Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Available online at
ScienceDirect
www.sciencedirect.com
Review article
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history: Background: Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder with various clinical presentations. It has been
Received 16 May 2018 historically considered a male disorder. An increasing number of authors stress the existence of sex/
Accepted 30 June 2018 gender bias in prevalence and the need to define sex/gender differences in the clinical presentation.
Available online xxx
Review: Recently, an increasing number of authors have studied the impact of sex/gender on autism’s
clinical presentation. The sex ratio of four boys to one girl commonly reported in literature is questioned.
Keywords: Sociocultural and familial influences can impact female clinical presentation as well as the way the
Autism spectrum disorder
difficulties of girls with autism are perceived. Issues of autism diagnostic instruments such as sex/gender
Gender
Sex
bias are also studied since they have an impact on the access to diagnosis for girls. Clinical variability is a
Diagnosis part of autism spectrum disorder, but some traits appear to be more specific of the female phenotype:
Prevalence existence of a ‘‘camouflage’’ phenomenon and less unusual play or restricted interests.
Discussion: Better understanding and diagnosis of females with autism is required to ensure the access to
the support and treatment they need. Professionals must apprehend the sex/gender clinical differences
to prevent the frequent misdiagnosis or missed diagnosis of females with autism.
Conclusion: Pursuing research on sex/gender differences seems necessary to ensure appropriate support
and diagnosis of undiagnosed females.
C 2018 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arcped.2018.06.008
0929-693X/ C 2018 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article in press as: Young H, et al. Clinical characteristics and problems diagnosing autism spectrum disorder in girls.
Archives de Pédiatrie (2018), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arcped.2018.06.008
G Model
ARCPED-4647; No. of Pages 5
Please cite this article in press as: Young H, et al. Clinical characteristics and problems diagnosing autism spectrum disorder in girls.
Archives de Pédiatrie (2018), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arcped.2018.06.008
G Model
ARCPED-4647; No. of Pages 5
the vision and formation of healthcare professionals, teachers, and disability, stress that women with ASD intellectual disability are
the general population on the clinical presentation of girls with not sufficiently diagnosed. Some authors show that subtle
ASD should be broadened to ensure better identification and differences exist between male and female phenotypes in the
diagnosis [6,27]. symptomatology, which can have an impact on the identification
of difficulties, even when the patients have the same level of ASD
3.4. Classification and diagnostic tools severity [7,27].
Today, the literature seems to show similarities in the clinical
Autistic traits are homogenously distributed in the general presentation of boys and girls at preschool age [2,33,34]. Pheno-
population [7] and ASD is at the extremities. We know that in the typical differences seem to appear particularly during primary and
general population, the distribution of autistic traits differs middle school, as they begin adolescence. Adolescence is a period
between men and women. Therefore, the definition of the limits of vulnerability for girls with ASD because of the new challenges
of autism should take that difference into account. In clinical related to puberty and relationships with peers becoming more
practice, diagnoses cannot depend only on a statistical threshold. complex [35].
The necessity of a diagnosis is also based on the existence of During primary school, girls have as many difficulties in social
functional impairments, suffering, and the need for care. interactions and communication as boys [26,27]. They nonetheless
Classifications (DSM and ICD) and clinical tools (ADI-R and show less obvious autistic behaviors in the interpersonal context
ADOS in particular) have been based on Kanner and Asperger’s [15], interpersonal difficulties, and externalized problems [27]. Their
descriptions. Therefore, their sensitivity concerns mostly the male pretense play is also relatively preserved [23,36]. Even though girls
phenotype of ASD [28]. Researchers’ and clinicians’ main criticism seem to have the same type of social communication deficit, it
of the ADI-R and ADOS concerns the fact the sex has not been taken appears that their social motivation and desire to be appreciated by
into account in the development or the validation of these tools peers is greater than it is for boys [7,8,21]. They also demonstrate a
[29]. If females present symptoms that are not included in the better socioemotional reciprocity (nonverbal communication,
diagnosis algorithms of ASD, those symptoms cannot be identified appropriate facial communication, offering comfort). A key notion
and the diagnosis cannot be made [30]. Beggiato et al. [31] showed in the female phenotype of ASD is the ‘‘camouflage.’’ Considering the
that four items of the ADI-R show a significant difference between same level of severity at the ADI-R during adulthood, women show
boys and girls: the variety of facial expressions used to their autistic symptoms less (on the ADOS) but perceive them more
communicate, pretense play, restricted interests, and unusual than men [15,22,26]. They try to hide their deficits with a great deal
preoccupations. The first two are good at discriminating the of energy and show great determination to learn social and societal
difference considering sex. As those items seem to influence the norms and nuances [17,22]. This camouflage can be of two types:
score of the algorithm and consequently of ASD, the application of active (use of strategies to mask their difficulties, copying peers, and
corrective factors related to the sex of the subject could improve overcoming social communication deficits typical of ASD to ‘‘seem
the sensitivity of the ADI-R to the female phenotype [31]. Kopp and normal’’ and maintain friendships) or passive (spontaneous
Gillberg [3] stress the lack of sensitivity of the ADOS to female mimicking of behaviors such as accents) [17]. Peer groups play an
issues. This is strengthened by another study [32], which showed a important part in this camouflage because they allow them to
lower sensitivity of the ADOS (2 and 3) than the CARS regarding the develop friendships by helping them structure behaviors. These
identification of girls with ASD and in comparison with boys. Since friendships allow them to strengthen their ability to interact and
the ADOS depends on clinical observations, a camouflage of empathize [6].
symptoms, which can be seen with girls, can explain this lack of Comorbidities are commonly associated with ASD; however, the
sensitivity. These tools seem to underestimate the symptomatic results reported in the literature diverge. They find more [17,26,37],
severity of girls with ASD. Their reliability and sensitivity can less [36], or the same level of internalized problems [15] in girls as in
therefore be debated [3,33]. boys. Those divergences could be the consequence of methodologi-
cal problems such as lack of statistical power related to small
4. Clinical specificities of the female phenotype of ASD samples, a wide age range, and modifications in clinical tools and
diagnosis criteria due to the evolution of diagnostic classification.
4.1. Female phenotype Women frequently have an anteriority of multiple diagnoses:
anxiety, anorexia nervosa, depression, and emergence of personality
It is currently said that there are more girls with ASD who disorder. Due to the camouflage of their deficits, girls and women
present intellectual disability than a high level of functioning often experiment periods of distress [6,37]. These periods are related
(Table 1). Recent literature reports studying the link between sex to the repetition of negative societal reactions to their behaviors
and ASD, focusing on women with ASD without intellectual despite the great efforts that can be executed to compensate their
Table 1
Few characteristics of the ASD (autism spectrum disorders) female phenotype.
Please cite this article in press as: Young H, et al. Clinical characteristics and problems diagnosing autism spectrum disorder in girls.
Archives de Pédiatrie (2018), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arcped.2018.06.008
G Model
ARCPED-4647; No. of Pages 5
deficits (difficulties understanding the subtlety of nonverbal Social deficits can be seen in various disorders such as ASD,
communication leading to inadequate behaviors). Therefore, girls anxiety disorders, and emerging personality disorder. Therefore, in
can be more at risk of developing internalized problems (anxiety, some situations where social difficulties cannot be to attributed
depression, somatic symptoms) [26,38], especially because they do ASD with certainty, one must retrace the developmental history to
not have access to the support they need [22]. A recent study [19] understand whether they are explained better by ASD (lack of
showed that ASD should be sought in presence of a high level of social reciprocity, difficulties in regulating feelings, etc.) or by
emotional or behavioral disorder in girls (more than for boys). another diagnosis. It seems necessary to explore further the
camouflaging that has been reported in various studies [17]. Self-
4.2. Focus: restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, or evaluation may be a good way to recognize it better, measure it, in
activities order to provide patients with the necessary care. Moreover, it
seems important to identify those girls/women who are not
At school age and during adolescence, it appears that between diagnosed because of this camouflage to determine their long-term
girls and boys there are more differences in repetitive patterns of progression and the support they need [8]. Variability in the
behavior, interests, or activities (RRBIs) than in social communi- clinical presentation is part of ASD symptomatology. Therefore,
cation [20,35]. Numerous authors show less frequent RRBIs in girls phenotypical differences between men and women do not allow
than in boys [7,15,27,30,36,39] without it being related to IQ establishing a definition of clinical subtypes related to sex.
[39]. Another hypothesis discussed is that girls and boys have the Nonetheless, professionals must know how to better identify
same level of RRBIs but differences in the type of RRBI. Interests of women with ASD (without intellectual disability) to allow a better
children with ASD might differ with sex. Therefore, a boy with ASD diagnosis. The delay in diagnosis, concerning especially girls with
may be passionate about maps, trains, and pipelines, a girl can be ASD and a high level of functioning can cause academic problems,
focused on animals, dolls, or singers, which can be more difficult to problems with peer relationships, and internalized problems
identify as RRBIs [3,7,18,23,28]. Girls also show fewer interests for [4]. An early diagnosis can reduce family stress and the
parts of objects and rituals [18]. establishment of adapted care [4,40]. One must nonetheless be
A way to identify correctly a RRBI in an interest that can seem careful not to pathologize women/girls with autistic traits without
typical of girls is to question its quality and intensity. Asking ‘‘Is intellectual disability but with no problems in everyday life [7].
this activity causing social or academic problems?’’ or ‘‘Is this
activity allowing investment in other activities?’’ or ‘‘What
happens when you prevent her from doing this activity?’’ can 6. Conclusion
allow one to judge the quality of this interest and identify its
atypicality if necessary [6]. The underidentification of girls with It appears that various elements are implicated in the apparent
ASD can therefore be related to these atypical and subtle feminine male predominance in ASD: methodological bias with predomi-
presentations in addition to symptoms that can be less severe than nantly masculine samples in studies on ASD, clinical tools based on
for boys [3,5,7,22,28]. Frequently, in order to be diagnosed, girls/ the male phenotype, and clinical differences between girls and
women with ASD need to present behavioral problems, develop- boys influenced by sociocultural and familial factors [6]. We need
mental difficulties, or mental health problems at the same time to keep in mind that certain women (possibly those with an
[19,25]. IQ > 70 with no behavioral problems) are experiencing a delay in
diagnosis, errors in the diagnosis, or are not identified at all
[6]. Moreover, recent literature concerning girls/women with ASD
5. Discussion is centered on women with an IQ > 70. Therefore, there is very
little information on girls/women with an IQ < 70 or those who are
Whatever the sex or the age, there is a negative impact on the immediately under the diagnosis threshold. It is important to keep
quality of life of people with ASD compared to the general in mind that a male bias can persist even with increased vigilance
population. Quality of life must be improved, which depends on a or with the adjustment of diagnostic criteria because the way
better identification of ASD symptoms. To allow access to the female phenotype and errors in diagnosis influence the sex bias is
support and care they need, better identification of girls and not known.
women with ASD is essential, requiring therefore, acknowledge- Pursuing explorations is imperative to identify the female
ment of the bias responsible for this misdiagnosis or missed population in need of support. Moreover, a better understanding of
diagnosis. The relation between biases in sampling and diagnostic the influence of the biological sex of phenotypical presentation
criteria is important. Results concerning male samples lead to the could help research on ASD biology [8]. Finally, the first step is for
development and modification of diagnostic criteria that empha- professionals to understand that ASD presents differently in boys
size the underestimation of the disorder for the sex considered as and girls. We need to search more but it is there. The fact that it is
less prevalent [13]. Some authors argue that new diagnostic not obvious does not mean it is not severe [9].
criteria, more sensitive to sex differences, may be necessary
[7,19]. Others argue that the main point is a better understanding
Disclosure of interest
by professionals of the specificities of women’s behaviors given
that differences in the identification of symptoms between girls
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
and boys may be due to the way they are explored rather than the
way they are measured [8,20].
One way to improve the diagnostic sensitivity and to identify References
the suffering related to compensation mechanisms could be to
carry out a self-evaluation for adolescents and adults. This self- [1] Ingudomnukul E, Baron-Cohen S, Wheelwright S, et al. Elevated rates of
testosterone-related disorders in women with autism spectrum conditions.
administered questionnaire, which could be proposed before or Horm Behav 2007;51:597–604.
after a consultation, could explore difficulties of everyday life [6], [2] Tsai LY, Beisler JM. The development of sex differences in infantile autism. Br J
which can be ignored because of the camouflage phenomenon. Psychiatry 1983;142:373–8.
[3] Kopp S, Gillberg C. Girls with social deficits and learning problems: autism,
These difficulties can be a poor understanding of social codes, atypical Asperger syndrome or a variant of these conditions. Eur Child Adolesc
isolation, and the feeling of being bullied by peers, etc. Psychiatry 1992;1:89–99.
Please cite this article in press as: Young H, et al. Clinical characteristics and problems diagnosing autism spectrum disorder in girls.
Archives de Pédiatrie (2018), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arcped.2018.06.008
G Model
ARCPED-4647; No. of Pages 5
[4] Begeer S, Mandell D, Wijnker-Holmes B, et al. Sex differences in the timing of [23] Knickmeyer RC, Wheelwright S, Baron-Cohen SB, Sex-typical Play:. Masculin-
identification among children and adults with autism spectrum disorders. J ization/defeminization in girls with an autism spectrum condition. J Autism
Autism Dev Disord 2013;43:1151–6. Dev Disord 2008;38:1028–35.
[5] Giarelli E, Wiggins LD, Rice CE, et al. Sex differences in the evaluation and [24] Shattuck PT, Durkin M, Maenner M, et al. The timing of identification among
diagnosis of autism spectrum disorders among children. Disabil Health J children with an autism spectrum disorder: findings from a population-based
2010;3:107–16. surveillance study. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2009;48:474–83.
[6] Kreiser NL, White SW. ASD in Females: are we overstating the gender differ- [25] Dworzynski K, Ronald A, Bolton P, et al. How different are girls and boys above
ence in diagnosis? Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev 2014;17:67–84. and below the diagnostic threshold for autism spectrum disorders? J Am Acad
[7] Lai MC, Lombardo MV, Auyeung B, et al. Sex/gender differences and autism: Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2012;51:788–97.
setting the scene for future research. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry [26] Rynkiewicz A, Schuller B, Marchi E, et al. An investigation of the ‘‘female
2015;54:11–24. camouflage effect’’ in autism using a computerized ADOS-2 and a test of sex/
[8] Werling DM. The role of sex-differential biology in risk for autism spectrum gender differences. Mol Autism 2016;7:10.
disorder. Biol Sex Differ 2016;7:58. [27] Mandy W, Chilvers R, Chowdhury U, et al. Sex differences in autism spectrum
[9] Hendrickx S. Women and girls with autism spectrum disorder: understanding disorder: evidence from a large sample of children and adolescents. J Autism
life experiences from early childhood to old age. London, UK: Jessica Kingsley Dev Disord 2012;42:1304–13.
Publishers; 2015. [28] Gould J, Ashton-Smith J. Missed diagnosis or misdiagnosis? Girls and women
[10] Fombonne E, Quirke S, Hagen A. Epidemiology of pervasive developmental on the autism spectrum. Good Autism Pract 2011;12:34–41.
disorders. In: Amaral D, Geschwind D, Dawson G, editors. Autism Spectrum [29] Lord C, Rutter M, Couteur AL. Autism diagnostic interview-revised: a revised
Disorders. Oxford, USA: Oxford University Press; 2011. version of a diagnostic interview for caregivers of individuals with possible
[11] Mattila ML, Kielinen M, Linna SL, et al. Autism spectrum disorders according to pervasive developmental disorders. J Autism Dev Disord 1994;24:659–85.
DSM-IV-TR and comparison with DSM-5 draft criteria: an epidemiological [30] Wilson CE, Murphy CM, McAlonan G, et al. Does sex influence the diagnostic
study. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2011;50:583–92. evaluation of autism spectrum disorder in adults? Autism Int J Res Pract
[12] Kim YS, Leventhal BL, Koh YJ, et al. Prevalence of autism spectrum disorders in 2016;20:808–19.
a total population sample. Am J Psychiatry 2011;168:904–12. [31] Beggiato A, Peyre H, Maruani A, et al. Gender differences in autism spectrum
[13] Hartung CM, Widiger TA. Gender differences in the diagnosis of mental disorders: divergence among specific core symptoms. Autism Res
disorders: conclusions and controversies of the DSM-IV. Psychol Bull 2017;10:680–9.
1998;123:260–78. [32] Mussey JL, Ginn NC, Klinger LG. Are males and females with autism spectrum
[14] Thompson T, Caruso M, Ellerbeck K. Sex matters in autism and other develop- disorder more similar than we thought? Autism 2017;21:733–7.
mental disabilities. J Learn Disabil 2003;7:345–62. [33] Pilowsky T, Yirmiya N, Shulman C, et al. The autism diagnostic interview-
[15] Lai MC, Lombardo MV, Pasco G, et al. MRC AIMS Consortium Baron-Cohen S. A revised and the childhood autism rating scale: differences between diagnostic
behavioral comparison of male and female adults with high functioning systems and comparison between genders. J Autism Dev Disord 1998;28:143–
autism spectrum conditions. PLoS One 2011;6:e20835. 51.
[16] Sedgewick F, Hill V, Yates.. et al. Gender differences in the social motivation [34] Mandic-Maravic V, Pejovic-Milovancevic M, Mitkovic-Voncina.. et al. Sex
and friendship experiences of autistic and non-autistic adolescents. J Autism differences in autism spectrum disorders: does sex moderate the pathway
Dev Disord 2016;46:1297–306. from clinical symptoms to adaptive behavior? Sci Rep 2015;5:10418.
[17] Bargiela S, Steward R, Mandy W. The experiences of late-diagnosed women [35] Jamison R, Bishop SL, Huerta M, et al. The clinician perspective on sex
with autism spectrum conditions: an investigation of the female autism differences in autism spectrum disorders. Autism 2017;21:772–84.
phenotype. J Autism Dev Disord 2016;46:3281–94. [36] McLennan JD, Lord C, Schopler E. Sex differences in higher functioning people
[18] Hiller RM, Young RL, Weber N. Sex differences in autism spectrum disorder with autism. J Autism Dev Disord 1993;23:217–27.
based on DSM-5 criteria: evidence from clinician and teacher reporting. J [37] Pisula E, Pudło M, Słowińska M, et al. Behavioral and emotional problems in
Abnorm Child Psychol 2014;42:1381–93. high-functioning girls and boys with autism spectrum disorders: parents’
[19] Duvekot J, van der Ende J, Verhulst FC, et al. Factors influencing the probability reports and adolescents’ self-reports. Autism 2017;21:738–48.
of a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder in girls versus boys. Autism [38] Solomon M, Miller M, Taylor SL, et al. Autism symptoms and internalizing
2017;21:646–58. psychopathology in girls and boys with autism spectrum disorders. J Autism
[20] Frazier TW, Hardan AY. Equivalence of symptom dimensions in females and Dev Disord 2012;42:48–59.
males with autism. Autism 2017;21:749–59. [39] Frazier TW, Georgiades S, Bishop SL, et al. Carter CS. Behavioral and cognitive
[21] Hiller RM, Young RL, Weber N. Sex differences in pre-diagnosis concerns for characteristics of females and males with autism in the Simons simplex
children later diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. Autism 2016;20:75–84. collection. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2014;53:329–40.
[22] Dean M, Harwood R, Kasari C. The art of camouflage: Gender differences in the [40] Halladay AK, Bishop S, Constantino JN, et al. Sex and gender differences in
social behaviors of girls and boys with autism spectrum disorder. Autism autism spectrum disorder: summarizing evidence gaps and identifying
2017;21:678–89. emerging areas of priority. Mol Autism 2015;6:36.
Please cite this article in press as: Young H, et al. Clinical characteristics and problems diagnosing autism spectrum disorder in girls.
Archives de Pédiatrie (2018), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.arcped.2018.06.008