cannot be discriminated. In short, conceptual time and
space are essentially relative, because they are systems of relations
which have no meaning apart from qualitative differences in the
terms which they relate; while yet again, for the purpose of the
conceptual construction which yields them, the terms have to be
taken as having no character but that which they possess in right of
the relations.[148]
One other feature of the space and time construction is sufficiently
important to call for special mention. Space and time are commonly
thought of as unities of some kind. All spatial positions, it is usually
assumed, fall within one system of space-relations; all dates have
their place in one all-inclusive time. This character of unity completes
the current conception of the spatial and temporal order. Each of
those orders is a unity, including all possible spatial or temporal
positions; each is an endless, infinite, continuous series of positions,
which all are purely relative. There are other peculiarities, especially
of the current concepts of space, with which it is not necessary to
deal here, as they are of an accidental kind, not arising out of the
essential nature of the process by which the conception is
constructed. Thus it is probably a current assumption that the
number of dimensions in space is three and no more, and again that
the Euclidean postulate about parallels is verified by its constitution.
As far as perceptual space is concerned, those assumptions
depend, I presume, upon empirical verification; there seems to be no
reason why they should be made for the conceptual space-order,
since it is quite certain that a coherent science of spatial relations
can be constructed without recourse to them.[149]
§ 5. The question now is, whether the whole of this spatial and
temporal construction is more than imperfect, and therefore
contradictory, appearance. I will first state in a general form the
arguments for regarding it as appearance, and then proceed to
reinforce this conclusion by dealing with some special difficulties.
Finally, I propose to ask whether we can form some positive
conception of the higher order of Reality of which the spatial and
temporal series are phenomenal.
That the space and time order is phenomenal and not ultimate,
can, I think, be conclusively shown by a general argument which I
will first enunciate in principle and then develop somewhat more in
detail. An all-comprehensive experience cannot apprehend the detail
of existence under the forms of space and time for the following
reason. Such an experience could be neither of space and time as
we perceive them, nor of space and time as we conceptually
reconstruct them. It would not be of perceptual space and time,
because the whole character of our perceptual space and time
depends upon the very imperfections and limitations which make our
experience fragmentary and imperfect. Perceptual space and time
are for me what they are, because I see them, so to say, in
perspective from the special standpoint of my own particular here
and now. If that standpoint were altered, so that what are actually for
me there and then became my here and now, my whole outlook on
the space and time order would suffer change. But the Absolute
cannot look at the space and time order from the standpoint of my
here and now. For it is the finitude of my interests and purposes
which confine me in my outlook to this here and now. If my interests
were not bound up in the special way in which they are with just this
special part or aspect of the life of a wider whole, if they were co-
extensive with the life of that whole, every place and every time
would be my here and now. As it is, here is where my body is, now is
this particular stage in the development of European social life,
because these are the things in which I am primarily interested. And
so with all the other finite experiences in which the detail of the
absolute experience finds expression. Hence the absolute
experience, being free from the limitations of interest which condition
the finite experiences, cannot see the order of existence from the
special standpoint of any of them, and therefore cannot apprehend it
under the guise of the perceptual space and time system.
Again, it cannot apprehend existence under the forms of space
and time as we conceptually reconstruct them. For Reality, for the
absolute experience, must be a complete individual whole, with the
ground of all its differentiations within itself. But conceptual space
and time are constructed by deliberate abstraction from the relation
to immediate experience implied in all individuality, and
consequently, as we have just seen, they contain no real principle of
internal distinction, their constituent terms being all exactly alike and
indistinguishable. In short, if the perceptual time and space systems
of our concrete experience represent individual but imperfect and
finite points of view, the conceptual space and time of our scientific
construction represents the mere abstract possibility of a finite point
of view; neither gives a point of view both individual and infinite, and
neither, therefore, can be the point of view of an absolute
experience. An absolute experience must be out of time and out of
space, in the sense that its contents are not apprehended in the form
of the spatial and temporal series, but in some other way. Space and
time, then, must be the phenomenal appearance of a higher reality
which is spaceless and timeless.
§ 6. In principle, the foregoing argument appears to me to be
complete, but, for the sake of readers who care to have its leading
thought more fully developed, it may be re-stated thus. Perceptual
space and time cannot be ultimately real as they stand. They are
condemned already by the old difficulty which we found in the notion
of reality as made up of qualities in relation. Perceptual space and
time are aggregates of lesser parts, which are themselves spaces
and times; thus they are relations between terms, each of which
contains the same relation once more in itself, and so imply the now
familiar indefinite regress.[150] Again, when we try in our conceptual
space and time construction to remedy this defect by reducing space
and time altogether to mere systems of relations, the difficulty turns
out to have been merely evaded by such a process of abstraction.
For, so long as we keep rigidly to our conceptual construction, the
terms of our relations are indistinguishable. In purely conceptual
space and time, as we have seen, there is no possibility of
distinguishing any one direction from any other, since all are
qualitatively identical.
Indeed, it is obvious from first principles that when the sets of
terms between which a number of relations of the same type holds
are indistinguishable, the relations cannot be discriminated. To
distinguish directions at all, we must, in the end, take at least our
starting-point and one or more standard directions reckoned from it
—according to the number of dimensions with which we are dealing
—as independently given, that is, as having recognisable qualitative
differences from other possible starting-points and standard
directions. (Thus, to distinguish before and after in conceptual time,
you must at least assume some moment of time, qualitatively
recognisable from others, as the epoch from which you reckon, and
must also have some recognisable qualitative distinction between
the direction “past” and the direction “future.”) And with this reference
to qualitative differences we are at once thrown back, as in the case
of perceptual time and space, on the insoluble old problem of Quality
and Relation. The assumed starting-point and standard directions
must have qualitative individuality, or they could not be
independently recognised and made the basis for discrimination
between the remaining directions and positions: yet, because of the
necessary homogeneity of the space and time of conceptual
construction, they cannot have any such qualitative individuality, but
must be arbitrarily assumed. They will therefore themselves be
capable of determination only by reference to some other equally
arbitrary standard, and thus we are once more committed to the
indefinite regress. The practical usefulness of these constructions
thus depends on the very fact that we are not consistent in our use
of them. In all practical applications we use them to map out the
spatial and temporal order of events as seen in perspective from a
standpoint which is, as regards the conceptual time and space order
itself, arbitrary and indistinguishable from others.
§ 7. Instead of further elaborating this general argument, a task
which would be superfluous if its principle is grasped, and
unconvincing if it is missed, I will proceed to point out one or two
special ways in which the essential arbitrariness of the spatial and
temporal construction is strikingly exemplified. To begin with, a word
may be said about the alleged unity of space and time. It is
constantly taken for granted, by philosophers as well as by practical
men, that there can be only one spatial and one temporal order, so
that all spatial relations, and again all temporal relations, belong to
the same system. Thus, if A has a spatial relation to B and C to D, it
is assumed that there must be spatial relations between A and C, A
and D, and B and C, B and D. Similarly if A is temporally related with
B, and C with D. This view is manifestly presupposed in the current
conception of Nature, the “physical universe,” the “physical order,” as
the aggregate of all processes in space and time. But there seems to
be no real logical warrant for it. In principle the alleged unity of all
spatial and temporal relations might be dismissed, on the strength of
the one consideration that space and time are not individual wholes,
and therefore can contain no principle of internal structural unity.
This is manifest from the method by which the space and time of our
conceptual scheme have been constructed. They arose, as we saw,
from the indefinite repetition of a single type of relation between
terms in which we were unable to find any ultimately intelligible
principle of internal structure. But unity of structure cannot be
brought into that which does not already possess it by such mere
endless repetition. The result of such a process will be as internally
incoherent and devoid of structure as the original data. Hence space
and time, being mere repetitions of the scheme of qualities in
relation, cannot be true unities.
This becomes clearer if we reflect on the grounds which actually
warrant us in assigning position in the same space and the same
time to a number of events. For me A and B are ultimately in the
same space when there is a way of travelling from A to B; they are in
the same time when they belong to different stages in the
accomplishment of the same systematic purposes. Thus in both
cases it is ultimately from relation to an identical system of purposes
and interests that different sets of positions or events belong to one
space or one time. The unity of such a space or time is a pale
reflection in abstract form of the unity of a life of systematic purpose,
which is one because it has unique individual structure. It is in this
way, from the individual unity of the purpose and interests of my
ordinary waking life, that I derive the right to refer its experiences to
a single space and time system. Similarly, it is in virtue of the
inclusion of my own and my fellow-men’s purposes in a wider whole
of social systematic purpose that I can bring the space and time
relations of their experience into one system with my own. And
again, the sensible occurrences of the physical order belong to one
space and time with the space and time relations of human
experience, because of the varying ways in which they condition the
development of our own inner purposive life. But there are cases,
even within our own conscious life, where this condition appears to
be absent, and in these cases we do not seem to be able to make
intelligible use of the conception of a single time or a single space.
Take the case of our dreams. The events of my dreams stand in
spatial and temporal relations within the dream itself, but there would
be no sense in asking what are the spatial relations between the
places seen in my dreams and the places marked on the map of
England; or what are again the temporal relations between the
events of last night’s dream and those of this morning, or those of
the dreams of last week. Precisely because there is usually no
systematic identity of purpose connecting the dream with the waking
life or with other dreams, the time and space of the dream have no
position with respect to the time and space system of waking life, nor
those of one dream with relation to those of another.[151] Of course, it
may be said that the dream-space and dream-time are “imaginary,”
but the problem cannot be got rid of by the use of an epithet. To call
them imaginary is merely to say that they are not systematically
connected with the time and space of waking life, not to disprove
their genuineness as actual space and time constructions.
Similarly, if there are intelligent purposes of which our human
purposive life is debarred from taking account as such, as we urged
that there must be behind the phenomenal physical order, the time
and space within which those purposes are conceived and executed
would have no place in our spatial and temporal system. The
phenomenal events of the physical order would fall within our
system, but not the life of inner purpose of which that order is the
manifestation to our senses. Ultimately, in fact, all spaces and all
times could only form one spatial and temporal system on condition
that the infinite absolute experience views all its contents in spatial
and temporal form; then the various space and time systems
corresponding to the purposes of the various groups of finite
individuals would finally, for the infinite individual, form one great
system of time and space relations. But we have already seen that
the infinite experience cannot comprehend its contents in spatial or
temporal forms.
We infer, then, that there may be—indeed, if our interpretation of
the physical order is valid, there must be—a plurality of spaces and
times within the Real. Within any one such space or time all its
members are spatially and temporally interrelated, but the various
spaces are not themselves related in space, nor the various times
before or after one another in time. Their relation is the purely logical
one of being varying modes of the expression in a finite detail of the
underlying nature of the ultimate Reality.[152] For the absolute
experience they must be all at once and together, not in the sense of
being in “one space and time,” but in the sense of forming together
the systematic embodiment of one coherent ground or principle.
§ 8. Similar consequences, as to the phenomenal character of
space and time, follow from the consideration of the familiar Kantian
antinomies founded upon the concept of spatial and temporal infinity.
Space and time must be externally boundless and internally
indefinitely divisible, and yet again cannot be either. Freed from
unessential accessories, the argument for either side of the antinomy
may be stated thus. Space and time must be boundless because all
spatial and temporal existence means spatial and temporal relation
to a second term, itself similarly related to a third term. For precisely
the same reason both must be indefinitely divisible. Yet again, they
can be neither, since only the individual exists, and within such an
interminable network of relations between terms which are nothing
but the supporters of these relations there is no principle of individual
structure.[153] Thus the Kantian antinomies are a simple consequence
of the old difficulty about quality and relation. Space and time must
be mere relations, and the terms of those relations therefore
qualitatively indistinguishable; again, since they are relations they
cannot be relations between nothings or, what is the same thing,
between terms with no individual character. As in all cases where the
problem of relation and quality arises, it then conducts us to the
indefinite regress.
So long as we continue to look upon space and time as real, we
have therefore to choose between two equally illogical alternatives.
We must either arbitrarily refuse to continue the indefinite regress
beyond the point at which its difficulties become apparent, as is done
by the assertion that space and time have finite bounds or indivisible
parts, or we must hold that the absolute experience actually
achieves the summation of an unending series. With the recognition
that space and time are phenomenal, the result of a process of
construction forced on us by our practical needs, but not adequately
corresponding to the real nature of individual existence, the difficulty
disappears. Both sides of the antinomy become relatively true, in the
sense that for our practical purposes we must be content to adopt
now the one and again the other; both become ultimately untrue in
the sense that space and time, being constructions of our own, are
really neither finite nor infinite series, but are the one or the other
according to the purposes for which we use our construction.
§ 9. If spatial and temporal position and direction must thus in the
end be appearance, phenomenal of some more individual reality, we
have finally to ask, Of what are they the appearance? It is not
enough to say “of ultimate Reality,” or “of the Absolute.” Ultimately
this is, no doubt, true of space and time, as it is of everything else,
but we desire further to know if they are not proximately the
appearance of some special features of the inner physical life of the
lesser individuals which compose the Absolute. We naturally look for
some third term, in the nature of finite individuality, to mediate
between the structureless abstract generality of space and time
relation, and the perfect individual structure of the spaceless and
timeless Absolute Individual. We want, in fact, to connect the spatial
and temporal form which our experience wears, with some
fundamental aspect of our nature, as beings at once individual and
finite.
Nor is it particularly difficult to make the connection. When we
remember that space and time, as they actually condition our
perception and movement, are the space and time which radiate out
from an unique here and now of immediate feeling, it is fairly evident
that the spatial and temporal aspect of our experience is, as already
suggested, a consequence of that limitation of our attentive interests
which constitutes our finitude. It is the narrowness of my interests, or
at least of those which are sufficiently explicit to rise into the “focus”
of consciousness, that is reflected in the distinction of my here from
all the theres which are around me. Here is where my body is,
because of the specially intimate connection of the realisation of my
interests and purposes with those events in the phenomenal physical
order which I call the state of my body. Were my interests widened