Riz Allen S.

Armenia January 9, 2024

BSEE - II GE 8 - U

1. Genuine Moral Dilemma:

Movie: "12 Years a Slave" (2013)

Analysis: "12 Years a Slave" portrays the genuine moral dilemma faced by Solomon
Northup, a free black man kidnapped and enslaved. The film explores the moral choices
forced upon him and others in the brutal context of slavery. It raises questions about
complicity, resistance, and the profound ethical challenges individuals face in such
oppressive circumstances.

Aristotelian Virtue Ethics: Applying Aristotle's virtue ethics, the film emphasizes virtues
like courage, justice, and resilience. Solomon's journey showcases virtues in the face of
adversity, as he maintains his moral integrity despite the dehumanizing conditions,
highlighting the enduring power of virtue.

2. False Moral Dilemma:

Movie: "The Truman Show" (1998)

Analysis: "The Truman Show" presents a false moral dilemma as the protagonist,
Truman Burbank, navigates a constructed reality. Truman faces decisions that seem
genuine but are orchestrated by the show's producers. The film explores the ethical
implications of manipulating someone's life for entertainment, questioning the
authenticity of moral choices.

Aristotelian Virtue Ethics: Aristotle's virtue ethics is reflected in Truman's journey as he

seeks authenticity and truth. Virtues such as courage and wisdom guide him in breaking
free from the false moral dilemmas imposed upon him, showcasing the importance of
virtues in discovering one's true path.
3. Self-imposed Dilemma:

Movie: "A Beautiful Mind" (2001)

Analysis: "A Beautiful Mind" portrays the self-imposed dilemma faced by John Nash, a
brilliant mathematician dealing with schizophrenia. Nash's internal struggles and the
challenges he faces within his own mind create a poignant self-imposed dilemma. The
film explores the impact of mental health on decision-making and personal
relationships.

Aristotelian Virtue Ethics: Applying Aristotle's virtue ethics, the film examines the
virtues of courage, friendship, and self-reflection. Nash's journey involves overcoming
personal challenges, seeking support from friends, and developing intellectual virtues to
navigate his self-imposed dilemma.

4. World-imposed Dilemma:

Movie: "Children of Men" (2006)

Analysis: "Children of Men" depicts a world-imposed dilemma where humanity faces

extinction due to infertility. The film explores the moral choices made by individuals in a
dystopian society on the brink of collapse. The world imposes challenges that force
characters to confront the ethical implications of their actions.

Aristotelian Virtue Ethics: Aristotle's virtue ethics is evident in the characters' virtues of
courage, justice, and solidarity. The film emphasizes the importance of virtuous actions
in navigating a world-imposed dilemma, showcasing the enduring relevance of
Aristotle's ethical principles.
5. Multi-Person Dilemma:

Movie: "The Belko Experiment" (2016)

Analysis: "The Belko Experiment" presents a multi-person dilemma as a group of

individuals is trapped in a building and forced to participate in a deadly social
experiment. The film explores the ethical choices made by individuals under extreme
circumstances, where survival often requires difficult decisions impacting the group.

Aristotelian Virtue Ethics: Applying Aristotle's virtue ethics, the film examines virtues
such as justice, prudence, and cooperation. The characters' actions and decisions reflect
their virtues and vices in the face of a multi-person dilemma, illustrating the importance
of virtuous behavior even in dire situations.